tobacco and tuberculosis

1
745 perature rising to 100° F., the breathing becoming hurried and the patient being stupefied. She recovered, but optic atrophy remained, and vision amounted only to distinguishing move- ments of the fingers. In this case the alcohol was applied to a raw surface for four days. Can this dangerous poison be absorbed through the intact skin ? There is no evidence that it can, although the opportunity has been abundantly present in the extensive use of methylated spirits for making liniments and for disinfecting the hands and arms of surgeons. But, as Dr. McKechnie suggests, it is possible that investigation might trace cases of moderate impairment of vision to the continued external use of methyl alcohol. He is not " taking any chances," and has discontinued its external use since encountering this case. MALARIA IN ENGLAND. No cases of indigenous malaria have been reported in this country so far during the present year. So Sir Ronald Ross tells us in the memorandum which we print on another page. Three conditions are, of course, essential for the home production of malaria : (1) The return of infected soldiers from abroad; (2) the presence of anopheline mosquitoes ; and (3) access of one to’the other. In regard to (1) the large proportion of infected soldiers are concentrated in eight malaria hospitals on specially selected sites, although the article in another column of this issue by Major A. J. Hall, Captain E. Williams, and Captain S. Douglas on two cases which developed a fatal infection after reaching this country should put every medical officer on his guard to look for sporadic cases. In regard to (2) Sir Ronald Ross consolingly says that anophelines are com- paratively so scarce in most parts of Britain as to render the danger minimal. But the danger is there and is only to be avoided by close attention to the third link in the vicious circle. In regard, therefore, to (3) strict instructions have been issued that in places where mosquitoes abound all cases of malaria are to be collected in sheds protected against the entry of the insects. On the care with which Sir Ronald Ross’s memorandum is read and laid to heart by all those who have to do with febrile disorders in returned soldiers depends the immunity of our civilian population from an infec- tion which is easily acquired and with difficulty got rid of. -- TOBACCO AND TUBERCULOSIS. IN the American Review of Tuberculosis for March Dr. W S. Duboff, of Colorado, tilts at the view that smoking is harmful in pulmo- nary tuberculosis, especially when complicated by laryngeal disease. His conclusions are based on the observation of 1000 patients at the sanatorium of the Jewish Consumptive’s Relief Society, whom he classifies as non-smokers, exces- sive, moderate, or light smokers. The fact that in the course of pulmonary tuberculosis women are as subject to laryngitis as men is, in his opinion, practically equivalent to an acquittal of tobacco; and his tabulated analysis showing that in most cases of throat disease associated with pulmonary tuberculosis the patients were non-smokers leads him to the sweeping generalisation that " tobacco obviously does not predispose to laryngeal com- plications." In the same journal Major Gerald B. Webb, M.O.R.C., deals with 3288 soldiers, whose lungs were auscultated with special reference to the detection of " smoker’s rhonchi." These bronchial rhonchi were audible in most of the men who smoked cigarettes, whereas the majority of the non-smokers, pipe-smokers, and cigar-smokers did not exhibit this sign. Of the men examined 20 per- cent. were non-smokers, and of 233 men discharged for tuberculosis from a command numbering about 25,000, 22 per cent. were non-smokers. From evi- dence of this type the author suggests that even inhaling cigarette smoke does not aid the outbreak of pulmonary tuberculosis. He quotes in support the case of R. L. Stevenson, whom he describes as an inveterate cigarette-smoker, but who lived ta die of apoplexy, an ex ttno disce omnes line of argument which medical men do not often misuse so entirely. A third opinion is given by Dr. Julius Dworetzky, of Otisville, N.Y., who considers tobacco as well as alcohol to be a direct irritant to the throat. Neither of the two first authors attempts. to meet the objection to tobacco that its use promotes spread of infection. Their arguments that tobacco is innocuous to the smoker himself, as far as tuberculosis is concerned, are mainly based on rather slender statistical evidence. But their papers are useful as a stimulus to further research and as a check on the anti-tobacco fanatic, who would at all costs rob the consumptive of the inestimable solace that smoking often brings. Dr. F. W. Edridge-Green has been appointed Senior Ophthalmic Surgeon to the Central London Medical Boards (National Service). Sir Arbuthnot Lane, Sir James Mackenzie, and Colonel Herbert .Bruce, C.A.M.C., have started for America as delegates to the American Medical- Conference. _______________ KING EDWARD’S HOSPITAL FUND FOR LONDON. THE annual meeting of the Governors and General Council of this Fund was held at St. James’s Palace on May 14th, the Speaker of the House of Commons being in the chair. The accounts and balance-sheet for 1917, which were pre-- sented by Lord Revelstoke, having been adopted, Mr. F. M. Fry brought forward the draft report of the Council, which showed that the total receipts for the year were jE258,572, of which JE1518 were contributions to capital and JE237,OM receipts on general account. The League of Mercy contri- buted JE15,000. The grants made for the year amounted to JB190.000, being JE20.00& more than in 1916 and JE32.500 in excess of the grants made in 1912 and 1913, the years of the highest distribution before the war. Of the- amount distributed, B181.000 was given to London hospitals—jE140,02& in aid of general maintenance, £ 12,150 to the reduction of debts on maintenance account, and .S28.825 towards improvement schemes or in reduction of liabilities on such schemes undertaken before the war. Mr. Fry said that the Fund had continued to encourage hospitals to post-- pone all schemes of capital expenditure not exceptionally urgent or not already in hand at the outbreak of war, and the total grants in aid of new schemes were only JE8675. Grants for maintenance, largely due to the munificence of Lord Astor, were .B8750 more than in 1916 and .e34,650 more than in 1915. Of .S9000 distributed by the Con- valescent Homes Committee, JE7050 was allocated to consumption sanatoria, and .S1950 to convalescent homes. The grants to sanatoria enabled 62 beds to be reserved for the use of patients in London hospitals. The total sum distributed during the last ten years was JB1,614,000. Since the foundation of the Fund 21 years ago .E2,458.415 had been distributed. During the year the amount spent on adminis- tration was .E3460 10s., or JB1 9s. 0._’,-d. per JE100 of the total amount received, as compared with B3161 2s. 3d., or 19s. 4M. per 2100 in the previous year. The increased expenditure had been occasioned mainly by additions to the remuneration of the staff. The Speaker, in moving the adoption of the report, which was unanimously carried, stated that for the first time the Governors had this year secured the services of some lady- visitors.

Upload: lethien

Post on 30-Dec-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TOBACCO AND TUBERCULOSIS

745

perature rising to 100° F., the breathing becominghurried and the patient being stupefied. Sherecovered, but optic atrophy remained, andvision amounted only to distinguishing move-

ments of the fingers. In this case the alcoholwas applied to a raw surface for four days. Canthis dangerous poison be absorbed through theintact skin ? There is no evidence that it can,

although the opportunity has been abundantlypresent in the extensive use of methylated spiritsfor making liniments and for disinfecting the handsand arms of surgeons. But, as Dr. McKechniesuggests, it is possible that investigation mighttrace cases of moderate impairment of vision to thecontinued external use of methyl alcohol. He isnot " taking any chances," and has discontinued itsexternal use since encountering this case.

MALARIA IN ENGLAND.

No cases of indigenous malaria have beenreported in this country so far during thepresent year. So Sir Ronald Ross tells us in thememorandum which we print on another page.Three conditions are, of course, essential for thehome production of malaria : (1) The return ofinfected soldiers from abroad; (2) the presence ofanopheline mosquitoes ; and (3) access of one to’theother. In regard to (1) the large proportion ofinfected soldiers are concentrated in eight malariahospitals on specially selected sites, although thearticle in another column of this issue by MajorA. J. Hall, Captain E. Williams, and Captain S.Douglas on two cases which developed a fatalinfection after reaching this country should

put every medical officer on his guard to lookfor sporadic cases. In regard to (2) Sir RonaldRoss consolingly says that anophelines are com-paratively so scarce in most parts of Britain asto render the danger minimal. But the dangeris there and is only to be avoided by close attentionto the third link in the vicious circle. In regard,therefore, to (3) strict instructions have been issuedthat in places where mosquitoes abound all cases ofmalaria are to be collected in sheds protectedagainst the entry of the insects. On the care withwhich Sir Ronald Ross’s memorandum is read andlaid to heart by all those who have to do withfebrile disorders in returned soldiers depends theimmunity of our civilian population from an infec-tion which is easily acquired and with difficulty gotrid of.

--

TOBACCO AND TUBERCULOSIS.

IN the American Review of Tuberculosis forMarch Dr. W S. Duboff, of Colorado, tilts atthe view that smoking is harmful in pulmo-nary tuberculosis, especially when complicatedby laryngeal disease. His conclusions are basedon the observation of 1000 patients at thesanatorium of the Jewish Consumptive’s ReliefSociety, whom he classifies as non-smokers, exces-sive, moderate, or light smokers. The fact that inthe course of pulmonary tuberculosis women areas subject to laryngitis as men is, in his opinion,practically equivalent to an acquittal of tobacco;and his tabulated analysis showing that in mostcases of throat disease associated with pulmonarytuberculosis the patients were non-smokers leadshim to the sweeping generalisation that " tobaccoobviously does not predispose to laryngeal com-plications." In the same journal Major Gerald B.

Webb, M.O.R.C., deals with 3288 soldiers, whoselungs were auscultated with special reference to thedetection of " smoker’s rhonchi." These bronchialrhonchi were audible in most of the men whosmoked cigarettes, whereas the majority of thenon-smokers, pipe-smokers, and cigar-smokers didnot exhibit this sign. Of the men examined 20 per-cent. were non-smokers, and of 233 men dischargedfor tuberculosis from a command numbering about25,000, 22 per cent. were non-smokers. From evi-dence of this type the author suggests that eveninhaling cigarette smoke does not aid the outbreakof pulmonary tuberculosis. He quotes in supportthe case of R. L. Stevenson, whom he describes asan inveterate cigarette-smoker, but who lived tadie of apoplexy, an ex ttno disce omnes line ofargument which medical men do not often misuseso entirely. A third opinion is given by Dr. JuliusDworetzky, of Otisville, N.Y., who considers tobaccoas well as alcohol to be a direct irritant to thethroat. Neither of the two first authors attempts.to meet the objection to tobacco that its use

promotes spread of infection. Their argumentsthat tobacco is innocuous to the smoker himself, asfar as tuberculosis is concerned, are mainly basedon rather slender statistical evidence. But theirpapers are useful as a stimulus to further researchand as a check on the anti-tobacco fanatic, whowould at all costs rob the consumptive of theinestimable solace that smoking often brings.

Dr. F. W. Edridge-Green has been appointedSenior Ophthalmic Surgeon to the Central LondonMedical Boards (National Service).

Sir Arbuthnot Lane, Sir James Mackenzie, andColonel Herbert .Bruce, C.A.M.C., have started forAmerica as delegates to the American Medical-Conference.

_______________

KING EDWARD’S HOSPITAL FUND FORLONDON.

THE annual meeting of the Governors and General Councilof this Fund was held at St. James’s Palace on May 14th,the Speaker of the House of Commons being in the chair.The accounts and balance-sheet for 1917, which were pre--sented by Lord Revelstoke, having been adopted, Mr. F. M.Fry brought forward the draft report of the Council, whichshowed that the total receipts for the year were jE258,572, ofwhich JE1518 were contributions to capital and JE237,OMreceipts on general account. The League of Mercy contri-buted JE15,000.The grants made for the year amounted to JB190.000, being JE20.00&

more than in 1916 and JE32.500 in excess of the grants made in 1912 and1913, the years of the highest distribution before the war. Of the-amount distributed, B181.000 was given to London hospitals—jE140,02&in aid of general maintenance, £ 12,150 to the reduction of debts onmaintenance account, and .S28.825 towards improvement schemes or inreduction of liabilities on such schemes undertaken before the war.Mr. Fry said that the Fund had continued to encourage hospitals to post--pone all schemes of capital expenditure not exceptionally urgent or notalready in hand at the outbreak of war, and the total grants in aid ofnew schemes were only JE8675. Grants for maintenance, largely due tothe munificence of Lord Astor, were .B8750 more than in 1916and .e34,650 more than in 1915. Of .S9000 distributed by the Con-valescent Homes Committee, JE7050 was allocated to consumptionsanatoria, and .S1950 to convalescent homes. The grants to sanatoriaenabled 62 beds to be reserved for the use of patients in Londonhospitals. The total sum distributed during the last ten years was

JB1,614,000. Since the foundation of the Fund 21 years ago .E2,458.415had been distributed. During the year the amount spent on adminis-tration was .E3460 10s., or JB1 9s. 0._’,-d. per JE100 of the total amount

received, as compared with B3161 2s. 3d., or 19s. 4M. per 2100 in theprevious year. The increased expenditure had been occasioned mainlyby additions to the remuneration of the staff.

The Speaker, in moving the adoption of the report, whichwas unanimously carried, stated that for the first time theGovernors had this year secured the services of some lady-visitors.