Power Query vs. SSIS

Which one is the most powerful ?

SQLSaturday Rheinland 201428.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Organizer

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

You Rock! Sponsor

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Gold Sponsor

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Silver Sponsor

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Bronze Sponsor and Media Partner

28.06.2014

The SQL Server community (in France)

Webcasts, Conférences, Afterworks

.Pro

Next event : SQLSaturday Paris 2014September 13thTour Montparnasse, Paris

Jean-Pierre RiehlPractice Manager Data & BI – AZEO

MVP SQL ServerPresident at GUSS

David JoubertSenior BI Consultant - CellenzaMVP SQL ServerVP at GUSS

Who we are ?

SSIS

Champion

Power Query Champion

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Disclaimer

This session is an informal comparison between tools

This session isn’t : An exhaustive comparison A “how-to” or a “Best Practices” session

Each of us will be proud of his tool So, we will be dishonest

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Disclaimer

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSFXTrMzg58

28.06.2014

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Let’s Go !

28.06.2014

demo

Summary

SSIS Power Query

Application Logic OK KO

Data Sources OK OK

Transformation OK OK

Destinations OK KO

Execution OK KO

Winner SSIS

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

But…

28.06.2014

SSIS Power Query

Extensibility OK KO

Easiness / Learning KO OK

Real-time / WYSYWIG KO OK

Performances OK KO

Collaboration KO OK

Winner Power Query

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

A matter of Philosophy

SSIS : « aimed to industrialize data integration focusing on development and scalability »

Power Query : « aimed to help end users to create and share easily self-service ETL »

28.06.2014

Business User• Document centric• Exploration• Real-time, WYSYWYG• Easy to learn• Collaborative

Developer• IDE / Source Control• Extensibility• Fine tuning• Automation

SQLSaturday Rheinland 2014

Thank you!for sponsorshipfor volunteeringfor participation

for a great SQLSaturday #313

28.06.2014