reprint 1006 - my.hko.gov.hk
TRANSCRIPT
Reprint 1006
颱風納沙(1117)的個案分析
沈志泰 & 柯銘強
第二十六屆粵港澳氣象科技研討會
澳門,2012 年 1 月 17-19 日
1
Case study of Typhoon Nesat (1117)
[Corrigendum]
Shum Chi-tai Or Ming-keung
Hong Kong Observatory
Abstract
Typhoon Nesat (1117) developed over the western North Pacific to the east of the
Philippines on 23 September 2011, and moved west-northwest steadily towards Luzon
in the following few days. As Nesat entered into and traversed the northern part of the
South China Sea during 27 to 29 September, the maximum sustained wind speed near
its centre maintained around 130 km/h. However, satellite images showed there were
signs of expansion of its circulation. NOAA analysis of wind field on the night of 28
September and the early morning of 29 September indicated that the gale radius of
Nesat increased by over 100 kilometres in 6 hours. The expansion of Nesat’s
circulation resulted in a more significant beta effect, causing Nesat to take a more
northwesterly track closer to Hong Kong from the night of 28 September. Owing to
the extensive circulation of Nesat and its closer approach to the south China coast,
gales affected many places in Hong Kong during the morning of 29 September and
the Observatory needed to issue the No.8 Gale or Storm Signal. This paper reviews
the performance of various numerical weather prediction models on the forecast track
of Nesat, in particular during its passage over the northern part of the South China Sea.
Factors favouring the expansion of Nesat’s circulation are also analyzed with an aim
to improving operational forecasting of tropical cyclones.
2
1. Introduction
Typhoon Nesat was the only tropical cyclone (TC) necessitating the issuance of
No.8 Signal (Gale or Storm Signal) in Hong Kong in 2011. Although it passed at a
distance as far as 350 km to Hong Kong, gale force winds affected many places in the
territory because of its extensive circulation. This has made Nesat one of the TCs
having the farthest closest approach from the territory necessitating the No.8 Signal
(another case was Typhoon Joe in 1980). Past statistics showed that the chance for
TCs to cause general gales in Hong Kong was very low at such distance. It is
understandable that statistical method for predicting the onset of gales did not work
well for the case of Nesat. In order to let forecasters predict changes in local wind
strength better, more understanding is obviously required in the structural and track
changes of large and expanding TCs similar to Nesat.
While forecasters mainly concern the forecasting of the track and intensity
changes of TCs in weather operations, the size of TC is also a crucial factor
determining local wind changes. According to Weatherford (1988), there is a weak
relationship between the outer-radius wind strength and the inner-core intensity of a
TC. This means that a TC can have its intensity (maximum wind speed near its centre)
remaining unchanged but the gale radius expanding. A larger TC is also associated
with a more significant beta-effect (Chan 1987), which may in turn influence its track.
In this paper, an overview and some highlighting features of Nesat are described in
Section 2. Section 3 analyzes the size changes of Nesat, and discusses factors
favouring its expansion using surface and upper-air observation data, NCAR/NCEP-2
Reanalysis data and satellite imagery data. The performance of numerical weather
prediction models on the forecast track of Nesat and the associated beta-effect are
discussed in Section 4. Section 5 provides hints for forecasters on predicting size and
track evolution of large TCs.
2. Overview of Typhoon Nesat (1117)
Nesat originated as a tropical depression over the western North Pacific to the east
of the Philippines on 23 September 2011. It tracked in the general direction of
west-northwest in the following few days and intensified gradually to typhoon in the
3
morning of 26 September (Figure 1a). Just before crossing Luzon, Nesat reached its
peak intensity with an estimated maximum sustained wind of 145 km/h (80 knots)
near its centre on 27 September. It soon entered the South China Sea (SCS) in the
evening on the same day and slightly weakened, but still maintained at typhoon
strength. Nesat traversed the northern part of the SCS in the following two days and
made landfall over Hainan Island in the afternoon of 29 September. It weakened
gradually because of land interaction and finally dissipated over northern Vietnam on
1 October.
Nesat was characterized by its rapid expansion of gale radius and the more
northwesterly track when it passed to the south-southwest of Hong Kong from the
night of 28 September to the early morning of 29 September. From NOAA
multi-platform analysis (Figure 3), the gale radius of Nesat increased rapidly from
12UTC to 18UTC on 28 September. The most distinguishable increase occurred in the
northeastern quadrant where the gale radius increased by more than 100 kilometres.
Nesat also took a more northwesterly track at the same time, making its closest
approach to Hong Kong about 50 km closer than that indicated by an earlier forecast
track based on 12UTC 28 September (Figure 1b, Distance of closest approach based
on forecast of 12UTC 28 September was about 400 km, compared with the actual
distance of 350 km). A combination of these two factors has resulted in general gales
affecting Hong Kong on 29 September (Figure 2), and the Observatory issued the
No.8 Signal on the same day.
3. Analysis on the size changes of Nesat
3.1 Size of Nesat
Although there is no universal definition of TC size, the radius of 17.5 ms-1
(gale
radius) is adopted in this study as this parameter is important in operational weather
forecasting. Lee et al. (2010) analyzed 73 TCs over the western North Pacific
attaining typhoon strength during the period 2000-2005. They defined TCs having
radius of 15 ms-1
wind greater than 2.6o latitude (67% percentile in their study) as
large TCs. In the case of Nesat, the radius of gales (17.5 ms-1
) reached a maximum of
3.5o latitude according to NOAA multi-platform analysis. Nesat is thus considered a
4
large typhoon from these observations.
Before focusing on the factors leading to the size expansion of Nesat, its
formation mechanism may have already hinted its future evolution into a large size
storm. Lee et al. (2008) identified six synoptic patterns for TC formation by analyzing
the zonal and meridional wind magnitude in the four quadrants of the mesoscale
convective system (MCS) before the TC formation (Table 1). They are easterly wave
(EW), northeasterly flow (NE), coexistence of northeasterly and southwesterly flow
(NE-SW), southwesterly flow (SW), monsoon confluence (MC) and monsoon shear
(MS). The MS pattern has strong easterlies to its north and westerlies to its south in
the outer core region during the formation stage, which is the most favourable pattern
for formation of large TCs. In the case of Nesat, two relatively maxima of zonal winds
could be identified to the northeast and southwest of the MCS at 12UTC on 21
September (Figure 4), which was about 48 hours before its formation. The 850 hPa
streamlines at the same time (Figure 5) showed organized westerlies associated with
cross-equatorial flow to its south and easterlies associated with subtropical ridge to its
north, satisfying the criteria of MS pattern described by Lee at al. (2008). As such,
there were already hints that Nesat might develop into a large TC during the
formation stage.
3.2 Factors favouring size expansion of Nesat
During the period when Nesat was a typhoon, it underwent two major phases of
size expansion according to NOAA multi-platform analysis. The first period is from
00UTC to 18UTC on 26 September when it was still to the east of the Philippines.
This can be more easily understood as the increase in gale radius was in line with its
intensification (increase in maximum sustained wind speed near its centre from 120
km/h to 145 km/h). The second period is from 12UTC 27 September to 18UTC 28
September when Nesat was over the SCS, with the most pronounced expansion
during the last 6 hours of the period. Such expansion is attributed to three factors: a)
increasing strength of southwesterlies (SW’lies) to the south of Nesat; b) more
significant upper-level divergence in its outer core; c) interaction with the northeast
monsoon.
5
a) Strength of southwesterlies
Moisture supply associated with SW’lies in the outer core of a TC is an important
ingredient supporting its development. Visible satellite images from 25 September to
28 September (Figure 6) suggest that the low-level southwesterly jet to the south of
Nesat was intensifying as it traversed from the western North Pacific to the SCS, as
indicated by more deep convection developing on the southern quadrants of Nesat. On
25 September, TC Haitang (1118) still lingered over the SCS and SW’lies were being
drawn into its circulation. As Haitang moved westward and weakened, Nesat became
the only TC drawing the SW’lies on 27 and 28 September. Water vapor images
(Figure 7) during the same period also show that mid-to-upper level convections
triggered by low-level SW’lies intensified significantly after Nesat entering the SCS.
In addition to the weakening of Haitang, another reason causing intensification of
SW’lies was the development and westward extension of a low-level anticyclone to
the southeast of Nesat. 850 hPa analysis at 12UTC of 27 and 28 September (Figure 8)
both indicated existence of such anticyclone. Isotach analysis at 850 hPa (Figure 9)
show that the wind maxima were located between Nesat and this anticyclone from
00UTC on 27 September to 12UTC on 28 September. According to Liu et al. (2002)
and Carr (1997), this 850 hPa anticyclone is called ‘trailing anticyclone’, which was
observed to the southeast of expanding TCs in a number of case studies and numerical
simulations.
In addition to the visual analysis of satellite images, a method used by Lee et al.
(2008) is taken in this paper to quantify the strength of SW’lies associated with Nesat.
Distributions of cloud-top temperatures within a box of 10o longitude x 5
o latitude that
has its northern boundary 5o south of Nesat’s centre has been examined (Figure 10).
This domain is chosen as we are interested in the intensity of convections associated
with SW’lies outside the central core of Nesat. The thresholds of temperatures used
for this study correspond with the color scale used in the D’vorak analysis. A general
increase in the percentage coverage of temperatures <-241K (Dark Gray or colder)
and <-231K (Medium Gray or colder) regions can be identified from 06UTC on 25
September to 12UTC on 27 September (Figure 11a). Gale radius of Nesat was found
to increase steadily during the period except the last 12 hours when it was crossing
Luzon. Gale wind radius of Nesat also increased significantly from 12UTC to 18UTC
6
on 28 September when it was located to the south-southwest of Hong Kong. The
percentage coverage of these two thresholds peaked (indicated by the blue arrows in
Figures 11a & b) about 24 hours before the significant expansion of Nesat at the night
of 28 September. In other words, the maximum convective activity in the southern
outer circulation of Nesat preceded its maximum gale radius.
According to Hill (2009), latent heat release in the outer rainbands of TCs can
result in the diabatic lateral expansion of the cyclonic potential vorticity distribution,
favouring expansion in its size. Hence, increase in convective activity outside the TC
core should occur before expansion of the TC circulation. The distribution of
cloud-top temperatures quantifying the intensity of convections, as defined in Figure
11, may become a precursor for increase in gale radius of a TC. Although more case
studies are needed to conclude a reference value of ‘lead time’ for operational use,
forecasters should remain alert if there is a sharp increase in convections associated
with the SW’lies outside the TC circulation.
b) Upper-level divergence
As shown in Figure 3, the expansion of gales mainly occurred in the northern and
eastern quadrants of Nesat at 18UTC on 28 September. Such asymmetric distribution
can be explained by the more significant upper-level divergence associated with a 200
hPa anticyclone to the northeast of Nesat. 200 hPa analysis (Figure 12) show an
anticyclone moved from the east of the Philippines at 12UTC on 27 September to
southeastern China at 12UTC on 28 September. As indicated by the black dotted
circle in Figure 12, more significant divergence was observed to the northeast of
Nesat, matching with the asymmetry of gales indicated in the NOAA multi-platform
analysis.
c) Interaction with northeast monsoon
In the morning of 28 September (Figure 13), surface analysis indicated a ridge
extending from a high cell over northwestern China, but pressure gradient over
southern China coastal areas remained relatively slack. As the northeast monsoon
associated with the high cell spread southward and Nesat edged closer to the coastal
7
areas, surface pressure gradient tightened over southern China to the north of Nesat in
the morning of 29 September. To quantify the combined effect between the northeast
monsoon and Nesat, ΔP972, i.e. the pressure difference between Hong Kong and
Chenzhou, China, can be used as a reference index. From Table 2, there was no
increase in ΔP972 from 06UTC to 12UTC on 28 September with local pressure in
Hong Kong remaining almost unchanged. The gale radius of Nesat had not expanded
during that period. However, from 12UTC to 18UTC on 28 September, ΔP972
increased by 4.5 hPa (from 5.1 hPa to 9.6 hPa). After eliminating the effect of local
pressure drop of 2.5 hPa (from 1002.1 hPa to 999.6 hPa), an increase of pressure
gradient of 2 hPa could be attributed to the effect of pressure rise from the northeast
monsoon. This coincided with the period of Nesat’s expansion. Surface pressure
gradient further tightened from 18UTC 28 September to 00UTC 29 September with
ΔP972 increasing to 10.9 hPa while local pressure had ceased dropping. Gales
affected many places in Hong Kong at the time of maximum ΔP972 (from Figure 2).
As a result, interaction with the northeast monsoon could be another reason
explaining the asymmetry of gales of Nesat.
3.3 Hints from numerical models
The expansion of gales associated with Nesat is generally not evident from
analysis of major numerical models. In fact, the performance of forecast surface wind
field inside the circulation of a TC is dependent on the performance of TC intensity
forecast, of which models still cannot handle very well at present. According to
Rogers et al. (2006), the slow improvement in intensity forecasting is the result of
deficiencies in collecting inner-core data of the TC, inadequate specification of the
vortex in the initial conditions of models and gaps in our understanding of the physics
of TCs. Lajoie et. al. (2010) pointed out that surface wind profiles of TCs from
numerical models were not performing better than other derived techniques. In the
case of Nesat, guidance from 2011092612UTC run by ECMWF, JMA and HKO
meso-model (Table 3) generally showed that Nesat would intensify during its passage
over the SCS on 28 and 29 September. Such predictions did not materialize as the
intensity of Nesat flattened at 130 km/h during the period. Hence, performance of
intensity forecast of the TC should be taken into account when assessing the
8
reliability of forecast surface wind profile.
Despite the limitations mentioned above, some favourable synoptic patterns
leading to increasing size can still be identified. Both ECMWF (Figure 14) and JMA
(not shown) indicated the development of a 850 hPa anticyclone to the southeast of
Nesat from T+24 hours to T+72 hours in the 12UTC run on 26 September. Such
development of an anticyclone, as mentioned in Section 3.2, is a mechanism for
enhancing the SW’lies associated with Nesat. A 200 hPa anticyclone was also forecast
to move to the northeast of Nesat at 12UTC on 28 and 29 September (Figure 15), and
enhanced divergence between this anticyclone and Nesat may be hinted. Tightened
surface pressure gradient from interaction with northeast monsoon was also predicted
for 29 September by the same model run (Examples of ECMWF runs are shown in
Figure 16). As a result, even though numerical models may not directly predict a
larger gale radius for Nesat, forecasters can identify some hints in the prognostic
charts to assess the possibility of gale radius expansion.
4. Performance of numerical models on track prediction of Nesat and the
associated beta-effect
4.1 Performance of numerical models on track prediction of Nesat
When Nesat was still located to the east of the Philippines, numerical models
generally forecast correctly its west-northwestward track as it moved across the
northern part of the SCS. Model runs at 12UTC on 26 September (Figure 17) show
that ensemble track consisting of four models (ECMWF, NCEP, JMA and EGRR)
and EGRR were the best performers in terms of forecasting the direction of
movement before 06UTC on 28 September, with ECMWF and NCEP showing
poleward bias and JMA showing equatorward bias. However, all models have
underestimated the speed of Nesat during its passage over SCS, even for the ensemble
track. The forecast positions on 29 September by the 2011092612UTC ensemble track
generally lagged behind the actual positions by nearly 100 kilometres although initial
position analysis was quite good.
9
4.2 Evidence of beta-effect and hints from numerical models
As Nesat traversed the northern part of the SCS, the most significant change is
its more northwesterly track from the night of 28 September to the morning of 29
September (Figure 18). This coincided with the timing associated with expanding gale
radius of Nesat. According to Carr (1997), an expanding TC can gain poleward
component in its movement by modifying the environmental anticyclone to its east to
become more north-south oriented. Such change in synoptic environment is an
evidence for occurrence of beta-effect. In the case of Nesat, 500 hPa analysis (Figure
19) show a ridge could be observed to its east at 12UTC on 28 September, which was
more north-south oriented compared with the analysis at 12UTC on 27 September.
Water vapor images (Figure 7) also indicate the subsidence to the east of Nesat
becoming more prominent from 27 to 29 September. Further in-depth study of
meso-scale analysis may also be required to explain quantitatively the degree of such
poleward turn.
Although model runs at 12UTC on 26 September (Figure 18) generally cannot
capture the slight northwestward turn of Nesat, ECMWF run at 12UTC on 27
September did hint occurrence of such turn (Figure 18). Forecast timing for the turn
was however about 12 hours earlier than the actual timing. Further analysis of the 500
hPa geo-potential height field forecast by ECMWF (Figure 20) shows that the line of
5880 m became obviously more north-south oriented from 12UTC on 26 September
to 12UTC on 29 September, matching with the actual analysis of the 500 hPa level.
Such change in orientation provides clues for Nesat to take a more northwesterly track
at some stage as it traversed the SCS.
5. Conclusion and hints
In conclusion, Nesat was characterized by its expanding gale radius and the more
northwesterly track as it traversed the SCS from the night of 28 September to 29
September. Expanding size of Nesat was mainly due to a) increasing strength of
SW’lies to the south of its circulation; b) more significant upper-level divergence in
its outer core; c) interaction with the northeast monsoon. As the onset of gales is a
major concern in operational weather forecasting, the following hints are suggested
10
for the monitoring of TC development:
1. To analyze the formation mechanism of the TC, in particular patterns favourable
for expansion into large size, such as the MS pattern.
2. To analyze possible signs of intensifying SW’lies by a) visual analysis of satellite
images; b) analysis of the percentage coverage of cloud-top temperatures <-241K
and <-231K in the southern outer circulation of the TC.
3. To identify formation of a ‘trailing’ anticyclone at 850 hPa to the southeast of the
TC from actual analysis or numerical models.
4. To identify signs of enhanced 200 hPa divergence in particular quadrants of the
TC from actual analysis or numerical models.
5. To assess possible tightening of surface pressure gradient from interaction
between the northeast monsoon and the TC over the SCS.
In case indications for size expansion exist, forecasters should remain alert if a
poleward turn will be followed because of more significant beta-effect. This can be
hinted by the more north-south orientation of the ridge at the steering layer, or
increased subsidence associated with such ridge as shown in the satellite images. In
reality, such as the case of Nesat, there may not be enough lead time for an early alert.
This should remain to be a challenge for the forecaster in the near future.
Further studies on the role of low-level SW’lies in TC development may be
carried out to enhance our understanding on the size evolutions of TCs. The feasibility
of incorporating relevant findings into numerical models may also be explored.
.
Acknowledgement:
The authors would like to thank Mr C.K. So for his assistance in providing the
cloud-top temperature data for analysis, Mr K.C. Tsui and Dr. C.M. Cheng for their
comments on the paper.
References:
Carr, L.E., III, and R.L. Elsberry, 1997: Models of tropical cyclone wind distribution
and beta-effect propagation for application to tropical cyclone track forecasting. Mon.
Wea. Rev., 125, 3190-3209.
11
Chan, J. C.-L., and R.T. Williams, 1987: Analytical and numerical studies of the
beta-effect in tropical cyclone motion. Part I: Zero Mean flow. J. Atmos. Sci., 44,
1257-1265.
Hill, K.A., and G.M. Lackmann, 2009: Influence of Environmental Humidity on
Tropical Cyclone Size. Mon. Wea. Rev., 137, 3294-3315.
Lajoie, F., and K. Walsh, 2010: A Diagnostic Study of the Intensity of Three Tropical
Cyclones in the Australian Region. Part I: A Synopsis of Observed Features of
Tropical Cyclone Kathy (1984). Mon. Wea. Rev., 138, 3-21.
Lee, C.-S., K.K.W. Cheung, J.S.N. Hui, and R.L. Elsberry, 2008: Mesoscale features
associated with tropical cyclone formation in the western North Pacific. Mon. Wea.
Rev., 136, 2006-2022.
Lee, C.-S., K.K.W. Cheung, W.-T. Fang and R.L. Elsberry, 2010: Initial Maintenance
of Tropical Cyclone Size in the Western North Pacific. Mon. Wea. Rev., 138,
3207-3223
Liu, K.S., and J.C.L. Chan, 2002: Synoptic Flow Patterns Associated with Small and
Large Tropical Cyclones over the Western North Pacific. Mon. Wea. Rev., 130,
2134-2142.
Rogers, R., S. Aberson, M. Black, P. Black, J. Cione, P. Dodge, J. Gamache, J.
Kaplan, M. Powell, J. Dunion, E. Uhlhorn, N. Shay and N. Surgi, 2006: The Intensity
Forecasting Experiment: A NOAA Multiyear Field Program for Improving Tropical
Cyclone Intensity Forecasts. Bulletin of American Met. Soc., 87, 1523-1537.
Weatherford, C.L., and W.M. Gray, 1988: Typhoon structure revealed by aircraft
reconnaissance. Part II: Structural variability. Mon. Wea. Rev., 116, 1044-1056.
12
Synoptic
Pattern
NE quadrant NW quadrant SW quadrant SE quadrant
U V U V U V U V
EW S W S W
NE S S S
NE-SW S S
SW S W S S
MC S S
MS S S
Table 1: Classification of six synoptic patterns for formation of TCs as defined by Lee
et al. (2008). ‘S’ refers to strong zonal(U)/meridional(V) wind components with
average speed greater than 5 ms-1
in the respective 5o x 5
o quadrant from the TC centre.
‘W’ refers to weak zonal(U)/meridional(V) wind components with average speed
smaller than 2 ms-1
in the respective 5o x 5
o quadrant from the TC centre.
Date/Time (UTC) ΔP972 (hPa) Hong Kong MSLP (hPa)
28 Sep 06 5.7 1002.0
12 5.1 1002.1
18 9.6 999.6
29 Sep 00 10.9 1000.0
06 8.5 1001.9
Table 2: Summary of ΔP972 and mean sea level pressure (MSLP) of Hong Kong
from 06UTC 28 September to 06UTC 29 September. ΔP972 is calculated by
subtracting the MSLP at Hong Kong (45007) from that of Chenzhou, China (57972).
Table 3: Summary of intensity forecasts of Nesat by numerical models from the
2011092612UTC run.
13
Figure 1 (a): Track of Nesat from 23 September to 1 October.
(6-hourly positions are marked according to UTC.)
Figure 1 (b): Actual track of Nesat (in black solid line) and forecast track of Nesat at
2011092812UTC (in black dotted line).
14
Figure 2: Wind distribution over Hong Kong at 08HKT on 29 September 2011 when
No.8 Gale or Storm Signal was in force and Nesat was centred about 350 km from
Hong Kong.
15
Figure 3: Evolution of wind radii of Nesat as indicated by NOAA multi-platform
analysis from 2011092806UTC to 2011092900UTC at 6-hourly intervals. Green,
yellow and red color roughly corresponds to strong, gale force and storm force winds
respectively.
16
Figure 4: Isotachs (in ms-1
) of zonal flows at 850hPa (left) and 925 hPa (right) of
MCS of Nesat at 2011092112UTC from NCEP/NCAR-2 Reanalysis data. The centre
of MCS of Nesat was around 9oN 139
oE, indicated by the red dot.
Figure 5: 850 hPa streamlines at 2011092112UTC associated with the MCS of Nesat
(centre indicated by red dot.)
17
(a) 201109250201UTC
(b) 201109260201UTC
(c) 201109270201UTC
(d) 201109280201UTC
Figure 6: Visible imageries of Nesat and Haitang from 201109250201UTC to
201109280201UTC at 24-hour intervals, showing the enhanced low-level SW’lies in
its southern outer circulation as it traversed the SCS.
(Pictures taken from MTSAT of JMA)
Haitang Nesat Haitang Nesat
Nesat Nesat
Haitang
18
(a) 201109250032UTC
(b) 201109260032UTC
(c) 201109270032UTC
(d) 201109280032UTC
(e) 201109290032UTC
Figure 7: Water vapor imageries of Nesat and Haitang from 201109250032UTC to
201109290032UTC at 24-hour intervals, showing the enhanced convection associated
with the SW’lies in its southern outer circulation as it traversed the SCS (from a-d),
and more prominent subsidence from 27 to 29 September in black box (from c-e).
(Pictures taken from MTSAT of JMA)
Haitang Nesat
Haitang Nesat
Haitang
Nesat Nesat
Nesat
19
Figure 8: Streamline analysis at 850 hPa at 2011092712UTC (top) and
2011092812UTC (bottom). The anticyclone to the southeast of Nesat is marked in the
red box.
20
Figure 9: Isotachs (in ms-1
) and wind barbs at 850 hPa associated with Nesat from
2011092700UTC to 2011092812UTC at 12-hour intervals, showing the isotach
maxima to the southeast of Nesat.
21
Figure 10: Dimensions of the box with 10o longitude x 5
o latitude that has its northern
boundary 5o south of Nesat’s centre.
Figure 11: Time series of percentage coverage of cloud-top temperatures lower than
various thresholds of color scheme in the D’vorak channel computed in (a) the box
defined in Figure 10; (b) the right half of the box defined in Figure 10. Red arrow
indicates the period when Nesat underwent rapid increase in gale radius from 12UTC
to 18UTC on 28 September. Blue arrows indicate the peaks in percentage coverage of
cloud-top temperatures <-241 K and <-231 K before Nesat’s expansion.
5o
5o
10o
22
Figure 12: Streamline and divergence analysis at 200 hPa at 2011092712UTC (top)
and 2011092812UTC (bottom). An anticyclone can be analyzed to the northeast of
Nesat at 2011092812UTC. Black dotted circle indicates the northeastern quadrant of
Nesat with enhanced divergence from 2011092712UTC to 2011092812UTC.
23
(a) 00UTC on 28 September 2011
(b) 00UTC on 29 September 2011
Figure 13: Surface analysis at (a) 00UTC on 28 September 2011 (b) 00UTC on 29
September 2011. The tightened pressure gradient because of interaction with northeast
monsoon is marked in the red box to the north of Nesat.
24
Figure 14: ECMWF 850 hPa prognostic charts of the 2011092612UTC run from T+0
hour to T+72 hours at 24-hour intervals. Note the presence of an anticyclone to the
southeast of Nesat (marked in black box), especially for 2011092712UTC and
20011092912UTC forecasts.
25
Figure 15: ECMWF 200 hPa prognostic charts of the 2011092612UTC run from T+0
hour to T+72 hours at 24-hour intervals. Note the presence of an anticyclone to the
northeast of Nesat (marked in black box) for 2011092812UTC and 20011092912UTC
forecasts.
26
Figure 16: ECMWF surface prognostic charts of the 2011092612UTC run from T+0
hour to T+72 hours at 24-hour intervals. Note the tightened pressure gradient (marked
in black box) spreading from inland China for 2011092812UTC and 2011092912UTC
forecasts.
27
Figure 17: Forecast tracks of Nesat from various models (Red-JMA; Purple-ECMWF;
Blue-EGRR; Light blue-NCEP; Green-Ensemble) of the 2011092612UTC runs with
the best track analysis in black.
Figure 18: Forecast tracks of Nesat from various models (Red-JMA; Purple-ECMWF;
Blue-EGRR; Light blue-NCEP; Green-Ensemble) of the 2011092712UTC runs with
the best track analysis in black. The northwest turn by ECMWF is marked.
NW turn by ECMWF
28
Figure 19: Streamline analysis at 500 hPa at 2011092712UTC (top) and
2011092812UTC (bottom). The ridge to the east of Nesat (marked in red box) was
found to be more north-south oriented at 2011092812UTC compared with
2011092712UTC.
29
Figure 20: ECMWF 500 hPa prognostic charts of the 2011092612UTC run from T+0
hour to T+72 hours at 24-hour intervals. The contour of 5880 m line is marked in red.