september 2–3, 2004 royal sonesta hotel new orleans new orleans, la state of the business process...
TRANSCRIPT
September 2–3, 2004Royal Sonesta Hotel New OrleansNew Orleans, LA
State of the Business Process Outsourcing(BPO) Industry
September 3rd, 2004
2
Mark B. Hodges – Chairman & [email protected]; 281-733-0263
EquaTerra – co-founded the first sourcing lifecycle management company. Assists clients in the assessment of internal transformation (e.g. shared services) vs. external BPO including Outsourcing Centers of Excellence.
Exult – played key executive roles in creating the first comprehensive, global HR and F&A outsourcing company. TPI – founded and led their BPO practice. GartnerGroup – advised emerging and mature BPO and ITO services companies. G2 Research – advised companies on commercialization of their business functions into outsourcing companies.
3
EquaTerra Overview
We support the G & A process improvement lifecycle…
Knowledge & Knowledge & EducationEducation
Knowledge & Knowledge & EducationEducation
Strategy & Strategy & AssessmentAssessment
Strategy & Strategy & AssessmentAssessment
Insource or Insource or OutsourceOutsourceAdvisoryAdvisory
Insource or Insource or OutsourceOutsourceAdvisoryAdvisory
GovernanceGovernanceGovernanceGovernance
G & A Processes - Human Resources, Finance & Accounting, Information Technology, Procurement, CRM
Across Industries - Manufacturing, Consumer Products, Utilities, Energy, Financial Services, Healthcare, Public Sector, etc.
4
Content Overview
Why are Corporations Signing BPO Contracts?
State of the BPO Market
A Pragmatic Approach for Evaluating BPO for your Company
Realizing the BPO Business Case: Governance
5
Why are Corporations Signing BPO Contracts?
6
Lack of resources and focus for process improvement
Shareholders and stock price pressures
Lack of capital for ERP investments
Change: M&A, divestitures, contraction, growth
Focus on value added, business partner activities
The denominator (# of employees) keeps getting smaller
Regulatory pressures
BPO Demand Catalysts
7
What are the Alternatives to BPO? Continue course of existing services with additional cost reduction:
• reduction of people and administrative products and processes• service improvement within corporate staff functions and • “captive” offshoring
Continue opportunistic outsourcing with individual process providers
Substantial investment in technology to further enable MSS and ESS and reduce G&A FTEs
Change G&A functional grades and pay structure and benefits structure (market-based vs industry-based)
Do nothing
Comprehensive BPO
8
Systems
Administration
Consultative
Governance
Legend: = Client = BPO Provider
Process Examples
Strategy Governance Policy Decisions
Expertise Development Reengineering Innovation
Systems Technology Transactions Infrastructure
Operations Administration Execution Context
= Collaborative
Process Layers
In-Scope Functions for BPO | Exiting the Administrative Transactions Business
Finance & Accounting
Human Resources
ProcurementInformation Technology
Other
9
Guaranteed cost savings on 7-10 year contract
Cost savings of 15% - 25% vs. existing baseline costs
BPO provider funds transition costs for in-scope processes
Provider makes investments in ERP technology and other technology applications
Savings can be front loaded or begin after the transition of each process
BPO provider often assumes employee and process costs post transition of each process
BPO provider takes responsibility for IT personnel, systems hosting and ongoing maintenance costs
Client retains ERP license costs
Overall implementation timeframe often 12-24 months faster than internal transformation
The BPO Value Proposition is Compelling
10
State of the BPO Market
The HR Function | 23 Processes
Compensation Benefits (DC,
DB, H&W) Payroll Travel &
Expense
Compensation,
Benefits & Rewards
Data Records and Management
HRIT/HRIS Employee &
Manager Self Service
Workforce Analytics
Employee Data Management
Recruiting, Staffing & Resourcing
Expatriate Administration
Domestic Relocation
Workforce Deployment
Severance Administration
Workforce Planning & Deployment
HR Strategy Labor &
Employee Relations
3rd Party Vendor Management
Employee Communications
Policy & Legal Compliance
Human Capital
Services
Organizational &
People Development
Organizational Development
Performance Management
Training Employee
Development Succession
Planning
12
HR – What Can be Outsourced?
“Consultative” Activities
“Strategic” Activities
Standardization/Efficiency/Defined Service
Management Involvement/Knowledge Transfer
SpecificDivision/Location
Generic/Companywide
• Site specific policy development
• Site specific employee relations
• Substance Abuse Testing
• Vendor Management
• Learning Administration
• ESC and Tier 0/1 Inquiries
• Severance/Outplacement
• Payroll and T&E Administration
• Relocation/Expatriate Admin.
• Compensation Administration
• Benefit Administration
• HRIS/HRIT & Data/Records
• Staffing Administration
• Organizational Development
• Compensation Design
• Benefits Design
• Learning Development
• Succession Planning
• Performance Management
• Staffing Policy and Tools
• Communications Development
• HR Strategy
• Workforce Planning
• Talent Management
• Labor Relations
• Policy & Legal Compliance
“Transactional” Activities
13
Since 1999, Many Corporations Have Adopted HRO American Express (Mellon)
Avaya BASF (Mellon) AT&T Bank of America Bank of Montreal BC Hydro British Aerospace British Petroleum British Telecom Cable & Wireless CIBC Circuit City Dynegy Equifax Fifth Third Bancorp (Convergys) Fleet Boston Gateway
Goldman Sachs GE General Motors Goodyear IBM International Paper Lincoln National Lockheed Martin (Mellon) McKesson Medco Motorola Procter & Gamble Prudential Financial Rohm & Haas Sony Telecom Italia Unisys Williams
14
The Universe of Potential HRO Providers
AON
Arinso
Deloitte
Fidelity (FESCO)
Hewitt
IBM
Mellon
Spherion
SnHRgy
Towers Perrin
Xchanging
Offshore Players
Private Equity Firms
ACS
ExultAccenture
EDS
15
The Finance & Accounting Function 33 Processes
Accounts Payable
Accounts Receivable
Travel & Expense Reporting
Leases Credit
Transaction Managemen
t
General Ledger Accounting
Revenue/ Cost Accounting
Debt/ Equity Accounting
Statutory Accounting
Business Unit Accounting
General Accounting
Tax Compliance & Planning
Reverse Audits
Tax Consulting & Compliance
Financial Accounting & Reporting
ERP or Financial System
Financial Reporting &
Data
Policies & Procedures
Controls & Design
Controls Implementation
Internal Audit Services
BusinessContinuity Planning
Business Process Risk Assessment
Risk Managemen
t
Transaction Analysis
Exception Reporting & Resolution
Financial Analysis
Operating Budgets
Capital Investments
Treasury Functions
Debt Equity Financing
Cash Management
Performance Analysis
Financial Management
16
Standardization/Efficiency/Defined Service
Management InvolvementKnowledge Transfer
SpecificDivision/Location
Generic/Companywide
• Inventory Accounting
• Cost/Plant Accounting
• Sales/Marketing Accounting
• Site specific analysis
• Project accounting
• Senior Finance Management
• Financial Analysis
• Financial Planning
• Management Reporting
• Budgeting/Forecasting
• Credit Policy
• Accounts Payable
• Travel and Entertainment
• Fixed Asset Accounting
• Accounts Receivable/Collection
• General Accounting
• Payroll Processing
• Employee Administration
• Cash Application
• Banking and Cash Management
• Billing
• Tax Compliance/Planning
• Internal Audit
• Banking
• Risk Management
• Treasury Management
• External & Statutory Reporting
Methods of Adding ValueMethods of Adding ValueMethods of Adding ValueMethods of Adding Value
Process Process CharacteristicsCharacteristics
Process Process CharacteristicsCharacteristics
F&A Services | What Should be Retained?
17
Leading F&A BPO Providers
Accenture
ACS
Cap GeminiErnst & Young
Creditek
Deloitte Consulting
EDS
Exult
EquitantEquitant
GE
OPI PwC (IBM)
SourceNet Solutions
Unisys
Xansa
HP
18
F&A BPO Providers | New Entrants
Perot Systems
Ephinay
EXL
WNS
HP
19
A Pragmatic Approach to Evaluating BPO For
Your Business
20
STAGE 3Bid Evaluation,
Negotiation and Transition
(6 – 8 weeks)
A Staged Approach | Stages 1, 2 & 3
Get these right, the first time . . .
STAGE 2Relationship Development
and Structuring
(8 – 10 weeks)
STAGE 1Analysis, Education,
RFI and Sourcing Strategy
(4 – 6 weeks)
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Analysis of Costs and Processes
• Education
• Sourcing Strategy
• RFI or RFP
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Statements of Work
• Service Levels and Volumetrics
• Financial Analysis
• Develop Business Case
• Pricing
• Governance and RM Design
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Distribute RFP
• Visits by BPO providers
• Reference site visits
• Negotiations
• Governance and RM Build and Implementation
• Transition Planning
21
STAGE 3Bid Evaluation,
Negotiation and Transition
(6 – 8 weeks)
A Staged Approach | Stages 4, 5 & 6
Design with the end in mind . . .
STAGE 2Relationship Development
and Structuring
(8 – 10 weeks)
STAGE 1Analysis, Education,
RFI and Sourcing Strategy
(4 – 6 weeks)
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Analysis of Costs and Processes
• Education
• Sourcing Strategy
• RFI or RFP
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Statements of Work
• Service Levels and Volumetrics
• Financial Analysis
• Develop Business Case
• Pricing
• Governance and RM Design
JOINT ACTIVITIES
• Distribute RFP
• Visits by BPO providers
• Reference site visits
• Negotiations
• Governance and RM Build and Implementation
• Transition Planning
22
Future State Service Delivery
Future State Service Delivery
Current Service Levels &
Volumetrics
EquaTerraKnowledge & Tool
Sets
Future State – Initial Design
BPOProviders – RFI or RFP Approach
ERP Best Practice Maps
Internal Costs & FTE Baselines
Key Inputs
Determining Best Practice Service Delivery for BPO
Inte
rnal
Exte
rnal
23
The Definitive BPO Checklist
Statement of Work (process maps, documented activities, future state)
Service Levels, Methodology and Service Level Agreement
Financial Model (5-10 year projection)
Schedules (e.g. existing 3rd party contracts)
List of Likely G&A BPO Providers
Pricing and Charging Units
Exhibits (e.g. in-scope countries, personnel)
Sourcing Strategy
Service Contract and Business Terms
Service Delivery Management
Contract Management
Governance
Financial Management
Pre-RFP
RFP
Governance &
Relationship
Management
24
BPO is growing in other functional areas across all major industry segments
11.7%CAGR
Communi-cation
Distribution
Financial Services
Energy &
Industrial
Public
Sectors Opportunity2004
$5 $10 $15 $20 $25
F&A
HR
Proc.
CRM
Solution Areas Opportunity2004
Billions
Source: IBM analysis based on multiple industry sources (Gartner, Dataquest, IDC, AMR)
$10
$20
$30
$40
$37.9B,12% CAGR
$8.9B,15% CAGR
$20.1B,13% CAGR
$21.3B, 15% CAGR
$12.4B
$12.0B
$24.4B
$17.6B
$23.1B
25
. . . as more leading corporations adopt BPO
F&A
AFC EnterprisesAirgasANZ BankAT&T Wireless CompaqCiscoFox MediaHewlett PackardHome DepotIngersoll RandMicrosoftVivendi
HR
BASFCable and
WirelessCelaneseCIBCFifth ThirdGoldmanGoodyearIBMMcKessonSonyState of FloridaUnisysUnited Healthcare
IT outsourcing has been in existence since the late 80’s, and is not listed separately. It is included in most of the agreements across areas.
IT, F&A and HR (Two or More)
Bank of AmericaBank of MontrealBarclay’s BankBC HydroBritish
AerospaceBritish
PetroleumBritish TelecommDynegyEquifaxGatewayGeneral MotorsGE
International Paper
LucentMRGMotorolaNortelProcter &
GamblePrudential
FinancialRoyal Dutch
ShellTelecomm ItaliaThomas Cook
26
Max
imiz
ing
Cos
t Sav
ings
Service Delivery Model
In-Scope Employees
Technology
Scope - # of Processes
Scope - % of Processes
• Standard • Tailored
• Terminated • Transitioned
• Provider Site • Client Site
• > 10 • < 5
• 75% • < 50%
30% - 50%Annual Run
Rate SavingsKey Factor
10% - 20% Annual
Run Rate Savings
Location• Multi-shore • Onshore
Max
imiz
ing
Org
aniz
atio
nal C
omfo
rt
BPO Sourcing Strategy – Sample Decision Set
27
Leading G&A BPO Providers
Comprehensive
• Accenture• ACS• CGEY*• Hewlett Packard*• IBM (PwC)• Perot Systems*
F&A
• Accenture• ACS• CGEY• Hewlett Packard• IBM (PwC)• Perot Systems
HR
• Accenture• ACS• CGEY*• Hewlett Packard*• IBM (PwC)• Perot Systems*
IT
• Accenture*• ACS• CGEY• Hewlett Packard• IBM (PwC)• Perot Systems
• Deloitte• Ephinay• Equitant• OPI• Sourcenet• Unisys• WNS• Xansa
• Aon• Arinso• Convergys• EDS• Exult• Fidelity (FESCO)• Hewitt• Mellon • SynHRgy
(Mercer)
• CSC• EDS• Infosys• Keane• SAIC• Satyam• Unisys• Wipro
* “Comprehensive” servicescould be delivered withan existing partner
28
Improved Quality
Decreased Concentration Risk
Dramatic Cost Savings
Time Compression and Multiple Shifts
Top Global Talent
Resource Flexibility
Closer Location and Access to Global Markets
What Customers are Finding: Offshore BPO
29
180 Day Project Plan K
ey
Act
ivit
ies
Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3
Analysis of Costs & Processes
• Validate Phase I results• FTEs• Indirect & Direct Costs• Sub-processes• Projected Investments
Education• Governance & Relationship Management (RM) Reqs• Retained processes• Retained organization• Internal improvement opportunities.• RFI Process
Sourcing Strategy• Single vs. multiple providers• Selective vs. comprehensive• Intelligence on BPO providers• Business Terms• Sole source or competitive bid
Statements of Work• Accounts Payable• Payroll• Accounts Receivable• Travel & Expense Reimburs.
Service Levels• Current• Target (internal vs. external)
Financial Analysis• Economic factors• Productivity factors• 5 – 10 year projection
Develop Business Case• Cost savings• Process improvement• Tangible & Intangible
Pricing• Fixed vs. variable• Output-based pricing
Governance & RM Design
Distribute RFP• To qualified BPO providers• Based on Sourcing Strategy
Visits by HRO providers• Preliminary evaluation• Shortlist determination• Preliminary negotiation
Reference Site Visits• 3-5 customer visits
Negotiations• Final business terms• Final legal terms• Final negotiation
Governance & RM Build & Implementation
Transition Planning
Analysis, Education and Sourcing Strategy
(Months 1 & 2)
RFP Development and Pricing
(Months 3 & 4)
Bid Evaluation & Negotiation
(Months 5 & 6)
30
BPO: Realizing the Business Case
Key Characteristics for BPO Success Common Pitfalls in the BPO Process Governance & Relationship Management Key Market Terms and Conditions
31
Key Characteristics for BPO SuccessAppropriate use of RFI and/or RFP with competitive process
Excellent change management as well as internal and external communications
Commitment from executive leadership with a strategic imperative to act
Strong governance design and implementation
Executive sponsor is personally involved and passionate
Business objectives are clearly understood and internal interests are aligned
A firm timeline (or willingness to set a firm deadline)
Precise understanding of internal cost
Resources have been identified, empowered and budgeted including internal resources and expert external advisor and legal
Agnostic as to “how” and “where” BPO is performed (focus on “what”)
Processes have undergone conceptual “future state” reengineering
Emphasis on a long term relationship not the “transaction”
Collaborative approach to the process and negotiations
32
Common Pitfalls in the BPO Process
Decision criteria and their relative importance are poorly defined such as price points, provider qualifications, etc.
Poor design and implementation of governance and retained organizations
Internal approval levels and process are unclear
Potential providers are permitted to bypass the process and communications protocol
Focus is on first/second years savings rather than on balanced short/long term benefits
Potential providers are used to frame the requirements and the sourcing process
Reliance on future negotiations to re-position the deal
Over-reliance on “free” providers’ advice, assessments and RFP development
Choice of commercial model disconnected from change drivers
Shortcuts are taken to expedite the deal
33
CONTRACT MANAGEMENT
PROCESS
RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT
TOOLS
Outsourcing Governance | Maximizing the Value of BPO
PEOPLE
Financial Administration
Customer Care Monitoring Communications
Governance Protocols Corporate Standards and Policy
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
Satisfaction Planning
Driving Value
Costs Compliance Competitive
SERVICE DELIVERY MANAGEMENT Service Provider
Performance Program Management Internal Services
Informed DecisionsEffective Execution
34
Contract Management | 12 Processes
Facing Service Providers and Business Units
CONTRACT MANAGEMENT
TOOLSPEOPLE
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
Controlled Costs ConsistentCompliance
FinancialPayments Invoice VerificationService Provider paymentsCharge BackAnalysis & PlanningForecasting & TrackingConsumption AnalysisFinancial Compliance
AdministrationContract Change Control &
DocumentationInternal Controls & ReviewBenchmarking & Competitive AnalysisThird Party Vendor Contracts
PROCESS
Informed DecisionsEffective Execution
Coordination and
Collaboration
35
Relationship Management | 9 Processes
Facing Service Providers and Business Units
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
PROCESS
TOOLSPEOPLE
Informed DecisionsEffective Execution
Satisfaction Planning
Driving Value
Controlled CostsConsistentCompliance
Coordination and
Collaboration
PROCESS
RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
Governance Protocols Decision Rights Steering Committee(s) Issue Management Corporate Standards & Policy
Customer Care MonitoringCommunicationsPlanning & Review (Monthly, Quarterly, Annual)Renegotiation & New Services
36
Service Delivery Management | 11 Processes
Facing Service Providers and Business Units
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
TOOLSPEOPLE
Controlled CostsConsistentCompliance
Coordination and
Collaboration
ENTERPRISECAPABILITY
PROCESS
InformedDecisionsEffective
Executions
Service Provider PerformanceBreach Tracking & MonitoringNotification & ReportingProblem Escalation & Resolution
Program ManagementForecasting & BudgetingWork Initiation & AuthorizationProject MonitoringNotification & Reporting
Internal ServicesSecurity ManagementBusiness Continuity ManagementConsumption Advisory ServicesRegulatory Compliance
SERVICE DELIVERY MANAGEMENT
37
Effective Contracting | Key Terms & Conditions Strong governance and relationship management Key client control rights and approvals
Key service provider personnel Service provider actions that could negatively impact the business Key subcontractors Software that is introduced into the client’s environment Notification when the location of service provision is changed
Right to use 3rd parties – non-exclusive Termination rights
Change of control Convenience Cause (with known & minimal costs)
Financial performance credits Continuous improvement of service levels each year Meaningful benchmarking & performance reviews