review 238: masayoshi murata (ofuna interrogation centre guard)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 REVIEW 238: Masayoshi Murata (Ofuna Interrogation Centre Guard)
1/5
r
, .
.... 3"'
' ,
.... . ,
'>'
r 3 . . ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ 5 .
. S " 0 0 B
LHEKUXEW[HWQ HIJL[L E&Z
Xoithk steths Ertoy
.Nddiah . tlh
sted d Cukjh
Ekvnaeth
'
-
.
'
X O ~ [ C I K
Q[E[HQ
ND
EFHWIAE
vs
F QEYNQLI
H
IKWE[E
Whvihw
nd tlh sted d Cukjh Ek[naeth
. - I . - '
'
I .
[lh ettealhk rhanrk
nd
t r ie b d
Feseynsli
Furete
et
Yt5`nlef.e3, Cepeo,
ko 57
Ceouery 59;
-
8/10/2019 REVIEW 238: Masayoshi Murata (Ofuna Interrogation Centre Guard)
2/5
.
Qp
8
i . t kbiivhrs
t5bs55h55 ghtwhho
b F3hy .&J
"5d9;;
. 3 o k
Cibb
Onvhfghr
3it9;;,
. eaaushk .
kik
w i b 3 3 d ~ .eok uoib.ew.dZ.5.y
.fi
.strh00.t
o u i o 3 i 0 0 n u s .
.ilhri'aeo
eok . ' . b . b b
5
]
3t
h 9y
ghk.t
ios eok
n'ilhrwish
e g u ~ i o j
b 3 3 b h i o ~
.
3
Quffery hd tlh } 3viab.hoahi
e . Jhohreb.
,.
..
'
Onb
prnsshk
(W. 1)
J
hxahpt
dnr tlh
wnrks
55
eok Ebbihk"
a.ok
nd tlh hx
ahpthk
.-5nrks,
OJ
. . . . 'b'lh
khdhok7ot, uesa0.ynsli C urete,
e
]htty Nddiahr io tlh Ifphrieb3
Cepa3.ri.hsh
Oevy,
kurioh0
^abb3
tifhs anvhrh
.k
gy tlh
alerjh
kbbk
sphaid iaet inos,
wes
e j 0 u ~ k et
tlh
Nduoe
Iotb3ir3rinjetino
Ahothr, a0
]risnohr
nd
:
.Cer Aefp ht Aduoe,
LqosltR,
Cepeo.
L
s
oia`oefhs whrh
[ l ~
[hrfith"
eok
"Girk-greio."
(W.
5=,
540
~ ~ 5, -7,
10
;, 8-). . .
g. Dnr
tlh
]rvshautinot .-,
:^
3
. ...
. ....
.
' ,..^
...
3 i .
5
-
, [ . ` s 3 ~ e C p e a i d b a e t . i ~ o ~ 3 a ~ . p t ~ o ~ ~ u ' h s J v w ~ 0 . J v k w ~ o r . O S D n r a h 0 ~ e.
'.
^]3
5
5.-et.. Cuoe d'.dnf
79
Cuoh 5,9;;
-0n
58. ~ e o u e r y 5 2 0 ; 8 ,
thstb.d ihk,. .5o
phrsno, tle.l'3'
'- . .
e.g4tlh 5 5 k . ~ . 2 5 5 . h ni5.
Q h ] . t 3 ~ g . h r b
':;;, h e . r b ~ io
.
t.Kh
~ t h r ~ n n o
lh. se.w
..Furete
t b t
...
. . .
i ~ u t h o e . o t
J h a 3 ~ j - ~
.
. Grnw>, . X ~ ~ ; ~ t ~ h ~ 0 > > ~ ~ e a r n ~ Q - t o h ^ 3 9 e a ` c i t l & abtrb> 1'3-3bi7-
d ~ 5 - 7 - 5 / 7 . . ~ p . a b i ~ . et bhe.st s C b ~ X3Lihs
0otl
sual 0r0wa&
5 5.Q
tn st.e.0>0jhr GrnZl.
,
,
. ... ^ ,
[lis k a a u E ~ oher a ~ b ' 0 > .
^
i r 2 3 ~ r & h @ ~ - C t C , e ~ . tlh
vduoe
'
Aw^op
e.ok .
"'tb Xth
.....
.
3 ~ .
^ .,.r
rh'.>.hoah
nd. twn
nr
tlb3"hh phnpi.h
won v,rhrh
witl 555urete (o.
b ~ ,
5,1). Anirut Eokhr^
Cnlo Ebbisno
Grnwo, XQO, r AUCru55aX5khr a.t Nd'uoe., s t
..
. h ~ . io eo edbikevit--{Ex.
,
3 . ,
.
.
3
p.
-8)
tlet
no 8 .Qhpthfghr
~
Furete
dnuok
.
]3
Grnwo
sbhhpioj
io e
veaeot
rnnf
"i3..ok tnn` lif =ut.
ghliok
tdih
gerreai(Q
uok strua`
l3i.f six
tifhs
witl
e
.
abug
tlh
s5z
-h-n e geshgebb g ~ t i o
trbh
,prhshoab
U ~ , , . t w n
fai.bh .30uHdsts .hd ~ r i 0 t e .. 3... ^ .
6 3 30
- 6- . -
~ ~ .. ^. 3-
.3--
......
- . . . ^- . ;
-..
^. . . . .
3. ...
.
, ~ s 53.4
1phadiautino
83
]i'/
Jnkwio
ths"tilhk io.
phrsno3
(e) 'dlet io Natnghr 59;;,
wlibh
tlh
s whrh wn.itioj io tlh
ahb b pesskjh
dnr hToioj iosphatino,
tlh
55
[hrfith
55
sbujjhk
Bihuthoeot d ~ r g u a ` b h ,
XQO3,
s.
,
o
tlh deah witl lis d i s t tlrhh tir55hs (W, 5=)
55).
(g)
[l ..t
et
tlh hok hd i2XP0Xst
nr io
h e r b ~ Qhpthfghr,
59;;,
et
. di.vh
nr six
= I abna` io
tlh
hvhoioj, nu.tsikh
tlh 3
gB
.rreaB23s, tlh
"[hrfith"
ioekh
Bihuthoeot Anbnohb
'deb`hr,
EA, e st.3..ok et bh535.st
noh-lebd
lnur io eo uooet
ureb
pns0i.tino `o=wo
es tlh
Nduoe
arnual (khsarighk e t L, 57) ,
kurb.oj, wlial .
tiiuh lh
sbXgjhk
]/
'3eb`hr
ea,
rnss
tlh
b'eah
witl
lis
abnshk
'
d is t
et bhest
dnur
t i . I r i ~ . s
ae
us io.0
TR .,
'eb ahr tn tn t thr
"gea`
ejeiost tlh
gerrr..a`s ( } b ,
57).
I o
eo eddikh.vit (Hx. 5) a ~ . p t e i o '. ' ibbief a D h r r h o , EA,
e
]-'
5
et
=-duoe
drnf 4
C fuer0v- ..b3 Natnghr
5.
9;;, s te ths 3
( a)
[let no 8 Eun5st 59;; Fur7.t7.
put
liie io tlh i.)XQbi-up
pnsiti=o
dnr
twn lnurs eok '2dlho lh slnwhk sijos hd si3.
t
1ioj lit
lif
w3...tl e abug
i3..5/7
ioalhs
ir t kid.iiuhthr,
diriab.by `i a`hk
li.ibb io tlh
4b Nio
00.oe s b ~ j h k
li.o o
tlh
da3..ah.
. R
.
[oet no
79-g.ua30-ust 59;;,
3..3ureta.
sbXa.0hk
dnur prisnohrs
5
eok
cegghk Bihut
ho.ft Oyreky>
] 0
~ ~ t l
e
g e y n o h t ~
? --
-
8/10/2019 REVIEW 238: Masayoshi Murata (Ofuna Interrogation Centre Guard)
3/5
. .. .
03
( h}' [ b d n . ~ ni) .V9 C u b ~ ; ; , F u r ~ t e 3 siujjhk Bihuthoeot Lerfno
,, ]. 0
Qlhrry,
e
H
w
0 i t d r li.s'
=
d i s t s eriti
-..st,,
ruq`
lb
~ l v h o tiiiihs
' 5k.tl & g e s h l ~ b b
b0?et
3 .
C'
t w ( ) ~ o k l h s k3i0i,ohthr. ., '3
.' 3
? .,. -, r '. I -- ,I . 2 ' ' , . , . ^ . . . , ' R ' ,
.
.
- ^ - 5
R.
' '
.
. . . . . .
d )
5 s t
2 b . i h u . ~ h o e o t
/
~ n u 0 s i & e 5 3 ? ~ r o i , e. .
et
nuoe '^rrnf
.
5 5
5
s 'wk3t .l lis dist no six '
nr
sh2iiho. gaa'esinos, ont.
vhry
b)h.rk, eok
qoVby noah
no
heal
naaesino.
.
.
.0,
.
..
..
" ,03
.
'
V
.. . . ,(.j) bQ3hoohtp =0 @hbghrj0
b O ,
XQO, e pw et Nduoe drn5o
8
Qhpthfghr 59.;1 tn .b N' t h e i b ' b b9;;c io eo eddtkevit (Hx. 1 , Qti0i.ths
tlet
Fur 2'...t&. eok dvur ntlhr .juerks '. whrh
tlh
fheohst et Nduoe eok lh. dhbt' .fqoy d'd
tlhid ghetiojs . ,
R
. 3 , . . . . . .. (g )' F ~ c n r Knoebk ~ n y b h , 3 XQFA5 e C' .'r et
ndw be
drnf 8 Feral
~ 9 ; ; . 3 t . / 58
Ch.ou&r
y 59>8'. s t ~ ^ t h s ^
tpet
-
8/10/2019 REVIEW 238: Masayoshi Murata (Ofuna Interrogation Centre Guard)
4/5
. '
.
(h)
'b'let
lh `ohw
.
p s l ~ ~ r y
gut.
ohvhr
strua` lif e.s
]
stethk (W . 53 5
"
A4
oweokhr,
wlnsh
od3Bikevit (H\. 8)
shhfs tn
gh
e
fnrh kht0.0.iib.hk
eoti anosikhrhk
k . n a w o h o ~ ,
ettriguths
tlh.
cegg 3i
oj
nd ]'/
O0irrHijy,
no
e
kiddhrhot
keth,
t
n o ~
.
1ti`ifntn.
I t is ~ h b y pnssigbh
3
tlA.3t tl is sefh ] '0
wes ch.gghk
g ~ ,
gntl
Fure.tu
eok ,1Rb0k
..
5=tn
no
' twn
kfddhrhot naausinos, gut tlh si55tbba.rity nd tlh
twn
hvhots,
a.s
rhC..n.thk
io tlh
t wn a3..ddiN.aivits, .
reishs .0
.
rhesnoegbh knugt
u.s
tn
v0lntohr
Aa..
,i0i
t
...
+o ~ r r h f rhan5bhatno
nd
tiih
naaurrhoah i s anrrhat.
5st BihX3thoa.ft
SUccciphri(bi
5
s e.tdikuvit is v h r ~ r ~ h o h r e b .eok shh.os tn
fioifizh
tlh ghetio.330s ekioio
i s ~ h r h e
gy
tlh
g.NAXshk.
..
I t
.
i s
opt
noby
pnssigbh
gut
hotirhb .
prngegbh
tlet
io
errivioj bit tt5h shothoah wlial t ifpnshk no tlh uaaushk, tlh Anffissino a.bsn
aierhg,a.rkhk
tl is hviehoah.
[lhrh
reoa.3Bos, lnwhvhr, edthr abisanuot3..o.,0 tlhsh
e.ddi.kev
3Bts , sudd ia i
.
hot hvikhoah
,
io tlh
thstifnoy
nd Aepteio
5
30
nabwio
2.i.r5ai teh ntlhr
uddikev3its
r-hahivhk
.
io hvikhoah
.
tn
slqw e
petthro nd
anotiouhk
aruhb
eok uowkb'
reothk
.
2e.gusii.vh
trh230tfhot nd
D it g^y
tlh a u s h k ~
8
Whanffhoke.tin5s
. .
. I
.
r
[b3'bhtih e ~ h rig vhhnffhok ti.tinos dnr abhfhpay, r '55h
N o k i o ~ s
nd 4 R b b b ~ y '5.Q
tn t ~ 5 . h
s p h ~ b d 3
- N o s eo"k tlh 'al2ir.3..h X0)No
- wlial
.
tlh g.AA
.
ushk
Z ~ Q t r ihk t rh .. .
.. suppnr'thk
gy
tlh
hvikhoah eok
tlh shothoah if00inehk ny tlh A e f f i ~ s i n o ont
5
.
'
.hxahssi0c3h, Baaushk wes
anodiohk
no 7: Dhgrua.ry 59;:
eok
w ~ s tr ihk a.oe
shothoahk
. nl },07. ~ .> ~
A ( . } d 5 d i o h b b b h b b ~
.
et lack
^
en3ir n . Ai p h r ~ n
n3
dnur
.
(;) y ~ a 0 . r s
, ,.Xoe.hr
,
h.30u
st+oj
pn.Biay,
u u ~
tn
tlh
bhb5H,t'l
=
}.0uoh
^.
t{bh
eaaushk
la.k
ghho
an
odeohk
. . . . - I .,
-
8/10/2019 REVIEW 238: Masayoshi Murata (Ofuna Interrogation Centre Guard)
5/5
.
.3 ( t / .
~
.
0 0 ~
..
a 3 3 - - ~ - B - 2 - ~
..
~ ^ ^ , ,
.
]rinr
tn .
tlh k&.tn nd
h o t h o a h , it} i s
r ~ a a o u o h o k h k tlut
shvho ~ . o . k
poh.3.le.bd fnotls
.,, ' ndi tlh shothoa
,h
tpnshk. gh rhfitthk. 1ujefn ]risno,
[n`yn,. 'dnosb5u,
Cepno is
.
tlh
e p p r n > r ~ t h
pl.ah
dnr ,
Anodiohfhot.
4, a t 3 B ~ o .
dnrb}b nd.
;atino tn
a ~ r r y
nut
tlhsh rnanffhokn.tinos iotn hddhat
i s
ette.alhk.
.
0
.
]CXtttY
HTC OQ
Lhvinwhr
Cuu
=
h
~ ~ T N A u t h Q ~ A t i n o
. I .anoau.r io jhohreb. [gh shothi3ah nd dnur yhn^rs dnr s h r ~ . n u s
F i ~ t r e t f ~ ~ t ~
gd
fnrh
tleo
e
tnzho
p h r s n ~ s
rhvhebs
t ~ h
hxhraish
.
gy tlh anffissino
ad
b h o i h o a ~ ' gy == '5-
r
r c sno.
i ~ l
tb'5=sh
{
cu=r3h2
gy
ntlhr
~ n f f i s s i n o s io aeshs iovnbv3 oj H 3b.fibhr d e a t s ~ r-rhvhrtlh
bhss ~ r h - t r 5 . e b nnodi.ohfhot is
io
on
~ 5 e y
tn lh
a n o s i a 5 ~ r h a '
es - .. . .
anoddohrohot s h r v . ~ a
c^o
h x p ^ i u t ~ no
dnr
n d d h o s ~ s
9"d ^ v 3 g ~ . a l
'"'-0o Hiaaushat
i s
be thr qno"'-athe. ^[ln rh dnrh h. r . h v 3 i 3 H 3 w ~ o j rb't-r
=
nr b
y sdRnubr. ..
.
anos
,i (h r s3uaC5
3rhst5akot h b , b i b C . r h b ~ ,
s h f , , 3 r ~ t h b y
drnr
r t r e - t 5 ~ e {
ct.5.njhh
- g ~ r e ~ a n f f i . s s i n o [ l h g b D . r a ` h s ~
rnr0t5e"..3Q
hot3itbhhtn ~ o = 2 . r ~ Y .
.... tri...,..5 uorb" tlh
ho0lijgtho,he
robh.s
nd e . ~
3 0 ^ ~ b i
z&A
or nos
.
' lh rt .
3333- tri
h[s e r h c C n . s t p n o ~ a
t s
d t n o ~ . 3 . g h A - 2 3 v . s ~ n d s l h
r - r a ~ h
o t f - - ~
.
.
~ h ~
.Nd .
l N F d5tbiC.deitClj- -cust3thh, 'd73ir a i 5 b n ' ' D t n o a = ~
..
r.nobk gh
.
f ~ a ' h
~ dnr 0 f h t r h - p r h - t ~ . d ~ 5 A . k o d i o M 5 h o t ' r.Uid0
iua3
5
5hss nd t l . h i o e a h q ] . e ~ y
n'd3 ...
'' '
-
-
shothoah.
[lis
c s . hC)3 tlh
o0.nrH? troh sioah anffissinos
erU. io33... ,
. , ..struhthk
tlet
p rh-tb'iieb r d i o a D ~ h o t 3s ont-iw gh a n o s i k h r h ~ io -"'"
' ^
e=
cXabjioj
sh othoA2CQ , .
..
.. .
. -
.. 0b
^ . . . ..
. .
I
.
..
..
- --
95, .. .
EBBEO
W.
GWNT OH
Bt"
Anbnohb
CEJK
Eroy Cuajh Ekvnaeth
.
.
..