postoperative cognitive dysfunction after shoulder surgery ...€¦ · jan fierens promotor 1:...
TRANSCRIPT
Academiejaar 2015 – 2016
Postoperative cognitive dysfunction after shoulder surgery in beach chair position: a
pilot study
Jan FIERENS
Promotor 1: Prof. dr. Stefan De Hert
Promotor 2: Dr. Tom Jacobs
Masterproef voorgedragen in de master in de specialistische geneeskunde Anesthesie - Reanimatie
Academiejaar 2015 – 2016
Postoperative cognitive dysfunction after shoulder surgery in beach chair position: a
pilot study
Jan FIERENS
Promotor 1: Prof. dr. Stefan De Hert
Promotor 2: Dr. Tom Jacobs
Masterproef voorgedragen in de master in de specialistische geneeskunde Anesthesie - Reanimatie
Table of contents
Abstract ...................................................................................................................... 1
Introduction ................................................................................................................. 3
Beach chair position ................................................................................................ 3
Near-infrared spectroscopy: technical aspects and clinical use ............................. 5
Postoperative decline in cognitive function ............................................................. 7
Goal of the study ...................................................................................................... 11
Materials and methods ............................................................................................. 12
Results ...................................................................................................................... 15
Discussion ................................................................................................................ 18
References ............................................................................................................... 21
Nederlandse samenvatting ....................................................................................... 27
1
Abstract
Background/Goal
Major shoulder surgery in beach chair position has been associated with severe
adverse neurologic events even in healthy middle-aged patients. This has been
attributed to the beach chair position itself as it reduces cerebral oxygenation. The aim
of the present study is to identify whether intra-operative episodes of cerebral
desaturation are associated with postoperative cognitive decline.
Methods and Materials
After obtaining ethics committee approval and informed consent, 11 adult
patients (4 males and 7 females with mean age=65;0 y, SD=12.4y) without prior
neurological and psychiatric disorder were enrolled prospectively. Neurocognitive
function was assessed preoperatively, at the 3rd postoperative day and at 3 months
postoperatively. Memory and attention performance were evaluated by means of the
Auditory Verbal Learning Test (AVLT), the Stroop Color Word Test (SCWT) and the
Symbol Digit Modalities Test (SDMT). Near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) was used to
determine intra-operative episodes of cerebral desaturation, defined as a decrease in
cerebral tissue oxygen saturation (rScO2) of more than 20% compared to the baseline
value. Routine anesthesia was applied. A repeated measures multivariate analysis of
variance with time as within-subject variable (pre-surgery, post-surgery, and follow up
assessment) was performed.
Results
Cerebral desaturation occurred in all patients. No significant changes in overall
cognitive test performance was observed over time, neither was there any significant
interaction between time and age or cerebral desaturation. A significantly increased
performance was observed between the postoperative and the follow-up assessment
on the AVLT (p=.014), which may possibly be attributed to a test-retest effect.
Conclusion
These preliminary results suggest no association between episodes of cerebral
desaturation and postoperative cognitive dysfunction. The current sample is yet too
2
small to come to definite conclusions, and confirmation in an adequate sample-sized
study population (as is planned in this ongoing study) is mandatory.
3
Introduction
Beach chair position
Surgery on the shoulder joint is one of the most common surgical procedures
performed by orthopedic specialists. Since its introduction in the early eighties beach
chair position is the most frequently preferred position for both open and arthroscopic
shoulder surgery. Patients are positioned sitting up more than 70 degrees upright with
the operative arm draped free to be manipulated by either a mechanical arm rest or a
surgical assistant. The head rests on a well-padded head block.
Figure 1: Classical beach chair position (picture copyrighted by Ao Foundation)
The advantages of the classic beach chair position include easier access to the joint,
lack of brachial plexus strain, less risk for neurovascular trauma and if necessary an
easy conversion from arthroscopic to open procedure (Skyhar et al., 1988; Gelber et
al., 2008).
4
The safety of this position has been well established. Most patients who undergo
shoulder surgery in this position do not show adverse sequelae (Friedman et al., 2009).
Nonetheless severe adverse neurologic events have occurred in a relatively healthy
middle-aged population supposedly not at risk for severe cerebrovascular incidents. A
case of visual loss and ophthalmoplegia has been described after a surgically
uneventful rotator cuff repair in 2003 (Bhatti and Enneking, 2003). Pohl and Cullen
have reported four cases of ischemic brain damage and spinal cord injury, resulting in
a permanent vegetative state and death in two cases (Pohl and Cullen, 2008). The
American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon’s Association has reported eight cases of
cerebrovascular events during shoulder surgery in beach chair position (Friedman et
al., 2009). The etiologic mechanisms are largely unknown. It is postulated that the
upright position induces unfavorable hemodynamic changes. In healthy awake
volunteers, assuming a sitting position induces a sympathic nervous system response.
Heart rate and systemic vascular resistance rise to maintain adequate mean arterial
pressure and cardiac output (Smith et al., 1994; Edgell et al., 2004). This autonomous
effect does not diminish with increasing age (Edgell et al.2004; Murell et al., 2011).
During general anesthesia these sympathic responses are diminished due to the
vasodilation effect and blunting of the baroreceptor reflex of anesthetics, resulting in
an attenuated increase in system vascular resistance, decrease in mean arterial
pressure and a decreased cardiac output. A high incidence of severe hypotension is
not surprising during general anesthesia in a sitting position (Potter et al., 1999). These
profound physiological changes may lead to undetected cerebral hypotension. This
reduction in cerebral perfusion pressure below a critical threshold of duration and
severity may induce neurological damage. This threshold is felt to be the lower limit of
cerebral autoregulation, which according to recent publications is a subject of
physiological heterogeneity. While it attempts to maintain a constant cerebral perfusion
pressure over a wide range of mean arterial pressures, both lower and upper limits are
subject of interpatient variability, taking patient’s age, comorbidities and pharmacologic
therapies in consideration (Drummond, 1999; Sanders et al, 2011). Cerebral
hypotension may go unnoticed using standard intraoperative monitoring. Cerebral
perfusion pressure can be estimated using mean arterial pressure (MAP) (Murphy and
Szokol, 2011). However cerebral perfusion pressure can be severely underestimated
using brachial cuff readings, due to hydrostatic pressure differences between head and
5
arm/heart level. This difference can be as much as 20 to 40 mmHg depending on the
elevation of the head (Koh et al, 2012)
Near-infrared spectroscopy: technical aspects and clinical use
Near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) is a non-invasive technique allowing
measurements of tissue oxygenation, including brain oxygenation. It became possible
to measure regional cerebral oxygen saturation (rScO2) after the innovative work of
Jöbsis. He demonstrated that light in the near-infrared spectrum can penetrate the
bone of the cranium, allowing measurements of oxyhemoglobin and deoxyhemoglobin
inside the brain (Jöbsis, 1977). Non-invasive, self-adhesive optical sensors are applied
to the skin of the forehead. These optrodes emit a light in the near-infrared spectrum.
Its reflection is measured by sensors at fixed distances from the light source. The
strength of the reflected light detected by these sensors is inversely related to the
concentration of light-absorbing molecules in the underlying tissue. Oxyhemoglobin
and desoxyhemoglobin absorb light at a wavelength of 800 nm in the near infrared
spectrum, but they both have a different characteristic peak absorption. Using a
modified Beer-Lambert law, NIRS provides a measurement of the concentration of
oxygenated and deoxygenated hemoglobin to total hemoglobin concentration.
Algorithms are used to distract absorption of superficial extracranial tissue from that
obtained from deeper cerebral tissue to obtain a cerebral saturation value of the
superficial frontal cortex (Zheng et al., 2013). Traditional pulse oximetry, which uses
light in the red and infrared spectrum, distinguishes between venous and arterial blood.
NIRS does not make this differentiation. Approximately 70 to 80 % of cerebral blood is
venous blood, consequently rScO2 provides an indication of the regional oxygen supply
and demand (McCormick et al, 1991; Murking and Arango, 2009). Continuous
measurements of cerebral oxygenation allow for an accurate recognition of episodes
of cerebral desaturation. NIRS is used extensively in major surgery at high risk for
adverse neurologic outcome. It has found its way into the arsenal of the cardiac
anesthesiologist. NIRS may predict postoperative neurological dysfunction after
cardiac surgery and allows detection of intraoperative cannula misplacement during
cardiopulmonary bypass (Zheng et al, 2013). During pediatric cardiac surgery, NIRS
6
is the most widely applied and accepted tool in multimodal neuromonitoring. Some
evidence exists in the pediatric population that decreased cerebral oxygen values are
associated with brain abnormalities on postoperative MRI scans, though no conclusive
evidence exists on the neurologic outcome after perioperative intervention solely
based on NIRS values (Clark et al., 2012). NIRS not only has its part in cardiac surgery,
but it is widely used during major vascular procedures. NIRS offers the possibility to
predict neurologic events during carotid endarterectomy. About ten percent of patient
suffer from postoperative neurologic changes triggered by carotid clamping. A
decrease in rScO2 is related to potential postoperative neurologic deterioration and
might imply the need for a different anesthetic approach (Pennekamp et al, 2009),
using deliberate hypertension, or surgical approach, using a carotid shunt (Nielsen,
2014). NIRS also opens the possibility to predict a hyperperfusion syndrome in the
immediate postoperative period after releasing the carotid clamp (Pennekamp et al.
2012). Similar applications of NIRS are performed during abdominal surgery, both
laparoscopic and open. Inducing a head up position for laparoscopic procedures
induces a decrease in rScO2, up to 80% of baseline value in 20% of patients (Gipson
et al., 2006). Similar results were found during laparoscopic gynecological procedures
(Lee et al., 2006). Clamping the inferior caval vein during orthotopic liver
transplantation, induces a decrease in rScO2. A cerebral desaturation of 13% has been
associated with release of neuron specific enolase, a biomarker of neuronal damage
(Plachky et al., 2004). This makes NIRS a viable option for monitoring cerebral
autoregulation and subsequently hemodynamic management during major abdominal
and transplantation procedures.
Few studies exist assessing events of cerebral desaturation and their
neurocognitive sequelae. A systematic review by Zheng and colleagues only cited low-
level evidence that interventions to improve cerebral saturation could prevent stroke or
post-operative cognitive dysfunction during cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary
bypass (Zheng et al., 2013). Two studies examine the effects of cerebral desaturation
and occurrence of neurocognitive dysfunction in abdominal surgery. They both
associated cerebral desaturation with postoperative cognitive decline, as evidenced by
a lower mini-mental state examination (MMSE) score or the occurrence of
postoperative delirium (Casati et al, 2007; Morimoto et al., 2009). This association was
also confirmed during thoracic surgery (Tang et al., 2012). Several observational
7
studies have investigated the use of NIRS during shoulder surgery in different
positions. During arthroscopic procedures in lateral decubitus rScO2 is maintained. On
the other hand beach chair position may induce a dramatic decrease in rScO2 (Fisher
et al., 2009; Dippmann et al. 2010, Tange et al, 2010; Lee et al. 2011; Yadeau et al.,
2011; Jeong et al., 2012; Ko et al., 2012; Moerman et al. 2012; Salazar et al, 2013;
Pant et al, 2014). Lowered cerebral saturation corresponded with a decreased MAP.
A restoration of MAP to preoperative value restored rScO2 (Lee et al., 2011).
Postoperative decline in cognitive function
Postoperative decline in cognitive function is becoming increasingly recognized
in Postoperative cognitive dysfunction (POCD) is broadly defined as a decline in
cognition temporally associated with surgery. Cognitive function is a rather ‘simple’
name for a broad and elaborate spectrum of capabilities such as learning,
understanding, perception, attention, verbal abilities, executive functions and abstract
thinking. Unlike delirium, no elaborate definition exists to accurately describe cognitive
dysfunction. It is considered a mild neurocognitive disorder and, according to DSM IV
criteria, it can only be identified as an exclusion diagnosis. Other neurocognitive
disorders such as delirium, dementia and other amnestic disorders have to be
excluded first (Alcover et al, 2013). While it is categorized as a trivial brain dysfunction,
it has been associated with an increased one year mortality, impairment of daily
functioning, risk of leaving the labor market or early retirement, increased health care
cost and dependency on government support payments (Deiner and Silverstein, 2009).
Cognitive deterioration after cardiac surgery has been described in about three
to eight patients out of ten, with ongoing cognitive deficits after six months in up to 60%
of these patients. POCD had been described in one out of four elderly patients in the
first seven days after major non-cardiac surgery. The cognitive symptoms persist in
about ten to twenty percent following major surgery after six months. Incidence is lower
in younger patients and minor surgery (Steinmetz and Rasmussen, 2016).
8
The pathophysiologic mechanisms leading to POCD after surgery are poorly
understood. Animal studies attribute an extensive role to the immune system
succeeding surgical ‘trauma’. Peripheral surgery in a mice model activates the
inflammatory TNFα/NF-κB pathways with cytokines release. In turn these cytokines
disrupt the integrity of the blood-brain barrier, which allows macrophages to invade the
hippocampal formation more easily, impairing memory formation. Cognitive functioning
remains preserved when cytokine release is blocked by activation of the anti-
inflammatory cholinergic pathways (Terrando et al., 2011). POCD has been
extensively studied in cardiac surgery. Longer duration of cardiopulmonary bypass,
poor left ventricular function, manipulation of an atherosclerotic aorta, cerebral
hyperthermia and valve surgery have all been associated with postoperative cognitive
deterioration (Tomotko and Maekawa, 2014). Although cognitive dysfunction has been
less comprehensively studied and identified in non- cardiac surgery, numerous risk
factors have been identified in more recent studies. Table 1 gives an overview of the
most common risk factors (Rundshagen, 2014).
Table 1: Risk factors for POCD
Patient Advanced age; pre-existing cerebral, cardiac or vascular disease;
preoperative mild cognitive impairment; low educational level; history
of alcohol abuse; genetic predisposition
Surgery Extensive surgical procedure; intra- or postoperative surgical
complications; secondary surgery; cardiac surgery (long
cardiopulmonary bypass, poor cardiac function, valve surgery and
atherosclerotic aorta handling)
Anesthesia Long-acting anesthetics; marked disturbances of homeostasis
(hypoxemia, hypotension), intra- or postoperative anesthesia
complications
Several observational studies have revealed an association between extensive
surgery, secondary surgery and postoperative complications and an increased
incidence of POCD (Steinmetz and Rasmussen, 2016). Age is a major risk factor for
9
POCD. Increasing age implies a decreased cognitive performance and ability to
compensate for cognitive deficits. This coincides with the ‘brain reserve’ theory, which
shows a greater vulnerability for POCD in brains with a lower reserve. This also
includes patients with a pre-existing mild cognitive impairment (Deiner and Silverstein,
2009). A low educational level is a further risk factor for POCD. Several studies have
presumed the expression of the APOE 4 allele as a risk factor (Alcover et al, 2013).
Hudetz et al showed that patients with a positive history for alcohol abuse had worse
cognitive impairment after surgery. A severe disruption of homeostasis, such as severe
hypotension or hypoxemia, have been blamed for postoperative cognitive deterioration
(Steinmetz and Rasmussen, 2016; Rundshagen, 2014). Even though general
anesthesia has often been blamed for causing neurotoxicity, currently no sufficient
evidence exists to link POCD to general anesthesia. The residual effect of the
anesthetics solely depends on its pharmacokinetic properties. A shorter duration of
action implies a shorter impairment of cognitive function in the postoperative period.
Diagnosis of postoperative cognitive dysfunction requires a preoperative
baseline cognitive function analysis and a determination of what will be defined as a
significant decline in cognitive functioning. Cognitive deterioration is a subtle process
and can only be detected using a combination of neuropsychological tests. Current
test batteries for POCD have several issues. First there is the flooring effect, i.e. what
is the correct technical approach for a patient with an already low baseline score.
Secondly there is currently no real consensus about which tests have to be used to
diagnose POCD. A 1995 recommendation lists four essential tests to diagnose POCD:
Rey Auditory Verbal Learning test (a word learning test), Trail Making test (ability to
perform combined tasks), Groove Pegboard test (manual dexterity) and Digit Span test
(ability to remember a sequence of numbers) (Murkin et al., 1995). This variety of tests
may be due to the absence of theoretically substantiated model that accurately
describes causes and outcomes of cognitive changes due to surgical trauma. This
confusing recommendation resulted in a lot of combinations of different tests have
being in clinical studies, making data interpretation and comparison a real challenge.
A possible explanation is the duration of these combinations of tests. A
comprehensive neuropsychological examination takes about three hours, which is not
always suitable in a perioperative setting. Currently diagnosis of POCD implies testing
10
in the following domains: learning and memory, attention, executive functioning and
language, supplemented by a decline in perception and abstract thinking (Tsai et al,
2010). Finally, there is no clear agreement about the optimal timing when to test
patients at risk for POCD. Patients undergoing their preoperative cognitive assessment
may not score as well as expected due to pre-procedural anxiety or effects of
premedication. Patients who are tested shortly after surgery may have substandard
scoring due to residual effect of the medication or anesthetics, pain and general health
status. Trials requiring long-term follow-up may experience loss to follow up in patients
suffering from POCD, leading to confounding by attrition.
Postoperative cognitive decline had been extensively tested in cardiac surgery,
but less in non-cardiac surgical patients. Several studies have tried to associate the
occurrence of POCD with various adjustable surgical and anesthetic factors. Currently
only two clinical studies have addressed the association between cerebral desaturation
during shoulder surgery in beach chair position and postoperative cognitive
dysfunction. One study did not find any significant change in postoperative MMSE
score (Salazar et al., 2013). The other study combined both executive function tests
and serum biomarkers of brain injury. No differences in cognitive outcome were found
between the beach chair group and supine position control group (Laflam et al, 2015).
11
Goal of the study
This study aims to identify episodes of cerebral desaturation using NIRS during
shoulder surgery in beach chair position and will try to associate these episodes to
potential postoperative neurocognitive dysfunction using a combination of
neurocognitive tests. These will test executive functions mediated by the frontal lobe,
i.e. the location where NIRS is used to measure cerebral oxygenation. Considering the
underlying shoulder pathology, all tests will be motor free. Furthermore patient risk
factors for events of cerebral desaturation and postoperative neurocognitive
dysfunction will be investigated. We hypothesize that events of cerebral desaturation
are connected to neurocognitive dysfunction in the postoperative period.
12
Materials and methods
Approval from the local ethics committee was obtained. Written informed
consent was obtained from study candidates. All consecutive patients planned for total
shoulder arthroplasty, were screened for inclusion after referral to the preoperative
consultation. The average time interval between this consultation and date of surgery
was ten days. Exclusion criteria were age younger than 18, prior neurologic event,
amourosis fugax, apparent cognitive dysfunction, carotid stenosis, previous head and
neck surgery, cervical disc herniation, recent acute myocardial infarction and syncope.
Elderly patient aged 75 or more were screened using a mini-mental state examination
for gross neurocognitive deficit prior to inclusion in the study. A score lower than 24 is
compatible with a preoperative existing neurocognitive deficit, thus these patients were
excluded. Collected demographic data included age, gender, level of education,
smoking status, prior health problems (diabetes mellitus, chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease, metabolic syndrome, pre-existing cardiovascular disease), length,
weight, body mass index (BMI) and current medication use. Education level was
defined as years in any form of education (primary education, secondary education,
college/university, doctorate, night classes). A baseline preoperative neurocognitive
function was assessed using the ‘Auditory Verbal Learning Test’ (AVLT), ‘Stroop Color
Word Test’ (SCWT) and ‘Symbol Digit Modalities Test’ (SDMT). All neurocognitive
tests evaluate frontal lobe mediated executive functions. All tests were motor free,
considering the underlying shoulder pathology. Patients did not receive any
psychoactive medications (e.g. anxiolytics) before performing this neurocognitive
assessment.
No premedication or anxiolytics were administered pre-operatively. After arrival
in the operating room, the standard protocol for shoulder surgery was followed. An
intravenous line was placed and normal saline was used as a standard. A three or five
leads ECG, depending on the cardiovascular status of the patient, was applied to the
patient. A pulse oximeter was secured to the index finger of the non-operated hand. A
blood pressure cuff was positioned on the non-operated arm. Non-invasive blood
pressure was measured every three minutes. All three were connected to the
anesthesia monitor. Before induction of general anesthesia an ultrasound guided
interscalene block was placed using a mixture of plain levobupivacaine 0.5% and
13
mepivacaine 2%. Two INVOS sensors (Covidien, Medtronic, Minneapolis, USA) and a
bispectral index (BIS) sensor (Covidien, Medtronic, Minneapolis, USA) were applied
on the patient’s forehead. Anesthesia was induced with sufentanil (0.1 µg/kg), propofol
(2 – 3 mg/kg) and cisatracurium (0.1 mg/kg). After reaching adequate depth of
anesthesia and neuromuscular blockade an endotracheal tube was placed. Anesthesia
was maintained with a mixture of 50% air and 50% inspired oxygen and sevoflurane
(age corrected MAC value of 1) and adapted to obtain BIS values between 40 and 60.
Additional doses of muscle relaxants and opiates were at the discretion of the treating
anesthesiologist. An oral thermometer was placed and patient’s temperature was kept
at a minimum of 35.5°C using forced air warming. A baseline cerebral oximetry value
was obtained after obtaining adequate depth of anesthesia and before positioning.
Afterwards the patient was positioned in the beach chair position. Patients were raised
to a 60 to 70 degrees sitting position with the head fixed in midline position. Continuous
cerebral oximetry was obtained during the entire anesthetic and surgical procedure.
All personnel in the operating room was blinded for cerebral oximetry measurements.
Likewise all auditory signals of the device were disabled.
Cerebral desaturation was defined as a decline in cerebral oxygen saturation of
20%, compared to baseline value. An area under the curve combining the duration and
severity of cerebral desaturation (AUCrScO2) was calculated. Intraoperative hypotension
was defined as systolic blood pressure lower than 80 mmHg. Bradycardia was defined
as a heart rate below 45 beats per minute. They were treated with ephedrine and
atropine respectively, according to current standard of care guidelines in our operating
theatre. In view of the current debate concerning the use of phenylephrine and its effect
on cerebral oxygenation, this drug was not our first choice of medication. Standard
postoperative nausea and vomiting and pain protocols were followed. The amount of
blood loss and fluids given to the patient as well as the doses of all drugs administered,
were recorded. After the surgical procedure, the patient was awakened and
transported to the postoperative care unit, where they were discharged after reaching
discharge criteria (Aldrete score > 8).
The first postoperative testing took place on the third postoperative day
(concordant with the day of hospital discharge in the majority of standard cases). The
‘Auditory Verbal Learning Test’ (AVLT), ‘Stroop Color Word Test’ (SCWT) and ‘Symbol
14
Digit Modalities Test’ (SDMT) were repeated using alternative versions where
appropriate to minimize test-retest effects.
The second postoperative testing took place three months post-surgery. This
coincided with a follow-up consultation with the treating orthopedic surgeon in the
outpatient clinic. The ‘Auditory Verbal Learning Test’ (AVLT), ‘Stroop Color Word Test’
(SCWT) and ‘Symbol Digit Modalities Test’ (SDMT) were assessed again. After this
follow-up moment, the study was ended. All neurocognitive tests were performed by
the same person.
Statistical analysis was performed using the SPSS Statistics version 23 (2015)
(IBM, New York, USA). Data were tested for normal distribution using the Shapiro –
Wilk test. Normally distributed data are reported as mean and standard deviation (SD).
The incidence of cerebral desaturation in patients older than 65 and patients suffering
from hypertension was analyzed using the Fisher Exact test. Correlation were
calculated using Pearson correlation coefficient. The pre-surgery, post-surgery and
follow-up test results were analyzed using a repeated multivariate analysis of variance
(repeated ANOVA). Age and degree of cerebral oxygen desaturation were included as
covariates. A p - value lower than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
15
Results
21 consecutive patients, planned for total shoulder arthroplasty, were screened
for inclusion. After medical evaluation 12 (57.1%) were included in the study. One
patient did not complete the second postoperative neurocognitive evaluation and was
considered lost to follow-up. Table 2 shows relevant demographic data of included
patients. Consequently statistical analysis was performed on the data of 11 patients,
who completed all three neurocognitive evaluations after surgery. Two patients
(18.2%) required additional surgery in beach chair position because of surgical
complications. One patient required shoulder reduction under general anesthesia two
months postop after prosthesis luxation. The other patient required evacuation of a
hematoma at the surgical site under general anesthesia four days after the initial
surgery.
Table 2: Patients characteristics
Sex, male/female (n (%)) 4 (36.4%) / 7 (63.6%)
Age, years (mean ± SD) 65 ± 12.39
Education level, years (mean ± SD) 10.6 ± 3.8
Hypertension, yes/no (n (%)) 5 (45.5%) / 6 (54.5%)
Table 3 shows relevant information about anesthesia and surgery. All patients
received crystalloid solutions. Following current controversy about fluid administration,
colloids were only used in severe blood loss, which none of our patients suffered from.
The surgical procedure did not necessitate deliberate hypotension, so current standard
practice in case of low blood pressure was followed. The use of phenylephrine as first-
line treatment of hypotension was discouraged. 7 out of 11 patients (63.63%) received
ephedrine (6 – 33 mg) and 2 patients (18.2%) received phenylephrine (100 – 700 µg)
for systolic blood pressure lower than 80 mmHg. Phenylephrine was only used as a
second line agent in hypotension refractory to ephedrine. Two patients (18.2%)
received a fluid bolus of crystalloids for the treatment of hypotension. No patients
received atropine for a heart rate lower than 45 beats per minute.
16
Table 3: Anesthesia and surgical characteristics
Duration BCP, min (mean ± SD) (min – max) 110 ± 32 (48 – 192)
Blood loss, ml (mean ± SD) (min – max) 325 ± 352 (120 – 1200)
Total fluids, ml (mean ± SD) (min – max) 789 ± 487 (360 – 2250)
Drugs use, n (%) Atropine: 0 (0%)
Ephedrine: 7 (63.63%)
Phenylephrine: 2 (18.2%)
Fluid bolus: 2 (18.2%)
The descriptive statistics of the neurocognitive tests at the three different points
in time are displayed in table 4. The AVLT score represents a learning score. The total
score represents the number of correct answer during the first five AVLT test runs. The
SCWT is scored as the number of correct answers. The SDMT represent the time in
seconds to finish the entire test.
Table 4: Descriptive statistics of the neurocognitive tests
SCWT, n (mean ± SD) T1 55.52 ± 35.67
T2 64.74 ± 43.89
T3 56.35 ± 45.0
AVLT, n (mean ± SD) T1 38.18 ± 10.27
T2 38.18 ± 12.41
T3 48.73 ± 13.07
SDMT, s (mean ± SD) T1 42.36 ± 14.73
T2 42.18 ± 15.79
T3 47.64 ± 10.45
No patient experienced gross neurological complications. Mean baseline rScO2
before induction was 60.9% and 62.4%, respectively on the left and right side. Before
positioning mean rScO2 on the left side was 71.2% and 75.2% on the right side. After
positioning to beach chair positioning, there was a relative decrease of rScO2 of more
17
than 20% in 3 patients (27.3%). During the overall surgical procedure in beach chair
position there was a relative decrease of rScO2 of more than 20% in all eleven patients
(100%). The mean AUCrScO2 during the entire surgical procedure in beach chair
position was 73.42 %*sec on the left side and 180.92 %*sec on the right side. Age
older than 65 did not appear to be a significant risk factor for cerebral desaturation after
positioning in beach chair (χ² = 0.244; P = 0.62). Likewise, adequately treated
hypertension did not appear to be a risk factor for cerebral desaturation after
positioning (χ² = 0.749; P = 0.39). Similarly no correlation was found between age and
AUCrScO2 on the right (r = 0.081, P = 0.81) and left side (r = -0.040, P = 0.91).
A repeated measures multivariate analysis of variance with a Greenhouse-
Geisser correction with time as within-subject variable (pre-surgery, post-surgery, and
follow up assessment) was performed. Age and degree of rScO2 desaturation were
included as covariates and SCWT, SDMT and AVLT as measures. The analysis
revealed no significant changes in overall cognitive test performance over time. In
addition, no significant interaction between time and age or rScO2 desaturation was
unveiled. Post-hoc tests only revealed a significant rise in score between the
postoperative and follow-up assessment on the AVLT performance (P = 0.014), which
can be attributed to a test-retest effect.
18
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study to examine the incidence of cerebral
desaturation and its association with postoperative neurocognitive sequelae in such a
homogenous surgical group. All patient underwent the same surgical procedure, a total
shoulder arthroplasty, with a similar amount of surgical time and duration of beach
chair position. As demonstrated in previous research, a high incidence of cerebral
desaturation occurs when a patient’s position is changed from supine to beach chair.
Our results confirmed a cerebral desaturation during the surgical procedure in beach
chair position in all of our patients. This corresponds with previous research (Fisher et
al., 2009; Dippmann et al. 2010, Tange et al, 2010; Lee et al. 2011; Yadeau et al.,
2011; Jeong et al., 2012; Ko et al., 2012; Moerman et al. 2012; Salazar et al, 2013;
Pant et al, 2014). Episodes of cerebral desaturation were similar in patients with and
without chronic hypertension. Finally our study showed no decline in cognitive outcome
after shoulder surgery in beach chair position.
The exact frequency of neurologic complications in patients undergoing surgery
in beach chair position is unknown. Major stroke occurs in 0.0004% of patients
according to a survey of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (Friedman et al.,
2009). When the treating anesthetist fails to appreciate the effect of hemodynamic
changes caused by the gravitational effect of the head-up position, cerebral
hypoperfusion may ensue. Blood pressure decreases proportionally to the weight of
the ‘fluid’ column. A subtraction of 1.35 mmHg per cm of head elevation is advised to
estimate the actual blood pressure at the brain. Although we were not able to provide
beat-to-beat blood pressure measurements and link them directly to episodes of
cerebral desaturation, several previous studies have shown the connection between
cerebral desaturation and hypotension. Not all patients will subsequently develop
cerebral ischemia, if compensatory mechanism such as a higher oxygen extraction
reserves are sufficient. At risk are patients with altered cerebral autoregulation (such
as untreated hypertension), cerebral atheromatosis and other problems with the circle
of Willis.
19
Cerebral desaturation was not associated with neurocognitive deficit in our
study population. In the majority of studies trying to find an association between
neurocognitive dysfunction and operations in beach chair position, no systematic
neuropsychological testing was performed. This is the second study that uses a test
battery of validated neuropsychological tests. Although our neuropsychological testing
is compatible with the 1995 consensus guideline and subsequent revisions, we chose
not to include motor testing, thus disabling some executive functions and
frontotemporal interactions. We opted to retest our patient on the third postoperative
day to reduce the possibility of residual effect of medication and anesthesia, which
could affect test scores negatively. Postoperative cognitive dysfunction may not always
be apparent during the hospital stay. We opted to retest at the third month
postoperative. A significant retesting effect was found in the AVLT, a test with memory
forming and recall as prime goal. Substitution to a more difficult test could possibly
eliminate this effect and improve test quality. A possible addition to our neurocognitive
testing could be the use of specific enzymatic markers of cerebral damage. Neuron-
specific enolase (NSE) is a neuronal isoform of the glycolytic enzyme enolase and is
more specific for grey matter lesions. Protein S100B is an intracellular calcium-binding
dimer, implicated in the proliferation and differentiation of neurons. It is more specific
for white matter. Considering the different characteristics, the more prudent approach
would be to analyze both, though current evidence has yet to define a clear consensus
about cut - off values compatible with neuronal damage, especially in the case of the
more subtle neurocognitive dysfunction. Other biomarkers of brain damage are
currently under investigation in a post-resuscitation and traumatic brain injury setting
(Tomaszewski, 2015) Only two studies show an association between POCD and
elevated serum markers of brain damage (Xie et al., 2013; Lagram et al., 2015).
Another possible option is the electroencephalogram (EEG). Patients who develop
cognitive dysfunction show less burst suppression and states of deep sleep during
anesthesia (Deiner et al., 2015). Thus far no study has investigated the use of EEG in
the postoperative diagnosis of POCD.
Our study has several limitations. The small sample size and lack of power could
explain the absence of a statistically significant result. This has several implications.
Our smaller study population did not allow for any proper subgroup analysis. Perhaps
the effect of cerebral desaturation does not have significant cognitive implications in
20
healthy patients, but may prove to be important in patients with cardiovascular risk
factors, such as peripheral artery atheromatosis, diabetes mellitus with associated
autonomous neuropathy, severe untreated hypertension and coronary artery disease.
No analysis was possible in the group of older patients (> 65 years old), who might be
at increased risk for the development of neurocognitive dysfunction. Our inclusion
criteria were strict. We chose not to admit any patients with a pre-existing
neurocognitive deficit or psychiatric disorder to the study protocol. Nonetheless both
patients group have an impaired cerebral reserve and are especially at risk for the
development of POCD. Another limitation is the lack of control group. We did not
compare our beach chair group with a similar non-beach chair group. Prolonged
shoulder surgery in lateral decubitus or other major joint surgery could be considered
as a control group in later study protocols.
In conclusion, a large fraction of our study patients undergoing shoulder surgery
in beach chair position are prone to experience episodes of cerebral desaturation at
positioning and during surgery. In our patient population, this cerebral lack of oxygen
was not correlated with any development of postoperative cognitive dysfunction. In
patients at risk for cerebral desaturation, specific monitoring and appropriate
hemodynamic interventions seems warranted as long as a potential relation between
cerebral desaturation and POCD has not been definitively excluded.
21
References
ALCOVER L., BADANES R., MONTERO M.J., SORO M., BELDA F.J.: Postoperative
delirium and cognitive dysfunction. Trends Anaesth Crit Care, 2013, 199-204.
BHATTI M.T., ENNEKING F.K.: Visual loss and ophthalmoplegia after shoulder
sugery. Anesth Analg, 2003, 899-902.
CASATI A., FANELLI G., PIETROPAOLI P., PROIETTI R., MONTANINI S.: Monitoring
cerebral oxygen saturation in elderly patients undergoing general abdominal sugery: a
prospective cohort study. Eur J Anaesthesiol., 2007, 59-65.
CLARK J.B., BARNES M.L., UNDAR A., MYERS J.L.: Multimodality neuromonitoring
for pediatric cardiac surgery: our approach and critical appraisal of the available
evidence. World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg, 2012, 87-95.
DEINER S., LUO X., SILVERSTEIN J.H., SANO M.: Can intraoperative processed
EEG predict postoperative cognitive dysfunction in the elderly?, Clin Ther, 2015, 2700-
2705.
DEINER S., SILVERSTEIN J.H.: Postoperative delirium and cognitive dysfunction. Br.
J. Anaesth, 2009, i41-i46.
DIPPMANN C., WINGE S., NIELSEN H.B.: Severe cerebral desaturation during
shoulder arthroscopy in the beach-chair position. Arthroscopy, 2010, 148-150.
DRUMMOND J.C.: The lower limit of cerebral autoregulation: time to revise our
thinking. Anesthesiology, 197, 1481-1483.
EDGELL H., Robertson A.D., HUGHSON R.L.: Hemodynamics and brain blood flow
during posture change in younger woman and postmenopausal women compared with
age-matched men. J Appl Phsyiol, 2012, 1482-1493.
ELY E.W., SHINTAI A. TRUMAN B., SPEROFF T., GORDON S.M., HARRELL F.E.J.,
INOUYE S.K., BERNARD G.R., DITTUS R.S.: Delirium as a predictor of mortality in
mechanically ventilated patients in the intensive care unit. JAMA, 2004, 1753-1762.
22
FISHER G.W., TORRILLO T.M., WEINER M.M., ROSENBLATT M.A.: The use of
cerebral oximetry as a monitor of the adequacy of cerebral perfusion in a patient
undergoing shoulder surgery in the beach chair position. Pain Pract, 2009, 304-307.
FRIEDMAN D.J., PARNES N.Z. ZIMMER Z., HIGGINS L.D., WARNER J.J.P.:
Prevalence of cerebrovascular events during shoulder surgery and association with
patient position. Orthopedics, 2009.
GELBER P.E., REINA F., CACERES E., MONLLAU J.C. A comparison of risk between
the lateral decubitus and the beach-chair position when establishing an antero-inferior
shoulder portal: a cadaveric study. Arthroscopy, 2007, 522-528.
GIPSON C.L., JOHNSON G.A., FISHER R., STEWART A., GILES G., JOHNSON J.O.,
TOBIAS J.D.: Changes in cerebral oximetry during peritoneal insufflation for
laparoscopic procedures. J Minim Access Surg, 2006, 67-72.
GUENTHER U., RIEDEL L., RADTKE F.M.: Patients prone for postoperative delirium:
preoperative assessment, perioperative prophylaxis, postoperative treatment. Curr
Opin Anaesthesiol, 2016, ePub ahead of print.
HUDETZ J.A., IQBAL Z., GHANDHI S.D.: Postoperative cognitive dysfunction in older
patients with a history of alcohol abuse. Anesthesiology, 2007, 423-430.
JEONG H., JEONG S. LIM H.J, LEE J., YOO K.Y.: Cerebral oxygen saturation
measured by near-infrared spectroscopy and jugular venous bulb oxygen saturation
during arthroscopic shoulder surgery in beach chair position under sevoflurane-nitrous
oxide or propofol-remifentanil anesthesia. Anesthesiology, 2012, 1047-1056.
JOBSIS F.F.: Noninvasive, infrared monitoring of cerebral myocardial oxygen
sufficiency and circulatory parameters. Science, 1977, 1264-1267.
KO S.H., CHO Y.W., PARK S.H., JEONG J.G., SHIN S.M., KANG G.: Cerebral
oxygenation of patients during arthroscopic shoulder surgery in the sitting position.
Korean J Anesthesiol, 2012, 297-301.
23
KOH J.L., LEVIN S.D., CHEHAB E.L., MURPHY G.S.: Cerebral oxygenation in the
beach chair position: a prospective study on the effect of general anesthesia compared
with regional anesthesia and sedation. J Shoulder Elbow Surg, 2013, 1325-1331.
LAFLAM A., JOSHI B., BRADY K., YENOKYAN G., BROWN C., EVERETT A.,
SELNES O., MCFARLAND E., HOGUE C.W.: Shoulder surgery in the beach chair
position is associated with diminished cerebral autoregulation but no differences in
postoperative cognition or brain injury biomarker levels compared with supine
positioning: the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation Beach Chair Study. Anesth
Analg, 2016, 176-186.
LEE J.H., MIN K.T., CHUN Y.M., KIM E.J., CHOI S.H.: Effects of beach-chair position
and induced hypotension on cerebral oxygen saturation in patients undergoing
arthroscopic shoulder surgery. Arthroscopy, 2011, 889-894.
LEE J.R., LE P.B., DO S.H., JEON Y.T., LEE J.M., HWANG J.Y., HAN S.H.: The effect
of laparoscopic surgery on cerebral oxygenation. J Int Med Res, 2006, 531-536.
LIN S.M., LIU C.Y., WANG C.H., HUANG C.D., HUANG P.Y., FANG Y.F., SHIEH M.H.,
HUO H.P.: The impact of delirium on the survival of mechanically ventilated patients.
Crit Care Med, 2004, 2254-2259.
MOERMAN A.T., DE HERT S.G., JACOBS T.F., DE WILDE L.F., WOUTERS P.F.:
Cerebral oxygen desaturation during beach chair position. Eur J Anaesthesiol, 2012,
82-87.
MORIMOTO Y., YOSHIMURA M., UTADA K., SETOYAMA K., MATSUMOTO M.,
SAKABE T.: Prediction of postoperative delirium after abdominal surgery. J Anesth,
2009, 54-56.
MCCORMICK P.W., STEWART M., GOETTING M.G., DUJOVNY M., LEWIS G.,
AUSMAN J.L.: Noninvasive cerebral optical spectroscopy for monitoring cerebral
oxygen delivery and hemodynamics. Crit Care Med, 1991, 89-97.
MILLBRANDT E.B., DEPPEN S., HARRISON P.L., SHINTANI A.K., SPEROFF T.,
TRUMAN B., BERNARD G.R., DITTUS R.S., ELY E.W.: Costs associated with delirium
in mechanically ventilated patients. Crit Care Med, 2004, 955-962.
24
MURKIN J.M., ARANGO M.: Near-infrared spectroscopy as an index of brain and
tissue oxygenation. Br J Anaesth, 2011, 3-13.
MURKIN J.M., NEWMAN S.P., STUMP D.A., BLUMENTHAL J.A.: Statement of
consensus on assessment of neurobehavioral outcomes after cardiac surgery. Ann
Thorac Surg, 1995, 1289-1295.
MURPHY G.S., SZOKOL J.W.: Blood pressure management during beach chair
position shoulder sugery: What do we know? Can J Anaesth, 2011, 977-982.
MURRELL C.J., COTTER J.D., GEORGE K., SHAVE R., WILSON L., THOMAS K.,
WILLIAMS M.J., AINSLIE P.: Cardiorespiratory and cerebrovascular responses to
head-up tilt I: influence of age and training status. Exp Gerontol., 2001, 9-17.
NIELSEN H.B.: Systematic review of near-infrared spectroscopy determined cerebral
oxygenation during non-cardiac surgery. Frontiers Physiol, 2014.
PANT S., BOKOR D.J., LOW A.K.: Cerebral oxygenation using near-infrared
spectroscopy in the beach-chair position during shoulder arthroscopy. Arthroscopy,
2014, 1520-1527.
PENNEKAMP C.W.A., BOTS M.L., KAPPELLE L.J., MOLL F.L., DE BORST G.J.: The
value of near-infrared spectroscopy during carotid endarterectomy in perioperative
stroke prevention. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg, 2009, 539-545.
PENNEKAMP C.W.A., IMMINK R.V., DEN RUIJTER H.M., KAPPELLE I.J., FERRIER
C.M., BOTS M.L., BUHRE W.F., MOLL F.L., DE BORST G.J.: Near-infrared
spectroscopy can predict the onset of cerebral hyperperfusion syndrome after carotid
endarterectomy. Cerebrovasc Dis, 2012, 314-321.
PLACKY J., HOFER S., VOLKMANN M., MARTIN E., BARDENHEUER H.J.,
WEIGAND M.A.: Regional cerebral oxygen saturation is a sensitive marker of cerebral
hypoperfusion during orthotopic liver transplantation. Anesth Analg, 2004, 344-349.
POHL A, CULLEN D.J.: Cerebral ischemia during shoulder surgery in the upright
position: a case series. J Clin Anesth, 2008, 463-469.
25
POTTER J.M., PIDGEON C., CUNNINGHAM A.J.: The sitting position in
neurosurgery: a critical appraisal. Br J Anesth, 1999, 117-128.
RUNDSHAGEN I.: Postoperative cognitive dysfunction. Dtsch Artzebl, 2014, 119-125.
SALAZAR D., SEARS B.W., AGHDASI B., ONLY A., FRANCOIS A., TONINO P:
Cerebral desaturation events during shoulder arthroscopy in the beach chair position:
patient risk factors and neurocognitive effects. J Shoulder Elbow Surg, 2013, 1228-
1235.
SALAZAR D., SEARS B.W., ANDRE J., TONINO P, MARRA G.: Cerebral desaturation
during shoulder arthroscopy: a prospective observational study. Clin Orthop Relat Res,
2013, 4027-4034.
SANDERS R.D., DEGOS V., YOUNG W.L.: Cerebral perfusion under pressure: is the
autoregulatory ‘plateau’ a level playing field for all? Anaesthesia, 2011, 965-976.
SKYHAR M.J., Altchek D.W., WARREN R.F., WICKIEWICZ T.L., O’BRIEN S.J.
Shoulder arthroscopy with the patient in the beach-chair position. Arthroscopy, 1988,
256-259.
SMITH J.J., PORTH C.M., ERICKSON M.; Hemodynamic response to the upright
position. J Clin Pharmacol, 1998, 375-386.
TANG L., KAZAN R., TADDEI R., ZAOUTER C., CYR S., HEMMERLING T.M.:
Reduced cerebral oxygen saturation during thoracic surgery predicts early
postoperative cognitive dysfunction. Br J Anaesth, 2012, 623-629.
TANGE K., KINOSHITA H., MINONISHI T., HATAKEYAMA N., MATSUDA N.,
YAMAZAKI M.: Cerebral oxygenation in the beach chair position before and after
general anesthesia. Minerva Anesthesiol, 2010, 485-490.
TERRANDO N., ERIKSSONS L.I., RYU J.K., YANG T., MONACO C., FELDMANN M.,
JONSSON FAGERLUND M., CHARO I.F., AKASSOGLOU K., MAZE M.: Resolving
postoperative neuroinflammation and cognitive decline. Ann Neurol, 2011, 986-995.
TOMOTKO G, MAEKAWA K.: Cerebral dysfunction after coronary bypass surgery. J
Anesth, 2014, 242-248.
26
TSAI T.L., SANDS L.P., LEUNG J.M.: An update on postoperative cognitive
dysfunction. Adv Anesth, 2010, 269-284.
WITLOX J., EURELINGS L.S.M., DE JONGHE J.F.M., KALISVAART K.J.,
EIKELENBOOM P., VAN GOOL W.A.: Delirium in elderly patients and the risk of
postdischarge mortality, institutionalization and dementia. JAMA, 2004, 443-451.
XIE Z., MCAULIFFE S., SWAIN C.A., WARD S.A., CROSBY C.A., ZHENG H.,
SHERMAN J., DONG Y., ZAHGN Y., SUNDER N., BURKE D., WASHICOSKY K.J.,
TANZI R.E., MARCANTONIO E.R.: Cerebrospinal fluid aβ to tau ratio and
postoperative cognitive change. Ann Surg, 2013, 364-369.
YADEAU J.T., LIU S. S., BANG H., SHAW P.M., WILFRED S.E., SHETTY T.: Cerebral
oximetry desaturation during shoulder surgery performed in a sitting position under
regional anesthesia. Can J Anaesth, 2011, 9574-9577.
ZHENG F., SHEINBERG R., YEE MS., ONO M., ZHENG Y., HOGUE C.W.: Cerebral
near-infrared spectroscopy monitoring and neurologic outcomes in adult cardiac
surgery patients: a systematic review. Anest Analg, 2013, 663-676.
27
Nederlandse samenvatting
Achtergrond/doel
Majeure schouderchirurgie in strandstoelhouding is geassocieerd met ernstige
neurologische gevolgen, zelfs in een gezonde patiëntenpopulatie van middelbare
leeftijd. De strandstoelhouding zelf wordt vaak aangehaald, aangezien deze de
cerebrale oxygenatie in het gedrang kan brengen. Deze studie heeft als doel de
associatie aan te tonen tussen peroperatieve episodes van cerebrale desaturatie en
postoperatieve cognitieve dysfunctie.
Materialen en methoden
Na toestemming van het Ethisch Comité en het afnemen van geïnformeerde
toestemming, werden 11 volwassen patiënten (4 mannen, 7 vrouwen met gemiddelde
leeftijd van 65 jaar met een SD van12.4 jaar) zonder voorafgaande neurologische of
psychiatrische pathologie op prospectieve wijze geïncludeerd. Zowel preoperatief, als
op de derde dag en drie maanden postoperatief werd de neurocognitieve functie
beoordeeld. Geheugen en aandacht werden geëvalueerd door middel van de ‘Auditory
Verbal Learning Test (AVLT)’, de ‘Stroop Color Word Test (SCWT)’ en de ‘Symbol
Digit Modalities Test (SDMT)’. Nabij-infrarood spectroscopie (NIRS) werd gebruikt om
peroperatieve episodes van cerebrale desaturatie op te sporen, gedefinieerd als een
daling van de basiswaarde met meer dan 20%. Standaard anesthetische zorg werd
verleend. Een herhaalde meting multivariaat analyse van variantie met tijd als ‘within-
subject’ variabele werd uitgevoerd.
Resultaten
Cerebrale desaturatie kwam voor bij alle patiënten tijdens de chirurgische
procedure. Er werden geen significante veranderingen in cognitief vermogen
gevonden tijdens de drie evaluatiemomenten. Eveneens was er geen significante
interactie tussen tijd en leeftijd met cerebrale desaturatie. Een significante verbetering
in test score voor de AVLT test postoperatief werd opgemerkt. Dit is meer dan
waarschijnlijk het gevolg van een belangrijk test-hertest effect.
28
Conclusie
Deze voorlopige resultaten tonen geen associatie tussen episodes van
cerebrale desaturatie en postoperatieve cognitieve dysfunctie. De huidige
patiëntenpopulatie is echter nog te klein om tot definitieve conclusies te komen.
Bevestiging van de bekomen resultaten in een grotere populatie is noodzakelijk.