thiri~ legislative assembly attention (under -rule 63) eight calling attention notices were...

A BRIEF REPORT

BUSINESS TRANSACTED DURING THE

SECOND SESSION

(J~LY-AUGUST), I

I OF

1999

GO LEGISLATURE SEt 1 P O R I O N M U ~ A I I 2002 I

2003 YEAR OF THE:

THE THIRI~ LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY

OF I

THE STATE OF GOA

ZRETARIAT

CHILD

THE BUSINESS TRANSACTED DURING THE

SECOND SESSION (JC'LY-AUG,UST), 1999 I

1 I I

I

PREFACE

This booklet contains brief information on the business transacted by the Third Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa during the Second Session July-August, 1999.

ASSEMBLY HALL, PORVORIM-GOA

30 APRIL, 2002.

S. A. KARVEMR SECRETARY, LEGISLATUIPE

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Brief Report of the Second Session July-August, 1999 of the Third Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa.

Statement No.1 - Statement No.2 - Statement No.3 - Statement No.4 -

Statement No.5 - Statement No.6 - Statement No.7 - Statement No. 8 -

Statement No. 9 1

Statement No. 10 - Statement No. 11 Statement No. 12 - Statement No. 13 1

1 Statement No. 14 -

Statement No. 15 - I

Statement No. 16 Statement No. 17 -

Statement No. 18 1- I

Statement No. 19 1-

Dates of Meeting Attendance of Members Percentage of Attendance of Members. Summary of Business transacted during the Second Session of July-August, 1999 by the Third Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa. Main Demands ~ u ~ ~ l e m e n t 4 ~ ~ Demands

Government

Zero Hour dfentions

A Brief Report of the Second Session July - August, 1999 of the Third Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa.

The Second Session July-August 1999 of the Third Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa commenced at the Assembly Hall, Panaji on Wednesday 7 July, 1999. The House was adjourned sine-die on 3 Augilst,1999. Total time taken for the Business of the sitting was 69 hours and 05 minutes.

MOTION FOR CONGRATlJLATlONS

Motions for Congratulation congratulating:-

i) Mr. Leander Paes and Shri Mahesh Bhupati, First Indian duo who brought credit to the Nation by winning the prestigious Wimbledon titles in the year 1999.

3 Shri Eduardo ~aleird for having been ellxted as the Member of the Parliament for ~ a ~ ~ a l Sabha from Goa. I

I

iii) Shri N. Shivdas for hkving received an ~ k a r d at Natural Competition for Children's L i t e r a t b r e ( ~ ~ c ~ L ) 1998-91) for the book titled 'BABU' in Konkani language.(

I

Motion for ~ondolende was moved on the ],assing away of Shri George Vaz, Veteran Freedom ~ighter and Trade ~ n ? ; ~ n Leader.

i FI~ANCIAL BUSINE 3s

I I Discussion and voting on Demands for Grants for the year

1999-2000 took place for 2 days i.e. on 14 15 July,1999. In all 80 Demands were set forth or discussion and The discussion and 7 voting on Demands took place for 9 days 20, 21, 22, 26, 27, 28, 29 July and 2 ~ 1 . 1 ~ ~ ~ 4 1 9 9 9 . I

( Vide Statement No. 5)

Presentation of Supplementary Demands for Grants for the year 1999-2000 (First Batch) on 14.2.1999 and discussed and passed on 2.8.1999.

(Vide Statement No. 6)

Government Resolutions

Two notices of Resolutions were received and were admitted.

(Vide Statement No. 7) ----

Government Legislative Businjess

Eight Bills were introduced during the session and all were passed.


I

Private Members' Bills I Notice to a Private ers' Bill was rec ived and the same

lapsed as the Member cted as Minister. f 1 (Vide Sl atement No.9) I I --- I

Other nnouncements

Announcemen 1 of Assent to Bill I 1 I

(Vide Starement No.10 )

' Private Members' Resolutions

9, 16, 23, & 30 July 1999 were aIlotted for, Private Members' Business. Thirty seven notices bf Resolutions we& received, out of which ten were passed. I I

( Vide Statement No.1 I) i I

1

Calling Attention (Under -Rule 63)

Eight Calling Attention Notices were received, out of which five were admitted.


Papers laid on the Table

Seventeen papers were laid on the Table of the House.

(Vide Statement No.13 )

Starred and Unstarred Questions

Notices of 669 Starred Questions and 16 Unstarred Questions were received.

Questions Stmc:d Unstarred Total

Received 669 16 685

Disallowed 1 14 - 14

Starred Questions admitted , I as Unstarred 1 75

- 75

Consolidated

Admitted

Replied I - 171

Not replied ! 1 90 - 456

(Vide Statement No. 14 I

Postponed ,

short Notice Que I

1 - 1

One Short Notice Question was receivbd and the same was disallowed.

( Vide Statement No.16 & 17 )

I

- 4 -

Presentation of Report

One Report of Business Advisory Committee was presented.

(Vide Statement No. 18) ----

Zero Hour Mentions

Fifty-eight Zero Hour Notices were received and all were discussed.

( Vide Statement No.19 )

~ i ___-_ I

I I

-- 5 -

STATEMENT No. 1

I

Dates of Meeting

S1. Date of Meeting Time of Meeting Total Period

No. From To Hrs. Mts.

S1. Date of Meeting Time of Meetin2 Total Period No. From To Hrs. Mts.

- 7 -

STATEMENT No. 2

Attendanceof Members (excluding Speaker,Dy .Speaker, Ministers andEeaderof Opposition)

Date Present Absent

- 8 -

STATELVENT No. 3

Percentage of attendance of each Member of the Legislative Assembly (Excluding Speaker, Dy. Speaker, Ministers and Leader -.

of Opposition.) !

SI. No. of days i Percentage No. Name of the Member attended the

Session.

1 2 3 4

1. Shri Ramakant Khalap 20 100% 2. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu 3. Shri Manohar Azgaonkar 4. Shri Francis D'Souza : 5. Shri Dayanand Mandrekar 6. Shri Suresh Parulekar 7. Dr .Wilfred de Souza 8. Shri Ulhas Asnodkar 9. Shri Somnarh Zuarkar

10. Smt. VictoriaFernandes 11. ShriFrancis Silveira 12. Shri Pandurang Raut 13. Shri Prakash Phadte 14. Dr. Suresh Amonkar 15. Shri Venkatesh Dessai

I 16. Shri Vishwas Satarkar 1 17. Shri RamkrishnaDhavalikar

I 18. Shri Subhash Shirodkar 19. Shri Shaikh Hassan doo on 20. Shri Mauvin Godinho 21. Shri Jose PhilipD'Souza 22. Shri Luis Alex Cardozo 23. Shri Digambar Karnat I . ShriFilipeNery Rodrig es

I 25. Shri Arecio D'Souza I

26. Shri Vinay Tendulkar , 27. Shri Prabhakar Gaonkar/

Shri Ramrao Dessai i

-9-

STATEMENT NO. 4.

Summary sf Business transacted by the Goa Legislative Assembly, day to day during the Second Session of

July-August, 1999.

WEDNESDAY, 7 JULY, 1999.

I. ADDRESS BY THE GOVERNOR

Lt. Gen. J.F.R Jacob, PVSM(Retd.) 3.E. the Governor deliv- ered an address to the House.

11. Laying the copy of the Address by the Gojrernor.

Secretary laid the copy of the Address by {he Governor on h e Table of the House

I

111. Shri Dayanand Narvekar presented the House the Report of the Business Advisory Committee and tbe following motion:

"This House agreBs with the business proposed by the Business Advisory Committee."

Motion was proposed, put to vote and ado jted. i IV. Shri ~ a ~ a n a n d Narvekar announced the 3 siness to be transacted during

the week. 1 1. Election of the Deputy Speaker. 1 2. Presentation of Annual Financi 1 Statement for the year

1999-2000. ' i

3. Private ~ember s ' Business. 1 I

V. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu raised a joint of order that there i have been some contemptuous utterances in the press by the Hon. Leader of Opposition, Shri Manohar Parrikar regarding attempt at the Panchayat level at Tuem to demand money from small scale units.

I

Hon. Speaker ruled that the House is a place where we have to discuss serious matters. When somebody makes allegations outside the House, Hon. Members should refute it in the papers or wherever it has come. If Hon. Member makes a charge on you here, you have every right to deny the charge or refute it. You are a new Member, lot of things will come in the papers. We don't have to pay attention to that.

THURSDAY, 8 JULY, 199!3

I. ELEC.TION OF. DEPUTY SPEAKER:

Hon. Speaker made following announcement.

For the election of the Deputy Speaker, the following nominations were received by Legislature Secretariat:

1) Shri Aleixo Sequeira - Proposed by Shri Luizinho Faleiro and Seconded by Shri Mauvin

i I

Godinho. I I

2) Shri Prakash ~hadtej - Proposed by Manohar Panikar by Shri Vinay ( Tendullcar.

I As two Members dontested for the ffice of Dy. Speaker,

I being more than one candidate, election folloy d.

I Motion moved by Shri Luizinho Faleiro wa put tovote and adopted.

I i

Seventeen Members offered felicitar.ions to the Dy. Speaker, Shri Aleixo Sequeira. Dy. Speaker in returri thanked the Members for electing him as Dy. Speaker.

Hon. Speaker informed the House that. he would deviate from the usual procedure being followed in the House., of Members speaking first and then the senior Leaders of the Opposition as well as Miriisters. However, he would allow the Hon. Members to speak today, as some of the Members are very new and they are not aware of the procedure.

Hon. Speaker also informed the House that yesterday he did not want to stop the new Member from Pemern from talking as we are guided by the Rules of the House. The Business of the House comes first. He further continued that if they have got any important matter to be brought in the Ilouse, they should give a notice two hours before the cornrnerlcelnent of the sitting of the House. He further continued that the Members during the question hour have to elicit information and they now have the Right to Information Act where one can get al\ the information. He also informed the House (that if the Hon. disturb the proceed- ings of the House, be will have to and it is as good as you have not spoke+ in the House.

Hon. Speaker immensely about the procedure to be

the Annual Financial Statement for the ye& 1999-2000.

ii) Nineteen ~tarreh Questions were notireached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

11. ZERO HOUR ME~TIONS I j !

1) Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon made i i mention regarding the non payment of compensation for landslitle victims at Tariwada, Vasco da Gama.

- 12-

2) Shri Prakash Velip made a mention about power theft in Cuncolim Industrial Estate.

3) Shri Pandurang Raut made a mention of loss in K. T. C.

4) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention of the non availability of doctors in time at Canacona Hospital.

5 ) Shri Manohar Panikar made a mention ab ut inferior quality of rice supplied through fair price shops. b

Shri the

Shri Luis Alex Cardozo made a menti& about lack of proper facilities at Margao Bus Stand.

Smt. Victoria Fernandes made a mentioh of request for bus shed near G.M.C. Bambolim. I Shri Manohar Azgaonkar made to take action againit the murd

I

Shri Vinay ~endulk4r made a in Sanvordem ~ o n s t k u e n c ~ .

Shri Vishwas ~ a r a r k ~ r made a the wheels of a MLA' s car.

Shri Digambar K d a i made PetroleumIGas ~ ~ e h c ~ for spo

I National level. i

!

. ~ a ~ a n a n d ~arvekar hnounced th week.

Discussion on overn nor's Addre

Presentation of Supplementary D 1999-2000(~irst ~a t ch ) .

I

General Discussion bn Annu 1999-2000. I

I I

Introduction of Govefnment Bills. I

Private Members' ~psiness. 1

- 13 -

IV. PRIVATE MEMBERS' BUSINESS

Resolutions:-

1) Shri Digambar Kamat moved the following resolution:

"Whereas Margao city is situated on the banks of river Sal and in olden days the essential items like tiles, wood etc. used to be transported to Margao city via rher Sal and due to non dissiltation of the river the areas like Khareband, Pedda, Comba .

flooded every year during monsoon. Therefore this House strongly recommends Government to take up the work of dissiltation of this river on priority basis to avoid continuous flooding of these areas during monsoons."

The Resolution was moyed and proposed. '

1

Resolution was postponed to 16 July 1999.

2) Shri Prakash Velip moved the following I

"Whereas people from Barce and su rounding areas of V .P. Barce are facing acute shortage of wat r during summer season as there is no source of water upply in nearby areas; Therefore this Mouse strongly recomme ds Government to set up a water supply scheme to provide rinking water in these areas." I

Resolution was moved' and proposed. Thr e Members took part in the debate. The resolution has withdrawn by of the House.

3) Shri Prakash Phadte moved the following I

'This House res{lves that the which was originally a Village of Village Panchayat. "

Resolution was moved land proposed. Four Members took part in the debate. Resolution was put to vote and defeated.

I 1

- 14-

MONDAY, 12 JULY, 199!3

I. i) Eleven Starred Questions were answered.

ii) Twenty three Starred Questions were not reached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

11. RULING BY HON. SPEAKER ON ZERO HOUR

It has become a practice to raise the matters of urgent nature in the House during Zero Hour after the Question H:our is over, even though various opportunities are available to the Procedure and Conduct of Busine such matters.

Since there is no rule for regula are experiencing difficulties to regulate would like to prescribe the following proce in our Assembly in the !absence of whic is disturbed and regular B,usiness lis and cannot be completed hithin the

Those Members whb would like House during Zero Hour bay give the Secretary, Legislature redarding the to raise in the House medtioning therein

, alleast by l.OOp.m. beforel\ the commence for the day. Secretary, Legidahre wil and the same will be forbarded to the ~ in i s t e r will be in apositiop to collect the in to the point/points raised lby the Member which have not been apprpved by raised in the House and intimation t the member concerned orhly or in writin Zero Hour.

It may please be no{ed that during 2,ero 'Hour unless a notice t Legislature by 1.00 p.m. An the day of th

-15-

11. A. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

1) Shri Prakash Velip made a mention about request to increase the salaries of Anganwadi workers.

2) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention about his decision to donate his eye to a soldier losing both his eyes.

3) Shri Vinay Tendulkar made a mentica about rehabilitation of displaced farmers of Dhangar communi1.y by Forest Department in V. P. Collem and V. P. Mollem in Sanguern Taluka.

4) Smt. Victoria Fernandes made a mention about the ban on fishing during breeding sdason.

I I I

5 ) Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon made a mention about the handing of burial ground at Margao to Muslim community.

111. MOTION FOR CONGRATULATION

Shri Digambar Kamat moved the following motion for congratulation:-

"This House whole heartedly congra ulates Shri. Leander Paes and Shri Mahesh ~ h u ~ a t i , First Indian uo, who brought credit to the Nation by winning prestigious Wi nbledon titles in the year 1999." i

The Motion was proposed. Ten Me~n ers took part in the debate, The motion was passed unanimously.

I 1 1

1. Shri Luizinho Faleiro laid the following papers on the Table of the House:- ?2

i) Annual Report of Goa University for the year 1997 -98.

ii) Annual Audited Accounts for the year 1996-97 . iii) The GoaLand Repenue (Inspection, Scjarch and S~apply of copies of

Land Records) (Amendment) Rules,1!998. I

I

- 16-

2. Shri Francisco Sardinha laid on the Table of the House:-

The Goa Standards of Weights and Ivleasures (Enforcement) Amendment Rules, 1999.

V. MOTION OF THANKS TO THE ADDRESS OF THE GOVERNOR (First day)

Shri Arecio D' Souza moved the following:

That an Address be presented to the Governor i n the following terms:

"That the Members of the Legislative Assembly of Goa, as- sembled in this Session are deeply gratefjd to the Governor for the Address which h e has been pleased t4, deliver to the House on 7 July,1999. I I

Motion was proposed. I

I Shri Jose Philip B'Souza, econded the motion. i Shri ~amakan't Khalap, mo to the Motion of Thanks:

" But regrets that t I ere is no

1. Extensive pilferage, thpft and electricity supply.

ly scheme for supply of

among the educateti youth of Goa.

e: bridges and failure to

- 17 -

8. Incidents of Malaria and absence of underground drainage system.

9. Failure of Sulabh Sauchalaya Scheme.

10. Construction of Ponda Bye-pass.

11. Failure to provide parallel road for Ribartdar Patto portion.

12. Steps for rehabilitation of gaddas in Muriicipal areas.

13. Poor up-keep and general degradation in the services of Goa Medical College, Asilo and Hospicio as well as Health Centres in the State.

14. Failure to conduct economic and social survey of other Backward classes.

15. Total neglect of Agriculture.

16. Failure of single window system appIic~.ble to industries.

17. Poor maintenance of roads.

"But regrets that there is no menti n of- 4

I

1. That inspite of i n e a s e in power and ater tariff Government has failed to augmentithe resources or

Amendments proposedi

Shri Manohar Parrikar, moved the following of Thanks:-

2. Failure to ensure ie-deployment of sd>lus staff properly.

3. Extensions to few favourite staff still cclntinues inspite of reduction in retirement age of Government servzmts to 58 years.

amendments to the Motion

6. Failure to mentibn anything about c mipletion of Pernem water supply schenle(pkoposed).

4. Proposed increase in Corporations by forminglpropose to form Tillari Irrigation Qorporation.

5. Failure to mention about improvemen and also improvihg pumping and theri:by Opa water works.

/augmentation of resources supply under Assonord

7. Failure to protect the villagers and agricul :ure activities by keeping them out of the Madei & Netravali Wild Life Sanctuary.

8. Failure to improve power supply situation in the state.

9. Failure to ensure that subsidies promised to SSI units and overdue for long are paid to them.

10. Failure to ensure education system as also functioning of Board improvement thereby improving quality of education as also exami- nations conducted by board are above an). doubts.

11. Failure to improve the functioning of G.M.C. as also other hospitals under Directorate of Health Services.

12. Failure to open up the old age pension scheme to needy."

Amendments proposed. Thirteen Members took part in the debate. I

TUESD~Y, 13 JULY, 1999.

I. i) Nine Starred Questions were answered. I ii) 'Twenty-four Starred Questions were not eached and were trans-

ferred to Unstaned I iii) Three Unstarred ~u4stions were answerd.

Shri Luizinho Faleiro laid the following pap n on the Table of the House:- !

i) Finance Accounts 1987-98;

5) Appr~priafion Accoubu 1997 -98; and

iii) ~ e ~ o r t of the ~orn~t r4 l le r and ~ud i to r h a 1 ended 3 1st March, 1998.

of India for the year

- 19 --

The Motion of Thanks to the Governor's Address moved by Shri Arecio D'Souza was put to vote and adopted.

WEDNESDAY, 14 JULY, 1999

I. i. Nine Starred Questions were answereq.

ii. Thirty Starred Questions were not reached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

iii. Three Unstarred Questions were answered.

IS. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS I I I

1) Shri Arecio D'Souza made a mention about request to have a I separate electricitfi office in Cunc01im.i

2) Shri Filipe Neri Rodrigues made a menti on about proper planning to be done for the two lane road on NH 1'7 at Sirlim.

3) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention about the gas agency at Canacona insisting upon public to bu;y a gas stove to get a new connection. No qee home deliv F gas cylinder being given and the gas cylinder godown is close to the electricity sub station.

I

I

4) Shri ~ha ikh ~ a s s a am on mad tion about power supply to be restored to buif,dings rehabilit

I I

Shri Luizinho F aleiro moved the following R.esolution: - 1) Whereas the &-ison's Act,1894 (Central Act -9 of 1894), is

presently in force in the State of Goa; And whereas the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Nevlr Delhi, vide their letter D.O. No. V-16013/2/97/GPA.IV dated 12/2/1998, stated that it is in the , process of streamlining the prison administration and has been

actively interacting with the National Hurnan Rights Commission and National Commission for Women Rig,nts and have prepared an ontline of :he new prison Bill to replace the existing Prisons Act, I. 894.

And whereas the Government of hdia/Ministry of Home Affairs have in their vide letler also stated that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its order dated [he 23 December 1996 in Writ Petition (c) No.12223 of 1984 has also deliberated on various issue like overcrowding, delay in trial, torture and ill treatment, neglect of health and hygiene, insubstantial food and inadequate clothing, prison vices,

-deficiency in communication, streamlining ofjail visits and has given directions to the Union of India to deliberate about enacting a new prison Act to replace century old Indian ~ t i s o n Act,1894.

And whereas, since the subject "Prisons" iS a matter in list I1 - State list of Seventh Schedule to the Parliament have no authority te Iegisiatc on the under Article 252 of the ~onstituti+n

I

And whereas the ~o*ernrnent of of Home Affairs I vide their said D.O. letter dated this State to have the appropriate' resolution authorizing ~ar l iamei ta r~

I And whereas it appehs to the of this State that it is desirable that matters relating "Prisons" should be

I regulated in this State, by

Now, therefore, this relating to the subject "Prisons" law in terns of

Resolution was was put to vote and

1 I i

public debt of the States and for all ma:.ters connected therewith or ancillary and incidental thereto;

And whereas, the subject matter of such a law is relatable mainly to the matter enumerated in entry 43 in list 11 in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India; - And whereas, Parliament has no powea to make such a law for the States with respect to the matter enumerated in entry 43 in List I1 aforesaid except as provided in Article 249 and 250 of the Consti- tution of India;

And whereas, the Public Debt Act, 1944 is applicable for marketable loans raised by Reserve Bank of India on kehalf of both Union and the State Government.

And whereas, it is felt desirable to repeql the Public Debt Act,1944 and replace the same with a new Le islation viz. "Government Securities Acty' id order to enable the Reserve Bank of India to render efficient anh improved service to the holders of Government Securities. 1 Now, therefore, in pursuance of Assembly hereby 'resolves that be empowered to regulate by law mktters securities and all -

i other matters connected thereto." I

Resolution proposkd, put to vote and pad sed unanimously.

IV. SUPPLEMENTARY PEMANDS FOR GRANTS 1999-2000 (First Batch): I

Shri Manohar Parrikar raised a point of ordeb and quoted Articles 204 and 205 of the Constitution of India and s:ated that Supplementary Demands for Grants cad ot be presented unl ss the Goa Appropriation Bill, 1999 is passed. r 1

I Hon. Speaker ruled that :being an unusual sit iation he would allow the Hon.Chief Minister to p(ksent the Supplemen ary Demands and that the

Bill, 1999 is passed. 1 r

passing of the same would be taken up only after the Goa Appropriation

Shri Luizinho Faleiro presented the Supplemeritary Demands for Grants 1999-2000 (First ~a t ch ) .

V . GENERAL DISCUSSION ON ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000 Ten members took part in the debate.

THURSDAY, 15 JULY, 19S19

I. Shri Luizinho Faleiro made corrections to Starred Question No.34. Shri Manohar Parrikar. raised apoint of order pointing out that replies given in the Mouse are wrong and manipulative. He also cited the reply given to Starred Question No.139 which was given earlier in the last session and Hon. Minister for Transport had then apologized and a ruling was also given by the Hon. Speaker as it was subject to breach of privilege. Hon. Speaker stated that wrong replies should not be given in the House. He also stated that he will not hold the Hon. Minikters responsible, but the officers corbcerned. He directed the Ministers to warn the officers concerned and that a serious note should be t+en of this in future.

i) Six Starred Questions were answered. 1 I I

ii) Fifteen Staned ~uebtions were not reac and were transferred to Unstaxred list. 1

lii; Three &stand Qdestions were

iv) One Starred ~uestiok was post I Hon. Chief Minister:

11. ZERO HOUR M E N T I O ~

1) Shri ~itendra~eshpribhu made am of Gynaecologist in Pernem hospit

I

- 23 -

5) Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon made a mention about the request to release power connection to hawkers, gadda owners etc. for Saptah festival.

111. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE

Shri Luizinho Faleiro laid on the Table the following:

i) 27th Annual Report 1997 -98 of Goa Meat Complex Ltd.

ii) The Goa Agricultural Tenancy (Discharge of Joint Responsibility of Tenants )Rules, 1999 .

IV. GENERAL DISCUSSION ON ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000 (Secodd day).

Eight members took part in the debate.

The following Bills w&e introduced:- ]

i) BillNo. 5 of 199q -The GoaMunicipali ies (Amendment) Bill, 1999. I

ii) Bill No.6 o f , 1999-The Goa anchayat Raj (Second Amendment)BiIl j 1999.

' I

I

/I 1 FRIDAY, 16 JULY,19.19

I i. Shri Churchill Alemao informed the Mouse that the reply to Starred - Questio,n No. 196 had been revised by hkm and reply as amended was laid on the Table.

ii. Five Starred Questions were answered.

iii. Fifteen Starred Questions were not r ached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

1 i I

iv. Two Unstarred Questions were ansdered.

-24- 11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

i) Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu made a mention about the request to make available free of cost Hepatitis 'B' vaccine.

5) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention about t he complaint regarding selling of fish by Karwar fishermen outside the Canacona fish market.

111. ANNOUNCEMENT OF BUSINESS TO 13E TRANSACTED DURING THE WEEK.

Shri Dayanand Narvekar announced the following Business to be transacted during the ensuing week: t

1. Discussion and voting on Demands for Grant for the year 1999- 2000.

2. Introduction of Government Bills. I

3. Private Members' Buqiness. I I

IV. PRIVATE MEMBERS' Bl!JSINESS 1

1. Private Members' Bills 1 Shri Manohar Parrikar rnov 'd for leave to ei

I Bill No.4 of 1999 1 The Goa Excis4 Duty (Amendment)

I Bill, 1999. I 1 Six Members took part in the debate. Motion fix leave to introdue

the Bill was put to vote and defeated.

i l

lowing postponed

"Whereas Margao city is situated on the banks of river Sal and in olden days the essential items like tiles,, wood etc. used to be transported to Margac city via river Sal and due to non dissiltation of the river the areas 'like Khareband, Pedda, Comba flooded every year during monsoon. There- fore this House strongly recomme:nds Government to take up the work of dissiltation of this river on priority basis to avoid continued flooding of these areas during monsoons."

Resolution was moved and proposed. Four Members took part in the - ' debate. Resolution was put to vote and passed unanimously.

ii) Shri Digambar Kamat moved the followinf; resolution:

"Whereas the Muslim community of Margao and surrounding areas were allotted an area of land for the purpose of burial ground at Pajifond, Margao since more than 50 ye& and whereas due to increase of Muslim populatioq of Margao and surrounding areas, this burial ground is found t? be inadequate;

I

Government to allot

I I iii) Shri Manohar Parrikar moved the followi~lg resolution :

"Whereas due to the Bombay High Court (Goa Bench) decision to remove kioswgaddas from the footpaths as also encroachment in markets have resu1;:ed in lot of hardship to the kiosklgadda owyers; therefore this /House recommends Govern- ment to work out plans for markets all Municipal Councils on top priority and that the displaced owners be reha- ', I bilitated in sucq markets within

Resolution was moved and proposed. Fourteen Members took part in the debate. Resolution was put to vote and ~~assed.

iv) Shri Prakash Velip moved the following resolution :

"This House recornmends Government to implement watershade programme in every panchayat area of Quepem Constituency for conservation of water for the benefit of farmers from those respective areas."

2

Resolution was moved and proposed. Four members took part in the debate. Resolution was withdrawn by the leave of the House.

!

v) Shri Ramrao Desai moved following resolut' on : I Y I

h his House unanidpusly resolves that the rules for transfer of municipal property kith 213 majority o council and Govern- ment permission but v h auction may .e relaxed in case of

to remove" difficulty of need of I

I rehabilitation programrpe as per High C~,urt Orderlas per the affidavits filed by the abilitation programme,

Resolution was moved add proposed. T

- 27 -

V. Smt. Nirmala Sawant announced that Sunrise Unit at Cuncolim Industrial Estate was raided on 17 July, 1999 for power theft.

MONDAY, 19 JULY, 1999

I. i) Thirteen Starred Questions were answered.

ii) Twenty Starred Questions were not rexhed and were transferred to Unstarred list.

iii) One Unstarred Question was answered.

11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

i) Shri Manohar Aagaonkar made a requ(:st to stop sand extraction at Uguem along River Terekhol.

ii) Shri Vinay Tendulkar made a mention about the flooding of villages in Shiroda and Sanvordem Constituency due to heavy rains and blocking of waterways with mining re.jects.

iii) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention about the plantation of cashew trees in land acquired for construction of Panchayat Ghar at Canacona. i

/

v) Smt. Victoria Fernandes made a ment on about the urgent repairs to retaining wall of a well near Govern ent school at Santa Cruz. 6

I

iv) Shri Arecio D'Souza made a mention negligence of electricity staff which school going boy at Gudi, Paroda.

vi) Shri Prakash ~hadte made a mentioh about the urgent repairs to

about the action against caused the death of a young

Saptakoteshwar temple at Narve.

111. GOVERNMENT BILL

Bill No. 2 of 1999 - The Goa Contingency Fund (Second Amendment)BilI, 1999-was introduced.

-28-

IV. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000.

Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No. Demand No.

General Administration and Co-ordination. Settlement and Land records. Treasury & Accounts Admn. (North Goa). Treasury and Accounts Admn.(South Goa ). Excise Sales Tax and Enterta.nment Transport Goa Sadan Collectorate(North Gaa) Collectorate(South Gda) Police Jails Vigilance

TUESDAY, 20 JULY, 1999 I i I

I

I. i) Shri Ravi Naik made a correction to one St

ii) Seven Starred Questiois were answered.

The Demands were moved a/ld proposed. Cut M DemandNos. 2,7,11,12,13,14,1S,16,17,18 and22. part in the debate. Cut Motions wdre put to vote and de were put to vote and granted. I

1

I iii) Twenty nine Starred p s t i o n s were nod reached and were

transferred to Unstarred list.

btions were moved to NineteenMembers took

kated. The Demands

- 29 -

111. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000.

Demand No. 23 - Demand No. 24 -

Demand No. 25 - Deinand No. 26 - Demand No. 27 - Demand No. 29 - Demimd No. 30 - Demand No. 31 - Demand No. 32 - Demand No. 33 -

Home Goa Public Mer,'s Corruption Commission (Investigation aild Enquiries). Home Guards and Civil Defence Fire and Emergency services. Evacuee property. Estate Office Lotteries Panchayats Finance !

Revenue

The Demands were m y e d and proposed. Tfventy one Members took part in the debate. Cut Motions were moved to ~ernarjd Nos.23,24,25,26,27,30,31, 32 and 33. The Cut Motions were put to vote iind defeated. The Demands were put to vote and

I

I . i) Shri Luizinho ~dleiro sought postpon ,merit of one starred question to the next Assembly Session as the information sought for was bulky. However; Hon. Speaker direct d.Shri Luizinho Faleiro to lay the information on the Table of the Ho lse during the current session of the Assembly. I

ii) Eight Starred Questions were answe I

ferred to unstarred list. iii) Twenty four Stakred Questions were reached and were trans-

iv) One Unstarred Question was answered.

11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS.

i) ShriVenkateshDessai made a mention about the request to denotify Madei Wild Life Sanctuary.

ii) Shri Ulhas Asnodkar made a mention about the repairs to bus shed at Tisko on Porvorim Mapusa Highway.

iii) Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon made a mention about the request to provide inverters in the corridors of the Assembly.

111. CALLING ATTENTION

i) Shri Pandurang Raut called the attention of !3hri Churchill Alemao to the following matter of urgent public importance:-

" Apprehension in the minds of Industrialists in particular and people of Goa in general due to abrupt disconnection of regular water supply to the Coca Cola factory at Verna Industrial Estate and thus the Coca Cola ifactory suffered loss, so also loss of revenue to the Governmeilt due to stoppage of production. Steps Goyernment has taken, in the matter."

I Shri Churchill Alemao madb a statement A few queries were

raised by way of clarifications. were not satisfied with the replies. Han. Speaker, a fresh reply on 22 July, 1999.

THE YEAR 1999-2000.

Demand No. 34 - Demand No. 35 - Demand No. 36 -

Demand No. 50 - Goa College of Pharmacy Demand No. 54 - Town & Coutitry Planning Demand No. 55 - Municipal Administration Demand No. 69 - Parks and Gardens.

The Demands were moved and proposecl. Cut Motions were moved to DemandNos. 34,35,36,37,38,39,40,43,46,54 and 55. Fifteen Members took part in the debate. The cut motions were put to vote and defeated. The Demands were put to-vote and granted.

THURSDAY, 22 JULY 1999

I. i) One Starred Question was postponizd. i

ii) One Unstarred Question was postdoned. I I I

iii) Eleven Starred Questions were an$wered. I I

iv) Sixteen starrid Questions were nolt reached and were transferred to Unstarred list. 1 i

I

11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

ii) Shri Vinay TeGdulkar made amenti n about the pollution caused due to release of slurry from the benefi ation plants by mine owners.

iii) Shri ~ h a i k h ~ h s s a n ~ a r o o n made a nention about the pollution and health hazard caused by the FCI godowns at Bogda, Vasco da Gama. I i I

iv) Dr. Wilfred db Souza made a medtion about the retrenchment of teachers take4 in place of teachers deputed for training.

I

i) Shri Manohar, Parrikar made a me: turbid water supply to Panaji.

v) Shri Vishwas Satarkar made a mention about the Vaghurme village being cut off firom Ponda due to flooding.

ltion about the inadequate and

111. CALLING ATTENTIONS

1) Shri Churchill Alemao sought postponement of calling attention for 23-7-99 to the following matter to which his attention was called by Shri Pandurang Raut on 21-07-1999 as he wanted to give full justification and full details:-

"Apprehension in the minds of 1ndustriali:sts in particular and people of Goa in general due to abrupt disconnection of regular water supply to the Coca Cola factory at Verna Industrial Estate and thus the Coca Cola factory suffered loss, so also losses of revenue to the Government due to stoppage of production. Steps Government has taken in the matter."

2) Shri Manohar Parrikar called the attention of Shri Francisco Sardinha to - the following matter of urgent public importance:- '

"Apprehension and anxiety in the minds of le people of the State of Goa due to non availability of rice for publi distribution(system) during the month of July,l999 thus creating h dship to the public.

I ment in the matter. ' Action taken by the Goveq I ;I

Shri Francisco Sardinha rn replied by way of clarification.

IV. GUVERNMENT BILL

Bill No. 7 of 1999

V. DISCUSSION AND VOTI THE YEAR 1999-2000.

DemandNo. 56 - Demand No. 63 - Demand No. 64 -

' Demand No. 65 - Demand No. 71 -

Demand No. 73 - State Election Commissign Demand No. 75 - Planning, Statistics and Evaluation Demand No. 79 - Goa Gazetter Demand No. 57 - Social Welfare Demand No. 58 - Women and Cli,ild Development . Demand No. 76 - Electricity

The Demands were moved and proposed. Cut Motions were moved to Demand Nos. 56,64,65,7 1,57,58 and76. Twenty four Members took part in the debate. The Cut Motions were put to vote and defeated. The Demands were put to vote and granted.

VI. HALF AN HOUR DISCUSSION ( NOT!CE UNDER RULE 61)

Shri Manohar Panikar and Shri Prakash Velip raised the discussion on the points arising out of rcplb given on 16/07/1999) to StarredQLlestionNo.* 195 regarding generation of power by independent ower producers. 4 I

Eight Members took part in the debate.

Smt. Nirmala Saw an1 replied to the poi

F,RIDAY 23 JULY,

I. i) Thirteen Starred Questions were a I

I

iii) Five Unstarred huestions were ans

ii) Fifteen Starred Unstarred list.

I I) Shri Vishwas katarkar made a r quest to repair Mardol to

Madcaim road. ( I r'

2) Smt. Victoria Pjernandes m d e a ~qzradun of washing away of Ribandar-Panvel road due to heavy rains.

Questions were not reached and transferred to

111. Shri Dayanand Narvekar anlnounced the Busin~:ss to be transacted during the week.

i) Discussion and Voting on Demands for Grants for the year 1999-2000.

ii) Leave to introduce. introduction, consideration, clause by clause reading and passing of - The Goa Appropriation Bill, 1999.

.., 111) Goverriment Bills (if any).

iv) Private Members' Business.

IV. CALLING ATTENTION

Shri Churchi31 Alemao made a statement on the disconnection of regular water supply to the Coca Cola factory at Verna Industrial Estate, to which his attention was called by Shri Pandurang Raut, on 21 July, 1999.

Shri Manohar Parrikar raised a point of order undqr Rule 290 and stated tkat when the House is in Ses~ion it is expected thALt Hon. Minister does not make any statement, important policy anno ncement outside the House and in this case, the House is seized of the matter. i

e should first inform

Shri Manohar

V. Srnt. Nirrnalz Sawant

Petition No. l'i'6/98. Committee appointed by Or

Y I. PRIVATE

nt of unpredictable ucers of crop like

This House strongly recommends Government to formulate Crop Insurance Scheme under centrally sponsored Crop Insurance Scheme by advocating this cause with Central Government."

Resolution was moved and proposed.

Amendments were moved by S/Shri Pandurang Raut, Digainbar Kamat and Vishwas Satarkar to include banana, betalnut and supari.

Resolution was amended and passed unanimously.

2. Shri Manohar Panikar moved the folIowing resolution:

"Whereas debris/waste material of the building under construction and other kind of wastes are incliscriminately dumped on the road sides thus damaging water flijw channels blocking stream water drains an4 spoiling the natu ecological balance of the area; I

This House drefore strongly rec nds Ciove~nrnent to direct the Panchayat in the State of Goa tify the places of dump- ing the debris in order to strictly e the provisions of the Goa Non-biodegradable Garbage(C ct 1996 and take strong action against the defaulters and authority to ensure compliance." and

I

I

3. S/Shri Manohar Pa+kar and Prakash qhadte, moved the following resolution: I I

i I

I "Whereas debris/waste material of !the building under construction and other kiid of waste are indi!rcri~ninatel~ dumped on the road sides thus damaging water flo J- charnels blocking streslm water drains and oiling the natur i ecological balance of the area; i

This House therefore strongly reco Government to direct the in the State of notify the places of '

the provisions of CControl) .4ct,1996 and take

stringent action against the defaulters and appoint the authority to ensure compliance."

Both the Resolutions were moved and proposed. Two Members took part in the debate. Resolutions were passed unanimously..

4. Shri Ramrao Desai and Shri Prakash Phadt: moved the following resolution.

"Considering \/aricsus traditional aspects like Arts, Literature, Sports etc., of Bicholim and surrounding area:

This House stro~gly recommends Government to establish a Bhavan at BichoIim having all infrastructual facilities for conservation of Arts and Literature and development of cultural tradi- tion."

Resolution was moved and proposed. members took part in the debate. Resolut;,sn was +ithdrawn by of the House.

5. Smr. Victoria Fernandes i oved the

global standards."

Resolution was moved ahd proposed. One took part in the I debate. Resolution was passed unanimously.

MONDAY 26 JULY 1999.;

I) i) Eight Starred ~uest ions wen answered. i and were trans-

were answerec. 1

11) ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

i) Shri Sanjay Bandekar made a mention about the request to depute staff for malaria work at Canacona.

ii) Dr. Suresh Amonkar made a mentlon about the loss caused due to heavy rains to paddy crop, houses etc. in Amona Constituency.

iii) Smt. Victoria Fernandes made a mention about the loss caused clue to heavy rains to agarkars and khazan field cultivators in Santa Cruz Constituency.

iv) Shri Vinay TenduIkar made a mention about no replies being given to the members of Opposition benches.

I11 MOTION FOR COlWOLENCE. I I

Shri Dayanand Narvekar moved the follow'ng condolatory motion:- 1 'That this ~ o d s e condoles the s id and untimely death of

Veteran Freedom Fighter and Trade Leader Shri George Vaz." I

Motion was proposed!

Six Members took pakt in the debate. One silence was observed I as a mark of respect to the,departed soul. !

- v DISCUSSION AND /VOTING ON DEM WDS FOR GIQANTS FOR THE YEAR 19993'000.

I Bill No.% of 19q9 - The Goa

I ment) Bill, ~

I Demand No. 3 1- District and Sejsion Court (North Goa).

I I Demand No. 4 1- District and ~ebsion Court (South Goa). I Demand No. 5 1- Prosecution

School Education ( Amend- 1999, was introduced.

-38-

Demand No. 6 - Election Office Demand No. 52 - Labour Demand No. 60 - Employment Demand No. 61 - Craftsmen Training , Demand No. 62 - Law Demand No. 68 - Forests

Demand No. 74 - Irrigation

I) i) One Starred Question has postponed. 1

All theDemands for Grants were moved andproposed. Cut Motions were moved toDemandNos. 3,4,6,52,61,62,68 and 74. Eighteen Members took part

I

ii) Nine Starred Questions were answered.

iii) Fifteen Starred Questions were not reached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

iv) One Unstarred Questicjn was answered.

I

in the debate. The Cut Motions wkre gut to vote and put to vote and granted. i 1

I TUESDP/Y 27 JULY 1999 I

Shri Shaikh Hassan H fisherman being deni Personnel.

s moved the following Motion for Co

as Member of

defeated. Delllands were

. -39-

The Motion proposed. Nine Members took part in the debate. f h e Motion was put to vote and passed unanimously. ,

IV) PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE

Shri Churchill Alemao laid on the Table of the House the Audit Report and Finance Accounts for the year 1993-94 to 1996-97 of Khadi & Village Industries Board.

V) CALLING ATTENTION

SlShri Vishwas Satarkar, Ulhas Asnodkar and Prakash Phadte called the attention of Shri Luizinho Faleiro to the following matter of urgent public importance:-

"Anxiety in the minds of the le of Goa in general and farmer cornmunit$ in particular excessive rains that have virtually destroyed the agricul ities in the State of Goa. Thus washing away the Padd sowed thereby resulting into "wet famine", further Go as not initiated any compensation toward; the dama rop. Action ~overnment proposes to take 'in the matter."

Shri Luizinho Faleiro made a state thereon. Few questions were replied by way of

Demand No.

Demand No.

Demand No. Demand No.

Demand No. Demand No. Demand N o.

Demand No.

VI) DISCIJSSION AKD VOTING ON THE YEAR 1999-4000.

I

Science, Tech ology & Environment 1 Printing and Stfitionery .

Public Works 1 Industries and ivlines

Sports and Yonth Affairs

Factories and Boilers Fisheries

Tourism

DEM4NDS FOR GRANTS FOR

-40-

The Demands were moved and proposed.

The Cut Motions were moved to the Demand Nas.'72 , 20, 21, 19,42, 59,66 and 78 . Twenty four members toakpart in the debate. Cut Motions were put to vote and defeated. All the Demands were put to vote and granted.

I) i) One Starred Question was postponed to 2/8/1999.

ii) Eleven Starred Questions were answered.

iii) Seventeen Starred Questions were not reacheti and transferred to Unstarred list.

iv) Six Unstarred Questions were answered.

11) ZERO HOUR MENTION , 1 I

Shri Prakash Phadte made a mention about the repo -ted news regarding collapse of Sharda Vidyalaya sLhool building at Cu J ibarjua.

I 111) PAPERS LAID ON THE TAPLE

Shri Luizinho Faleiro laid on the Table

ii) Statement

Government for loan Bodies aid other

I

1V. DISCUSSION AND VOTINC.! ON DEMANDS THE YEAR 1999-2000.

. .

Demand No. 47 -

i Demand No. 45 : Arahieves

Demand No. 48 - Demand No. 49 -

-41 - Demand No. 51 - Goa Dental College

Demand No. 53 - Food and Drugs Ad ministration

DemandNo. 67 - Ports Administration

Demand No. 70 - Civil Supplies and Price Control

Demand No. 77 - River Navigation Department .

Demand No. 80 - Legal Merrology

The Demands were moved and proposed. Cut Motions were moved to Demand Nos. 47,48,70 and 77.

Nineteen Members took part in the debate. The Cut Motions were put to vote and defeated. The Demands were put to vote and granted.

THURSDAY 29 JULY 1999

I) i) Thirteen Starred Questions were answered. -

ii) Thirteen Starred Questions were not reached and were transferred to Unstarred list. ,

i iii) Six Unstarred Questions were answer d.

11) PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE I i) Shri Ravi Naik laid on the Table of the ouse the Annual Accounts

for the year 1996-97 and 1997-98 of oa Construction, Housing and Finance Corporation Ltd.

ii) Shri Dayanand Ngvekar laid on the able of the House the First Annual Report(1997-98) of the Goa Development Corpora- tion Limited.

III. CALLING ATTENTION

Shri Manohar Parrikar called the attention of the Shri Francisco Sardinha to the following matter of urgent public importance:-

"Anxiety in the minds of people that due to failure of Drug Controller of Goa, the local drug manufacturing Govei-nrnent controlled Goa Antibi-

otics has been manufacturing sub-standard life saving drug, but is not being corrected, thereby posing danger to the life of the people of the State. Further that, due to sub-standard drug the GAPL is on the verge of losing its approvallgetting blacklisted in State of Andhra Pradesh. The action proposed to take in the matter."

Shri Francisco Sardinha promised to make a statement on 2 August 1999.

IV) DISCUSSION AKD VOTING ON DEMANCjS FOR GRANT FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000.

t Denland Xo. 1 - Legislature ~ecretadlat

I

Demand No. 10 - Notary Services.

Demand No. 28 - Administrative Tribunal

Charged Expenditure - Raj Bhavan ( Discussion only)

Charged Expenditure - Debt services/ ( Discussion only)

Charged Expenditure - Goa Public Commission , (Discussion o

- 43 - FRIDAY 30 JULY, 1999

s I) i) Twelve Starred Questions were answered I

ii) Thirty two Starred Questions were not reached and were transferred to Unstarred list.

iii) Forty Unstarred Questions were answered.

11) ZERO HOUR MENTION

Shri Ulhas Asnodkar made a mention asout a construction being carried out in the open space in P&T colony at Porvorim.

111) Hon. Speaker read out the following letter received from H. E. the Governor.

My Dear Shri Rane,

With warm regards. ~

I have received with reat satisfaction D. Letter No. SP/LA/1539/ 7 1999 dated 21st July, 1999 conveying the tha of Members of the Goa I' Legislative Assembly for the Address, I have to the House on 7th

Sincerely,

July 1999. I am thankful to

I J. 4. R. JACOB

every Member of

i) Public Accounts ommittee , c In pursuance of ~ u l k - 201, the speak$a nominated the following

Members on the Public ~cbounts Committee folt the Year 1999-2000. I

1. Shri Digambar Kamat ... I Chairman I

2. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu . . . Member I

3. Shri Francisco Silveira .,. Member

4. Smt. victoria Fernandes . . . Member

5. Shli Subhash Shirodkar ... Member

6. Shri Ramakant KPlalap . . . Member

7. Dr. Wifred de Souza ... Member

ii) Estimates Committee

In pursuance of Rule - 203, the Speaker nominated the following Members on the Estimates Cornmittee for the Year 1999-2000.

1) Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon . . . Chairman 2) Shri Subhash Shirodkar . . . Member 3) Shri Filipe Rodrigues . . . Member 4) Shri Sornnath Zuwarkar ... Member 5) Dr. Suresh Amonkar . . . Member 6) Shri Vishwas Satarkar . . . Member 7) Shri Francis D'Souza . . . Member

I iii) committee on public 4ndertakings 1

In pursuance of Rule - 241, the nominated the following Members on the Committee on the year 1999-2000.

1) Shri Mauvin ~ o d i n h o . . . 2) Shri Venkatesh . . . 3) Shri Arecio ... 4) Shri

. . .

' 7) ShriPrakashVeli . . .

Chairman Member Member Member Member Member

Member

- 205, the ornmittee on G c

:Speaker nominated the vernment Assurances

Chairman

I Member I !

3) Shri Arecio D'Souza ... Member

4) Shri Filipe Rodrigues . . Member I

5) Shri Sanjay Bandekar ... Member

6) Shri Vinay Tendulkar . . . Member

7) Shri Pandurang Raut ... Member

v) Committee on Petitions

In pursuance of Rule - 206, {he Speaker nominated the following Members on the Committc=e on Petitions for the year 1999-2000.

1) Shri Luis Alex Cardozo ... Chairman

vi) Delegated ~ e ~ i s l h i o n committee. I

2) Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu . . . Member

3) Shri Manohar Azgaonkar . . . Member

4) Shri Somnqth Zuwarkar . . i Member

I In pursuance of Rule - 216, e Speaker nominated the following ~emb41-s on the Committee ~n Delegated Legislation for the year 1999-2090. 1'

I I

5) Shri Ulhas bsnodkar . . 6) Shri ~ a m r d o Desai

I . .

7) Shri Isidore Fernandes I

. .

I I

I 1) Shri Shaikh(Hassan Haroon . . .I Chairman

I I

Member

Member

Member

2) Shri ~ a u v i d Godinho ..-I Member I I

3) Smt. victoria Fernandes 1 ...I Member

4) Shri Sanjay 1 Bandekar ..., Member I

5) Shri Manohar Parrikar ... Member

6) Shri ~ a ~ a n $ d ~an&ekar . . . Member

7) Shri Prakashl Velip Member

vii) Rules Committee

In pursuance of Rule - 219, the Speaker nominated the following Members on the Rules Committee for the year 1999-2000.

1) Hon. Speaker ... Chairman 2) Hon. Dy. Speaker ... Member 3) Shri Subhash Shirodkar . . . Member 4 Shri Filipe Rodrigues . . . Member 5) Shri Vishwas Satarkar . . . Member 6) Shri Prabhakar Gaonkar . . . Member

7) Shri RarnkrishnaDhavalikar . . . Member

viii) Committee of Privileges

In pursuance of Rule - 232, the S nominated the following Members oh the Committee of 1999-2000. t

ix) Library Committee

In pursuance of Rule - 2

-47-

x) Budget Committee

In pursuance of Rule - 242, the Speaker nominated the following Members on the Budget Committee for the year 1999-2000.

1) Shri Somnath Zuwarkar . . Chairman

2) Shri Mauvin Godinho . . Member

3) Shri Venkatesh Desai ... Member

4) Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu .. . Member

5) Shri Manohar Parrikar . , . Member

6) Dr. Suresh Amonkar .,. Member

7) Dr. Wilfred de Souza . . . Member

V. A) PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE

Shri Luizinho Faleiro laid on the Table of the House, The Goa Motor Vehicles Rules, 199 1.

B) FULFILLMENT OF ASSURANCE

~ h r i ~ a ~ a n a n d ~arve4arlaid on the able a dmpy of aster plan on ~ a d e i

Shri Dayanand ~arvehar announced the foilowing Business to be transacted during the ensuing week; 1

i) Discussion and voting on Supplemenlary Demands for Grants for the year 1999-2000 (First Batch).

River containing 4 volumesi in fulfillment of the on 13 July, 1999. I

I I

VI. ANNOUNCEMENT OF BUSINESS TO ING THE WEEK. 1

ii) Leave to introduce, introduction, cor~sideration,clause by clause reading and passing of the Goa Supplementary Appropriation Bill, 1999.

lssurance given to the House

BE TRANSACTED DUR-

iii) All remaining stages of the Government Bills.

-- -48-

VII. PRIVATE MEMBERS' _BUSINESS

1) Bills

Bill No.9 of 1999 - The Goa Evacuee Property (Protec- tion of Dwelling Houses) Bill, 1999 by Shri Prakasl? Phadte was introduced.

i) Shri Ramrao Desai, moved the following resolution:

"This HoGse resolves that Chandreshwar Bhutnath Temple and surrounding hill at Paroda, Quepem ,be developed into a touristic spot to attract and encourage t$)urism in the area." ,

Resolution was moved and broposed. Three ~ e j n b e r s took part in the debate. Resolution was withdrawn by the leave of the /House.

I

ji) Shri Prakash Velip rnoqed the following res I

"Whereas every CO-operative instituti ns in Goa demands new Co-operative ct considering the local problems of d Co-operative movement;

t This House strongly I ecomrnends to enact Goa Co-

operative Act at the e liest for of Co-operative Institutions in ~ o a . "

a The Resolution was moved tookpart in the

debate. Resolution was put to

iii) Shri Prakash Phadte, ved the following re P

The Resolution was moved and proposed. Three Members took part in the debate. Resolution was put to vote and passed unanimously.

I

iv) Dr. Suresh Amonkar, moved the following resolution:

"Whereas in many Village l'anchayats of Pale Constitu- . ency there are no fixed places for cremation and thus the people

I

from Hindu communities find it v e ~ y difficult to perform the last rites of their deceased family mernber causing great inconve- nience and also financial burden;

Therefore, this House strongly recommends Government to allot/acquire sufficient land in the Village Panchayats of Pale, Velguem, Surla, NaveIim,Kudne and Amona for the cremato- rium in Pale Constituency."

I Resolution was move9 and proposed. Fiv Members took part in the

debate. The resolution was #ithdrawn by the I 1

M O ~ D A Y 2 AUGUST 1 I

I. i) Eight Starred ~uis t ions were

ii) Thirteen Starred duestions were not re/lched and were transferred to Unstarred list. , I I

iii) Five Unstarred Questions were answered.

11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS I

Shri Venkatesh Dessai made a request to hol(i Panchayat meeting once in a month instead of every 15 days.

I

I I

111. CALLING ATTENTIOY ,

Shri Francisco Sardinhajmade a statement t which his attention was drawn by Shri Manohar Parri* on 29-07-1999.

\ Few queries were raised h d replied to by way of clarification.

IV. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON SUPPLEMENTARY DEMANDS FOR GRANTS FOR THE YEAR 1999-2000 (First Batch).

P

Demand No. 2 - General Administration & Coordination Demand No. 5 Prosecution Demand No. 6 - Election Office Demand No. 13 - Transport Demand No. 17 - Police Demand No. 21 - Public Works Demand No. 31 - Demand No. 33 : - Demand No. 34 - School Education DemandNo. 35 - Higher Education Demand No. 37 - Government Pol Demand No. 40 - Demand No. 42 - Sports & Youth Affairs Demand No. 43 - I p, & Culture I

Demand No. 47 - Goa Medical College & Hospitals

Demand No. 55 - Demand No. 57 - Social Welfare Demand No. 59 - tactories & Boilers Demand No. 61 - Demand No. 63 - Demand No. 64 - Demand No. 66 - Demand No. 68 - Demand No. 76 - DemandNo. 81 -

V. GOVERNMENT BILLS

B . The following Bills moved by Shri LuizinhoFaleiro were considered and passed.

i) Bill No.6 of 1999 - The Goa Panchayat Raj (Second Amendment) Bill, 1999.

ii) Bill No.7 of 1999 - The Cioa Protection of Interests of Depo~~i tor (in Financial Esta- blishments) Bill, 1999.

iii) Bill No.10 of 1999- The Goa Tillari Irrigation Develop- ment Corporation Bill, 1999.

C. The follbwing Bills moved by Shri Luizinho F aleiro were considered, read clause by clause and passed.

i) Bill No.2 of 1999 - The doa Contingency Funds (Sec- ond Afnendment) Bill, 1999.

I I ii) Bill No.5 of i999 - The G )a Municipalities (Amendment)

Bill, 1 99. I iii) Bill No.8 of li999 - The G )a School Education (Amend-

ment) ill, 1999. b i) The House committee was constitklted to go into investigation of

the question arising of the control on the manufacture of the drug of Goa Antibiotics, consisting of the following Members:-

ii) The House Copmittee was constit ted for assessing the damages caused to paddy fields and water bo silting up the river etc. and also studying the causes and the remkdial measures to be envisaged

1. Shri Francisco Sardinha . . . Chairman Minister for Health

2. Shri Maqohar Parrikar 3. Shri Shaik'i'i Hassan Haroon 4. Dr. Suresh Amonkar 5. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu

. . . Member

. . . Member

. . . Member

. . . Member

to eliminate or reduce the pollution by mining rejects consisting of the following members:-

1. Shri Dayanand Narvekar . . . Chairman

Minister for Irrigation

2. Dr. Suresh Amonkar . . . Member

3. Shri Vinay Tendulkar . . . Member

4. Shri Prakash Phadte ... Member

5. Shri Jose Philip D' Souza . . . Member

6. Shri Venkatesh Desai . . . Member

7. Shri Pandurang Raut . . . Member

TUESDAY 3 AUGUST 1999

I. i) Smt. Nirmala Sawant made a correction to the Starred Question No. 563.

5) Eleven Starred ~uesti4ns were answered I

I iv) Five Unstarred Questions were answered.

1

iii) One Starred ~ u e s t i o h was not reached Unstarred list. I

I and transferred to

-53 -

C. CALLING ATTENTION

Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu called the attention of Shri Luizinho Faleqo.

"Serious apprehension in the minds of parents of students of Peter Alvares High School, Morjimin particular and people of Morjimin general due to failure of Administration of the aforesaid school run by Shramic Sudharak Saunstha, further the teachers are being harassed unnece- ssarily and not been paid their salary for months together thus affecting, the quality of education. Action Government proposes to take in the matter".

Shri Luizinho Falejro made a statement and a few questions were replied to by way of clarification.

D. I. Announcement of result of two hlembers of Goa Legislative Assembly on State Library Council.

Shri Vishwas Satarkar and Smt. Victoria Fernandes were declared duly elected on the State Library Council.

I

2. Announcement, of result of two of Goa Legislative Assembly on the Board of Seco Higher Secondary Education. I

Dr. Suresh Amonkar and Shri Dhavalikas were duly elected on the Board of Sqcondary and Education.

11. GOVERNMENT BXLLS : I

Clause by Clause

1) Bill N0.6 of Panchayat Raj (Second Clauses 2, 3 to 10, 1

I preamble and title were

I i The motion for passing of the Bill was pdt to vote and adopted. Three

Members took part in the debate. I

Motion was put to vote and adopted.

-54-

The Bill was declared passed.

ii) Bill No. 7 of 1999 - The Goa Protec1:ion of Interests of Depositors (in Financial Establish- ments) Bill, 1999.

Clauses 2,3 to 15, 1 preamble and title were put tcl vote and adopted.

The motion for passing of the Bill was moved. Two Members took part in the debate. Motion was put to vote and carried. The Bill was declared passed.

iii) Bill No. 10 of 1999 - The Goa Tillari /Inrigation Develop- I ment Corporatio i Bill, 1999. I I I

The motion for passing of Bil was proposed put vote and adopted. I

Clauses 2,3 to 65, the sched?le, clause 1, preambl: vote and adopted.

The Bill was declared passed.

111. Election of two Members of he Legislative of Goa on Goa Town and Country Planning i oard.

I

and title were put to

Shri Digambar ~ a k a t and hri Jitendra rabhu, MLAs were declared elected on the Goa Town Board unanimously.

I IV. House was adjourned sine-d e and the National nthem was recited by the Members.

STATEMENT No. 5

DEMANDS FOR GRANTS FORTHE Y EAR 1999-2000 1

Total No. No. of of No. of Demands discussed Demands Remarks

Demands Guillotined

80 Demand No. 1 - Legislature Secretarial. Demand No. 2 - General Administration DemandNo. 3 - District and Session Court

(North Goa) DemandNo. 4 - District and Session Clourt

(South Goa) DemandNo. 5 - Prosecution DemandNo. 6 - Election Office and

Co-ordination I

DemandNo. 7 - Settlement and Land icecords DemandNo. 8 - Treasury & Account Adrnn.

(North Goa) DemandNo. 9 - Treasury and Accou ts Admn.

(South Goa) Demand No. 10 - Notary Services DemandNo. 11 - Excise DemandNo. 12 - Sales Tax and Entert inment DemandNo. 13 - Transport DemandNo. 14 - Goa Sadan DemandNo. 15 4 Collectorate(North oa)

Demand No. 17 - Police DemandNo. 18 - Jails

1 DemandNo. 21 - Public Works DemandNo. 22 - Vigdance Demand No. 23 - Home

I DemandNo. 16 - Collectorate (South G oa)

DemandNo. 19 - Industries and Mines, Demand No. 20 1 Printing and Station ry

DemandNo. 24 - Goa Public Men's Cc rmption ' Commission (Investigation 1 and Enquiries). I

DemandNo. 25 - Home Guards and Civil Defence DemandNo. 26 - Fire andEmergency Service:; DemandNo. 27 - Evacuee Property DemandNc. 28 - Administrative Tribunal DemandNo. 29 - Estateoffice Demand No. 30 - Lotteries DemandNo. 31 - Panchayats DemandNo. 32 - Finance DemandNo. 33 - Revenue Demand No. ' 34 - School Education DemandNo. 35 - Higher Education Demand No. 36 - Technical Education Demand No. 37 - Government Polytechnic

DemandNo. 40 -

DemandNo. 44 - Demar~dNo. 45 - ;

Demand No. 56 - Information and Publicity DemandNo. 57 - Social Welfare DemandNo. 58 - Women and Child DemandNo. 59 - Factories & ~oilersl DemandNo. 63 - Employment 1 Demand No. 61 - ~raf fsmen~ra in in~i DemandNo. 62 - Law

DemandNo. 63 - Rajya SainikBoard

Demand No. 64 - Agriculture

DemandNo 65 L ~ n i m d ~ ~ s b a n d i & , Veterinary Service

DemandNo. 66 1 Fisheries

DemandNo. 67 - Ports Administratic

DemandNo. 68 - Forest

DemandNo. 6R - Parks and Gardens

DemandNo. 70 - Civil Supplies and

Demand No. 71 - Co-operation Demand No. 72 - Science, Technolog

Environment DemandNo. 73 - StateElection

DemandNo. 74 - Irrigation

DemandNo. 75 - Planning Statistics

Demand No. 76 Electricity

n

Price Control

y &

Comlnission

; ~ n d Evaluation

DemandNo. 77 - River Navigation D€partment

DemandNo. 78 -Tourism

DemandNo. 79 - GoaGazetter

DemandNo. 80 - Legal Metrology

- 5 8 -

STATEMENT No. 6

Demands for Supplementary Grants for the Year 1999-2000 (First Batch

Total No. No. of of No. of Demands discussed Demands Remarks

Demands Guillotined

1 2 3

29 Demand No. 2 -General Administration and Co-ordination

DemandNo. 5 - Prosecution Demand No. 6 - Election Office DemandNo. 13 - Transport

I DemandNo. 17 - Police DemandNo. 21 - Public Works

DemandNo. 40 -

~ e m a n d ~ o . 43 - Ar

" DemandNo. 49 - Ins

DemandNo. 55 - DemandNo. 57 - DemandNo. 59 -

DemandNo. 63 - DemandNo. 6% -

STATEMENT No. 7

GOVERNMENT RESOLUTIONS

No. of Name of the No. of Notices Date of Notices Minister admitted/ discussed Discussion Text of Resolution

Received adoption

ChiefMinister _ _ -2 14-07-1999 -1. Whereas the Prisons' Act, 1894 (Central Act 9 of 1894) is presently in force in the State of Goa; And whereas the Government of India, Minishy of Home Affairs, New Delhi, vide their letter D. 0. No. V-16013121-97lGPA.IV dated 12-2- 1998 stated that it is in the process of streamling the prison administration and has been actively interacting with the I National Human Rights Commission and National ul

\O Commission for Woman Rights and have prepared an I

--- -- - --- --- outiine of ihe new prison Bill to replace the existing Prisons 1

Act, 1894.

And Whereas the Government of IndidMinistry of Home Affairs have in their vide letter also stated that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its ordsr dated the 23rd December, 1996, in Writ Petition(c) No. 12223 of 1984 has also deliberated on various isues like overcrowding, delay in trial, torture and ill treatment, neglect of health and hygiene, insubstantial food and inadequate clothing prison vices, deficiency in . communication, streamilining of jail visits and has given directions to the Union of India to deliberate about enacting

' a new prison Act to replace century old Indian Prison Act 1894;

And whereas, since the subject "Prisons" is a matter in List 11-State List of Seventh Schedule to the Constitution Parliament have no authority to legislate on the subject unless Resolutions under Article 252 of the Constitution are passed by two or more States;

And whereas the Government of India/Ministry of Home Affairs vide their said D. 0. letter dated 12-2-1998, requested this S,lte to have the appropriate resolution passed by out State Legislature authorising Parliamentary -legislation on prisons in public interest;

And whereas it appears to the Legislature of this State that -__ - it is desirable that matters relating to the subject "Prisons" 1

should be regulated in this State by Parliament by law. o\ 0

Now, therefore, this House resolves that the matters relating I to the subject "Prisons" should be regulated in this State by Parliament by law in terms of Article 252 of the Constitution."

-- 1407-1999 2 WEEREAS, i ~ ~ G 6 ~ ~ G g i s l a t i v e Assembly considers that it is desirable to have a uniform law throughout India for the regulation of Public Debt of the States and for all matters connected therewith or ancillary and incidental thereto;

AND WHEREAS, the subject matter of such a law is relatable mainly to the matter enumerated in entry 43 in list I1 in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India;

AND WHEREAS, Parliament has no power to make such a law for the States with respect to the matter enumerated in entry 43 in List I1 aforesaid except as provided in Article, 249 and 250 of the Constitution of India;

AND WHEREAS, the hb l i c Debt Act, 1944 is applicable for marketable loans raised by Reserve Bank of India on behalf of both Union and the State Government;

AND WHEREAS, it is felt desirable to repeal the Public Debt Act, 1944 and replace the same with a new Legislation I viz. "Government Securities Act" in order to enable the

--- - P,-B=f'Je ;;f IZ&Z ;G i-eiide~ ~ ~ G L ~ G I I L and improved ,

service to the holders of Government Securities; I

NOW, therefore, in pursuance of Clause(1) of Article 252 this Assembly hereby resolves that the Parliament be empowered to regulate by law matters relating to Government securities and all other matters connected herewith or ancillary or incidental thereto."

STATEMENT No. 8

STATISTICAL INFORMATION OF GOVERNMENT BILLS

S1. No.

Name of the Bill Name of the Date of Dats of Date of Minister Introduction Consideration Passing

1 2 3 4 5 6

1. BillNo. 1 of 1999- Chief Minister 29-7-1999 29-7-1999 29-7-1999 The Goa Appropriation Bill, 1 999

2. BillNo. 2 of 1999- Chief Minister 19-7-1999 2-8-1999 2-8-1999 The Goa Contingency Fund (Second Amendment) Bill, 1999

- 3. BillNo. 3 af 1999- Chief Minister 2-8-1999 2-8-1999 2-8-1999 T h m S u p p l e m e n t a r y Appropri3hK-- -

Bill, 1999 I U-l

4. BillNo. 5 of 1999- Chief Minister 15-7-1999 2-8-1999 2-8-1999 The GoaMunicipalities (Amendment) Bill, 1999

I 5. Bill No. 6 of 1999- Chief Minister 15-7-1999 3-8-1999 3-8-1999

The Goa Panchayat Raj (Second Amendment), Bill, 1999

v f i k 7 ijf 1999 ;-- CnTe1" Minister 22-7-iW 3-8-4~993 j-8-199 The Goa Protection of Interests of Depositors (inFinancialEstablishments)Bill, 1999

7. Bill No. 8 of 1999- Chief Minister 26-7-1999 2-8-1999 2-8- 1W The Goa School Education (Amendment) Bill, 1999

8. BillNo.10of1999- IrrigationMinister 29-7-1999 3-8-1999 3-8-1999 The Goa Tillari Inigation Development Corporation Bill, 1999

STATEMENT No. 9

STATISTICAL INFORMATION OF PRIVATE MEMBERS' BILL

S1. Name of the Bill Name of the Date of Date of Date of Remarks No. Member Introduction Consideration Passing

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

1. The Goa Evacuee Property Shri Prakash Phadte 30-7-1W -- - lapsed as the Member (Protection of Dwelling - was inducted as Ilouses)Bill, 1999-- - - - - -- - -- - Minister

- 64 -

STATEMENTNO. 10

ANNOUNCEMENT OF ASSENT TO BILLS

S1. No. Name of the Bill Date on which whether assented by Assent President or ~overn i r

1 Bill No. 1 of 1999 - 3-8-1999 Governor Appropriation Bill, 1999

STATEMENT No. 1 1

STATEMENT OF PRIVATE MEMB

No. of days allotted for the discussion

No. of notices of resolutions received

No. of notices withdrawn dy the Members 1 .

. No. of Resolutions not ad&ittedldisallowe !

No. of Resolution balloted j ,

No. of Resolutions passed

STATEMENT No. 12

CALLING ATTENTION (NOTICES UNDER RULE63)

No. of No. of Consolidated No. of Notices Subject in brief Name of Date on which Notices Notices Admitted Member matter was put

received disallowed1 lapsed/withdrawn

8 3 - 5 1. Disconnection of regular water Shri Pandurang Raut 23-7-1999 supply to the Coca Cola Factory at Vema Industrial Estate.

2. Non availability of rice for public Shri Manohar Parrikar 22-7-1999 distribution 1

0\ ul

3. Excessive rains that have virtu- V i s h \ ~ s S?tzrhr, 27-7-1999 ally destroyed the agricultural Ulhas Asnodkar & I activities Prakash Phadte

Shri Manohar Parrikar, 2-8-1999 4. Goa Antibiotics has been

msli~ufacturing substandard life saving drug.

Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu 3-8-1999 5. Failure of Administration of

Peter Alvares High School Morjim.

STATEMENT No. 13

PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE OFTHE HOUSE DURING THE JULYIAUG. SESSION, 1999

S1. No. Papers laid on the Table of the House La id by Date

1. Annual Report of the Goa University for Chieflfinister 12-7-1999 theyear 1997-98. I

2. Annual Audited Accounts for the year Chiefldinister 12-7-1999 1996-97

3. The GoaLand Revenue (Inspection, Search Chief Minister 12-7-1999 and Supply of copies of Land Records) (Amendment)Rules,l998. ' i

4. The Goa Standards of peights and Measures (Enforcement) Amendment Rules, 1999. I

5. Finance Accounts 1997-98 I 6 Appropriation Accounts 199$-98

I 7. Report of the Comptroller / and Auditor

General of India for the y{ar ended 31 March, 1998. 1

8. 27th Annual Reuort 1997-98 &f ~ o a eat Complex Ltd.

Minis er for Health 12-7-1999 1

12. Settlement Reports under Goa Land CbiefMinister 28-7-1988 Revenue Code, 1968.

13. Settlement prepared in terms of Clause ChiefMinister -28-7-1999 3(2)(a)(b) of GoaStateGuarantees Act, 1993 in respect of the guarantees given by the Government for loan etc. raised by Statutory Corporation, Local Bodies and other Institutions.

14. The Annual Accounts for the year 1996-97 Minister for Housing 29-7-1999 and 1997-98 of Goa Construction, Housing and Finance Corporation Ltd.

15. TheFirst AnnualReport (1997-98) ofthe Goa Minister for Irrigation 29-7-1999 Forest Developmept CorporationLimited.

I I 16. The Goa Motor Vehicles ~u le s ; 199 1. Chief Minister 30-7- 1999

17. A copy of Master Plan on Madei river cor taining 4 volumes.

I 1

- Minister for Irrigation 30-7-1999

i I

STATEMENT No. 14 STATISTICAL INFORMATlON OF STARRED QUESTIONS OF SECOND

SESSION JULY-AUGUST, 1999

AdministrativeRefonn I. - 1 - .- - - - Departments

Archieves 3 - 1 - 2 1 1 -

Animal Husbandry 3 - 1 - 2 - 2 - Agriculture 12 - 1 - :I1 2 9 -

4 1 3 - 11 5 6 -

5 - 5 - 15 2 13 -

8 2 6 -

1 1 - -

8 2 6 - 1.8 3 15 -

7 3 4 -

8 5 3 - 2,2 9 23 -

3 -

Art & Culture 6 - 2 -

Civil Supplies 13 L 1 1

Cooperation 9 11 1 2

Education 21 5 -

Environment 8 T- l 1 - - Employment - 1

2 k 2 Finance 11 1

Forest I 2 1 2 1 r - - Fisheries 7 -

2 - Industries 9 22 -

- - 1 - 1 - - - 1 - 1 -

8 -

General Administration 11

Home 35

2 1 -

1 2 -

Housing Board

Mines 13 1 2 - 10 1 9 - Public Health 43 - 4 4 35 '16 19 .-

Personnel 11 - 2 3 6 1 5 - Public Works 105 2 15 5 83 17 6 -

Power 44 1 1 2 4 0 2 9 2 0 -

Panchayati-Raj 13 - 2 - 11 3 8 -- Provedoria 4. 2 2 -

Revenue 35 - 10 2 23 8 14 1

River Navigation 3 - - - 3 1 2 -

Sports 15 - 3 - 12 6 6 -

Social Welfare 1 16 1 1 1 5 9 4 5 - I

Tourism 1 10 - - I - 10 3 7 - Town & Country Planning

/TTransport

Urban Development

Vigilance

Women & Child Dev.

I. T. I.

Irrigation

Protocol I

Law 4 - - jl 4 1 3 - OfficialLan..&Pub.G. 1 4 - - I

I- 4 - 4 - I

Planning 1 2 - - I 1 1 - 1 - i I

I

STAmMENTNo. 15

STATISTICAL INFORPJAIION OF IINSTARRE

"2 .d

c

s t? C

1

AdrninistrativeKeform - -- 1 - i - 1 - Department I

Animal Husbandry 1 -

Art & Culture Civil Supplies

Finance Forest General P,drninistration - Home

Industries Labour Mines Public Health Personnel Public Works Power Panchayati-Raj Revenue

Town & Country Pla. -

Women & Child Dev. -

STATEMENTh o. 16

DISPOSALOFSHORT NOTICE QUESTIONS

Short Notice Questions received ............................ 1

Admitted ........... :. ................................................... -

Not admitted ........................................................... 1

Department ............................................................. G. A. D.

STATISTICAL INFORMATION OF NOTICE QUESTIONS OF SECON,D SESSION

) Presentation of fileport

Total 1 1 - - - - - -

1. Report of Business Advisory Corninittee 07-07- 1999

I I

S1. No. Name of the Report Date of Presentation -

ZERO HOUR MENTIONS

Sl. Date of Zero Hour Mention Zero Hour Mention regarding No. Assembly made by

1 2 3 4

1. 9-7-1999 Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon Non Payment of Compensation for landslicie victims at Tariwada, Vasco da Gama.

2. 9-7-1999 Shri Prakash Velip Power theft in Cuncolim Industrial Estate.

3. 9-7-1999 Shri Pandurang Raut Loss in K. T. C.

4. 9-7-1999 Shri Sanjay Bandekar

1

5. 9-7-1999 Shri Manohar Panikar I

I 7. 9-7-1999 Smt. VictoriaFernandes I

8. 9-7-1999 Shri Manohar Azbaonki

I

9. 9-7-1999 Shri Vinay Tendu lkar \

Eon availability of doctors in time at Canacona Hospital.

Inferior quality of rice supplied through Fair Price Shops. I No prop r facilities at ~ a k a o Bus

I 10. 9-7-1999 Shri Vishwas Sataykar

13. 12-7-1999 Shri Sanjay Bandekar Decision to donate his eye to any soldier losing both the eyes.

14. 12-7-1999 Shri Vinay Tendulkar Rehabilitation of displaced farmers of Dhangar community by Forest Department in V. P. Collem and V. P. Mollem in Sanguem Taluka.

15. 12-7-1999 Smt. VictoriaFeqandes Ban on fishing during breeding season.

16. 12-7-1999 Shri Shaikh Haroon Regarding handing of burial ground at Margao to Muslim Com- munity.

18. 14-7-1999 Shri Filipe Neri Rodrigues


/ 20. 14-7-1999 Shri Shaikh Hasan Haroon

21. 15-7-1999 Shri Jitendra Beshprabhu

22. 15-7-1999 Shri Rarnkrishna Dhavalikar

23. 15-7-1999 ShriLuis Alex Cardozo

Re/luesr to have separate electricity of ice in Cuncolim. 4

at Canacona insisting store to get new free home delivery being given. Gas

Power supply to be restored to building rehabilitating Tariwada

i victims.

No: availability of Gynaecologist in P;einem Hospital.

Mr. Naik, a KTC worker his eye due to wrong

in Hospicio Mospi-

Maintenance of Old Age Homes.

24. 15-7-1999 Shri Prabhakar Gaonkar

25. 15-7-1999 Shri Shaikh Kassan Haroon

26. 167-1999 Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu


28. 19-7-1999 Shri Manol~ar Azgaonkar

I

I

32. ' 19-7-1999 Smt. VictoriaFemandes

I I 33. 19-7-1999 Shri Prakash Phadtq

I 34. 207-1999 Dr. Suresh Amonk 4.

Request to widen Sanguem- Netravali road. Request to transfer a PWD engineer Shri Naik.

Request to release power connection to hawkers, gadda owners etc. at Saptiih festival

Request to make available free of cost Heoatitis 'B'vaccine.

Complaint regarding selling of fish by Karwar fishermen outside the Canacona fish Market.

Request to stop sand extraction at Uguem ;,long river Terekhol.

I villages in Shiroda and Constituency due to

and blocking of

of cashew trees in land for construction of Ghar at Canacona.

35. 20-7-1W Smt. VictoriaFernandes

36. 21-7-1999 Shri Venktesh Dessai

37. 21-7-1999 Shri Ulhas Asnodkar

38. 21-7-1999 Shri Shaikh Hassan Haroon

39. 22-7-1999 Shri Manohar Panikar

40. 22-7-1999 Shri Vinay Tendulkar


1 43. 22-7-1999 Shri Vishwas Satarkar.

I

44. 23-7-1999 Shri Vishwas Satarkar

45. 23-7-1999 Smt. VictoriaFernandes


47. 267-1999 Dr. Suresh Amonkar

Refusal of visas to Indian na~ionals by UAE Government.

Request to denotify Madei Wild Life Sanctuary.

Repairs to Bus Shed at Tisko on Porvorim-Mapusa Highway.

Request to provide inverters in the corridors of the Assembly.

Inadequate and turbid water supply to Panaji.

Pollution caused due to release of slurry from the benefication plants by mine owners.

Pollution and health hazard caused by the FCI godowns at Bogda Vasco da Garna.

Retrenchment of teachers taken in place of teachers deputed for training.

Vaghurme village being cut off from Ponda due to flooding.

Request to repair Mardol to Madcaim road.

Washing away of Ribandar-Panvel road due to heavy rains.

Request to depute staff for Malaria work at Cmacona.

1 Loss caused due to heavy rains to paddy crop, houses, etc in Amona Constituency.

48. 26-7-1999 Smt. Victoria Fernandes

49. 26-7-1999 Shri Vinay Tendulkar


51. 28-7-1999 Shri Prakash Phadte.

52. 30-7-1999 Shri Ulhas Asnodkar

53. 2-8-1999 Shri Venktesh Dess$

I

55. 3-8-1W Shri Prabhakar Gaolkar

I 56. 3-8-1999 Shri ~ha ikh asa an loon

Loss caused due to heavy rains to agarkars and khazan field cultivators in S a ~ t a Cruz Constituency.

No replies being given to members of opposition benches.

Traditional fishermen being denied access to Bhimavol beach by Navy Personnel.,

Reported news regarding collapse of Sharda IJidyalaya School building at Curr$barjua.

.constructidn being carried out in open space in P&T Colony at Porvorim.

I

Request to !?old Panchayat meeting once in a mI3nth instead of every 15 days. ; Posting of IPS Officers on Cadre post. 1

thiri~ legislative assembly attention (under -rule 63) eight calling attention notices were...

Documents