strategic plan 2014 - 2018 · strategic plan 2014 - 2018 regulating water, ... modern society...

36
STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

Upload: others

Post on 26-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

Page 2: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,
Page 3: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

1COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 2

INTRODUCTION 4

CONTEXT 6

OUR MISSION, OUR VISION, OUR VALUES 8

THE COMMISSION’S STRATEGIC GOALS 2014 – 2018 9

STRATEGIC GOAL 1 10TO ENSURE THAT “ENERGY AND GAS ARE SUPPLIED SAFELY”

STRATEGIC GOAL 2 14TO ENSURE THAT “THE LIGHTS STAY ON”

STRATEGIC GOAL 3 17TO ENSURE THAT “THE GAS CONTINUES TO FLOW”

STRATEGIC GOAL 4 20TO ENSURE “A RELIABLE SUPPLY OF CLEAN WATER AND EFFICIENT TREATMENT OF WASTEWATER”

STRATEGIC GOAL 5 23TO ENSURE THAT “THE PRICES CHARGED ARE FAIR AND REASONABLE”

STRATEGIC GOAL 6 27TO ENSURE “REGULATION IS BEST INTERNATIONAL PRACTICE”

CONCLUDING REMARKS 32

CONTENTS

Page 4: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

2 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

THE COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION’S STRATEGIC

PLAN FOR THE PERIOD 2014 – 2018 OUTLINES THE

COMMISSION’S GOALS FOR THIS FIVE YEAR PERIOD AS WELL

AS HIGH LEVEL STRATEGIES AND ACTIONS TO ACHIEVE

THESE GOALS. THE COMMISSION’S AIM IS TO STRIKE A

BALANCE BETWEEN ALL OF THESE GOALS TO ENSURE THE

PUBLIC INTEREST IS PROTECTED OVERALL. THE COMMISSION

WILL ALSO BE GUIDED BY GOVERNMENT POLICY OBJECTIVES

AND INTERNATIONAL COMMITMENTS SUCH AS RENEWABLE

ENERGY TARGETS.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Page 5: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

3COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

THE COMMISSION HAS SET THE FOLLOWING STRATEGIC GOALS, IN NOORDER OF PREFERENCE:

Goal 1 TO ENSURE THAT “energy and gas are supplied safely”A WORLD CLASS PUBLIC SAFETY RECORDUnderneath this there are 5 strategies outlined in the areas of compliance, investigationand enforcement, continuous improvement, safety promotion and public awareness, andexternal engagement.

Goal 2 TO ENSURE THAT “the lights stay on”SECURE ELECTRICITY SUPPLIES FROM PRODUCTION TO CONSUMPTIONUnderneath this there are 4 strategies outlined in areas of networks, interconnection,generator adequacy/power system resilience and emergency planning.

Goal 3 TO ENSURE THAT “the gas continues to flow”SECURE NATURAL GAS SUPPLIES WITH IMPROVED DIVERSITY OF SOURCESUnderneath this there are 3 strategies outlined in the areas of gas market structures, gassystem resilience and gas networks.

Goal 4 TO ENSURE “a reliable supply of clean water and efficient treatment ofwastewater”SECURE, ROBUST WATER SUPPLIES AND WASTE WATER DISPOSALUnderneath this there are 3 strategies outlined in the areas of the structure of theregulatory framework, the system of charges for water customers and efficient investment.

Goal 5 TO ENSURE THAT “the prices charged are fair and reasonable”FULLY COMPETITIVE WHOLESALE AND RETAIL MARKETS AND WELL-REGULATEDNETWORKS, DELIVERING FAIR AND EFFICIENT PRICES TO CUSTOMERS.Underneath this there are 4 strategies outlined in the areas of wholesale markets,competition in markets and competitive prices, incentivising monopolies and innovationand consumer welfare.

Goal 6 TO ENSURE “regulation is best international practice”LIVING UP TO OUR VALUESUnderneath this there are 5 strategies outlined in the areas of values, human resourcemanagement, integrated business planning, regulatory practice and stakeholderengagement.

Page 6: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

4 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

INTRODUCTION

PURPOSE OF THIS DOCUMENT

THE COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION (“THE COMMISSION”) ISIRELAND'S INDEPENDENT ENERGY AND WATER REGULATOR. THISDOCUMENT SETS OUT THE COMMISSION’S STRATEGIC PLAN FOR THEYEARS 2014 TO 2018. IT SETS OUT OUR PROPOSED NEW VISION,MISSION AND STRATEGIC GOALS FOR THE PERIOD, TAKING ACCOUNTOF RECENT AND EXPECTED RELEVANT DEVELOPMENTS AND, OFCOURSE, OUR POWERS AND FUNCTIONS. THE PLAN IS PREPARED ANDWILL BE REVIEWED, AS NECESSARY, TO ENSURE IT CONTINUES TOMEET THE APPLICABLE LEGISLATIVE REQUIREMENTS AND BESTPRACTICE GUIDELINES.

BACKGROUND TO THE COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION

THE COMMISSION WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1999. SINCE THEN ITSPOWERS AND FUNCTIONS HAVE EXPANDED AND IT NOW HAS A WIDERANGE OF ECONOMIC, CUSTOMER PROTECTION AND SAFETYRESPONSIBILITIES IN ENERGY. THE COMMISSION HAS FURTHEREXPANDED ITS ROLE BY RECENTLY BECOMING THE ECONOMICREGULATOR OF THE IRISH PUBLIC WATER AND WASTEWATER SECTOR.

A CONTEXT TO OUR WORK IS PROVIDED IN THE NEXT SECTION OFTHIS DOCUMENT, WHILE BELOW WE PROVIDE A BRIEF SUMMARY OFOUR DIVERSE ROLES ACROSS ENERGY AND WATER.

Page 7: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

5COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

ECONOMIC REGULATION

EnergyOur aim is to protect the interests of energycustomers, maintain security of supply, andto promote competition covering thegeneration and supply of electricity andsupply of natural gas. As part of this role,the Commission jointly regulates the all-island wholesale Single Electricity Market(SEM) with its counterpart in NorthernIreland, the Utility Regulator. The SEM isgoverned by a decision-making body knownas the SEM Committee, consisting of theCER, the Utility Regulator and anindependent members.

WaterThe Commission has recently assumed therole of economic regulator for the Irishwater and wastewater sector, covering theservices provided by Irish Water. Ourprimary aim is to protect the interests ofcustomers of Irish Water. This role will focuson water and wastewater charges andcustomer protection.

Customer ComplaintsThe Commission has an important relatedfunction in customer protection by resolvingcomplaints that customers have with energycompanies through its Customer Care team.This will expand to deal with Irish Watercustomers, in line with legislation.

ENERGY SAFETY REGULATION

In energy safety, the core focus of theCommission is to protect lives across arange of areas in the energy sector. Thisincludes safety regulation of electricalcontractors and gas installers (covering bothnatural gas and Liquefied Petroleum Gas(LPG)). In addition, the CER is the safetyregulator of the downstream natural gasindustry (covering storage, transportationand supply) and LPG piped distributionsystems. It is also safety regulator ofupstream petroleum safety extraction andexploration activities; this includes oil andgas activity both onshore and offshore.

Page 8: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

6 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

ECONOMIC REGULATOR FOR ENERGY

The Commission for Electricity Regulation wasestablished in 1999 as economic regulator of the Irishelectricity sector. Like much of Europe, the sector wascharacterised by a single, dominant electricity company,a lack of customer choice, a lack of real competitiveforces, a lack of significant investment in energyinfrastructure and high growth in demand for reliableand cost-competitive energy supplies. In 2002, theCommission for Energy Regulation, as it was thenrenamed, assumed responsibility for a gas sector whichexhibited many of the same characteristics.

Across Europe there was a drive for a single energymarket to bring secure, competitively priced energysupplies to all customers. This has been underpinned bythree packages of European legislation. Allied to thishave been the climate change and energy securityagendas under which Ireland must meet challengingrenewables targets by 2020.

In the intervening 14 years the Commission hasoverseen major change right across the Irish energysector. At the core of our economic regulation has beenprotection of the customer interest.

Key achievements include:

• an all-island, competitive wholesale electricitymarket which has driven investment, market entry,price transparency and competition;

• major investments in the electricity and gasnetworks which has enhanced security of supply andunderpinned economic growth and recovery;

• liberalisation of the electricity and gas retail markets,delivering price deregulation and competition withnew market participants offering value and choicefor consumers;

• delivering circa 20% of electricity consumption fromrenewable energy (mainly wind), which is helpingdecarbonise the electricity system and meetinternational obligations.

Throughout this time there has been a strong consumerfocus on energy prices. Energy prices have increasedthroughout the EU, driven by increasing global fuel

prices. Ireland is a price-taker on international fuelmarkets, and we are particularly impacted by increasinggas prices, given that gas remains the primary fuel inthe electricity market. Following decades of under-investment, Ireland additionally required significantnetwork investment to underpin growth, deliversustainable energy mix and ensure security of supply.

All of this has implications for end-user prices, at a timewhen economic developments have placed increasingpressure on consumers and businesses. The advent ofunconventional oil and gas has also created acompetitiveness gap between the US and the EU. Wewill continue to seek the balance in deliveringcompetitive prices and secure supplies for current andfuture customers.

ENERGY SAFETY REGULATOR

In 2006, the Commission was transformed from a purelyeconomic regulator to a combined safety and economicregulator. Since then the Commission regulates thesafety of the downstream gas industry, the upstream oiland gas (exploration and extraction) industries andaspects of the electricity industry. This combination ofeconomic and safety functions is not unique but it doesbring its challenges, not least in maintaining a balancebetween the protection of life and the obligations thatthat places on the energy sector, and the maintenanceof competitive forces and competitively priced energy;both of which ultimately serve the public interest.

The Commission has overseen some majortransformations in energy safety regulation. At its coreis the protection of human life. Achievements include:

• Establishing the Gas Safety Framework – adoption of best practice goal-setting regime;

• Statutory oversight of Registered ElectricalContractors – launch of Safe Electric;

• Establishment and launch of Registered Gas Installerscheme;

• Establishment of Petroleum Safety Framework –covering Ireland’s on/offshore oil and gasexploration and extraction activity.

CONTEXT

Page 9: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

7COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

ECONOMIC REGULATOR FOR WATER

The third major transformation in the Commission’sfunctions occurred in 2013 with the addition ofeconomic regulation functions for the water andwastewater sector; a situation that is evolving. TheCommission’s focus in water is on protecting theconsumer interest in the setting of charges for watersupply and wastewater treatment and disposal.

BRINGING IT ALL TOGETHER

The previous version of the Commission’s Strategic Plan(2010-2014) focused on a range of issues. Theseincluded security of supply, prices, adapting to changefrom Europe and improving standards of safety.Progress has been achieved on all these fronts and yetmany of these issues are just as relevant today; with theadded focus on reliable water supplies and efficientwaste water removal.

Modern society demands and expects safe, secureenergy and clean water, on a sustainable basis. Withoutboth, modern economies do not function.

As an organisation, the CER is acutely aware of this. Theadvent of water regulation within our statutory remitprovides us with the requirement, but also theopportunity, to take stock of our vision for these twovital resources and our role in meeting society’s needsand protecting society’s interest both now and over thelong term. The Commission must adapt to meet theneeds of changing national policy.

The water sector is transforming. The model ofexchequer financed local authority provision, with noresidential charges, is giving way to a modelcharacterised by a single national water company and aself-financing model incorporating residential watercharges.

In energy, national and external factors are drivingradical change in energy markets. Customer protectionand customer welfare are increasingly to the fore. Theresponse to climate change continues to shape EUenergy policy and national energy policy and is an

important factor in designing regulatory processes. Thedrive for energy efficiency complements the evolution ofSmart Grids; our own National Smart MeteringProgramme forms a significant plank in this smartfuture. At the same time, the electricity sector mustadapt to high levels of renewable generation in terms ofphysical infrastructure, system operation and marketdynamics. In gas, the security of supply of Ireland’s gassupplies is as much about diversity of supply at anational level as at is about delivering liquid,interconnected markets at a European level. AcrossEurope the lessons from the Macondo Incident have aresulted in a mandatory goal-based safety regime foroffshore oil and gas activities.

All of these factors are driving change and theCommission must be ready to and meet the demands ofthis future whether as regulatory authority, nationalchampion, competent authority or enforcementauthority. Our key resource is our staff, and their skillsand judgement. We recognise that as the demands onour organisation change, we must adapt.

The Commission subscribes to the principles of BetterRegulation. This Plan sets out our mission/vision/valuesand our priorities for energy and water. It identifies thedeliverables for which we are happy to be held toaccount, by the public.

Page 10: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

8 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

OUR MISSION

Regulating Water, Energy and Energy Safety in the Public Interest

OUR VISION

The Vision of the Commission is as follows:

The short and long run interests of the public are protected by ensuring:

• energy and gas are supplied safely;• the lights stay on;• the gas continues to flow;• a reliable supply of clean water and efficient treatment of wastewater;• consumer prices for energy and water are fair and reasonable; and• regulation is best international practice.

OUR VALUES

In fulfilling our mission and our statutory functions, it is vital that the CER develops andadheres to key values for the organisation so that all stakeholders, and particularly thepublic, trust us and have faith that we will serve them properly as an independent regulator.

In regulating we stress that:

• We are committed to public service – we will always act in the public interest• We act with integrity in everything we do• We are professional in our dealings with stakeholders• We are accessible to stakeholders – we listen to what people have to say• We are proportionate and objective – we take balanced decisions• We are transparent – we are open to scrutiny and are committed to explaining our

decisions• We are accountable for our decisions and for the way we spend our resources• We value and develop our staff – they are our chief resource

Page 11: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

9COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

THE COMMISSION’S STRATEGIC GOALS 2014 – 2018

Goal 1 TO ENSURE THAT “energy and gas are supplied safely”A WORLD CLASS PUBLIC SAFETY RECORD

Goal 2 TO ENSURE THAT “the lights stay on”SECURE ELECTRICITY SUPPLIES FROM PRODUCTION TO CONSUMPTION

Goal 3 TO ENSURE THAT “the gas continues to flow”SECURE NATURAL GAS SUPPLIES WITH IMPROVED DIVERSITY OF SOURCES

Goal 4 TO ENSURE “a reliable supply of clean water and efficient treatment ofwastewater”SECURE, ROBUST WATER SUPPLIES AND WASTE WATER DISPOSAL

Goal 5 TO ENSURE THAT “the prices charged are fair and reasonable”FULLY COMPETITIVE RETAIL MARKETS AND WELL-REGULATED NETWORKS,DELIVERING FAIR AND EFFICIENT PRICES TO CUSTOMERS

Goal 6 TO ENSURE “regulation is best international practice”LIVING UP TO OUR VALUES

Page 12: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

10 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

Safety regulation is now an established and significant aspect of the Commission’s legislativeresponsibilities. From 2014, the full suite of the Commission’s safety functions in the areas ofelectricity, natural gas, LPG, and oil and gas exploration and production will be established.Below, we set out our strategic objectives in this area.

Safety regulation is about protecting life and property. Our strategies and objectives aredesigned to deliver this goal.

ALARP the core of much of our safety regulation is the concept of “As Low as ReasonablyPracticable”, often shortened to ALARP. Undertakings regulated by CER are responsible forthe safety of their operations. To operate they must demonstrate that the risk theseoperations pose to the safety of the public are ALARP; that they have taken all measures thatare reasonably required to ensure this is the case. The CERs assurance of the petroleumundertakings demonstration of ALARP is a continuous process involving complianceassurance (including audit and inspection of undertakings), incident investigation,prosecution and enforcement where required, regular performance reporting and analysis ofperformance across a range of safety indicators and, ultimately, the feedback of all theselearnings/evidences to help improve the overall safety regulation framework; a process ofcontinuous improvement.

MEASURE(S) OF SUCCESS

• Continuous improvement in safety standards with ultimate goal of zero safety incidents• World-class safety performance when benchmarked against other jurisdictions

TO ENSURE THAT

“energy and gas are supplied safely”FACILITATING A WORLD CLASS PUBLIC SAFETY RECORD

STRATEGIC GOAL ONE

Page 13: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

11COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

1.1 Compliance Assurance - The ongoingmonitoring of compliance of industry with thesafety regulatory requirements

The Petroleum Safety Framework, the Gas SafetyFramework and the Electrical Safety regulatorydocuments encapsulate the policies, proceduresand the standards for compliance against whichpetroleum undertakings, LPG and natural gasundertakings, the GSSB1, the ESSBs2, gas installersand electrical contractors will be measured.

The Commission will actively monitor compliance,under a risk-based audit and inspection regime, toensure that the public can be confident that theregulated entities are operating in compliancewith regulatory requirements.

ACTIONS 1.1

1.1.1 We will conduct ongoing audits andinspections of each regulated entity

1.1.2 We will impose independentverification on regulated petroleumentities.

1.1.3 We will use results of audits andinspections to inform ongoingimprovements in the safetyframework.

1.2 Enforcement – enforcing compliance with theregulatory systems when required.

In order for any regulatory system to accomplishits intended purpose, it is critical that regulatoryrequirements are ultimately enforced by theRegulator when required, in line with statutorypowers. This is especially important in the safetyregulatory area, where enforcement demonstratesthe intent of the regulator to act to secure safeoutcomes and to protect lives.

Enforcement action may arise from a variety ofsources including the result of audit or inspectionor performance reporting. Significantly, it mayalso arise from the incident investigations.

The Commission’s powers in the event of non-compliance are varied (depending on scale of non-compliance), and include:

1. Issuing an Prohibition Notice;2. Issuing an Improvement Notice;3. Prosecution of people undertaking

designated petroleum activities without aSafety Permit;

4. Prosecution of non-registered gas installersand non-registered electrical contractors whoundertake Gas Works or Restricted ElectricalWorks.

ACTION 1.2

1.2.1 We will investigate and takeappropriate enforcement actionsagainst petroleum, gas and electricityundertakings (including gas installersand electrical contractors) to ensurecompliance with the petroleum, gasand electricity safety regulatorysystems where any non-compliance has been identified.

The Commission has five strategies which are designed to achieve Strategic Goal One. Delivering on theseinterlinked strategies will over the course of this plan 2014 - 2018 help CER to deliver a world class public safetyrecord in the areas that fall within our remit.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL ONE

1 Gas Safety Supervisory Body - RGII (Register of Gas Installers of Ireland)2 Electricity Safety Supervisory Bodies – RECI (Register of Electrical Contractors of Ireland) and ECSSA (Electrical Contractors Safety and Standards Association)

Page 14: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

12 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

1.3 Continuous improvements in safety - Applyinga continuous improvement philosophy to thesafety regulatory systems

The environment, technologies and best practiceswhich inform the development of safetyregulatory systems change over time. Therefore,regulatory policies and procedures also need toevolve; safety performance improvements cannever be taken for granted. The Commission willcontinually review the regulatory system, with theintention of identifying and implementing on-going improvement.

An example of the changing environment and itsimpact on the regulatory framework is in the areaof petroleum safety. Following the high profileincident at the Macondo Well in the Gulf ofMexico in 2010, the EU Commission haspromoted a new Directive on the safety ofoffshore oil and gas operations. This appliesacross the EU and establishes minimumrequirements for preventing major accidents inthe offshore environment. The Petroleum Safety Framework will be reviewed and revised, as necessary, to ensure compliance with the Directive.

ACTIONS 1.3

1.3.1 We will require regular performancereporting by each regulated entityagainst CER prescribed appropriatesuites of safety performanceindicators.

1.3.2 We will engage with the industry,through safety governance groups and through public consultation, todetermine and implement specificimprovements to the relevant safetyframework.

1.3.3 We will review and implement thenecessary changes to the PetroleumSafety Framework arising fromDirective 2013/30/EU with theDepartment; we will initiate/implement changes to other aspects of our regulatory frameworks in linewith relevant legislation during theplan 2014-2018.

1.4 Safety Promotion and Public Awareness -Undertaking comprehensive promotion andpublic awareness campaigns

For the regulation of safety to be most effective,the general public must be made aware of gasand electricity safety issues, as they impact them.These issues may include their role in ensuringonly registered installers or contractors carry outwork on the electrical or gas installation in theirhome. It may also include their role in preventingsafety incident; this is particularly relevant to thedangers of Carbon Monoxide. It is also importantthat the public understand the importance of theirrole, or civic duty, within the regulatory system(e.g. reporting gas leaks) and that the public haveconfidence in the regulatory systems in place; thatare ultimately there to protect them.

ACTIONS 1.4

We will co-ordinate the delivery of promotionand public awareness campaigns which willaim to achieve the following outcomes:

1.4.1 Increased levels of general publicawareness of gas and electrical safety issues.

1.4.2 Greater willingness among the general public to take preventative and positive actions with respect toenergy safety.

1.4.3 Obtain higher levels of awareness of the Registered Gas Installer andRegistered Electrical Contractorschemes; specifically raise awarenessof the need to use a RGI or REC for Gas Works and Restricted ElectricalWorks respectively.

1.4.4 Identify and promote, in co-operationwith other public bodies/agencies,public awareness on specific safetyissues such as Carbon Monoxide.

Page 15: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

13COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

1.5 External Engagement – Co-operating andworking with other agencies to facilitate thedischarge of respective safety regulatoryfunctions

The Commission’s role as Safety Regulator issignificantly different from its role as an EconomicRegulator. Most notably, the safety functions ofthe Commission potentially overlap with orcomplement the functions of a diverse range ofnational agencies; these include the Health andSafety Authority, the planning authorities, theEnvironmental Protection Agency, and the IrishCoast Guard, amongst others. Effective inter-agency co-operation and working practices arenecessary to ensure the regulatory function ofeach agency is discharged effectively and that the overall regulatory burden is minimised.

ACTIONS 1.5

1.5.1 We will co-operate and consult withrelevant agencies and bodies whosefunctions complement or overlap withthe Commission’s safety functions; asnecessary, we will underpin thiscommitment with Memoranda ofUnderstanding and agreed workingpractices, which will be subject toreview on a regular basis.

1.5.2 We will share supporting evidence andinformation with relevantagencies/bodies and stakeholders toassist them in the discharge of theirown functions.

1.5.3 As a member of EUOAG (EU OffshoreAuthorities Group), and in cooperationwith other safety regulatory bodiesacross European and the world, CERshall work with its Europeancolleagues to inform higher safetystandards in Ireland and elsewhere.

Page 16: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

14 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

The Commission has a key role in ensuring security and reliability of electricity supplies in asustainable manner. The Commission monitors generator adequacy through oversight ofEirGrid and considers changes necessary to deliver security of supply standards. We recognisethat demand side, storage and interconnection can also add to security of supply. A keyconsideration will be the sustainability of the mix of measures adopted; protecting security ofsupply for current and future generations. There is a strong overlap with Goal Five whichcovers markets for generation and demand side measures, including flexibility. Goal Twofocuses on generator adequacy, network security and emergency planning.

MEASURE(S) OF SUCCESS

• No major security of supply outages over period of plan.• Support EirGrid operation of the grid to minimise risk of blackouts.• Support delivery of adequate network capacity to ensure that electricity can be delivered

cost effectively for all reasonable requests for demand.

TO ENSURE THAT

“the lights stay on”SECURE ELECTRICITY SUPPLIES FROM PRODUCTION TO CONSUMPTION

STRATEGIC GOAL TWO

Page 17: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

15COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

2.1 Infrastructure: Electricity Networks

Network development is a key aspect inmaintaining secure supplies and increasing therole of indigenous renewable energy in Ireland’senergy mix. Electricity networks are regulated asnatural monopolies. The Commission must ensurethat customers and network users receive valuefor money while the network owners andoperators earn sufficient returns in order to makethe necessary investments in the sustainabledevelopment and maintenance of the networks tomeet increases in demand and renewablepenetration. Development of the transmissionnetwork to support large scale renewabledevelopment across Ireland will be of importance.A key component in the delivery of this will be the4th Price Review for transmission and distribution(for the period 2016 – 2020). Also, with theconclusion of Gate 33 Direction on RenewableGenerator Connections the Commission willaddress the connection policy for generation onthe system to ensure it is fit for purpose inbalancing the requirements for priority access andsecure operation on a sustainable basis.

ACTIONS 2.1

2.1.1 We will continue to work with theelectricity network owners andoperators to plan and implement theappropriate levels of networkdevelopment to support security ofsupply, renewable development and acompetitive electricity sector. We willensure that network enhancement anddevelopment is carried out efficientlyand that benefits are analysed againstassociated costs. We will use networkprice controls and regular monitoringto deliver this action.

2.1.2 We will continue to monitor thedelivery of Gate 3 connections toensure network connections supportdelivery of national renewable targetsfor 2020.

2.1.3 We will review connection policy withthe aim of providing a fair opportunityfor generation to receive offers ofconnection to the networks takingaccount of system needs, limitationsand national policy.

2.2 Interconnection – Future interconnectionprojects

The Commission considers increasedinterconnection with Europe to be helpful in bothimproving security of electricity supplies andcompetitiveness of the electricity market. Overthe course of this plan, interconnection willbecome a significant new feature of the Irishelectricity system, opening up new competitivepossibilities but also bringing challenges forsystem planning and operation. The Commissionwill seek to maximise the benefit to consumers ofcurrent interconnectors and seek to establishfurther interconnection options, but only proceedwith further interconnection projects which are oflong term benefit to consumers, where a robustcost benefit analysis has been completed, inconsultation with all relevant stakeholdersincluding the government.

ACTIONS 2.2

2.2.1 The Commission will seek to getmaximum consumer benefit fromexisting interconnectors throughefficient market design, under I-SEMproject.

2.2.2 We will continue, in co-operation withthe system operator and government,to examine the potential for futureinterconnectors to both France andGreat Britain but only proceed withprojects after completion of a robustcost benefit analysis.

The Commission has developed four strategies (outlined below) which are designed to achieve Goal Two. Alongwith market strategies under Goal 5, these strategies will tie together over the course of this plan 2014 - 2018 todeliver secure electricity supplies in a stable, competitive wholesale market, on a sustainable basis.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL TWO

3 Criteria for Gates Renewable Generator Offers and related matters, 16/12/2008

Page 18: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

16 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

2.3 Generator Adequacy /Power System Resilience

The Commission will review generator adequacyand other forms of capacity, eg. storage, demandside, interconnection, to ensure that the lightsstay on. We will continue to encourage EirGrid toundertake prudent operation of the electricitysystem. The advent of high levels of renewablespenetration, increased levels of interconnectionsand the advent of new forms of common modefailure, resulting from the use of newtechnologies, has added complexity to theoperation of the power system. We will work withthe system operator and network owner to seekto identify power system operation risks andmitigate those risks as necessary.

ACTION 2.3

2.3.1 We will monitor generator adequacyand other forms of capacity, such asdemand side management, storageand interconnection to ensure securityof supply standards are achieved.

2.3.2 We will seek opportunities toencourage power system resiliencethrough prudent system operation bythe transmission and distributionsystem operators. This will bemonitored on an annual basis.

2.4 Emergency Planning – Policies to deal withemergency events

The Commission is cognisant that despite marketmechanisms and stringent security of supplyplanning, security of supply events could occurdue to a variety of reasons. Therefore robustemergency-related policy and plans should be inplace to mitigate the impact of such events.

The emergency planning arrangements currentlyin place are for both electricity and gas, given thecontinuing reliance on gas supplies in the currentgeneration mix. These emergency plans willcontinue to be monitored and updated.

ACTION 2.4

2.4.1 We will work through the TFEP (TaskForce on Emergency Procedures) groupto identify, implement/update andmonitor plans and protocols tominimise the effect of emergencyevents on electricity and gascustomers.

Page 19: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

17COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

The Commission plays an important role in natural gas planning and security of supply. This isof key importance both to “standard” gas customers such as homes and businesses but also tothe electricity industry, given that over 55% of Ireland’s power is now produced from naturalgas (of which 95% is imported from UK). This goal is about enhancing structures to deliversecurity of supply in gas while acknowledging the increasing diversity of sources over thecoming years.

MEASURE(S) OF SUCCESS

• No major security of supply issues• Full implementation of European network codes in junction with UR and OFGEM• Improve system resilience in conjunction with diversity of sources, facilitating storage

and improving flexibility.

TO ENSURE THAT

“the gas continues to flow”SECURE NATURAL GAS SUPPLIES WITH IMPROVED DIVERSITY OF SOURCES

STRATEGIC GOAL THREE

Page 20: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

18 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

3.1 Gas Market Operational Structures

Increasing market coupling and integration in gas,like in electricity, is a key mechanism by whichIreland can improve gas security of supply andcompetitiveness. This issue has now beenaddressed comprehensively at a European levelthrough the development of network codes. TheCommission will seek to go beyond minimumrequirements set out in the network codes andexplore options for increasing integration acrossthe two islands of Ireland and Great Britain wherethis is in the long-term interest of the consumer.We will also consider interaction with theelectricity market when developing network codeimplementation.

ACTION 3.1

3.1.1 We will work with the NorthernIreland Utility Regulator, the EnergyRegulator in Great Britain and thenatural gas industry to implement theEuropean network codes whichdelivers improved gas security ofsupply and improved benefits for themarket and customers.

3.2 Gas System Resilience

Gas supplies are now a key strategic service forthe Irish economy given the number of residentialcustomers who rely on gas heating, businesseswho need reliable gas supplies and the prevalenceof gas fired generators in the electricity market(albeit with secondary fuel back-up). We will seekto improve the gas system resilience byfacilitating, where practicable and safe, newsources of indigenous gas, sources from LNG andimproved gas storage. In the event that Ireland islikely to become a gas exporter we will ensurethat the necessary infrastructure is delivered intime to facilitate this. Gas export would improvegas security and competitiveness but will probablyonly occur if new sources of supply are found.

ACTIONS 3.2

3.2.1 We will continue to monitor Irish gasdemand and analyse the impacts ofvarious gas supply and availabilityscenarios to ensure that sufficientcapacity is available to satisfy demandfrom all sources in the near term.

3.2.2 Additionally we will examine possiblesources of gas for the long term,including indigenous sources, LNG and increased gas storage.

The Commission has developed three strategies (outlined below) which are designed to achieve Goal Three. Thesestrategies are separate individual pieces which will tie together over the course of this plan 2014 - 2018 to deliversecure natural gas supplies.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL THREE

Page 21: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

19COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

3.3 Infrastructure: Gas Networks - Implement newfive year revenue strategy for gas networks(2017 – 2022)

As in the electricity sector, the monopoly aspectsof the natural gas sector such as networks areregulated by the Commission using a five yearcontrol mechanism.

ACTION 3.3

3.3.1 We will carry out a full historical andforecast revenue review of gasnetworks to put in place the correctmechanism for the period 2017 - 2022.

3.3.2 Full consultations will be carried out on proposed revenues, controls andmodels in 2016. The network reviewswill be analysed in order to ensure that necessary and appropriatenetwork development is planned andcarried out efficiently.

Page 22: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

20 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

The Commission has been given the responsibility of being the regulator for the provision ofwater and wastewater services. This is a period of major change in the Irish water sector, witha commercial semi-state company, Irish Water, being set-up to provide water services at anational level. Irish Water will replace the old system of having such services provided by 34separate local authorities. The Commission will regulate Irish Water as a network monopoly toensure that it is run as efficiently as possible while still providing a clean and safe water supplyto all consumers. The changes will also see residential consumers being charged for water fromOctober 2014, and the Commission will ensure that a fair and transparent system of charging isimplemented. This is against a background of Irish water services needing significant newinvestments both to modernise an ageing network as well as to meet new EU standards onefficient disposal of wastewater. Our key challenge will be to keep costs at the efficient levelwhile ensuring sustainable water production both now and in the future.

MEASURE(S) OF SUCCESS

• A credible regulatory framework to facilitate low cost funding from capital markets.• All customers paying their water bills, and understanding their bills.• Water and wastewater quality measure being improved, and increased compliance with

EU Water Framework Directive.

TO ENSURE THAT

“a reliable supply of clean water and efficienttreatment of wastewater”SECURE, ROBUST WATER SUPPLIES AND WASTE WATER DISPOSAL

STRATEGIC GOAL FOUR

Page 23: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

21COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

4.1 Establish Framework for the economicregulation of Irish Water

Our aim will be to implement a coherentframework for the regulation of Irish Water. Tothis end, we will set-out a series of papersspecifying how we intend to fulfil our statutoryobjectives in the water sector. This will specifythe principles of how Irish Water is to beregulated. Our approach to water networkregulation will draw on our experience in energyand international experience. This will involvedeveloping a framework for measuring efficientoperating costs, methods of benchmarking costsagainst other water companies, and a system ofassessing the need for new investments, as wellas ensuring any investments are made in anefficient manner. We will consider environmentaland sustainability matters relating to national andEU requirements in all relevant aspects ofregulating Irish Water, but we recognise thebudgetary constraints on the company andgovernment in early years of operation.

ACTIONS 4.1

4.1.1. Use the statutory objectives given tous in legislation to give a clear andunderstandable framework for theregulation of Irish Water.

4.1.2. Work to build a system of networkregulation, using best principles bothfrom our own experience of energynetworks as well as water regulationin other jurisdictions.

4.2 System of Charges for Water Customers

We will work to ensure efficiencies are made thatwill minimise the cost of water and wastewaterservices. We will do this by requiring Irish Waterto make necessary reductions in cost. TheCommission will do this using data and analysis,and identifying a clear time path over whichefficiencies are made.

We will develop methods for charging to waterservice customers that are fair and transparent.They will set out the relative cost of water supplyand wastewater treatment. The new water meterswill allow us to set charges related to the volumeof water used. For those without meters, we willdevelop a set of assessed charges. The CER willensure that all bills are clear and understandable,and will consult with all stakeholders, includingconsumer groups in doing so.

The Commission will seek a high level of customerservice by Irish Water, as a monopoly provider,which is responsive to their customer needs. Tofacilitate this we will pursue an independentcustomer complaints function that will deal withcustomer complaints and address grievances. Atthe same time an effective suite of customerprotection measures will be required to ensure therelationship between Irish Water and itscustomers is effectively governed with a view toimproving service standards.

ACTIONS 4.2

4.2.1. Work to ensure that consumer costsare as low as is consistent withensuring clean and stable supplies ofwater and treatment of wastewater.

4.2.2. Develop and maintain a system ofcharging that is fair and transparent toall consumers.

4.2.3. We will work with Irish Water toensure that, as a monopoly provider, itstrives to achieve and improve a highlevel of customer service that respondsto customer needs and desires.

The Commission has developed three strategies (outlined below) which are designed to achieve Goal Four. Thesestrategies are separate individual pieces which will tie together over the course of this plan 2014 - 2018 to deliverreliable supplies of clean water and efficient disposal of wastewater.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL FOUR

Page 24: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

22 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

4.3 Efficient Investment

The bringing together of 34 Local Authorities willallow us to seek reductions in operating costs andfacilitate the more efficient planning of the waternetwork. This will be achieved by assessing waterneeds across the country. The CER will work withIrish Water to ensure a system is in place thatminimises the necessary level of investment andoptimises the network.

It is clear that the Irish water network is relativelyold, and that it must meet the demographic,economic and environmental needs of the Irishpeople now and in the future. We recognise thatsignificant investment will be needed to upgradeit, to reduce leaks, and to ensure that consumerssee year-on-year increases in the quality of waterand wastewater services they currently receive.Also, Ireland faces challenging EU targets forwastewater disposal by 2021 which will requiresignificant investments if they are to be met. Wewill work with both Irish Water and theEnvironmental Protection Agency (EPA) whendetermining how these targets will be achieved.

Nevertheless, while investments will be needed, itis vital to ensure that they are carried out in anefficient manner which minimises consumer costs.We will regulate Irish Water to ensure that it hasincentives to choose the most efficient andlowest-cost investments that are needed tomaintain and improve the network. TheCommission recognises the key role that assetmanagement will play in this regard.

ACTIONS 4.3

4.3.1 Work with Irish Water to develop asystem for assessing investment needs.

4.3.2 Ensure that sufficient investment ismade to improve the network andmeet the requirements of the EU Water Framework Directive.

4.3.3 Ensure that any investments are carried out efficiently.

Page 25: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

A key purpose of economic regulation is to ensure that energy and water prices are at acompetitive and efficient level. Consumers need to be protected against monopolists, or anyfirms with market power, charging excessive prices. The CER regulates the energy and watersectors which are vital services for all consumers. The CER sees it as vital that these services areprovided at the lowest possible efficient cost to consumers, particularly given the generalincrease in fuel costs in the last 10 years and the fact that consumers have not previously beencharged for water. Strategic Goal Four addresses water charges, while Goals Two and Threeaddress charges for electricity and gas networks. This Goal focuses on energy retailcompetition and electricity wholesale competition.

The CER needs to protect both the current and future interests of all consumers. Energy retailmarkets are now fully deregulated from 2014; with the removal of remaining end-user pricecontrols in the gas residential market. Nevertheless, the CER must ensure that consumerscontinue to benefit from competition, including exercising choice by switching, and can accesscompetitive prices. The CER will also continue to seek a high level of consumer protection,particularly for vulnerable customers, including through supplier charters and codes of practiceand through its dispute resolution service.

The Commission, together with our UR colleagues and the SEM Committee, are working todevelop the integrated Single Electricity Market (I-SEM) to ensure that it complies withEuropean network code requirements, delivers secure supplies and efficiently uses theinterconnectors. This will be delivered through a stable competitive wholesale market thatencourages efficient investment in competitive technologies that may include flexibleconventional generation, renewable generation (with government support where required),demand side participation, storage and increased interconnection. The necessary level ofinvestment is required to make sure prices are as low as possible in the future as well as today.

MEASURE(S) OF SUCCESS

• Active, unregulated, competition in all electricity and gas markets, allied to high consumerswitching rates in retail markets.

• Ensure compliance with European target model by end of 2016.• Continued efficiency improvements in regulated networks, as well as diminishing market

power in any other markets.• On-going roll-out of new meters under the NSMP, as well as new demand-side measures• Reducing levels of customer complaints.

TO ENSURE THAT

“the prices charged are fair and reasonable”FULLY COMPETITIVE RETAIL AND WHOLESALE MARKETS DELIVERING FAIR PRICES TO CUSTOMERS

STRATEGIC GOAL FIVE

23COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

Page 26: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

24 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

5.1 Wholesale Electricity: The Single ElectricityMarket

The Single Electricity Market (SEM) has twinobjectives of delivering security of supply andefficient prices through an efficient, wholesalemarket structure. The Commission through itsparticipation in the SEM Committee aims toensure that the SEM provides a more efficient,competitive and customer focussed electricitysector in Ireland. This includes encouragingincreased flexibility of supplies in the market toefficiently and reliably accommodate the highpenetration levels of renewables that areexpected on the system.

The SEM Committee (SEMC) is the decision-making body which governs the exercise ofregulatory functions on SEM matters. The SEMC iscomposed of members of CER, NIAUR and anIndependent Member.

The SEM was delivered through a spirit ofpartnership with the two Regulatory Authoritiesworking with the Governments and the electricityindustry north and south. Continued progress willalso be achieved by working with our SEMpartners and maintaining regulatory certainty inrules and procedures underpinning the SEM.

ACTION 5.1

5.1.1 Through the SEMC we will ensure thatthe I-SEM is implemented to complywith European network coderequirements by the end of 2016bringing benefits of more integratedmarkets to customers.

5.1.2 The I-SEM will build on the experienceof the SEM and include effectivemonitoring and implementation ofrules, including market powermitigation measures as required.

5.1.3 We will seek to develop a wholesalemarket that will treat flexibleconventional generation, demand side participation, storage, andinterconnection equally, whiledelivering government renewable

energy targets. We will addressinteraction of electricity and gasmarkets as part of the wholesalemarket design.

5.1.4 We will work with ACER and the CEERto seek common European solutions to the challenges our market faces, where practicable.

5.1.5 The Commission will seek to minimisecurtailment of renewable generatorsby increasing incentives forconventional generators to be moreflexible, by stimulating demand sideparticipation and by efficient use ofinterconnectors. The SEMC/CER, under DS3, will complete a review ofancillary services to encourage flexiblegeneration and demand sideparticipation and the Commission willseek to ensure that any new ancillaryservice arrangements are monitoredand reviewed regularly to ensureefficient delivery of flexible generatorand/or demand side operation.

The Commission has developed four strategies which are designed to achieve Strategic Goal Five. These strategies tie together over the course of this Strategic Plan to facilitate competitive prices and an enhancedcustomer experience.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL FIVE

Page 27: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

25COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

5.2 Competition in Markets and Competitive Prices

We will promote competition in Retail andWholesale markets to ensure prices are at thecompetitive level. At the same time all consumersmust be afforded the necessary protections toensure they can access and benefit fromcompetition in the retail market.

Effective competition is generally regarded assuperior to regulation in achieving efficient prices.Competitive markets should bring prices to theefficient level by each firm competing on the basisof price and quality of service , thus empoweringconsumers and giving them choice.

ACTIONS 5.2

5.2.1 We will ensure that retail energymarkets have a competitive structure,as well as through the SEM Committeepromoting competition at a wholesalelevel. We shall continue to monitor themarket to ensure firms are chargingcompetitive prices and set market ruleswhich facilitate competitive behaviourboth at the wholesale and the retaillevel. If markets are not achievingcompetitive outcomes, we willintervene using our powers to ensurethat consumers are protected and,ideally, competition is restored.

5.2.2 The Commission will revise and keepunder review its retail monitoringframework as necessary to support ourrole in ensuring effective competitionand customer choice.

5.2.3 Competitive markets need well-informed and empowered consumers,and the CER will act to ensure that allconsumers are protected against anyunfair practices while also havinginformation that will enable them toswitch. It will do this by ensuring ahigh level of information in themarket, and requiring all marketparticipants to offer clear andtransparent pricing offers. It will alsoensure that all consumers have theability to switch suppliers easily, thusfurther promoting competition andchoice.

5.2.4 The Commission will investigate anybarriers to switching, what steps might

be available to stimulate or encourageswitching activity among those whohave never switched.

5.2.5 The forthcoming roll-out of SmartEnergy Meters will change the way inwhich consumers purchase energy. TheCommission will act to ensure that thisroll-out stimulates competition, byensuring a range of offerings areavailable to customers that enhancechoice and allow informed comparisonof different offers.

Page 28: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

26 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

5.3 Incentivising Monopolies

Networks are natural monopolies, and constitute a large part of the cost of each service,particularly for water. While the CER willencourage contestability where possible in energynetwork development, most of the networks will be subject to ongoing price regulationdesigned to ensure network prices are at thecompetitive level.

ACTIONS 5.3

5.3.1 We will ensure networks arebenchmarked internationally to driveefficiency gains.

5.3.2 We will place tough incentives onmonopolies to drive improvements intheir performance without sacrificingservice quality.

5.4 Innovation and Consumer Welfare

A key to ensuring competitive markets and fairprices to consumers is ensuring that entry barriersare as low as possible, and that innovative newproducts and services are encouraged. Innovationcan lead to major reductions in consumer costs, as witnessed in areas such as telecommunicationsand airlines. The CER will act to ensure entrybarriers are kept as low as possible, and that new products and services can be offered for the benefit of consumers.

We will promote innovation and new productsthat can reduce prices and enhance consumerwelfare.

A key focus for the CER is the rollout of newdigital meters to residential and small businesscustomers in Ireland. This is being managed underthe National Smart Metering Programme (NSMP).This will allow existing and new entrants to usethe new metering system to offer innovative newproducts which can benefit consumers, facilitatesmart grids and further stimulate competition byspurring their competitors to react.

ACTIONS 5.4

5.4.1 We will ensure that new energy metersunder the NSMP and the IT systembacking them up permit a wide rangeof products and solutions to be usedby a large number of entrants.

5.4.2 We will generally act to limit barriersto new entry in all markets. We willfocus on ensuring customers canswitch to new providers, and bylimiting any artificially high barriers toentering wholesale or retail markets.

5.4.3 We will where appropriate provideincentives to stimulate efficientinnovation, both through networkreviews as well as increased emphasison areas such as demand-sidemeasures. This process of continualinnovation should provide a widerrange of choice for consumers as wellas driving down prices of existingservices.

Page 29: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

The Commission has a set of values which inform its work.

Through our Values we commit to:

• act in the public interest• act with integrity • deal professionally with our stakeholders• listen to what people have to say• be proportionate and objective; take balanced decisions• transparency• be accountable for our decisions and for the way we spend our resources• value and develop our staff – they are our chief resource

Values, and the behaviours they drive, define the organisation and what the public can expectof it. They represent the standards in public office we set for ourselves. If the values arerelevant, and we live up to them, we can deliver a regulatory service that meets bestinternational practice, which will support the organisation in the delivery of Strategic GoalsOne to Five.

MEASURES OF SUCCESS

• An organisation whose decision making demonstrates best regulatory practice beingfollowed.

• Leaders who foster an organisational culture of commitment to living up to its values.• Committed professional staff equipped with the necessary skills, knowledge, and

experience required to do their job.

TO ENSURE THAT

“Regulation is Best International Practice”LIVING UP TO OUR VALUES

STRATEGIC GOAL SIX

27COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

Page 30: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

28 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

6.1 Values

The Commission’s role has changed significantlysince its foundation. The Commission iscommitted to ensuring our values are relevant tothe role we fulfil today and into the future, andthat we live up to those values as we deliver thecorporate functions, operational work andprojects of CER which are key to pursuit of our goals.

ACTION 6.1

6.1.1 We will undertake a review of how welive up to our values as we undertakethe delivery of all our legislativeresponsibilities.

6.2 Human Resource Management

The achievement of the goals set out in thisstrategic plan and the significant corporateservices within CER which facilitate this, relies onthe knowledge and expertise of our staff and theirjudgement in developing policies,recommendations and decisions. The Commissionis committed to developing and supporting ourstaff. We will use human resource planning toidentify and balance the training and developmentneeds of the organisation and our staff. We willensure our Performance Management andDevelopment system is in line with best practicefor the public sector and is aligned with work plandelivery. An integral part of this will include acommitment to align and develop skills andresources with our business plan priorities.

Given the specialised and continually developingnature of the water and energy sectors,considerable time and effort must be spenttraining and developing staff and ensuring thatinformation is captured and imparted freely acrossthe organisation. Knowledge management,retention and transfer within the Commission is ahigh priority.

ACTIONS 6.2

6.2.1 We will ensure our Resource Planningsystem identifies the skills andcompetency requirements of theorganisation and aligns and developsthis to our staff.

6.2.2 We will continue to implement a bestpractice Performance Managementand Development system.

6.2.3 We will implement a knowledgemanagement system appropriate tothe evolving needs of the organisation.

6.2.4 Our training and developmentprogramme, our resource planningactivities and our business planningactivities will be aligned.

The Commission has developed five strategies which are designed to achieve Goal Six. These strategies over thecourse of this plan 2014 - 2018 will deliver the goal of providing a regulatory service to best international practice.

STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE STRATEGIC GOAL SIX

Page 31: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

29COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

6.3 Integrated Business Planning

This Strategic Plan establishes the goals andobjectives for the organisation. We will developand implement an integrated business planningprocess. This will focus on management processeswhich provide a clear link between our strategyand our annual and quarterly work planning andreporting process. This will operate alongside ourresource planning/performance managementprocesses.

ACTION 6.3

6.3.1 We will implement an integratedbusiness planning process which willprovide a clear link between individualobjectives and the Commission’s goals.

6.4 Regulatory Practice

The Commission, in this strategic plan, commits toregulate to best international practice. Our activemembership of various international regulatoryfora such as ACER4, CEER5 and EUOAG6, as well asour engagement with internationalagencies/regulators, allows us to build ourknowledge base on best practice and share ourown experience of regulatory practice.Domestically, there is a drive to deliver bestpractice in the public sector. The GovernmentStatement on Economic Regulation and ongoinginitiatives in the area of public sector reform(Public Sector Reform Plan 2014-2016) arerelevant in this regard. The Commission commitsto active involvement in these areas to facilitatedelivery of best regulatory practice. A goodexample is the application of formal RegulatoryImpact Assessment (RIA) within the Commission’sdecision making process.

ACTION 6.4

6.4.1 We will subject our regulatory practiceto regular review and document andimplement best regulatory practice.

6.4.2 We will specifically review theapplication of formal RIA within theCommission’s decision making process.

4 ACER Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators5 Council of European Energy Regulators6 EU Offshore Authorities Group

Page 32: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

30 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

6.5 Stakeholder Engagement

The Commission’s expanded remit across energyand water and between economic and safetyregulation necessarily puts our stakeholders at thecentre of our strategy. The Irish citizen is ourultimate stakeholder and this is borne out in theCommission’s clear public interest remit across ourvarious legislative functions. We are committed toeffective communication with all our stakeholderson matters relevant to our statutory remit.

This Strategic Plan identifies and recognises thecritical role energy and water plays in the lives ofcitizens, commerce and industry. It acknowledgestheir need for access to safe, secure, reliable andcompetitively priced energy and water. We haveidentified the increasingly integrated nature ofenergy networks and markets (the SEM and ourrelationship with UR is a prime example), and theincreasing drive from Europe towards the singleenergy market and international co-operation onsafety matters.

Aspects of the Commission’s work are directlyrelevant to environmental policy (e.g. PSO, Gate3). Previous strategic plans included a specificenvironmental goal. Increasingly the focus is onco-operation with the relevant environmentagency; notably the EPA. This is reflected in theMoU between both agencies (subject to ongoingreview). While the Commission will continue tofulfil our statutory functions as they relate to theenvironment, we recognise the increasinglyintegrated nature of environmental andenergy/water regulation; both in terms of safetyand economic regulation.

The Commission is also committed to workingwith our EU institutions and relevant agencies toprovide constructive input to EU policy andlegislative developments with a specific aim toensure the interests of the Irish consumer areprotected.

We will pursue joint initiatives with relevantagencies in the field of energy regulation andwater regulation in this spirit. As appropriate, wewill agree a joint programme of work of realisticand achievable outcomes which are of mutualbenefit. We will adopt a set of practical oversightand working arrangements to help us deliver onour commitments.

Finally, we are committed to working with all ourstakeholders in a spirit of open dialogue, trust andmutual respect.

ACTION 6.5

The Commission will continue to pursue astructured, co-operative and mutuallybeneficial engagement with a broad range of statutory and non-statutory stakeholders,on a formal basis as necessary, across threebroad groupings:

6.5.1 National6.5.2 North/South (All-Island)6.5.3 International

Page 33: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

31COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

Page 34: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

32 COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018

REGULATING WATER, ENERGY AND ENERGY SAFETY IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST

THE COMMISSION MUST BE EQUIPPED TO MEET THE

CHALLENGES IN THE ENERGY AND WATER SECTORS OVER THE

PERIOD OF THIS STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 – 2018 AND BEYOND.

THE PACE OF DRAMATIC CHANGE IS LIKELY TO CONTINUE IN

THE ENERGY SECTOR. DECISIONS ON SMART METERING,

DEVELOPMENTS IN RETAIL COMPETITION, CHANGES TO

WHOLESALE MARKETS, THE EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SAFETY

REGULATION ARE SET TO ALTER THE LANDSCAPE FOR ALL

PLAYERS AND STAKEHOLDERS. THE WATER SECTOR WILL

WITNESS A PERIOD OF PROFOUND CHANGE AND CHALLENGE.

THROUGHOUT ALL THIS THE CUSTOMER INTEREST, WHETHER

IN TERMS OF PROTECTING LIFE OR ENSURING CUSTOMER

WELFARE IS PROTECTED, WILL BE TO THE FOREFRONT OF THE

COMMISSION’S THINKING.

THE COMMISSION WILL STRIVE TO ACHIEVE OUR VISION TO

PROTECT THE INTERESTS OF THE PUBLIC, AND THAT ALL

CONSUMERS USE ENERGY AND WATER IN A SAFE AND

INFORMED MANNER. WE MUST DO THIS IN LINE WITH OUR

MISSION AND IN KEEPING WITH OUR VALUES.

THIS STRATEGIC PLAN IS THE HIGH LEVEL DESCRIPTION OF

HOW THIS WILL BE ACHIEVED BETWEEN 2014 AND 2018.

CONCLUDING REMARKS

Page 35: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,
Page 36: STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 · STRATEGIC PLAN 2014 - 2018 REGULATING WATER, ... Modern society demands and expects safe, secure energy and clean water, ... but also the opportunity,

COMMISSION FOR ENERGY REGULATION (CER)The Exchange, Belgard Square North, Tallaght, Dublin 24T: 01 4000 800 | F: 01 4000 850 | [email protected] | www.cer.ie