umar's thesis abbreviation

7/29/2019 Umar's Thesis Abbreviation

1/15

i

AUTHOR DECLARATION

I hereby declare that the work in this academic project is my own except for

quotations and summaries which have been duly acknowledged.

Date: 15th of June 2013 Signature : ....

Name : Umar Mukhtar Bin Mohd Noor

Matric. No. : 1080183

Address : No. 4, Jalan 3/3, Taman Desa

Taming Sari, 76300 Sungai

Udang, Melaka, Malaysia.


2/15

ii

.

.

:53152:..................................:

:51152:42/2 0211


3/15

iii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

In the name of Allah, the Most Merciful and the Most Compassionate.

Alhamdulillah, praise to the Almighty. Grateful to Him who had made this work

become possible complete.

Then, I would like to express my deepest appreciation to all those who providedme the possibility to complete this report. A special gratitude I give to my final

year academic project supervisor and also my lecturer, Dr. Resali bin Muda,

whose contribution in stimulating suggestions and encouragement, helped me tocoordinate my project especially in writing this academic project.

Next, as regard to my beloved family, the most important person in my life, myparents, Mohd Noor bin Omar and Fauziah binti Md Sharif. Then, not forgotten to

my beloved siblings Abidah Aqilah binti Mohd Noor, Nurfathiyyah binti Mohd

Noor, Mohd Syamil bin Mohd Noor and Mohd Nabil bin Mohd Noor. Without all

of them, I would not have spirit to undergone this academic project.

Furthermore, I would also like to acknowledge with much appreciation the crucialrole of the staff of Faculty of Syariah and Law, Islamic Science University of

Malaysia, who gave the permission to use all required equipment and the

necessary materials to complete the task. Special thanks go to the rest of thelecturers and all my colleagues who help me to embrace the idea and gave

suggestions about the research.

Last but not least, many thanks go to the Dean of faculty, the Head Programwhose have invested his full effort in guiding us in achieving the goal. To all my

colleagues, lecturers, I would like to send my deepest gratitude to all of you andask for forgiveness from my fault. I would like to take this chance to wish all of

you the best in your undertaking future.


4/15

iv

ABSTRAK

Kajian ini dijalankan adalah bertujuan untuk mengenalpasti kemungkinan untuk

melaksanakan undang-undang Diyat dalam system undang-undang jenayah di

Malaysia. Kajian ini juga dijalankan dengan melakukan perbandingan

keberkesanan antara undang-undang jenayah Malaysia yang diambil daripada

undang-undang British dengan undang-undang Diyat dalam Islam. Kajian ini

mensasarkan perlaksanaan yang bersifat umum kepada seluruh rakat Malaysia dan

tidak hanya dilaksanakan dalam kerangka bidang kuasa undang-undang Syariah

yang terbatas seperti yang diamalkan sekarang. Kajian ini juga bertujuan untuk

mengkaji keberkesanan undang-undang jenayah semasa di Malaysia dalam

memberikan keadilan yang setimpal dan sokongan kepada keluarga mangsa kes

menyebabkan kematian terutama kes bunuh. Kajian ini juga akan melibatkan

perbincangan tentangan pembahagian saksama nilai keadilan dalam

pernghakiman oleh mahkamah dengan membandingkan pembahagian tersebut

antara konteks undang-undang British dan undang-undang Islam.


5/15

v

ABSTRACT

The study is to examine the possibility to implement the law of blood money

under Malaysian criminal legal system. It is also to compare the Malaysian

current legal provision that was brought and developed under British law with the

blood money system. It also looks into plural implementation of blood money in

civil jurisdiction rather than inserting thereof into the current Syariah criminal

jurisdiction. This research is confined to the study of implementation of blood

money in homicide case especially in murder. It is also the purpose of this

research to examine the effectiveness of current Malaysia criminal law in giving

justice and mollifying the family member of homicide victim. This research will

also include the discussion on the distribution of justice between British law

system and Islamic law system.


6/15

vi

...

..


7/15

vii

LIST OF CONTENT

Content Page

AUTHOR DECLARATION i

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iii

ABSTRAK iv

ABSTRACT v

MULAKHAS AL-BAHTH vi

LIST OF CONTENT vii

LIST OF CASES ix

LIST OF STATUTES x

LIST OF TRANSLITERATIONS xi

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xiii

CHAPTER ONE: RESEARCH PROPOSAL

1.1 Background of Research1.2 Statement of Problems1.3 Objective and Aim of Research1.4 Research Methodology1.5 Literature Review1.6 Scope And Limitation Of Research

1

1

3

3

4

6

CHAPTER TWO: INTRODUCTION

2.1 Justice as the Aim of Any Law2.2 The Nature of Justice in Homicide Case2.3 Archaic Dichotomy of Crime and Tort

8

10

12

CHAPTER THREE: EXHAUSTIVE PUNISHMENT FOR

HOMICIDE UNDER MALAYSIAN LAW

3.1 Provision of Homicide in Act 574 of Penal Code of Malaysia3.2 Provisions in Act 593 of Criminal Procedure Code of Malaysia3.3 Effectiveness of Punishment for Homicide Case

15

17

20


8/15

viii

CHAPTER FOUR: PRACTICES OF BLOOD MONEY LAW IN

HISTORY AND CURRENT

4.1 Blood Money Law in History4.2 Blood Money Law in Current Practices4.3 Real Cases Study

23

29

31

CHAPTER FIVE: IMPLEMENTATION OF BLOOD MONEY LAW

5.1 Murder in Compatibility with Malaysian Penal Code.5.2 The Law of Diyat in Islam5.3

Single Litigation

5.4 Impecunious Offender: Takaful replacing the system of Aqilah5.5 The Law of Diyah & Takaful v No-Fault Liability Scheme5.6 Blood Money as the Alternative Punishment and Not as a Mere

Additional Punishment

5.7 Plural Administration

35

38

4042

48

49

52

CONCLUSION: SUGGESTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 54

BIBLIOGRAPHY 61


9/15

ix

LIST OF CASES

Case Citation

PagePublic Prosecutor v Low Lu KengMuar, High Court Criminal Appeal No.

42-8-199023


10/15

x

LIST OF TABLE

TABLE Page

TABLE 1: Calculation of Diyah 29


11/15

xi

LIST OF STATUTE

Name of Statutes Page

Penal Code [Act 574] 1, 16, 17,18, 49

Federal Constitution of Malaysia 20, 41

Criminal Procedure Code [Act 593] 17, 19, 20, 22,

41, 55, 57

Pakistan Qisas and Diyat Ordinance 1991 30

Sudan Criminal Act 1991 30

Iran Chapter on Hudud and Qisas 30

Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code (II) Enactment 1993 30


12/15

xii

LIST OF TRANSLITERATION

ARABIC LETTERS TRANSLITERATION a b t th j h kh d dz r z s sy


13/15

xiii

s dh th zh gh f q k l m n w h y


14/15

xiv

LIST OF ABBREVIATION

AC Appeal Court

All ER All England Report

Anor. Another

BLR Building Law Report

Cap Capital

CJ Court Judge

CLJ Current Law Journal

Cox CC Cox Criminal Cases

Cr App Court Appellate

DPP Deputy Public Prosecutor

FC Federal Court

HL House Lords

J Judge

JP Justice of the Peace Reports


15/15

xv

KB Kings Bench

n.a. No author

MLJ Malayan Law Journal

Ors. Others

P.B.U.H. Peace be upon him

PP Public Prosecutor

R Rex

QB Queens Bench

SCR Supreme Court Reports

SLR Singapore Law Reports

Sya Syariah

Vol. Volume

YA Yang Arif

umar's thesis abbreviation

Documents