synthesis and characterization of microwave absorbing srfe12o19/znfe2o4 nanocomposite
TRANSCRIPT
ORIGINAL PAPER
Synthesis and Characterization of Microwave AbsorbingSrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 Nanocomposite
Sachin Tyagi • Himanshu B. Baskey •
Ramesh Chandra Agarwala • Vijaya Agarwala •
Trilok Chand Shami
Received: 28 March 2011 / Accepted: 11 October 2011 / Published online: 1 December 2011
� Indian Institute of Metals 2011
Abstract Zinc ferrite and strontium hexaferrite; SrFe12
O19/ZnFe2O4 (SrFe11.6Zn0.4O19) nanoparticles having
super paramagnetic nature were synthesized by simulta-
neous co-precipitation of iron, zinc and strontium chloride
salts using 5 M sodium hydroxide solution. The resulting
precursors were heat treated (HT) at 850, 950 and 1150�C
for 4 h in nitrogen atmosphere. The hysteresis loops
showed an increase in saturation magnetization from 1.040
to 58.938 emu/g with increasing HT temperatures. The ‘as-
synthesized’ particles have size in the range of 20–25 nm
with spherical and needle shapes. Further, these spherical
and needle shaped nanoparticles tend to change their
morphology to hexagonal plate shape with increase in HT
temperatures. The effect of such a systematic morpholog-
ical transformation of nanoparticles on dielectric (complex
permittivity and permeability) and microwave absorption
properties were estimated in X band (8.2–12.2 GHz). The
maximum reflection loss of the composite reaches -26.51
dB (more than 99% power attenuation) at 10.636 GHz
which suits its application in RADAR absorbing materials.
Keywords Nano materials � Heat treatments �Thermal analysis � Magnetic
1 Introduction
M type strontium hexaferrite (SrFe12O19), which is a hard
hexagonal magnetic material, has been a subject of con-
tinuous interest for several decades due to its applicability
in electronic components, magnetic memories and record-
ing media [1]. The practical application of strontium
hexaferrite as a permanent magnet is well known and it is
also used as a dielectric/magnetic filler in the electromag-
netic filler attenuation materials (EAM). EAM are used to
minimize the electromagnetic interference (EMI), a specific
type of environmental pollution. EMI problems are
attracting more attention due to the extensive use of elec-
tromagnetic (EM) waves in application of wireless com-
munication such as EM waves of 0.8–1.2 GHz are used for
mobile phones, 2.45 GHz for electronic ranges, 5.6–8.2
GHz (G-band) for synthetic aperture radar (SAR) or
microwave communication on the ground, 8.2–12.4 GHz
(X-band) and 12.4–18 (Ku-band) for SAR or electron spin
resonance (ESR) apparatus [2]. To overcome EMI prob-
lems, it is suggested that EM wave absorbing materials with
capability of absorbing unwanted EM signals having large
absorption peak, less coating thickness and wide working
frequency bandwidth are to be used. Single material cannot
meet these demands, so new systems have been evolved
comprising of composite powder including hard and soft
magnetic materials [3–5]. Zinc ferrite (ZnFe2O4) having a
cubic spinel structure is a soft magnetic material and is
widely studied as microwave absorbing material [6–8].
In view of this, in the present research, the microwave
absorption properties of the composite powder consisting
of hard magnetic strontium hexaferrite and soft magnetic
zinc ferrite were studied.
The conventional way of synthesizing hexaferrites in-
volves solid state reaction route having high HT temperature
S. Tyagi (&) � R. C. Agarwala � V. Agarwala
Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering,
Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee 247667, India
e-mail: [email protected]
H. B. Baskey � T. C. Shami
Special Materials Group, DMSRDE (DRDO Lab), Kanpur,
Uttar Pradesh, India
123
Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614
DOI 10.1007/s12666-011-0068-7
(C1,200�C), which results in powders with large particle
size, limited chemical homogeneity and low sinterability
[9]. So, the preparation of fine and uniform hexaferrite
powder without impurity is a challenging task. There are
several processing routes available in the literature [9–13].
Hydrothermal method employs expensive autoclaves, good
quality seeds of a fair size and the impossibility of
observing the crystal as it grows [14]. Sonochemical syn-
thesis can generate a transient localized hot zone with
extremely high temperature gradient and pressure [15]
which can assist the destruction of the sonochemical pre-
cursor and the formation of nanoparticles. Low temperature
combustion synthesis is complex, takes long time for self
ignition reaction to occur and needs cationic surfactants to
remove the impurity like hematite phase (aFe2O3) [16, 17].
Mechanical alloying leads to impurity and lattice strains [9].
The present investigation deals with the synthesis of zinc
substituted strontium hexaferrite nanoparticles by modified
flux method. This method is economical and is quite suitable
for mass production as compared to that the other mentioned
methods [18]. Further, studies on relative complex permit-
tivity and permeability of zinc substituted strontium hexa-
ferrite and their influence on magnetic, dielectric and
microwave absorption properties were also carried out.
2 Experimental Procedure
In the present investigation, analytical grades of ferric
chloride (FeCl3�6H2O), strontium chloride (SrCl2), zinc
chloride (ZnCl2) and NaOH were used for synthesizing
SrFe11.6Zn0.4O19 (SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4) nanoparticles by
modified flux method. Stochiometric amounts of strontium
chloride and zinc chloride were dissolved completely into
ultra pure water to make an aqueous solution (I) and ferric
chloride (FeCl3) was separately mixed in ultra pure water to
make an another aqueous solution (II). Both the above
solutions were mixed in 1:1 molar ratio. The brownish col-
ored ferrite particles were precipitated from this mixture by
gradually adding sodium hydroxide, NaOH (5 M) solution at
room temperature (pH 12.0). The aqueous suspension was
stirred gently for 15 min to achieve good homogeneity.
The precipitates so formed were filtered off, washed with
water and dried at 100�C overnight. The precipitated nano-
crystalline powder was mixed thoroughly with NaCl in 1:2
ratios (by weight). Since the melting point of NaCl is about
800�C, so the ‘as-synthesized’ particles were given a heat
treatment of 850, 950 and 1150�C for 4 h in nitrogen
atmosphere to achieve a uniform growth. During annealing,
the particles surrounded by molten NaCl salt make the pro-
cess similar to one taking place in liquid phase sintering with
high diffusion rates. This makes the process fast and hexa-
ferrite particles crystallize out completely with multiple
morphologies after cooling in the furnace. Then cooled
mixture of nanoparticles and NaCl was washed by ultra pure
water so that NaCl is dissolved and, SrFe11.6Zn0.4O19
(SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4) nanoparticles could be filtered out.
3 Characterization Studies
Thermal study for the formation of zinc substituted stron-
tium hexaferrite nanoparticles was done in nitrogen atmo-
sphere by differential scanning calorimetry, DSC (Perkin
Elmer, Pyris Diamond) at the heating rates 10 K/min. The
crystallization of phases present in different annealed
samples was identified by X-ray diffraction (XRD) using
Bruker AXS D8 diffractometer with Cu-Ka radiation.
Crystallite size of the powder was measured by X-ray line
broadening technique employing Scherrers’ formula.
Morphological study was carried out by field emission
scanning electron microscope, FESEM (QUANTA FEG
200 FEI) and transmission electron microscope, TEM
(Philips, EM 400; TECHNAI 20G2-S-TWIN). Magnetic
measurements were carried out in the applied field range of
-10,000 to ?10,000 Gauss at room temperature (300 K)
by means of vibrating sample magnetometer, VSM (155,
PAR). To study the dielectric properties, all the samples
(80 wt%) were mixed with epoxy resin and 2% hardener.
The ferrite/epoxy composite thus obtained were cast into
rectangular pellet and cured at 75�C for 30 min. The
composite thus prepared was polished and mounted on an
aluminum foil (to obtain a single layer metal-backed
absorber) to exactly fit into the measuring wave guide. The
complex permittivity and permeability measurements were
carried out on Network Analyzer (Agilent E8364B PNA
series) using Material measurement software 85071 in the
frequency range of 8.2–12.2 GHz at room temperature.
The reflection loss (RL) curves were calculated from
complex permittivity and permeability at given frequency
and absorber thickness with following equations:
Zin ¼ Zo lr=erð Þ1=2tanh j 2pfd=cð Þ lrerð Þ1=2
n o
RL ¼ 20 log Zin � Zoð Þ= Zin þ Zoð Þj j
where f is frequency, d is the thickness of absorber
(d = 2.5 mm), c is the velocity of light, Zo is the imped-
ance of air and Zin is the impedance of absorber.
4 Results and Discussion
4.1 Thermal Study
The DSC/DTG/TG traces of the sample synthesized by
modified flux method at the heating rate of 10 K/min are
608 Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614
123
shown in Fig. 1. In the DSC study of ‘as-synthesized’ zinc
substituted strontium hexaferrite, only endothermic peaks
are observed indicating that SrFe11.6Zn0.4O19 nanoparticles
are formed by the endothermic reaction. The endothermic
peak at about 813�C is attributed to the formation of various
phases like aFe2O3, ZnFe2O4 and SrFe12O19. This is con-
firmed by the XRD analysis of the powder heat treated at
850�C (Fig. 2). The second endothermic peak at 1,128�C is
attributed to endothermic reaction resulting in the formation
of desired phases (SrFe12O19 and ZnFe2O4) with increased
crystallinity, which is also confirmed by the XRD analysis
of the powder heat treated at 1,150�C (Fig. 2). Thermal
Gravimetry, TG analysis of ‘as synthesized’ powder
(Fig. 1) shows a weight loss of *62% in the temperature
range of 31–1,131�C, after that no weight loss is observed.
This is probably due to degassing and loss of moisture
during the heat treatment process. The differential thermo
gravimetric (DTG) curve indicates the derivative of ther-
mogravimetry data which is attributed to the rate of weight
loss during the endothermic reactions occurring at 813 and
1,128�C. The endothermic reaction occurring at 1,128�C
shows the weight loss of about 50% at the rate of 1.041 mg/
min (DTG) after that both TG and DTG curves become
smoother, this indicates the completion of reaction as M
type zinc substituted strontium hexaferrite nanoparticles
(SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4) are formed. This study forms the
Fig. 1 DSC–DTG–TG traces of
‘as synthesized’ SrFe12O19/
ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles
at 10 K/min in nitrogen
atmosphere
Fig. 2 XRD pattern of
SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4
nanoparticles in ‘as synthesized’
and heat treated at 850, 950 and
1150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614 609
123
basis for the selection of heat treatment temperature for the
formation M type zinc substituted strontium hexaferrite.
4.2 XRD Study
The indexed XRD patterns of the SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4
nanoparticles in ‘as-synthesized’ and after heat treatment at
850, 950 and 1150�C for 4 h in the nitrogen atmosphere are
shown in Fig. 2. From the results, it can be inferred that the
ferrite powder in ‘as-synthesized’ condition was showing
only the peak corresponding to impurity of NaCl (JCPDS
card No. 5-637). When annealed at 950�C, SrFe12O19,
2h = 34.386, d = 2.616 (JCPDS card No. 24-1207) and
ZnFe2O4, 2h = 35.542, d = 2.520 (JCPDS card No.
02-1043) also contained certain other phases, their peaks
correspond to impurity of aFe2O3, 2h = 33.360, d = 2.680
(JCPDS card No. 05-637). As expected, the degree of
crystallinity and amount of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparti-
cles was further increased by increasing the heat treatment
temperature from 850 to 1,150�C. The crystallite size of
SrFe12O19 phase (2h = 34.386) was found to increase with
increase in heat treatment temperature. It increases from
50 nm at 850�C to 55 nm at 1,150�C. From the XRD and
DSC results, it may be concluded that under the given co-
precipitation reaction, the ferric chloride is converted to
aFe(OH)3 and NaCl, which is then dehydrated to form
aFe2O3. Zinc chloride is converted to Zn(OH)2 and NaCl
which further dehydrated to zinc oxide; and strontium
chloride is also dehydrated to Sr(OH)2 which further con-
verted to strontium oxide. Finally, SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4
nanoparticles are formed during the post synthesis calci-
nations stage and can be described by the following
chemical reactions.
Neutralization with sodium hydroxide
12FeCl3 þ 36NaOH! 12Fe OHð Þ3þ 36NaCl
ZnCl2 þ 2NaOH! Zn OHð Þ2þ 2NaCl
SrCl2� þ 2NaOH! Sr OHð Þ2þ 2NaCl
Nucleation of nano crystals
12Fe OHð Þ3! 6Fe2O3 þ 18H2O
Zn OHð Þ2! ZnOþ H2O
Sr OHð Þ2! SrOþ H2O
Growth of nano crystals
ZnOþ Fe2O3 ! ZnFe2O4
SrOþ 6Fe2O3 ! SrFe12O19
4.3 Morphological Study
The FESEM micrographs of ‘as-synthesized’ and heat
treated ferrite powder at temperatures of 850, 950 and
1150�C are shown in Fig. 3. In the ‘as-synthesized’ con-
dition, the particles seem to have spherical and needle
shaped morphology with particle size in the range of
20–25 nm (Fig. 3a). With increasing heat treatment tem-
perature, the particles grow and constitute multiple mor-
phologies. Also, with rise in heat treatment temperature,
the systematic growth of particles is observed with sharp
plane of crystals. This process of crystal growth and mor-
phological evolution can be described in terms of Ostwald
ripening. In ‘as-synthesized’ condition, the nanoparticles
with size in the range of 20–25 nm with spherical and
needle shaped morphology are observed. As the HT tem-
perature is increased, these nanoparticles slowly disappear
except for the few that grow larger, at the expense of
smaller ones. Thus particles of small size act as nutrients
for the bigger ones. At 1,150�C, SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nano-
particles (with size in the range of 80–90 nm) having large
hexagonal plate shape are observed (Fig. 3c, d). This is
also evidenced by TEM micrograph of the powder in ‘as-
synthesized’ and heat treated condition (Fig. 4). These
multiple morphologies, possessing large surface areas,
leads to plenty of interfacial polarization to weaken the
energy of EM waves. It is reported that barium and
strontium hexaferrite nanoparticles with hexagonal plate
like morphology are potential materials for the RADAR
absorption applications [19–21].
4.4 Magnetic Study
The magnetic measurements of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nano-
particles have almost negligible coercivity and remanance
values (Fig. 5) in the ‘as-synthesized’ condition showing
the superparamagnetic behavior of the material. But when
the ‘as-synthesized’ powders are heat treated (at 850, 950
and 1150�C), the particles appear to transform from su-
perparamagnetic to ferromagnetic nature. Saturation mag-
netization is found to be dependent on HT temperature.
It increases from 1.040 to 58.938 emu/g with increase in
HT temperature (Fig. 5). The rise in saturation magneti-
zation with the HT temperature can be attributed to the
increased formation of strontium hexaferrite and zinc fer-
rite which is confirmed by X-ray study of powder HT at
various temperatures (Fig. 2) [18]. The coercivity of
1,671 Gauss is observed for the powder heat treated at
950�C and thereafter decreases to 1,238 Gauss at 1,200�C.
This might be due to the presence of aFe2O3 up to 950�C;
which has a high intrinsic coercive force [22]. In addition,
the change in morphology and particle size may also affect
the magnetic properties [18]. The co-precipitated powder
heat treated with NaCl at 1,150�C having large hexagonal
plate shape achieved maximum saturation magnetization.
While the co-precipitated powder heat treated with NaCl at
950�C that have similar hexagonal plate like structure in
610 Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614
123
Fig. 3 FESEM micrographs showing the effect of heat treatment temperature on the morphology of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles, a ‘as
synthesized’ and heat treated at b 850�C, c 950�C and d 1,150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
Fig. 4 TEM micrographs showing the effect of heat treatment temperature on the morphology of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles, a ‘as
synthesized’ and b heat treated at 1,150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614 611
123
addition to aFe2O3 achieved a maximum coercivity
(Table 1). Thus the synthesis of spinel, ZnFe2O4 along
with hexagonal, SrFe12O19 particles in nano size range
results in higher saturation magnetization and lower coer-
civity than those reported for single phase strontium
hexaferrite and zinc ferrite [6, 8, 23]. Hexaferrite nano-
particles having low coercivity and high saturation mag-
netization find their applications in magnetic recordings in
hard disks, floppy disks, video tapes, etc. [22].
4.5 Dielectric Study
Complex permittivity and permeability values represent the
dielectric and magnetic properties of the materials. The real
parts (e0, l0) of complex permittivity and permeability
symbolize the storage capability of electric and magnetic
energy. The imaginary parts (e00, l00) represent the loss of
electric and magnetic energy. As a microwave absorber,
big imaginary parts of complex permittivity and perme-
ability are expected. The real and imaginary parts of
complex permittivity (Fig. 6a, b) and permeability
(Fig. 7a, b) of nanoparticles are plotted as a function of
frequency in X-band (8.2–12.2 GHz). It is observed that,
with increase in heat treatment temperature from ‘as-syn-
thesized’ condition to 1,150�C, both complex permittivity
and permeability are observed to increase continuously.
The real part of permittivity is found to increase from 5.228
(average value) in ‘as synthesized’ condition to 9.883
(average value) when heat treated at 1,150�C (Fig. 6a). The
Fig. 5 The effect of HT temperature on hysteresis loops of SrFe12
O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles in ‘as synthesized’ condition and heat
treated at 850, 950 and 1150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
Table 1 Effect of heat treatment temperature on the morphology and magnetic parameters of strontium hexaferrites
Temperature (�C) Morphology Coercivity
(Gauss)
Remanance,
Mr (emu/g)
Saturation magnetisation,
Ms (emu/g)
Mr/Ms
92 (As synthesized) Spherical and needle (20–25 nm) 5.000 0.0209 1.040 0.020
850 Small hexagonal (60–65 nm) 1,655 20.267 37.497 0.540
950 Large hexagonal (70–80 nm) 1,671 23.131 43.204 0.535
1,150 Large hexagonal (80–90 nm) 1,238 29.906 58.938 0.507
Fig. 6 The effect of HT temperature on real (e0) and imaginary (e00) part of permittivity of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles in ‘as synthesized’
condition and heat treated at 850, 950 and 1150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
612 Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614
123
same trend is observed for the imaginary part of permit-
tivity. The maximum imaginary permittivity of 3.48
(average value) is observed for the material heat treated at
1,150�C (Fig. 6b). Also, the real permeability increases
from 1.104 (average value) in ‘as-synthesized’ condition to
1.233 (average value) when heat treated at 1,150�C
(Fig. 7a). Similarly imaginary permeability is also
increasing with increase in heat treatment temperature. The
maximum imaginary permeability of 1.111 (average value)
is observed for the powder heat treated at 1,150�C
(Fig. 7b). The increase in complex permittivity and per-
meability with increase in heat treatment temperature in all
the cases is attributed to the increased formation and
growth of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles with increase
in HT temperature. The significance of the results is the
stability in the values of complex permittivity and perme-
ability (obtained for large bandwidth) than those reported
in literature [6–8, 23] for pure strontium hexaferrite and
zinc ferrite.
4.6 Reflection Loss Study
The RL for ‘as-synthesized’ SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanopar-
ticles are low for all the frequencies between 8.2 and
12.2 GHz (Fig. 8) and minimum to maximum values are
found to be in the range of -5.04 dB (at 8.200 GHz) to
-14.91 dB (at 10.636 GHz). For SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4
nanoparticles heat treated at 850�C, the RL is evidently
improved to -22.15 dB at 10.636 GHz and has further
enhanced to -26.51 dB for the material heat treated at
1,150�C (Fig. 8). The increment in RL with increasing heat
treatment temperature is attributed to the increased for-
mation of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles. The strongest
RL and the widest bandwidths (for RL [ 10 dB) are given
in Table 2. The improvement of RL originated from the
formation of hard and soft ferrite which can be explained
on the basis of exchange coupling interaction between hard
magnetic (SrFe12O19) and soft magnetic (ZnFe2O4) phases,
which changes the relative complex permeability of the
materials. In this study, the nanocomposite powders were
synthesized by modified flux method so two kinds of grains
can be combined. The composite powder including hexa-
ferrite (SrFe12O19) and spinel ferrite (ZnFe2O4) coupled to
each other by exchange through interface of ferrite parti-
cles. There will be more interfaces if the grain size is
smaller, and there will be stronger exchange coupling
interaction at the interface. As we know the cubic spinal
crystal structure of ZnFe2O4 is similar with the structure of
S block of SrFe12O19, so it is possible that the vacancy of
ZnFe2O4 is combined with Fe3? at the SrFe12O19 surface,
Fig. 7 The effect of HT temperature on real (l0) and imaginary (l00) part of permeability of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles in ‘as synthesized’
condition and heat treated at 850, 950 and 1150�C in nitrogen atmosphere
Fig. 8 The effect of HT temperature on RL of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 in
‘as synthesized’ condition and heat treated at 850, 950 and 1150�C
Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614 613
123
which is another possible reason for strong interface cou-
pling interaction. Thus, exchange coupling interaction
existing between hard and soft magnetic phases improves
the dielectric and microwave absorption properties [4, 5],
which is in agreement with the present study. Moreover,
microwave absorption enhanced when particles size is
reduced from micron to nano size [24]. This can be
explained by quantum size effect in nanocrystallite parti-
cles which makes the electronic energy levels split and the
spacing between adjacent energy states increases inversely
with the volume of the particles. If the particle of absorber
material is small enough and the discrete energy level
spacing is in the energy range of microwave, the electron
can absorb the energy as it leaps from one level to another,
which may lead to increase in attenuation. The -10 dB
absorption bandwidth corresponds to 68% EM wave
amplitude attenuation or to 90% power attenuation,
whereas a -20 dB absorption bandwidth corresponds to
90% amplitude attenuation or to 99% power attenuation
[25]. The epoxy resin is an insulator and nonmagnetic;
thus, it is transparent to EM waves. In the SrFe12O19/
ZnFe2O4/epoxy composite, the epoxy resin only functions
as matrix [25]. The RL of the composite mainly stems from
the contribution of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 magnetic compos-
ite. Thus more than 99% power attenuation is observed for
the composite material heat treated at 1,150�C which suits
its application in Stealth defense in all military platforms.
5 Conclusions
Uniform needle and spherical shaped nanoparticles
(20–25 nm) of SrFe12O19/ZnFe2O4 have been successfully
synthesized by modified flux method. The SrFe12O19/
ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles have higher saturation magnetiza-
tions of 58.938 emu/g and low intrinsic coercivity
(1,238 Gauss) when heat treated at 1,150�C while com-
paring with heat treated powder at 950�C (43.204 emu/g,
1,671 Gauss). The real and imaginary parts of permittivity
and permeability increases with increase in heat treatment
temperature. The maximum RL of -26.5 dB (more than
99% power attenuation) at 10.636 GHz is obtained for the
material heat treated at 1,150�C.
Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge Ministry of Human
Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India for the fel-
lowship granted to first author of this study.
References
1. Vishwanathan B, and Murthy V R K, Ferrite Materials Scienceand Technology, Narosa Publishing House, New Delhi (1990).
2. Li D S, Horikawa T, Liu J R, Itoh M, and Machida K, J AlloysCompd 408 (2006) 1429.
3. Masala O, Hoffman D, Sundaram N, Page K, Proffen T, Lawes
G, and Seshadri R, Solid State Sci 8 (2006) 1015.
4. Maeda T, Sugimoto S, Kagotani T, Tezuka N, and Inomata K,
J Magn Magn Mater 281 (2004) 195.
5. Liu J R, Itoh M, and Machida K, Appl Phys Lett 88 (2006)
062503/1.
6. Peng C H, Hwang C C, Wan J, Tsai J S, and Chen S Y, Mater SciEng B 117 (2005) 27.
7. Yusoff A N, and Abdullah M H, J Magn Magn Mater 269 (2004)
271.
8. Qiu J X, Wang C Y, and Gu M Y, Mater Sci Eng B 112 (2004) 1.
9. Cullity B D, and Graham C D, Introduction to Magnetic Mate-rials, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey (2008).
10. Chin T S, Hsu S L, and Deng M C, J Magn Magn Mater 120(1993) 64.
11. Liu X, Wang J, Gan L M, and Ng S C, J Magn Magn Mater 195(1999) 452.
12. Sivakumar M, Gedanken A, Zhong W, Du Y W, Bhattacharya D,
Yeshurun Y, and Felner I, J Magn Magn Mater 268 (2004) 95.
13. Huang J, Zhuang H, and Li W, J Magn Magn Mater 256 (2003)
390.
14. O’Donoghue M, A Guide to Man-Made Gemstones, Van No-
strand Reinhold, Great Britain (1983) p 40.
15. Suslick K S, Ultrasound: Its Chemical, Physical and BiologicalEffects, VCH, Weinheim (1988).
16. Hasab M G, Ebrahimi S A S, and Badiei A, J Eur Ceram Soc 27(2007) 3637.
17. Hasab M G, Ebrahimi S A S, and Badiei A, J Eur Ceram Soc 310(2007) 2477.
18. Hessien M M, Rashad M M, and El-Barawy K, J Magn MagnMater 320 (2008) 336.
19. Tyagi S, Agarwala R C, and Agarwala V, J. Nano R 10 (2010) 19.
20. Sharma R, Agarwala R C, and Agarwala V, Mater Lett 62 (2008)
2233.
21. Sharma R, Agarwala R C, and Agarwala V, J. Nano R 2 (2008)
91.
22. Fu Y P, and Lin C H, J Alloys Compd. 386 (2005) 222.
23. Ataie A, and Heshmati-Manesh S, J Eur Ceram Soc 21(2001)
1951.
24. Ruan S, Xu B, Suo H, Wu F, Xiang S, and Zhao M, J Magn MagnMater 212 (2000) 175.
25. Liu X, Zhang Z, and Wu Y, Composites: Part B 42 (2011) 326.
Table 2 The strongest RL and
the widest bandwidths (for
RL [ 10 dB) in ‘as
synthesized’ and heat treated
conditions
Powder Minimum
(8.200 GHz)
Maximum
(12.200 GHz)
The widest bandwidth
for RL [ 10 dB (in GHz)
The strongest RL (dB)
at 10.636 GHz
As synthesized -5.04 -6.99 1.8 (9.7–11.5) -14.91
HT at 850�C -7.19 -9.23 3.2 (8.8–12.0) -22.15
HT at 950�C -8.06 -10.17 3.5 (8.7–12.2) -24.12
HT at 1,150�C -8.53 -10.64 3.5 (8.7–12.2) -26.51
614 Trans Indian Inst Met (December 2011) 64(6):607–614
123