presentation leeds
DESCRIPTION
Presentation LeedsTRANSCRIPT
1
18 April 2023
2
COULD YOUR CLIENTS BE MAKING MORE USE OF BUSINESS PROPERTY RELIEF?
For professional advisers only and should not be relied upon by retail clients
3
TAX EFFICIENT INVESTING WITH OXFORD CAPITALBACKGROUND
• Oxford Capital has been managing tax efficient investments since 1999.
• Partnership owned.
• 40 employees split between head office in Oxford and London.
• Managing assets in excess of £300m.
• Two core investment strategies – Growth and Infrastructure.
• Experienced investment teams with proven track records.
4
TAX EFFICIENT INVESTING WITH OXFORD CAPITALINVESTMENT EXPERTISE
Investment Strategy Growth Infrastructure
Client Motivation
Potential for investment
returnTax planning investment
Offering
5
TAX EFFICIENT INVESTING WITH OXFORD CAPITALTHE OXFORD CAPITAL JOURNEY
Investor Support Advisor Support
• Dedicated investor services team.• Efficient and timely management of EIS3
certificates.• Semi-annual cash statements and annual
audited valuation reports.• Annual investor reporting event for each
investment strategy.• Online support via Oxford Capital’s ‘Investor
Centre’.
• Business development support, including workshops with professional partners / introducers and joint presentations to clients.
• CPD qualifying workshops on how BPR and EIS can be integrated into holistic wealth planning.
• Regular updates (face-to-face, webinars, conference calls) on offerings.
• Dedicated investor services team.• Parallel reporting.• Online support via Oxford Capital’s ‘Investor
Centre’.
6
AGENDA
1 UNDERSTANDING THE IHT PROBLEM
2 WHAT IS BUSINESS PROPERTY RELIEF AND WHERE DOES IT FIT?
3 IDENTIFYING SUITABLE CLIENTS
4 DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
7
UNDERSTANDING THE IHT PROBLEM
8
BPR BACKGROUNDUNDERSTANDING THE IHT PROBLEM
• Assets in excess of £325,000 (the nil rate band) subject to IHT at 40%.
• The nil rate band is frozen at this level until 2020/21.
• New main residence nil rate band proposed from April 2017.
• Over £3.4bn collected by HMRC (2013/14).
• Generally regarded as a ‘voluntary tax’.
• As ‘asset values’ recover, the problem will only get worse.
• Ageing population.
9
BPR BACKGROUNDTHE IMPACT OF AN AGING POPULATION
• Number of the UK residents aged 65 and over is 11.1m (representing 17.4% of the population).
• This age group has increased by 17.3% in ten years.
• Males over 75 up 26% (women up 6%).
Source – ONS 2012.
10
BPR BACKGROUNDRISING HOUSE PRICES
• The average detached house is now valued at £323,100 (or 99.4% of the nil rate band).
• House prices are up, on average 11%, in five years.
• In London and the South East, prices have increased by almost 30%.
Region5 years
agoCurrent value
% change
London £524,300 £672,500 28.3%
North £228,900 £233,800 2.1%
Yorks & Humb
£223,400 £260,100 16.4%
N. West £251,100 £267,700 6.6%
E. Midlands
£206,700 £247,200 20%
W. Midlands
£266,600 £249,400 6.9%
E. Anglia £237,000 £299,200 26.2%
S. East £377,400 £490,400 29.9%
S. West £345,600 £377,400 9.2%
Scotland £257,000 £253,300 -1.4%
UK average
£290,200 £323,100 11.3%Source: Halifax Property Index Q3 2014.
11
BPR BACKGROUNDESTATES PAYING IHT EXPECTED TO DOUBLE
• The number of estates paying IHT is expected to double.
• Over the next five years 236,000 estates are expected to be subject to IHT.
• By 2018/19, almost 10% of estates will be subject to IHT.
Tax year
Proportion of
deaths subject to IHT
(%)
Deaths (‘000s)
Number of deaths subject to IHT (‘000s)
2013-14 4.8 548.7 26.2
2014-15 6.5 547.9 35.9
2015-16 8.0 547.6 43.8
2016-17 9.0 548.0 49.1
2017-18 9.6 549.0 52.7
2018-19 9.9 550.6 54.5
Source – OBR 2013.
12
BUSINESS PROPERTY RELIEF (BPR)BACKGROUND
13
BPR BACKGROUNDHISTORY OF BPR
• Introduced by Finance Act 1976.
• Designed to prevent a business having to be sold to pay IHT.
• Provided as a statutory relief, it offers non-contentious tax savings.
• Relief available at up to 100%, depending on asset.
• Increasingly used as a wealth management solution.
14
BPR BACKGROUNDTHE THREE PILLARS OF ESTATE PLANNING
ESTATE PLANNING
Solutions that utilise BPR Lifetime gifting Creating a fund to pay the IHT liability
15
BPR BACKGROUNDKEY BENEFITS
Access and control retained.
No complex trust structures or medical underwriting.
FLEXIBILITY
SIMPLICITY
Can accommodate a change in circumstances.AVAILABILI
TY
TIMELINESS
IHT benefits are achieved after just two years and if held on death.
16
BPR BACKGROUND
THE PROBABILITY OF SUCCESS
• Few estate planning solutions are effective immediately.
• Gift based solutions typically take seven years to be fully effective.
• BPR solutions provide freedom from IHT after just two years.
Current age
Male Female
Life expectancy
Probability of surviving two
years
Probability of surviving
seven years
Life expectancy
Probability of surviving two
years
Probability of surviving
seven years
65 18 97% 89% 20 98% 92%
70 14 96% 82% 16 97% 88%
75 11 93% 71% 12 95% 79%
80 8 88% 55% 9 91% 64%
85 5 80% 34% 6 84% 44%
90 4 68% 17% 4 73% 23%
95 2 53% 0% 3 58% 0%
Source: Office for National Statistics
17
IDENTIFYING SUITABLE CLIENTS - BPR PLANNING IDEAS
18
BPR PLANNING IDEASSUMMARY
‘Accelerated’ Estate Planning
Lifetime Gifting – Making Transfers Into Trust in Excess of the Nil Rate Band
Starting the Journey - Reducing the Costs of Estate Restructuring
BPR as a Trustee Investment – Managing the Periodic Charge
Mental Capacity – Powers of Attorney
Exit Planning for Business Owners
Death Bed Planning – It’s Never Too Late
The ‘Holy Trinity’
19
LIFETIME GIFTING – MAKING TRANSFERS INTO TRUST IN EXCESS OF THE NIL RATE BAND
20
LIFETIME GIFTING
A SIMPLE EXAMPLE
• Transfers into a ‘relevant property’ trust are chargeable lifetime transfers (CLT), with amounts in excess of the available nil rate band subject to tax at 20%.
• Where the person making the gift chooses to pay any liability, the effective rate of tax increases to 25%.
Value of transfer
£428,000
Less annual gifting exemption
£3,000
Value of CLT £425,000
Less, available nil rate band
£325,000
Amount subject to tax £100,000
Tax due at 20% £20,000
21
EIS IN ACTION
LIFETIME GIFTING
£428,000
Available to gift
£328,000
DiscretionaryTrust
£100,000
BPR qualifyingassets
22
EIS IN ACTION
LIFETIME GIFTING
£428,000
Available to gift
£428,000
DiscretionaryTrust
£100,000
BPR qualifyingassets
Option 1
After two years, transfer
to existing trust
23
EIS IN ACTION
LIFETIME GIFTING
£428,000
Available to gift
£328,000
DiscretionaryTrust (No.1)
£100,000
BPR qualifyingassets
£100,000
Discretionary Trust (No.2)
Option 2
After two years, transfer
to new trust
24
BPR AS A TRUSTEE INVESTMENT –
MANAGING THE PERIODIC CHARGE
25
BPR PLANNING IDEASBPR AS A TRUSTEE INVESTMENT – MITIGATING THE PERIODIC CHARGE
• Relevant property trusts are subject to periodic charges every ten years.
• Where the trust assets exceed the nil rate band available, IHT is paid at 6% on the excess.
• Capital distributions are ‘added back’ when determining trust assets.
Value of trust fund
£1,325,000
Less, available nil rate band
£325,000
Amount subject to tax £1,000,000
Tax due @ 6% £60,000
26
BPR PLANNING IDEASBPR AS A TRUSTEE INVESTMENT – MITIGATING THE PERIODIC CHARGE
Without EIS With EIS
Value of trust asset not qualifying for BPR £1,325,000 £325,000
BPR qualifying trust assets Nil £1,000,000
Amount subject to IHT £1,000,000 Nil
IHT payable @ 6% £60,000 Nil
27
MENTAL CAPACITY – POWERS OF ATTORNEY
28
BPR PLANNING IDEASPOWERS OF ATTORNEY - RESTRICTIONS ON THE ABILITY TO MAKE GIFTS
Section 12, MENTAL CAPACITY ACT 2005 - SCOPE OF LASTING POWERS OF ATTORNEY, GIFTS
(1) Where a lasting power of attorney confers authority to make decisions about P's property and affairs, it does not authorise a donee (or, if more than one, any of them) to dispose of the donor's property by making gifts except to the extent permitted by subsection (2).
(2) The donee may make gifts• (a) on customary occasions to persons (including himself) who are related to or connected
with the donor, or
• (b) to any charity to whom the donor made or might have been expected to make gifts, if the value of each such gift is not unreasonable having regard to all the circumstances and, in particular, the size of the donor's estate.
(3) “Customary occasion” means—• (a) the occasion or anniversary of a birth, a marriage or the formation of a civil partnership,
or
• (b) any other occasion on which presents are customarily given within families or among friends or associates.
(4) Subsection (2) is subject to any conditions or restrictions in the instrument.
29
BPR PLANNING IDEASPOWERS OF ATTORNEY – HOW BPR CAN HELP
• No need to make a gift / create a trust.
• Assets are registered in the name of the donor.
• The donor retains full access to the investment, together with the proceeds.
• No need to involve the Court of Protection.
• Saving time and money.
• Freedom from IHT after just two years.
30
EXIT PLANNING FOR BUSINESS OWNERS
31
BPR PLANNING IDEASEXIT PLANNING FOR BUSINESS OWNERS
RESTORING BPR ON THE SALE OF A BUSINESS
• On sale, the proceeds will be in the estate of the client as BPR ‘shelter’ is lost.
• BPR can be ‘restored’ immediately by investing the proceeds in to BPR qualifying assets within three years, buying time to consider options and allowing significant amounts to be transferred into trust without lifetime IHT charges.
32
BPR PLANNING IDEASEXIT PLANNING FOR BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SALE DUE TO ILL HEALTH
• What if the client is forced to sell a BPR qualifying business as a result of a terminal or critical illness? The illness may significantly reduce life expectancy. While sale may qualify for Entrepreneurs Relief, any gains will be taxed at 10%*.
• An investment into an EIS offers a potential solution given it attracts BPR qualifying status after two years.
*Assumes sale qualifies for Entrepreneurs Relief at 10%.**Subject to meeting qualifying criteria.
***Income tax relief of up to £300,000 could also be claimed.
Without EIS With EIS***
Gain on sale of business
£1,000,000 £1,000,000
CGT payable immediately*
£100,000 Nil
Proceeds net of CGT £900,000 £1,000,000
IHT arising on death £360,000 Nil**
Balance passing to beneficiaries
£540,000 £1,000,000
33
DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
34
DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
OVERVIEW OF CLIENT OBJECTIVES
• Freedom from IHT in the near term
• Typically seeking capital preservation
• A desire to balance the need for access with the opportunity to achieve a real return
• Flexibility to accommodate a change in circumstances
• The ability to access capital, either as a lump sum or a regular ‘income’
35
DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
BALANCING RISK WITH THE NEED FOR INVESTMENT RETURNS
• Many clients will be risk averse
• Diversification at an asset level can help manage specific risk
• Consider spreading the investment across a number of providers
• Important to achieve a ‘blend’ of liquidity options in order to allow the required level of access whilst also providing the potential for returns.
36
DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
CONSIDERATIONS WHEN ASSESSING A CLIENT’S NEED FOR ACCESS
• Not all clients will have the same need for access
• Arranging a suitable contingency fund remove the need to redeem investments – at least in the short term
• A diversified portfolio can offer a range of access options
• High level of access can impact on potential returns
• Many clients who request higher levels of access rarely utilise it.
37
DESIGNING A CLIENT RECOMMENDATION
STRUCTURING THE INVESTMENT
Immediate:
• Review accumulation or income options
• Need to consider the client’s tax position
• Determine frequency of any withdrawals
• Should the application be in joint or single names
Future:
• Consider how the client’s circumstance may change over time
• Will this necessitate rebalancing a client’s portfolio?
• What are the costs and tax implications of making changes?
38
ESTATE PLANNING SERVICE
39
ESTATE PLANNING SERVICESUMMARY
Client motivation Tax planning investment.
Strategy
Discretionary investment management service investing in companies that qualify for BPR. Focus on capital preservation.
Structure
Subscriptions invested in one or more holding companies depending on portfolio selected.
Configurability5 investment options, offering the choice of access, income and growth.
Flexibility
Ad hoc and/or regular access to capital, the option of a regular income, plus opportunity to switch option if circumstances change.
Subscriptions
Minimum of £50,000. Minimum for top up £25,000. Subscriptions are invested monthly.
40
ESTATE PLANNING SERVICEUNDERSTANDING THE INVESTMENT OPTIONS
CHOICE OF FIVE OPTIONS
Investment Option
Target dividend Income (p.a.)
Target capital growth (p.a.)
Target access to capital
Income 4% 6 months
Growth, with access 3% 1 month
Growth, with return 5% 6 months
Growth, balanced access and return
4%
Up to 50% within 1 month, with the balance after 6 months
Growth and Income 2% 2% 6 months
41
Q&A
42
REGULATORY NOTICE
We invest in companies for which there is no established or ready market for their shares. Capital is at risk and investors should only invest if they can afford to lose their capital. Investment is of a long term and illiquid nature. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Any tax advantages associated with investing are subject to change and depend on the individual circumstances of each investor.
This financial promotion is issued and approved by Oxford Capital Partners LLP (“Oxford Capital”) 201 Cumnor Hill, Oxford, OX2 9PJ. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under number 585981. Applications for investment in funds/portfolios managed by Oxford Capital may be made only on the basis of the relevant Information Memorandum and application form, copies of which are available from Oxford Capital. No reliance is to be placed on the information contained in this document in making any such application. This material is directed only at persons in the UK and is not an offer or invitation to buy or sell securities. This document is not an offer or invitation to invest in products managed by Oxford Capital nor does it solicit any such offer or invitation.
43
18 April 2023
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT Leeds - Tuesday 22nd September 2015
Presentation by:
John MarsdenFounder and Managing DirectorInnvotec Ltd
This presentation is approved by Innvotec Limited who is Authorised and
Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
Innvotec Limited is registered in England and Wales Company Number 02030086.
Innvotec is a small authorised UK AIFM “Alternative Investment Fund Manager”
regulated by the FCA (FRN: 122365).
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
TAX AND INVESTMENT PLANNING USING:
ENTERPRISE INVESTMENT SCHEME (EIS)
&
SEED ENTERPRISE INVESTMENT SCHEME (SEIS)
INVESTING IN HIGH GROWTH BUSINESSES
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Innvotec – where old meets new
Old - been around since 1987 and making venture* investments since 1989. New - a new and novel way of running a venture capital business.Result - a fast-growing, results driven manager focused on capital appreciation that is delivering performance for its clients. Its business model and lean cost structure results in Fund charges being competitive, results driven and with no need for “hidden” add-ons.
*venture= primarily early stage, not necessarily tech, investing
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Innvotec Background/ History
• Independent - ownership in hands of directors / staff.
• Clients - traditionally pension funds, corporates, ERDF (European money).
• Focus-capital appreciation.
• Regulated - from the outset, currently FCA as a small authorised Alternative Investment Fund Manager (AIFM). Can hold and control client money and assets.
• Early 2000’s - business modus operandi review resulted in working with Strategic Partners.
• 2009 - launched initial EIS Fund with Anglo Scientific as its first Strategic Partner.
• 2015/16 - 7 EIS/ SEIS Funds in conjunction with 5 Strategic Partners.
• 2015 - Bermuda subsidiary (Offshore money into Innvotec portfolio companies).
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Recap on benefits accruing to EIS / SEIS investing
• Set off against income tax.
• Capital gains tax deferral (partial exemption for SEIS).
• Carry back facility.
• Capital gains tax exemption on exit-3 year holding period.
• IHT reliefs- 2 year holding period.
• Loss reliefs.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Income Tax Benefits
EIS SEIS
Relief 30% 50%
Annual Limits £1m £100k
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Capital Gains Tax Exemption/Deferral
EIS SEIS
Annual Limit Unlimited £100k
Deferral 100% 50%
Exemption 0% 50%
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Carry back facility
Against Income Tax CGT Reinvestment
EIS 1 year 3* years
SEIS 1 year 0** years
*Qualifying investment must be made one year before or three years after gain on which relief is sought.** Qualifying investment has to be made in same tax year.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
IHT benefits of EIS/ SEIS
• Investments outside of IHT net if held for more than 2 years.
• This is due to Business Property Relief (BPR).
• The investor will still retain access to the funds invested if needed.
• Various IHT planning opportunities.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Gross investment
Income Tax relief @ 30%
CGT deferral relief @ 28% (assuming qualifying gains to defer)
Net Cost (Effective)
EIS example of cost of investment
£ £
25,000 100,000
(7,500) (30,000)
17,500 70,000
(7,000) (28,000)
10,500 42,000
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Gross investment
Income Tax relief @ 50%
CGT deferral relief @ 28% (assuming qualifying gains to defer)
Net Cost (Effective)
SEIS example of cost of investment
£ £
25,000 100,000
(12,500) (50,000)
12,500 50,000
(7,000) (28,000)
5,500 22,000
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Other benefits of EIS/ SEIS
• 100% Capital Gains Tax Exemption if shares held for 3 years.
• Loss Relief (to include negligible value claim) with amount of loss (less initial tax relief received) offset against income – this protects the downside.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
HMRC Reviews & Budget Changes
Recent HMRC reviews and budget changes have focused on tax reliefs going where they were intended to - namely investments where there is a degree of risk.
• This has resulted in the closing of “loop holes” with respect to EIS companies that carry little or no investment risk i.e. asset – backed, those whose business is dependent on feed-in tariffs, subsidised electricity generation.
• This increasingly hard-line approach to EIS investing will continue.
• Whilst there will still be offerings that will test “the edge of HMRC’s envelope”, funds, in the main, will increasingly have to invest in conventional private companies from the fledgling (in the case of SEIS) to the more mature, profit/ cash generating.
NB a company can’t apply for reliefs for the first time if it has been trading for more than 7 years or 10 years in the case of knowledge intensive companies and there is a £12m aggregate EIS limit (£20m for knowledge intensive companies).
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
HMRC Reviews & Budget Changes
• Broadly speaking Fund Managers will continue to build EIS portfolios that will be classed as either capital “preservation” or “growth/appreciation” but the type of business to be targeted will revert to the more conventional trading company and more specifically its trading features (is it profitable / cash generative) and where it is on its valuation growth “curve”.
• SEIS portfolios by the very nature of the target companies have to be focused on growth/ capital appreciation.
• Occasionally there are “hybrid” funds appearing offering investors the prospect of investing in both SEIS / EIS opportunities in the same tax year. NB the same portfolio company can be in receipt of both SEIS and EIS in the same tax year.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
• Perceived to be more risky given target companies and they are but:
• Risks need to be analysed, known and understood and then matched against potential upside.
• Risks within a Fund lie in the business risks inherent in the individual companies and the accompanying probabilities.
• The “upside” depends on where the individual companies are on their growth curves.
Capital Appreciation Funds/ High Growth Opportunities(typically with a technology-bias)
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Capital Appreciation Funds/ High Growth Opportunities(typically with a technology-bias)
• Investors / advisers have no way of knowing anything about the type and stage of companies being invested in and depend on the expertise of the Fund Manager.
• Less understanding on the advisers’ part of the type of target companies leads to less inclination to recommend.
• The conundrum being that investors themselves want to support emerging UK-based companies and make a decent gain for so doing.
• So the more advisers know about the portfolio composition and how risk is being handled the more they are likely to recommend.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Why invest in EIS / SEIS Technology Funds?
• There are many different types of technology.
• What makes a true opportunity in technology?
• When is a company ready for investment?
• What is disruptive technology?
• What is digital technology?
• The benefits of technology that have a global reach.
• Why EIS / SEIS technology investment strategies are different?
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Capital Preservation & Capital Appreciation
Capital preservation = seeking target private companies that are deemed by the Fund Manager to carry a minimal risk of failure and a good prospect of being able to “exit” and generate cash after the 3 year holding period. The ideal target is profitable and cash generative but requires additional funding to develop further and this can only come/ part come from equity. NB many profitable private companies would prefer debt so that their equity holding is not diluted.
Capital Appreciation = seeking target companies that the Manager believes have the potential for exponential increase in value, the position of such companies on the value growth curve increases as the various levels of risk are reduced. NB such companies are typically loss making and cash consuming, require further equity to fund their on-going progress. “Exits”, in many cases, are likely to be well beyond a three year window but the financial rewards can be substantial with, as a target, returns of 5x to 20x+.
So if there is appetite for EIS/ SEIS, a balanced portfolio would seem sensible.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Risk mitigation in capital appreciation (EIS/SEIS) Funds
How to address this?
• Innvotec addresses this through its strategic partnering programme.
• Most Fund Managers whose business is based on tax-efficient investing do not have the (costly) specialist expertise in-house to offer investment products focused on capital appreciation.
• Innvotec is typical and yet is a firm supporter of growth focused funds. As an investment house it has opted to work with and alongside third parties, its “strategic partners”, who possess the necessary skills to build (or create) deal flow, evaluate the technology (if applicable), business strategy and stage of development of investment opportunities. The Partners then provide the required degree of “hands on” support during the post investment and development phase of the portfolio companies.
• The intention is to address as far as is possible the risk within each portfolio company and hence within the Fund.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Innvotec’s strategic partners;
• *Anglo Scientific –EIS.
• *Startup Funding Club (SUFC)– SEIS.
• Oxford Innovation Opportunities Network (OION) – SEIS.
• FinTech Circle – SEIS.
• Bank House- EIS/ SEIS.
• Williams Advanced Engineering (EIS/SEIS)**.
Each Fund has a different and novel profile.* Flagship Partner
** subject to main F1 Board Approval
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Number 1 priority when advising clients is performance
Past performance no guarantee to future performance but:
• 7 EIS Funds, average uplift on cost 30%* (before tax benefits) FTSE comparative movement 25%.
• 2 SEIS Funds, uplift on cost of initial fund 29%* (before tax benefits).
*Based on standard valuation criteria of most recent 3rd party transaction in the shares
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
EIS / SEIS Investment Approach
• The approach of working with knowledgeable specialists does help Fund Managers when working with businesses offering the prospect of fast growth but which carry a commensurate level of risk.
• Despite the risk, good and sustained performance from capital appreciation funds can be obtained.
• Investors like their money to be safe above all but then look for an above average return.
• Investors do like to feel that their tax reliefs can be used to make a difference.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
So why does Innvotec consider itself not a “me too” in the world of EIS/SEIS fund providers, probably because;
• Its undiluted focus on Funds offering the prospect of real capital appreciation.
• Its happy to share its Funds’ performance.
• Its business model of working with knowledgeable strategic partners each of whom is non-competitive with the others.
• Its policy of client friendly visible charging, together with a challenging performance hurdle that is portfolio based.
• Its approach to launching funds with novel themes.
• Its general “can do” approach.
EIS MAGAZINE EVENT
Thank you for your time
Any questions are welcome?
Alternatively, I would be delighted to speak on a one to one basis after the talk.
Tel: +44(0) 207 630 6990
Email: [email protected]
68
Downing Estate Planning ServiceFor investment professionals only
69
Important noticeInvestment professionals only
This presentation has been prepared for independent financial advisers, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, and has not been approved for any other purpose.
If you forward this document to any other person, you must ensure that you have taken responsibility for it under the financial promotion rules. The information contained herein is in summary form, subject to change, and has been set out for illustrative purposes only and no reliance should be placed upon it. Investment decisions should be based only on the relevant Downing Estate Planning Service Product Literature.
Downing LLP, Ergon House, Horseferry Road, London SW1P 2AL, is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Firm Reference Number 545025).
9 September 2015
Important notice
70
Key risks
Key risks
Investors’ capital is at risk. Set out below are some of the key risks involved with an investment through the Downing Estate Planning Service (the Service).
Taxation: rates of tax, tax benefits and allowances described in this presentation are based on current legislation and HMRC practice and depend on personal circumstances. These may change from time to time and are not guaranteed. In addition, any changes to the sectors that qualify as IHT trades may have a material adverse effect on the value of the shares or the ability to achieve the objectives of the Service.
IHT investments: there is no guarantee that sufficient investments in IHT Companies will be made within the expected timetable, or at all. In addition, IHT Companies may subsequently cease to qualify for IHT relief. In such cases, the IHT relief could be delayed or lost.
Liquidity: Although the Service will seek to provide access to funds on a monthly basis, in the event of substantial demand, there could be a delay because the investments made through the Service will be in unquoted companies, the shares of which are less liquid than listed shares. Such investments are also considered to be higher risk than securities listed on the London Stock Exchange.
Performance: past performance is not a guide to future performance and there is no guarantee that the Service’s objectives will be achieved. The value of investments and the income derived from them may go down as well as up and investors may not get back the full amount invested.
Please refer to the relevant Product Literature for a full list of the risk factors.
71
Contents
• About us• Downing Estate Planning Service• Investment strategy• Case studies• Track record• Downside protection insurance• Distributions, access and charges• Conclusion• Appendix
Contents
About us
73
About us
About us
• Specialise in tax-efficient investments: VCT, EIS, IHT, AIM NISA
• Over £650m FUM; over £140m for BPR funds
• Established 1986
• We are a cautious investor: focus on yield and cash generative assets
Downing Estate Planning Service
75
• Strategy: Asset-backed and/or
renewable energy
• Entry/access: Monthly allotments and
access subject to liquidity
• Diversification: subscription
immediately spread across over 50
businesses
• Returns: Base target growth of 4% p.a.
(medium term) & upside potential
• Downside protection insurance
Downing Estate Planning Service
Downing Estate Planning Service
Key points
76
Downside protection insurance
• Downside protection insurance policy (underwritten at Lloyds)
• Designed to cover a loss of up to 20% of original net investment
based on total return: 75.6p to 94.5p, assuming 5.5% initial charges (Downing & IFA*)
• Cover for all subscribers up to age 90 at death (min. of 2 years cover)
• No medical questionnaire & no exclusions for pre-existing conditions
(max investment covered approx. £500,000)
• Premiums paid by Downing out of its fees
Downside protection insurance
Range of outcomes illustrating the effects of the Insurance Policy on £100,000 subscribed
Total Return at time of death
140,000 120,000 100,000 80,000 60,000
Insurance payout - - - 14,500 18,900
*Level of adviser charge is not fixed and Downing does not advocate any specific level.
77
Distributions and access
Distributions, access and charges
• Distributions:
6 monthly at a level set by investor (subject to liquidity)
Provided by way of sale of shares
Can be deferred and switched on at later date
• Access:
Monthly access subject to 10 days’ notice and liquidity
No exit charges
• Liquidity for access from:
New funds raised
Cash within Fund
Maturing investments (e.g. secured short term loans regularly maturing)
Sale of investments
78
Charges
Distributions, access and charges
Initial charge 2%
Annual management charge
2% plus VAT
Performance fee (on exit)
20% on cash proceeds over 4% p.a. compound
Both initial and ongoing adviser charges can be facilitated through this service.
Charges to underlying companiesDowning charges each business arrangement fees of 1%-2% (average 0.69% in the last 12 months)* of the amount invested plus a monitoring fee of up to 0.5% p.a. (average 0.25% in the last 12 months)*.
For full details of charges please refer to the relevant Product Literature.
Fund charges (for advised clients)
* To 31 May 2015, source: Downing LLP
Investment strategy
80
Investment strategy
Investment strategy
and/or
Asset-backed companies(Pulford Trading Ltd)
e.g. hotels, property development
Renewable energy companies(Bagnall Renewables Ltd)
e.g. solar, hydro & AD businesses
Subscribe through the Service
Direct investments Loans LoansDirect investments
81
Investment strategyWhy asset-backed businesses?
• Lower risk compared to businesses with no tangible assets
• Attractive range of sectors: hotels, pubs, care homes, nurseries
• Over 15 years’ asset-backed experience
• Invested >£150 million in asset-backed businesses since 2011
• Can do follow-on investments with proven operators
Investment strategy
Icon Hotels LLP, Humber Royal Downoak Ltd, Crown & Thistle
82
£43.5mAs at 30 June 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Pubs/property development, London£11.7m
Care home, Scotland£8.3m
Care home, Scotland£7.6m
Hotel, Grimsby £3.8m
Care home, Scotland£3.3m
Care home, Scotland £2.2m
Pubs, Warwick £2.1m
Property development, London £1.6m
Solar, England£1.5m
Solar, Surrey & Sussex£0.8m
Solar, England & Wales £0.6m
Sectors
Care
Hotels
Property dev.
Solar
Asset-backed portfolioDirect investments
83
Asset-backed portfolioLoans
AD, Norfolk£1.3m
AD, Exeter£4.7m
AD, Somerset£3.6m
Pubs, Home Counties£2.6m
Pubs, London£2.2m
Property development, Birmingham£2.1m
Property development, Devon£1.1m
Property development, Newcastle£1.7m
AD, Norfolk£1.6m
Property development, Bristol £1.5m
£30.7mAs at 30 June 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Property development, London £3.5m
AD, Dumfries£1.0m
Solar, Northamptonshire £1.0m
Property development, Bristol £0.5m
AD, Devon£0.5m
11 other investments under £500kTotal value £1.8m, various sectors
Sectors
AD
Pubs
Property dev.
Solar
Various
Case studies
85
Background• Acquisition of an 85 bed “turnkey” care home
located in Glasgow
Deal structure and terms• DIHT provided 75% of the funding required with
Management providing the balance• DIHT 8% p.a. paid interest and hold a 20%
profit share
Investment rationale• Experienced team with 10+ sites in England
and Scotland• Excellent location and client demographics
Progress
• The site has performed well• Bearsden has returned £3m of our original
investment through a bank refinancing
Pipeline• We have supported team to acquire and / or
build 3 further care homes that are performing in line with expectations.
Case Studies – Care Home
Investment partner: Care Concern Group
Investment vehicle: Bearsden LLP
Valuation 30 June 2015: £3.3m
86
Background• Construction of a 50,000 square foot data
centre in Birmingham (3MW)• Deal completed in summer 2015
Deal structure and terms• DIHT providing £10.4m of the funding with
partners providing £10.5m of sub-ordinated capital.
• DIHT 10.9% priority return and hold a 35% profit share.
Investment rationale• Outstanding and proven operational team and
co-investor• Market Opportunity to build a leading data
centre business in the Midlands.
Progress• The deal completed in the summer and
construction is underway.
Pipeline• Management have multi site experience and
there is an opportunity to roll out to additional, and identified sites.
Case Studies – Data Centre
Investment partner: Pure Date Centre Birmingham
Investment vehicle: Palmer Street LLP
87
Background• 58 bed Grimsby hotel, acquired in December
2010 for £1.6m• 3 star hotel in need of extensive renovation
works
Deal structure and terms• DIHT provided 85% of the funding required for
the purchase and the capex• DIHT 8% p.a. paid interest and hold a 50%
stake in the LLP
Investment rationale• Partnering with a hotel renovation company
(Icon) and a hotel management (Bespoke)• Under-supply of quality hotel rooms in the local
market, combined with strong corporate demand
Progress• The renovation project was successful and the
hotel now operates as a four star hotel• EBITDA increased from £160k in FY10 to
£525k in FY14
Pipeline• Currently assessing further opportunities to
build a portfolio of mid-market hotels in provincial locations with Icon Hotels
• This investment has also given us the opportunity to work with Bespoke Hotels, one of the leading hotel management companies in the UK, who we would strongly support to acquire and operate additional hotel properties
Case Studies – Hotels
Investment partner: Icon Hotels / Bespoke
Investment vehicle: Icon Hotel (Grimsby) LLP
Valuation 30 June 2015: £3.8m
88
Case Studies – Property Developments
Investment partner: Antic London
Investment vehicle: HB SP LLP
Valuation 30 June 2015: £11.7m
Background• Developing London properties – typically linked
to a pub (that they would operate)• Refurbishment or new build of residential or
commercial properties
Deal structure and terms• DIHT typically provides 80-90% of the funding
required for the purchase and the capex• DIHT 8% p.a. interest and hold a 50% stake in
the LLP
Investment rationale• Experienced London property developer and
pub operator.• Targeting well priced opportunities in areas that
have gone through or are going through gentrification
Progress• 3 x residential developments and 4 x pub
refurbishments completed• 2 x residential, 1 x commercial and 2 x mixed-
use developments and 2 x pub refurbishments currently ongoing
Pipeline• Developer has a regular flow of new
development opportunities• Currently progressing through the existing
works, and will look to take on new projects as these complete
89
Case Studies – Secured Lending
Investment partner: Downing LLP
Investment vehicle: Bridging Trading LLP (“BTLLP”)
Valuation 30 June 2015: £30.7m
Background• Lending vehicle created by Downing to take
advantage of attractive lending opportunities that are available to it through its VCT and EIS investments
• Enables DIHT to immediately start the BPR qualification period
• Loans allocated between Asset-Backed IHT and Renewables IHT
Deal structure and terms• Average interest rate of 9% on loans• Loans usually hold a first ranking position, with
an LTV of <30% • All loan proceeds flow back to the DIHT Funds
Investment rationale• Majority of loans provided to Downing VCT or
EIS investee companies, where Downing has significant controls over the borrower
• Excellent risk adjusted returns
Progress• Since 2012, the BTLLP loan book has grown to
over £60m (£27.3m allocated to Asset-Backed IHT and £34.4m to Renewables IHT)
• Loans provided to renewable projects, asset-backed trading businesses and property development projects
• BTLLP has never had to write off a loan that it has made
Pipeline• £23m (net) deal pipeline of new loans for the
second half of 2015 for BTLLP, which will be allocated between Asset-Backed IHT and Renewables IHT
90
• Funded 86 deals totalling >£300m within the sector since 2010• Funding construction through to operation provides access to
improved returns, whilst experience mitigates risks
Investment strategy
Willowglen Renewables Ltd, Hogsbrook Farm Woodbridge Solar Ltd, Ketton 1
Redstart Renewables Ltd, Kames Hydro Curlew Power Ltd, Oldside and Siddick
Why renewable energy businesses?
Investment strategy
£308m invested
2010 – Q1 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Solar£127.9m
Wind£12.4m
AD£147.2m
Hydro£20.1m
91
Renewables portfolioDirect investments
Rooftop solar, England & Wales £2.1m
Onshore wind, Lincolnshire & Scotland £4.6m
£15.3mAs at 30 June 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Commercial solar, England£5.9m
Rooftop solar, Devon & Dorset£2.7m
Sectors
Solar
Wind
92
Renewables portfolioLoans
Ground-mounted solar, S. England£7.6m
AD – CHP, Norfolk £2.9m
£34.6mAs at 30 June 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Ground-mounted solar, S. England£6.1m
Onshore wind, Cumbria£0.4m
Ground-mounted solar, S. England£4.0m
AD – gas-to-grid, Norfolk£3.9m
AD – gas-to-grid, Lincolnshire£3.4m
AD - CHP, Devon£1.9m
Ground-mounted solar, Lincolnshire£1.8m
Ground-mounted solar, S. England£1.5m
Ground-mounted solar, Lincolnshire £1.1m
Sectors
AD
Solar
Wind
93
Allocation of loans and direct investments across the entire IHT portfolio:
Renewable energy loans• No of loans: 11• Value: £34.6m• % of IHT portfolio: 24.6%
IHT portfolio summary
£140.8mAs at 30 June 2015
Source: Downing LLP
Cash• Value: £16.7m• % of IHT portfolio: 11.8%
Asset-backed direct investments• No of investments: 11• Value: £43.5m• % of IHT portfolio: 30.9%
Renewable energy investments• No of investments: 4• Value: £15.3m• % of IHT portfolio: 10.9%
Asset-backed loans• No of loans: 26• Value: £30.7m• % of IHT portfolio: 21.8%
Track record
95
Target returns
Target return 4% p.a. over the medium term
Track record
Priority return 9.0%1
Management fee (incl. VAT) (2.4%)
Effect of cash drag (1.5%)2
5.1%
Corporation tax (1.0%)
4.1%
1 Current average priority return on direct investments – 9.3%
loans – 9.6%
2 1.5% cash drag equates to holding cash of 15% - 20% of net assets with no return. Current cash levels are 11.8%.
Target should be met by priority return alone
Equity upside is on top
96 Track record
Track recordDEPS quarterly share prices
Fe
b-1
3
Ma
y-1
3
Aug
-13
Nov
-13
Fe
b-1
4
Ma
y-1
4
Aug
-14
Nov
-14
Fe
b-1
5
Ma
y-1
5
Date
Conclusion
98
Conclusion
• Capital preservation strategy:
- Asset-backed and/or renewable energy businesses
- Downside protection insurance
• IHT relief after 2 years
• 4% p.a. base target growth over the medium term*
• Proven track record
• Invest into existing portfolio of 15 direct investments & 37 loans
already generating sufficient returns to achieve base growth of 4%
Conclusion
* Please note this is a target and is not guaranteed
Ergon House, Horseferry RoadLondon SW1P 2AL / 020 7416 7780Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct [email protected] / www.downing.co.uk
100
18 April 2023
101
18 April 2023