result evaluation of coherent target model product with...
TRANSCRIPT
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Result evaluation of Coherent Target Model Product with long-term InSAR
data set in Shanghai
LIESMARS
Mingsheng Liao, Yan WANG, Lijun LU, Deren LILIESMARS, Wuhan University
P. O. Box C310, 129 Luoyu Road, 430079, Wuhan, China
Zheng FANG, Zixin WE, Hanmei WANG, Lijun YANG, Ying LIUShanghai Institude of Geological Survey, Shanghai, China, 200072
November 29, 2005
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Outline
• Background of our project• Subsidence in China• Overview of methodology• Preliminary result• Conclusion and remark
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Project 2567, Dragon Programme
The scientific investigations of Project 2567, DRAGON Programme, focus on the applications of ESA data (ERS-1/2 and Envisat/ASAR) in TOPOGRAPHIC MEASUREMENT , include
•• Topographic mappingTopographic mapping
•• Land deformationLand deformation monitoring monitoring <=<= topic of this presentationtopic of this presentation
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Prof. Deren Li Prof. Mingsheng Liao (Contact Point)
State Key Lab. For Information Engineering in Surveying, Mapping and Remote Sensing(LIESMARS) Wuhan University
Prof. Chao Wang Chinese Academy of Sciences
Prof. Agen Zhang Center for Land Subsidence of China Geological Survey
The partners in China
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Prof. Fabio RoccaDipartimento di Elettronica ed Informazione
Politecnico di Milano, Italy
Dr. Alessandro FerrettiTele-Rilevamento Europa – T.R.E. s.r.l. Via Vittoria Colonna 7 20149 Milano, Italy
The partners in Europe
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
In China, land subsidence is one of the most urgent environmental dilemmas facing numerous megalopolises on which it is densely populated, thereby causing prominent damage.
Subsidence in China
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Example: Subsidence History of Shanghai:
Reasonable adjusted the quality of water pump
Underground water over-pumped
3.5
87 (max.: 110)40
1972-1989 slightly subsidence
1957-1965 serious1949-1956 acceleration
Increase the quantity of water pumping and municipal engineering constructions
161990- now accretion
Reduced pumping and artificial intake of water
-31966-1971 rebound1966 – nowControl
subsidence
Underground water pumped241921-1948 development1921-1965Obvious
subsidence
Main causesAverage velocity (mm/y)
StagePeriod
Subsidence in China
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Subsidence in China
• In Shanghai, Land subsidence is also a primary geologic disaster . Particularly with the developing of massive construction and increasing of groundwater mining, land subsidence had presented some new peculiarities in the past 15 years. It makes great effect on city planning、flooding prevention or municipal infrastructure.
• The ground network, such as optical leveling, GPS etc., is not enough for dynamic monitoring.
• InSAR should be of great benefit to understand the spatial and temporal distribution of land subsidence.
• Shanghai has been selected as main test site in our DRAGON project.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
For limitations of traditional D-InSAR, the Permanent Scatterers technique has initiated by A. Ferretti and F. Rocca etc.
Point-wise targets are not affected by geometrical decorrelationSome pixels are only slightly affected by temporal decorrelationWe do look for reliable phase information on point target
Overview: methodology
∆φint = ∆φdef + ∆φgeom + ∆φtmp + ∆φtopo + ∆φnoise
Components of interferometric phase:
Point Target InSAR technique is applied for detecting long-term deformation in Shanghai test site.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Overview:Subsidence Monitoring in Shanghai, PS InSAR
Result of PS InSAR with ERS-1/2 derived by POLIMI and TRE
• 26 images (1993-2000) processed using PermanetScatterer technique;
• The velocity distribution in PSs has been compared with the subsidence map of Shanghai:
=>the results from InSAR and leveling are quite consistent.
---- (Report of Dragon Programme)
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
• The Coherent Target Analysis (CTA) provided an alternative approach to exploit the temporal and spatial characteristics of interferometric signatures of long-term InSAR data.• Coherent targets that includes targets that are temporarily coherent as well as targets with a low coherence. • CTA was adapted in Shanghai for cross validation of different approaches.
Overview: methodology
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Features of Coherent Target Analysis
• Coherent Target Analysis methodology was said that not limited to a large number of scenes (Marco Van der Kooij, Fringe 2003).
• The temporal coherence is the main measurement of how stable the phase of a scatter is over time, not intensity stability index or averaging coherence .
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Temporal Coherence
– Temporal coherence is used for measure of how stable the phase of a scatterers over time.
– Temporal Coherence of n Scenes of Interferogram is defined as
2 2
1 1( cos( )) ( sin( ))
n n
i ii i
n
φ φγ = =
+=
∑ ∑
• If φi does not change, the temporal coherence will be 1.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Criterion to Identify Coherent TargetExpected Temporal Coherence via the number of Interferograms
Recommended 4 sigma threshold: 0.91 for 10 scenes0.70 for 20 scenes0.44 for 50 scenes
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
• Coherent Target Analysis (CTA) with ERS-1/2 conducted by LIESMARS.
• 24 images (1993-2000) processed using Coherent Target Analysis method;
• SRTM DEM used as external DEM data set;
• The data processing chain for CTA is constructed based on a commercial InSAR software.
• The cross validation of results from CTA, PS and Leveling is working on.
Overview:Subsidence Monitoring in Shanghai, CTA
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Preliminary result in Shanghai
Shanghai City Map
Developing urban area
Traditional urban area
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Subsidence map from ground network(1990-1998)
Preliminary result in Shanghai
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
SAR images
20661512000-12-5ERS2
1891-202000-6-13ERS2
18211622000-4-4ERS2
17862602000-2-29ERS2
17511142000-1-25ERS2
1716501999-12-21ERS2
1681981999-11-16ERS2
1611-3481999-9-7ERS2
15413501999-6-29ERS2
15063031999-5-25ERS2
11214491998-5-5ERS2
1086-661998-3-31ERS2
946-3101997-11-11ERS2
420-5541996-6-3ERS1
280-3851996-1-15ERS1
1754931995-10-2ERS1
70-1861995-6-19ERS1
001995-4-10ERS1
-513-701993-11-13ERS1
-5832411993-9-4ERS1
-6184501993-7-31ERS1
-653681993-6-26ERS1
-688811993-5-22ERS1
-7235491993-4-17ERS1
-9335001992-9-19ERS1
BtBnDateSensor
85 Km
85 K
m
25 scenes ERS-1/2 SAR images from 1992-2000
Preliminary result in Shanghai
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Main steps in CTA Processing
• Generation of interferograms (including flat earth phase and topographic phase removal) • Atmospheric correction (constant phase) • Phase modification based upon DEM elevation • Calculation of temporal coherence adjusted for atmospheric and DEM error • Deformation estimate for each pixel with the “template search”; • Final output map (geocoded or slant-range) and reporting products
- average backscatter- temporal coherence- DEM error - deformation map
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Criterion to Identify Coherent Target
For 24 scences of interferograms , the temporal coherence is expected to be higher than 0.7
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Master image
24 scenes of interferogram created
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
interferogram
temporal coherence
atmospheric offset
coherent point targets
Average backscatter image
Preliminary result in Shanghai
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Validation of point target
Preliminary result in Shanghai
Example:Hero’s Monument is diamond-shaped stable scatterer, a landmark built up during 1988-1994.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
………0.84 -22.90 20 0.79 -18.35 10
0.78 -26.66 29 0.76 -22.90 19 0.80 -34.99 9
0.78 -26.67 28 0.79 -24.36 18 0.85 -39.52 8
0.75 -27.42 27 0.75 -29.68 17 0.75 -38.76 7
0.77 -28.18 26 0.79 -28.16 16 0.76 -40.28 6
0.75 -28.18 25 0.80 -28.16 15 0.79 -13.82 5
0.77 -26.67 24 0.81 -28.17 14 0.75 -44.81 4
0.78 -28.94 23 0.76 -27.41 13 0.76 -23.62 3
0.75 -47.07 22 0.77 -27.41 12 0.76 -22.11 2
0.76 -19.10 21 0.85 -27.41 11 0.75 -19.09 1
CoherenceCT Vel.(mm/y)No.Coherenc
eCT Vel.(mm/y)No.CoherenceCT Vel.
(mm/y)No.
Preliminary result in Shanghai
Subsidence velocity and temporal coherence on part of coherent targets
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Benchmark
Reference point
CTs
Distribution of benchmarks and CTs in the test site
Preliminary result in Shanghai
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Comparison of subsidence velocities, coherent target via benchmark
-- Nearest neighboring Coherent Target with benchmark
Validation of the results (1)
Benchmark
< 100m
Nearest CT
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Average:-1.0406 mm/y STDEV: 6.576682 mm/y
14.21 -17.75 -31.96 16
1.64 -11.38 -13.01 15
10.20 -6.63 -16.83 14
-3.22 -43.50 -40.29 13
-6.69 -21.25 -14.56 12
-10.94 -39.13 -28.18 11
0.01 -25.88 -25.89 10
-7.53 -30.38 -22.85 9
-4.81 -23.88 -19.07 8
1.93 -13.38 -15.30 7
-6.57 -35.50 -28.93 6
-6.29 -21.63 -15.33 5
1.60 -14.50 -16.10 4
-2.61 -17.88 -15.27 3
-0.23 -14.75 -14.52 2
2.64 -11.13 -13.77 1
Difference (mm/y)Leveling (mm/y)CTs (mm/y)No.
min. difference
max. difference
Validation of the results (2)
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Validation of the results (3)
Comparison of subsidence velocities between CTs and benchmarks-- Nearest neighbor with benchmarks
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Discussions
•The distribution tendency of subsidence from CTA method is consistent with the leveling data in benchmarks.
• Few coherent targets with large bias exist in preliminary result.
• According to the preliminary validation, temporal coherence can be introduced as a measurement for selection of stable point target.
• The further investigation and field survey should be carried out later to explore the characteristics of point target and improve the accuracy.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Conclusion & Remark (1)
• The ERS-1/2 image stack covering the test area, Shanghai between 1992 and 2000 were chosen and processed with Coherent Target Analysis.
• The product based on the Coherent Target Analysis is compared with ground leveling data.
•The preliminary result is promising but expected to be investigated in more detail.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
Conclusion & Remark (2)
• In many coastal cities in China like Shanghai, there are a lot of new constructions on soft clay ground. The problem of ground stability appears obviously.
• Up to now the mechanism of the soft clay ground stability has not been comprehensively known because of the lack of the systematic monitoring and the accumulated data.
• InSAR technique should be a potential technique in urban environment research.
• And plenty of historic archive and new arrival SAR dataset from ESA should benefit to monitoring subsidence in these cities.
DRAGON Programme (id:2567)
LIESMARS