re: traffic impact study addendum 86-90 dundas street east ... · proposed mixed use development 86...

8
GHD 140 Allstate Parkway Suite 210 Markham Ontario L3R 5Y8 Canada T 1 905 752 4300 F 1 905 752 4301 W www. ghd.com September 24, 2019 Reference No. 11116840 Mississauga 1 Emblem Developments 22 Adelaide Street West Suite 2060 Toronto, ON M5H 4E3 Attention: Shamil Jiwani RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East Residential Condominium Mississauga Ontario 1. Introduction GHD is pleased to present the enclosed Traffic Impact Study Addendum to examine the traffic related impacts from a recent proposed residential condominium development (with ground floor commercial area) located at 86-90 Dundas Street East in the City of Mississauga (see Figure 1). The current site plan dated September 19, 2019 (see Figure 2 or attachment) prepared by Studio JCI proposes a total of 334 condominium units in 16 storeys, along with 324 sq.m. (3,488 sq.ft.) of ground floor commercial area. The original development scheme of January 29 th , 2018 prepared by A J Tregebov Architects proposed a total of 289 condominium units in 29 storeys, along with 158 sq.m. (1,701 sq.ft.) of ground floor commercial area. GHD prepared a Traffic Impact Study in October 31, 2018 based on the January 2018 site plan. The proposed future subject site land uses proposed by the original (January 2018) and recent (September 2019) site plans are summarized in Table 1. Table 1 Original and recent proposed site land uses Commercial GFA Residential Units Original (January 2018) 158 m 2 (1,701 ft 2 ) 289 Recent (September 2019) 324 m 2 (3,488 ft 2 ) 334 Differences (Recent Site Plan – January 2018 Site Plan) +166 m 2 (1,787 ft 2 ) +45

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GHD 140 Allstate Parkway Suite 210 Markham Ontario L3R 5Y8 Canada T 1 905 752 4300 F 1 905 752 4301 W www.ghd.com

September 24, 2019 Reference No. 11116840 Mississauga 1 Emblem Developments 22 Adelaide Street West Suite 2060 Toronto, ON M5H 4E3

Attention: Shamil Jiwani

RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East Residential Condominium Mississauga Ontario

1. Introduction

GHD is pleased to present the enclosed Traffic Impact Study Addendum to examine the traffic related impacts from a recent proposed residential condominium development (with ground floor commercial area) located at 86-90 Dundas Street East in the City of Mississauga (see Figure 1).

The current site plan dated September 19, 2019 (see Figure 2 or attachment) prepared by Studio JCI proposes a total of 334 condominium units in 16 storeys, along with 324 sq.m. (3,488 sq.ft.) of ground floor commercial area.

The original development scheme of January 29th, 2018 prepared by A J Tregebov Architects proposed a total of 289 condominium units in 29 storeys, along with 158 sq.m. (1,701 sq.ft.) of ground floor commercial area. GHD prepared a Traffic Impact Study in October 31, 2018 based on the January 2018 site plan.

The proposed future subject site land uses proposed by the original (January 2018) and recent (September 2019) site plans are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1 Original and recent proposed site land uses

Commercial GFA Residential Units

Original (January 2018) 158 m2 (1,701 ft2) 289

Recent (September 2019) 324 m2 (3,488 ft2) 334

Differences (Recent Site Plan – January 2018 Site Plan) +166 m2 (1,787 ft2) +45

Page 2: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GHD | Traffic Impact Study Addendum | 80-90 Dundas Street east | Proposed Residential Development | 11116840 | 2

The assessment in this memo includes:

A review of the estimated future site trips based on the original and recent proposed land uses. A review of the parking requirements for the recent proposed land uses.

Our findings and conclusions are contained herein.

Figure 1 Site location

Page 3: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GH

D

140

Alls

tate

Par

kway

Sui

te 2

10 M

arkh

am O

ntar

io L

3R 5

Y8

Can

ada

T 1

905

752

430

0 F

1 9

05 7

52 4

301

W w

ww.g

hd.c

om

Figu

re 2

S

epte

mbe

r 20

19 s

ite

plan

Page 4: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GHD 140 Allstate Parkway Suite 210 Markham Ontario L3R 5Y8 Canada T 1 905 752 4300 F 1 905 752 4301 W www.ghd.com

2. Site trip generation The original proposed site traffic volumes was extracted from the Site Trip Generation Table in Section 5.1 of the October 2018 Traffic Impact Study (TIS).

The recent proposed site traffic was estimated from the trip rates contained in Trip Generation, 10th Edition, produced by the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE). Site trips for the residential condominium units were estimated based on the trip rates of Multifamily Housing (High-Rise) (LUC #222), and site trips for the commercial uses were estimated based on the trip rates of Shopping Centre (LUC # 820).

The 2016 Transportation Tomorrow Survey (TTS) data shows the existing non-auto modal splits are approximately 30% and 32% respectively for a.m. and p.m. peak hour. As a conservative analysis, the subject site is assumed to achieve the same transit model split applied to the future planning horizons. In addition, it is expected that patrons of the commercial use will primarily be residents of the proposed development. Therefore, an internal capture rate from the Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition, produced by the Institute of Transpiration Engineers were applied to the estimated trip generation for the commercial use. Resulting in a gross trip reduction of 14% for a.m. peak hour and 10% for p.m. peak hour.

Table 2 summarizes the trip generation of the original and recent proposed site land uses.

Table 2: Original and recent proposed site trip generation

Land use Units / GFA Parameter

AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour

In Out Total In Out Total

Original (October 2018

TIS)

Residential 289 units Trips 15 71 86 68 34 102

Commercial 158 m2 (1701 ft2) Trips 3 3 6 6 7 13

Total Site Trips 18 74 92 74 41 115

Recent (September

2019)

Residential (LUC 222) 334 Units

Trip Ratio 24% 76% 100% 61% 39% 100% Gross Trips 25 81 106 74 48 122

Non-auto Trips -8 -24 -32 -24 -15 -39 Vehicle Trips 17 57 74 50 33 83

Commercial (LUC 820)

363 m2 (3902 ft2)

Trip Ratio 62% 38% 100% 48% 52% 100% Gross Trips 2 2 4 24 25 49

Int. Cap. Trips 0 0 0 -10 -11 -21 Vehicle Trips 2 1 2 20 21 41

Total Site Trips 19 58 76 70 54 124 Trip Difference

(Recent Proposed Trips – Original proposed Trips) +1 -16 -15 -4 13 9

As indicated in Table 2, the recent (September 19, 2019) site plan is expected to generate 76 and 124 two-way trips at the weekday AM and PM peak hours, respectively, which is -15 and +9 trips than the trips

Page 5: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GHD | Traffic Impact Study Addendum | 80-90 Dundas Street east | Proposed Residential Development | 11116840 | 5

estimated in the Original (October 2018) TIS during the weekday AM and PM peak hours, respectively. Therefore, there will be no significant change from the findings and conclusions of our original TIS.

The October 2018 TIS concluded that, the existing Dundas Street road network in the vicinity of the site can be expected to have satisfactory operational characteristics and provide adequate capacity for the projected site traffic volumes. There are no recommended improvements at the study intersections or site driveway to accommodate the proposed development.

3. Parking requirement

The recent site plan (dated September 19, 2019) proposes 334 dwelling units and 324 m2 of ground floor commercial area. The development’s residential unit breakdown is as follows:

268 one bedroom units; and 66 two-bedroom units.

City staff have noted they are willing to accept parking rates as approved for the development at the southwest corner of Hurontario Street and Elm Street. The required parking provision was calculated using the proposed unit breakdown as summarized in Table 3 below.

Table 3 Parking Provision Table

Use Units Existing Bylaw

Required Parking Rate

City Proposed Parking Rate

Required Parking Supply

Resident Parking One bedroom – 268 units 1.25 0.9 242

Two bedroom – 66 units 1.40 1.0 66

Visitor Parking Total residential units – 334

units 0.20 0.15 50

Total 358

The proposed parking provision for the site is 349 parking spaces, including 32 car stackers located in the underground garage plus 3 car share spaces located on the surface level.

Therefore, the proposed parking supply with the introduction of car share is considered appropriate given the proximity to transit corridors with increased transit service level, consequently reducing the expected parking demand.

Page 6: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

GHD | Traffic Impact Study Addendum | 80-90 Dundas Street east | Proposed Residential Development | 11116840 | 6

4. Conclusions / recommendation

Based on the review of the original and recent proposed site land uses and trip generations, the site plan (September 19, 2019) is expected to generate 76 and 124 two-way trips at the weekday AM and PM peak hours, respectively. Fortunately, this is 15 less trips during morning peak hour, hence there will be no recommendation for the proposed site plan. However, the latest site plan generates extra 9 trips than the trips estimated in the Original (October 2018) TIS during the weekday PM peak hours. This is not a significant amount of traffic compared to the two-way volumes on Dundas Street and therefore, with the recent site plan, there will be no material change to the findings and conclusions of our original (October 2018) TIS.

The October 2018 TIS concluded that the existing Dundas Street road network in the vicinity of the site can be expected to have satisfactory operational characteristics and provide adequate capacity for the projected site traffic volumes. Therefore, there are no recommended improvements at the study intersections or site driveway to accommodate the proposed development.

We trust the enclosed is sufficient for your needs, but please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned should you require any additional assistance.

Respectfully Submitted,

GHD

Sept 24, 2019

Will Maria, P. Eng. Dhaval Harpal, Dipl. T. Senior Project Manager Transportation Planner

Dhaval Harpal, Dipl. T.

Page 7: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

PRO

POSE

D M

IXED

USE

DEV

ELO

PMEN

T86

- 90

DUN

DAS

STRE

ET E

,M

ISSI

SSAU

GA, O

ntar

io

DRAW

ING

LIST

ARCH

ITECTU

RAL

A0.0

0PR

OJE

CT S

TATI

STIC

SA1

.00

SITE

PLA

NA1

.01

GRO

UND

FLO

OR

SITE

PLA

N A3

.P4

PARK

ING

LEVE

L 04

A3.P

3PA

RKIN

G LE

VEL 0

3A3

.P2

PARK

ING

LEVE

L 02

A3.P

1PA

RKIN

G LE

VEL 0

1A3

.01

GRO

UND

FLO

OR

PLAN

A3.0

2 GR

OUN

D FL

OO

R M

EZZA

NINE

PLA

NA3

.03

2ND

FLO

OR

PLAN

A3.0

4 3-

5 FL

OO

R PL

ANA3

.05

6TH

FLO

OR

PLAN

A3.0

6 7T

H FL

OO

R PL

ANA3

.07

8-14

FLO

OR

PLAN

A3.0

8 15

TH F

LOO

R PL

ANA3

.09

16TH

FLO

OR

PLAN

A3.1

0 RO

OF

PLAN

A5.0

0 NO

RTH

ELEV

ATIO

NA5

.01

EAST

ELE

VATI

ON

A5.0

2SO

UTH

ELEV

ATIO

NA5

.03

WES

T EL

EVAT

ION

A6.0

0SE

CTIO

N A

20 D

e Bo

ers D

r. su

ite 5

25To

ront

o, O

N M

3J 0

H1t.

416.

901.

6528

f. 4

16.9

01.8

962

ww

w.st

udio

jci.c

om

Scal

e: 1

: 30

00CO

NTEX

T PL

AN1

SUBJ

ECT

SITE

REIS

SUED

FO

R O

PA /

REZO

NING

SEPT

EMBE

R 19

, 201

9

PERS

PECT

IVE

VIEW

FRO

M D

UNDA

S ST

REET

EAS

T

Page 8: RE: Traffic Impact Study Addendum 86-90 Dundas Street East ... · proposed mixed use development 86 - 90 dundas street e, mississauga, ontario drawing list architectural a0.00 project

7360

0

[241

'-5 1

/2"]

2487

0

[81'

-7"]

4410

[14'

-5 1

/2"]

9750

[32']

1500

0

[49'

-2 1

/2"]

3660

0

[120

'-1"]

8000

[26'-3"]

7000

[22'-11 1/2"]

14750

[48'-4 1/2"]

1065

0

[34'

-11

1/2"

]

1045

0

[34'

-3 1

/2"]

1000

[3'-3

1/2

"]

500

[1'-7

1/2

"]92

00

[30'

-2"]

3000

[9'-1

0"]

9200

[30'

-2"]

3000

[9'-1

0"]

9190

[30'

-2"]

3000

[9'-1

0"]

5900

[19'

-4 1

/2"]

4000

[13'

-1 1

/2"]

4500

[14'

-9"]

12600

[41'-4"]

7000

[22'-11 1/2"]

5000

[16'-5"]

20900

[68'-7"]

4000

[13'-1 1/2"]

3000

[9'-1

0"]

2500

[8'-2

1/2

"]

3050

[10'

]

24850

[81'-6 1/2"]

10900

[35'-9"]

11000

[36'-1"]

3800

[12'-5 1/2"]

2850

[9'-4"]

3340

[10'-1

1 1/2

"]

165

[6 1/2"]

1537

[5'-0

1/2"

]

2698

[8'-10"]

16TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 5

0.6m

MEC

HANI

CAL

PENT

HOUS

EHE

IGHT

: 55.

1m15

TH S

TORE

YHE

IGHT

: 47.

6m

14TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 4

4.7m

15TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 4

7.6m

15TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 4

7.6m

15TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 4

7.6m

15TH

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 4

7.6m

7TH STOREYHEIGHT: 21.5m

6TH STOREYHEIGHT: 19.35m

OUT

DOO

RAM

ENIT

Y AR

EA(7

TH S

TORE

Y)HE

IGHT

: 21.

5m

COM

M.

ENTR

Y

COM

M.

ENTR

Y

EXIT

EXIT

LOAD

ING

EXIT

RES.

ENT

RY

COM

M.

ENTR

Y

LOAD

ING

AMEN

ITY

AMEN

ITY

AMEN

ITY

EXIT

OUT

DOO

RAM

ENIT

YAT

GRA

DE

OUT

DOO

RAM

ENIT

YAT

GRA

DE

DOTT

ED E

XTEN

TSO

F BE

LOW

GRA

DEPA

RKIN

G

DOTT

ED LI

NE O

FBA

LCO

NY E

XTEN

T (T

YP)

HATC

HED

EXTE

NT O

FLA

ND D

EDIC

ATIO

N

PADM

OUN

TTR

ANSF

ORM

ER

TOP

OF

BANK

NEW

PRO

PERT

Y LI

NE(3

m T

OP

OF

BANK

SET

BACK

)

3000

[9'-10"]

NEW

PRO

PERT

Y LI

NE(4

2m R

IGHT

OF

WAY

)

2m LA

NDSC

APE

BUFF

ER

2000

[6'-6 1/2"]

SHO

RT T

ERM

BIC

YCLE

PARK

ING

(24)

CL OF ROAD

DUNDAS STREET EAST

2653

[8'-8

1/2

"]

2091

[6'-1

0 1/

2"]

DOTT

ED O

UTLI

NEO

F GR

OUN

D FL

OO

R

1028

80

[337

'-6 1

/2"]

9005

[29'-6 1/2"]

49552

[162'-7"]

3000

[9'-1

0"]

1200

[3'-11"]

1000

[3'-3 1/2"] EXIS

TING

PRO

PERT

Y LI

NE

EXIS

TING

PRO

PERT

Y LI

NE

DOTT

ED E

XTEN

TSO

F BE

LOW

GRA

DEPA

RKIN

G

2ND

STO

REY

HEIG

HT: 6

.5m

3660

[12'

]

SITE

PLA

N 1:20

0 A1.0

0

Gene

ral N

otes

:

1. T

hese

Con

trac

t Do

cum

ents

are

the

pro

pert

y of

the

Arch

itect

. Th

e Ar

chite

ct b

ears

no

resp

onsib

ility

for

the

inte

rpre

tatio

ns o

f th

ese

docu

men

ts b

y th

e Co

ntra

ctor

.Up

on

writ

ten

appl

icatio

n th

e Ar

chite

ct

will

pr

ovid

ew

ritte

n/gr

aphi

c cla

rifica

tion

or s

uppl

emen

tary

info

rmat

ion

rega

rdin

g th

e in

tent

of

the

Cont

ract

Doc

umen

ts.

The

Arch

itect

will

rev

iew

Sho

p Dr

awin

gs s

ubm

itted

by

the

Cont

ract

or fo

r des

ign

conf

orm

ance

onl

y.

2.

Draw

ings

ar

e no

t to

be

sc

aled

fo

r co

nstr

uctio

n.Co

ntra

ctor

to v

erify

all

exist

ing

cond

ition

s an

d di

men

sions

requ

ired

to p

erfo

rm th

e W

ork

and

repo

rt a

ny d

iscre

panc

ies

with

the

Con

trac

t Do

cum

ents

to

the

Arch

itect

bef

ore

com

men

cing

wor

k.

3. P

ositi

ons

of e

xpos

ed o

r fin

ished

mec

hani

cal o

r ele

ctric

alde

vice

s, fit

tings

, an

d fix

ture

s ar

e in

dica

ted

on

the

Arch

itect

ural

dr

awin

gs.

The

loca

tions

sh

own

on

the

Arch

itect

ural

dra

win

gs g

over

n ov

er t

he M

echa

nica

l an

dEl

ectr

ical d

raw

ings

. Tho

se it

ems

not c

lear

ly lo

cate

d w

ill b

elo

cate

d as

dire

cted

by

the

Arch

itect

.

20 D

e Bo

ers D

rive

suite

525

Toro

nto

ON

M3H

0H1

t. 41

6.90

1.65

28 f

. 416

.901

.896

2w

ww

.stud

iojc

i.com

CLIE

NT:

ARCH

ITEC

T:

DATE

:DE

SCRI

PTIO

N:

Revi

sions

:

DRAW

ING

NO.:

PRO

JECT

NO

.:SC

ALE:

DATE

:DR

AWN

BY:

ADDR

ESS:

86-9

0 DU

NDAS

STR

EET

EAST

, MIS

SISS

AUGA

MIS

SISS

AUGA

MIX

ED-U

SE B

UILD

ING

SEPT

EMBE

R 19

, 201

9

1911

N

LAND

SCAP

E: SEFE

RIAN

DES

IGN

GRO

UP

CIVI

L:

SKIR

A &

ASS

OCI

ATES

LIM

ITED

761

Bran

t Str

eet,

Suite

202

,Bu

rling

ton,

ON

L7R

2H7

t. 90

5.63

4.31

10

3464

Sem

enyk

Cou

rt, S

uite

100

,M

ississ

auga

, ON

L5C

4P8

t. 90

5.27

6.51

00

22 A

dela

ide

Stre

et W

, Sui

te 2

060,

Toro

nto,

ON

M5H

4E3

t. 64

7.93

3.00

24