renewable energy club annual assembly - what do estore and flowbox (storage technologies) have in...

14h30: Welcome words by Daniel Dobbeni, President Who we are today & Short overview 2015 & strategic choices for 2016 by Francois de Hemptinne, Manager

15h00: The European Sustainable Energy Accelerator by Klaas Schüring, CEO, Kic Inno Energy Benelux 2 case studies: ESTORE: Electrical energy storage device for cold stores, by Aart de Geus, ArtEnergy.nl FLOWBOX: an AREVA & Schneider Electric‘s new energy storage solution by Klaas Schüring, CEO Kic Inno Energy Benelux 16h00 Plenary session – Putting you in Pole Position 16h30 Networking cocktail

Who we are today Short overview of 2015 Strategic choices for 2016

Wind Solar Biomass Wave&Tidal Energy storage

Our Mission:

• to put our members’ expertise & specific added value top-of-mind

• to identify, support & create international business.

The business areas: The members are:

Members: 85 (end 2015)

Business Ways

http://online.agoria.be/AO1.wsc/webextra/prg/nwAttach?vWebSessionID=147823&vUserID=22319&file=g:%5CUploads%5Conline.agoria.be%5Cearec%5CEAREC000214_2000.jpg&filename=CMI.jpg

http://online.agoria.be/AO1.wsc/webextra/prg/nwAttach?vWebSessionID=147988&vUserID=22319&file=g:%5CUploads%5Conline.agoria.be%5Cearec%5Cearec049398_6985.JPG&filename=CREANERGY%20LOGO.JPG

http://www.google.be/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwj12oz-hcDJAhUKXRoKHRYeBTQQjRwIBw&url=http://www.passwerk.be/nl/deme&psig=AFQjCNH7xQ9RGLnkxrn0epQj2hmaKGncHQ&ust=1449244330759030

http://www.google.be/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjF4v3_h8DJAhXHvRoKHQgkApUQjRwIAw&url=http://www.stepstone.be/bedrijf-jobs--Elia-nv-sa--3497.html&psig=AFQjCNHL0opECLaMTpAHS3vmJxzUpaO-kw&ust=1449244872899955

https://www.google.be/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjKj6mzksDJAhXBPRoKHVJZBlIQjRwIBw&url=https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fichier:Segula_Technologies_Logo.jpg&psig=AFQjCNE4opDFjapgm3aTGvcnI4N2JFjn2Q&ust=1449247663822421

http://www.buyck.be/

http://online.agoria.be/AO1.wsc/webextra/prg/nwAttach?vWebSessionID=147124&vUserID=22319&file=g:%5CUploads%5Conline.agoria.be%5Cearec%5CEAREC039318_1981.jpg&filename=atm-pro%20-%20logo.jpg

Sponsor Public & regulatory law firm Strategic Partners Innovation & Technology Partners

Business intelligence • International conference for the Storage of Energy (Düsseldorf) • Fact Finding Mission to THETIS-EMR (Nantes) • Visit of the Marine Energy Center in Orkney (Scotland)

Privileged contacts • The Energy Outlook 2014 with Fatih Birol, Chief Economist, IEA • Power lunch ENERGY during Prince Mission to UAE • Power Dinner with Adnan Amin, CEO , IRENA (Int’l Renewable Energy) • DE-BE cooperation for Energy Transition (Berlin) • Club’s General Assembly: Kic Inno Energy & Estore/Flowbox

Experience sharing • When ICT meets Energy: Global Smart Grid Foundation & Energyville • Biogas power Plant – ENOVOS/NPG Energy (Tongeren) • RE projects: Legal framework with FieldFisher

Promotion • Club’s Summer event: Visualizing Europe with • EWEA Stand & Conference (Paris) • COP21 (Paris)

Business Intelligence Privileged contacts Experience Sharing Promotion

• 26/01: Meet the Belgian Ambassadors in France & India • 04/02: Client Seminar: Tractebel / Lahmeyer • 08-14/02: The Energy Outlook 2015 – l’Après-COP21 with Fatih Birol, IEA • 17/03: Int’l conference for the Storage of Energy (Dusseldorf) • 14/04: RE Projects: Financing structures

And more to come

ORE Catapult (UK) / Summer Event / Power lunches with AMPRION & ISSOL/ AON Risk management / Event Waste to Energy / Mission to DK or Side event @ Hamburg Wind Energy 2016: Structure - condition monitoring

The European Sustainable Energy Accelerator by Klaas Schüring, CEO, Kic Inno Energy Benelux incl. 2 cases studies: ESTORE: Electrical energy storage device for cold stores, by Aart de Geus, ArtEnergy.nl FLOWBOX: an AREVA & Schneider Electric‘s new energy storage solution by Klaas Schüring, CEO Kic Inno Energy Benelux

www.renewableenergyclub.be [email protected]

Grab the app & evaluate this event!

www.agoria.be/connect

Energy Union – Our European future

Klaas Schuring 8th December 2015

2 2

2 2 Copyright © 2015 KIC InnoEnergy

Energy Union. What? (1/2) A clearly defined framework

3 3


Energy Union. What? (2/2) Cheaper, cleaner, and secure

Cost energy

time 2010 2020 2030

€1

€2

4 4


Energy Union. How? (1/9) Many dimensions required …. inter-related

Societal & Individual

Technology

Human Capital

Regulation

Value Chain/Market/Biz

Model

Supply Chain

Societal &Individual

Technology

Human Capital

Regulation

ValueChain/Market/Biz

Model

Supply Chain

5 5


Energy Union. How? (2/9) Technology dimension

Think City 2009Platser: 2Längd: 314 cmMax Hast:113 km/h0-100km/h: 16 s.Räckvidd: 161 kmEffekt: 34kW (46hk)Utrustning: Ej AC, Ej servo, direkt elvärme, ingen aktiv säkerhet…

VW e-Golf 2014Platser: 5Längd:425 cm Max Hast: 140 km/h0-100km/h: 10,4 s. Räckvidd:190 kmEffekt: 85 kW (115hk)Utrustning: ACC, servo, värmepump, aktiv säkerhet, LED-belysning….


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

6 6


• EDSO: We will need storage « at whatever cost » with anincrease of the share of RE.

• RTE: we should stop focussing on conventional economicanalysis when it comes to storage (Tesla powerwall is maybe noteconomical, but it is sexy), and should consider the digitaltransformation

• JRC: We should not only consider storage for mitigation ofClimate Change, but also for Adaptation to CC.

• Eurelectric: for a new market design, we should start from thisrule: everyone going to the grid should be balanced. No moresimple injection of electricity in the grid.

• Tesla has been mentioned 5 times. Tesla appears as a mindchanger, enabling the blossoming of game changers.

Energy Union. How? (3/9) Business model dimension

32%

26%

42%

John Europe energy bill

Energy

Grid

Others


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

7 7


Energy Union. How? (4/9) Regulation dimension


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

8 8


Energy Union. How? (5/9) Supply & value chain dimension


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

9 9


Energy Union. How? (6/9) Society and individual dimension


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

10 10


Energy Union. How? (7/9) Human capital dimension (both sides)


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

12 12


3 timelines (2015-2020-2030) / 2 dimensions higher gradients

Energy Union. How? (9/9) Our judgment

13 13


Conclusions 1

1. It is a systemic problem => requires systemic solutions

2. It is a multidimensional problem => requires multidisciplinary solutions

3. It is a global problem => requires European solutions

Fortunately in Europe we are specially well prepared for complex challenges

Let´s lead again


Technology

Human Capital

Regulation


Model

Supply Chain

Shareholding structure Partnership as of end 2014

Towards sustainability An “Energy Europe” long term micro system

Partners across all the value chain

Partners from all energy carriers

Partners across all the supply chain

Challengers and incumbents

11 country regulations

14

KIC InnoEnergy: contributing to the energy innovation ecosystem (1/6) ... equipped to deliver results ….

14 Copyright © 2015 KIC InnoEnergy

The leading engine for innovation and entrepreneurship in Sustainable Energy)

120 Million end customers

KIC InnoEnergy: contributing to the energy innovation ecosystem (2/6) ... creating structural impact, complementing other EU instruments

15

Innovation Projects 59 patents filled (1patent/3M€) 71 new products and services

3B€ forecasted sales

Business Creation 55 start-ups created, post revenue

22M€ external investors

Education 424 Graduates Game changers populating industry and PRO

96% graduates with job in 6 m.

IMPACT

Synergies with EU SET Plan, Outreach/S3, Insight-E

Research & Innovation

Business Creation

EDUCATION

4 start-ups as result of Innovation Pro.

5 start-ups have been awarded an Inno. Pro

Graduate

Manpower Inno Project

Creates start-up

Recruit students

Gets Inno Project

3 cases

Sustainable Equity in 55 start-ups

71 ROI term sheets signed

Leveraging Knowledge Triangle 100+ KT transactions

From 27 partners to 220+ A micro energy system

15

16

Support game changers along their lifetime

In the world of KIC InnoEnergy Game Changers are talented people that

cultivate within themselves an innovation spirit. They are able to

engage and lead teams, and they rely on strong multidisciplinary

competences and skills.

Thus they are talented people with the vision to shape the future of

sustainable energy, and they design and implement creative solutions

that make the vision become reality.


KIC InnoEnergy: contributing to the energy innovation ecosystem (3/6) ... Human capital being the corner stone….

17

Live Business Booster in Berlin 21-22 October!!


100+ ventures

200+ industries

50+ students (PhDs)

20+ VCs/BAs

KIC InnoEnergy: contributing to the energy innovation ecosystem (6/6) … last monthexample …

Innovation project ESTORE: Smart controller for storing Electrical Energy in coldstores

Aart de Geus

CC-Benelux / Smart Cities

December 8th 2015 ESTORE

• Electricity demand is not constant throughout the day • Renewable electricity production peaks at random times • Further growth of renewable electricity production on going

and wanted • The EU electricity grid needs FLEXIBILITY - at low costs

Introduction

2

December 8th 2015 ESTORE

• Use the flexibility of the cold stores to store extra energy by the Estore controller and reduce costs

• Keep the quality of the frozen goods

• Market: • EU: 71 million M3 cold stores • Electricity consumption by cold stores: • 4500 GWh cold stores capacity: 850 MW

Cold Stores

3

December 8th 2015 ESTORE 4

When possible increase demand

When possible shut down demand

Electrical Power demand


Cold Store at maximum capacity

(cooling down)

Cold Store Refrigeration system off

(warming up again)

Use Cold store capacity


Price of electricity


Smart Estore controller • Estore controller:

• System identification • Optimizer for control strategy • Using the APX 24hr ahead electricity pricing • Calculates the lowest price strategy for the cold store by:

• Controlling the temperature between -18 and -24 C • dynamic programming using price, cold store temperature

and outdoor temperature • Keeping the quality of the frozen foods • hardware/software tool is add-on to OEM control


Typical temerature of cold store wih estore controller


Smart Estore controller: functioning

ESTORE

CONTROLLER

Find capacity switching sequence with lowest costs within temperature limits

3rd IIR Conference on Cold Chain and Sustainability

Estore results

Large NL Cold Store

577.500 m3 (100.000 Pallets)

11.500 MWh / year

14 hours running per day

Reference: € 670.000

ESTORE: € 563.000

Scenario Reference scenario (single tariff)

Night loading (doubly tariff)

Night loading (hourly market prices)

BE 15,88% 9,43% 6,15%

UK 12,27% 8,08% 2,14%

FR 15,25% 8,17% 5,46%

DE-AT 12,93% 6,71% 2,87%

TABLE ESTORE SAVINGS (14 hr)

Cost savings by applying the estore controller


Business model • Operation with Day Ahead Market related prices :

• lowering energy price cold stores by 10-20%

• Operation with “aggregators” for cold stores Availability of switch on or off power: X euro per MWh Utilisation of switch on or off power: Xx euro per MWh

• Combine functions as part of an ESCO

3rd IIR Conference on Cold Chain and Sustainability

• Controller as result of a KIC InnoEnergy project • Prototype product available • Operation tested with developed Emulator • First Demonstration in Germany, • Next field testing in Netherlands, December 2015 • On the market by the end of the year 2015 via

Cofely (GDF SUEZENGIE)

Conclusions


Partners

16

CONFIDENTIEL AREVA ENERGY STORAGE

H² / HBr battery, a promising solution for energy storage

AREVA PROPIETARY&CONFIDENTIAL

Flow Batteries – p.2

Energy storage Market and Technologies Energy Storage market Challenge

Storage applications and solutions

Flow battery technologies

Flow battery H2/HBr technology H2/HBr technology presentation and competitive advantage

Product presentation 150kW module to the 1MW Product

H2/HBr Cost advantage

Flowbox project and Business Creation AREVA Business Creation

Flowbox project funded by Europe

Early adopters first feed back

2

3

1

Content


Flow Batteries - p.3

Storage market size and growth, 2013-2022, Bn€*

Product launch CAGR%

3,9 4,8 6,27,7 9,1 10,6 12,0

13,715,63,8

4,55,5

6,47,0

7,6

8,220

16

2013

8

24

4

0 2022 2021 2020

12

2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014

22 €Bn BCG Energy Storage market estimate

SNE Research Energy Storage market estimate

CAGR

>40%

Breakdown by technology, Bn€

28

50

64

75

Lithium -ion

Flow batteries

Sodium -sulfur

CAES

Pumped hydro

2011-2030 (cum) BCG view*

279

61 22%

27%

23 %

18%

10 %

1

The market Driver is the COST LOW LCOE (€/kWh) ------------------ LOW CAPEX (€/kW)

The market will grow when the storage will be competitive (<1500€/kW - <200€/kWh LCOE)

Energy storage market context and challenge



Each application has its own requirements

Power capability (MW) 1 10 100 1,000 0,001 0,01 0,1

min

sec

Discharge time

days

Frequency regulation

Portable power - Decentralized Power Supply

Wholesale energy services arbitrage

Renewable integration optimization

Smart buildings – C&I energy management

hours Residential

Backup Power

Transport

Source: AREVA, ENEA, CVA, BNEF, NERC….

Pumped Hydro Storage

Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES)

Hydrogen Storage

Power capability (MW) 1 10 100 1,000 0,001 0,01 0,1

min

sec

hours

Discharge time

days

Battery

Flywheel

Flow battery

Super capacitors

Superconducting Magnetics Energy Storage

Storage Applications and Technologies

FLOW BATTERY competitive on the segment: 5h to 12h and 0,1 to 10MW Power level

1



High cycle life Energy & power independently

scalable Cost reduction opportunities No restriction for storage location Good electrical efficiency

+

Possible Environmental impact depending in couple Tend to be a complex system High cost Industrial scalability to be proven

- Maturity

Perfomance

Life

Cost

Zn/Br VRB H2/HBr Fe2/Cr3 Liq/Sol

Primus Power Premium Power ZBB

Vanadium Liq/Liq Prudent Energy Sumitomo Celstrom

Liq/Gaz Enstorage

Liq/Liq Enervault (Total) Imergy Power system

One of the most promising => H2/HBr when at maturity in 2017 - 2018

1 Flow batteries Principle and Technology Type



Content










2

3

1

AREVA PROPIETARY&CONFIDENTIAL Flow Batteries - p.7

H2/HBr technology and competitive advantage 2

3HBr 2H+ +2 e- + HBr3 2H+ + 2 e- H2

Charge Décharge

Lower cost potential (PVDF) At the prototype level compare

to PRIMUS (lab scale) Low membrane resistance

(charge transfer)

Toxicity of HBr/HBr3 Performance and scale up

effect needed to be proven

+ -

• 65% AC / AC efficiency • Energy and power dissociation • Operating at 2 – 17 bars and > 40°C • 30 sec from stop and 1 sec from Idle

Technology Readiness Level

1 9 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE => Low cost for 6h – standard low cost materials

AREVA PROPIETARY&CONFIDENTIAL Flow Batteries - p.8

From the 150kW module to the 1MW product

Demonstrator: 150kW/0,9 MWh Process: 150kW - 40 feet container

PC : 500kW - 20 feet container

Pilot: 0,5 to 1 MW / 3 to 6 MWh 5 process modules

2 PC modules

40*40 m Footprint

2


H2/HBr cost advantage


2

CONSERVATIVE DATAS

Peak Power for small duration LITHIUM

Average Power for long autonomy

FLOW BATTERY


Content










2

3

1



ENSTORAGE Entreprise & Techno identified

Pre ETUDE (SECU)

2014 2015 2016 2017 2012 2020 2009

50kW POC

- Industries - Couplage éoliennes - Couplage PV

TRL6 TRL3 TRL8 TRL9

AREVA Flow Battery program Objective : New business creation

AMI ADEME FLOWFIELD Clients Orders

3

PHASE1

Test @ CEA SITE

DEMONSTRATION POC to PRODUCT

Design Cost Plan

Assembly Installation

PHASE2 EVALUATION SITES CLIENT

PHASE3 INDUSTRIALISATION & COMMERCIALISATION

Déploiement en 2020….

PHASE4

KIC InnoEnergy FLOWBOX

2018



PHASE 2 : Flowbox Project Partnership


3

Validate Technical performance:

- Build a 150 kW module & design the 1MW Pilot - Validate performance, ease to install and to operate - Understand the H2/HBr chemistry safety issue

Validate cost potential : Validate demonstrator cost and estimate cost reduction plan

KIC InnoEnergy | Boosting Innovation for Sustainable Energy | Speaker: Name

PC =>Challenge High A Low V Modify existing bricks

Stacks – HBr / system Expertise =>Challenge Lower cost IP (Membrane – System)

Systems - BOP => Systems Integration Cooling/safety

Regulations Safety => Main Challenge Br2 and H2 safety mgt

End User =>Validate the needs and the technology

Testing - Comparison VRB =>Know-how on batteries Evaluation


Next steps key Milestones

March 2014: FLOW BOX project GO EIT – KIC InnoEnergy

2014 2015 2016 2017

March 2016: Techno validation

3

December 2015: Demonstrator 150kW installed on MEGASOL site

2016: 1MW Pilot project starting: Flowfield application projects

2018

2017-2018 Market Entry

Today



KEM ONE Plant Site Industry on Fos Port

PV Antilles Guyane

PV To replace NAS Batteries in their existing sites

CRE3 call for tender on a site in Guyane

Site: Plateform Caban Tonkin – INNOVEX Project

WIND/PV Insul’grid project starting

Network Agregation For peak shaving application

Industrial Partners For Product development

Regional Support : Prefect - Fos Port

Voice of Customers / Partners

3



Thank you
