student and institutional benefits of effective peer tutoring programs dr. preston vanloon iowa...
TRANSCRIPT
Student and Institutional Benefits of Effective Peer Tutoring
Programs
Dr. Preston VanLoonIowa Wesleyan College
MRADE ConferenceSeptember 2009
A Definition of a Peer Tutor:
“A one to one or small group teaching experience where one person who is knowledgeable and has expertise in a specific content area or discipline provides tutelage, help, or clarification to another who does not.” (Gier, 1994)
Tutor Academic Gains
• Improved academic self-concept. (Astin, 1993)
• Tutors obtain a greater mastery of course content. (Johnson, Sulzer-Azaroff, & Mass, 1977; Mc
Keachie, Pintrich, Lin, & Smith, 1986)
• Greater conceptual understanding of the concepts they teach to other college students.
(Bargh & Schul, 1980; Benware & Deci, 1984)
• Significant gains in learning as a result of their collaborative interaction. (Whitman, 1988)
Tutor Personal Benefits
• Improved interpersonal skills
• Improved communication skills
• Flexibility in scheduling
• Satisfaction of helping others
• Increased confidence
• Extra spending money
• Increase teambuilding skills
• Develop leadership skills
• Certification
(Johnson, Sulzer-Azaroff, & Mass, 1977; Mc Keachie, Pintrich, Lin, & Smith, 1986; Whitman, 1988; Bargh & Schul, 1980; Benware & Deci, 1984).
Tutee Academic Gains• Similar-age peers in a less threatening
environment. (Gross & McMullen, 1983)
• Similar amounts of prior experience with the
concept being learned and at a more proximal stage of cognitive development. (Vygotsky, 1978)
• Development of higher-level thinking skills.
(Kurfiss, 1988)
Tutee Personal Benefits
• Feel more at ease, and concentrate better on the subject matter, with a peer tutor rather than a professional teacher or consultant.
• Develop friendship from the students that tutor them.
• Receive individualized instruction
• Receive more teaching
Tutee Personal Benefits continued:
• Respond better to their peers.
• Academic achievement.
• Increased self esteem.
• Greater academic motivation.
• Become self directed/independent learners.
(Sheets, 1994)
Institutions
What are some of the benefits that higher education institutions receive from peer tutoring programs?
Institutions
• Retention of underrepresented and disadvantaged students with underdeveloped basic-academic skills (National Academy of Sciences-National Research Council, 1977).
• Peer tutoring is a cost-effective support strategy. (Levin, Glass and Meiser, 1984)
Characteristics of Effective Tutoring
Programs:
• Highly structured training. (Brandwine &
DiVittis, 1985; Santee, 2006)
• Supervision and monitoring of tutors. (Brewster, 2007)
• Course credit and grade. (Brewster, 2007)
Characteristics continued
• Supplemental activities to the regular classroom instruction. (Lidren, et. al., 1991)
• Tutors selected with faculty involvement based on academic abilities and motivation. (Brewster, 2007, Santee, 2006)
• Compensation (Santee, 2006; Oesterreich, 2000)
• Advanced training for tutors. (Johansen et. al., 1992)
Student Centered Peer Tutoring Programs…
• Take more responsibility for their education.
• Engage in self and peer assessment.
• Evaluate their own strengths and weaknesses.
• Become aware of their personal and
academic development while at college. (Saunders, 1992)
Learning Benefits of Peer Tutoring• A reduced pupil-teacher ratio that results in
quicker feedback and prompting.
• More active learning with greater student ownership of the learning process.
• Better application of knowledge and skills to new situations.
• Greater self-disclosure and opportunities to respond may also result in less anxiety and fear of making errors.
(Brewster, 2007; Greenwood, Carta, and Kamps,1990)
A Developmental
Research Based Peer Tutoring Program:
Iowa Wesleyan College
Academic Resource Center
Peer Tutoring Program
Personnel:
• Two staff
1 full-time associate
1 part-time writing specialist
• $11, 000 Peer Tutor Budget
• 16 Peer Tutors
• Work 3-4 hours per week
• By drop-in or appointment
Requirements to be a Peer Tutor:
• Recommendation of Professor to tutor in content area
• Grades of A or B in content area of tutoring
• Interview with ARC director
• Take two required tutoring courses
• Be a caring and empathetic person
Tutors are recruited through:• Referrals from Professors
• Advertising
• Financial Aid Office
• Other Tutors
• Word of Mouth
• Other Sources
Peer Tutoring Courses:
• EDUC 200: Introduction to Peer Tutoring
(1 credit)
• EDUC 201: Advanced Peer Tutoring
(1 credit)
Level One Training:EDUC 200: Introduction to Peer TutoringSession 1: Definition of Tutoring, Tutor Roles and ResponsibilitiesSession 2: Steps of the Tutoring CycleSession 3: CommunicationSession 4: Ethics and TutoringSession 5: Do’s and Don’ts of TutoringSession 6: Planning Session 7: Critical Thinking Session 8: Problem SolvingSession 9: Study SkillsSession 10: Note-Taking
Level Two Training (EDUC 200 continued):Session 11: Reading College TextbooksSession 12: Objective Test Taking StrategiesSession 13: Writing Session 14: Referrals Session 15: Documentation
EDUC 201: Advanced Peer TutoringSession 1: Learning Styles and Learning DifferencesSession 2: Cultural AwarenessSession 3: Content Area TutoringSession 4: Tutoring Techniques: Probing QuestionsSession 5: Preparing for Exams and Test Anxiety
Level Three Training (EDUC 201 cont.)
Session 6: Time Management Skills
Session 7: The Tutor-Tutee Relationship
Session 8: Resources for Tutors
Session 9: Multiple Intelligences and Tutoring
Session 10: Group and Individual Tutoring
Session 11: Reading Difficulties: Dyslexia
Session 12: Empathy and Tutoring
Session 13: Assertiveness
Session 14: Memory Strategies
Session 15: Professionalism
Texts:
• The College Reading and Learning Association’s Tutor Training Handbook, Revised Edition (2003).
• The Master Tutor: A Guidebook for More Effective Tutoring, 2nd Edition, The Cambridge Stratford Study Skills Institute
Types of Tutoring done by tutors:
1. One-on-one
2. Small group
3. Review sessions
4. Supplemental Instruction
5. Assisting professor in the classroom
Tutor Benefits at IWC:
• Hourly Salary
• Tuition Free Tutoring Courses
• Bookstore Discounts
• Academic Credit
• International Certification (CRLA)
• Resume
• Future Job References
• Pizza Parties
Questions ?
Contact Information:
Dr. Preston VanLoon, Associate ProfessorIowa Wesleyan College601 N. Main StreetMt. Pleasant, Iowa [email protected](319) 385-6376