report thesis new
DESCRIPTION
Report Thesis NewTRANSCRIPT
-
19
:
:
:
:
-
.
.
-
.
.
.
.
-
1 ........................................................................................................
2 .......................................................................................................
2 ......................................................................................................... . 1 2 .............................................................................................................................. . 1-1
6 ................................................................................................................. . 2-1
7 ............................................................................................... . 2 7 ........................................................................................................ . 1-2
7 ........................................... . 2-2
21 .................................................................................................................... . 3-2
21 .................................................................................................................... . 4-2
31 .............................................................................................................. . 5-2
31 .................................................................................................................. . 6-2
71 ........................................................................................ . 7-2
12 ................................................... . 8-2
22 ............................................................................................................. .1-8-2
22 ......................................................................................... . 3 42 ......................................................................................................................... . 1-3
42 ................................................................................................................. enilpS-B . 2-3
52 ....................................................................... )TSC( noitamrofsnarT-epahS-ssalC . 3-3
62 ................................................ )TRSC( noitamrofsnarT-tnemenifeR-epahS-ssalC . 4-3
22 ................................................................ 21032 . 2 82 ...................................................................................................... . 1-4
92 .......................................................................................................................... . 2-4
33 ........................................................................................................ . 3-4
-
13 .................................................................... .1-3-4
33 ................................................................... .2-3-4
43 .................................................................. .3-3-4
63 ................................................................. .4-3-4
73 ............................................................................... .5-3-4
02 ....................................................................................................... . 2
12 .......................................................................................................
-
11 .................................................................................................... OSPT 1-2 41 ...................................................................................................................... 1 2-2 41 ..................................................................................................................... 1 3-2 51 ..................................................................................................................... 2 4-2 51 ..................................................................................................................... 3 5-2 61 ...................................................................................................................... 4 6-2 61 ...................................................................................................................... 5 7-2 91 ........................................................... 35 8-2 32 ........................................................... 35 9-2 82 ...................... 51332 TNEULF LIOFX 1-4 13 ................................................................. 2-4 23 ....................................... 3-4 23 .............................................. 4-4 33 ................................................................. 5-4 33 ....................................... 6-4 43 .............................................. 7-4 43 ................................................................. 8-4 53 ....................................... 9-4 53 ............................................ 31-4 63 ............................................................... 11-4 63 ..................................... 21-4 73 ............................................ 31-4 83 ....................... 41-4 51-4
83 .................................................................................................................................................. 93 .... 61-4
-
31 ....................................................................................................... 1-2 81 ........................................................................ 2-2 81 ........................................................................... 3-2 32 ................................................... 4-2 33 ........................................................................................................ 1-4
13 ................................................................................ 2-4 13 ............................................................................................ 3-4
-
.1
.1-1
.
.
.
1
.]2, 1[
:
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
noitazimitpO epahS cimanydoreA 1
-
.1
.2
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. ]3[ .
.
.
.
) (
. ) (
.
.
.
.
-
.
.
(
. ) ) ( ]6-4[
.
.
.
]7[
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
]8[
.
.
.
-
.
. ]9[
.
.
.
. ]31[
.
.
.
. 1
: .
.
.]21, 11[
:]31[ .
. 2 . . .
3
.]41[
)DFC( scimanyD diulF lanoitatupmoC 1 ladomitluM 2 )sAEOM( smhtiroglA yranoitulovE evitcejbO-itluM 3
-
. ]51[ 2 1
.
. ]61[
.]71[
3
.
.
.2-1
:
.
.
.
.
.
1 )OSP( noitazimitpO mrawS elcitraP
)AE( mhtiroglA yranoiyulovE 2 ecnegrevnoC erutamerP 3
-
7 :
.2
.1-2
n
X .
G P . V
.
. )1( t
)1( V X X t t t)1 ( 1
. )2(
)2( X G X P V V t w t12
]2,0[ 21
w .
. Vt
.2-2
. ]22-81[
. . OSPT .
1 .
. .
. 3 2
ytisreviD 1 yrotarolpxE 2 evitatiolpxE 3
-
8 :
t R OSPT )3( 1 .
t R2 ) ( .
2
0
j i
jj i j iij i
j i
F F t RnoisilloC
F F
X XX X
)3( X X
.
.
.
)4( . :
.
xamxam R
noitaretI R t RnoitaretIxaM
)4(
.
Rxam
.
noisilloC 1
-
9 :
1
xam2
Ni i
NL Ui
X X
KR
)5(
. iht X XU Li i, 1 K N
.
.
)6( R Rxam xam
OSPT
.
. tsebPi Fi
i
.
. . F tsebPi j
2
*
2
j i
j i
j i
j
tsebP F jj i
j
j i
tsebP F jj i
tsebP FP
tsebP F
P XP
P X
)7(
P P*
P* . P*.
P* .
mrawS 1
-
31 :
P* .
. P*
.
)8( G
.
.
nim xam
2 2 nimnoitaretI 2 2
noitaretIxaM
)8(
:
i i i i i i ij 13 2 1* j
)9( X G X P V V noisilloC t t
)9( )2(
.
. OSPT
-
11 :
OSPT 1-2
-
21 :
.3-2
1 OSPT
: . OSP
]12[ OSP-RDF .1 ]32[ SBIRC .2 ]02[ OSPRA .3
. 2
.
.4-2
. 33
. 3335 3332 3331 331 35 32
5,3 OSPT . )9,3 4,3(
)6( . ) 2 3( 2
vxam
. 32 .
:
noitcnuF kramhcneB 1 snoitcnuF etisopmoC 2
-
31 :
niamoD laitinI niamoD noitcnuF noitcnuF
)5,5-( )5,5-( nigirtsaR
),0( ),0( zciwelahciM
)005,005-( )005,005-( lefewhcS
)001,001-( )001,001-( kgnaweirG
)2,2-( )2,2-( kcorbnesoR
)23,23-( )23,23-( yelkcA
)1,1-( )1,1-( 1noitcnuf tseT
)5,5-( )5,5-( snoitcnuf etisopmoC
1-2
.5-2
kcorbnesoR ,knaweirG ,lefewhcS ,zciwelahciM ,nigirtsaR: . OSPT yelkcA
. OSP
.6-2
. : ]42[
. .1 . .2 . .3 .4
. . ]52[
.
.
. ]62[
-
41 :
. 2-2
1 2-2
.
]42[ .
.
: 1
noitcnuF erehpS F01 1
3-2 1
-
51 :
: 2
noitcnuF sknaweirG F01 1
2-2 2
: 3
noitcnuF sknaweirG F01 1
3 2-2
-
: 16
4 :
1 10F :Ackley, Rastrigin, Weierstrass, Griewank and Sphere Function
2-6 2
5
1 10F :Rastrigin, Weierstrass, Griewank, Ackley and Sphere Function
2-7 2
-
71 :
.7-2
2-2 33
OSP . 3-2
yelkcA . yelkcA knaweirG
OSPT OSP
knaweirG .
erehpS
lefewhcS zciwelahciM ,nigirtsaR . ]32[
. kcorbnesoR
.
OSPT 3-2 9-2 .
.
OSPT
.
-
: 18
Function Dim TPSO PSO ARPSO FDRPSO CRIBS
Rastrigin
20 18.82 23.69 23.32 24.75 24.72
50 63.61 113.85 116.83 131.64 120.56
100 137.93 309.57 314.35 351.29 292.32
Michalewicz
20 -15.11 -13.33 -13.13 -12.75 -12.94
50 -33.49 -20.09 -18.98 -21.81 -20.29
100 -63.77 -31.16 -34.17 -34.61 -30.56
Schwefel
20 -1.44e+04 -5337.06 -5265.33 -5495.45 -5365.71
50 -2.68e+04 -1.31e+04 -1.31e+04 -1.37e+04 -1.30e+04
100 -5.12e+04 -2.58e+04 -2.65e+04 -2.77e+04 -2.61e+04
Griewangk
20 2.06e-01 1.31e-02 1.72e-02 1.11e-02 2.46e-02
50 3.55e-01 1.12e-03 4.68e-03 1.91e-02 1.09e-02
100 4.71e-01 3.56e-03 3.31e-03 7.66e-02 5.5e-03
Rosenbrock
20 18.17 38.27 34.12 27.56 37.27
50 46.02 130.09 135.49 253.42 158.82
100 99.60 345.12 346.24 1490.56 402.17
Ackley
20 8.88e-01 2.58e-05 2.82e-04 5.57e-02 1.22e-01
50 1.59 1.78e-01 2.44e-01 1.06 3.27e-01
100 2.03 1.01 1.21 1.98 5.75e-01
2-2
Function Dim TPSO PSO ARPSO FDRPSO CRIBS
TF 5 0.2 0.38 0.36 0.49 0.29
CF1 5 15.95 43.79 31.64 123.84 32.87
CF2 5 65.63 97.90 89.41 70.17 92.81
CF3 5 120.28 156.65 152.68 248.73 187.69
CF4 5 216.76 272.39 469.17 398.72 327.64
CF5 5 32.42 72.78 47.71 77.64 66.09
2-3
-
91 :
02 2-2
-
32 :
02 9-2
-
12 :
1 .8-2
.
. 2
.
.
.
: 3
. 4
.
.
.
( ]72[ 5
. )
.
.
6
. %33 ]82[
.
)OSPTOM( noitazimitpO mrawS elcitraP lairotirreT evitcejbO itluM 1 tnorF oteraP 2 evihcrA lanretxE 34 detanimoD-noN
roamitsE ytisneD robhgieN tseraeN 5 noitatuM 6
-
22 :
OSPTOM
)evihcrA lanretxE dna mrawS( noitazilaitinI )1
0 =noitaretI )2
noiaretIxaM < noitaretI elihw :4
)9 3 :snoitauqE( etadpUyticoleV :5 )1 noitauqE( etadpUnoitisoP :6
noitatuMlaimonyloP :7
noitaulavEssentiF :8
evihcrA lanretxE etadpU :9
evihcrA lanretxE morf elcitrap hcae rof G dna P ngissA :01
++ noitaretI :11
elihw dne :21
evihcrA lanretxE nruter :31
.1-2-2
]92[ 2AEPS ]72[ II-AGSN:
]13[ TDZ . ]33[ SSYbA
. - ZLTD .]23[ ZLTD
) ( ]33[ ) ( :
. ]43[ )VH( ]72[ .
]53[ lateMj
331 .
331 331 OSPTOM
. 33352
331
.
-
: 23
MOTPSO Parameterization
Swarm Size: 100
Mutation polynomial
Archive Size: 100 individuals
: 0.5
Inertia weight: (0.9 to 0.4)
NSGA-II SPEA2 AbYSS MOTPSO Prob
HV HV HV HV
6.61 e1 1.83 e4 1.03 e1 6.61e 1 7.72e3 1.05e 1 6.60e 1 8.69e 1 1.52e 1 6.59e 1 1.37e 2 3.70e 1 ZDT1
3.28 e1 6.10 e4 9.87 e2 3.28e 1 7.10e 3 1.07e 1 3.26e 1 8.73e 3 1.55e 1 3.26e 1 1.28e 2 3.81e 1 ZDT2
5.16e 1 9.13 e4 7.32 e1 5.16e 1 6.10e 3 7.09 e1 5.14e 1 9.72e 3 7.10e 1 5.15e 1 8.13e 1 7.47e 1 ZDT3
6.60e 1 8.86 e4 1.19 e1 6.55e 1 1.14e-2 1.27 e1 6.51e 1 3.42e 2 2.72e 1 6.56e 1 1.49e 2 4.02e 1 ZDT4
4.00e 1 9.48 e3 8.47e 1 4.01e 1 5.06e-3 8.99 e2 3.79e 1 2.42e 2 2.28e 1 3.88e 1 1.47e 2 3.56e 1 ZDT6
4.94e 1 2.49e 3 1.25e 1 4.86e 1 5.85e3 1.40e 1 4.89e 1 5.89e 3 1.81e 1 4.88e 1 7.13e 3 4.03e 1 DTLZ1
2.12e 1 7.85e 3 1.42e 1 2.12e 1 5.39e 3 1.09e 1 2.12e 1 7.34e 3 1.48e 1 2.11e 1 1.11e 2 3.84e 1 DTLZ2
2.12e 1 7.85e 3 2.81e 1 - 1.66e 0 7.55e 1 - 2.28e 0 1.07e 0 - 1.04e 0 9.53e 1 DTLZ3
2.08e 1 2.86e 3 2.38e 1 2.11e 1 5.39e3 1.08e 1 2.10e 1 7.66e 3 1.48e 1 2.09e 1 1.13e 2 3.95e 1 DTLZ4
2.12e 1 7.85e 3 1.35e 1 2.12e 1 5.36e 3 1.10e 1 2.12e 1 7.47e 3 1.50e 1 2.11e 1 1.05e 2 3.79e 1 DTLZ5
2.12e 1 7.85e 3 1.15e 1 1.11e 1 9.50e2 2.31e 1 9.02e 3 3.03e 1 8.25e 1 1.75e 1 4.39e 2 8.64e 1 DTLZ6
3.34e 1 4.95e 3 5.19e 1 3.34e 1 5.51e 3 5.19e 1 3.34e 1 9.09e 3 5.44e 1 3.33e 1 1.04e 2 6.23e 1 DTLZ7
2-2
-
42 :
.3
.1-3
:
, 0
n
n i i
i
u B p u p
)01(
: Bn i,
1 , n
ii nn i
iu u u B
)11(
. 1+n n
enilpS-B .2-3
: enilpS-B
, 0
n
k i i
i
u N p u p
)21(
Nk i,
. k . k
:
,11
1,,0
t u t fii i
iesiwrehto
u N
)31(
1 1
1 ,1 1 ,,
k i i
i k i i k i
k i k iu t t uk i
t t t t
u N u Nu N
)41(
pi u ti
:
-
52 :
,0
,1
,2
i
k i fi
n i k fi k i t
n i fi k n
)51(
)TSC( noitamrofsnarT-epahS-ssalC .3-3
2 1
. .
.
: TSC ]63[ .
. .1
. .2
. .3
:
1
2
N
N )61( ) (uS) ( C =) (
z c
x c
1 . c 2
N
N ) (S ) ( C
: .
11 12 2
N NNN
)71( ) ( C
. ) ( C0.15.0 . .
:
noitcnuF ssalC 1 noitcnuF epahS 2
-
62 :
1
n
i i
i
S A uS
)81(
. Ai :
1 n
ii ni
iS
)91(
x0 TSC c
: c
C SREL 2 0
)02(
x1 c .
)12( S(nat 1
)TRSC( noitamrofsnarT-tnemenifeR-epahS-ssalC .4-3
enilpS-B 1 ]73[ TRSC
. TSC
enilpS-B TRSC ]73[ .
.
.
enilpS-B
.
TSC enilpS-B enilpS-B
. 1
1
snoitcnuF tnemenifeR 1
-
72 :
. TSC
.
.
1
2
N
N ) (R ) (S) ( C =) (
)22(
. )41( enilpS-B ) (R
-
82 51332 :
21032 .4
.1-4
LIOFX . ]83[ LIOFX . -
- . LIOFX .
. LIOFX
.
21032 TNEULF LIOFX 1-2
-
92 51332 :
LIOFX LIOFX . TNEULF
LIOFX . TNEULF
.2-4
.
1 :
6
1.0 aM 3 eR 1D
L
Cdna e ta f
C
2
.
0
6 2
e ta C fM1.0 aM 3 eR 2
.
H 3 .
. H . H
.
xam
6
dna e ta x fH1.0 aM 3 eR 3
.
xam
6 2
e ta C fL1.0 aM 3 eR 4
1 oitaR edilG
esiurC 2 rotcaF epahS 3
-
33 51332 :
.3-4
. Ai .
REL . 51332
. 1-4
# )4.0,100.0( 1
)4.0,100.0( 2
)4.0,100.0( 3
)4.0,100.0( 4
)4.0,100.0( 5
)4.0,100.0( 6
)4.0,100.0( 7
)4.0,100.0( 8
)4.0,100.0( 9
)4.0,100.0( 01
)100.0-,4.0-( 11
)100.0-,4.0-( 21
)100.0-,4.0-( 31
)100.0-,4.0-( 41
)100.0-,4.0-( 51
)100.0-,4.0-( 61
)100.0-,4.0-( 71
)100.0-,4.0-( 81
)100.0-,4.0-( 91
)100.0-,4.0-( 02
1-2
331 35 . .
OSPTOM 2-4 . 51332
.
-
13 51332 :
liofriAL
D
CC
Hxam CM0 x
Lxam C
ACAN
51032
1267.1 0481.0 0800.0 54.99
0600.2 7299.0 2570.0 040.87 derreferP
1049.1 0633.0 6330.0 72.061 1 .jbO tseB
7845.1 1514.0 2000.0 29.131 2 .jbO tseB
3368.1 8299.0 8190.0 37.901 3 .jbO tseB
7622.2 7351.0 2950.0 02.68 4 .jbO tseB
2-2
tnemevorpmI liofriA
%1.16 1 .jbO tseB
%5.79 2 .jbO tseB
%5.934 3 .jbO tseB
%3.62 4 .jbO tseB
3-2
OSPTOM 3-4 2-4 . 51332
.1-3-2
2-2
-
23 51332 :
3-2
2-2
-
33 51332 :
.2-3-2
2-2
6-2
-
43 51332 :
7-2
.3-3-2
2-2
-
53 51332 :
9-2
01-2
-
63 51332 :
.2-3-2
11-2
21-2
-
73 51332 :
31-2
.2-3-2
.
H 3xam x f
xam
2
. C fL 4 . 41-4
H .
51-4 . .
-
83 51332 :
21-2
21-2
-
93 51332 :
61-2
-
34
.2
OSPTOM . OSP
.
. .
.
.
.
)TSC( noitamrofsnarT-epahS-ssalC . 51332
.
.
.
.
-
41
[1 ] Buckley, P., H., Zhou, Y., B., Zingg, and W., D., 2010, "Airfoil Optimization Using Practical Aerodynamic Design Requirements," 47(5), pp. 13.
[2 ] Kuntawala, N. B., 2011, "Aerodynamic Shape Optimization of a Blended-Wing-Body Aircraft Configuration , " Ph.D. thesis, University of Toronto ,
[3 ] ,. ,1385 ," ," Ph.D. thesis , ,
[4 ] Ashrafizadeh, A., Raithby, G. D., and Stubley, G. D., 2002, "Direct Deign of Shape," Numerical Heat Transfer, 41(6), pp. 10.
[5 ] Ashrafizadeh, A., Raithby, G. D., and Stubley, G. D., 2003, "Direct Deign of Ducts," Fluids Engineering, ASME Transaction, 125(pp. 7.
[6 ] Ashrafizadeh, A., Raithby, G. D., and Stubley, G. D . ,2004 ," Direct Deign of Airfoil Shape with a Prescribed Surface Pressure," Numerical Heat Transfer, 46(6), pp. 22.
[7 ] ,. ,1386 ," ," Ph.D. thesis , ,
[8 ] Epstein, B., and Peigin, S., 2007, "Accurate Cfd Driven Optimization of Lifting Surfaces for Wing-Body Configuration," Journal of computers & fluids, 36(pp. 16.
[9 ] Fazzolari, A., Gauger, N. R., and Brezillon, J., 2007, "Efficient Aerodynamic Shape Optimization in Mdo Context," Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics,
203(pp. 13. [10 ] Carpentieri, G., Koren, B., and Tooren, M. J. L. V., 2007, "Adjoint-Based Aerodynamic
Shape Optimization on Unstructured Meshes," Journal of Computational Physics ,224( pp. 21.
[11 ] Jameson, A., Martinelli, L., and Pierce, N. A., 1998, "Optimum Aerodynamic Design Using the NavierStokes Equations," Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics, 10(1), pp. 213-237.
[12 ] Anderson, W. K., and Venkatakrishnan, V., 1999 ," Aerodynamic Design Optimization on Unstructured Grids with a Continuous Adjoint Formulation," Computers &
Fluids, 28(45), pp. 443-480. [13 ] Arias-Montao, A., Coello Coello, C., and Mezura-Montes, E., 2011, "Evolutionary
Algorithms Applied to Multi-Objective Aerodynamic Shape Optimization," 356(pp. 211-240.
[14 ] Wickramasinghe, U. K., Carrese, R., and Xiaodong, L., 2010, "Designing Airfoils Using a Reference Point Based Evolutionary Many-Objective Particle Swarm
Optimization Algorithm," eds., pp. 1 -8. [15 ] Kennedy, J., and Eberhart, R., 1995, "Particle Swarm Optimization," eds., 4, pp. 1942-
1948 vol.4. [16 ] Eberhart, R., and Shi, Y., 1998, Evolutionary Programming Vii, Springer Berlin /
Heidelberg, Comparison between Genetic Algorithms and Particle Swarm Optimization.
[17 ] Poli, R., 2008, "Analysis of the Publications on the Applications of Particle Swarm Optimisation," J. Artif. Evol. App., 2008(pp. 1-10.
[18 ] Poli, R., Kennedy, J., and Blackwell, T., 2007, "Particle Swarm Optimization," Swarm Intelligence, 1(1), pp. 33-57.
-
42
[19 ] Mendes, R., 2004, "Population Topologies and Their Influence in Particle Swarm Performance," Ph.D. thesis, Departamento de Informatica, Escola de Engenharia,
Universidade do Minho, Portugal. [20 ] Riget, J., and Vesterstrm ,J. S., 2002, "A Diversity-Guided Particle Swarm Optimizer-
the Arpso," Technical Report No. Department of Computer Science, University of
Aarhus, Denmark. [21 ] Peram, T., Veeramachaneni, K., and Mohan, C. K., 2003, "Fitness-Distance-Ratio
Based Particle Swarm Optimization," eds., pp. 174-181. [22 ] Ben Ghalia, M., 2008, "Particle Swarm Optimization with an Improved Exploration-
Exploitation Balance," eds., pp. 759-762. [23 ] Monson, C. K., and Seppi, K. D., 2006, 1144006. [24 ] Liang, J. J., Suganthan, P. N . , and Deb, K., 2005, "Novel Composition Test Functions
for Numerical Global Optimization," eds., pp. 68-75. [25 ] Ahrari, A., Saadatmand, M. R., Shariat-Panahi, M., and Atai, A. A., 2010, "On the
Limitations of Classical Benchmark Functions for Evaluating Robustness of Evolutionary Algorithms," Applied Mathematics and Computation, 215(9), pp. 3222-
3229. [26 ] Gaviano, M., and Lera, D., 1998, "Test Functions with Variable Attraction Regions for
Global Optimization Problems," Journal of Global Optimization, 1 3(2) , pp. 207-223. [27 ] Deb, K., Pratap, A., Agarwal, S., and Meyarivan, T., 2002, "A Fast and Elitist
Multiobjective Genetic Algorithm: Nsga-Ii," Evolutionary Computation, IEEE
Transactions on, 6(2), pp. 182-197. [28 ] Deb, K., 2001, Multi-Objective Optimization Using Evolutionary Algorithms John
Wiley & Sons , [29 ] Zitzler, E., Deb, K., and Thiele, L., 2000, "Comparison of Multiobjective Evolutionary
Algorithms: Empirical Results," Evolutionary Computation, 8(2), pp. 173-195. [30 ] Nebro, A. J., Luna, F . , Alba, E., Dorronsoro, B., Durillo, J. J., and Beham, A., 2008,
"Abyss: Adapting Scatter Search to Multiobjective Optimization," Evolutionary
Computation, IEEE Transactions on, 12(4), pp. 439-457. [31 ] Zitzler, E., Laumanns, M., and Thiele, L., 2001, "Spea2: Improving the Strength Pareto
Evolutionary Algorithm," Computer Engineering, TIK-Report(pp. 1--21. [32 ] Deb, K., Thiele, L., Laumanns, M., and Zitzler, E., 2005, Springer Berlin Heidelberg,
Scalable Test Problems for Evolutionary Multiobjective Optimization. [33 ] Knowles, J., Thiele, L., and Zitzler, E., 2006, "A Tutorial on the Performance
Assessment of Stochastic Multiobjective Optimizers," Technical Report No. 214,
Computer Engineering and Networks Laboratory (TIK), Swiss Federal Institute of
Technology (ETH) Zurich , [34 ] Zitzler, E., and Thiele, L., 1999, "Multiobjective Evolutionary Algorithms: A
Comparative Case Study and the Strength Pareto Approach," Evolutionary
Computation, IEEE Transactions on, 3(4), pp. 257-271. [35 ] Durillo, J. J., and Nebro, A. J., 2011, "Jmetal: A Java Framework for Multi-Objective
Optimization," Advances in Engineering Software, 42(pp. 760-771. [36 ] Kulfan, B. M., 2008, "Universal Parametric Geometry Representation Method," 45(1),
pp. 17. [37 ] Straathof, M. H., 2012 ," Shape Parameterization in Aircraft Design: A Novel Method,
Based on B-Splines," Ph.D. thesis, http://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:b4aee571-0489-42ff-
ab55-d74e980f724a [38 ] Drela, M., and Giles, M. B., 1987, "Viscous-Inviscid Analysis of Transonic and Low
Reynolds Number Airfoils," 25(10), pp .