sustainability principles and commitmentsterravia.com/terravia_sustainability.pdfas part of...
TRANSCRIPT
I co-founded TerraVia with a college friend more than a decade ago with a clear goal in mind: to make
products that are better for people and the planet. Our founding ethos was to create a successful
company by tackling the world’s biggest challenges with better solutions. It was that simple.
It remains that simple. Even today, after more than twelve years and hundreds of millions of dollars invested
in product development, TerraVia is, at heart, a simple business. We make healthy and nutritious ingredients
and specialty oils by harnessing the power of algae – the mother of all plants and the Earth’s original oil
producer.
But as we know, just ‘doing it’ isn’t enough. We have to prove we’re doing it. We have to demonstrate to
our stakeholders that our products are healthy and safe and we must explain why they benefit the world.
This is what our sustainability effort is all about. This paper covers our entire operation, from sourcing
feedstock to manufacturing products. We have consulted numerous stakeholders, and will continue to
engage them and listen to their feedback.
Like our business, our sustainability program will continue to evolve as our business grows and with
continuous stakeholder feedback. This marks the beginning of TerraVia’s journey to share our efforts, report
on progress, and articulate our aspirations.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 2
Foreword – Jonathan Wolfson
As part of developing our sustainability program, TerraVia has met with over 50 groups, including non-profit
organizations, scientific groups, and trade associations. We would like to especially thank the groups below that
participated in our Stakeholder Roundtables and provided critical and constructive feedback to our sustainability
program:
The participation of these organizations in providing feedback to TerraVia does not necessarily indicate endorsement of
TerraVia’s sustainability program.
• Royal Society for the Protection of Birds
• UK Synthetic Biology Leadership Council
• UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences
Research Council
• Union of Concerned Scientists
• The Woodrow Wilson Center
• World Wildlife Fund US
• World Wildlife Fund UK
• Daniel J. Evans School of Public Policy and
Governance, University of Washington
Acknowledgements
• Bonsucro
• Friends of the Earth EWNI
• Forum for the Future
• SYNENERGENE
(Karlsruhe Institute of Technology)
• National Wildlife Federation
• Natural Resources Defense Council
• The David and Lucile Packard Foundation
• Rathenau Instituut
• Roundtable on Sustainable Biomaterials
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 3
Contents2 Foreward
3 Acknowledgements
4 Introduction
Putting Principles Into Practice:
6 i. Transparency
7 ii. Environmental Impact
13 iii. Safety & Containment
15 iv. People & Communities
17 v. Regulation and Governance
19 Conclusion
FERMENTATIONTANK
Up To 85% Oil
The average wildalgae only has a5–10% oil content
OIL-PRODUCINGALGAE
More than a decade ago, our company was founded as Solazyme. We invested in developing a unique understanding
and expertise around algae to address some of society’s most serious challenges. In 2016, we transitioned to focus our
efforts exclusively on producing food, nutrition and specialty ingredients. To reflect this refined focus and strategic
direction, we renamed the company TerraVia.
T E R R A V I A ’ S A P P R O A C H T O S U S T A I N A B I L I T Y
At TerraVia, we work hard every day to bring our algae-based food and ingredients to market. Our closed fermentation
production process uses algae to convert a wide variety of plant sugars into nearly any kind of oil, food ingredients, and
other products.
We create products intended to address some of society’s critical environmental and health challenges. These include
providing replacements to palm and soybean oil, which threaten critical wildlife habitats when unsustainably produced,
and helping to address nutrition security with healthier oils and ingredients that help in making affordable and nutritious
food products.
O U R P R O C E S S A N D T E C H N O L O G Y
TerraVia works with algae, the Earth’s original oil producers and the foundation of all plant life. TerraVia’s manufacturing
process can produce a wide range of algae-based ingredients from a variety of plant sugar feedstocks at a single
manufacturing facility. Our algae are grown in the dark in contained stainless steel fermentation tanks, like those used
to make beer and wine.
We have a diverse portfolio of ingredients and specialty oils. All of our products start with native algae strains. Some of
our products are made by simply applying the centuries-old technique of fermentation to algae to ensure a pure and
consistent, efficient and sustainable supply of our unique products. Thus, many of our oils and whole algae products are
made with native algae strains while others are made with the assistance of biotechnology.
Figure 1. TerraVia process for making oil and whole algae products
To make our products, we feed plant sugar and other nutrients to the algae and they grow full of oil and other nutrients,
such as protein and fiber, in the fermentation tanks. Then, we remove the algae from the tanks and dry them. For our
whole algae ingredients, we leave the algae dry and they remain in a powder form. To make our oil ingredients, the
dried algae are then pressed to release the oil, just like the process to make coconut or seed oils. The algae is separated
from the oil, which is then refined and there is no algae mass left in the final oil product.
None of the leftover algae material goes to waste. The remaining algae material is still full of healthy carbohydrates,
proteins and other micronutrients. It can be used in a wide range of products, including as a fuel source for energy
generation.
Introduction
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 4
SUGARCANE
CORN & STOVER
SUGAR BEET
SWITCHGRASS
FOREST RESIDUE
WASTE STREAMS
FLEXIBLE INPUT AQUACULTURE& ANIMALNUTRITION
FOOD
PERSONALCARE
MULTIPLEMARKETS
OIL FAMILIES
OLEIC
CAPRIC-LAURIC
MID-CHAIN
STRUCTURED LIPID
LONG CHAIN
PROTEIN RICH
LIPID RICH
WHOLE ALGAEPOWDERS
DOWNSTREAMPROCESSING
ALGAE
R E S P O N S I B L E I N N O V A T I O N
TerraVia makes a variety of algae-based oils and ingredients, some of which are made by applying the tools of
biotechnology used for decades to make cheese, vitamins and medicines. Where we do apply the technology, we use
standard genetic engineering techniques to improve or adjust the fatty acid profiles of the triglyceride oils the algae
already produce in order to deliver ingredients that provide specific health, performance, and environmental benefits.
We are an innovator in an important, emerging sector and we are conscious of the environmental and social debate
that surrounds the use of biotechnology to produce food and other materials.1 Biotechnology, engineering biology,
synthetic biology and other types of scientific innovation all have the potential to provide breakthrough solutions when
applied responsibly, with transparency and public engagement. TerraVia is working with policymakers, scientists, and
non-governmental organizations to promote good government oversight.
TerraVia believes in and is inspired by innovation. With a global population predicted to reach 9 billion by 2050, society
will need all kinds of solutions to produce enough food, clothing and shelter with fewer resources and with less
environmental and adverse social impacts. While many of these problems are exponential, many of society’s solutions so
far have been incremental. We must innovate and seek breakthrough solutions to meet these problems. This is the
foundation upon which TerraVia is founded. For many companies, this will enable them to rethink their supply chains as
they seek to create healthier and more sustainable products. We need many different solutions and we will need all
kinds of collaborations to make that happen.
Our Principles of Responsible InnovationWe have actively pursued input from stakeholders in the non-profit, public and private sectors in developing TerraVia’s
sustainability program and our Principles for Responsible Innovation.
We will be transparent and clear about our processes and technology
We commit to supply chain integrity and sustainability excellence
We will continuously work to achieve the highest safety standards for our processes and products
We will support progressive coalitions amongst corporate, government, NGO and academic sectors working
to achieve governance and regulatory frameworks that promote accountability
We support and will encourage dissemination of clear and broad consumer information for products that
enable informed consumer choice
We are open to rigorous dialogue and will regularly engage with and report back to stakeholders
We support the communities where we operate and do business
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 5
DEVELOPING BIOTECHNOLOGY RESPONSIBLY
1 There have been numerous initiatives to develop sustainability and responsibility principles for the biotechnology sector, including the 2010 US Presidential Commission for the study of bioethical issues, the UK's Nuffield Council on Bioethics 2012 report, Emerging Biotechnologies: technology, choice and public good, and the Forum for the Future 2013 report Sustainable Returns - Industrial Biotechnology Done Well, and EU Commission Initiative on Responsible research & Innovation http://ec.europa.eu/programmes/horizon2020/en/h2020-section/responsible-research-innovation
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Transparency is central to all of our sustainability principles.
STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION AND DIALOGUE
With so many breakthrough applications of biotechnology, how do we ensure that humanity benefits while developing
the technology responsibly?
To help understand and define TerraVia’s role and responsibility within the broader context, in 2014 we initiated a series
of external consultations with civil society organizations, scientific bodies and trade associations, in the U.S. and the EU.
Four independently facilitated Roundtables were held, the objectives of which were to seek feedback on, and input to,
the ongoing development of our sustainability program.
More recently, we also opened a dialogue with individual NGOs in the environmental, labelling and sustainable
agriculture sectors – supportive, neutral and critical – in order to better understand their expectations around consumer
information and transparency. We plan to build on this engagement, particularly in the area of consumer information
and product labelling, as we accelerate our move into food products and build our ingredients business. To date, we
have met with more than 50 non-profit organizations, foundations, government agencies, trade groups, and thought
leaders.
Additionally, we are open to engaging in other complementary initiatives, and have taken part in a number of forums
addressing the responsible development of biotechnology.
PUBLICATION OF DATA
One of the issues that has been raised most frequently by the stakeholders we have consulted is the need to publish our
data on safety related scientific studies and lifecycle analyses of our products. We have already published several of our
safety studies in the U.S. and Brazil, and plan to publish more as we develop new data. Additional information is
available through our various regulatory submissions. We are currently working on publishing our environmental safety
data in a peer reviewed journal. (Please see “Safety” section.)
We are also making public the product lifecycle analysis (LCA) of our oil and whole algae food products. These LCAs
measure the environmental impacts of producing our products. The LCA for our oil products is complete and the results
are described below. A summary is also available on our website. The results for the whole algae food products will be
shared publicly upon completion.
TRANSPARENCY ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
SAFETY andCONTAINMENT
PEOPLE andCOMMUNITIES
REGULATION andGOVERNANCE
i. Transparency
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 6
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > TRANSPARENCY
i ii iii iv v
As we grow and expand our business, we will continue to engage stakeholders and
seek their input on the responsible development of our technology.COMMITMENT
We will publish our environmental safety data in a peer reviewed journal.COMMITMENT
P U T T I N G P R I N C I P L E S I N T O P R A C T I C E
TerraVia’s approach to implementing our principles are reflected in five primary areas:
TerraVia transforms renewable plant sugars into algae-based ingredients and specialty personal care oils.
Fundamentally, we take what the world has in abundance – plant sugars – to produce what society needs every day –
oil, protein and other nutrients.
The primary environmental impacts of making our products are from the sugar feedstock we use to feed our algae and
the energy used to power our production facilities. We evaluate our environmental impacts in two ways: 1) at the
product level - through product lifecycle analyses; and 2) at the operational level.
O U R P R O D U C T S
Independent lifecycle analyses (LCAs) provide us with a very important tool for assessing the embedded environmental
impacts of our products. They also help to inform our business decision-making around current and future feedstock
sourcing as well as where to locate potential new production facilities.
ALGAE OILS
Our largest oil production facility is the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils joint venture facility based in Orindiύva, Brazil.
The facility is capable of producing a range of oils and the same inputs are required for the different oils. The only
difference is the type of algae strain that is grown in the fermentation tanks. Thus, the LCA is similar for any oil produced
at this facility.
We asked thinkstep (formerly PE INTERNATIONAL) to conduct a comprehensive cradle-to-gate study of the algae oil
produced at the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility. The study also included a comparative analysis of algae oil
with other major commercial bio-based oils: palm and palm kernel, soybean, canola/rapeseed, olive, sunflower, and
tallow. The study is in conformance with ISO 14040/44 standards for Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and was critically
reviewed by a third party panel of experts. The LCA demonstrates that oils produced at the Solazyme Bunge Oils facility
have a lower carbon and water footprint than nearly all major commercial bio-based oils. In a separate analysis looking
at land use efficiency (i.e., the amount of oil produced per hectare of feedstock), TerraVia algae oil production has one
of the highest oil yield per hectare compared to most major commercial plant oils.
ii. Environmental Impact
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 7
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
We are committed to communicating about how we make our products and what is in
them. Thus, we are engaged in numerous stakeholder dialogues to help inform how we
communicate this information to consumers.
COMMITMENT
CONSUMER INFORMATION
TerraVia recognizes that there is growing stakeholder support for labelling and for greater levels of consumer information
and transparency. We are committed to communicating with our consumers about how we make our products and
what is in them. The question for TerraVia is how do we do this effectively?
It is our firm belief that consumers have a right to know how their products are made and what is in them. We are
therefore seeking stakeholder input about consumer information and transparency. The input from this process will help
inform how we communicate product information with customers and consumers.
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
The Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions associated with producing oil at the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility is
lower than nearly all other major bio-based commercial oils (see Figure 3). This low GHG impact is due to two primary
factors: 1) the low carbon footprint of the sugarcane feedstock and 2) the waste sugarcane material (bagasse) provides
all of the energy to power both the Bunge sugar mill and the co-located Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oil facility.
SUGARCANEWASTE
ALGAECONVERTS SUGAR TO OIL
FERMENTATIONTANK
AN IM AL N UTRITIO
N
CA RE
PERSONAL
FOOD
• AQUACULTURE •
HIGH QUALITYINGREDIENTS FOR
MULTIPLE MARKETS
EXCESS POWERTO GRID
SUGAR
ONSITEDOWNSTREAMPROCESSING
SOLAZYME BUNGE RENEWABLE
OILS FACILITY
BONSUCRO®
CERTIFIEDSUGAR MILL
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 8
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
Figure 3.
Source: thinkstep (2016), Cradle-to-Gate Study of Competing Bio-Based Oils. Third Party reviewed to ISO 1404/44 Standards. Includes land use change.
Figure 2.
kg CO₂ eq / kg oil
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Carbon Emissions of Algae Oil Produced in Brazil Versus Major Commercial Bio-based Oils
Soybean Oil
Tallow
Palm Kernel Oil
Olive Oil
Palm Oil
Canola Oil
Sunflower Oil
Algae Oil (Sugarcane)
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 9
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
WATER CONSUMPTION
Oil produced at the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oil facility requires less water consumption than most major bio-based
commercial oils (see Figure 4). The low water consumption is due to the fact that the sugarcane supply is rain-fed and a
contained fermentation process is used. Furthermore, much of the treated wastewater is placed back on the
sugarcane fields as “fertigation”.
LAND USE EFFICIENCY
Our Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility can produce more oil per hectare of land converting sugarcane to algae
oil than nearly all other oil producing crops. Although palm oil has very similar yields, the devastating land use impacts of
expanding palm oil production over the past two decades have been well documented in some regions.2
Figure 4.
Source: thinkstep (2016), Cradle-to-Gate Study of Competing Bio-Based Oils. Third Party reviewed to ISO 1404/44 Standards. Includes land use change.
kg Water Consumed / kg oIl
0 20 40 60 80 100 25802560
Water Consumption of Algae Oil Production in Brazil Versus Major Commercial Bio-based Oils
Olive Oil
Sunflower Oil
Palm Oil
Palm Kernel Oil
Soybean Oil
Tallow
Canola Oil
Algae Oil (Sugarcane)
2 May-Tobin, et al. (2012) Recipes for Success. Union of Concerned Scientists and Climate Advisers.
MT of oil/hectare
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
Source: Murphy, D. J. (2009). Global oil yields: Have we got it seriously wrong? AOCS. http://www.aocs.org/Membership/informArticleDetail.cfm?ItemNumber=1102FAO Statistical Databases and Technical Conversion Factors for Agricultural Commodities
Oil Yield Per Hectare
Algae Oil (Sugarcane)
Palm
Canola
Sunflower
Palm Kernel
Soybean
Olive
Figure 5.
FEEDSTOCK - BRAZILIAN SUGARCANE
TerraVia’s current oil production takes
place in the São Paulo State of Brazil.
Around 90% of Brazil’s sugarcane
production is harvested in the
South-Central region, especially the
state of São Paulo, which accounts for
over 50% of Brazilian sugarcane
production. In 2009, the Brazilian
government launched the National
Agro-Ecological Zoning of Sugarcane
(ZAE Cana) initiative which sets out
strict policies guiding sugarcane
expansion and development. The ZAE
Cana policies define land suitable for
sugarcane production based on
environmental, economic and social criteria.
They do not allow sugarcane expansion into the
Amazon rainforest region (including previously
deforested areas) or into areas of high conservation
value (HCV). TerraVia respects these regulations and
expects rigorous compliance from its sugarcane suppliers.
Brazilian sugarcane used to produce our products in Brazil is
sourced through the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils joint
venture. The Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility is
co-located with the Bunge Moema sugar mill which has been
Bonsucro® certified since 2011. We began manufacturing at the
Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility in early 2014.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 10
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
3 http://bonsucro.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Bonsucro-Production-Standard-v4-01.pdf
Amazon Rain Forest
SugarcaneCultivation
Sources: NIPE-Unicamp, IBGE and CTC
Solazyme BungeFacility is located in the São Paulo area
~4,300 Km
~2,700 Km
O U R F E E D S T O C K S
TerraVia’s manufacturing process can use a variety of sugar feedstocks to produce oils and other algae-based
ingredients. This feedstock flexibility enables us to choose the optimal feedstock for any particular geography, while also
enabling us to produce a wide variety of oils and whole algae ingredients from the same manufacturing facility.
This input-output flexibility offers enormous potential, both commercially and for the sustainability aspects of TerraVia’s
technology. This means that we can locally source feedstock from the country in which our manufacturing facilities are
situated. Locally sourcing feedstock reduces the distance between producer and consumer. It also allows us to make
products in a diversity of regions.
Our goal is to integrate cellulosic derived sugar feedstocks into our supply chain (see below for more discussion on
cellulosics). However, until the logistics and conversion technologies for cellulosics become broadly commercially viable,
we are using two primary feedstocks: Brazilian sugarcane and dextrose derived from U.S. corn.
We understand that there is growing demand for plant sugars as societies look to transition to a low carbon, bioeconomy
where a wide variety of products will require plant sugars as a feedstock. It will be important to utilize the current stock of
plant sugars efficiently and consider future land use impacts. TerraVia is a member of the Roundtable on Sustainable
Biomaterials where we participate in global discussions and standard setting addressing these issues. The Roundtable on
Sustainable Biomaterials is an independent and global multi-stakeholder coalition which works to promote the
sustainability of biomaterials.
FEEDSTOCK - U.S. CORN
Our manufacturing facility in Peoria, Illinois, uses readily available dextrose (sugar). At targeted nameplate capacity, this
facility provides approximately less than 5% of our total production. U.S. corn-derived sugar is recognised to have a
relatively high GHG impact due to the carbon intensity of corn cultivation. As a result, we are currently exploring a
number of options for sourcing more sustainably grown feedstock for our U.S. operations. Options that we are looking at
include the potential use of offsets for sustainably grown corn as well as supporting the work being undertaken by
several non-profit organizations and farmers groups to advance the sustainability of food, fiber, and fuel production.
FUTURE FEEDSTOCKS - CELLULOSICS
Our mid-term goal is to integrate cellulosic derived sugar feedstocks into our supply chain. Sugars derived from
lignocellulosic feedstocks present an exciting opportunity to continuously lower the environmental impact of producing
algae oil and products.
We have been working on the use of cellulosic-derived sugars for more than five years, including research collaborations
with multiple entities and a major project in conjunction with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). To date, we have
produced oils using lignocellulosic sugars derived from multiple sources including switchgrass, forage sorghum, maple
wood pulp, sugar beet pulp, corn-stover, sugarcane bagasse, municipal green waste, and loblolly pine. As the first step
in our DOE project, we demonstrated the ability to scale up our production process using cellulosic sugars at commercial
scale in our Peoria facility where we have produced edible, healthy oils from inedible cellulosic material.
The speed at which we can transition to using cellulosic-derived sugars will depend on the development of commercial
logistics and conversion systems that we can bolt on to our production. This is coming, but it presents a significant hurdle
for our company to transition to cellulosic feedstocks.
We are, and will continue to engage partners, pursue commercial cellulosic technologies, and monitor developments in
cellulosic biomass-derived sugars. We will, where possible, play our part in helping to bring this potentially
game-changing technology to market.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 11
COMMITMENT We will continue to explore options for sourcing more sustainably grown feedstocks
in the U.S.
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
We are working towards sourcing 100% of our sugar, from sugarcane, sustainably. COMMITMENT
To help ensure that we meet our commitments to sustainability and labor practices, Bonsucro® certified sugar is currently
being purchased and the process of securing certification against the Chain of Custody Standard for the Brazilian sugar
supply is underway. We are working towards sourcing 100% of our sugar, from sugarcane, sustainably. Bonsucro®
certification provides supply chain traceability to the farm level for the sugarcane feedstock.
TerraVia and Solazyme Bunge are members of Bonsucro®, a multi-stakeholder non-profit organization dedicated to
improving the sustainability of global sugarcane production and improving the lives of sugarcane workers. We are
conscious of the potential impact that feedstock supplies may have on the surrounding landscape, and on wildlife
habitats and species populations. The Bonsucro® Production Standard sets out economic, social and environmental
principles and criteria for achieving sustainable production of sugarcane.3 Specifically, Principle 4 in the Bonsucro®
standard addresses active management of biodiversity and ecosystem services. This includes preventing the cultivation
of sugarcane in areas of high conservation value or legally protected lands, as well as improving soil and water resources.
Our mid-term goal is to integrate cellulosic-derived sugar feedstocks into our supply chain.
We will continue to monitor developments in cellulosic biomass-derived sugars and will
help to bring this potentially game-changing technology to market.
COMMITMENT
O U R O P E R A T I O N S
TerraVia is taking steps to measure, manage and minimize all water, waste and GHG emissions from our directly
controlled operations. This covers our manufacturing site at Peoria, Illinois and our joint venture facility in Orindiύva, Brazil.
At Peoria, we have been implementing energy and water efficiency initiatives. These include:
• Recycling program for metal, cardboard, and other materials
• Reduced steam usage and installed pre-heat exchanger for the boilers to improve energy
• Automated lighting and use of more efficient ballasts.
• Reduced Water Usage For Fermentation Cooling:
- Implemented a “closed-loop” piping system that eliminated the use of ground water for cooling the two main
fermenters – saving millions of gallons of water per year.
• Reduced energy use through installing condensate pumps that reuses condensate water back into the boiler system.
- This is saving 3,500,000 btu’s per hour of heat. Over the course of a year, this is equivalent to saving the carbon
emissions caused by nearly 2 million vehicle miles driven a year.
Our joint venture facility in Brazil has a low carbon footprint due to the fact that waste sugarcane material (bagasse)
provides all of the energy to power both the sugar mill and the oil production facility. The Brazil facility can also feed
excess energy back to the grid.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 12
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
We will work to measure, manage and minimize all water, waste and GHG emissions from our directly controlled operations.
COMMITMENT
O U R T E C H N O L O G Y
A primary aspect of our mission is to produce oils that provide significant health, functional, and sustainability benefits.
For example, an oil that can be a more sustainable alternative to palm oil or healthier food oils, such as oils with the
lowest levels of saturated fat. In order to make these oils, we apply the tools of biotechnology, including standard
genetic engineering techniques, to the algae to develop these oils. These are tools that have been used for decades to
generate important drugs, vitamins, foods, hygiene and household products that are broadly used and beneficial for
people. We may introduce one or sometimes a few genes from a plant with desired properties, or we might make only
modest changes to the algae’s existing genes, for example, by shutting off production of an undesired oil component.
All of our algae oils are standard triglyceride oils. And while certain of the algae have been optimized through genetic
engineering, there are no genetically modified organisms in the final algae oil. Similarly, while most cheeses do not
contain genetically modified organisms, over 80% of the cheese in the US and the UK include an ingredient (chymosin)
made with genetically modified organisms.
We make a variety of algae products, some of which are made without applying any genetic engineering technology.
Where we do apply the technology, we are working to improve or adjust the fatty acid profiles of the triglyceride oils the
algae already produce in order to deliver ingredients that provide specific health, performance, and environmental
benefits. Below is a summary of our commercial products and the technologies applied.
iii. Safety and Containment
PRODUCT
AlgaVia®
Protein
AlgaVia® Lipid Powder
AlgaWise®Oils
GENETIC ENGINEERING APPLIED
No
No
Yes3,4
FINALPRODUCTCONTAINSGMO
No
No
No
BENEFIT FOR PEOPLE
Whole algae protein powder is a vegan source of protein, fiber and micronutrients. Free of known allergens and gluten-free
Whole algae lipid
powder can reduce or replace eggs, diary fats, and oils. Free of known allergens and gluten-free
Highest levels of mono-unsaturated fats, that help maintain heart health, low levels of saturated fat, zero trans fat and high smoke point
PRODUCTIONPROCESS
StandardContained Fermentationand Drying
StandardContained Fermentationand Drying, Expeller Pressing and Refining
BENEFIT FOR PLANET
More protein produced per hectare of land than other common vegan sources1; low carbon and water footprint2
Low carbon and water footprint2
Lower carbon and water footprint than nearly all major commercial oils.5
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 13
Table 1. Summary of TerraVia nutritional products
1Assumes sugarbeet feedstock; Calculated from FAO and USDA Statistical Databases; Redefining Agricultural Yields: from tonnes to people nourished per hectare, Cassidy, et. al (2013); Proteins From Land Plants – Potential resources for human nutrition and food security, Li Day (2013)
2 thinkstep (2015) Cradle-to-Gate Assessment of Whole Algal Flour and Whole Algal Protein Products. Third Party Reviewed to ISO 1404/44 Standards
3 No antibiotic resistant markers are used4 Similar process used to make chymosin ingredient present in most US/European cheese5 thinkstep (2016), Cradle-to-Gate Study of Competing Bio-Based Oils. Third Party Reviewed to ISO 1404/44 Standards.
ORIGIN OF ALGAE STRAIN
A freshwater pond in theNetherlands
A freshwater pond in the Netherlands
A chestnut tree in Germany
S A F E T Y
TerraVia has carried out a number of environmental safety studies in line with the ethic of the Precautionary Principle –
where the burden of proof to show that our algae are not harmful sits with TerraVia. Our studies demonstrate conclusively
that, in the event of an accidental release, our algae are safe and benign to the environment.
All of our algae are Biosafety level 1 (BSL 1) organisms, and pose no or insignificant risks to human and animal health or
the environment. We have conducted extensive water and soil tests on both our native base strain algae, as well as
several genetically engineered algae strains. The genetically engineered algae do not live any longer than native algae
strains in the environment. These studies have demonstrated that the genetically engineered algae do not reproduce or
persist in the environment, there are no negative impacts on soil microbiota or water quality, and there are no adverse
effects on water microorganisms and earthworms. In addition, the algae only grow in the dark (thus, not capable of
photosynthesis) and do not contribute to algae blooms, which sometime occur from photosynthetic algae. Though
several of these studies are publicly available through regulatory filings, we are also currently working to make our safety
studies widely available through publication in one or more peer-reviewed journals.
C O N T A I N M E N T
As mentioned earlier, the algae are grown in contained fermentation tanks, similar to those used in making vitamin C or
beer fermentation processes, not in the open environment. All algae cells are inactivated after fermentation and no live
algae remain in the waste streams following production.
We have met and, in many cases, exceeded all of the regulatory requirements of both the U.S. EPA and the Brazilian
CTNBio (National Technical Commission on Biosafety) for how we handle and contain the algae. The EPA has reviewed
our safety studies submitted under the MCAN (Microbial Commercial Activity Notice) process and we have successfully
completed EPA review of four MCANs. This allows our algae to be used in commercial production. CTNBio has approved
several algae strains for manufacturing at the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility. In Brazil, CTNBio regulations are
consistent with the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety to the Convention on Biological Diversity and its guiding principles
are based on the Precautionary Principle for environmental protection.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 14
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > SAFETY & CONTAINMENT
ORIGIN OF ALGAE STRAIN
GENETIC ENGINEERING APPLIED
No
No
Yes1,2
FINALPRODUCTCONTAINSGMO
No
No
No
BENEFIT FOR PEOPLE
Anti-aging compound, providing visibly reduced wrinkles and smoother looking skin
Skin Hydration, silky sensory feel, hair repair, hair frizz control
Depending on the type of AlgaPūr oil: skin hydration, odor stable formulations, increased lather; substitute for petroleum-based ingredients
BENEFIT FOR PLANET
Traceable, sustainable oil
A sustainable alternative to palm, palm kernel oil, and other commercial sources of oil3
PRODUCTIONPROCESS
StandardContained Fermentationand Drying
StandardContained Fermentationand Drying, Expeller Pressing and Refining
PRODUCT
Alguronic® Acid
GoldenChlorella®
AlgaPūr Oils™
Table 2. Summary of TerraVia specialty personal care products
A brook in Germany
A freshwater pond in the Netherlands
A chestnut tree in Germany
1 No antibiotic resistant markers are used2 Similar process used to make chymosin ingredient present in most US/European cheese3 thinkstep (2016), Cradle-to-Gate Study of Competing Bio-Based Oils. Third Party Reviewed to ISO 1404/44 Standards.
iv. People and Communities
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 15
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > PEOPLE AND COMMUNITIES
COMMITMENT We will continue to meet, and strive to exceed, the standards and requirements for
containment of microorganisms everywhere we operate.
4 http://bonsucro.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Bonsucro-Production-Standard-v4-01.pdf
It is important to our business that we have positive, mutually beneficial relationships with local communities, who are some
of our most important stakeholders.
Wherever TerraVia operates, we work to understand the impacts that our operations have, to practically engage with
community leaders, and to explore how we may best contribute, economically and socially, to community development.
These activities will differ depending on where our facilities or sourcing activities are located.
We recognize that many small-scale farmers, or other types of community-based food producers, face a wide range of
macro-economic and political pressures, which can often adversely impact their livelihoods. As a responsible company, we
seek to ensure that our operations and products do not add to these pressures, and we look to work with our relevant
stakeholders to mitigate these pressures where we can.
We are a young and emerging company. We are still learning about the sort of engagement our local communities expect
and need. But we have begun the journey, and we are committed to fulfilling our community responsibilities with their help.
G L O B A L O P E R A T I O N S
We have a manufacturing and business operation presence in numerous locations including:
South San Francisco, California • São Paolo, Brazil • Peoria, Illinois • Orindiύva, Brazil
Our largest manufacturing operations take place in Orindiύva, Brazil at our Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils joint venture.
Below is a summary of our activities to support our employees and the local community.
O U R E M P L O Y E E S
Our production operations in Brazil employ hundreds of local people, as well as support those who work to grow and
process the sugarcane feedstock. As mentioned earlier, the sugar mill that is co-located with the Solazyme Bunge
Renewable Oils facility has been Bonsucro® certified since 2011. The Bonscuro® certification has standards which must be
met that address the environmental, health and safety conditions for workers in the mill and farms that supply the mill.4
Outlined in Principle 2, these standards include criteria for providing a safe and healthy work environment, meeting
minimum wage requirements, and complying with international labor conventions.
In the event of an accident, we have strict standard operating procedures and containment facilities to ensure any spills
are controlled and contained. Our plants are designed with a perimeter of containment (e.g. walls or trenches). Any
material that is spilled or released is contained and washed into sumps, then sent to treatment tanks for inactivation.
In Brazil, the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils manufacturing facility is a “closed system” which means there are physical
containment mechanisms in place to prevent the release of live microorganisms. These containment mechanisms
include walls and berms around the facility, drains to wastewater treatment tanks, and exhaust treatment. CTNBio
inspected and approved the closed system production in July 2014.
COMMITMENT
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 16
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > PEOPLE AND COMMUNITIES
We remain committed to working with local communities where we operate to strengthen these support programs.
At the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility, in addition to meeting all local and national employment laws, Solazyme
Bunge Renewable Oils provides employee benefits that support continuous career development and thriving families.
These benefits include:
• Health, dental and life insurance that exceeds that required by the Brazilian government
• Subsidized meals provided at the facility
• Evening transportation to and from work
• Continuous safety training and events
• Career development opportunities for all employees including skill development such as English language and
leadership training
C O M M U N I T Y
Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils has been supporting a series of community investments in conjunction with Bunge
Foundation’s Program, Semear Leitores. The program was implemented with the local mayor and community members
to encourage reading and literacy among schoolchildren in the community around Orindiύva, where the Solazyme
Bunge Renewable Oils facility is located. The objectives of Semear Leitores are to offer knowledge and technical
support to develop libraries in local elementary schools, to provide new books and all of the infrastructure at the libraries,
to invest in teacher training, and to promote literary events to the local community. The program supports the Secretary
of Education’s work in the region.
With the success of the initial program in Orindiύva, other Mayors and community members requested programs for their
area. Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils has invested in ten additional reading spaces in four municipal locations. The
project directly impacts over 5,000 early grade students and their families.
Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils will continue to support education improvement in the region through teacher training
and the provision of literacy materials. Indicators will also be introduced to measure the educational impacts of the
program.
We are committed to the responsible development of biotechnology. This means complying with all regulations that
currently govern our sector, wherever we operate, and to engaging with stakeholders in enabling future oversight
frameworks to take account of, and anticipate, the fast pace of evolution in the biotechnology industry.
M I C R O O R G A N I S M S
U.S.
Research and Development
Research and development activities are regulated by the relevant federal, state, and municipal authorities in the U.S.
TerraVia operates under common biosafety protocols following the same standards and regulations that are applied to
university and company R & D laboratories working in biotechnology and pharmaceutical research.
Production
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has been regulating research, development and commercial activity of
microbial products of biotechnology since 1986. The US’s regulatory policy is governed by the Coordinated Framework
for Regulation of Biotechnology.5
In the case of novel genetically engineered microorganisms, this notification is called a Microbial Commercial Activity
Notice (MCAN). The MCAN review is intended to ensure that the EPA can adequately identify and regulate risks to
human, animal, and plant health associated with microbial products of biotechnology. TerraVia has conducted
numerous safety studies and EPA scientists conduct a risk assessment to ensure that the microorganism will not present
an unreasonable risk of injury or health to the environment. The EPA evaluates potential human health and
environmental hazard, as well as potential environmental, worker and general population exposure from manufacturing,
processing use and disposal.
TerraVia has worked closely with the EPA in its reviews of our organisms and products. We have met and, in many cases,
exceeded all of the regulatory requirements of the EPA and we have successfully completed EPA review of four
MCANs.6
BRAZIL
In Brazil, genetically engineered microbes are regulated by CTNBio. As mentioned earlier, Brazil’s regulations are
consistent with the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety to the Convention on Biological Diversity7 which incorporates the
Precautionary Approach and reaffirms the precaution language in Principle 15 of the Rio Declaration on Environment
and Development.8 The Cartagena Protocol is the international agreement that aims to ensure the safe handling,
transport and use of living modified organisms resulting from modern biotechnology that may have adverse effects on
biological diversity, also taking into account risks to human health. It went into force in September 2003. Brazil is a
signatory of the Cartagena Protocol and ratified the agreement in February 2004.
CTNBio has approved several algae strains for manufacturing at the Solazyme Bunge Renewable Oils facility. View here
for the CTNBio approvals that are publicly available:
http://pesquisa.in.gov.br/imprensa/jsp/visualiza/index.jsp?jornal=1&pagina=7&data=21/10/2013
http://pesquisa.in.gov.br/imprensa/jsp/visualiza/index.jsp?jornal=1&pagina=16&data=25/08/2015
5 https://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2015/07/02/improving-transparency-and-ensuring-continued-safety-biotechnology6 http://www.epa.gov/oppt/biotech/pubs/submiss.htm, Solazyme’s MCANs: J12-0003, J13-0030, J14-0017, J14-0020 7 http://bch.cbd.int/protocol/background/8 http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0013/001395/139578e.pdf
v. Regulation and Governance
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 17
F O O D P R O D U C T S
U.S.
Our food products are regulated as food ingredients in the United States by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
under the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. The safety evaluations for any ingredient reviewed under the Generally
Regarded as Safe (GRAS) process are publicly available. We currently have four food ingredients with GRAS status in the
U.S. All have received a GRAS determination from a panel of scientific experts and a ‘no questions’ letter from the FDA.
AlgaVia® Lipid Powder
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/fcn/fcnDetailNavigation.cfm?rpt=graslisting&id=469
AlgaVia® Whole Algae Protein
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/fdcc/?set=GRASNotices&id=519
Two oils have received FDA no questions letters
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/fdcc/?set=GRASNotices&id=527
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/fdcc/index.cfm?set=GRASNotices&id=384
BRAZIL
AlgaVia® Lipid Powder is a whole algae product made from a native algae strain, which means the algae has not been
genetically engineered. The food regulatory agency in Brazil, ANVISA, has approved the use of AlgaVia® Lipid Powders.
The National Health Surveillance Agency or ANVISA (Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária) is the Brazilian regulatory
agency that is responsible for the approval and supervision of food, cosmetics, tobacco, pharma and other products.
EU
The European Food Safety Agency (EFSA) reviews foods for suitability and safety and approve for use in the European
Union (EU). All new GE-derived foods are considered "novel" and subject to extensive, case-by-case, science based
food evaluation by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). The criteria for authorization fall in four broad categories:
“safety”, “freedom of choice”, “labeling”, and “traceability”.
Our native algae derived (non-engineered) Lipid Powder and Whole Algae Protein are currently allowable for food use
in the EU. An oleic oil that we produce is made with a non-modified Chlorella strain is considered “not novel” and is
currently allowed for food use in the EU.
Our high oleic algae oils are considered a novel food, and will require an evaluation to be approved for use in the EU.
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 18
PUTTING PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE > REGULATION AND GOVERNANCE
TERRAVIA SUSTAINABILITY | 19
Our company mission is about helping make life better for people and the planet while building a responsible and
profitable business.
What TerraVia does is radically simple: we transform renewable, plant sugars into healthy, sustainable oils and ingredients
using algae. We aim to use what the world has in abundance (plant sugars) to produce what society needs every day,
with a lower environmental impact and in a compressed production time - from months and years to a matter of days.
This means we can produce oil and food ingredients in a diversity of geographies and seasons, tremendously improving
supply chain integrity and resilience in the face of changing climate conditions.
As our Sustainability program sets out, we aim to run our business and meet these goals in a responsible, transparent and
truly sustainable manner. We will report on progress and continuously update our commitments.
We think these are good things. We hope that you agree. We are at the beginning of this journey and welcome input on
the continuing development of our sustainability programs. Please contact us and join us on our journey.
Conclusion