safeguarding against fraud · • accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor...

58
Safeguarding Against Fraud Dave Lakly, MPA [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Safeguarding Against Fraud

Dave Lakly, MPA

[email protected]

Page 2: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

At the end of this session, the participant will be able to:

• Recall definition of internal control

• Define fraud

• Discuss the fraud triangle

• Recall categories of fraud

• Identify fraud prevention and detection for common transactions

Learning Objectives

2

Page 3: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

SCHOOL FRAUD

3

Page 4: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Purchasing card used in an inappropriate manner

• Took money from a school cash fund

• Cash from student parking passes, the sale of replacement student planners, and parent cash donations—all kept in a “zippered pouch near” the principal’s office

Alleged Theft by School Principal

4

Page 5: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Prosecutors assert the money was used for:

• $7,932 for Cutco knife sets

• $539 Bod-e BURN drinks

• $252 for iTunes gift cards

• $1,149 for iPad and iTunes gift cards

• $357 for softball equipment

• $363 for tools

Alleged Theft by School Principal

5

Page 6: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

QuestionHow do you think this principal

was able to commit fraud?

6

Page 7: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

What Can You Do?Establish a Strong System

of Internal Control

7

Page 8: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Internal control is “a process, effected by an entity’s board of directors, management and other personnel, designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the achievement of objectives in the following categories:

• Effectiveness and efficiency of operations

• Reliability of financial reporting

• Compliance with applicable laws and regulations.”

Internal Control Definition

8

Page 9: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Internal Control

9

Page 10: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Integrity and ethical values

• Parameters for governing body’s oversight

• Assignment of authority and responsibility

• Process for attracting, developing and retaining competent individuals

Control Environment

10

Page 11: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Possibility an event will occur and adversely affect the achievement of objectives

• Cannot eliminate risk completely

• Estimating the likelihood and frequency of occurrence

Risk Assessment

11

Page 12: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Methods used to reduce risk

• Control activities are:

• Tools – both manual and automated

• Policies and procedures

• Preventive or detective

Control Activities

12

Page 13: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Enables the organization to share relevant and quality information

• Facilitates the sharing of information up, down and across the entity

Information and Communication

13

Page 14: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Ongoing assessments of whether controls are in place and working as designed

Monitoring

14

Page 15: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Breakdown in Internal Control

Increases Opportunity for Fraud

15

Page 16: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

FraudAn Overview

16

Page 17: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Fraud is the use of one’s occupation for personal enrichment through the deliberatemisuse or misapplication of the employing

organization’s resources or assets.

Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) Definition

17

Page 18: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

18

Rationalization

Incentive

(Pressure!)

Fraud Triangle

Opportunity

Page 19: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Behaviors are logically justified

• Examples include:

• “I get no respect and I will get even.”

• “Joe makes more money than I do and I have more experience.”

• “I only got a 2% raise this year – everybody else got more.”

Rationalization

19

Page 20: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Something that motivates someone to commit fraud

• Examples of incentives include:

• Financial stress – Unpaid medical bills

• Addictions – Gambling, drug, alcohol

• Pathologies – Intellectual challenge

Incentive

20

Page 21: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Not only permits fraud to occur, but actually promotes it

• Lack of sound and comprehensive framework of internal controls

Opportunity

21

Page 22: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Asset Misappropriation

• Corruption

• Financial Statement Fraud

Three Fraud Categories

22

Page 23: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Theft of cash

• False billing schemes (e.g., fake invoices)

• Inflated expense reports

Asset MisappropriationExamples

23

Page 24: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Kickbacks to purchasing agent or elected official

• Bid rigging (government gives preference to one bidder; makes it appear that bidding occurred when it did not)

• Gratuities (favors or gifts provided to government official for particular actions)

Corruption Examples

24

Page 25: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Employee calling in sick when they are well

• Employees driving public vehicles for personal purposes

• Employees making excessive personal phone calls during work

• Employees using government-owned equipment at home

Abuse Examples

25

Page 26: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

QuestionWhich category of fraud

do you think is the largest?

26

Page 27: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

2016 ACFE Fraud Survey

27

Page 28: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Average Life of Fraud Before Detection:

18 Months

28

Page 29: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Misconceptions about Controls and Audits

• Segregation of Duties

• A Simple Segregation of Duties Test

• Whistleblower Programs

General Fraud Prevention

29

Page 30: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Clean audit opinion does not mean no fraud

• Audit determine if financial statements are fairly presented

• Internal controls considered for audit procedures performed

• Internal control may have weakness that goes undetected that might lead to fraud

Misconceptions

30

Page 31: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

No one person should perform the following duties:

Custody of Assets

Reconciliations

Authorization

Bookkeeping

Segregate the Following Duties

31

Page 32: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Segregation Test

32

Custody

- E. Johnson

Reconciliation- I. Cheatum

Authorization- I. Cheatum

Bookkeeping- Suzy Que

Page 33: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

QuestionWhat is the most common

method of detecting fraud?

33

Page 34: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Tips

34

2016 ACFE Fraud Survey

Page 35: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Signs of Fraud –General

35

Page 36: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Unexplained increases in wealth

• Employee personal problems

• Employee living beyond his means

• Unusually close relationships with vendors

External Red Flags of Fraud

36

Page 37: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Signs of Fraud and Controls – Payroll

37

Page 38: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Employee with Little or No Payroll Deductions

• Excessive Overtime Expenses

• Excessive Payroll Expenses When Compared to Budget

Payroll Red Flags

38

Page 39: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Employee A retires but remains in payroll system

• Payroll clerk changes Employee A’s direct deposit number to his own bank account number

• Employee A’s payroll is processed each week, the direct deposit goes to payroll clerk’s personal bank account

Ghost Employee Example

39

Page 40: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Department head inflates his friend's hours worked and signs off on the departmental hours worked

• Payroll clerk inflates her pay rate in the master pay rate file

Inflating Pay Rateand Hours Worked

40

Page 41: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Compare salaries to budget

• Compare salaries to prior year

• Immediately remove terminated employees from payroll system

• Review number of employees regularly paid

• Compare pay rates in computer to approved rates in personnel file

• Review recurring gross salary and hourly payments for reasonableness

Payroll Controls

41

Page 42: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Signs of Fraud and Controls –

Disbursements

42

Page 43: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Altered or Incomplete Supporting Documentation for Disbursements

• Purchasing Party (e.g., Department Head) Picking Up Processed Checks

• Unexplained Increases in Expenses

• Excessive Expenses When Compared to Budget

Disbursements and Purchasing Red Flags

43

Page 44: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Vendor gives $4,000 to a school purchasing clerk (as a bribe)

• The purchasing clerk awards the contract to vendor

• Vendor inflates invoices by $10,000 and provides an inferior product to the school

Bribery Example

44

Page 45: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list

• The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that of vendor

• The accounts payable clerk creates a fictitious invoice and then enters the invoice into the accounts payable module

• Check is processed and mailed to AP clerk

Fictitious Vendor Example

45

Page 46: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Accounts payable clerk sets up a bank account in the name of fictitious vendor

• She is the sole authorized check signer

• She deposits the check from the school

• She writes checks from the fictitiousvendor bank account to herself

Fictitious Vendor Example

46

Page 47: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Require two persons to complete external wire transfers

• If wire is by phone or fax, require bank to call back before transfer is made

• Limit personnel with wire capability and do not share passwords

Wire Transfer Controls

47

Page 48: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Require second person approval of the journal entry used to record the wire transfer

• Use all bank-provided wire transfer controls (if not, school may be liable)

Wire Transfer Controls

48

Page 49: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Signs of Fraud and Controls – Capital

Assets

49

Page 50: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• All Contractors Submit Consistently High Bids

• Qualified Contractors Not Submitting Bids

• Reports of Missing Capital Assets

• A Lack of Accountability for Capital Assets

Capital Asset Red Flags

50

Page 51: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Create a bid policy

• Require sealed bids for all amounts over your government's threshold

• Open sealed bids in a public meeting

• Request bids from multiple companies

• For major construction projects, hire a construction monitor

Capital Asset Controls

51

Page 52: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Signs of Fraud and Controls – Cash

Receipts

52

Page 53: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Always use a pre-numbered receipt when possible

• Keep cash in a secure location accessible by limited staff

• Make deposits daily or at least weekly depending on amount on hand

Cash Receipts Overview

53

Page 54: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• No two people should work from one cash drawer

• Create receipts immediately • Restrictively endorse (For Deposit Only)

checks• Personal checks (including employee

checks) should not be cashed from cash drawers

• Balance cash and checks with receipts or report of transactions (such as lunches sold)• Supervisor should review cash deposit and

supporting documentation

Cash Drawer Safety

54

Page 55: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

Closing Comments

55

Page 56: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

• Fraud comes in many forms; today we have covered some examples of frauds and related controls

• If you encounter fraud, report using your school protocol

• Be aware of your role in preventing and detecting fraud

Closing Comments

56

Page 57: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

57

Page 58: Safeguarding Against Fraud · • Accounts payable clerk adds a fictitious vendor to the vendor list • The accounts payable clerk enters her own address (or a P.O. box) as that

© 2017 The Carl Vinson Institute of Government. All rights reserved.