tyrone o. shane hill, a035 596 053 (bia may 14, 2012)

8/12/2019 Tyrone O. Shane Hill, A035 596 053 (BIA May 14, 2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tyrone-o-shane-hill-a035-596-053-bia-may-14-2012 1/7

Dominique, BarbaraThe Dominique Group PLLC225 Broadway, Ste., 2515New York, NY 10007

Name: HILL, TYRNE SHANE

Executive Oce r Immgraon Review

Board of Immigation ppealsOce of he Clek

5 /07 Leesburg Pik. St 2000

Fa Cld1 Vgii 1204

OHS/CE ice of Chief Counsel • NYD201 Varick, Rm 1130New York, NY 10014

A035-596053

Dae of this noice 5/4/202

ncosed is a copy of the Board's decson and order in the above-rerenced case.

ncosue

Panel Members:Greer Anne

Sncerely,

Donna CarChief Cerk

Cite as: Tyrone O. Shane Hill, A035 596 053 (BIA May 14, 2012)

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished



U Dpartmnt of Justic Dcison of th Boad o mmigaion Appals

Executiv Oc r Immigaion Rviw

Fas Chrc, rgnia 221

File: A035 596 053 - New York, NY

In re: TYRONE . SHAE HILL

REMOVAL PROCEEDGS

APPEA

Date

ON BEHALF OF RESPONENT Barbara Dominique Esquire

ON BEHAF OF DHS: Ma T. Abraham

Asssant Chief Counsel

CHAGE:

MAY 1420

Notice Sec 237( a)(2)( A)( ) I& N Act [8 USC § 1227( a)(2)( A)( i)] Convcted of two or more crmes nvoving moral trpide

APPLICAION enaton

ORDER:

e Board as without opnon he result of he decson below The decson beow s

herere e na agency deteination See 8 C R § 003 (e)(4).

Cite as: Tyrone O. Shane Hill, A035 596 053 (BIA May 14, 2012)



NTE SAES EPARTMN F ST

EXETV FFE FR MMGRATN REVWNE SAS MMGRAN R

ew rk New r

Fie N. A 0 0 Mrc 2011

n te Mtter f

TRE 0 SHANE H REMVA REENGS

Repndent

AGE igrtin nd Ntinity Act Sectin27 (} (2 (A} (ii

APAN Termintin f prceeding

N BEHA RESNE

Brbr minique

00 urc StreetNew rk New rk 000

N BEHAF HS

Mry Tttnniyi Abrm

Aitnt ief une

S N TH MMGRA GE

e repndent ntive nd citizen f mic He

purprtedly entered te nted Stte n r but Augut

7 wfu permnent reident Te eprtment f Hmend

Security by iunce f Ntice t Apper dted ecember

200 crged te repndent wit remvbiity under

27 ( (2 (A (i} bed upn cim f tw crime f mr

turpitude ciming tt e w cnvicted f te crime f teft

f ervice n Mrc 12 under dcet number 2N087 in

te rimin urt nty f ew rk nd tt e w cnvicted



under ere dcke nber 95N0009 n e de n

t e r nd e cre dd nt rie ut f nge

cee f crin cnduc

At ering befre igrn udge Rber Weie e

renden' cune de te rguen t n fc t w

nge ffene n w ffene nd t ere d been

cnditn dicrge f e r ce en w cnverted

in cnvcn nd i w bt inge crie nd e

ffene udge Wee ecifc enterned rgen nd

tted e w rered ernte rceeding bed n

tt A t te e w cerficte were befre grtn

udge Weie

e Gvernent cceed M inque' rguen wtu

re nd cceted udge Weie decn fin ne fr

te Gvernen did reque udge ee terinte e ce

wtu rejdice t furter rceedng n e grund t te

rereenttn d been de b M nique e beeved

er cen w enbe t rev due t ter cnvicin n

befre te ur e

e rder f udge Weie enered Mrc 0 , de n

indce ne w r e er weter t w wit r wtut

reudice Hweer e r in itenng e e

underd cern w n cnten tt te

Gvernen w n brred frever fr bringng frer

rceedng gnt te renden

A 05 596 05 Mrc 5, 0



Te Gvernment, n Mrc rd ued ter tice t

Apper identc in regrd t e firt tce t Apper,

te n difference being te dte f iunce n tt dcument,

nd tt ce cme n t be erd befre me firt n Mrc t

nd gin td, Mrc t

Te Gvernment mde te rgument tt tere w errr i

te firt prceedng. T n fct tere re tw crme,

erte dcket number, eprte crme ctted b te

repndent nt rig ut f nge ceme mking m menbe

t remv nder 27{ (2 {A {ii nd fied per urunt

t tt

Te urt find tt te prrite prcedure n tee

dentic crge tt te Gvernment mut mve t reen r

rerge befre grtin udge Weie etting frt te b

fr te errr tt te beeve ccrred n Mrc 2nd wen udge

Weie ued i decin nd wing dge Wee te

prtnit t crrect n errr in deciin I beieve t

i w f te ce tt ere been findng b nter dge

f fire t tin te crge et frt, tt tere

n new evidece. Ti i nt itutn were ce w n

ppe nd cud nt be ed but ubequent n nger n

ppe t ce f e e fct beg ttempted be

preented n rt f new NTA

d nt it reviewng dge �ver udge Wee.

Frtermre, tee rgument ve t been mde t udge Weie

A 0 0 rc , 20



and that s what pocedes eque t s to gve a dge the

oppotnty to examne the agments o the pates and to

mae a decson athe than o a eow udge o the same

sdcton as opposed to an Appeate udge to second-gess

what the dge woud have done had the agument been pesented to

hm

nde that ccumstance, nd t appopate to temnate

ths Notce to Appea on the gonds that t s poceduay

baed hs s a mets decsion by the Cot. t s n

contempaton that the Govenment whch st can tmey mae

the appopate moton to udge Wese w pusue that Bt

beeve that poceday nde ths ccmstance whee the Jdge

s avaabe whee the cam s that the dge made an eo

based pon an assmpton o acts not popey beoe that Cot

that the pocede shod be to eage and o e-open

poceedng

hs ode s enteed by dge Fes today Mach 5

0 on the ecod

nted States gaton udge

A 05 59 05 4 Mach 5 0



CERTIFICATE PAG

hereby certify ha he attached proceeding before

JUDGE NOEL ANNE FERRIS, in the matter of:

TYRONE 0 SHAN H

A 035 596 053

New York, ew York

is an accurae, verbam ranscrip of the recording as provided by

te Execuive Office for igraion Review and a hi is he

oriinal transcript thereof for he file of he Executive Office

for iration Review.

� ;_ r�.-1Kristen J B oti Transcrib rree Sae R oring, nc

May 1, 201(copetion dae)

By submision of thi CRTCAT PAGE, he Contracor cerifiestat a Sony BEC/T-14 7, 4 channel ranscriber or equivaen, and/orC, as described in Section C, paragraph C3 of the conracws used to transcribe the Record of Proceeding sown in the above

pragraph

tyrone o. shane hill, a035 596 053 (bia may 14, 2012)

Documents