tradeoffs nairobi workshop, 20-21 june 2005 tradeoff analysis: an operational and accepted tool for...
TRANSCRIPT
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
Tradeoff Analysis:an operational and accepted tool for policy analysis.
Objectives and Program
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
1995
1990
2010
2005
2000
Traditional agricultural research:• Little integration• Focused on farm/field level
Question asked on pesticide use inEcuadorian Andes. No toolsavailable.
Development of first version
of TOA framework
Applications of TOAframework
TOA as an accepted tool?TOA applied in several projects?
TOA time line
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
Starting point…
• Tradeoff Analysis framework• Tradeoff Analysis model• User guide• Scientific publications• Two applications in the Andes
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
Objectives
1. Consolidation of frameworks and methods
5.Communication
2. Testing and applicationof toolbox and framework
2. Testing and applicationof toolbox and framework
3. Development of user-oriented software
3. Development of user-oriented software
4. Institutionalization strategies and policy links
4. Institutionalization strategies and policy links
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
• Project 1: Prototyping Ecoregional Analyses Tools to Improve Science-Based Decision Making in Research and Development
• Project 2: Transregional Analysis of Crop-Livestock Systems: Understanding Intensification and Evolution across Three Continents
• Project 3: Tradeoff Analysis as an Operational and Accepted Tool for Policy Analysis
Given the toolbox for ecoregional research, what tools are we going to apply when? How do select the
tools in an application?
Several ecoregional problems can not be dealt with using a single
tool. How do we combine tools to tackle the problem?Many tools in our toolbox are
science tools. How do we lift these tools from the scientific laboratory to the real world?
Objectives
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
Generic? Needed?Usable?
Is Tradeoff Analysis …
If so … can we transfer and institutionalize TOA?
Objectives
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
• Apply the TOA model in a case study(Generic?)
• Develop training materials and web site. (make it usable)
• Make a general inventory of projects in Kenya and select projects
• Training workshop• Backstopping• Institutionalization
Strategy
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005
Workshop program
Monday 20 June 2005• Opening session• The tradeoff analysis• The Machakos case study• Reception/Dinner
Tuesday 21 June 2005• The future of Machakos• Tradeoff applications• The future of TOA• Closure
Tra
deoff
s
Nairobi Workshop, 20-21 June 2005