squeezed light in present and future gw observatories · alexander khalaidovski squeezed light in...

55
Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski for the AEI Quantum Interferometry group (Roman Schnabel) 13th Marcel Grossman Meeting MG13 Stockholm University Albert Einstein Institute Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics Institute for Gravitational Physics of the Leibniz University Hannover http://www.qi.aei-hannover.de

Upload: others

Post on 05-Sep-2020

16 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 1

Squeezed light

in present and future GW observatories

Alexander Khalaidovski for the AEI Quantum Interferometry group

(Roman Schnabel)

13th Marcel Grossman Meeting – MG13 – Stockholm University

Albert Einstein Institute

Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics

Institute for Gravitational Physics of the Leibniz University Hannover

http://www.qi.aei-hannover.de

Page 2: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 2

ET sensitivity curves

Page 3: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 3

Coherent state

Page 4: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 4

Michelson interferometer – bright port

Page 5: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 5

Vacuum state (0-point fluctuations of EM field)

Page 6: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 6

Origin of the quantum noise

Page 7: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 7

Squeezed vacuum state

Page 8: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 8

Injecting squeezed vacuum

Page 9: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 9

How to do?

Page 10: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 10

Generation of squeezing

LiNbO3 or

PPKTP

BASED ON OPTICAL PARAMETRIC AMPLIFICATION (OPA)

Squeezed field:

Pump field: 532 nm cw

1064 nm cw

For GW observatories

Page 11: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 11

squeezed-light lasers for

GW observatories

Page 12: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 12

The GEO 600 squeezed-light laser

Page 13: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 13

LIGO-H1 squeezed-light laser

Page 14: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 14

Requirements

Squeezing in earth-bound GW detection band

(10 Hz – 10 kHz)

Stable control scheme

(allowing for long-term, independent operation)

Strong squeezing

Page 15: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 15

Squeezing spectrum

Page 16: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 16

Loss sources

Page 17: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 17

Loss sources

Page 18: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 18

Squeezing available for injection

maximal directly observed squeezing: 9.6 dB

up to 11.5 dB available for injection

Page 19: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 19

Squeezing spectrum

Page 20: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 20

Available well below 10 Hz

Page 21: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 21

Long-term stability (automated exp. control)

Khalaidovski et al., Class. Quantum Grav. 29 (2012) 075001

duty cycle: 99.93 %

Page 22: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 22

squeezed-light lasers are ready

the message concerning squeezed-light lasers

Page 23: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 23

State-of-the-art

Page 24: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 24

squeezing in GW observatories today

Page 25: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 25

Squeezing-improved GEO 600 sensitivity

The LIGO Scientific Collaboration, Nature Phys. 7 (2011) 962-965

Factor 1.5

sensitivity improvement

Up to 3.5 dB

detected squeezing

Page 26: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 26

H. Grote @ March LVC Meeting (MIT)

Page 27: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 27

H1 with squeezed light

• 2.25 dB squeezing

enhancement

• squeezing

observable down to

100 Hz

• no noise added at

lower frequencies

• inspiral range

improved by 1 Mpc

Courtesy Lisa Barsotti for the LIGO Scientific Collaboration

Page 28: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 28

the future

Page 29: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 29

Einstein Telescope

Page 30: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 30

Einstein Telescope

Goal: 10 dB squeezing detected

total allowed optical loss: 10 %

Page 31: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 31

Loss sources

- Faraday isolators

- polarization optics

propagation loss, especially:

escape efficiency of the squeezed light source

detection loss

non-perfect mode-matching

Page 32: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 32

Squeezing injection

ˆ X 1

ˆ X 2

Quantum noises

Shot-noise

dominated

Radiation

pressure noise

dominated

Page 33: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 33

Filter cavities

Page 34: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 34

Remaining challenges

very low round-trip loss required

deviation from design parameters

Page 35: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 35

Filter cavities

Page 36: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 36

Remaining challenges

very low round-trip loss required

mode-matching

deviation from design parameters tunable loss

filter cavity length control scheme (detuned from resonance!)

Page 37: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 37

Conclusions

Squeezing is already used in the first detector generation (GEO 600, H1)

Squeezing will become a ‚standard‘ technique in future detector

Optical loss is squeezings‘ biggest enemy!!!

- better AR coatings

- lower crystal absorption

- lower propagation loss

(mainly polarization optics)

} higher squeezing contribution

generations

Page 38: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 38

thank you

Page 39: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 39

Experimental layout (scaled to reality)

• Breadboard: 113x135 cm

• Main Laser: InnoLight Mephisto

> 120 opt. components

• Aux. Lasers: Mephisto OEM

total weight ≈ 120 kg

• Optics: ATF (superpolished)

• Nonlinear medium: PPKTP

• Beam height: 50mm

• Compact design

Page 40: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 40

LIGO-SQUEEZER

• generally similar to AEI device

• main differences:

- „off-the shelf“ optics used

- requires more space, beam height 4´´

- no cleanroom environment

higher stray light contribution

- no fast data acquisition channels

- SHG design

- doubly-resonant (1064 nm and 532 nm)

- bow-tie configuration

additional 42 dB isolation

- LO beam from PSL via fiber

excess phase noise, no MC

• AEI contributions

- balanced homodyne detector

(- control scheme)

Page 41: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 41

Control scheme for audio-frequency squeezing

Page 42: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 42

Origin of the quantum noise

Page 43: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 43

Loss sources

r=T

T + L

escape efficiency of the squeezed light source

Absorption

Page 44: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 44

Loss sources

escape efficiency of the squeezed light source

propagation loss (Faraday isolator, pol. optics, coatings)

Page 45: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 45

Loss sources

escape efficiency of the squeezed light source

propagation loss

detection loss (photo diodes, homodyne fringe visibility)

Page 46: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 46

Loss sources

escape efficiency of the squeezed light source

propagation loss

detection loss

< total loss during characterization: 10.5 %

Page 47: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 47

how much squeezing can we inject in

GEO 600?

Injection of squeezed light

Page 48: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 48

Sensitivity to optical loss

Page 49: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 49

Sensitivity to optical loss

maximal squeezing: 9.6 dB

total identified loss: 10.5 %

Page 50: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 50

Implementation in GEO 600

Page 51: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 51

Optical loss

Page 52: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 52

Expected squeezing impact

due to loss from injection to detection

Page 53: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 53

near future

Page 54: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 54

Next steps at GEO HF

• OMC

• propagation

reducing losses

• mode-matching } ca. 22 %

seem feasible

Page 55: Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories · Alexander Khalaidovski Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories 1 Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories

Squeezed light in present and future GW observatories Alexander Khalaidovski 55

Goal

6 dB detected squeezing

Factor 2 sensitivity improvement