som sears fazlur kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 sears, the bundled tube …with belt...

56
Sears Tower Fazlur Kahn and the Bundled Tube SOM

Upload: others

Post on 15-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

Sears Tower

Fazlur Kahn and the Bundled Tube SOM

Page 2: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

2

Watch seller to biggest retailer in 100 years

Page 3: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

3

Sears, the bundled

tube…with belt trusses

Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world

Ü  1969 Sam Walton incorporates as WalMart

Ü  2005 Sears bought by Kmart

Ü  1990 Trizec REIT buys Sears Tower

Sears Tower

Page 4: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

4

Lower floors for Sears, upper floors rental

Ü 11,250 s.f. per floor

Ü 28,125 s.f. per floor

Ü 39,375 s.f. per floor

Ü 50,625 s.f. per floor Ü  Needed 279,000 s.f.

Page 5: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

5

No setbacks required

Ü  4.65 million square feet gross

Ü  3.81 million square feet net rentable

Ü  81/19 ratio of net to gross, very efficient

Page 6: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

6

What bonds the tubes together?

Ü  9 tubes, each 75’ square

Page 7: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

7

1974 Sears Tower

Ü  1,400 feet to roof

Ü  1,738 feet to antenna tip

Ü  4 belts, no suspenders

Page 8: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

8

Down 100’ to go up 1,400’

Ü  200 caissons down to bedrock below lowest sub-basement

Ü  August 1970 excavation begins

Ü  June 1971 Steel setting begins

Page 9: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

9

Digital Design 1969

Ü  Build time August 1970 - May 1973

Ü  1,005 days, or 143 weeks to build 110 floors, 1.3 floors per week, 4,626 s.f./day!

Ü  Steel set two floors per week

Page 10: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

10

Ü  Tubes 75 feet on a side, 5,625 foot clear areas

Ü  Columns 15 feet on center

Page 11: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

11

Trusses like WTC

Page 12: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

12

•  Field connections in shear zone

•  Shop welding for moment connections

•  Reduced possible field welds by 95%

Page 13: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

13

Composite structure, truss floor

Page 14: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

14

Below centerline for beam / slab eccentricity

Page 15: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

15

Page 16: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

16

Built up from plates

Page 17: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

17

Page 18: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

18

Page 19: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

19

Page 20: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

20

Ü Field connections in shear zone

Ü Shop welding for moment connections

Ü Reduced possible field welds by 95%

Page 21: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

21

Page 22: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

22

Page 23: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

23

Page 24: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

24

Belting Bundled Tubes

Page 25: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

25

Page 26: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

26

Page 27: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

27

Almost done

Ü  Topped out May 3 1973

Ü  Over 12,000 people signed the last beam, Ü  Sears employees Ü  Construction crew Ü  Citizens

Ü  All wanted to be part of history

Page 28: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

28

Page 29: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

29

Page 30: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

30

Kenmore?

Page 31: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

31

Page 32: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

32

…meanwhile back in New

York… Ü  1966 WTC project planning

begins

Ü  Construction completed 1973, just behind Sears

Ü  Owner: Port Authority of NY & NJ

Ü  Builder, Tishman Realty and Construction

Ü  Architect, Minoru Yamasaki

Ü  Structural: Leslie Robertson

Page 33: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

33

Page 34: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

34

Skylobby elevator strategy

Ü  Double deck elevators

Ü  Three double decks in most shafts - 6 cabs per shaft

Page 35: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

35

Page 36: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

36

A complicated excavation slows progress

Page 37: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

37

Holding back the street

Page 38: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

38

Billet and Grillage

Ü  Like the Empire State Building the WTC columns sat upon a steel plate, steel beams on a concrete base

Page 39: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

39

Custom Columns

Ü  Normal for super-tall building Ü  Built up out of

5” thick steel plate

Ü  Not “off the shelf”

Page 40: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

40

Triple Trees

Ü  Sears columns 15’ o.c.

Ü WTC columns 3’4” o.c.

Ü  Prefab as triples to reduce field connections

Page 41: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

41

Page 42: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

42

Longspan trusses

Ü Sears span 75 feet

Ü WTC span 60 feet Ü Hard to cover with

spray on fire protection

Ü  Bottom tab for viscoelastic damper, 10,000 used to keep sway between 6 and 15 milli-g’s, their tested threshold of human perception

Page 43: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

43

Trusses tied to slab

through top chord loops

Page 44: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

44

Page 45: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

45

Page 46: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

46

51 ton tree columns

Page 47: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

47

Page 48: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

48

Trees adapt 3’4” spacing for entrance purposes

Page 49: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

49

Page 50: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

50

Page 51: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

51

Climbing Corner Cranes

Ü  OA 207’ sq

Ü  42,849 s.f. per fl

Ü  87’ core

Ü  60’ spans each side

Page 52: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

52

Ü Kangaroo Cranes Ü Named for

jumping floors as steel was set

Ü  60 foot reach

Ü  50 ton capacity

Page 53: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

53

Ü Set three floors of triple tree wall every ten days

Ü 3,600 people per day onsite at peak

Page 54: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

54

All floor, little core

Ü  1999 publication cites design was engineered to resist impact of 707 and 747 marsden and whiteman, 1999 p231

Page 55: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

55

Page 56: SOM SEARS Fazlur Kahn - mjobrienarchitect · 2018-06-20 · 3 Sears, the bundled tube …with belt trusses Ü 1969, Sears is largest retailer in the world Ü 1969 Sam Walton incorporates

56

The family of supertalls Sears will be 6th