tarsal tunnel syndrome: outcomes of surgical · pdf filebastias g, gutierrez r, layseca a,...

12
Bastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G Foot and Ankle Unit Hospital del Trabajador Santiago, Chile Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical Treatment in 31 patients

Upload: vuongbao

Post on 07-Feb-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Bastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G Foot and Ankle Unit

Hospital del Trabajador Santiago, Chile

Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical

Treatment in 31 patients

Page 2: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

• No conflicts to disclose • My disclosure is in the final AOFAS mobile app • I have no potential conflicts with this

presentation

Page 3: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Introduction

• Tarsal tunnel syndrome (TTS) is an entrapment neuropathy of the posterior tibial nerve or its branches within its fibroosseous tunnel beneath the flexor retinaculum on the medial side of the ankle.

Page 4: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Introduction

• Management of this neuropathy is complex with unclear outcomes in current literature.

• Operative treatment has been reported to have good-excellent results in space ocupying lesions.

• Post-traumatic TTS is usually related to poor results.

Page 5: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Patients and Methods

• We included all patients who underwent tarsal tunnel release at our institution from January 2011 to December 2013.

• Clinical data was collected including:

Physical exam findings Duration of symptoms Trauma History Intraoperative findings Workmen´s Compensation involvement Outcome according to patient´s postoperative symptoms

Page 6: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Results

• 31 patients – Male: 11 – Female: 20

• Mean Age : 45 years (Range 19-66)

• Duration of Symptoms: 12 weeks (Range 1-36)

– 38,7% of the patients received plantar fasciitis

• Previous foot and ankle fracture history: 22 patients (73,3%)

• 18 patients with worker´s compensation involvement

Page 7: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Results

• Clinical Findings – Medial ankle pain: 100% (31 pts.) – Paresthesias : 87% (27 pts.) – Positive Tinel sign: 52% (16 pts.)

• Diagnosis was made clinically in all patients with abnormal electrodiagnostic findings in 27 patients (87%).

Page 8: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Results

• Intraoperative Findings: – Varicosities: 15 pts. – Fibrosis/Scarring: 9 pts – Hypertrophic Retinaculum: 6 pts. – Space Occupying Lesions (SOL): 1 pt.

Page 9: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Results

• Clinical Outcomes: – Favorable: 20 pts. (64,5%)

• 4,5 weeks in average • Improvement up to 12

weeks postoperatively • 18/20 patients with less

than 6 months of symptoms

– Not Favorable: 11 pts. • No changes: 8 pts • Worsening of symptoms

postoperative: 3 pts

• Complications (25%):

– Symptomatic scar: 4 pts. – Revision surgery: 3 pts – Wound complication: 3

pts. – Deep wound infection: 2

pts. – CRPS 1 pt.

Page 10: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Favorable Not Favorable p Female 8 (42.73%) 3 (27.27%) Male 11 (55.00%) 9 (45.00%) p=0.45 Worker´s compensation

8 (44.44%) 10 (55.56%) p=0.03

Trauma history 13(59.09%) 6 (75.00%) p= 0.67 Paresthesias 17 (62.96%) 10 (37.04%) P=0.63 Tinel 11 (68.75%) 5 (31.25%) p=0.47 Hypertrophic retinaculum

6 (83.33%) 1 (16.67%) p=0.36

Varicosities 8 (53.33%) 7 (46.67%) p=0.47 Fibrosis 5 (62.50%) 3 (37.50%) p=0.99 < 6 months symptoms

18 (90%) 7 (72,72%) P=0.05

Page 11: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

• Tarsal tunnel release outcomes depend on patient selection.

• In our study, patients subject to workmen ́s compensation was statistically associated with worse clinical outcome.

• Contrary to current literature, traumatic STT was not asociated with worse outcome.

• Tarsal tunnel release for space occupying lesions (mainly varicosities), were associated with symptom relief, but without statistical significance.

Conclusions

Page 12: Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome: Outcomes of Surgical · PDF fileBastias G, Gutierrez R, Layseca A, Bergeret JP Verschae G . Foot and Ankle Unit . Hospital del Trabajador . Santiago, Chile

Bibliography

• Gould J, Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome Foot Ankle Clin N Am 16 (2011) 275–286

• Pfeiffer W, Cracchiolo A. Clinical results after tarsal tunnel decompression. J Bone Joint Surg 1994;76-A(8):1222–30.

• Hendrix C, Jolly GP, Garbalosa JC. Entrapment neuropathy; the aetiology of intractable chronic heel pain syndrome. J Foot Ankle Surg 1998;37(4):273–9.

• DiGiovanni BF, Abuzzahab FS, Gould JS. Plantar fascia release with proximal and distal tarsal tunnel release: surgical approach to chronic disabling plantar fasciitis with associated nerve pain. Tech Foot Ankle Surg 2003;2:254–61.