supporting information - pnas information méheust et al. 10.1073/pnas.1517551113 s-gene expression...
TRANSCRIPT
Supporting InformationMéheust et al. 10.1073/pnas.1517551113S-Gene Expression AnalysisGiven that the analysis using dozens of algal and protist genomicdatasets showed that homologs of all of the S genes are expressed,we asked whether some of them might be differentially expressedin response to stress. This question was motivated by two ob-servations: (i) The composite genes entered eukaryote nucleargenomes via primary endosymbiosis, and therefore they may stillretain ancient cyanobacterial functions even when fused to noveldomains, and (ii) many of the S genes are redox enzymes orencode domains involved in redox regulation, and therefore theirroles may involve sensing and/or responding to cellular stressresulting from the oxygen-evolving photosynthetic organelle. Toaddress this issue, we inspected RNA-seq data from organismsthat encoded particular S genes that had either been generatedunder conditions of cellular stress or spanned the light–darktransition. For genes present in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, weused data from ref. 53 that compared triplicate transcript datafrom this alga grown in standard Tris-acetate-phosphate (TAP)medium (54) or TAP with the addition of 200 mM NaCl. Thecomposite gene families 10, 24, and 18 showed significant dif-ferential expression (DE) under salt stress [up-regulation in bothcases (P = 4.14e-4, P = 0.0268, and P = 0.0077, respectively)].These genes encode bacterial–cyanobacterial domain fusionsthat are involved in stress responses (i.e., rhodanese domain in10) and in preventing protein misfolding (i.e., DnaJ/Hsp40 do-main at the N terminus of 24). Interestingly, the DnaJ domain isfused to an upstream SCP superfamily region that likely forms an
extracellular domain. This novel protein is found only in greenalgae and plants, and may play a role in responding to salt stress.For S genes present in the diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum,
we used RNA-seq data from ref. 30 that compared culturesgrown under control and nitrogen (N)-depleted conditions. Thisanalysis showed that out of six families present in this alga (2, 1,28, 20, 35, 61), three are differentially expressed under N stress(28, 35, 61). One of these is family 28, which encodes anN-terminal bacterium-derived, calcium-sensing EF-hand domainfused, intriguingly, to a cyanobacterium-derived region with sim-ilarity to the plastid inner-membrane proten import componentTic20, which acts as a translocon channel. This fused protein mayuse Ca2+ as a signal for protein import, and is found in severalstramenopile (brown algal) species. The homolog in P. tricornutum(NCBI gi:219117465) is significantly down-regulated (P = 2.57e-23)under N depletion.Finally, for S genes present in Arabidopsis thaliana, we used
RNA-seq data reflecting light-dependent DE in seedlings, coty-ledons, and roots (14). This analysis showed that four distinctS-gene families have DE in plant tissues in the presence of light(14, 19, 1, 18). One of the gene families showing DE is family 1,which is broadly distributed in algae and plants and is composedof a cyanobacterium-derived N-terminal hydrolase domain fusedto a non-cyanobacterium-derived LPLAT family (lysophospho-lipid acyltransferases) domain. This gene was significantly up-regulated in all three plant tissues in the presence of light.
Méheust et al. www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/1517551113 1 of 5
Glo
eoch
aete
.witr
ocki
ana.
SAG
46_8
4C
para
doxa
Cya
nidi
osch
yzon
.mer
olae
.stra
in.1
0DPo
rphy
ridiu
m.a
erug
ineu
m.S
AG.1
380.
2C
mer
olae
Rho
della
.mac
ulat
a.C
CM
P73
6ca
rragh
een
Gsu
lphu
raria
Ery
thro
lobu
s.au
stra
licus
.CC
MP
3124
Rho
doso
rus.
mar
inus
.UTE
X.L
B.2
760
Ppu
rpur
eum
Mad
agas
caria
.ery
thro
clad
iode
s.C
CM
P32
34E
ryth
rolo
bus.
mad
agas
care
nsis
.CC
MP
3276
Tim
spur
ckia
.olig
opyr
enoi
des.
CC
MP
3278
Com
psop
ogon
.coe
rule
us.S
AG.3
6.94
Gal
dier
ia.s
ulph
urar
iaR
hodo
soru
s.m
arin
us.C
CM
P76
9O
stre
ococ
cus.
taur
iV
carte
riP
icoc
ystis
.sal
inar
um.C
CM
P18
97M
icro
mon
as.s
p..R
CC
299
Mpu
silla
Ota
uri
Chl
orel
la.v
aria
bilis
Cre
inha
rdtii
Auxe
noch
lore
lla.p
roto
thec
oide
sC
sube
llips
oide
aho
llow
.gre
en.s
eaw
eed
Mic
rom
onas
.sp.
NE
PC
C29
Mic
rom
onas
.sp.
CC
MP
2099
Cva
riabi
lisD
unal
iella
.terti
olec
ta.C
CM
P13
20P
yram
imon
as.p
arke
ae.C
CM
P72
6O
stre
ococ
cus.
luci
mar
inus
.CC
E99
01C
occo
myx
a.su
belli
psoi
dea.
C.1
69M
icro
mon
as.s
p.R
CC
472
Tetra
selm
is.s
triat
a.LA
NL1
001
Chl
amyd
omon
as.re
inha
rdtii
Bat
hyco
ccus
.pra
sino
ssh
ephe
rd.s
.pur
sePe
dicu
laris
.ker
neri
Man
oao.
cole
nsoi
Zam
ia.k
ickx
iilo
ng.g
rain
ed.ri
ceC
ycas
.med
ia.s
ubsp
..med
iaD
acry
dium
.nau
sorie
nse
gray
.rock
cres
sZa
mia
.inte
grifo
liach
ickp
eaC
astil
leja
.rubi
cund
ula
Trip
hysa
ria.p
usill
aG
ossy
pium
.arb
oreu
mP
hero
spha
era.
fitzg
eral
dii
Cer
atoz
amia
.mira
ndae
Enc
epha
larto
s.hi
ldeb
rand
tiiC
horis
pora
.tene
llaE
utre
ma.
halo
philu
mPo
doca
rpus
.spa
thoi
des
Eut
rem
a.sa
lsug
ineu
mD
onto
stem
on.s
enili
sD
acry
dium
.gui
llaum
inii
Podo
carp
us.s
alig
nus
Enc
epha
larto
s.co
ncin
nus
Enc
epha
larto
s.ca
ffer
Enc
epha
larto
s.sc
lavo
iE
ncep
hala
rtos.
aem
ulan
sG
lyci
ne.s
oja
Pedi
cula
ris.k
ansu
ensi
sE
ncep
hala
rtos.
cyca
difo
lius
Nic
otia
na.to
men
tosi
form
isE
ncep
hala
rtos.
dyer
ianu
sS
elag
inel
la.m
oelle
ndor
ffii
Enc
epha
larto
s.gr
atus
Bos
chni
akia
.him
alai
cam
uskm
elon
Pie
ris.n
ana
Ste
rigm
oste
mum
.vio
lace
umA
ltens
tein
.s.b
read
.tree
Tozz
ia.a
lpin
aC
ordy
lant
hus.
ram
osus
Enc
epha
larto
s.w
oodi
iZa
mia
.pum
ilaPo
doca
rpus
.luci
enii
Cyc
as.li
tora
lisZa
mia
.hym
enop
hylli
dia
Eup
hras
ia.c
ollin
aO
roba
nche
.cal
iforn
ica
Nic
otia
na.b
enth
amia
naP
hysc
omitr
ella
.pat
ens
Enc
epha
larto
s.tri
spin
osus
com
mon
.sun
flow
erw
ood.
toba
cco
Eup
hras
ia.a
lsa
swee
t.ora
nge
Japa
nese
.rice
Enc
epha
larto
s.w
hite
lock
iiPo
pulu
s.eu
phra
tica
Mac
roza
mia
.fras
eri
Enc
epha
larto
s.ap
lana
tus
Eru
ca.v
esic
aria
Japa
nese
.apr
icot
mal
o.si
naPe
dicu
laris
.folio
saB
osch
niak
ia.ro
ssic
aC
ycas
.cha
mbe
rlain
iiE
ncep
hala
rtos.
prin
ceps
Cas
tille
ja.e
xser
taA
froca
rpus
.man
nii
Sac
char
um.h
ybrid
.cul
tivar
.R57
0Po
doca
rpus
.aris
tula
tus
Sol
anum
.dem
issu
mS
trobi
lant
hes.
atte
nuat
aA
frica
n.oi
l.pal
mA
ptos
imum
.pum
ilum
Enc
epha
larto
s.nu
bim
onta
nus
Pedi
cula
ris.tu
bero
saca
stor
.bea
nN
icot
iana
.atte
nuat
aC
itrus
.cle
men
tina
Mur
icar
ia.p
rost
rata
Frag
aria
.ves
ca.s
ubsp
..ves
casu
gar.b
eet
Podo
carp
us.g
uate
mal
ensi
sE
ucal
yptu
s.gr
andi
sE
ncep
hala
rtos.
kisa
mbo
Bra
ssic
a.ju
ncea
win
e.gr
ape
Zam
ia.p
ygm
aea
Zam
ia.a
cum
inat
aC
astil
leja
.tenu
isPo
doca
rpus
.cun
ning
ham
iiR
obes
chia
.sch
impe
riiJa
troph
a.cu
rcas
barr
el.m
edic
Cer
atoz
amia
.mor
ettii
Enc
epha
larto
s.cu
pidu
sfo
xtai
l.mill
etO
roba
nche
.ludo
vici
ana
Mac
roza
mia
.ste
nom
era
Nel
umbo
.nuc
ifera
Enc
epha
larto
s.do
lom
iticu
sbu
gle
appl
ePo
doca
rpus
.law
renc
eiC
astil
leja
.min
iata
Cle
ome.
hass
leria
naso
ybea
nPo
doca
rpus
.tota
raZa
mia
.neu
roph
yllid
iaLe
com
tella
.mad
agas
carie
nsis
spot
ted.
mon
key.
flow
erLe
pido
zam
ia.p
erof
fsky
ana
Enc
epha
larto
s.le
hman
nii
Enc
epha
larto
s.itu
riens
isP
hase
olus
.vul
garis
Pyr
us.x
.bre
tsch
neid
eri
Cer
atoz
amia
.mix
eoru
mE
ncep
hala
rtos.
long
ifoliu
sC
ycas
.xip
hole
pis
Enc
epha
larto
s.se
ntic
osus
Enc
epha
larto
s.tra
nsve
nosu
sfie
ld.m
usta
rdC
ycas
.mac
onoc
hiei
Enc
epha
larto
s.pt
erog
onus
Triti
cum
.ura
rtuE
ncep
hala
rtos.
euge
ne.m
arai
sii
Afro
carp
us.fa
lcat
usG
lech
oma.
hede
race
aC
ycas
.cal
cico
laE
ncep
hala
rtos.
mun
chii
Ret
roph
yllu
m.c
ompt
onii
Rhe
um.a
ustra
leM
orus
.not
abili
sZa
mia
.por
toric
ensi
sM
adag
asca
r.per
iwin
kle
Ory
za.o
ffici
nalis
Enc
epha
larto
s.la
natu
sE
ncep
hala
rtos.
lebo
mbo
ensi
sC
apse
lla.ru
bella
Ara
bido
psis
.lyra
ta.s
ubsp
..lyr
ata
sesa
me
wild
.Mal
aysi
an.b
anan
aC
erat
ozam
ia.m
ique
liana
Enc
epha
larto
s.m
idde
lbur
gens
isPe
nste
mon
.cob
aea
Dac
rydi
um.x
anth
andr
umLa
miu
m.p
urpu
reum
sorg
hum
Est
erha
zya.
cam
pest
risdo
mes
ticat
ed.b
arle
yth
ale.
cres
sE
ncep
hala
rtos.
inop
inus
Ret
roph
yllu
m.m
inus
Che
lone
.obl
iqua
Hirs
chfe
ldia
.inca
naA
froca
rpus
.gra
cilio
rC
amel
ina.
sativ
aAu
reol
aria
.ped
icul
aria
Enc
epha
larto
s.fri
deric
i.gui
lielm
iO
roba
nche
.pin
orum
caca
ora
pePo
doca
rpus
.cor
iace
usA
egilo
ps.ta
usch
iiE
ncep
hala
rtos.
ngoy
anus
Sitk
a.sp
ruce
Orth
ocar
pus.
brac
teos
usE
ncep
hala
rtos.
cerin
usM
acro
zam
ia.p
lurin
ervi
aC
ycas
.thou
arsi
iD
acry
dium
.bal
ansa
ePo
lygo
natu
m.p
ubes
cens
Gen
lisea
.aur
eaE
ncep
hala
rtos.
ghel
linck
iiZe
a.m
ays
Pht
heiro
sper
mum
.japo
nicu
mPo
pulu
s.tre
mul
abl
ack.
cotto
nwoo
dC
astil
leja
.fiss
ifolia
Enc
epha
larto
s.ar
enar
ius
Pedi
cula
ris.ju
lica
Bra
chyp
odiu
m.d
ista
chyo
nC
astil
leja
.cris
ta.g
alli
date
.pal
mPo
doca
rpus
.acu
tifol
ius
cucu
mbe
rS
chiz
opet
alon
.wal
keri
tom
ato
peac
hpo
tato
Cer
atoz
amia
.hua
stec
orum
Dac
rydi
um.e
latu
mE
ncep
hala
rtos.
turn
eri
Cof
fea.
cane
phor
aA
mbo
rella
.tric
hopo
daA
froca
rpus
.usa
mba
rens
isN
agei
a.fo
rmos
ensi
sC
ucum
is.m
elo.
subs
p..m
elo
Rho
dom
onas
.sp.
CC
MP
768
Gui
llard
ia.th
eta.
CC
MP
2712
Gon
iom
onas
.pac
ifica
.CC
MP
1869
Gth
eta
Pry
mne
sium
.par
vum
.Tex
oma1
Em
ilian
ia.h
uxle
yi.C
CM
P15
16E
huxl
eyi
Ple
uroc
hrys
is.c
arte
rae.
CC
MP
645
Em
ilian
ia.h
uxle
yi.3
74Is
ochr
ysis
.gal
bana
.CC
MP
1323
Em
ilian
ia.h
uxle
yi.C
CM
P37
0Is
ochr
ysis
.sp.
CC
MP
1244
Chr
ysoc
hrom
ulin
a.po
lyle
pis.
CC
MP
1757
Em
ilian
ia.h
uxle
yi.3
79Pa
vlov
a.sp
.CC
MP
459
Isoc
hrys
is.s
p.C
CM
P13
24E
mili
ania
.hux
leyi
.PLY
M21
9G
ephy
roca
psa.
ocea
nica
.RC
C13
03B
nata
nsLo
thar
ella
.glo
bosa
.CC
CM
811
Aure
oum
bra.
lagu
nens
is.C
CM
P15
10A
anop
hage
ffere
nsE
ctoc
arpu
s.si
licul
osus
Cha
ttone
lla.s
ubsa
lsa.
CC
MP
2191
Och
rom
onas
.sp.
CC
MP
1393
Pse
udop
edin
ella
.ela
stic
a.C
CM
P71
6H
eter
osig
ma.
akas
hiw
o.C
CM
P23
93P
terid
omon
as.d
anic
a.P
TAu
reoc
occu
s.an
opha
geffe
rens
Nan
noch
loro
psis
.gad
itana
Het
eros
igm
a.ak
ashi
wo.
CC
MP
3107
Din
obry
on.s
p.U
TEX
LB22
67N
gadi
tana
Het
eros
igm
a.ak
ashi
wo.
CC
MP
452
Vauc
heria
.lito
rea.
CC
MP
2940
Pela
goco
ccus
.sub
virid
is.C
CM
P14
29Pe
lago
mon
as.c
alce
olat
a.C
CM
P17
56H
eter
osig
ma.
akas
hiw
o.N
BAu
reoc
occu
s.an
opha
geffe
rens
.CC
MP
1850
Tpse
udon
ana
Frag
ilario
psis
.ker
guel
ensi
s.L2
_C3
Thal
assi
osira
.wei
ssflo
gii.C
CM
P10
10P
seud
o_ni
tzsc
hia.
fradu
lent
a.W
WA
7Th
alas
sios
ira.o
cean
ica
Thal
assi
osira
.wei
ssflo
gii.C
CM
P13
36A
mph
ipro
ra.s
pE
xtub
ocel
lulu
s.sp
inife
r.CC
MP
396
Thal
assi
osira
.ant
arct
ica.
CC
MP
982
Thal
assi
othr
ix.a
ntar
ctic
a.L6
_D1
Cha
etoc
eros
.affi
nis.
CC
MP
159
Dity
lum
.brig
htw
ellii
.GS
O10
3C
haet
ocer
os.d
ebili
s.M
M31
A_1
Thal
assi
osira
.rotu
la.G
SO
102
Cha
etoc
eros
.cur
vise
tus
Dity
lum
.brig
htw
ellii
.GS
O10
5D
itylu
m.b
right
wel
lii.G
SO
104
Thal
assi
osira
.rotu
la.C
CM
P30
96S
kele
tone
ma.
dohr
nii.S
kelB
Thal
assi
osira
.min
iscu
la.C
CM
P10
93S
kele
tone
ma.
mar
inoi
.Ske
lAS
kele
tone
ma.
men
zelii
.CC
MP
793
Nitz
schi
a.pu
ncta
ta.C
CM
P56
1P
haeo
dact
ylum
.tric
ornu
tum
.CC
AP
.105
5.1
Am
phor
a.co
ffeae
form
is.C
CM
P12
7P
robo
scia
.ala
ta.P
I_D
3C
haet
ocer
os.n
eogr
acile
.CC
MP
1317
Ast
erio
nello
psis
.gla
cial
is.C
CM
P13
4Th
alas
sios
ira.o
cean
ica.
CC
MP
1005
Ptri
corn
utum
Thal
assi
onem
a.ni
tzsc
hioi
des.
L26_
BP
mul
tiser
ies
Cor
ethr
on.p
enna
tum
.L29
A3
Pse
udo_
nitz
schi
a.au
stra
lis.1
0249
_10_
AB
Thal
assi
osira
.gra
vida
.GM
p14c
1Fr
agila
riops
is.k
ergu
elen
sis.
L26_
C5
Scr
ipps
iella
.troc
hoid
ea.C
CM
P30
99D
urin
skia
.bal
tica.
CS
IRO
_CS
.38
Am
phid
iniu
m.c
arte
rae.
CC
MP
1314
Kar
enia
.bre
vis.
CC
MP
2229
Cer
atiu
m.fu
sus.
PA16
1109
Het
eroc
apsa
.triq
uetra
Sym
biod
iniu
m.s
p.C
1A
lexa
ndriu
m.m
onila
tum
.CC
MP
3105
Perid
iniu
m.a
cicu
lifer
um.P
AE
R_2
Pro
roce
ntru
m.m
inim
um.C
CM
P13
29S
crip
psie
lla.h
ango
ei.S
HTV
5K
rypt
oper
idin
ium
.folia
ceum
.CC
MP
1326
Gle
nodi
nium
.folia
ceum
.CC
AP
1116
_3S
ymbi
odin
ium
.sp.
CC
MP
2430
Cry
pthe
codi
nium
.coh
nii.S
elig
oA
lexa
ndriu
m.te
mar
ense
.CC
MP
1771
Pro
roce
ntru
m.m
inim
um.C
CM
P22
33K
aren
ia.b
revi
s.W
ilson
Oxy
rrhi
s.m
arin
aA
zadi
nium
.spi
nosu
m.3
D9
Sym
biod
iniu
m.s
p.M
pP
roro
cent
rum
.min
imum
Ling
ulod
iniu
m.p
olye
dra.
CC
MP
1738
Oxy
rrhi
s.m
arin
a.LB
1974
Sm
inut
umS
ymbi
odin
ium
.sp.
C15
Scr
ipps
iella
.han
goei
_lik
e.S
HH
I_4
Kar
lodi
nium
.mic
rum
.CC
MP
2283
Kar
enia
.bre
vis.
SP
1K
aren
ia.b
revi
s.S
P3
Eut
rept
iella
.gym
nast
ica_
like.
CC
MP
1594
Und
escr
ibed
.sp.
CC
MP
2098
Und
escr
ibed
.sp.
CC
MP
2436
Und
escr
ibed
.und
escr
ibed
.CC
MP
2298
Und
escr
ibed
.sp.
CC
MP
2293
Und
escr
ibed
.sp.
CC
MP
2097
67666564636261605958575655545352515049484746454443424140393837363534333231302928272625242322212019181716151413121110987654321
Transcriptomes + Genome dataset + NCBI RefSeq (349 samples)
S−g
enes
fam
ilies
Taxonomic distribution of the 67 S-gene families
Rhodophyta
Cercozoa
Unknow
nC
ryptophytaC
hlorophytaO
chrophytaD
inophytaE
uglenozoaG
laucophytaB
acillariophytaH
aptophytaS
treptophyta
Fig. S1. Taxonomic distribution of the 67 S genes discovered in our study. The taxonomic distribution of the data is shown with black boxes indicating a presence and white boxes indicating presumed absence in the genome or transcriptome data from the taxon.
Méheust et al. www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/1517551113 2 of 5
A
B
C
Fig. S2. Mapping data for S genes in Picochlorum and A. thaliana. (A) S-gene family 31, which encodes RIBR + DUF1768 (PyrR) and is involved in riboflavinbiosynthesis. The CDS derives from the MMETSP database and encodes this 1,848-nt S gene from Picochlorum oklahomensis CCMP2329. The 6,609 RNA-seqreads mapped to it are from the closely related species Picochlorum SE3 (55). The homologous SE3 gene is encoded on Picochlorum contig 185.g609.t1.(B) S-gene family 23, which encodes a TPR repeat/RING and an ATP-dependent protease domain. This CDS also derives from the MMETSP database, andencodes the 1,554-nt S gene from P. oklahomensis CCMP2329. The 9,253 RNA-seq reads mapped to it are from Picochlorum SE3. The homologous SE3 gene isencoded on Picochlorum contig 43.g1 98.t1. (C) S-gene family 14, which encodes GIY–YIF superfamily and thioredoxin superfamily domains. This genic regionis from A. thaliana (ArGrxS16), and the 16,906 unique reads mapped to the exons are also from this species [see Table S2 for Sequence Read Archive (SRA)run accession numbers]. Thin blue lines indicate a spliceosomal intron. The mapping in all cases is colored in green, red, and blue for forward, reverse, andpaired-end reads, respectively. The fused domains and their putative annotations are shown. These data are typical for all of the Picochlorum and Arabidopsismappings and for many of the other plant and algal S genes when sufficient RNA-seq data are available (Table S2). This unambiguous, “deep” mapping acrossthe region that spans the domain fusion argues strongly against misassembly of this (and other) S genes.
Méheust et al. www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/1517551113 3 of 5
Fig. S3. Genomic PCRs that targeted S genes identified in Picochlorum species. The contig number in the Picochlorum SE3 assembly is given for each S gene, asis the S-gene family number (see Table S2 for details). The PCR primers were complementary to regions at the 5′ and 3′ termini of the S genes to span thedomain-fusion region. The sizes of these S-gene CDS fragments matched the fragment sizes resulting from PCR amplification as follows: S gene 11 (1,015 nt), Sgene 23 (1,419 nt), S gene 4 (1,214 nt), S gene 34 (924 nt), and S gene 12 (1,119 nt). Sanger sequencing of these PCR fragments showed identity to the genomicregion in Picochlorum SE3, and BLASTX analysis using the fragments showed that each spanned the domain-fusion region in the respective S gene. The matchof the CDS size to the genomic region is explained by the paucity of spliceosomal introns in Picochlorum SE3. These data demonstrate that the tested S genesexist as intact fragments in this green alga.
Fig. S4. Maximum-likelihood (RAxML) (57) tree of species encoding S-gene family 31. This composite gene is limited to the Viridiplantae (Fig. S1) and encodesfused RIBR + DUF1768 (PyrR) domains that are involved in riboflavin biosynthesis. This manually trimmed alignment includes a selection of taxonomicallydiverse green lineage species and is of length 524 amino acids. The intact gene (see also mapping evidence in Fig. S2) was analyzed using the LG + Γ + Ievolutionary model with the results of 100 bootstrap replicates, when ≥50% are shown at the branches. The topology of this tree is consistent with theexpected phylogeny of Viridiplantae (e.g., 56), indicating an ancient origin of this S gene. The NCBI gi numbers are shown after each species name, whenavailable.
Méheust et al. www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/1517551113 4 of 5
Other Supporting Information Files
Table S1 (DOCX)Table S2 (DOCX)Table S3 (DOCX)Table S4 (DOCX)Dataset S1 (XLSX)
Méheust et al. www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/1517551113 5 of 5