tripura as is to be vol 2 27.11.09 doc
TRANSCRIPT
Ministry of Panchayati Raj
e-PRI Study Project - Phase III
Volume II
As – Is, Gap Identification and To - Be Process Report
for
Panchayati Raj Institutions
in
The State of Tripura
By
National Informatics Centre Services Inc.
November, 2009
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 2 of 228
Confidentiality Statement
This report is intended solely for the information and use of the Ministry of Panchayati Raj,
Government of India, State Panchayati Raj Department, Government of Tripura, National Informatics
Centre and should not be used, circulated, quoted or otherwise referred to for any other purpose by
any institution or individual other than the Ministry, State PR department and National Informatics
Centre, nor included or referred to in whole or in part in any document without the prior consent of
National Informatics Centre Services Inc. or the Ministry.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 3 of 228
Table of Content 1. Scope and Approach of As – Is Study and To – Be Pro cess Design........................................ ..........................4
1.1. FINALIZED LIST OF SERVICES: ......................................................................................................... 8
1.1.1. Existing Services/Proposed Services........................................................................................... 8
2. PRI INTERNAL Function(s) As – Is and Gaps identific ation: ............................................. ..................................11
3. IT Applications:................................... ..............................................................................................................................30
4. As – Is Delivery Processes, Gaps and To – Be proces ses...................................................................................31
4.1. SERVICE 1: ISSUE OF BIRTH CERTIFICATE ............................................................................................... 31
4.2. SERVICE 2: ISSUE OF DEATH CERTIFICATE ............................................................................................. 40
4.3. SERVICE 3: ISSUE OF ROR-(REGISTER OF ORDINARY RESIDENCE) .......................................................... 50
4.4. SERVICE 4: ISSUE OF MARRIAGE CERTIFICATE ....................................................................................... 61
4.5. SERVICE 5 : APPLICATION FOR PENSION UNDER IGNOAPS(OLD AGE PENSION)...................................... 71
4.6. SERVICE 6: APPLICATION FOR PENSION UNDER IGNWPS (WIDOW PENSION) ........................................... 82
4.7. SERVICE 7: APPLICATION FOR PENSION UNDER IGNDPS ( DISABILITY PENSION) .................................... 91
4.8. SERVICE 8: APPLICATION FOR SCHEDULE CASTE CERTIFICATE............................................................. 101
4.9. SERVICE 9: APPLICATION FOR SCHEDULE TRIBE CERTIFICATE............................................................... 112
4.10. SERVICE 10: APPLICATION FOR OBC CERTIFICATE............................................................................... 123
4.11. SERVICE 11: APPLICATION FOR INCOME CERTIFICATE ........................................................................... 134
4.12. SERVICE 12: APPLICATION FOR RATION CARD....................................................................................... 146
4.13. SERVICE 13: APPLICATION FOR PRCT ................................................................................................. 157
4.14. SERVICE 14: APPLICATION FOR NON-CREAMY LAYER CERTIFICATE ....................................................... 167
4.15. SERVICE 15: APPLICATION FOR SURVIVOR CERTIFICATE ....................................................................... 177
4.16. SERVICE 16: TELEPHONE BILL PAYMENT .............................................................................................. 187
4.17. SERVICE 17: ELECTRICITY BILL PAYMENT ........................................................................................... 195
4.18. SERVICE 18: APPLICATION FOR LAND RECORDS COPY......................................................................... 203
4.19. SERVICE 19: APPLICATION FOR RTI ..................................................................................................... 212
4.20. SERVICE 20: NREGS – APPLICATION FOR JOB CARD, DEMAND FOR WORK ........................................... 221
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 4 of 228
1. Scope and Approach of As – Is Study and To – Be Process Design
A comprehensive As-Is Assessment was done to understand the functioning of the state Rural
Development and Panchayati Raj Department and other line departments, their operational and
organizational hierarchy, roles and responsibilities, services provided, Issues faced, Priority areas, IT
infrastructure available, Software applications availability, etc.
The consulting team of 3i Infotech Ltd. had meetings with the top officials of the respective and
Directorates and also had interviews and detailed discussions with the functional staffs in those
circles to understand the existing business processes and underlying activities of each function.
During this period 3i Infotech consultants did the following activities:
��� Identification of the Critical success factors (CSF) for service needs
��� Breakdown of the CSF into various process and sub-processes
��� Identification of Process boundaries and Process owners
��� Identification of disconnect and value adding process.
��� Determine the internal flow of information (initiator, recipient, format, and usage/purpose) and
approval mechanism considering the volumes, cycle time, queuing delays.
��� Study of the existing IT infrastructure
The following goals were kept in mind while capturing information for the As-Is Study of the project:
��� Information
••• Information flow within the Department
••• Availability of real time, relevant and reliable information to the senior management in
order to enable timely decision.
••• Complete visibility across all levels.
��� Technology
••• Use of ICT to improve service delivery standards within the department
••• Network connectivity at the Range Offices and Block Offices
••• Maintenance of central database to eliminate data redundancy
••• Generation of real time MIS reports to highlight areas of concern
��� Processes
••• Whether citizen facing processes are simple and customer friendly
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 5 of 228
••• Turnaround time for each transaction
••• The number of touch points for each transaction
••• Complete traceability across the entire process cycle
••• Whether there are built in mechanism within the processes to discourage corruption.
••• Interface with external government bodies and other departments.
��� Staffing & Skills
••• Whether there is required number of Forest staff for fulfilling its duties.
••• Whether the Forest personnel have the required training and skill sets for utilizing ICT
tools
��� Other Resources
••• Proposals / Plans to implement e-Governance initiatives to improve overall efficiency
of the Departments
••• Funding options to carry out e-Governance initiatives
••• Availability of Project Management and Program Management expertise to implement
projects.
Ministry of Panchayati Raj (MoPR) has entrusted the job of e-PRI Mission Mode Project to National
Informatics Centre Services Inc. (NIC-SI) to achieve the objective as under:
��� To carry out the comprehensive study the status of Panchayati Raj System in the state with
respect to devolution of Funds, Functions and Functionaries, Status of Activity Mapping
Document, Capacity Assessment, IT assessment etc.
��� To study the existing service delivery mechanism at the PRI levels and the identification of
new G2C, G2G services which can be delivered to the Citizens through the PRI framework.
��� To study the various Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) and Central Sector Scheme with
respect to their planning, execution, implementation, monitoring and the accounting
mechanism followed in the state.
��� To identify the service needs of the various stakeholders like other line departments, citizens,
special groups, self help groups, NGOs, anagnwari & asha workers, etc..
��� To bring in e-Governance in the PRI framework and strengthen the Panchayats with sufficient
IT and NON-IT infrastructure along with the connectivity for the information flow to the top
level through various middle levels and the trained domain knowledge expert manpower with
the sufficient knowledge of ICT at the disposal of PRIs at various levels.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 6 of 228
The main objective is to “Make all Government services accessible to the common man in his
locality, through common service delivery outlets and ensure efficiency, transparency & reliability of
such services to realize the basic needs of the common man”.
To achieve the mandated objective, following procedure was adopted to identify the government to
citizen services at various levels of PRIs:
To identify the services need of the citizen the first step was to identify the services provided by
Panchayat, which is available in most of the states through the Activity Mapping Document, which
gives the information on involvement of three tiers of PRI in different department & their activities.
Since this document is not prepared by the state RD department, the first draft of the services were
identified based on the discussion with officials of PR department.
The project envisages the study and subsequent re-engineering of the two broad categories of
services namely G2G services and G2C services. The project scope includes identification of 15
existing services to be identified for re-engineering for each state and 5 new services. The
methodology for the services identification can be given as follows:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 7 of 228
Step1 :- Define broad list of services to be studied . This was done based on extensive
interactions with various levels of officials at the Center, including central line ministries and
conducting various surveys like departmental surveys, internet surveys, state based surveys etc. the
indicative list of services was recognize. The services identified at this step are the umbrella list of
services which were refined subsequently at the state level.
Step2 :- Define state specific list of services from the umbrella list of services finalized at the
central level based on interactions at the Central Ministry level. Further to identification of
approximately seventy services, the same was presented to the State Government for their
deliberation.
Step2 :- Consultation with line Departments:- After a series of discussions with the various line
departments at the state level and at the time of the state level workshop, the list was further
improved upon.
Step3 :- Consultation with District Officials: While carrying on the discussions with various officials
at the District level, consequently, the list was further improved upon considering several parameters
like volume of transactions, demand by the citizens during Gram Sabha and other informal
discussions, etc.
Step4 :- Consultation with Target Beneficiaries:- The Gram Sabha was organized at two places in
the Bhadarwah block of Doda district to understand the requirements of the citizens. At the end of
this robust exercise the list of 15 services were identified which can be delivered through the various
levels of PRI framework and specially through Gram Panchayats once they come into the existence.
Step5 :- Identification of services to be re-engineered, which consists of existing list of services and a
list of new services that would be identified for delivery to the citizens. These new services are
determined based on Information & Services needs assessment study at the panchayat levels,
interactions would then be done with the Ministry and State level officials during the process
reengineering phase to understand their requirements and prioritize the list of new services to be
delivered to the citizens.
Step6 :- Further to the completion of study on information & services needs of the various stake
holders, a district level workshop was organized wherein the officials of all the line departments were
present. The purpose of the workshop was to appraise the district administration to get the feedback
on the study report being submitted and the gaps identified during the study with respect to the
functioning PRIs, Based on the inputs received during the workshop the list of identified services was
further improved upon and finalized.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 8 of 228
1.1. FINALIZED LIST OF SERVICES
Government to Citizen Services where first identified at State level during discussion with key
officials of State PR&RD departments. These services where further validated and improved
upon after discussion with Officials at Zila Parishad and Panchayat Samiti. Further the lists of
services were finalized based on services needs of citizens identified during Gram Sabha.
1.1.1. Existing Services/Proposed Services
The following list of services that were being delivered have been short listed on the basis of:
��� High no. of transactions
��� Demanded by the citizens during the Gram Sabha meetings
��� Mandated service by the Government of India
��� Service on the basis of criticality
��� Long procedure of a service
��� Shortage of manpowerReason for selecting the Services:
SR. NO.
EXISTING SERVICES
PRESENT SERVICE
DELIVERY LEVEL
INVOLVEMENT OF PRI
PROPOSED SERVICE
DELIVERY
REASON FOR SELECTING THE SERVICES
1. Birth Certificate Gram Panchayat
Complete
� Panchayat is fully involved to provide the Service
� Certificate is required for various other services
� Highly useful if database is integrate
� with other services like Ration Card, RoR
2. Death Certificate Gram
Panchayat Complete
� Panchayat is fully involved to provide the Service
� Certificate is required for various other services
� Highly useful if database integrate with other services like Ration Card, RoR
3. ROR-
(Register of orderly residence)
Gram Panchayat
Complete
� Panchayat is fully involved to provide the Service
� Certificate is basic requirement for various other services
� Highly useful if database integrate with other services like Ration Card, PRTC
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 9 of 228
SR. NO.
EXISTING SERVICES
PRESENT SERVICE
DELIVERY LEVEL
INVOLVEMENT OF PRI
PROPOSED SERVICE
DELIVERY
REASON FOR SELECTING THE SERVICES
4. Marriage Certificate
SDM Partial
� Marriage Register is maintained by the Gram Panchayat, certificate delivery should be at GP level.
� Panchayat is already involved to provide the Service
� Certificate is basic requirement for various other services
� Highly useful if database integrate with other services like Ration Card, PRTC , election record
5. Application for Pension under IGNOAPS
Social Education
Department
Partial
� Villager demand to root this service through Panchayat
� Volume is sufficient to provide the service
� Address the basic need of the elderly and needy rural populace
6. Application for Pension under IGNDPS
Gram Panchayat
Partial
� Villager demand to root this service through Panchayat
� Volume is sufficient to provide the service
� Address the basic need of the elderly and needy rural populaces
7. Application for Pension under IGNWPS
Gram Panchayat
Partial
� Villager demand to root this service through Panchayat
� Volume is sufficient to provide the service
� Address the basic need of the elderly and needy rural populaces
8. NREGA-1.Job Card, 2. Demand for work
Gram Panchayat
Complete
� Panchayat is fully involved in service
� Volume is high � Transparency in system and
monitoring
9. Income Certificate SDM -
� Villager demand the services for the convenience
� Certificate is required for various other purpose and government jobs
10. Caste Certificate
–SC SDM Partial
Panchayat Samiti level
� Demand is very high by the citizen.
� Certificate is required for various other purpose and government jobs.
� Volume is high
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. II - As-Is & To-Be Proc esses - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 10 of 228
SR. NO.
EXISTING SERVICES
PRESENT SERVICE
DELIVERY LEVEL
INVOLVEMENT OF PRI
PROPOSED SERVICE
DELIVERY
REASON FOR SELECTING THE SERVICES
11. Caste Certificate –ST
SDM Partial Panchayat Samiti level
� Demand is very high by the citizen.
� Certificate is required for various other purpose and government jobs.
� Volume is high for the service
12. Caste Certificate –OBC
SDM Partial Panchayat Samiti level
� Demand is very high by the citizen.
� Certificate is required for various other purpose and government jobs.
� Volume is high for the service �
13. Non Creamy
Layer Certificate SDM -
� OBC community demands for the services
� Certificate is required for the government jobs
14. Ration Card SDM Ration
High volume of the services
15. PRCT- Permanent Residence Certificate of Tripura
SDM office
� residence certificate required to the citizens for many other services
� Villager demand this certificate to be deliver at GP level as frequency to visit SDM office is very high
� Transaction volume is high
16. Survivor Certificate
SDM office
Certificate is demanded by the villagers and Pradhan
17. Land Records-Map, Khatyan
Revenue department SDM office
Gram Panchayat
� High volume of transaction � Citizen required the document
frequently � Citizen have to visit the SDM
office several time to know the status of application
18. RTI/ Grievance redressal
Panchayat Samiti
Gram Panchayat
� Citzen demand the service at GP level
� Transparency in the system
19. Telephone Bill Block Gram Panchayat
High volume of transaction
20. Electricity Bill Block Gram Panchayat
High volume of transaction
Gram Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 11 of 228
2. PRI INTERNAL Function(s) As – Is and Gaps identi fication:
This section describes the activities under various functions performed by PRIs and associated gaps. The functions are classified into the following
2 categories:
1. Primary Functions – These functions include G2G functional areas like planning, monitoring etc.
2. Common Functions – These are functions commonly performed by PRIs
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Zilla Panchayat Primary Functions 1 Planning DPC is not
formed at ZP level in Tripura, however in Dhalai District DPC is formed for BRGF only.
Manual PR official , CEO ZP etc.
Plan Plus is only used for BRGF, use of this application or other specific application for Panchayat samiti and Gram Panchayat level annual planning would be useful, as well as hands on training is required for the Plan Plus application..
DPC is required at District level.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 12 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Planning approach is bottom to top, but Plan is consolidated at District level
Manual PR official , CEO ZP , Line department
Line department should upload scheme statistics, beneficiary statistics and progress report to district portal or website continuously.
Training to PR official and Line departmental official regarding Planning, use of Plan plus
2 Reporting Financial Progress / Expenditure reporting Physical Progress reporting
Gram Panchayat Secretery send monthly report to BDO At block level , dedicated CIC worker at BDO office feed the report. Block update the data under Management of Information System (MIS) and online reporting at block level and district level is maintained. MPR (Monthely progress report ) of schemes send to DM office and Monthly progress meeting held at District level of each department. Inspection report of RD Works are also to be submitted by the BDOs to DM along with monthly return online submission of MPR (both physical & financial) by the DM to RD department. Update of website All Development works should be posted on website and this should be updated at every month. Conducting of Social Audit on quarterly basic for RD schemes
PR official at ZP , PS and GP level CEO ZP and PR officials
Scope for IT enabled Reporting Updating of District web site and line department/scheme website on monthly basis MIS reporting and Planning application should capture monthly report data also . Previous month status report tracking mechanism should be IT enabled.
Guideline on website
management of NIC and if
possible web site certification
practices as per the STQC should
be followed.
Trained IT staff Website administrator responsible for updating the website should be identified at the departments
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 13 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Physical verification of work by the PS and Pradhan. PS send report of progress of work with photographs to BDO
Updating of District web site and line department/scheme website on monthly basis
3 Implementation
� Inspection of RD schemes � Zila parishad is actively
involved in inspection of Panchayat scheme through its Inspectors or PO.
� Being a Secretery of Zila Parishad DPO monitor the Schemes of Panchayat Department and also review the report of Inspector and Panchayt officer and send it to CEO of zila parishad
� DPO ensure submission of Utilization certificate to the CEO of Zila parishad
� Apart from that The involvement of PRIs in function varies according to status of devolved fund, function and functionaries. In most CSS schemes, the role of PRIs is limited to review of implementation progress.
� Education (School) Zila Parishad shall have the power of supervision, control and monitoring of implementation of all the schemes/works of the Education (School Department) of Primary schools (Class I to V) within
Online mechanism to submit the utilization certification to officials at each level. All schemes of the department should be regularly updated by the department on the website or district portal, MIS report should be generate and send to CEO ZP and Ziladhipati for review at every month. MIS report of schemes and services should also generated for the concern Gram Panchayat and send to GP every Month. New scheme detail should be available online
Pradhan Should be able to Comment on all MIS report or Departmental report send to GP by the concerned department. This comment should directly go to ZP and CEO ZP for the recapitulation.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 14 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
the jurisdiction of Zila Parishad and suggest for improvement/ DEO/DEO-in-charge shall be designated as ex-officio Deputy Executive Officer (School Education Department) in Zila Parishad within the Zila Parishad area and shall assist Zila Parishad for overall supervision/control/ monitor/implementation of different schemes. Education (Social Welfare & Social Education) Supervision and monitoring of the implementation of the plan. Animal resources department Supervision of veterinary, first aid, dispensaries, animal resource institutions in the zilla parishad Industries department Supervision of the programme of cottage and small industries
for citizen view in the local language. There is no application or a centralized database or any other mechanism for sharing data required for PRI between the various associated offices and the issuing authorities, which introduces a delay in the process. It should be centralize
4 Accounting
The PR Department uses Single Entry cash basis accounting system to maintain their accounts
Manual Accountant and DPO
Accounting application
Training of computer to staff and accountant
5 Monitoring ZP receives reports on physical & financial progress of development & welfare schemes from Block level
Scope for use of monitoring software like Priasoft & Rural Soft
Common Functions 1 Informatio
n Dissemination
Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
District Panchayat office, And district line department or Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: a. use of web
site in local language may be helpful for
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 15 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
getting the information
b. apart from website use of ICT through use of Community Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
and involvement of elected member of PRI should be made compulsorily
2 Collecting Taxes
Examples: # Collection of House Tax # Collection of Patta
Presently there is no Tax collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of tax collection in Pachayat Act
Manual DPO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
Improvement Panchayat should collect at least minimum Tax for more involvement of citizen in the Panchayat raj institution
3 Generating own revenues
Examples: # Development fund # Sale of agricultural produce from common land
Presently there is no revenue collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of revenue collection in Pachayat Act
Manual DPO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
Panchayat should collect revenue for self dependence and promote activity of self dependence training to people Promote cottage industry and tie up with State/Central schemes or Private partner for marketing of these cottage produce Tripura is very rich State in terms of Natural Herbs, Bamboo produce.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 16 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
4 Record Management
Examples: # Maintenance of Pariwar registers # Maintenance of land records #File Management # File Numbering and Tracking # Archival of physical records and digital records # Security of records
All register are maintained in manual form. Office Management practice is not followed by the zila parishad.
5 Grievance Redressal
RTI Act DPO act as State Public Information officer at District Panchayat office and his appellate authority is Director Panchayat. CEO is SPIO at Zila Parishad Level and at the same time he is appellate authority for the Executive of Panchayat Samiti.
Manual Online RTI mechanism
6 Correspondence / Communication With Upper level, Attached and subordinate offices
# Forms for correspondence # Office Memo # Fax Facility # Office Order # Notice # Circular
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 17 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
# Telephonic Communications
7 Inventory / Asset Management
# Inventory Register # Asset Register
Asset Management by the proposed application
Block Panchayat Primary Functions 1 Planning Gramoday
scheme is initiated for Planning
Manual PR official , BDO Plan Plus is only used for BRGF, use of this application or other specific application for Panchayat samiti and Gram Panchayat level annual planning would be useful, as well as hands on training is required for the Plan Plus application.
Gramoday scheme should be implemented with the capacity building program
An Engineer service should be taken for the planning and monitoring purpose.
Planning approach is bottom to top , but Plan is consolidated at Panchayat samiti level
Manual PR official, BDO, Line department block level official.
Line department should upload scheme statistics, beneficiary statistics, and progress report to district portal or website continuously.
2 Reporting Financial Progress / Expenditure reporting
Gram Panchayat Secretary send monthly report to BDO At block level, dedicated CIC worker at BDO office feed the report.
Manual
PR official name and designation
Scope for IT enabled Reporting
Reporting
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 18 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Physical Progress reporting
Block update the data under Management of Information System (MIS) and online reporting at block level and district level is maintained. MPR (Monthly progress report ) of schemes send to DM office and Monthly progress meeting held at District level of each department. Inspection report of RD Works are also to be submitted by the BDO s to DM along with monthly return Update of website All Development works should be posted on website and this should be updated at every month. Conducting of Social Audit on quarterly basic for RD schemes Physical verification of work by the PS and Pradhan. PS send report of progress of work with photographs to BDO
BDO and PR officials
Updating of District web site and line department/scheme website on monthly basis MIS reporting and Planning application should capture monthly report data also. Previous month status report tracking mechanism should be IT enabled. Updating of District web site and line department/scheme website on monthely basis
3 Implementation
� Inspection of RD schemes � Zila parishad is actively
involved in inspection of Panchayat scheme through its Inspectors or PO.
� Being a Secretary of Zila Parishad DPO monitor the Schemes of Panchayat
Manual Online mechanism to submit the utilization certification to officials at each level. All schemes of the
Pradhan Should be able to Comment on all
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 19 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Department and also review the report of Inspector and Panchayt officer and send it to CEO of zila parishad
� DPO ensure submission of Utization certificate to the CEO of Zila parishad
Apart from that The involvement of PRIs in function varies according to status of devolved fund , function and functionaries . In most CSS schemes, the role of PRIs is limited to review of implementation progress. Education (School) Zila Parishad shall have the power of supervision, control and monitoring of implementation of all the chemes/works of the Education (School Department) of Primary schools (Class I to V) within the jurisdiction of Zila Parishad and suggest for improvement/ DEO/DEO-in-charge shall be designated as ex-officio Deputy Executive Officer (School Education Department) in Zila Parishad within the Zila Parishad area and shall assist Zila Parishad for overall supervision/control/ monitor/implementation of different schemes. Education (Social Welfare & Social Education) Supervision and monitoring of the implementation of the plan
department should be regularly updated by the department on the website or district portal, MIS report should be generate and send to CEO ZP and Ziladhipati for review at every month. MIS report of schemes and services should also generated for the concern Gram Panchayat and send to GP every Month. New scheme detail should be available online for citizen view in the local language. There is no application or a centralized database or any other mechanism for sharing data required for PRI between the various associated
MIS report or Departmental report send to GP by the concerned department. This comment should directly go to ZP and CEO ZP for the recapitulation.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 20 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Animal resources department Supervision of veterinary, first aid, dispensaries, animal resource institutions in the zilla parishad Industries department Supervision of the programme of cottage and small industries
offices and the issuing authorities, which introduces a delay in the process. It should be centralize
4 Accounting
The PR Department uses Single Entry cash basis accounting system to maintain their accounts
Manual Accountant and BDO
Accounting application
Training of computer to staff and accountant
5 Monitoring ZP receives reports on physical & financial progress of development & welfare schemes from Block level
Manual Scope for use of monitoring software like Priasoft & Rural Soft
Common Functions 1 Informatio
n Dissemination
Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
Manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: a. use of web site
in local language may be helpful for getting the information
b. apart from website use of ICT through use of Community Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval and involvement of elected member of PRI should be made compulsorily
2 Collecting Taxes
Examples: o Collection of
House Tax o Collection of
Patta
Presently there is no Tax collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of tax collection in Pachayat Act
Manual BDO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the
Improvement Panchayat should collect at least minimum Tax for more involvement
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 21 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
of citizen in the Panchayat raj institution
3 Generating own revenues
Examples: o Development
fund o Sale of agricultural produce from common land
Presently there is no revenue collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of revenue collection in Pachayat Act
Manual BDO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
Panchayat should collect revenue for self dependence and promote activity of self dependence training to people Promote cottage industry and tie up with State/Central schemes or Private partner for marketing of these cottage produce Tripura is very rich State in terms of Natural Herbs, Bamboo produce.
4 Record Management
Examples: o Maintenance
of Pariwar registers
o Maintenance of land records
o File Management
o File Numbering and Tracking
o Archival of physical records and digital records
All register are maintained in manual form. Office Management practice is not followed by the Panchayat Samiti level.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 22 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
o Security of records
5 Grievance Redressal
RTI Act BDO act as State Public Information officer at Block Panchayat office and his appellate authority is CEO ZP CEO is SPIO at Zila Parishad Level and at the same time he is appellate authority for the Executive of Panchayat Samiti.
Manual Online mechanism
6 Correspondence / Communication With Upper level, Attached and subordinate offices
o Forms for correspondence
o Office Memo o Fax Facility o Office Order o Notice o Circular o Telephonic o Communicati
ons
7 Inventory / Asset Management
Inventory Register Asset Register
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 23 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Information Dissemination
Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
District Panchayat office, And district line department or Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
Manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: c. use of web site
in local language may be helpful for getting the information
d. apart from website use of ICT through use of Community Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval and involvement of elected member of PRI should be made compulsorily
Gram Panchayat Primary Functions 1 Planning Gramoday scheme
is initiated for Planning But not use efficiently
Manual Pradhan,PS,Members
Plan Plus is only used for till Block level would be useful, as well as hands on training is required for the Plan Plus application.
Gramoday scheme should be implemented with the capacity building program
Planning is done at ward level, Planning approach is bottom to top,but Plan is consolidated at Gram Panchayat level, technical input is required
Manual PS,Pradhan. Line department should upload scheme statistics, beneficiary statistics and progress report to district portal or website continuously.
Technical assistance by line department
2 Reporting Financial Progress / Expenditure reporting
Gram Panchayat Secretary send monthly report to BDO At block level,
Panchayat secretery
Scope for IT enabled Reporting
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 24 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Physical Progress reporting
dedicated CIC worker at BDO office feed the report. Block update the data under Management of Information System (MIS) and online reporting at block level and district level is maintained. MPR (Monthly progress report) of schemes send to DM office and Monthly progress meeting held at District level of each department. Inspection report of RD Works are also to be submitted by the BDO s to DM along with monthly return Update of website however PS send the report manually All Development works should be posted on website and this should be updated at every month. Conducting of Social Audit on quarterly basic for RD schemes Physical verification of
PS
Updating of District web site and line department/scheme website on monthly basis MIS reporting and Planning application should capture monthly report data also. Previous month status report tracking mechanism should be IT enabled. Updating of District web site and line
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 25 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
work by the PS and Pradhan PS send report of progress of work with photographs to BDO
department/scheme website on monthly basis
3 Implementation � Inspection of RD schemes
� Zila parishad is actively involved in inspection of Panchayat scheme through its Inspectors or PO.
� Being a Secretery of Zila Parishad DPO monitor the Schemes of Panchayat Department and also review the report of Inspector and Panchayt officer and send it to CEO of zila parishad
� DPO ensure submission of Utization certificate to the CEO of Zila parishad
Online mechanism to submit the utilization certification to officials at each level. All schemes of the department should be regularly updated by the department on the website or district
Pradhan Should
be able to Comment on all MIS report or Departmental
3
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 26 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Apart from that The involvement of PRIs in function varies according to status of devolved fund, function and functionaries. In most CSS schemes, the role of PRIs is limited to review of implementation progress. Education (School) Zila Parishad shall have the power of supervision, control and monitoring of implementation of all the schemes/works of the Education (School Department) of Primary schools (Class I to V) within the jurisdiction of Zila Parishad and suggest for improvement/DEO/DEO-in-charge shall be designated as ex-officio Deputy Executive Officer (School Education Department) in Zila Parishad within the Zila Parishad area and shall assist Zila Parishad for overall supervision/control/ monitor/implementation
portal, MIS report should be generate and send to CEO ZP and Ziladhipati for review in every month. MIS report of schemes and services should also generated for the concern Gram Panchayat and send to GP every Month. New scheme detail should be available online for citizen view in the local language.
report send to GP by the concerned department.
This comment should directly go to ZP and CEO ZP for the recapitulation.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 27 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
of different schemes. Education (Social Welfare & Social Education) Supervision and monitoring of the implementation of the plan Animal resources department Supervision of veterinary, first aid, dispensaries, animal resource institutions in the zilla parishad Industries department Supervision of the program of cottage and small industries
4 Accounting The PR Department uses Single Entry cash basis accounting system to maintain their accounts
Manual PS Accounting application
Training of computer and ICT to staff and accountant
Common Functions 1 Information
Dissemination Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
Manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: a. use of web site in local language may be helpful for getting the information c. apart from
website use of ICT through use of Community
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval and involvement of elected member of PRI should be made compulsorily.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 28 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
2 Collecting Taxes Examples: o Collection of
House Tax o Collection of
Patta
Presently there is no Tax collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of tax collection in Pachayat Act
Manual BDO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
Improvement : Panchayat should collect minimum Tax for more involvement of citizen in the Panchayat raj institution
3 Generating own revenues
Examples: o Development
fund o Sale of
agricultural produce from common land
Presently there is no revenue collection at each level of Panchayat, however there is provision of revenue collection in Pachayat Act
Manual BDO Providing a Financial Module for Panchayat Software for accounting all the Financial Transaction e.g. Collections, payments etc.
Panchayat should collect revenue for self dependence and promote activity of self dependence employment training to people and Promote cottage industry and tie up with State/Central schemes or Private partner for marketing of these cottage produce As Tripura is very rich State in terms of Natural Herbs, Bamboo produce.
4 Record Management
Examples: o Maintenance of
Pariwar registers o Maintenance of
land records o File Management o File Numbering
o All register are maintained in manual form.
o Office Management practice is not followed by the
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 29 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
and Tracking o Archival of
physical records and digital records
Panchayat Samiti level .
5 Grievance Redressal
RTI Act BDO act as State Public Information officer at Block Panchayat office and his appellate authority is CEO ZP CEO is SPIO at Zila Parishad Level and at the same time he is appellate authority for the Executive of Panchayat Samiti.
Manual Online mechanism
6 Correspondence / Communication With Upper level, Attached and subordinate offices
o Forms for correspondence
o Office Memo o Fax Facility o Office Order o Notice o Circular o Telephonic
Communication
7 Inventory / Asset Management
o Inventory Register
o Asset Register
Information Dissemination
Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
District Panchayat office, And district line department or Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: a. use of web site in local language may be helpful for getting the information b. apart from
website use of ICT through use
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval and involvement of elected member of PRI should be made compulsorily
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 30 of 228
Gaps / Issues / Improvement opportunities S. No.
Function Activity Description Mode Role and Responsibility IT Process People
of Community Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
8. Information Dissemination
Generation of Awareness programs about the Services / Schemes etc.
Conducting Meetings Or Display board / Notice board
manual PR officials, Citizens, Community
Improvement: a. use of web site in local language may be helpful for getting the information b. apart from website use of ICT through use of Community Radio may be great medium of information dissemination in Panchayat
Meeting of line department and PR department official at regular interval and involvement of elected member of RI should be made compulsorily
3. IT Applications: S. NO. NAME OF THE IT
APPLICATION DESCRIPTION MODULES DEPLOYMENT STATUS
1 Plan Plus Used for Decentralized planning at ZP level and Block Level
Deployed in 4 ZP, 40 PS
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 31 of 228
4. As – Is Delivery Processes, Gaps and To – Be pro cesses
4.1. Service 1: Issue of Birth certificate Gram Panchayat act as a registrar of Death and Birth at Gram Panchayat level and maintain register of death and birth, BDO is the key signatory of
the Birth Certificate and issue birth certificate, however he require support of Doctor certificate if the child born at hospital or if the child born at
Home, Pradhan and Asha worker certificate or endorsement is required. For the Birth registration, If the certificate is issued within 15 days of birth,
no fee is charged however if it is after 15 days. Rs.5 is charged against the certificate.
4.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Issue of Birth C ertificate Snapshot
Name of service Issuance of Birth Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, BDO, Citizens Hospital
Process Input Process Output
o Application, o Transaction Charge / Cost (Rs 5 if it is after 15 days of birth) o Birth certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time:
Documents Involved
Registers o Register of Birth
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � Doctor certificate � Pradhan Endorsement � Asha karmi endorsement
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 32 of 228
4.1.1.1. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsi
bility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1 Citizen Fills up the
hardcopy of Application with Pradhan/Asha karmi endorsement and Docter Certificate
At GP Office
Application form Manual Citizen Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
2 Panchayat Secretery Receives the form physically
At GP Office
Manual Panchayat Secretary
Form might get tampered or lost
Workflow would enable transfer of application/form directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
3, Entry in Birth register as a registrar of Birth
At GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
On line register should be maintained
PS should made entry in register , which should be available online to BDO
4. Forwarding of register and Application format to BDO
At Panchayat Samiti Level
Doctor Certificate Pradhan endorsement
Manual Panchayat Secretary
PS brings the register at block, probability of damage and other type of hazards are involved It is time taking process because visit of PS to BDO office is not certain.
Register should be available online to BDO Application should be available online to BDO as e-form All evidentiary/support document database should be available online as a scanned document.
Upload all the document at Gram Panchayat level
Panchayat secretary and
5. Endorsement of application by the Panchayat officer at Panchayat samiti and approval made by the BDO
At Panchayat Samiti Level
Birth Register Application format Doctor Certificate Pradhan endorsement
Manual BDO office
Time taking process Use of digital signature PO and BDO
6. BDO sign the certificate and Birth register
At Panchayat Samiti level
Format of Birth Certificate Register of Birth
Manual BDO Use of digital signature BDO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 33 of 228
4.1.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 34 of 228
4.1.2. To-Be: Process Narration: Issue of Birth Cer tificate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Birth Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
� Doctor certificate
� Pradhan Endorsement
� Asha karmi endorsement
o Birth certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 7 Days Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Birth register
Documents Involved
Registers o Birth and death register
Format o Application format (may be application on plain paper)
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 35 of 228
4.1.2.1. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either
himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the PS
as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating
his biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI application Manual Citizen / Applicant
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section
on the application.
e-PRI application Manual Citizen / Applicant
5. The e-PRIA application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI application
6. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of
the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
e-PRI application Online Panchayat Secretary
7. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to
verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Online Panchayat Secretary
8. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed
form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant
agrees with the printed copy.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
9. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it
or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the operator along with copies of
any required documents
GP Manual Applicant
10. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI application Online Panchayat Secretary
11. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the
Online
1 days
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 36 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time (days)
Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
12. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the selected authority and
generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application-
GP
Online
13. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
14. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
15. Check the data base of birth and Death register e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
16. If it is already available in record , mark it to BDO for issuing the certificate e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
1 Days
17. If it is not issued previously, Check the supporting document and attach it for BDO office
validation (Scanned attachment depends on bandwidth of network otherwise it would be
send manually)
e-PRI application-
PS
Computeriz
e/Manual
Panchayat Secretary 1 Days
18. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to Authority GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
19. BDO office validate it and BDO issue the certificate with its digital signature e-PRI application-
PS
Computeriz
e
BDO
20. After issuance the certificate it would save on Birth and death register database e-PRI application-
PS
Online Panchayat Secretary
21. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application-
GP
Online
22. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant
with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
e-PRI application-
GP
Manual Panchayat Secretary
2 Days
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 37 of 228
4.1.2.2. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 38 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
� Centralized RBD(Register of Deaath & Birth) Database at the DP Level having integration with the ePRI Application.
Legal Changes:
• Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended • Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. • Submission of e forms by the Panchayat Secretary with its digital signature on behalf of applicant. • Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates. Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online form on his behalf. √
if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by the applicant, otherwise he get printout of the application
and get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of credentials √ √
Digital signature should be used √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the manual signature with stamp
stating the validation check.
√ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 39 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by BDO , on this regard legal transformation is required . √
Technology
e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability component √ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit the e form however in
case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √
4.1.2.3. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1. Birth Statistics for a Given Month by Birth Type.
This report shall provide information on Birth (Live and Still) registered for a given month in each Gram
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
4.1.2.4. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Center No. of
Days Designation No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation
1 Panchayat Secretary send the request to BDO office clerk
Panchayat Secretary 2 Panchayat Secretary 2 BDO
4.1.2.5. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s S.N No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for registering a birth and getting a Birth certificate. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like: Birth & Death already registered Late registration
Minutes/ Days Sarpanch / GP Secretary
2 Number of escalation
Number of escalations happening for and application in case of late/ very late registration
Sum of all escalations happening for an application in case of late / very late registration
Number Sarpanch / GP Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 40 of 228
4.2. Service 2: Issue of Death Certificate Panchayat act as a registrar of Death and Birth at Panchayat level and maintain the register of death and birth, BDO is the main signatory and issue
authority of death certificate however he require endorsement of Doctor if the patient death held at hospital or PMR by the doctor or if the death
occurred at Home, Pradhan and Asha worker certificate or endorsement is required on this behalf .if the certificate is issued within 15 days of birth ,
no fee is charged however if it is after 15 days Rs.5 is charged against the certificate.
4.2.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Issue of Death C ertificate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Death Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, BDO, Citizens Hospital
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Transaction Charge / Cost (Rs 5 if it is after 15 days of birth) o Death certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- 3 days Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers o Register of Death
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � Doctor certificate � Pradhan Endorsement � Asha karmi endorsement
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 41 of 228
4.2.1.1. As-Is Activity description
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1 Citizen Fills up the hardcopy of Application with Pradhan/Asha karmi endorsement and Docter Certificate
At GP Office
Application form Manual Citizen Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
Panchayat Secretary Applicant
2 Panchayat Secretery Receives the form physically
At GP Office
Manual Panchayat Secretary
Form might get tampered or lost
Workflow would enable transfer of application/form directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
3. Entry in Death register as a registrar of Death
At GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
On line register should be maintained
PS should made entry in register , which should be available online to BDO
4. Forwarding of register and Application format to BDO
At Panchayat Samiti Level
Doctor Certificate Pradhan endorsement
Manual Panchayat Secretary
PS brings the register at block, probability of damage and other type of hazards are involved It is time taking process because visit of PS to BDO office is not certain.
Register should be available online to BDO Application should be available online to BDO as e-form All evidentiary/support document database should be available online as a scanned document.
Upload all the document at Gram Panchayat level
Panchayat secretary and
5. Endorsement of application by the Panchayat officer at Panchayat samiti and approval made by the BDO
At Panchayat Samiti Level
Death Register Application format Doctor Certificate Pradhan endorsement
Manual BDO office
Time taking process
Use of digital signature PO and BDO
6. BDO sign the certificate and Death register
At Panchayat Samiti level
Format of Death Certificate Register of Birth
Manual BDO Use of digital signature BDO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 42 of 228
4.2.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 43 of 228
4.2.1.3. To-Be: Process Narration: Issue of Death C ertificate Snapshot
Name of service
Issuance of Death Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, Citizens
Process Input Process Output
Application,
Doctor certificate
Pradhan Endorsement
Asha karmi endorsement
Death certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 7 Days Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Death register
Documents Involved
Registers o Birth and death register
Format o Application format (may be application on plain paper)
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 44 of 228
4.2.1.4. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1) The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
2) The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
1 Day
3) The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI
application
Manual Citizen / Applicant
4) The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section on the application.
e-PRI
application
Manual Citizen / Applicant
5) The e-PRIA application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI
application
6) The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat Secretary
7) The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Online Panchayat Secretary
Same day
8) If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
9) The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the operator along with copies of any required documents
GP Manual Applicant
10) The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat Secretary
11) The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
Online
12) The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the selected authority and generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI
application-
Online
SAME DAY
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 45 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time (days)
Remarks
GP
13) The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
14) The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
15) Check the data base of birth and Death register e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
16) If it is already available in record , mark it to BDO for issuing the certificate
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary DAY 2
17) If it is not issued previously , Check the supporting document and attach it for BDO office validation .
e-PRI
application-
PS
Computerize
/Manual
Panchayat Secretary
18) If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to Authority GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
19) BDO office validate it and BDO issue the certificate with its digital signature
e-PRI
application-
PS
Computerize BDO
20) After issuance the certificate it would save on Birth and death register database
e-PRI
application-
PS
Online Panchayat Secretary
21) Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI
application-
GP
Online
22) PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
e-PRI
application-
GP
Manual Panchayat Secretary DAY 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 46 of 228
4.2.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 47 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
This section should include Pre requisites or dependencies required, if any for the functioning of the process
� Centralized Register of Birth and Death Database at the Zila Parishad Level having integration with the ePRI Application
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended
� Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments.
� Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by the applicant, otherwise he get
printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials
√ √
Digital signature should be used √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 48 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the
manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by BDO , on this regard legal
transformation is required .
√
Technology
e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability
component
√ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit
the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or
thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √
4.2.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Death Statistics for a Given Month This report shall provide information on Death
registered for a given month in each Gram
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and
Statistics Department
2. Number of escalation at each level CEO 3. Integration of Detail to PDS & Election department PDS and Election dept.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 49 of 228
4.2.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Center
No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation No. of Days Designation
Submit to BDO clerk Panchayat Secretary 3 BDO
4.2.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a Death
and getting a death certificate. This
shall start from the time applicant
submits the application to the PS till
he get the certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the individual
activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered like:
Birth & Death already registered
Late registration
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP
Secretary
2 Number of
escalation
Number of escalations happening for
and application in case of late/ very
late registration
Sum of all escalations happening for an
application in case of late / very late registration
Number Pradhan / GP
Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 50 of 228
4.3. Service 3: Issue of ROR-(Register of ordinary residence) Register of ordinary residence is available at Gram Panchayat level, entry in this register proves that the applicant is the resident of the particular
Gram Panchayat, it is primary entry in the GP level and endorsed by the Executive of the Panchayat Samiti, however before make entry in the
register the applicant have to submit application to the Gram Panchayat and GP approve it in the Gram Panchayat meeting by the formal resolution
of Panchayat.
4.3.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Issue of RoR Snapshot Name of service Entry in the RoR and receive Copy of RoR Process Owner Gram Panchayat Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.) Panchayat Secretery, BDO, Citizens
Process Input Process Output o Application (plain paper) o Resolution of Gram Panchayat o Ration Card o Voter ID card o Transfer Certificate (in case of Transfer from other village and
Marriage)
o Copy of RoR
Service Delivery Time Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Documents Involved Registers o Registers of ordinary residence
Format o Application (plain paper)
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Ration Card � Voter ID card � Transfer Certificate (in case of Transfer from other village
and Marriage � Resolution of Gram Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 51 of 228
4.3.2. As-Is Activity Description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1 Citizen Fills up the Application to Gram Panchayat
At GP Office Application Manual Citizen Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS
Applicant
2 Panchayat Secretery
Receives the form
physically
At GP Office Manual Panchayat
Secretary
Workflow would enable
transfer of application/form
directly to the concerned
approving authority
GP officer receives
the application
online
3 Application produce
in the Gram
Panchayat Meeting
At GP Application Manual Panchayat
Secretary
/Gram
Panchayat
Member
On line register should be
maintained
PS should made
entry in register , &
should be available
online to BDO
4 Resolution made by
the Gram Panchayat
At GP Manual Panchayat
Secretary
/Gram
Panchayat
Member
5 After Resolution entry
made in RoR
At GP Register of
ordinary
Residence
Manual PS Resolution
tracking for each
entry is difficult
6 Forwarding of
register to BDO
At Panchayat
Samiti Level
Manual Panchayat
Secretary
PS brings the
register at block,
probability of
damage and other
type of hazards
are involved
It is time taking
process because
visit of PS to BDO
Register should be available
online to BDO
Application should be
available online to BDO as e-
form
All evidentiary/support
document database should
be available online as a
scanned document.
Upload all the document at Gram Panchayat level
Panchaya
t
secretary
and
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 52 of 228
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
office is not
certain.
7 Endorsement of application by the Panchayat officer at Panchayat samiti and approval made by the BDO
At Panchayat Samiti Level
Resolution of Gram Panchayat
Manual BDO office Time taking process
Use of digital signature PO and BDO
8 BDO make initial on
the RoR
At Panchayat
Samiti level
/BDO office
Manual BDO Use of digital signature BDO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 53 of 228
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 54 of 228
4.3.2.1. To-Be: Process Narration: Issue of RoR Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of ROR copy
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, Citizens
Process Input Process Output
� Ration Card
� Voter ID card
� Transfer Certificate (in case of Transfer from other village & Marriage
� Resolution of Gram Panchayat
o ROR copy
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 7 Days Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o RoR register
Documents Involved
Registers o RoR register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 55 of 228
4.3.2.2. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
1) The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by filling
out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service and
provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen /
Applicant
2) The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP Manual Citizen /
Applicant
3) The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating his
biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
4) The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section on the
application.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
5) Application check the RoR databse about the applicant status if it is available PS would send it
to BDO for re issuance of copy of ROR
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
6) The e-PRIA application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and assigns
it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
7) The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of the
applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
8) The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to
verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
9) If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed
form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant
agrees with the printed copy.
GP Online Panchayat Secretary
10) The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it or
puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies of any required
documents
GP Manual Applicant
DAY 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 56 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
11) The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI application-GP
Manual Panchayat Secretary
12) The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the Gram
Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
13) The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the BDO and generates a
receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application-GP
Online
14) The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the application
to the Applicant
GP Panchayat Secretary
15) The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
16) If it is not available check the Compliance register for next GP meeting and resrve it for GP
resolution.
GP Computerize Panchayat
Secretary
SAME DAY
17) After resolution , mark it to BDO for issuing the certificate e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
18) If it is not issued previously , Check the supporting document and attach it for BDO office
validation .
GP Computerize/ Manual
Panchayat
Secretary
19) If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to Authority GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
20) BDO office validate it with its digital signature e-PRI application-PS
Computerize BDO
21) After issuance the certificate it would save on ROR register database e-PRI application-PS
Computerize Panchayat
Secretary
22) Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application-GP
Online BDO
23) PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with the
formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
DAY 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 57 of 228
4.3.2.3. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 58 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
� Centralized ROR Database at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application
Legal Changes • Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended • Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. • Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended, here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of
certificates. Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online form on his
behalf.
√
If entry is already in ROR database , PS directly send it to BDO for issuance of certificate otherwise it reserve for GP resolution ,
online Compliance register should be maintained which show the next proposed meeting of Panchayat .
√ √ √
if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the
application and get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of credentials √ √ √ v
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the manual
√ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 59 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
signature with stamp stating the validation check.
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by BDO , on this regard legal transformation is
required .
v √
Technology
1. e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability component √ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment) of applicant can be use to submit the e form
however in case of not possibility to use e signature, hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression can be
send to signatory authority.
√ v √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained, ROR should be integrate with death and birth register for automatic
updation.
√ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 60 of 228
4.3.2.4. Expected MIS / Reports Sr. No.
Name of Report Description Report Users
1. RoR entry should be integrate with Death & birth
register
if entry would be made on death register, ROR should be automatically updated BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and
Statistics Department
4.3.2.5. 5.3.2.4 Escalation Matrix **
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1. Send application to Panchayat Extension officer Panchayat Secretary 2 PEO 2 BDO
2. PEO verifies the detail and send it to BDO PEO 2 BDO
** does not include time of meeting held by Gram Panchayat
4.3.2.6. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s S.
No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of
Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a ROR. This shall start
from the time applicant submits the application to the
PS till he get the copy of RoR
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the
process.
Different scenarios can also be considered like:
Already entry in RoR
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP
Secretary
2 Number of
escalation
Number of escalations happening for and application in
case of late/ very late registration
Sum of all escalations happening for an application in case of
late / very late registration
Number Pradhan / GP
Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 61 of 228
4.4. Service 4: Issue of Marriage Certificate
Register of Marriage is available at Gram Panchayat level, after verification at Gram Panchayat, Panchayat Secretary make the entry in to the
Marriage register at Gram Panchayat and send the application to the Sub divisional Magistrate for the issuance of certificate. After formal
verification SDM issue the certificate to the applicant.
4.4.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Issue of Marriag e Certificate Snapshot Name of service
Issue of Marriage Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line deptts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens Sub Divisional Magistrate
Process Input Process Output
o Application (format)
o Date of Birth Certificate/Mark sheet of High School o Marriage Certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers o Registers of Marriage
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others o Date of Birth Certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 62 of 228
4.4.1.1. As-Is Activity description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1 Citizen Fills up the
Application to Gram
Panchayat
At GP Office Application Manual Citizen Online Application or
use of e-forms with the
PS authentication.
Citizens submits the
form online
PS
Applicant
2 Panchayat Secretery
Receives the form
physically
At GP Office Manual Panchayat
Secretary
Workflow would enable
transfer of
application/form directly
to the concerned
approving authority
GP officer receives
the application
online
3 After verification entry
made in Marriage
Register and endorse
the Application
At GP Register of
Marriage
Manual PS
4 Forwarding of
Application to SDM
office
At GP level Manual Citizen Citizen send the
application to SDM
only for signature,
however Register is
maintained at Gram
Panchayat level so It is
time taking process.
Upload all the
document at Gram
Panchayat level
Panchay
at
secretary
and
5 SDM signs the
certificate
At SDM
office
Manual SDM Time taking process Use of digital signature
6 Applicant receives the
Certificate from the
Certificate Desk of
SDM office
At SDM
office
Manual SDM
office
Dispatch
Clerk
BDO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 63 of 228
4.4.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 64 of 228
4.4.1.3. To-Be: Process Narration: Issue of Marriag e Certificate Snapshot Name of service Issuance of Marriage Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, Citizens SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Date of Birth Certificate/Mark sheet of High School � Marriage card � Pradhan or other evidence endorsement
o Marriage certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 7 Days Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Marriage register
Documents Involved
Registers o Marriage register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 65 of 228
4.4.1.4. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by filling out a
hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service and provided all
details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen /
Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any Governmental
agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP Manual Citizen /
Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating his
biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI
applicatio
n-GP
Manual Citizen /
Applicant
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section on the
application.
e-PRI
applicatio
n-GP
Manual Citizen /
Applicant
5. Application check the Marriage register databse about the applicant status if it is available PS would
send it to SDM for re issuance of copy of marriage certificate
e-PRI application-GP
Online
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and assigns it a
Unique Application number.
e-PRI application-GP
Online
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of the
applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to verify the
details mentioned on it.
GP Online Panchayat Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed form and
make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the
printed copy.
e-PRI application-GP
Computerize
Panchayat Secretary
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it or puts
GP Manual Applicant
DAY 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 66 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies of any required
documents
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the documents,
digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the Gram
Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
e-PRI application
Online
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and generates a
receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application-GP
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the application to
the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretery
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual
16. If it is not issued previously , Check the supporting document and attach it for SDM office validation
.
e-PRI application-GP
Computerize/Manual
Panchayat Secretary
17. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to Authority GP Manual
18. SDM office validate it with its digital signature e-PRI application-SDM
Online BDO
19. After issuance the certificate it would save on Marriage register database e-PRI application-SDM
Online Panchayat Secretary
20. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application-GP
Online
DAY 3 AND 4
21. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with the
formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Panchayat Secretary
DAY 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 67 of 228
4.4.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 68 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
This section should include Pre requisites or dependencies required, if any for the functioning of the process
• Centralized Marriage certificate Database at the BP Level having integration with the e PRI Application Legal Changes
• Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended • Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. • Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the
digital form • Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates. Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online form on his behalf. √
If entry is already in Marriage database , PS directly send it to SDM for issuance of certificate otherwise √ √ √
PS validiadate the supporting document and make provisional entry in the Marriage database √ √ √ √
if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and
get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of credentials √ √ √ √
SDM issue digitally signed certificate √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 69 of 228
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the manual signature with
stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM , on this regard legal transformation is required .
Technology
e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability component √ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit the e form however in
case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory
authority.
√ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained, Marriage register should be integrate with RoR and PDS register for automatic
updation.
√ √ √ √ √
4.4.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Marriage register entry should be integrate with RoR, PDS and Election register
if entry would made on marriage register , ROR should be automatically updated.
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
2. Monthly Report BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 70 of 228
4.4.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 Send the application to SDM certificate desk Panchayat secretary 2 SDM desk 2 SDM
2 Send the application to SDM after initial verification SDM certificate Desk 2 SDM
4.4.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1. Service
Delivery Time
Time required for registering a ROR. This shall start
from the time applicant submits the application to
the PS till he get the copy of RoR
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities
in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered like:
Already entry in Marriage register
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP
Secretary
2. Number of
escalation
Number of escalations happening for and
application in case of late/ very late registration
Sum of all escalations happening for an application in
case of late / very late registration
Number Pradhan / GP
Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 71 of 228
4.5. Service 5 : Application for Pension under IGNO APS(Old Age Pension) This function is fully devolved at Gram Panchayat level but due to overburden of Panchayat it is performed by Social Education Department from
December 2008 ,Director decided the quota of the beneficery at block level and send it to CDPO, Panchayat samiti decides quota of each Gram
Panchayt on the basis of quota Supervisor of Social education department receives the application from the applicant at gram Panchayat level and
validate it , he send the applicant list to the Gram Panchayat and GP select the beneficiary through the resolution , Supervisor send this list to
CDPO office which is at Block level , CDPO consolidate the list and send beneficiary list to Directorate for approval, Director approve the list and
accordingly send the fund to the CDPO office, CDPO disburse the pension through its supervisor to the beneficiary. Normally beneficiary gets
pension through Bank however if beneficiary account is not available it may be by Cash also.
4.5.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Old Age Pension Snapshot Name of service
Application for Pension under IGNOAPS
Process Owner
Citizen , Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen, Gram Pradhan ,Supervisor of Social education department CDPO
Process Input Process Output
o Application (format) o BPL o Proof of Age
o Pension for Old Age
Service Delivery Time Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks Documents Involved Registers Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � Date of Birth Certificate � BPL card � Resolution of Gram Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 72 of 228
4.5.1.1. As-Is Activity Description: Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Document
s involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1 Supervisor inform to GP
about the quota
Gram Panchayat and
Supervisor of Social
Education Department
Supervisor It is Top to
bottom
approach;
however bottom
to top approach
is required.
2 Citizen Fills up the
Application to
Supervisor of Social
Education Department
Supervisor of Social
Education Department
Application Manual Citizen Online
Application or
use of e-forms
with the PS
authentication.
Citizens
submits
the form
online
PS
Applican
t
3 After scrutinizing the
application he send list
of all applicant to Gram
Panchayat
Gram Panchayat Applicants
List
Manual Supervisor
4 Gram Panchayat select
the beneficiary in its
meeting through
resolution
Gram Panchayat Applicants
List
Manual Gram
Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 73 of 228
5 Supervisor receive the
list from GP and send it
to CDPO office
Supervisor of Social
Education Department
Beneficiar
y List at
Gram
Panchayat
Manual Supervisor It is time taking
process
Workflow would
enable transfer
of
application/form
directly to the
concerned
approving
authority
GP officer
receives
the
application
online
6 CDPO send the list to
directorate for the
approval and fund
disbursement , Director
release the fund
accordingly
Beneficiar
y List
Manual CDPO Time taking
process
7 CDPO transfer the fund
in the beneficiary
account or if account is
not available give it to
Supervisor to provide
the beneficiary
Manual CDPO/Supervi
sor
SMS alert at the
time of transfer
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 74 of 228
4.5.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 75 of 228
4.5.1.3. To-Be: Process Narration: Old Age Pension Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Pension
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens CDPO, Director Social Education
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � BPL � Proof of Age
o Pension
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 1 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Pension register
Documents Involved
Registers o BPL card o Proof of Age
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 76 of 228
4.5.1.4. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may
do this either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally
requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the PS as he
fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP
Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs
issued by any Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN
card etc.
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant
department’s section on the application.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
5. Application send alert to CDPO e-PRI application
Online
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application
Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI application
Online
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a
photograph of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the
Application Form.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks
the Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will
discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online form and
repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application
Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to
the PS along with copies of any required documents
GP Manual Applicant
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the Online Panchayat
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 77 of 228
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the
same
Secretary
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID
details of the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
e-PRI application
online
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the CDPO
generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a
copy of the application to the Applicant
GP Panchayat Secretery
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP
Same DAY
16. Sector super wiser screened the application and send it to CDPO along
with supporting document
GP Manual Supervisor Day 2
17. CDPO validate it with its digital signature e-PRI application-PS
Online CDPO Day 3
18. CDPO send the list of benificery to Director office e-PRI application-PS
Online CDPO
19. Director approve the list and sanctioned the amount e-PRI application-PS
Online Director ** Day 5
20. CDPO receive the sanctioned amount and transfer it to beneficiary
account
Bank Online /manual CDPO
21. Respective Panchayat receive the alert that Pension is being transferred
to the beneficiary account
e-PRI application-GP
Online CDPO
Day 6
22. PS inform the beneficiary on notice board that pension has been released GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 7
** More time may be taken at Directorate level
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 78 of 228
4.5.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 79 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Legal Changes
Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the digital form Recommendations & Impact
Objectives
O1 – Transparency & Accountability
O2 – Improved Decision Making
O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens
O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs)
O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations
O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary reserve the application for Gram Panchayat
beneficiary selection.
√
After beneficiary selection application send alert to CDPO , and send e form to CDPO , however Sector supervisor collect
the hard copy of application and after scrutinizing send it to CDPO office
√ √ √
List of beneficiary should be send online to director of social education office and when director approve the sanctioned
amount alert should come to CDPO office
√ √
CDPO issue the sanctioned amount to beneficiary account , alert come to respective Gram Panchayat √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
CDPO should be accountable to the Gram Panchayat directly and send alert of issuance of Pension to GP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 80 of 228
Objectives Recommendations
O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Technology
e-Pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability
component
√ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit
the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb
impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. Pension register should be integrate with Death register
for deletion of name
√ √ √ √ √
4.5.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1. List of beneficiary to whom Pension is released and send
by CDPO to Gram Panchayat
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics
Department, Gram Panchayat
2 List of new applicant Director, CDPO,BDO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 81 of 228
4.5.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S.
No. Activity Description
Responsibilit
y Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation No. of Days
Designation
1 Panchayat Secretary Provide the list of beneficiary to
the Supervisor of social education
PS 2 CDPO
2 After scrutinizing Supervisor send the list to the
CDPO
Department
supervisor
2 CDPO 2 Director of Social Education Department
3 CDPO send list to Director of Social education CDPO 2 Director of
Social Education
Department
4.5.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1. Service
Delivery
Time
This shall start from the time applicant
submits the application to the PS till he
get the pension
Sum of time taken to complete the individual
activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• Already receiving the pension
• New application
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP
Secretary
2 Selection of beneficiary depend on Gram Panchayat meeting
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 82 of 228
4.6. Service 6: Application for Pension under IGNW PS (widow pension) This function is fully devolved at Gram Panchayat level but due to overburden of Panchayat it is performed by Social Education Department from
December 2008 , at the State Directorate level Director decided the quota of the beneficiary for the block level and send it to CDPO of concerned
block, Panchayat samiti at block decides quota of each Gram Panchayat on the basis of this quota Supervisor of Social education department
receives the application from the applicant at gram Panchayat level and validate it , he send the applicant list to the Gram Panchayat where Member
of GP select the beneficiary through the resolution , after selection , Superviser of concerned GP send this list to CDPO office which is at Block
level , CDPO consolidate the list and send beneficiary list to Directorate for approval, Director approve the list and accordingly send the fund to the
CDPO office, CDPO disburse the pension through its supervisor to the beneficiary. Normally beneficiary gets pension through cheque however if
beneficiary account is not available it may be by Cash also.
4.6.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Widow Pension Snapshot
Name of service
Application for Pension under IGNWPS
Process Owner
Citizen , Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen, Gram Pradhan ,Supervisor of Social education department CDPO
Process Input Process Output o Application (format) o MoM of findings Gram Panchayat meeting o BPL Card o Death certificate of Husband
o Pension for Widow
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks Documents Involved
Registers Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � BPL card � Death Certificate of Husband � Resolution of Gram Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 83 of 228
4.6.1.1. As-Is activity description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1. Supervisor inform to GP about the quota
Gram Panchayat and Supervisor of Social Education Department
Manual Supervisor It is Top to bottom approach; however bottom to top approach is required.
2. Citizen Fills up the Application to Supervisor of Social Education Department
Supervisor of Social Education Department
Application Manual Citizen Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. After scrutinizing the application he send list of all applicant to Gram Panchayat
Gram Panchayat Applicants List Manual Supervisor
4. Gram Panchayat select the beneficiary in its meeting through resolution
Gram Panchayat Applicants List Manual Gram Panchayat
5. Supervisor receive the list from GP and send it to CDPO office
Supervisor of Social Education Department
Beneficiary List at Gram Panchayat
Manual Supervisor It is time taking process
Workflow would enable transfer of application/form directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
6. CDPO send the list to directorate for the approval and fund disbursement , Director release the fund accordingly
CDPO Beneficiary List Manual CDPO Time taking process
7. CDPO transfer the fund in the beneficiary account or if account is not available give it to Supervisor to provide the beneficiary
CDPO Manual CDPO/Supervisor
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 84 of 228
4.6.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 85 of 228
4.6.1.3. To-Be: Process Narration: Widow Pension Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Pension
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens CDPO, Director Social Education
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � BPL card � Death Certificate of Husband � Resolution of Gram Panchayat
o Pension
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 1 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Pension register
Documents Involved
Registers
� BPL card
� Death Certificate of Husband
� Resolution of Gram Panchayat
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 86 of 228
4.6.1.4. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do
this either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally
requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the PS as he
fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued
by any Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
Online Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant
department’s section on the application.
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
5. Application send alert to CDPO Online
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application
Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a
photograph of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the
Application Form.
Online Panchayat Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks
the Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
Panchayat Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will
discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online form and
repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application
Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to
the PS along with copies of any required documents
Manual Applicant
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the
copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the
same
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 87 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID
details of the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the CDPO
generates a receipt for the Applicant
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a
copy of the application to the Applicant
Panchayat Secretery
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual
Same DAY
16. Sector supervisor screened the application and send it to CDPO along with
supporting document.
Manual Supervisor Day 2**
17. CDPO validate it with its digital signature BP Online CDPO Day 3
18. CDPO send the list of beneficiary to Director office BP Online CDPO
19. Director approve the list and sanctioned the amount BP Online Director ** Day 5
20. CDPO receive the sanctioned amount and transfer it to beneficiary account BP Online /manual
CDPO
21. Respective Panchayat receive the alert that Pension is being transferred to
the beneficiary account
GP Online CDPO
Day 6
22. PS inform the beneficiary on notice board that pension has been released GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 7
**Not include the time taken to send application by the Supervisor to CDPO
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 88 of 228
4.6.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 89 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended
� Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments.
� Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the digital
form
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability & O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens & O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary reserve the application for Gram Panchayat beneficiary selection. √
After beneficiary selection application send alert to CDPO , and send e form to CDPO , however Sector supervisor collect the hard copy of application and after scrutinizing send it to CDPO office
√ √ √ √
List of beneficiary should be send online to director of social education office and when director approve the sanctioned amount alert should come to CDPO office
√ √
CDPO issue the sanctioned amount to beneficiary account , alert come to respective Gram Panchayat √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
CDPO should be accountable to the Gram Panchayat directly and send alert of issuance of Pension to GP
Technology
e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability component √ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. Pension register should be integrate with Death register for deletion of name
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 90 of 228
4.6.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 List of beneficiary to whom Pension is released send by CDPO to Gram Panchayat
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department, Gram Panchayat
4.6.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S.
No. Activity Description
Responsibility Center No. of
Days Designation No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designatio
n
1 Panchayat Secretary Provide the list of beneficiary to
the Supervisor of social education
PS 2 CDPO
2 After scrutinizing Supervisor send the list to the CDPO Department
supervisor
2 CDPO
3 CDPO send list to Director of Social education CDPO 2 Director of Social
Education Department
4.6.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of
Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service
Delivery Time
Time required for registering for Pension. This
shall start from the time applicant submits the
application to the PS till he get the Pension
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• New application for Pension
• Pension to old pensioner
Minutes/ Days Pradhan /
GP
Secretary
2 Time taken by Panchayat for beneficiary selection
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 91 of 228
4.7. Service 7: Application for Pension under IGN DPS ( Disability Pension) This function is fully devolved at Gram Panchayat level but due to overburden of Panchayat MOPR has transfer the function to Social Education now
it is performed by Social Education Department since December 2008 ,Director of Social education decided the quota of the beneficiary for each
block level and send it to the CDPO of concerned block, Panchayat samiti decides quota of each Gram Panchayt on the basis of quota Supervisor
of Social education department receives the application from the applicant at gram Panchayat level and verify and validate it , he send the applicant
list to the Gram Panchayat and GP select the beneficiary through the resolution of Panchayat , Supervisor send this list to CDPO office which is at
Block level , CDPO consolidate the list and send beneficiary list to Directorate for approval, Director approve the list and send the fund to the CDPO
office, CDPO disburse the pension through its supervisor to the beneficiary. Normally beneficiary gets pension through cheque however if beneficiary
account is not available it may be by Cash also.
4.7.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Disability Pensi on Snapshot Name of service
Application for Pension under IGNDP Process Owner
Citizen , Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen, Gram Pradhan ,Supervisor of Social education department CDPO
Process Input Process Output
o Application (format) o MoM of findings Gram Panchayat meeting o BPL Card
Disability Certificate
o Disability Pension
Service Delivery Time Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- 7 days** Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks Documents Involved Registers Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � BPL card � Disability Certificate � Resolution of Gram Panchayat
** Depend on GP meeting
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 92 of 228
4.7.1.1. As-Is activity description: Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibilit
y Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Supervisor inform to
GP about the quota Gram Panchayat and Supervisor of Social Education Department
Manual Supervisor It is Top to bottom approach; however bottom to top approach is required.
2. Citizen Fills up the Application to Supervisor of Social Education Department
Supervisor of Social Education Department
Application Manual Citizen Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. After scrutinizing the application he send list of all applicant to Gram Panchayat
Gram Panchayat Applicants List Manual Supervisor
4. Gram Panchayat select the beneficiary in its meeting through resolution
Gram Panchayat Applicants List Manual Gram Panchayat
5. Supervisor receive the list from GP and send it to CDPO office
Supervisor of Social Education Department
Beneficiary List at Gram Panchayat
Manual Supervisor It is time taking process Workflow would enable transfer of application/form directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
6. CDPO send the list to directorate for the approval and fund disbursement , Director release the fund accordingly
CDPO Beneficiary List Manual CDPO Time taking process
7. CDPO transfer the fund in the beneficiary account or if account is not available give it to Supervisor to provide the beneficiary
CDPO Manual CDPO/Supervisor
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 93 of 228
4.7.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 94 of 228
4.7.1.3. To-Be: Process Narration: Disability Pensi on Name of service
Issuance of Pension
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretary, Citizens CDPO, Director Social Education
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format)
� BPL card
� Disability certificate
� Resolution of Gram Panchayat
o Pension
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 1 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Pension register
Documents Involved
Registers
� BPL card
� Death Certificate of Husband
� Resolution of Gram Panchayat
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 95 of 228
4.7.1.4. 5.7.2.1 To-Be Activity Description:
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
23. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either
by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular
service and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s
behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant
24. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
Manual Citizen / Applicant
25. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
Online Panchayat Secretary
26. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s
section on the application.
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
27. Application send alert to CDPO Online
28. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
29. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a
photograph of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application
Form.
Online Panchayat Secretary
30. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the
Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
Panchayat Secretary
31. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the
Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until
the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
32. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form,
signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with
copies of any required documents
Manual Applicant
33. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of
the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
GP GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 96 of 228
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
34. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of
the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
35. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the CDPO generates
a receipt for the Applicant
Online
36. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
Panchayat Secretery
37. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application
Same DAY
38. Sector supervisor screened the application and send it to CDPO along with
supporting document .
Sector Supervisor Manual Supervisor Day 2**
39. CDPO validate it with its digital signature CDPO office
Online CDPO Day 3
40. CDPO send the list of benificery to Director office Online CDPO
41. Director approve the list and sanctioned the amount Online Director ** Day 5
42. CDPO receive the sanctioned amount and transfer it to beneficiary account
CDPO office
Online /manual
CDPO
43. Respective Panchayat receive the alert that Pension is being transferred to the
beneficiary account
e PRI Application GP
Online CDPO
Day 6
44. PS inform the beneficiary on notice board that pension has been released GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 97 of 228
4.7.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 98 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the
digital form
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary reserve the application for Gram Panchayat beneficiary
selection.
√
After beneficiary selection application send alert to CDPO , and send e form to CDPO , however Sector supervisor collect
the hard copy of application and after scrutinizing send it to CDPO office
√ √ √ √
List of beneficiary should be send online to director of social education office and when director approve the sanctioned
amount alert should come to CDPO office
√ √
CDPO issue the sanctioned amount to beneficiary account , alert come to respective Gram Panchayat √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
CDPO should be accountable to the Gram Panchayat directly and send alert of issuance of Pension to GP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 99 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Technology
e-pri application host the form for the respective service and departments, it would be treated as form availability
component
√ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit
the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb
impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. Pension register should be integrate with Death register
for deletion of name
√ √ √ √ √
4.7.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 List of beneficiary to whom Pension is released send by CDPO to Gram Panchayat
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department, Gram Panchayat
2 Integration with Death register and its reconciliation BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department, Gram Panchayat
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 100 of 228
4.7.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation
1 Panchayat Secretary Provide the list of beneficiary to the
Supervisor of social education
PS 2 CDPO
2 After scrutinizing Supervisor send the list to the CDPO Department
supervisor
2 CDPO
3 CDPO send list to Director of Social education CDPO 2 Director of Social Education Department
4.7.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
Service Delivery Time
Time required for registering for Pension. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the Pension
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• New application for Pension • Pension to old pensioner
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 101 of 228
4.8. Service 8: Application for Schedule Caste Cer tificate Application for caste certificate is issued by the SDM, however applicant need to endorsed the application from the Gram Pradhan After endorsing
the application he submit it to SDM office for internal processing , SDM office send the application to SC Committee at Panchayat Samiti level, BDO
act as a convener and Secretary of committee. The committee scrutinize the application and if find suitable send it to SDM with its
recommendation, as a final point SDM approve it and issue the certificate to the applicant.
4.8.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Schedule Caste C ertificate Snapshot Name of service
Scheduled Caste Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste Certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 102 of 228
4.8.1.1. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Ste
p Activity Channel Documents involved Mode Responsibilit
y Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Citizen fill the application
form and get it endorsed by the Gram Pradhan
Gram Panchayat
Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form at SDM office
SDM office
Gram Pradhan Endorsement on
Application
Age Certificate
Caste certificate of Father
PRT Certificate Copy of ROR
Manual Citizen Citizen Have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. SDM office Send the Application to the SC Committee for Scrutiny and approval
SDM office
Gram Pradhan Endorsement on
Application
Age Certificate
Caste certificate of Father
PRT Certificate Copy of ROR
Manual SDM office Certificate Clerk
SDM office send it to Committee which is at Panchayat Samiti (Block) , it takes time and there is chance to miss the support document enclosed with application
4. SC Committee scrutinize
the application and
provide its approval
Committee at Panchayat Samiti
Manual BDO as a
Secretary
and
convener of
Committee
Committee meting
interval is not defined,
some time it take long
time
5. If SC committee find any
deficiency , BDO as a
secretary of committee
inform the Panchayat
secretary of the applicant
village about the
particular deficiency
Panchay
at Samiti
and
Gram
Panchay
at
Manual BDO it take time , as it
depend on visit of PS
at BDO office.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 103 of 228
Improvement Opportunities Step
Activity Channel Documents involved Mode Responsibility
Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
6. PS inform the applicant
about the deficiency in the
application
Gram
Panchay
at
Manual Panchayat
Secretary
Due to work schedule,
PS is reluctant to give
such type of
information to citizen.
7. BDO send the approved
application to SDM office
for the signature and
dispatch
Panchay
at Samiti
office
Approved applications manual BDO
8. SDM certificate division
dispatch the Certificate
SDM office
Caste Certificate Manual SDM Applicant visit again
and again to track the
certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 104 of 228
4.8.1.2. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 105 of 228
4.8.1.3. 5.8.2 To Be: Process Narration: Schedule Caste Certificate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Caste Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens SDM, Committee
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 2 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Caste register
Documents Involved
Registers o Caste register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 106 of 228
4.8.1.4. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by
filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service
and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating his
biometric identity to the system.
On line Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section on
the application.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
5. Application check the caste register databse about the applicant status if it is available PS
would send it to SDM for re issuance of copy of Caste certificate
Online Panchayat Secretary
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
Online Panchayat Secretary
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of the
applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
Online Panchayat
Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to
verify the details mentioned on it.
Manual Panchayat
Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed
form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant
agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat
Secretary
DAY 1
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it
or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies of any
required documents
GP
Manual Applicant
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI
application-GP
Online Panchayat
Secretary
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the Gram
e-PRI Online
SAME DAY
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 107 of 228
** interval between Committee meeting is not included
Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database. application-GP
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and
generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI
application-GP
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat
Secretary
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application
GP Manual Panchayat
Secretary
16. If it is not issued previously , Check the supporting document and attach it for SDM office
validation. (Scanned attachment is depend on bandwidth of network otherwise it would be
send manually)
e-PRI
application-GP
Comput
erize/Ma
nual
Panchayat
Secretary
17. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP Manual Panchayat
Secretary
18. SDM office validate it and Send to Committee at Block level
( if bandwidth support scanned document send it online otherwise send manually)
SDM Manual/
Online
SDM office Day 2
19. Committee check the application and if there is any discrepancy send it respective
Panchayat
SDM Office Online BDO
20. If committee is satisfied , recommend SDM to issue the certificate SDM Office Online BDO
Day 3**
21. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI
application-SDM
Online SDM
22. After issuance the certificate it would save on Caste register database e-PRI
application
Online SDM office
23. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI
application-GP
Day 5
24. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with
the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Panchayat
Secretary
Day 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 108 of 228
4.8.1.5. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 109 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
This section should include Pre requisites or dependencies required, if any for the functioning of the process Centralized Caste certificate Database
at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application Block level committee meting interval, which is held ones in month. Legal Changes
Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the
digital form � Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended, here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates. Recommendations & Impact
Objectives
O1 – Transparency & Accountability
O2 – Improved Decision Making
O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens
O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs)
O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online form on his
behalf.
√
If entry is already in Caste certificate database , PS directly send it to SDM for issuance of certificate otherwise √ √ √
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by the
applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of credentials √ √ √ √ √
Details send to BDO office for further committee approval, committee may require further verification or supporting document
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 110 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
committee can send online notice to respective Panchayat
If committee approve the application , online send it to SDM for issuing the certificate . SDM digitally sign the certificate and send it to
respective GP
√ √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the manual
signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM , on this regard legal transformation is
required .
√ √ √
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit the e form
however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression would be
send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √ √
4.8.1.6. Expected MIS / Reports Sr. No. Name of Report Description
1. Monthly Report Number of applicant and certificate issued BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 111 of 228
4.8.1.7. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Center
No. of Days Designation
1 PS send the application to SDM SDM 1 SDM certificate Desk
2 SDM send it to block level Committee approval BDO 15* SDM
*Committee meeting held ones in a month.
4.8.1.8. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time Time required for registering a Certificate. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the copy of RoR
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• Block level Committee meting interval
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 112 of 228
4.9. Service 9: Application for Schedule Tribe Cert ificate Application for caste certificate is issued by the SDM, however applicant need to endorsed the application from the Gram Pradhan. After endorsing
the application he submit it to SDM office for internal processing , SDM office send the application to ST Committee at Panchayat Samiti level, BDO
act as a convener and Secretary of committee. The committee scrutinizes the application and if find suitable send it to SDM with its
recommendation, as a final point SDM approve it and issue the certificate to the applicant
4.9.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Scheduled Trib e Certificate Snapshot Name of service
Scheduled Tribe Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.) Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output � Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste Certificate
Service Delivery Time Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 113 of 228
4.9.1.2. As-Is Activity description
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1. Citizen fill the application form and get it endorsed by the Gram Pradhan
Gram Panchayat Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form at SDM office
SDM office Gram Pradhan
Endorsement
on Application
Age Certificate
Caste certificate
of Father
PRT Certificate
Copy of ROR
Manual Citizen Citzen Have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. SDM office Send the Application to the ST Committee for Scrutiny and approval
SDM office
Gram Pradhan
Endorsement
on Application
Age Certificate
Caste certificate
of Father
PRT Certificate
Copy of ROR
Manual SDM office Certificate Clerk
SDM office send it to Committee which is at Panchayat Samiti (Block) , it takes time and there is chance to miss the support document enclosed with application
4. ST Committee scrutinize the application and provide its approval
Committee at Panchayat Samiti
Manual BDO as a Secretary and convener of Committee
Committee meting interval is not defined, some time it take long time
5. If committee find any deficiency , BDO as a secretary of committee inform the Panchayat
Panchayat Samiti and Gram Panchayat
Manual BDO it take time , as it depend on visit of PS at BDO office.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 114 of 228
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
secretary of the applicant village about the particular deficiency
6. PS inform the applicant about the deficiency in the application
Gram Panchayat Manual Panchayat Secretary
Due to work schedule, PS is reluctant to give such type of information to citizen.
7. BDO send the approved application to SDM office for the signature and dispatch
Panchayat Samiti office
Approved applications
manual BDO
8. SDM certificate division dispatch the Certificate
SDM office Caste Certificate
Manual SDM Applicant visit again and again to track the certificate
SMS Alert
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 115 of 228
4.9.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 116 of 228
4.9.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Scheduled Tribe Certificate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Caste Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens SDM, Committee
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 2 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Caste register
Documents Involved
Registers o Caste register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 117 of 228
4.9.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by
filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular
service and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s
behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
On line Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section
on the application.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
5. Application check the caste register databse about the applicant status if it is available
PS would send it to SDM for re issuance of copy of Caste certificate
Online Panchayat Secretary
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
Online Panchayat Secretary
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph
of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
Online Panchayat Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant
to verify the details mentioned on it.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the
Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the
Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs
on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies
of any required documents
GP
Manual Applicant
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 118 of 228
** Committee meeting time schedule is not included
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
Online Panchayat Secretary
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the
Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
Online
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and
generates a receipt for the Applicant
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
Manual Panchayat Secretary
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application Manual Panchayat Secretary
16. If it is not issued previously, Check the supporting document and attach it for SDM office validation.
SDM
Computerize/Manual
Panchayat Secretary
17. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP office Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 2
18. SDM office validate it and Send to Committee at Block level (if bandwidth support scanned document send it online otherwise send manually)
SDM Manual/Online
SDM office Day 3
19. Committee check the application and if there is any discrepancy send it respective Panchayat
SDM Office Online BDO
20. If committee is satisfied , recommend SDM to issue the certificate SDM Office Online BDO
21. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI application-SDM
Online SDM Day 5
22. After issuance the certificate it would save on Caste register database e-PRI application
Online SDM office
23. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application-SDM
Online
24. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 119 of 228
4.9.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 120 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
This section should include Pre requisites or dependencies required, if any for the functioning of the process Centralized Caste certificate Database
at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application Block level committee meting interval , which is held ones in month .
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill
the online form on his behalf.
√
If entry is already in Caste certificate database , PS directly send it to SDM for issuance of certificate
otherwise
√ √ √
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e
signed the application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of
applicant on it and send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 121 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
verification of credentials
Details send to BDO office for further committee approval, committee may require further verification or
supporting document committee can send online notice to respective Panchayat
√ √ √
If committee approve the application , online send it to SDM for issuing the certificate . SDM digitally sign
the certificate and send it to respective GP
√ √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document
can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document
and make the manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM , on this
regard legal transformation is required .
√ √ √
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be
use to submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with
manual signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 122 of 228
4.9.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1. Monthly report Monthly report of certificate issued and application received
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department.
4.9.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 S.
No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 PS send the application to SDM PS 2 SDM
2 BDO send it to SDM after block level Committee approval
BDO 2 SDM
*Committee meeting held ones in a month.
4.9.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependencie s
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for registering a Certificate. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the copy of RoR
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• Block level Committee meting interval
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 123 of 228
4.10. Service 10: Application for OBC Certificate Application for caste certificate is issued by the SDM, however applicant need to endorsed the application from the Gram Pradhan. After endorsing
the application he submit it to SDM office for internal processing , SDM office send the application to OBC Committee at Panchayat Samiti level,
BDO act as a convener and Secretary of committee. The committee scrutinizes the application and if find suitable send it to SDM with its
recommendation, as a final point SDM approve it and issue the certificate to the applicant.
4.10.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: OBC Certifica te Snapshot Name of service
OBC Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste Certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Documents Involved Registers Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 124 of 228
4.10.1.2. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Citizen fill the
application form and get it endorsed by the Gram Pradhan
Gram Panchayat Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form at SDM office
SDM office Gram Pradhan
Endorsement
on Application
Age Certificate
Caste
certificate of
Father
PRT Certificate
Copy of ROR
Manual Citizen Citzen Have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. SDM office Send the Application to the OBC Committee for Scrutiny and approval
SDM office
Gram Pradhan
Endorsement
on Application
Age Certificate
Caste
certificate of
Father
PRT Certificate
Copy of ROR
Manual SDM office Certificate Clerk
SDM office send it to Committee which is at Panchayat Samiti (Block) , it takes time and there is chance to miss the support document enclosed with application
4. OBC Committee scrutinize the application and
Committee at Panchayat Samiti
Manual BDO as a Secretary and convener of
Committee meting interval is not
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 125 of 228
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
provide its approval
Committee defined, some time it take long time
5. If OBC committee find any deficiency , BDO as a secretary of committee inform the Panchayat secretary of the applicant village about the particular deficiency
Panchayat Samiti and Gram Panchayat
Manual BDO it take time , as it depend on visit of PS at BDO office.
6. PS inform the applicant about the deficiency in the application
Gram Panchayat Manual Panchayat Secretary
Due to work schedule, PS is reluctant to give such type of information to citizen.
7. BDO send the approved application to SDM office for the signature and dispatch
Panchayat Samiti office
Approved applications
manual BDO
8. SDM certificate division dispatch the Certificate
SDM office Caste Certificate
Manual SDM Applicant visit again and again to track the certificate
SMS Alert
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 126 of 228
4.10.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 127 of 228
4.10.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: OBC Certificate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Caste Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens SDM, Committee
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Gram Pradhan Endorsement on Application � Age Certificate � Caste certificate of Father � PRT Certificate � Copy of ROR
o Caste certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 2 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Caste register
Documents Involved
Registers o Caste register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 128 of 228
4.10.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either by
filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service
and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating
his biometric identity to the system.
On line Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section
on the application.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
5. Application check the caste register databse about the applicant status if it is available PS
would send it to SDM for re issuance of copy of Caste certificate
Online Panchayat Secretary
6. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
Online Panchayat Secretary
7. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of
the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
Online Panchayat Secretary
8. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to
verify the details mentioned on it.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
9. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the Printed
form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant
agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
10. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it
or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies of any
required documents
Manual Applicant
11. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 129 of 228
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
12. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the
Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
Online
13. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and
generates a receipt for the Applicant
Online
14. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
Manual Panchayat Secretary
15. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application Manual Panchayat Secretary
16. If it is not issued previously, Check the supporting document and attach it for SDM office validation. ( Scanned attachment is depend on bandwidth of network otherwise it would be send manually)
SDM
Computerize/Manual
Panchayat Secretary
17. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP office Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 2
18. SDM office validate it and Send to Committee at Block level ( if bandwidth support scanned document send it online otherwise send manually)
SDM Manual/Online
SDM office Day 3
19. Committee check the application and if there is any discrepancy send it respective Panchayat
SDM Office
Online BDO
20. If committee is satisfied , recommend SDM to issue the certificate SDM Office
Online BDO
21. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI application-SDM
Online SDM Day 5
22. After issuance the certificate it would save on Caste register database e-PRI application
Online SDM office
23. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application
Online
24. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of BDO and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 130 of 228
4.10.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 131 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
• Centralized Caste certificate Database at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application
• Block level committee meting interval, which is held ones in month.
Legal Changes
• Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended • Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. • Legal requirement of the applicant signing on the application form/ usage of Panchayat secretary digital signature for submission of the
digital form • Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended, here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
If entry is already in Caste certificate database , PS directly send it to SDM for issuance of certificate otherwise √ √ √
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the
application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and
send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials
√
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 132 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Details send to BDO office for further committee approval, committee may require further verification or supporting
document committee can send online notice to respective Panchayat
√ √ √
If committee approve the application , online send it to SDM for issuing the certificate . SDM digitally sign the
certificate and send it to respective GP
√ √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make
the manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √ √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM , on this regard legal
transformation is required .
√ √ √
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to
submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual
signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
√ √ √ √
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 133 of 228
4.10.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Monthly report Application received for the certificate and certificate provided to applicant
BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
4.10.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation
1 PS send the application to SDM SDM 2 SDM
2 BDO send it SDM after block level Committee approval BDO 2 BDO
*Committee meeting held ones in a month.
4.10.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
Service Delivery Time
Time required for registering a Certificate. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the copy of RoR
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• Block level Committee meting interval
Minutes/ Days Pradhan / GP Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 134 of 228
4.11. Service 11: Application for Income Certificat e Income certificate is issued by the SDM of respective division where applicant resides and make application, applicant have to get endorsed the
application by the respective any elected representative of his area, he submit the application with the required support documents at the SDM
office, if SDM is satisfied he issued the certificate to the applicant if he is not satisfied he verifies the application through Tehsil office or other
revenue officer.
4.11.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Income Certif icate Snapshot Name of service
Income Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output � Application (format) � Ration Card � Voter Card � PRT Card � Self declaration of Income � Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
o Income Certificate
Service Delivery Time Prescribed delivery time (if any): -- Actual delivery time: e.g. 4 weeks Documents Involved Registers Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Ration Card � Voter Card � PRT Card � Self declaration of Income � Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 135 of 228
4.11.1.2. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1 Citizen fill the
application form and get it endorsed by the MP/MLA
Citzen Application Manual Citizen
2 Citizen submit the form at SDM office
SDM office � Application Form
� Ration Card
� Voter Card � PRT Card � Self
declaration of Income
� Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
Manual Citizen Citzen Have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3 If SDM satisfied with the scrutiny of application and support document , he issue the certificate
SDM office
Income Certificate
Manual SDM Applicant have to visit Sub division to track the application and receive it
4 If SDM is not satisfied he send it to deputy collector for verification
SDM office � Application Form
� Ration Card
� Voter Card � PRT Card � Self
declaration of Income
� Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
Manual SDM Tracking of document is problematic for applicant
5 Deputy Collector send it to Revenue Inspector
SDM office � Application Form
Manual Deputy Collector Tracking of document is
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 136 of 228
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
for verification � Ration Card
� Voter Card � PRT Card � Self
declaration of Income
� Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
problematic for applicant
7 Revenue Inspector send it to Tahsildar for verification
SDM office � Application Form
� Ration Card
� Voter Card � PRT Card � Self
declaration of Income
� Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
Manual Revenue Inspector
Tehsildar office is remotely located from the Sub division, carrying of document have different hazard. Issue of tracking the document.
8 Tehsildar send its report to SDM office
9 SDM approve the application and signature it for dispatch
Panchayat Samiti office
Approved applications
manual BDO
10 SDM certificate division dispatch the Certificate
SDM office Caste Certificate
Manual SDM Applicant visit again and again to track the certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 137 of 228
4.11.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 138 of 228
4.11.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Income Certific ate Snapshot Name of service
Issuance of Income Certificate
Process Owner
Gram Panchayat
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Panchayat Secretery, Citizens SDM, Dy Collector, Revenue Inspector, Tahsildar
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Ration Card � Voter Card � PRT Card � Self declaration of Income � Endorsement by Local MLA/MP
o Income certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): e.g. 1 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 2 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Databases o Income certificate register
Documents Involved
Registers o Income certificate register
Format o Application format
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 139 of 228
4.11.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretery. He may do this either
by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular
service and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s
behalf
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
2. The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any
Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI
application-
PS
On line Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s
section on the application.
e-PRI
application-
GP
Manual Panchayat Secretary
5. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and
assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat Secretary
6. The PS then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph
of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
7. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the
Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
8. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard the
Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the
Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
9.
The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs
on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along with copies
e-PRI
application-
Online Applicant
Day 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 140 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
of any required documents GP
10. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the
documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat Secretary
11. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the
Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
e-PRI
application
Online
12. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and
generates a receipt for the Applicant
GP Manual
13. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the
application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
14.
The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application
e-PRI
application-
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
15. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
Day 2
16. If SDM satisfied issue the certificate with his digital signature SDM Office Manual SDM
17. If not satisfied send it to Dy Collector for verification e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM
18. Dy collector validate the document and if satisfied send it to SDM otherwise send it to
Revunue Inspector for further verification
e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online DY Collector
19. If RI satisfied return it to Dy Collector e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online Revenue Inspector
20. If RI is not satisfied send it to Tahsildar for field verification e-PRI online Revenue
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 141 of 228
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
application-
SDM
Inspector
21. After field verification Tasildar submit report to SDM office SDM Office Manual Tahsildar
22. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature SDM Office Manual SDM
23. After issuance the certificate it would save on Caste register database e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM office
24. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online
25. PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of SDMand deliver it to applicant
with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat
Secretary
Day 7
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 142 of 228
4.11.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 143 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Centralized Income certificate Database at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application
Legal Changes
Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended Acceptance of standardized e-form by respective line departments. Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates. Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the
application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and
send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials.
√ √ √ √
SDM may use online medium to send the application to Dy collector and Revenue Inspector for the verification , in
case of further field verification required RI would send application manually to the concerned Tahsildar .
√ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 144 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
After verification tesildar send the verification report to SDM office manually.
SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature √ √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the
manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM, on this regard legal
transformation is required .
√
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to
submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature
or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 145 of 228
4.11.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Monthly Report Application received by the Panchayat & certificate delivered. BDO, DPO, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
4.11.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 If required SDM send it to Dy Collector and RI
verification
Dy Collector 1 DY collector 1 Revenue Inspector
2 If required RI send it to Tahsildar field verification Tahsildar 5 Tahsildar
*Committee meeting held ones in a month.
4.11.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es S.
No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of
Measurement Monitoring Authority
Service Delivery Time
Time required for registering a Certificate. This shall start from the time applicant submits the application to the PS till he get the copy of certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process. Different scenarios can also be considered like:
• Field verification by Tahsildar
Minutes/ Days SDM
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 146 of 228
4.12. Service 12: Application for Ration card
4.12.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Ration card Snapshot Name of service
Ration card
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � ROR � Marriage certificate � Old ration card (if applicable) � Birth/Death certificate
o Ration card
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 4-6 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� ROR � Marriage certificate � Old ration card (if applicable) � Birth/Death certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 147 of 228
4.12.1.2. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibi
lity Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Citizen fill the
application form. Gram Panchayat
Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form with all supporting document at GP level
PS/Pradhan ROR, Marriage certificate, Old ration card (if applicable), Birth/Death certificate,
Manual Citizen Documents can be mis-placed
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. PS/Pradhan do Scrutiny and approval through Gram Sabha resolution
PS/Pradhan
Marriage certificate, Old ration card (if applicable), Birth/Death certificate, ROR
Manual GP officials Proper verification may not be done
e-forms with the attachment of checklist for document submission can be used
Real time submission & verification the form online
Applicant, GP officials
4. SDM office verifies application & documents
SDM office Marriage certificate, Old ration card (if applicable), Birth/Death certificate, ROR Application
Manual SDM office clerks
5. Issue of Ration card by signing of SDM
SDM office Signed ration card Manual SDM
6. Collection of Ration card by the applicant
SDM office Signed ration card Manual SDM office Citizen have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Upload digitally signed ration card
Online delivery Applicant, SDM officials
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 148 of 228
4.12.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 149 of 228
4.12.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Ration card Snapshot Name of service
Ration card
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � ROR � Marriage certificate � Old ration card (if applicable) � Birth/Death certificate
o Ration card
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 4-6 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Database o Ration card Database
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� ROR � Marriage certificate � Old ration card (if applicable) � Birth/Death certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 150 of 228
4.12.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time (days)
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretary. He may do this
either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a
particular service and provided all details to the PS as he fills up the form on the
applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant DAY 1
2. The Applicant will submit the application with all supporting documents. GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The PS Would log into the system using his username and password and
authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
e-PRI
application-
PS
On line Panchayat Secretary
4. The PS will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s
section on the application. He also Verify all supporting documents attached.
e-PRI
application-
GP
Manual Panchayat Secretary
5. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form
and assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI
application
Online Panchayat Secretary
6. The PS then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the
Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
7. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS will discard
the Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the
process until the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
8. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form,
signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the PS along
with copies of any required documents
GP Manual Applicant
9. The PS on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies
of the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
e-PRI
application-
Online Panchayat Secretary
DAY 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 151 of 228
GP
10. The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details
of the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
e-PRI
application
Online
11. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office
and generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI
application
Online
12. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of
the application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
13. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual Panchayat Secretary
14. PS also attached scanned copy of the supporting documents with the
application form and send it to SDM
e-PRI
application-
GP
Online Panchayat Secretary
Day 1
15. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP Manual Panchayat Secretary Day 2
16. SDM office clerks verify all the documents and put all information in ration card
format.
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
17. If satisfied then SDM issue ration card with his digital signature. e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM
18. If not satisfied send it to Dy Collector for verification e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM clerk
19. Dy collector validate the document and if satisfied send it to SDM otherwise
send it to Revunue Inspector for further verification
e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online DY Collector
20. If RI satisfied return it to Dy Collector e-PRI
application-
online Revenue Inspector
5 day
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 152 of 228
SDM
21. If RI is not satisfied send it to Tahsildar for field verification SDM Office Manual Revenue Inspector
22. After field verification Tasildar submit report to SDM office SDM Office Manual Tahsildar
23. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM
24. After issuance the certificate it would save on Ration card database e-PRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM office
25. Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of Ration card e-PRI
application
Online
Day 7
PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of SDM and deliver it to
applicant with the formal declaration that he validated the SDM digital signature
GP Panchayat Secretary
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 153 of 228
4.12.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 154 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Centralized Ration Card Database at the BP Level having integration with the ePRI Application
Legal Changes • Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended • Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. • Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended, here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online form on his
behalf.
√
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the application by
the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and send to final authority for
approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of credentials. √ √ √ √
SDM may use online medium to send the application to Dy collector and Revenue Inspector for the verification , in case of further
field verification required RI would send application manually to the concerned Tahsildar .
√ √
After verification tesildar send the verification report to SDM office manually.
SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature. √ √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 155 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the manual
signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM , on this regard legal transformation
is required .
√
Technology
√ √ √ √ √
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to submit the e
form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature or thumb impression
would be send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √
4.12.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Monthly Report Application received by the Panchayat and Card delivered. BDO, SDM, CEO, Planning and Statistics
Department
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 156 of 228
4.12.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation
1 PS send the Application to SDM PS 2 SDM Certificate Desk 1 Revenue Inspector
2 If required RI send it to Tahsildar field
verification
Tahsildar 5 Tahsildar
*Committee meeting held ones in a month.
4.12.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a Certificate.
This shall start from the time when
applicant submits the application to the
PS till he get the copy of certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the
individual activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be
considered like:
Field verification by Tahsildar
Minutes/ Days SDM
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 157 of 228
4.13. Service 13: Application for PRCT
4.13.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: PRCT certific ate
Snapshot Name of service
PRCT certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � ROR � Ration card � Parent’s voter ID � Birth certificate
o PRCT certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 6 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� ROR � Ration card � Parent’s voter ID � Birth certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 158 of 228
4.13.1.2. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Citizens fill the
application form. SDM office
Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form with all supporting document at SDM office
Gazetted officer
ROR Ration card Parent’s voter ID Birth certificate
Manual Citizen Documents can be mis-placed
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. Gazetted officer do Scrutiny and send it to Tahesilder for verification
Gazetted officer
ROR Ration card Parent’s voter ID Birth certificate
Manual SDM officials Proper verification may not be done
e-forms with the attachment of checklist for document submission can be used
Real time submission & verification the form online
Applicant, SDM officials
4. Tahesilder verifies application & documents
SDM office
ROR Ration card Parent’s voter ID Birth certificate Application
Manual Tahesilder clerks Time consuming
Document management system
Online transfer
Tahesilder
5. Validated application & documents send to Revenue Inspector for verification
SDM office
Ration card Parent’s voter ID Birth certificate Application ROR
Manual Tahesilder Time consuming
Online transfer
Revenue Inspector
6. Validated application & documents send to Deputy collector for verification
Deputy collector office
Ration card Parent’s voter ID Birth certificate Application ROR
Manual Deputy collector Time consuming
Online transfer
Deputy collector
7. After validation by Dy. Collector, SDM sign & issue the PRCT certificate
SDM office
SDM signed PRCT certificate
Manual SDM Citizen have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Upload certificate
SDM clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 159 of 228
4.13.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 160 of 228
4.13.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: PRCT certificat e Snapshot Name of service
PRT certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � ROR � Ration card � Parent’s voter ID � Birth certificate
o PRT certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 6 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Database o PRCT Database
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� ROR � Ration card � Parent’s voter ID � Birth certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 161 of 228
4.13.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1. The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Secretary. He
may do this either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by
verbally requesting for a particular service and provided all details to
the PS as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant Day 1
2. The Applicant will submit the application with all supporting
documents.
GP Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The Gazetted officer of SDM office Would log into the system using
his username and password and authenticating his biometric identity
to the system.
e-PRI application On line Gazetted officer
4. The SDM clerk will receive the application request and select the
relevant department’s section on the application. He also Verify all
supporting documents attached.
e-PRI application-SDM
Manual SDM clerk
5. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s
Application Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
e-PRI application Online SDM clerk
6. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the PS
will discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online
form and repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the
printed copy.
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
7. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed
Application Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and
hands it back to the SDM clerk along with copies of any required
documents
e-PRI application-SDM
Manual Applicant
Day 1
8. The SDM clerk on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the e-PRI application-SDM
Online SDM clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 162 of 228
form and the copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form
and submits the same
9. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the
SDM office and generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application Online
10. The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along
with a copy of the application to the Applicant
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
11. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his
application
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
12. SDM clerk also attached scanned copy of the supporting documents
with the application form and send it to Dy. Collector
e-PRI application-SDM
Online SDM clerk
13. If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to Dy.
Collector office
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
Day 3
14. Dy. Collector mark it and send to Revenue Inspector for verification e-PRI
application-SDM
Online Dy. Collector
15. Revenue Inspector validate it and send it to Tahesilder for last
verification
e-PRI
application-SDM
Online Revenue
Inspector
16. After field verification Tasildar submit report to SDM office SDM Office Manual Tahsildar
17. SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI
application-SDM
Online SDM
18. After issuance the certificate it would save onPRCT database e-PRI application Online SDM office
19. GP receive the alert of issuance of PRCT e-PRI application Online
20. PS at GP make printout it with validation of digital signature of SDM
and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he
validated the SDM digital signature
GP Panchayat
secretary
7 day
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 163 of 228
4.13.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 164 of 228
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
PS validate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the
application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and
send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials.
√ √ √ √
SDM may use online medium to send the application to Dy collector and Revenue Inspector for the verification , in
case of further field verification required RI would send application manually to the concerned Tahsildar .
√ √
After verification tesildar send the verification report to SDM office manually .
SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature. √ √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 165 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make
the manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM, on this regard legal
transformation is required.
√
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to
submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual
signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √
4.13.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 166 of 228
S. No.
Name of Report
Description Report Users
1 Monthly Report Application received by the Panchayat and Certificate delivered to applicant. SDM, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
4.13.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation
1 PS send the Application to SDM PS 2 SDM Certificate Desk 1 Revenue Inspector
2 If required RI send it to Tahsildar field verification
and tehisildar send it to SDM desk
Tahsildar 5 SDM
4.13.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a Certificate.
This shall start from the time when applicant
submits the application to the PS till he get
the copy of certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the individual
activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered
like: Field verification by Tahsildar
Minutes/ Days SDM
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 167 of 228
4.14. Service 14: Application for Non-Creamy Layer certificate
4.14.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Non-Creamy La yer certificate Snapshot Name of service
Non-Creamy Layer certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen DM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format)
� Income certificate
� Caste certificate
o Non-Creamy layer certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 6 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Income certificate
� Caste certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 168 of 228
4.14.1.2. As-Is Activity description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People 1. Citizen writes an application
on white paper for asking Non-Creamy layer certificate.
DM office Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizens submit the application with all relevant documents to the DM office.
DM office Application, Caste certificate, Income certificate
Manual Citizen Documents can be mis-placed
Online Application or use of e-forms with the DM official’s authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
DM officials, Applicant
3. DM office verifies & validates the documents & application.
DM office Application, Caste certificate, Income certificate
Manual DM officials Proper verification may not be done
e-forms with the attachment of checklist for document submission can be used
Real time submission & verification the form online
Applicant, DM officials
4. If DM office not satisfied then reject the application.
DM office Application, Caste certificate, Income certificate
Manual DM officials
5. If SM office satisfied, then send it for DM’s signature.
SDM Application, Caste certificate, Income certificate
Manual SDM official Time consuming
Document Management System
Online transfer
DM official
6. SDM signed the application and send it to certificate section for issuing Non-Creamy layer certificate.
SDM Application, Caste certificate, Income certificate
Manual SDM Time consuming, because DM is overloaded with work
Document Management System
Online transfer
SDM
7. Certificate section issues the certificate to the applicant.
SDM SDM Non-Creamy Layer certificate
Manual Certificate section clerk
Citizen have to go to DM office which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Upload certificate
Certificate section clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 169 of 228
4.14.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 170 of 228
4.14.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Non-Creamy Laye r certificate Snapshot
Name of service
Non-Creamy Layer certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen DM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format)
� Income certificate
� Caste certificate
o Non-Creamy layer certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 6 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Database o Non-Creamy layer certificate Database
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � Income certificate
� Caste certificate
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 171 of 228
4.14.1.5. 5.14.2.1 To-Be Activity Description:
S.
No.
Activity Channel Mode Responsibility
Centre
Expected
Time (days)
Remarks
1. The Applicant submits his request to the SDM office. He may do this
either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally
requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the SDM
official as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
SDM Office Manual Citizen / Applicant NA
2. The Applicant will submit the application with all supporting documents. SDM Office Manual Citizen / Applicant
3. The SDM clerk Would log into the system using his username and
password and authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
ePRI
application-
SDM
On line SDM clerk
4. The SDM clerk will receive the application request and Verify all
supporting documents attached.
ePRI
application-
SDM
Manual SDM clerk
5. The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s
Application Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
ePRI
Application
Online SDM clerk
6. If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the SDM
clerk will discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online
form and repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the printed
copy.
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
7. The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application
Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to
the SDM clerk along with copies of any required documents
SDM Office Manual Applicant
8. The SDM clerk on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form
and the copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form and
SDM Office Online SDM clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 172 of 228
submits the same
9. The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM
office and generates a receipt for the Applicant
ePRI
application
Online
10. The SDM clerk takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along
with a copy of the application to the Applicant
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
11. The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
12. If SDM clerk satisfied with the documents then he fills up details in the
Non-creamy layer certificate format.
ePRI
application-
SDM
Online SDM clerk
13. If SDM clerk not satisfied, then forward all scanned copy of supporting
document to Tehesilder for verification.
SDM Office Manual/On
line
SDM clerk
14. Tehesilder physically verify the documents. Manual Tehesilder
15. If Tehesilder not satisfied, then he send a rejection to SDM office Manual Tehesilder
16. If Tehesilder satisfied with then he mark it back to SDM clerk
SDM Office
Manual Tehesilder
17. SDM clerk update the status of application in the system and send it for
SDM’s sign
Online Tehesilder
18. SDM digitally sign the certificate and send it to end user Online SDM
19. SDM clerk receive the alert of issuance of Non-Creamy layer certificate
ePRI application -SDM
Online
20. SDM clerk make printout it with validation of digital signature of SDM
and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he validated
the SDM digital signature
SDM Office Manual SDM clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 173 of 228
4.14.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 174 of 228
Pre-Requisite Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the
application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and
send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials.
√ √ √ √
SDM may use online medium to send the application to Dy collector and Revenue Inspector for the verification, in
case of further field verification required RI would send application manually to the concerned Tahsildar .
√ √
After verification tesildar send the verification report to SDM office manually.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 175 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature. √ √ √ √
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make the
manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM, on this regard legal
transformation is required.
√
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to
submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual signature
or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 176 of 228
4.14.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report
Description Report Users
1 Monthly Report Application received by the Panchayat and Certificate
delivered to applicant.
SDM, CEO, Planning and Statistics
Department
4.14.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of
Days Designation
1 PS send the Application to SDM PS 2 SDM Certificate Desk 2 Revenue Inspector
2 If required RI send it to Tahsildar field verification and
tehisildar send it to SDM desk
Tahsildar 5 SDM
4.14.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es
S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a
Certificate. This shall start from the time
when applicant submits the application to
the PS till he get the copy of certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the
individual activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered
like: Field verification by Tahsildar
Minutes/ Days SDM
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 177 of 228
4.15. Service 15: Application for Survivor Certific ate
4.15.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Survivor Cert ificate Snapshot Name of service
Survivor Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Death certificate � Ration card � Affidavit
o Survivor Certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --4 weeks Actual delivery time: e.g. 7 weeks
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
� Death certificate
� Ration card
� Affidavit
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 178 of 228
4.15.1.2. AS-IS activity description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1. Citizen fills the application form.
GP Application Manual Citizen
2. Citizen submit the form with all supporting document at GP office
GP Death certificate Ration card Affidavit
Manual Citizen Documents can be mis-placed
Online Application or use of e-forms with the PS authentication.
Citizens submits the form online
PS Applicant
3. Panchayet Pradhan verify the documents and return back the validated documents to citizen
GP Death certificate Ration card Affidavit
Manual Panchayet Pradhan
Proper verification may not be done
e-forms with the attachment of checklist for document submission can be used
Real time submission & verification the form online
Applicant, SDM officials
4. Tahesilder verifies application & documents
SDM office
Death certificate Ration card Affidavit Application
Manual Tahesilder Time consuming
Document management system
Online transfer Tahesilder
5. Validated application & documents send to Revenue Inspector for verification
SDM office
Death certificate Ration card Affidavit
Manual Revenue Inspector
Time consuming
Online transfer Revenue Inspector
6. Validated application & documents send to Deputy collector for verification
Deputy collector office
Death certificate Ration card Affidavit
Manual Deputy collector Time consuming
Online transfer Deputy collector
7. After validation by Dy. Collector, SDM sign & issue the Survivor certificate
SDM office
SDM signed Survivor certificate
Manual SDM Citizen have to go to Sub Division which may be 20 to 30 km from Gram Panchayat
Upload certificate
SDM clerk
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 179 of 228
4.15.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 180 of 228
4.15.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Survivor Certif icate Snapshot Name of service
Survivor Certificate
Process Owner
Citizen
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Citizen SDM
Process Input Process Output
� Application (format) � Death certificate � Ration card � Affidavit
o Survivor Certificate
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): --1 week Actual delivery time: e.g. 7 weeks
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application
Database o Survivor Certificate Database
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others � Death certificate � Ration card � Affidavit
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 181 of 228
4.15.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
S. No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre
Expected Time (days)
Remarks
1 The Applicant submits his request to the Panchayat Pradhan. He may do this either by filling out a hardcopy of the form himself or by verbally requesting for a particular service and provided all details to the Pradhan as he fills up the form on the applicant’s behalf
Manual Citizen / Applicant NA
2 The Applicant will prove his identity using any of the valid ID proofs issued by any Governmental agency, for example Voter ID card, PAN card etc.
GP
Manual Citizen / Applicant
3 The Panchayat Secretary Would log into the system using his username and password and authenticating his biometric identity to the system.
On line Panchayat Secretery
4 The Panchayat Secretary will receive the application request and select the relevant department’s section on the application.
Manual Panchayat Secretery
5 The e-PRI application would then load the requested service’s Application Form and assigns it a Unique Application number.
Online Panchayat Secretery
6 The Panchayat Secretary then fills up the online form on behalf of the applicant and takes a photograph of the applicant by a Webcam. This photo is attached to the Application Form.
e-PRI application-GP
Online Panchayat Secretery
7 The Panchayat Secretary then takes out a printout of the filled up Application form and asks the Applicant to verify the details mentioned on it.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
8 If the Applicant wants something to be changed in the form, the Panchayat Secretary will discard the Printed form and make the changes on the online form and repeat the process until the Applicant agrees with the printed copy.
Manual Panchayat Secretary
9 The Applicant, when satisfied with the contents of the printed Application Form, signs on it or puts his thumb impression on it, and hands it back to the Panchayat Secretary along with copies of any required documents
GP
Manual Applicant
10 The Panchayat Secretary on receiving a manually signed printed copy of the form and the copies of the documents, digitally signs the online form and submits the same
Online Panchayat Secretary
11 The ePRI application Imprints the Unique Application number and the ID details of the Gram Panchayat on the form and saves it in the database.
Online
12 The ePRI application then sends or forwards the Application to the SDM office and generates a receipt for the Applicant
e-PRI application-GP
Online
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 182 of 228
13 The PS takes a printout of the receipt and issues the same along with a copy of the application to the Applicant
GP Manual Panchayat Secretery
14 The Applicant receives the receipt and the printed copy of his application GP Manual Panchayat
Secretery
15 If scanned submission is not possible send it manually to SDM office GP Manual Panchayat Secretery
16 If SDM satisfied issue the certificate with his digital signature Online SDM
17 If not satisfied send it to Dy Collector for verification Online SDM
18 Dy collector validate the document and if satisfied send it to SDM otherwise send it to Revunue Inspector for further verification
Online DY Collector
19 If RI satisfied return it to Dy Collector
e-PRI application-SDM
online Revenue Inspector
20 If RI is not satisfied send it to Tahsildar for field verification Manual Revenue Inspector
21 After field verification Tasildar submit report to SDM office
SDM Office
Manual Tahsildar
22 SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature e-PRI application-SDM
Online SDM
23 After issuance the certificate it would save on survivor register database e-PRI application
Online SDM office
24 Panchayat office receive the alert of issuance of certificate e-PRI application
Online
25 PS make printout it with validation of digital signature of SDM and deliver it to applicant with the formal declaration that he validated the BDO digital signature
GP Manual Panchayat Secretery
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 183 of 228
4.15.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 184 of 228
Legal Changes
� Use of Digital Signature as per IT Act 2000 is recommended � Acceptance of standardized e form by respective line departments. � Print out of digitally signed Certificate is recommended; here Legal transformation is required as Citizen require hard copy of certificates.
Recommendations & Impact
Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives as listed
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
Applicant come to Panchayat for the service, Panchayat secretary validate the identity of applicant and fill the online
form on his behalf.
√
PS validiadate the supporting document and if electronic signature is available of the applicant , PS get e signed the
application by the applicant otherwise he get printout of the application and get manual sign of applicant on it and
send to final authority for approval.
√ √ √
As per the proposed online approval and verification process, details are checked in the database for verification of
credentials.
√ √ √ √
SDM may use online medium to send the application to Dy collector and Revenue Inspector for the verification, in
case of further field verification required RI would send application manually to the concerned Tahsildar .
√ √
After verification tesildar send the verification report to SDM office manually.
SDM issue the certificate with his digital signature. √ √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 185 of 228
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
The printed copy will have a Unique ID and a website address where the original digitally signed document can be
viewed.
Panchayat secretary should validate the authenticity of the printed copy of the digitally signed document and make
the manual signature with stamp stating the validation check.
√ √ √ √
People
Panchayat secretary should be able to validate the authenticity of applicant and submit the e form. √
Panchayat secretary should be able to deliver the certificate which is digitally signed by SDM, on this regard legal
transformation is required.
√
Technology
use of electronic signature (Biometric or other method)(as per IT Act 2008 amendment)of applicant can be use to
submit the e form however in case of not possibility to use e signature , hard copy of application with manual
signature or thumb impression would be send to signatory authority.
Incremental database and online register should be maintained. √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 186 of 228
4.15.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Monthly Report Application received by the Panchayat and Certificate
delivered to applicant.
SDM, CEO, Planning and Statistics Department
4.15.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility
Center No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
PS send the Application to SDM PS 2 SDM Certificate
Desk
2 Revenue Inspector
If required RI send it to Tahsildar field verification and
tehisildar send it to SDM desk
Tahsildar 5 SDM
4.15.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es
S. No.
KPI Name
Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service
Delivery
Time
Time required for registering a Certificate.
This shall start from the time when
applicant submits the application to the
PS till he get the copy of certificate
Sum of time taken to complete the individual
activities in the process.
Different scenarios can also be considered
like:
Field verification by Tahsildar
Minutes/ Days SDM,CEO
ZP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 187 of 228
4.16. Service 16: Telephone Bill Payment Telephone bill is the statement of charges for the usages of telephone by the citizens. Online Telephone Bill Payment would enable the payment of bills at Gram Panchayat level.
4.16.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Telephone Bil l Payment Snapshot Name of service
Telephone Bill Payment
Process Owner
BSNL Office
Primary Actors Secondary Actors
Citizens BSNL Office
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Transaction Charge / Cost – amount as per telephone bill
o Supporting document : Telephone Bill
o Receipt of Bill Payment
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time : 1 Day Actual delivery time: 1 Day
Documents Involved
Format o Telephone Bill
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 188 of 228
4.16.1.2. As-Is Activity Description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People
1 Citizen travels to BSNL office for Payment of Bill
BSNL office
Telephone Bill
Manual Citizen Citizen travel to BSNL office
Online Application
Citizens Pays the Bill online
2 BSNL verifies the bill and amount paid
BSNL office
Telephone Bill Manual BSNL office
Bill might get tampered or lost
online payment mechanism
officer receives the payment online
Training
3 Issue Receipt for bill payment and updates in computer
BSNL office
Receipt for bill payment
Manual/ Electronic
BSNL office Delays, Skill Level
Generation of payment receipt online
Training
4 Citizen collects the receipt for payment
BSNL Office
Receipt for bill payment
Manual Citizen
Citizen travel from BSNL office back to his village
Citizen receives the receipt at GP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 189 of 228
4.16.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 190 of 228
4.16.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Telephone Bill Payment Snapshot Name of Service
Telephone Bill Payment
Process Owner
GP
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Gram Panchayat office, Citizen BSNL
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Transaction Charge / Cost : Amount mentioned in the bill +
service charge (as decided by PRI and BSNL)
Receipt for bill payment
Service Delivery Time
Actual delivery time : 1 Day Proposed delivery time: 1 Day
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Telephone Bill
Documents Involved
Format o Telephone Bill
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 191 of 228
4.16.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time Remarks
1 Citizen approaches the Gram Panchayat officewith telephone bill and the amount that is to be paid
GP Manual Citizen
2 Gram Panchayat officeaccepts payment against the bills makes payment online through his account
GP Manual Gram Panchayat office
3 ePRI application generates a receipt for the bill payment
ePRI Application Online Gram Panchayat office
4 Citizen collects the receipt against the bill paid
GP Manual Citizen
1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 192 of 228
4.16.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
Chh
attis
gar
h, B
SN
Le-
PR
I A
ppl
ica
tion
App
lican
t
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 193 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Pre requisites or dependencies required for the functioning of the process are: 1. ePRI application should have integration with BSNL office for acceptance of telephone Bills paymnet at GP level
Legal Changes
Legal changes that need to be taken are: 1. Gram Panchayat officeshould be authorized to collect payment against telephone bills online.
Key Recommendations
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives listed Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process 1. The automated system of payment acceptance and receipt generation can significantly improve the service delivery √
People Technology Integration of bill payment mechanism of BSNL with ePRI application √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 194 of 228
4.16.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports The following MIS reports are expected to be generated: S. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Payment of telephone bills per week/month
This report shall provide information on acceptance of payment against the bills for a given week/month in each Gram Panchayat
PS, CEO JP, BSNL circle officer
4.16.1.8. Escalation Matrix
4.16.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of
Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for delivery of service from the time an application is registered in the system
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process Days CEO ZP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 195 of 228
4.17. Service 17: Electricity Bill Payment Electricity bill is the statement of charges for the usages of electricity in the household connection by the citizens. Online Electricity Bill Payment would enable the payment of bills at Gram Panchayat level.
4.17.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Electricity B ill Payment Snapshot Name of service Electricity Bill Payment
Process Owner
TSEB Office
Primary Actors Secondary Actors
Citizens TSEB Office
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Transaction Charge / Cost – amount as per telephone bill
o Supporting document : Electricity Bill
o Receipt of Bill Payment
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time: 1 Day Actual delivery time: 1 Day
Documents Involved
Format o Electricity Bill
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 196 of 228
4.17.1.2. As-Is Activity Description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues
Technology Process People
1
Citizen travels to TSEB office for Payment of Bill
TSEB office
Electricity Bill
Manual Citizen Citizen travel to TSEB office
Online Application
Citizens Pays the Bill online
2 TSEB verifies the bill and amount paid
TSEB office
Electricity Bill
Manual TSEB office Bill might get tampered or lost
online payment mechanism
officer receives the payment online
Training
3
Issue Receipt for bill payment and updates in computer
TSEB office
Receipt for bill payment
Manual/ Electronic TSEB office
Delays, Skill Level
Generation of payment receipt online
Training
4
Citizen collects the receipt for payment
TSEB Office
Receipt for bill payment
Manual Citizen
Citizen travel from TSEB office back to his village
Citizen receives the receipt at GP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 197 of 228
4.17.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 198 of 228
4.17.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Electricity Bil l Payment Snapshot
Name of Service
Electricity Bill Payment
Process Owner
GP
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
Gram Panchayat office, Citizen TSEB
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Transaction Charge / Cost : Amount mentioned in the bill + service
charge (as decided by PRI and TSEB)
Receipt for bill payment
Service Delivery Time
Actual delivery time : 1 Day Proposed delivery time: 1 Day
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Electricity Bill
Documents Involved
Format o Electricity Bill
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 199 of 228
4.17.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time Remarks
1 Citizen approaches the Gram Panchayat officewith electricity bill and the amount that is to be paid
GP Manual Citizen
2 Gram Panchayat office accepts payment against the bills makes payment online through his account
GP Manual Gram Panchayat office
3 ePRI application generates a receipt for the bill payment
ePRI Application Online Gram Panchayat office
4 Citizen collects the receipt against the bill paid
GP Manual Citizen
1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 200 of 228
4.17.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 201 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Pre requisites or dependencies required for the fun ctioning of the process are : 1 ePRI application should have integration with TSEB office for acceptance of electricity Bills payments at GP level
Legal Changes
Legal changes that need to be taken are: 1. Gram Panchayat officeshould be authorized to collect payment against electricity bills and generate receipt of payment. Key Recommendations
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives listed Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process 1. The automated system of payment acceptance and receipt generation can significantly improve the service delivery
√
People Technology Integration of bill payment mechanism of TSEB with ePRI application √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 202 of 228
4.17.1.7. 5.17.2.3 Expected MIS / Reports The following MIS reports are expected to be generated:
S. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Payment of Electricity bills per week/month
This report shall provide information on acceptance of payment against the bills for a given week/month in each Gram Panchayat
PS, CEO ZP, TSEB
4.17.1.8. 5.17.2.4 Escalation matrix
4.17.1.9. 5.17.2.5 KPI, Critical Success Factors, D ependencies
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for delivery of service from the time an application is registered in the system
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process Days EO-PS, CEO ZP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 203 of 228
4.18. Service 18: Application for Land Records Cop y Citizen gets copy of Khatiyan as a part of computerized land records -
4.18.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Land Records Copy Snapshot
Name of service
Issuance of Land Record- Map
Process Owner
Tehsildar
Primary Actors Secondary Actors
Citizens RI, Dy. collector
Process Input Process Output
o Application,
o Supporting document
o Land Record-Map
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): Actual delivery time: 7 days
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application form
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others o Name of Village and Name of Owner of Land
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 204 of 228
4.18.1.2. As-Is Activity Description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1. Citizen Fills up the hardcopy application form
At Tehsil Office,
Application form
Manual Citizen Online Application
Citizens submits the form online
2. Tehsildar Receives the form physically
At Tehsil Office,
Application form
Manual Tehsildar, Form might get tampered or lost
Workflow would enable transfer of application directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
3. Verifies the details of the applicant
At Tehsil Office,
Application form
Manual Tehsildar
4. If the map is available with Tahsildar he takes the print and gives to the applicant otherwise he goes to SDM revenue office to bring the copy of map
Tehsil Application form
Manual Tehsildar Delay
5. Tehsil clerk marks to Revenue Inspector for approval
Tehsil Application form
Manual Tehsil Clerk Delay Online process to mark to Tehsildar
6. Dy Collector approves the application and marks to Tehsildar
Tehsil Application form
manual Dy Collector Delay Online approval process
7. Preparation of Certificate from computer section by Dy collector office
At Tehsil Land Record- Map
Manual Tehsil Clerk Delays, Skill Level
Training
8. Citizen collects the certificate
At Tehsil Land Record- Map
Manual Citizen Delays
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 205 of 228
4.18.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
Process: Application for Map
Rev
enu
e In
spe
cto
rD
Y C
ollec
tor
Co
mp
ute
r S
ecti
on
Cit
izen
Dy Collector Receives Physical Copy of the Form
Fill Manual Application Form and Submitted to
Tehsil office/ Patwari-GP
RI Receives application for
khatiyan
Stop
Collects the kahtiyan
Validated Document
Start
Validated the application and required Form
Takes the print of requested
Approves the application and marks to computer section
for issue of Map
Sign on khatiyan
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 206 of 228
4.18.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Land Records Co py Snapshot
Name of service
Issuance of Land records- khatiyan
Process Owner
Tehsildar
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line deptts.)
Dy Collector,RI,Citizens
Process Input Process Output
o Application, o Transaction Charge / Cost
o Land record copy
Service Delivery Time
Actual delivery time (if any): 5 Days Proposed delivery time: 2 Days
Application and Databases Involved
Automated Components, systems, applications o Application form
Databases o Land records
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application format (may be application on plain paper)
Supporting Documents
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 207 of 228
4.18.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time Remarks
1 Approach Gram Panchayat officefor the copy of map and fill manual form GP Manual
Citizen
2
Receives the manual application form GP Manual
Gram Panchayat office
3
Gram Panchayat officefills in the online application form for the certificate and generates a receipt for the application
ePRI Application Manual
Gram Panchayat office
1
4
Dy Collector receives the alert for new application
ePRI Application Online
Dory collect
5
Check the Land records database for requested application
Land records DB online
Dy Collector
6
If the details are found he digitally signs a copy of the map
ePRI Application Online
Dy Collector
6(a)
Dy Collector sends the digitally signed ma p to the ePRI application
ePRI Application Online
Dy Collector
5
6(b)
System generates the print of the map ePRI Application Online
Gram Panchayat office
1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 208 of 228
Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time Remarks
6(c)
Gram Panchayat officesigns the printed certificate
GP Manual
Gram Panchayat office
6(d)
Citizen collects the Certificate GP Manual
Citizen
7
If the details are not found he rejects the application as per the rejection component
ePRI Application Online
Dy Collector
8
System generates a rejection report ePRI Application Online
Gram Panchayat office
9
Citizen collects the Certificate GP Manual
Citizen
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 209 of 228
4.18.1.6. To – Be: Process Map:
Process: Application for Map
Ta
hs
ild
ar/
Re
ve
nu
e I
ns
pe
cto
r E
-PR
I A
pp
lica
tio
nA
pp
lic
an
t
ePRI application provides a print of
the map
Payment component
approves the application online using digital sign as per
Approval Component
Form Availability component
Rejects the application online using digital sign as per Rejection Component
Receives the application
Start
Land Record DB
Application Receipt
component
System checks the land record database
System registers the application and issues a Receipt
Stop
Status Tracking Component
Receives the reason for rejection
Collects the copy of map
System saves the rejection in a DB and notifies the applicant
Checks the Land Record DB for the
requested map
Details Found? yes
no
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 210 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies Pre requisites or dependencies required for the functioning of the process are: 1. access of ePRI application to the Dy Collector 2. availability of Digitized land records with the Dy Collector
Legal Changes
Legal changes that need to be taken are: 1. Gram Panchayat officeshould be authorized to verify the digital signature on the certificate issued. 2. Gram Panchayat officewould be authorized to sign and stamp the certificate generated from the system.
Key Recommendations
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives listed Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Objectives Recommendations
O1 O2 O3 O4 O5 Process 1. The automated system of certificate delivery can significantly improve the service delivery √ 2. Availability of digitalized land records with the Dy Collector can help reproducing the copy of the Maps at the GP level whenever needed
√ √
People Dy Collector can easily provide a copy of the certificate at the GP level if centralized Database for land records are maintained
√
Technology Integration of land records with ePRI application √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 211 of 228
4.18.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports
The following MIS reports are expected to be generated: Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Copy of maps issued per month This report shall provide information on copy of maps issued for a given month in each Gram Panchayat and at the tehsil level
Dy Collector, Dy Collector, SDM
4.18.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Centre
No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 Tehsildar does physical verification to confirm the details given by the applicant
Tehsildar 6 Tehsildar 13 SDM
4.18.1.9. KPI, Critical Success Factors, Dependenci es S.N. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement Monitoring
Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for delivery of service from the time an application for certificate is registered in the system
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process
Days Tehsildar, SDM
2 No of escalation This would measure the escalations during the service delivery
Total number of escalations for a Tehsildar
Number of escalations per month
Tehsildar, SDM
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 212 of 228
4.19. Service 19: Application for RTI
The right to information imposes a positive duty on government to disseminate information to the people and extends the right for people to seek and
receive information held by government bodies (and some information from private bodies). Generally, information is disclosed to the public in two
different ways:
(a) Proactively: Government bodies are required to actively publish and disseminate key categories of information which are of general interest to the
public, such as their organizational structure, the services they provide, important forms, decision making procedures and the like. This information can
be disclosed, for example, by putting up notices and information on notice boards, publishing information in the official gazette, by reading out
information in meetings or publishing documents on the internet.
(b) Upon request: Government bodies must put in place simple, timely and cheap procedures to facilitate access to specific pieces of information upon
request. Most commonly, specific officials within public bodies are given the responsibility for handling requests and providing information.
In order to facilitate accountability at the panchayat level, in 1997 the Government of India issued a circular stating that each State should consider
passing orders implementing three different aspects of transparency in local governance. First, PRIs, especially Gram Panchayats, should display all
vital information pertaining to development projects (especially receipt of funds and how they are being spent) in panchayat offices or on a prominent
board outside the local school. Second, all relevant records should be open to inspection. Third, members of the public should be able to obtain
photocopies of documents pertaining to development projects (including all bills, muster rolls, vouchers, estimates, measurement books, the criterion
and procedures for selection of beneficiaries and lists of beneficiaries), as well as matters of general public interest, on payment of a nominal charge.
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 213 of 228
4.19.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: Application f or RTI Snapshot
Name of service
Application for RTI
Process Owner
ZP,BP , GP
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
ZP Officials ,BP Officials, GP Officials, Citizens
Process Input Process Output
o Application: Application for RTI o Transaction Charge / Cost
1. Rs.0/ for BPL citizen 2. Rs. 10/- for non BPL citizen 3. Rs.2 / - per page for A3 & A4 size paper and
actual cost for bigger size paper 4. Rs 50/- per CD
o Information in form of Documents
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): 30 days Actual delivery time: 30 Days
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application form
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 214 of 228
4.19.1.2. As-Is Activity Description:
Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents involved
Mode Responsibility Gaps / Issues Technology Process People
1 Citizen fills the form for RTI
At GP • Application
form
Manual Sarpanch, Panchayat Secretary, Karmi
Online Application
Citizens submits the form online
2 GP officials verifies the form provides information if available or sends to Janpad
At GP • Application
form
Manual BDO,rpanch,
Form might get tampered or lost
Workflow would enable transfer of application directly to the concerned approving authority
GP officer receives the application online
3 BP officials verifies the form provides information if available or sends to ZP
At BP • Application
form
Manual BDO CEOZP
Form might get tampered or lost, delay skill level
Workflow would enable transfer of application directly to the concerned approving authority
BP officer receives the application online
Training
4 ZP officials verifies the form provides information if available
At ZP • Application
form
Manual BDO EO CEO ZP
Form might get tampered or lost, delay skill level
Workflow would enable transfer of application directly to the concerned approving authority
ZP officer receives the application online
Training
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 215 of 228
4.19.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 216 of 228
4.19.1.4. To-Be: Process Narration: Application for RTI Snapshot
Name of service
Application for RTI
Process Owner
ZP,BP , GP
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
ZP Officials ,BP Officials, GP Officials, Citizens
Process Input Process Output
o Application: Application for RTI
o Transaction Charge / Cost
1. Rs.0/ for BPL citizen
2. Rs. 10/- for non BPL citizen
3. Rs.2 / - per page for A3 & A4 size paper and actual cost for bigger size paper
4. Rs 50/- per CD
o Information in form of Documents
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): 30 days Actual delivery time: 32 Days
Documents Involved
Format o Application form
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 217 of 228
4.19.1.5. To-Be Activity Description: Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected
Time 1 Citizen approaches the GP and submits application for RTI GP Manual Citizen
2 Operator Receives the manual application form GP Manual Gram Panchayat office
3 Gram Panchayat officefills the application online ePRI Application Online Gram Panchayat office
1
4 PIO receives the applications online ePRI Application Online PIO
5
PIO checks if the application is for his dept? if the application is not
meant for his dept. he routes it to RTI cell ePRI Application Online PIO
6
If the application is for his dept., PIO check if the application is as per
RTI act otherwise rejects the application ePRI Application Online PIO
7 PIO marks to APIO for release of information ePRI Application Online APIO
8 APIO prepares information copy and report APIO Manual APIO
9
If the information is for one page APIO uploads the scanned copy
and update the system for the availability and release of information ePRI Application Manual APIO
10
If the information is more than one page APIO send information to
the citizen regarding the same through the status tracking
mechanism
ePRI Application online APIO
30
11
Citizen checks the status. If information demanded is in one page,
he takes the information from the GP using the ePRI application at
GP. If information is above one page he travel to respective dept to
collect information
ePRI Application Manual Citizen 1
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 218 of 228
4.19.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 219 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies
Pre requisites or dependencies required for the functioning of the process are: 1 Integration of RTI process flow through ePRI application
Legal Changes
Legal changes that need to be taken are: 1 ePRI Opearator should be authorized to accept application for RTI and payment as per need.
2 Gram Panchayat officewould be authorized to sign and stamp the documents generated from the system.
Key Recommendations
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives listed Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process
1. The automated system of application acceptance and receipt generation can significantly improve the service delivery
√
Technology
Integration of ePRI application of acceptance of application and release of information √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 220 of 228
4.19.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports The following MIS reports are expected to be generated: Sr. No. Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Application RTI per month This report shall provide information on application of RTI for a given month in each Gram Panchayat
PS,EO PS. CEO,ZP
4.19.1.8. Escalation matrix
Level 1 Level 2
S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Centre
No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 APIO provides the requested information APIO, 31 EO PS 38 EP PS
4.19.1.9. KPI, critical success factors, Dependenc ies
S. No. KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for delivery of service from the time an application for certificate is registered in the system
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process
Days EO PS, CEO ZP
2 No of escalation This would measure the escalations during the service delivery
Total number of escalations for a tehsil Number of escalations per month
EO-PS, CEO ZP
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 221 of 228
4.20. Service 20: NREGS – Application for Job Card, Demand for work The NREG Act 2005 provides enhancement of livelihood security, giving at least 100 days of guaranteed wage employment in every financial year to every household, whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work.
4.20.1.1. As – Is: Process Narration: NREGS- Job Ca rd & Demand of Work
Snapshot Name of service NREGS- Job Card & Demand of Work Process Owner
BP , GP
Primary Actors (PR Officials, Citizens, etc.) Secondary Actors (Non – PR, Other Agencies if any, Line depts.)
BP Officials, GP Officials, Citizens Bank
Process Input Process Output
o Application: 1. Form for Issue of Job Card 2. Form for demand of work
o Transaction Charge / Cost Rs.0 / -
o Job Card o Salary for work done
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): 15 days Actual delivery time: 15-20 days for Job Card & 15 days for demand of work
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application form
Legal documents (if service is mandated)
Others
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 222 of 228
4.20.1.2. As-Is Activity Description Improvement Opportunities Step Activity Channel Documents
involved Mode Responsibility Gaps /
Issues Technology Process People 1 Citizen applies for the following at
GP 1. Form for Issue of Job Card 2. Form for demand of work
At GP • Application form
Manual Sarpanch, Panchayat Secretary, Rojgaar Sahayak
Online Application
Citizens submits the form online
2 Rozgar Sahayak collects all the form and supporting documents and brings to PO at PS
• Application form
• Supporting Documents
Manual Rozgar Sahayak Online application sending
3 PO verifies the form and updates in database
At PS • Application form-Job Card
• Form for Demand for work
Manual/Online
PO NERGA Form might get tampered or lost
Workflow would enable transfer of application directly to the concerned approving authority
officer receives the application online
4 PO does 1. Issue of Job Card for applicant 2. Allotment of work to Job card owner
At PS • Job Card Manual/Online
CEO, Janpad PO NERGA
Delays, Skill Level
Training
5 Rozgar Sahayak collect the job card for the applicant from the JP offie
At PS • Job Card Manual Rozgar Sahayak Delays, Skill Level
6 Rozgar Sahayak distributes the Job Card to the citizens
At GP • Job Card Manual Rozgar Sahayak Delays, Skill Level
7 Muster creation at GP At GP Muster for NREGA
manual Sarpanch, Panchayat Secretary, Rojgaar Sahayak
Daily entry of muster at GP
Online muster filling
training
8 1.Verification of Muster submitted by Rojgaar Sahayak 2. Release of salary for job done by beneficiaries
BP ,Bank Cheque/ ECS
CEO, Janpad PO NERGA
Verification report submission for release of salary
online verification
Training
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 223 of 228
4.20.1.3. As-Is Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 224 of 228
4.20.1.4. To Be: Process Narration: NREGS- Job Card & Demand of Work Snapshot
Name of service
NREGS- Job Card & Demand of Work
Process Owner
JP , GP
Primary Actors Secondary Actors
PS, PO, Citizens Bank
Process Input Process Output
o Application: 1. Form for Issue of Job Card 2. Form for demand of work o Transaction Charge / Cost
o Job Card o Salary for work done
Service Delivery Time
Prescribed delivery time (if any): 20 days Actual delivery time: 16 days for Job Card & 15 days for demand of work
Documents Involved
Registers
Format o Application form
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 225 of 228
4.20.1.5. To-Be Activity Description:
Activity No. Activity Channel Mode Responsibility Centre Expected Time
1
Citizen applies for the following at GP 1. Form for Issue of Job Card 2. Form for demand of work
GP Manual Citizen
2
Rozgar Sahayak collects all the form and supporting documents fills the details at GP through ePRI application and sends the documents to PO
ePRI application Online Gram Panchayat office/
Rozgaar Sahayak
3 PO verifies the form and updates in database online ePRI Application Online PO
1
4 PO does 1. Issue of Job Card for applicant 2. Allotment of work to Job card owner
ePRI Application Online PO
5
Rozgar Sahayak receives the job card for the applicant from the JP offie ePRI Application Online Rozgaar Sahayak
6
Rozgar Sahayak distributes the Job Card to the citizens ePRI Application Online Rozgaar Sahayak
7
Muster creation at GP by Rozgar Shayak ePRI Application Online Rozgaar Sahayak
8 1.Verification of Muster submitted by Rozgaar Sahayak 2. Release of salary for job done by beneficiaries
APIO Manual PO
15
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 226 of 228
4.20.1.6. To-Be Process Map:
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 227 of 228
Pre- Requisites / Dependencies Pre requisites or dependencies required for the functioning of the process are:
1 Integration of NREGS application flow through ePRI application
Legal Changes Legal changes that need to be taken are:
2 Gram Panchayat officeshould be authorized to accept application for Job card of NREGS. 3 Rozgar Sahayak would be authorized to use digital signature for approval and rejection.
Key Recommendations
Table below should depict Recommendations to address the gaps identified and impact of each on the objectives listed Objectives O1 – Transparency & Accountability O2 – Improved Decision Making O3 – Improved Service Delivery to Citizens O4 – Internal Process Improvement (PRIs) O5 – Convenience to Govt. Employees
Objectives Recommendations O1 O2 O3 O4 O5
Process The automated system of application acceptance and receipt generation can significantly improve the service delivery
√
People Technology Integration of ePRI application with NREGS for acceptance of application for Job Card √ √ √
e-PRI Study Project (Phase III) Vol. I I - As-Is & To-Be Processes - Tripura
National Informatics Centre Services Inc Page 228 of 228
4.20.1.7. Expected MIS / Reports The following MIS reports are expected to be generated:
Sr. No.
Name of Report Description Report Users
1 Application for Job card per month This report shall provide information on application for Job Card for a given month in each Gram Panchayat
PS, PO, CEO JP. CEO,ZP
4.20.1.8. Escalation Matrix
Level 1 Level 2 S. No. Activity Description
Responsibility Centre
No. of Days Designation No. of Days Designation
1 PO issue job Card to applicant PO 16 EO PS 38 CEO ZP
2 Allocation of job to applicant PO 16 EO PS 24 CEO ZP
4.20.1.9. KPI, critical success factors, Dependenci es S. No.
KPI Name Description Method of calculation Unit of Measurement
Monitoring Authority
1 Service Delivery Time
Time required for delivery of service from the time an application is registered in the system
Sum of time taken to complete the individual activities in the process
Days EO-PS, CEO ZP
2 No of escalation
This would measure the escalations during the service delivery
Total number of escalations for a tehsil
Number of escalations per month
EO-PS, CEO ZP