the hurricane engine’s turbobooster or more power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · john persing (csu)...

48
The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to Hurricanes and Typhoons Michael T. Montgomery Naval Post Graduate School, Monterey, CA & NOAA’s Hurricane Resesarch Division, Miami, FL In collaboration with John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Upload: others

Post on 02-Apr-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster

or

More Power to Hurricanes and Typhoons

Michael T. Montgomery

Naval Post Graduate School, Monterey, CA& NOAA’s Hurricane Resesarch Division, Miami, FL

In collaboration with

John Persing (CSU)Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR)Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD)

Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Page 2: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

MOTIVATION

•What are the key thermodynamical and dynamical processes that determine the maximum intensity of a hurricane within a given environment?

•Is the physics sensitive to the basic geometry ? Axisymmetric (2D) versus 3D.

For majority of this talk the underlying sea surface temperatureis assumed prescribed (an infinite heat bath).

Page 3: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

[No Gilbert, Hugo, Mitch, Andrew, Isabel,…]A GLOBAL VIEW OF TROPICAL CYCLONES (1987)R. ELSBERRY (Editor)

Page 4: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 5: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 6: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

*

Page 7: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

K. Emanuel

Page 8: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

K. Emanuel 1997 J. Atmos. Sci.1995 J. Atmos. Sci

Page 9: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 10: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 11: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Camp & Montgomery 2001

Page 12: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 13: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

K. Emanuel 1988 J. Atmos. Sci.

Page 14: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

detailed observations are clearly needed to elucidate the structure, intensity, and

environmental parameters of the anomalous cases.

Figure 2.2: Holland and Emanuel MPI model estimates and the corresponding SST for (a) HMPI and (b) E-MPI. model estimates. Model estimates that were noticeably underestimated (Circles) and the corresponding maximum observed tropical cyclone intensity (Plus signs) are also shown. [From Tonkin et al. (2000)]

Page 15: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 16: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 17: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 18: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 19: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 20: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 21: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 22: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 23: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

•Eastin (2003) & Lee Joice (2000)(See new data below in this talk)

Page 24: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 25: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

EXPT: ZERO Latent/Sensible Fluxes

Within Eye t>13 d

EXP: ZERO Latent & Sensible Fluxes Within Eye t>13 d

EMPI

Page 26: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Hurricane Ivan (2004)

Page 27: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 28: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 29: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 30: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 31: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Page 32: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Next Steps

Are there examples of superintense storms in nature ?

Are there examples of superintense storms in 3D models ?

Improve MPI theory

Page 33: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 34: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Hurricane Isabel, September 13, 2003

SSMI 85 GHZ – Brightness Temperature

2218 UTC

GOES Visible

1745 UTC

NOAA P3 (~2 km altitude) – Lower fuselage radar (5 cm)

1747 UTC

Page 35: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 36: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 37: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 38: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 39: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., Vol. 80,pgs. 407-420.

Page 40: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Bell and Montgomery 2006, Mon. Wea. Rev., submitted

Page 41: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Bell and Montgomery, 2006,Mon. Wea. Rev., submitted

Page 42: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Montgomery et al., 2006Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., in press.

Page 43: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Montgomery et al., 2006,Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., in press.

Page 44: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Montgomery et al., 2006,Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., in press.

Page 45: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Montgomery et al., 2006,Bull Amer Met Soc in press

Page 46: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)

Montgomery et al., 2006,Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., in press.

Page 47: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)
Page 48: The Hurricane Engine’s Turbobooster or More Power to … · 2006. 11. 10. · John Persing (CSU) Michael Bell (CSU/NCAR) Sim Aberson (NOAA/HRD) Michael Black (NOAA/HRD)