supporting serendipitous discovery in the scholarly research process

Los Angeles | London | New Delhi | Singapore | Washington DC | Melbourne #SAGETalks

Make sure your volume is set appropriately

Make sure you have followed the instructions on your keypad properly

Make sure everything is plugged in properly to assure your devices are working correctly

If you have audio or visual

difficulties, please let us know via

the Question box and we will be happy to assist

you.

Please Check Your Settings


Beyond Search

Supporting Serendipity in the Scholarly Research Process


While we do our best to answer as many questions as we can, time constraints may not allow us to answer every question. Thank you for

understanding.

Send us your questions!Send in your questions via the Question Box on your screen. →

Using Twitter? Use the hashtag

#SAGETalks.


Gary PriceEditor,

Library Journal’s infoDOCKET

SAGE White PapersLettie Conrad & Alan Maloney

http://bit.ly/23Z99d4



http://content.news.sagepub.com/emessageIRS/servlet/IRSL?v=5&a=10050&r=58695&m=126&l=16&e=2&x=2457788.0


Lettie Conrad

• Executive Product Analysis Manager• Leads Discovery & Access programs

At SAGE, we take seriously our obligation to ensure readers get to the SAGE content they need as smoothly and effectively as possible wherever their starting point and regardless of their device.



Expecting the Unexpected

What do users need beyond search?How are those needs and expectations formed? Does demography or context impact these expectations?How are publishers servicing those indirect discovery needs?What happens when users aren’t sure what they’re looking for?


Research Methods

UX research Survey Interviews

Undergraduate Students u u

Masters/PhD Students u u

Faculty u u uContent & Tech

Providers u


Defining terms

• Types of search

• Known-item searching

• Exploratory searching

• Re-finding

• Don’t know what you need to know

SERENDIPITY!


What is serendipity?

1. the finding of unexpected information (relevant to the goal or not) while engaged in any information activity

2. the making of an intellectual leap of understanding with that information to arrive at an insight.

Andre, P., Teevan, J., Dumais, S. T., ‘Discovery Is Never by Chance: Designing for (Un)Serendipity’, C&C ‘09, October 26-30, 2009, Berkeley, California, USA


Why does serendipity matter?• Students and researchers re-frame their information need as

they go

• Some useful information discoveries are unintentional

• People like serendipity: it delights users

Designing for serendipity may be the holy grail of the search experience.

Russell-Rose, T., Tate, T. (2013). Designing the Search Experience: The Information Architecture of Discovery. Waltham, MA: Morgan Kaufmann.


Beyond search

• Email alerts

• Following citations

• Human recommendations

• Machine recommendations / relatedness


Recommendations as discovery

90% faculty 78% students

Online recommendations are about as useful than those I receive from peers


Context is key!How important are the following factors when evaluating recommended content?

• Related to my field of study• Can access the full text• Recognize / trust the provider


Listed as "also read" by other users

From a recognized / trustworthy publisher

Recommended by a peer / faculty member

From a known author / expert

Uses your search terms / keywords

Titles that look interesting / compelling

Relevant to your field

Titles that appear relevant for your studies

0.00% 25.00% 50.00% 75.00% 100.00%

When presented with links to recommended content, which factors motivate you to click on one or more

such links? (check all that apply)

Faculty Undergrads


Content types – students

1. Journals2. Books3. Case studies4. Multimedia


Content types – faculty

1. Journals2. Books3. Stats / datasets4. Conference reports


Industry research


Alan Maloney

• Sr. Product Analyst, Taxonomy & Semantic Technology• Leads Interlinking & Metadata programs

Content is arguably the thing that a publisher should do best.



Unplanned discovery in context

● ‘Researchers’ expectations are being set not by improvements relative to the past but rather by reference to consumer internet services’*

* Schonfeld, R. C. (2015, March 26). Meeting researchers where they start: Streamlining access to scholarly resources. Retrieved from http://sr.ithaka.org?p=241038



● ‘Researchers’ expectations are being set not by improvements relative to the past but rather by reference to consumer internet services’

● Amazon ‘integrates recommendations into every part of the purchasing process’*

* Mangalindan, J. P. (2012, July 30). Amazon’s recommendation secret. Fortune. Retrieved from http:// fortune.com/2012/07/30/amazons-recommendation-secret/



● ‘Researchers’ expectations are being set not by improvements relative to the past but rather by reference to consumer internet services’

● Amazon ‘integrates recommendations into every part of the purchasing process’

● Spotify ‘uses playlists as the common currency’ to show users undiscovered music*

* Pasick, A. (2015, December 21). The magic that makes Spotify’s Discover Weekly playlists so damn good. Quartz. Retrieved from http://qz.com/571007/the-magic-that-makes-spotifys-discover-weekly-playlists-so-damn-good/


(Pasick, 2015)


Is academic discovery different?

• Objectives are (slightly) different• There’s not as much data• Consumer psychology focuses on retail• Academic content is more personal

http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2015/04/09/academic-promotion-scholars-popular-media/


The popular-personal continuum

Popular Personal

Big data Small data

Network-driven Content-driven

mass market retail

entertainment

scholarly research


(Our) principles for serendipitous discovery

• Academic research is personal.• Content-focused, not behaviour-focused.• Point of serendipitous discovery is the current, specific

information need.• Serendipity should be unexpected.• Serendipity happens when people cross boundaries.• Serendipity is only useful when someone can make

sense of the surprise information.



• Content-focused, not behaviour-focused.• Point of serendipitous discovery is the current, specific

information need.• Academic research is personal.• Serendipity should be unexpected.• Serendipity happens when people cross boundaries.• Serendipity is only useful when someone can make



While we do our best to answer as many questions as we can, time constraints may not allow us to answer every question. Thank you for

understanding.

Send us your questions!Send in your questions via the Question Box on your screen. →

Using Twitter? Use the hashtag

#SAGETalks.


Webinar recording, slides, and follow-up Q&A will be emailed to you and available on sagepub.com/sagetalks

Thank you!

Alan Maloney [email protected] Lettie [email protected]

Be sure to check our website for updates on our webinar series!

SAGE White Papers


mailto:[email protected]







supporting serendipitous discovery in the scholarly research process

Education