review of typical behaviours observed in strongly...

42
Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly correlated systems Charles Simon Laboratoire CRISMAT, CNRS and ENSICAEN, F14050 Caen. “Models in magnetism: from basics aspects to practical use” Timisoara september 2009

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

Review of typical behaviours observed in

strongly correlated systems

Charles Simon Laboratoire CRISMAT, CNRS and ENSICAEN,

F14050 Caen.

“Models in magnetism: from basics aspects to practical use”Timisoara september 2009

Page 2: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 2

Some examples of strongly correlated electrons

• Superconductivity• Magnetism• Low dimensionnality• Heavy fermions• Mott insulators

Page 3: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 3

Free electrons

x 420-2-4

25

20

15

10

5

0

EF

K

Band structure (tight binding calculations)

Temperature effects (EF =1eV = 30 000K)

Page 4: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 4

Effect of electron electron repulsion U

From T. Giamarchi

Page 5: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 5

Effect of correlations

Broadening

Not so strong

Page 6: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 6

Photoemission

Page 7: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 7

Photoemission in insulators

Hubbard satellite U

Page 8: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 8

Strongly correlated metal

Peak of quasi particules

Hubbard peak

Page 9: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 9

Transport properties

• Specific heat Cp:• Sommerfeld expansion:

Page 10: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 10

Heavy fermions

Page 11: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 11

Band mass and effective mass

Page 12: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 12

De Haas Van Alphen effect

• In presence of magnetic field, it appears oscillations periodic in 1/H related to the extremum area of the Fermi surface.

• In addition, there is a magnetic field dependence of the amplitude related to effective mass. (high mass, high field).

Page 13: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 13From JP Brison

Page 14: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 14

Resistivity in T2

From R. Fresard

The prefactor A scales with γ2

Also magnetic susceptibility is Cte

condcutivity=ne2τ/m

Page 15: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 15

Thermoelectric power S

From Behnia et al.

S= k/e π2/2 T/TF (1 + 2/3 z)

Page 16: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 16

Page 17: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 17

Why oxides ?

• Metal U/t small, no correlations, screening of interactions by excitations electron-hole

• Oxides

Effective t can be smallU/t large

Page 18: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 18

Oxides are interesting

Page 19: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 19

Mott insulators V2 O3

Page 20: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 20

Mott insulators V2 O3

Page 21: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 21

Page 22: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 22

Organic conductor from Limelette et al.

Transfer of the spectral weight

Page 23: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 23

Page 24: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 24

Kondo effect

Page 25: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 25

Kondo effectMagnetic impurities

Page 26: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 26

DMFT

• Dynamical mean field theory• To put together quasiparticules and

Hubbard states• Limit: no Q dependence, cluster DMFT…

Page 27: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 27From A. Georges

Page 28: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 28

Cobaltates Ca3 Co4 O9

From Limelette

Page 29: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 29

Specific heat

Page 30: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 30

Nickelates RNiO3

Page 31: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 31

Cuprates

• They are high Tc superconductingmaterials

Two different scalesof energies

Page 32: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 32

Overdoped cuprate: normal Fermi liquid

Page 33: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 33

From B. Vignolle

Page 34: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 34

YBaCuO underdoped

YBa2 Cu3 O6.5 (p = 0.1)

A= 5.1 nm-2= 1.9 % of the carriers

Abnormal photoemission

Fermi arcs

Page 35: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 35

Fermi surface reconstruction: small pockets

Page 36: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 36

Page 37: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 37

Page 38: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 38

Other interpretation: stripes

Page 39: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 39

Cuprates

Page 40: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 40

Manganites Pr0.7 Ca0.3 MnO3

0

1

2

3

4

0 2 4 6 8 1010-2

101

104

107

1010

30K

M (μ

B/f.u

.)

R (Ω

)

B (T)

?IS

OLA

NT

METAL

0

1

2

3

4

0 2 4 6 8 1010-2

101

104

107

1010

30K

M (μ

B/f.u

.)

R (Ω

)

B (T)

?IS

OLA

NT

METAL

Electronic phase separation

Jahn Teller effect = orbital orderingColossal magnetoresistance

Page 41: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 41

From R. Sopracase

From C. Martin

10-3 10-2 10-1

100

102

10430K

4T

2TQ-2

Q-4

Inte

nsity

(cm

-1)

Q (Å)

2 3 4 5 6 70.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

Magnetic field (T)

S/V

(μm

-1) A

nano (a.u.)

HI-MHS

2 3 4 5 6 70.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

Magnetic field (T)

S/V

(μm

-1) A

nano (a.u.)

HI-MHS

From D. Saurel

Page 42: Review of typical behaviours observed in strongly ...magnetism.eu/esm/2009/slides/simon-slides-2.pdf · Some examples of strongly correlated electrons • Superconductivity • Magnetism

models in magnetism timisoara 42

Conclusions

• Effects of correlations: Fermi surface, effective mass, …– Specific heat, conductivity, magnetic

susceptibility, photoemission and dHvA effects

• Mott transition, Kondo effects– Phase separation, transfer of spectral weight

• Effects of low dimensions