sudden death in racing greyhounds - wordpress.com · sudden death in racing greyhounds ... overview...

38
Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS Hon. Senior Fellow of University of Liverpool School of Veterinary Science

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jun-2020

30 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds

Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVSHon. Senior Fellow of University of Liverpool School of Veterinary Science

Page 2: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

GBGB Sudden Death Survey

• Started August 2006.

• Suggestion by track vet Di Hodgson that sudden deaths should be investigated.

• Developed into a survey by Hazel Bentall/NGRC.

• Now run by Richard Payne for the GBGB.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

2

Page 3: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Histopathologists

• RVC team led by Dr Ken Smith.

• Dr Udo Hetzel (Liverpool vet school).

• Dr Peter Brown (Nottingham vet school).

• Carol Richardson (Greendale Labs) –early stages of the survey.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

3

Page 4: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

How the Survey Works

• Reported directly by track vet or racing office to Richard Payne on:▫ 07970 368702

• Three couriers transport frozen body to one of three centres:▫ Nottingham▫ RVC▫ Liverpool

• Standardized PME.• Reported back to GBGB.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

4

Page 5: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Organization into Thirds

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

5

Page 6: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Data Security

• All parties have a unique ID:▫ Track

▫ Track vet

▫ Greyhound

▫ Trainer

• Only GBGB know the true identities.

• Only GBGB uses the data.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

6

Page 7: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

RCVS Regulations

• Verbal consent from agent/owner.

• Only the reason for death is investigated.

• No unrelated research performed on samples.

• Samples are retained for retrospective analysis.

• Data is anonymized.

• Data only used for epidemiology.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

7

Page 8: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Added Extras

• Survey acts as a surveillance tool for disease:▫ Acute Haemorrhagic Pneumonia

▫ Canine Influenza

▫ Kennel Cough

▫ Kennel Sickness

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

8

Page 9: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Overall Rate

• 6.5 per 10,000 races.

• About two per month for all GBGB tracks.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

9

Page 10: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Any Guesses?

• What do you think the main diagnosis is ?

• My vote was for acute cardiac failure.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

10

Page 11: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths

• 131 Cases of sudden death comprising...• 46 Acute abdominal haemorrhage• 19 Acute haemorrhagic pneumonia• 18 Other (FB, peritonitis, lymphoma, [single cases])• 17 Acute cardiac failure• 12 No diagnosis (? Cardiac)• 6 Vertebral # (mainly cervical 2)• 4 Acute gastric dilation +/- volvulus• 4 Haemorrhagic gastroenteritis• 1 Str. zooepidemicus• 1 No PME (putrefaction)

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

11

Page 12: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Bar Chart of Diagnoses

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

12

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

NoDx AAH ACF Other AGDV StrZoo AHP HGE Ce# NK

Fre

qu

en

cy

ShortDx

Frequency Distribution

Page 13: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Overview of Three Syndromes

• Acute Abdominal Haemorrhage – AAH

• Acute Cardiac Failure – ACF

• Canine Haemorrhagic Pneumonia - CHP

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

13

Page 14: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

AAH

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

14

Page 15: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acute Abdominal Haemorrhage

• Big surprise.

• Multifocal bleeding from small vessels within the surface of the iliopsoas muscles.

• Muscle fascia ruptures to release blood into the abdomen in ~40% of cases.

• Repeat bleeds seen on histology:▫ 13/46 cases were repeat bleeds

▫ 9 of these 13 had healing blood vessels

▫ 8 of these 9 had scarring

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

15

Page 16: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Signs of AAH

• Usually appear 1-5 minutes post race:▫ Ataxia▫ Dyspnoea▫ Cyanosis

• Possible others for non-fatal AAH:▫ Weakness▫ Cramp (due to scarring)▫ Sudden-onset poor performance▫ Slow recovery▫ Anaemia

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

16

Page 17: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

PM Findings

• Subserosal capillary ruptures▫ Iliopsoas

▫ Gracilis, semimembranosus, deep gluteal

• Retroperitoneal haemorrhage▫ Bursts into abdomen

• Sudden hypovolaemia is fatal▫ High metabolic demand

▫ Vital organs not perfused (organ weights)

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

17

Page 18: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Organ Weights - Liver

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

18

300

500

700

900

1100

1300

AAH ACF Other dx

G_

liv

er

Dx

95% CI Notched Outlier Boxplot

95% CI Mean Diamond

Outliers > 3 IQR

Page 19: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

19

Page 20: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

20

Page 21: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

21

Histology of iliopsoas showing haemorrhage.

Page 22: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Possible Mechanisms (1)

• Hip hyperextension stresses the iliopsoas▫ Related to eccentric contraction at end of hip

extension (known risk factor for muscle injury)▫ Acceleration phase (first 30-50 m)

• Tension on mesentery▫ Lumbar spine dorsiflexion▫ Gut mass shuttle

• Previous bleed scars may affect muscle function▫ More tearing▫ Recurrent cramp

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

22

Page 23: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Possible Mechanisms (2)

• Fascial compression syndrome▫ Muscle swelling inside rigid envelope

▫ Ischaemia & infarction

▫ Degeneration & scarring

• Form of capture myopathy▫ Doesn’t fit clinical picture

• Acute rhabdomyolysis▫ Ditto

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

23

Page 24: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Possible Contributing Factors

• Hypertension▫ Known exercise & greyhound problem

▫ Some cases do have glomerular damage

• Thin vessel walls▫ Histological evidence present.

• No evidence for a genetic link

• No seasonal link

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

24

Page 25: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Treatment of AAH

• Bleeding is slow but persistent.

• Usually die within 15-20 minutes.

• Fast IV fluids.

• Coagulative agents – tranexamic acid (a.k.a. aminocaproic acid).

• Is it worthwhile?

• No cases have survived the clinical phase.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

25

Page 26: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Prevention and Detection of AAH

• Non-fatal haemorrhage does occur.

• Impossible to detect by clinical examination.

• History of persistent cramping.

• Undiagnosed sublumbar pain 1-4 days post-race.

• Poor recovery.

• Anaemia.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

26

Page 27: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Future Work

• Ultrasound.

• M.R.I.

• Fibrin degradation products▫ Difficult to do on PM blood samples.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

27

Page 28: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

ACF

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

28

Page 29: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acute Cardiac Failure

• Die at the pickup.

• Usually run very well (Cf. AAH which have slow last races).

• Possible causes:▫ Hyperkalaemia (fatal arrhythmia)

▫ Commotio cordis

▫ Sudden fall in venous return

▫ Hypoxia

▫ Lactic acidosis

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

29

Page 30: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Links with Racehorses and Athletes.

• The BHA is setting up its own sudden death survey with the advice from the GBGB.

• Possible similarities to human iliopsoas strain▫ Humans run using hip hyperextension

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

30

Page 31: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

APH

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

31

Page 32: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acute Haemorrhagic Pneumonia (1)

Sudden onset respiratory disease

• Lethargy

• Tachypnoea

• Pyrexic

• Coughing is not typical▫ Can be caught out that it is not a respiratory disease

• Die within 24-36 hours without aggressive therapy

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

32

Page 33: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acute Haemorrhagic Pneumonia (2)

Diagnosis

• Report to GBGB / Richard Payne▫ Epidemiological information needed from trainer

▫ Case history & treatment details from vet

• Samples to AHT (need GBGB permission first)▫ Plain blood

▫ Plain nasal swab

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

33

Page 34: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acute Haemorrhagic Pneumonia (3)

Treatment

• Needs aggressive i/v therapy for good prognosis

• Antibiotics

• NSAIDs

• Fluids according to need

• Oral and/or s/c therapy is not effective▫ Slight response

▫ Relapse common

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

34

Page 35: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

The survey is still active

• Sudden deaths▫ GBGB tracks

▫ Kennels

• Disease▫ Enteric infections

▫ Respiratory infections AHT interested in canine resp’y disease esp recent case of

H3N8 canine influenza.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

35

Page 36: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Summary

• EAD is rare (2 cases/month for UK).• Two main diagnoses at tracks:

▫ AAH▫ ACF

• Possible mechanisms need more work.• No risk factors identified.• AAH has subclinical component.

• Survey also monitors general kennel diseases.• CHP epidemiology.• Ongoing.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

36

Page 37: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

Acknowledgments

• Dr Sarah Williams – greyhound videos.

• Dr Peter Brown – gross pictures.

• Dr Udo Hetzel – histology pictures.

• GBGB for the funding & support.

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

37

Page 38: Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds - WordPress.com · Sudden Death in Racing Greyhounds ... Overview of Numbers for all Sudden Deaths •131 Cases of sudden death comprising... •46

All Done.

• Thank you.

• Any questions?

© 2010 Richard Payne MA VetMB HonFIRVAP MRCVS

38