sector: west coast rock lobster nearshore zone a rights allocation... · department of agriculture,...

Department of Agriculture, Forestry and

Private Bag

Roggebaai,

Score Sheet

Sector: West Coast Rock Lobster Nearshore Zone A

Application Number: WCNA15303

Delegated Authority Delegated Authority

D. Improperly A. Was the Application

Was your right or permit

revoked, cancelled, reduced or

under section 28 of the MLRA during

long-term right

Was the Application Submitted

Was application fee

Applicant form was submitted on time

Application fee was paid B.

Has the Application been Signed

the Commissioner of

No catch within Zone A. Average score of 0

allocated because of late rights transfer Complete the table below in relation

the applicant’s catch records in the

applying

C. Essential

Are you a South African

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Exclusionary

West Coast Rock Lobster Nearshore Zone Form

Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight

Applicant JOHANNA ID

Unsuccessful


Private Bag

Roggebaai,

50.00 15.00

100.00 15.00

100.00 15.00

100.00 20.00

100.00 20.00

100.00 15.00

100.00 0.00

25.00 0.00

100.00 100.00

100.00 10.00

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Comparative

Delegated # Criteria

Authority Score(%)

Delegated Authority

Section 1 Application Details Maximum Weight(%): 10.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

How many years have you lived and / or worked in the

How many years has the applicant been involved in the fishing

In what capacity have you been involved in the Fishing sector you

applying

What work are you currently involved

Section 2 Form of Applicant Maximum Weight(%): 10.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

If "Yes," in “2.1”complete the table below for all fishing rights allocated

the

Did you derive income from any other sources other than fisheries

respect of the financial year which end on any date between 1 July

and 30 June 2015? If "Yes", complete the table

Section 3 Compliance Maximum Weight(%): 20.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

Have you been charged with an offence under the MLRA, or

regulations or permit conditions during the long-term right


Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight



Private Bag

Roggebaai,

100.00 20.00

100.00 30.00

100.00 30.00

100.00 10.00

50.00 0.00

50.00 0.00

50.00 0.00

100.00 0.00

50.00 0.00

100.00 35.00

100.00 25.00

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Comparative


Authority Score(%)

Delegated Authority

Have you entered into a plea bargain under the Criminal Procedure Act

of 1977, for a contravention of the MLRA, or the regulations, or

conditions since

Have you been convicted of a contravention of the MLRA, or

regulations, or permit conditions during the long-term right

Have you paid an admission of guilt fine for a contravention of the

the regulations, or the permit conditions during the long-term right

Has your fishing vessel, motor vehicle, premises or any of the

assets been detained, arrested or seized under the MLRA or

preserved, confiscated or forfeited under the Prevention of

Crime Act 121 of 1998 during the long-term right period since

Compensation for Occupational Injuries & Diseases Act 130 of

Occupational Health & Safety Act 85 of

Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of

Marine Living Resources Act 18 of

Customs & Excise Act 91 of

Section 4 Access to a suitable vessel Maximum Weight(%): 20.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

Does the applicant own a suitable vessel (>50%

Does the applicant have a 50% ownership in a suitable


Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight



Private Bag

Roggebaai,

100.00 25.00

100.00 15.00

100.00 0.00

100.00 0.00

0.00 100.00

0.00 0.00

0.00 0.00

33.33 0.00

50.00 0.00

10.00 50.00

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Comparative


Authority Score(%)

Delegated Authority

Does the applicant have part-ownership in a suitable vessel

Does the applicant have an access agreement in a suitable vessel

catch agreement, charter agreement, or bank

Does the applicant consider building a

Section 5 Fishing Performance Maximum Weight(%): 35.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

Did you utilise its fishing right for at least five years during the period

to 2014(2005 to 2013 for

Complete the table below in relation to the applicant’s catch records in

sector applying

No catch within Zone A. Average score of 0 allocated because of late rights transfer

Section 6 Transformation Maximum Weight(%): 0.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

Does the applicant make donations of the annual taxable income

qualify for deduction in terms of section 18A of the Income Tax Act 58

Does the applicant procure goods / services from majority black

Complete the table below in respect to harbours where catch has

landed and

Complete the table below in respect to harbours where catch is to

landed and processed. Rank by order of usage from 1 – 3 (3 being

Section 7 Job Creation Maximum Weight(%): 5.00 Score(%) attained by applicant:

Does the applicant provide permanent employment? If "yes", complete

table below in respect of the financial year which ends on any

between 1 July 2014 and 30 June


Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight



Private Bag

Roggebaai,

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Comparative

Authority

Delegated Authority

Complete the following table in relation to the applicants employees as

28 February

10.00

50.00

Do you contribute towards medical aid or any kind of medical

arrangement for more that 50% of your

50.00

0.00

Do you contribute towards pension/provident fund for more that 50%

your

50.00

0.00

Do you provide all your employees with safe working conditions at

100.00

0.00

Do you provide any other kinds of benefits for your employees

employee share

50.00

0.00


Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight



Private Bag

Roggebaai,

Outcome: Unsuccessful

Delegated Authority Comment:

04-Aug-2017 of 6

Comparative

Authority

Delegated Authority


Application

Delegated

SIPHOKAZI

11 Apr

Weight


sector: west coast rock lobster nearshore zone a rights allocation... · department of agriculture,...

Documents