rapid evaporative ionisation mass spectrometry (reims) for food & agri-tech applications

27

Click here to load reader

Upload: waters-corporation

Post on 12-Apr-2017

1.144 views

Category:

Science


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 40

Dr Sara Stead sara_steadwaterscom

18th March 2016

Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS)

for Food amp Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 41

Overview

Real time analysis for food testing

Food authenticity applications

ndash Fish amp meat speciation

ndash Botanical origin of honey

ndash Authenticity of PDO butter

ndash Phytochemical profiling in herbs

Agri-tech applications

ndash Phenotypic profiling

Summary amp future study

Acknowledgments

copy2016 Waters Corporation 42

Origins of REIMS

Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry

(REIMS) is an emerging technique that allows rapid

characterisation of biological tissues with no need for

sample preparation

The inventor Professor Zoltan Takats of Imperial College

London created the iKnife by connecting an

electrosurgical knife to a mass spectrometer

ndash Electrosurgical knives use an electrical current to rapidly

heat tissue cutting through it while minimising blood loss

ndash In doing so they vaporise the tissue creating smoke that is

normally sucked away by extraction systems but is actually a

rich source of biological information that can provide the

surgeon a real-time decision-making tool

copy2016 Waters Corporation 43

Sample

REIMS Instrument Configuration

iKnife Hand-held

sampling device(s)

Diathermy generator

Informatics system

Source

REIMS is an emerging technique that allows rapid characterisation of biological

tissues and food samples

Xevo G2-XS QTof amp SYNAPT G2 Si

Potential for automation ndash Tecan system

copy2016 Waters Corporation 44

How Does it Work

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 2: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 41

Overview

Real time analysis for food testing

Food authenticity applications

ndash Fish amp meat speciation

ndash Botanical origin of honey

ndash Authenticity of PDO butter

ndash Phytochemical profiling in herbs

Agri-tech applications

ndash Phenotypic profiling

Summary amp future study

Acknowledgments

copy2016 Waters Corporation 42

Origins of REIMS

Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry

(REIMS) is an emerging technique that allows rapid

characterisation of biological tissues with no need for

sample preparation

The inventor Professor Zoltan Takats of Imperial College

London created the iKnife by connecting an

electrosurgical knife to a mass spectrometer

ndash Electrosurgical knives use an electrical current to rapidly

heat tissue cutting through it while minimising blood loss

ndash In doing so they vaporise the tissue creating smoke that is

normally sucked away by extraction systems but is actually a

rich source of biological information that can provide the

surgeon a real-time decision-making tool

copy2016 Waters Corporation 43

Sample

REIMS Instrument Configuration

iKnife Hand-held

sampling device(s)

Diathermy generator

Informatics system

Source

REIMS is an emerging technique that allows rapid characterisation of biological

tissues and food samples

Xevo G2-XS QTof amp SYNAPT G2 Si

Potential for automation ndash Tecan system

copy2016 Waters Corporation 44

How Does it Work

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 3: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 42

Origins of REIMS

Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry

(REIMS) is an emerging technique that allows rapid

characterisation of biological tissues with no need for

sample preparation

The inventor Professor Zoltan Takats of Imperial College

London created the iKnife by connecting an

electrosurgical knife to a mass spectrometer

ndash Electrosurgical knives use an electrical current to rapidly

heat tissue cutting through it while minimising blood loss

ndash In doing so they vaporise the tissue creating smoke that is

normally sucked away by extraction systems but is actually a

rich source of biological information that can provide the

surgeon a real-time decision-making tool

copy2016 Waters Corporation 43

Sample

REIMS Instrument Configuration

iKnife Hand-held

sampling device(s)

Diathermy generator

Informatics system

Source

REIMS is an emerging technique that allows rapid characterisation of biological

tissues and food samples

Xevo G2-XS QTof amp SYNAPT G2 Si

Potential for automation ndash Tecan system

copy2016 Waters Corporation 44

How Does it Work

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 4: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 43

Sample

REIMS Instrument Configuration

iKnife Hand-held

sampling device(s)

Diathermy generator

Informatics system

Source

REIMS is an emerging technique that allows rapid characterisation of biological

tissues and food samples

Xevo G2-XS QTof amp SYNAPT G2 Si

Potential for automation ndash Tecan system

copy2016 Waters Corporation 44

How Does it Work

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 5: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 44

How Does it Work

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 6: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 45

REIMS for Food Research Workflow Chemometric Profiling

iKnife and Xevo

G2-XS QTof

Model Generation

Different tissues

Different species

Different production

Identification of unknowns by similarity to database entries

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 7: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 46

Direct Analysis for Flexible amp Rapid Screening

Sub-sampling Determination

(5s)

Data analysis (2s)

Report

Sample to report in seconds

Point-of-control analysis

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 8: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 47

REIMS for Food Security

AGRI-TECHNOLOGY

PROTECTED STATUS

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 9: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 48

Oceana Survey Undertaken in 2015

Only 6 of Northern red snapper fish collected were truly red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

84 of tuna sold in sushi restaurants was escolar (health effects)

Almost 50 of all grocery stores visited in Boston sold mislabelled fish

31 of cod in Boston was mislabelled

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 10: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 49

Fish Speciation Study

Phylogentic tree

Gadidae ndash Cod Haddock Coley Whiting amp Pollock

Pangasiidae ndash River Cobbler amp Basa (Vietnamese Catfish)

Lophiida ndash Monkfish

Serranidae ndash Sea Bass

Salmo ndash Atlantic salmon

Pleuronectes ndash European plaice

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 11: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 50

North Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) Gadidae genus

Glycerophospholipids PAs PEs PCs PIs

EPA Eicosapentaenoic

acid

DHA Docosahexaenoic

acid

Arachidonic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Fatty acids Unsaturatedamp saturated

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 12: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 51

Spot the Differences REIMS neg ion +IPA 200 microlmin + leu enk

Cod

Whiting

Monkfish

Leu enk [M-H]-

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 13: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 52

PROTOTYPE Software - PoP Multi-Species Fish Model

Gadidae species Cod haddock whiting

coley

Atlantic Salmon

Salmo salar

Sea Bass Dicentrarchus

labrax

Basa Pangasius bocourti

Plaice Pleuronectes platessa

Monkfish Lophius piscatorius

PCA model LDA model

Real-time recogniser software - prototype

n=ge3

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 14: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 53

Meat Speciation An Emerging Issue in India (October 2015)

Bos taurus vs Bison bonasus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 15: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 54

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid (PUFA) Content

Ca x16

Arachidonic acid Ω6

C20H32O2

Eicosapentaenoic acid Ω3

C20H30O2

Ca x7

Good ratio of Ω36 acids

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 16: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 55

Multi-Species Muscle Tissue ndash MVA Models

2 biological replicates of each species 10 technical replicates per sample

PCA model

Non-ruminants

Ruminants

Buffalo Bovine

Porcine

Ovine

Gallus gallus

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 17: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 56

PROTOTYPE Real-Time Recogniser Software

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 18: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 57

Food Fraud amp Authenticity Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 19: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 58

REIMS Spectra

Kaempferol

Apigenin

Oleanolic acid ursolic acid

Herbs amp spices

PDO status Belgian butter

Botanical origin of honey

Essential Ω6 fatty acid

Ω9

Galangin Myricetin

Geographical origin of coffee

Caffeine Tanzania

Peru

Kenyan

Colombian

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 20: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 59

Herbicide Selectivity in Cereals

and Competing Weeds

Collaboration with Prof Rob Edwards

University of Newcastle

School of Agriculture Food amp Rural Development

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 21: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 60

Black-Grass vs Rye Grass Spectral Comparison

(50 to 1200 mz 6-8 combined scans)

Rye grass

B-G Pel

B-G Roth

B-G Oxford

B-G Nots

Black-grass grouped vs Rye grass EZInfo OPLS-DA scores amp S-plot

-10

-09

-08

-07

-06

-05

-04

-03

-02

-01

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

-014 -013 -012 -011 -010 -009 -008 -007 -006 -005 -004 -003 -002 -001 000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022

p(corr)[1] (C

orrela

tio

n)

p[1] (Loadings)

S-Plot (Black grass = -1 Lollium = 1)

1400263

900115

2772171

16504551900430 1150312

1660423

1650222

7414758

13903131170221

21605872170469

999280

1640275

19205371410447

1130162

1930453

2552326

1910415

789608

83749277434941

890162

8155041

1910613

2792326

1410257

1160273

1670376

1420379

1890476

7424819

1430295

2430625

2400606

11401181670597

2420682

2782199

5552222

2150628

1680474

2670647

1690422

2680652

2190560

2180432

1180312

22004632410607

14404462180665

1630323

5052589

1940420

2140450

8165106

2440529

7455052

2660738

8384946

1700281

11697676

8094982

1950502

11707704

5542578

2420409

117177555735311

2450553

7444981

2690692

2390650

2930754

1998563

8617405

2650702

1450321

11477844

8335289

2640620

8394948

1400519

8337086

2700652

1140359

2920795

2940695

39539336015605

2060688

8406590

2910720

8195257

8175112

8315120

2900772

1890230

1350443

1960452

1880293

11487867

1800564

3012278

1380355

11727795

2832641

3170824

2680890

5372213

1160503

5454991

2310683

1680217

910147

19502222300694

7194830

6954716

2562358

2320608

4234233

1790543

1560516

8205289

1290382

5392049

2570787

1570513

8627454

31807882950697

22105072050623246064420706101190275

5933974

7465073

3160869

2130503

9355658

5745342

2560841

6974842

4514525

11837466

11857577

1210294

5532010

8365219

1300399

3190802

8345370

2040579

3492758

5111992

1640516

6152411

1810549

2812465

11847494

2802354

2290659

2810806

8347144

1009284

5232013

25507382330434 2830815

2560594

49319185062539

2710566

11497875

5271964

11147670

1530357

7634579

2320847

1169309

28208231800357

11737845

5102015

1120180

7935181

8897736

8416608

8426729

5712109

2030529

1540434

2330701

8325140

4941957

9395429

13103671970286

2470491

1550549

1900186

7214974

3430887

4991964

2540732

1460259

11257343

880201

4794843

2580741

2890826

18205911830560

2080551

3060845

7645134

9825695

5382233

3410883

6025622

1280380

5075155

11277435

9275060

9235465

11267379

2800776

4791825

9995588

2590824

5082025

34408543200786

3903002

34208692710906

8056771

2340668

5211984

4801862

1770352

11867628

3050892

3070834

1710426

4701903

1340441

2090619

3210783

714506811617667

2752002

900361

7475107

2790792

9715456

3150858

860048

2960437

1780541

5221994

9365671

7654983

3393279

1870355

3080932

7665297

5714155

4651740

2530728

8215335

3450795

1710229

3511502

5242039

8355342

3670932

9535483

1550360

8635513

17302543300849

1520394

1340361

8185092

6964726

1590453

5352074

3310911

8907746

2220601

93454863320920

10297576

5522083

2960862

3090531

3392009

4531693

3400913

3220610

6455845

3140816

11627695

1330388

1700606

3251864

22806552720394

1920204

5672099

11877735

1470445

5432086

20085611320477

5592517

3290886

7594156

3040902

9639555

2630691

8955434

3080512

5465031

8125025

3230755

9285057

59541122990494

7204831

9245485

30910663690903

4661751

9295025

11457617

36117772270571

1550808

4551726

3963949

5192065

2200835

3680918

9775713

5822216

11287421

8694794

5174678

930349

9545319

3570876

9835672

1300170

3551006

39122377675241

6806206

5944002

5051964

6175527

4132085

1850665

9495535

3661005

880535834607019359283

29710422020548

69848505131827

3330729

9635594

920263

2350678

3971399

9955513

1580589

5355463

8065247

6753567

2970489

7614208

3560963

3751952

9215250

1840468

11747899

717456111047437

3331133

8637473

8404870

4832678

11297440

979335

3871967

5852164

3831176

3340639

8066815

3833529

3931039

8766168

2840925

2970779

22202334242853

1190486

5202085

73849767945208

3650938

17705469255469

5362122

7155010

59721564541688

6295896

910307

5952075

1529958

4872402

4711823

2730879

10005560

31116963621768

2720840

7125001

9785731

1970660

31006733700874

507262711758158

42442554524554

2850908

15803352600821

1550118

8357145

2230551

8786303

8146333

6135543

4911776

1090303

4152190

1730617

21005852850394

6162455

1610601

3580800

2490542

10307599

9645654

8436725

37108998765425

11467695

7394558

3921043

3810982

11507916

5281971

9649639

7604111

10080158

2010541

3030878

3090703

6302345

3791128

9405409

1810963

9225329

1019269

9747161

2780866

8485229

9795653

10277450

1610240

5772661

6786026

3941029

3530995

9369360

6435715

3801014

3813366

6112240

11290284

5722117

3350821

29808821720424

4052047

6155484

9840194

11637616

11040270

7134889

6714595

3110738

8534854

1440202

6575788

4561846

6415835

35409663951038

9555296

5875335

9665490

6262206

8505415

8714804

5982299

8160143

5085154

5962097

10616688

9600241

10090187

48048864071135

9105355

2480783

4411630

4191153

8775419

3821028

3371805

10927682

9675453

5774370

19908183590810

4921864

2110795

11280242

3911047

11167652

8880191

4431177

1076686311016946

10255946

9850237

3531390

3512037

1850363

8815267

5451675

5291878

11050264

8085375

2121010

10800206

11887752

8424172

3470782

3280995

9919899

8225432

2380653

1177029210560196

3360916

11520261

9414851

3851576

9965468

5995438

2860954

9120200

7364886

4771631

7234610

3731792

6826372

2971571

4242554

11530318

10776817

4171167

10320182

5755372

10810276

4571728

6465837

406116310570244

7685507

4391567

1860611

3502724

1050342

8400166

8776174

1780315

44422264894342

6694536

27408963351721

1270392

9046364

110573525314575

1059764

2261188

2571262

5872073

8640153

2600298

3231720

1978611

1861232

4754315

10636717

4012098

3131020

1200131

3581301

2751127

11897851

2360714

3892100

2610734

6573444

8890225

5554441

2481204

3291619

9434821

5295383

7224929

3631866

5494320

81348387845423

180104611317491

10056043

4781732

2221208

9505652

3461323

5595014

46317753601053

33710903251095

3341160

1090398

9036501

4211211

70722388597265

3781661

6432196

10496629

4161204

3221176

2870734

35913229130189

11760280

9610253

10075990

3001208

1130397

1870761 7920152

4611220

10330226

4181203

19805383721041

11177697

8965378

3391185

33909148170204

4511673

3611149

60356184363959

2880770

2121395

6275718

3252255

5133007

5631564

3241060

4291438

14306022110459

6816216

2520752

5802245

7874365

4491756

4722560

45823334051165

4301264

4041180

8917797

2621424

9502034151419

9078908

8297492

11026966

10015657

4142048

4091156

3901071

9929976

4632314

4451202

5862180

7200138

38410008650185

5151799

7974761

3640969

11307423

84101839195413

2241065

5332041

50930842370665

38819174331470

3581740

2091241

9685170

5715123

6312458

3120895

8126135

8858056

7374302

4862015

6102351

10065871

3271186

5662113

4532367

102158731720879

3521521

3261718

3761946

6555710

10036396

3021319

5442009

2311225

6994913

4222393

1470111

5342169

35916883991920

3981491

8755116

10736596

7875007

7895062

5792587

25802978655635

1780966

9975427

7994347

4081001

1410671

5652118

2620926

6002308

4311249

6934409

6252238

4031293

980043

86154448905095

2041051

43717257754112

4311900

3731305

35531981960976

7313592

7734037

102874705141693

4441353

1990420

10155624

5292651

10196235

4062073

2101220

8486200

6145565

4111637

2131022

3772055

44216624271665

5011862

7485024

9767251

1060404

3481091

9935616

1050224

3641958

4652444

8316978

4113810

3921980

4471331

6353838

1980305

2750798

4672536

9138408

1921084

1831050

3960984

4731403

4401536

8734682

10626651

5171728

5895261

3861463

2018539

1941229

2381188

2071104

9915809

2120594

4641793

4281708

9115094

3741481

8135368

7293762

8577775

4952886

2831425

4862666

7743735

10596627

7805173

52534965732068

9485331

26012943121671

3711714

4461364

86054932260647

1520676

6763465

9757116

11300258

5365522

4302003

8515357

10200218

9805620

7744096

4932667

1460603

6092011

7695379

7930167

6412360

2691252

8735703

37811363621304

10415820

7265051

4481786

3541711

3091548

1860960

3881317

9424849

533468410100171

3381774

259143011540310

7210149

3801917

6185555

43412733891118

4392265

5034686

10356243

4461877

1540831

9418797

10576240

3311661

39914584031945

103364676422377

3871298

4591785

5482840

3561780

4351518

42722365794373

4342626

488225511060256

6512632

8444552

4721541

5002650

4201229

3380855

10506621

4453829

10820266

518468711597428

9056537

11780249

6072117

4542509

4693301

10340177

4322114

8214478

10456572

4591281

4321208

5001910

7794627

4171931

5193196

5491898

11768396

1628964

7955233

84452415383269

7894417

768007510580204

5015091

4441711

9860242

4161956

10746662

4521721

4412435

6873647

6305865

8076797

5475120

5614925

8034406

2491240

6773451

8796416

2421225

1860338

4632876481267934619223181806

9727058

3281607

5534201

104764014452072

4121679

3771145

7884330

4251635

4512236

4581621

6383322

10046204

10646731

50546374602312

5243182

70864375575614

4001766

6165521

62632037975320

4252029

5432865

6472418

7254790

5931775

6392429

7814632

6442203

9088933

6012163

6315625

2881346

9659714

87447653362189

10210356

4592339

4752083

11437320

1270573

5942016

7033403

108357346585800

4101394

4021506

8566931

5393173

683636269139624141273

3742605

4732176

8264441

4682987

10276081

7985407

11907905

8454367

6382434

5113213

6662981

6233160

11677059

4221516

92056475853079

7825337

4022117

7184498

1179307

6092609

5502113

6960080

11327323

3061772

7053538

3521077

6552449

11607514

3702210

4202210

1820978

7705623

2740216

9620155

9925771

64523893222028

5481881

4612544

6373743

3631038

4982766

8654816

1200392

11337499

6893397

45019034552497

5784271

5792000

2641287

6513851

6234719

10135318

8017212

3041650

6743099

6793160

49431767244325

6736053

10346306

9699141

6856090

10206025

4182139

4011492

5862942

6233873

4912708

4601363

8434187

6232660

79652824692885

3051533

8477256

9379989

5442816

10436056

6892295

7690160

58853246772711

7244863

10786894

5932120

8496245

10186241

7354081

5873480

6553650

75649866103333

65328837354416

653367064027897736847

9148436

10486533

6532414

77742716363815

102260565202963

114473206253618

9379278

10257341

64233146005444

1720045

4341707

2901470

93356495752312

8868076

4383909

740037

4381486

4042285

103663969428790

6172476

10365645

5343210

8525504

6285847

4192072

5083184

63727655272742

6362876

9966806

5833168

6000019

7904100

35013863131867

6293708

8307611

6733289

6362513

6273401

3031451

1568979

5262899

6522390

8464478

7824490

9940011

1330657

7353627

66961638587998

62321267082732

8137782

6552940

9404196

10296202

12000146

8587666

6082227

8698389

6933234

6913016

10136221

3011785

6732705

3201910

11416918

61636878978755

9066763

7494260

11778053

7393429

9480182

9269170

8417967

7183339

7272987

7152996

9269582

6695659

8556195

EZInfo controlled by Progenesis QI 3 - Black grass vs lolliumusp (M9 OPLS-DA) - 2015-12-11 171517 (UTC+0)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 22: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 61

Summary amp Future Prospects

REIMS for food authenticity

ndash Direct analysis technique results possible in seconds

o New ionisation technique

ndash Simplicity of operation amp potential for automation

ndash Point-of-control analysishellip bringing the analysis to the sample

o RTR software commercialisation June 2016

Chemometric profiling

ndash Holistic profiling of the sample for QC

ndash Detection of the ldquounexpectedrdquo for authenticity

o Potential to identify amp verify unique product markers

Liquid sampling REIMS

ndash Alcoholic beverages fruit juices milk amp edible oils

Implementation of ion mobility into the workflow to enhance power to differentiate sample types amp model generation (CCS)

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 23: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications

copy2016 Waters Corporation 62

Acknowledgements

Prof Zoltan Takats (Imperial College London)

Dr Simon Hird Dr Jonathan Williams Dr Emrys Jones Dr Julia Balog

Dr Steve Pringle Dr Mike Morris Dr Jackson Pope (Waters Manchester

and Budapest)

Prof Chris Elliott Dr Olivier Chevallier Connor Black (Queens

University Belfast)

Prof Rob Edwards Dr Melissa Brazier-Hicks Dr Catherine Tetard-Jones

More Fish

Page 24: Rapid Evaporative Ionisation Mass Spectrometry (REIMS) for Food & Agri-Tech Applications