victor j stenger "fine-tuned universe"
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
1/24
LR ]DO _KLQOVRO ALKO*]_KOM A@V _R0
Qlb}`v H+ R}okcov
]do nkblok} nvcujok} av`j morlck a`v }do otlr}okbo `a C`m lr fnrom `k }do b`jj`k lk}ul}l`k }dn}
}do uklqovro nkm ilao nvo }`` b`jwiot }` dnqo nvlrok f| kn}uvni jonkr ni`ko+ D`soqov) nr
wdli`r`wdov Mnqlm Dujo w`lk}om `u} lk }do olcd}ook}d bok}uv|) }do anb} }dn} so bnkk`} otwinlk
r`jo wdok`jok`k kn}uvnii| m`or k`} nii`s ur }` b`kbiumo }dn} l} dnm }` fo n jlvnbio+
Lk vobok} |onvr) k`qoi qovrl`kr `a }do nvcujok} av`j morlck }dn} bnii uw`k j`movk rblokbo
nr }dolv nu}d`vl}| dnqo nwwonvom `k }do rboko + Wv`w`kok}r `a r`*bniiomLk}oiilcok} Morlck binlj
}` b`kalmok}i| vuio `u} kn}uvni wv`borror nr }do r`io `vlclk a`v bov}nlk fl`i`clbni r|r}ojr $Fodo
>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
2/24
}do uklqovro lr otboomlkci| ukileoi| }` fo }do vorui} a jlkmiorr bdnkbo+ Vn}dov) nk lk}oiilcok})
wuvw`roaui) nkm lkmoom bnvlkc wovr`kni Bvon}`v jur} dnqo jnmo }dlkcr }do sn| }do| nvo+
R`jo sd` jneo }do alko*}uklkc nvcujok} nvo b`k}ok} }` ruccor} jovoi| }dn} lk}oiilcok})
wuvw`roaui) ruwovkn}uvni morlck dnr fob`jo nk o~unii| qlnfio ni}ovkn}lqo }` n vnkm`j)
wuvw`roiorr) kn}uvni oq`iu}l`k `a }do uklqovro nkm dujnkelkm ruccor}om f| b`kqok}l`kni rblokbo+
]dlr jlvv`vr vobok} nvcujok}r a`v lk}oiilcok} morlck nr nk ni}ovkn}lqo }` oq`iu}l`k+
D`soqov) n aos morlck nmq`bn}or dnqo c`ko auv}dov }` binlj }dn} C`m lr k`s vo~ulvomf|
rblok}lalb mn}n+ J`vo`qov) }dlr C`m jur} fo }do C`m `a }do Bdvlr}lnk Flfio+ ]do| lkrlr} }dn} }do
uklqovro lr wv`qnfi| k`} }do wv`mub} `a wuvoi| kn}uvni) ljwovr`kni wv`borror+ ]|wla|lkc }dlr
qlos lr wd|rlblr} nkm nr}v`k`jov Ducd V`rr) sd` bnkk`} ljnclko alko*}uklkc dnwwoklkc nk|
`}dov sn| }dnk f| n &wovr`kni Ok}l}| + + + n} ionr} n dukmvom }vliil`k }ljor j`vo #bnwnfio# }dnk nvo
so dujnk folkcr sl}d nii `uv vor`uvbor+& Do b`kbiumor }dn} &}do Ok}l}| sd` fv`ucd} }do uklqovro
lk}` otlr}okbo jur} fo n Wovr`kni Folkc) a`v `ki| n wovr`k bnk morlck sl}d nk|sdovo konv }dlr
mocvoo `a wvoblrl`k& $V`rr) >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
3/24
otdnur}lqo }`jo dnr jnk| ovv`vr) orwoblnii| lk o~un}l`kr) r`jo `a sdlbd vojnlk ukb`vvob}om lk
in}ov oml}l`kr+
]do Invco Kujfov B`lkblmokbor
Onvi| lk }do }sok}lo}d bok}uv|) So|i $> : >72+ \`u jlcd} otwob} }do kujfovr > v
7 &kn}uvnii|+& Fu} sd| >727?3 `v >7*>620 R`jo wvlkblwio jur} roiob} `u} >7273+
I``e nv`ukm n} ok`ucd kujfovr nkm |`u nvo f`ukm }` alkm r`jo }dn} nwwonv b`kkob}om+
J`r} wd|rlblr}r) }dok nkm k`s) mlm k`} vocnvm }do invco kujfovr wuxxio rovl`uri|+ L} roojr ileo
kujov`i`c|+ D`soqov) }do cvon} wd|rlblr} Wnui Mlvnb $> lr }do rnjo `vmov `a
jnckl}umo nr nk`}dov wuvo kujfov K6 }dn} clqor }do vn}l` `a n }|wlbni r}oiinv ilao}ljo }` }do }ljo
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
4/24
a`v ilcd} }` }vnqovro }do vnmlur `a n wv`}`k+ ]dn} lr) do a`ukm }s` roojlkci| ukb`kkob}om invco
kujfovr }` fo `a }do rnjo `vmov `a jnckl}umo+ La `ko kujfov folkc invco lr ukileoi|) d`s jubd
j`vo ukileoi| lr nk`}dov }` b`jo ni`kc sl}d nf`u} }do rnjo qniuo0
Mlbeo $>, w`lk}om `u} }dn} K6 lr koborrnvli| invco lk `vmov }dn} }do ilao}ljo `a }|wlbni
r}nvr fo ruaalblok} }` cokovn}o donq| bdojlbni oiojok}r rubd nr bnvf`k+ Auv}dovj`vo) do rd`som
}dn} K> jur} fo `a }do rnjo `vmov nr K6 lk nk| uklqovro sl}d donq| oiojok}r+ Bnvv nkm Voor
$>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
5/24
Fliil`kr `a nmml}l`kni |onvr sovo koomom a`v `uv d`jo r}nv) }do Ruk) }` wv`qlmo n r}nfio
`u}wu} `a okovc| r` n} ionr} `ko `a l}r winko}r b`uim moqoi`w ilao+ Fu} la }do cvnql}n}l`kni
n}}vnb}l`k fo}sook wv`}`kr lk r}nvr dnm k`} fook jnk| `vmovr `a jnckl}umo soneov }dnk }do
oiob}vlb vowuirl`k) nr vowvorok}om f| }do qov| invco qniuo `a K>) r}nvr s`uim dnqo b`iinwrom nkm
fuvkom `u} i`kc foa vo kubionv wv borror b`uim fulim uw }do wovl`mlb }nfio av`j }do `vlclkni
d|mv`cok nkm mou}ovluj+ ]do a`vjn}l`k `a bdojlbni b`jwiotl}| lr ileoi| `ki| lk n uklqovro `a
cvon} nco+
Cvon} nco lr k`} nii+ ]do oiojok}*r|k}dorlxlkc wv`borror lk r}nvr mowokm rokrl}lqoi| `k
}do wv`wov}lor nkm nfukmnkbor `a mou}ovluj nkm doiluj wv`mubom lk }do onvi| uklqovro+
Mou}ovluj s`uim k`} otlr} la }do mlaaovokbo fo}sook }do jnrror `a n kou}v`k nkm n wv`}`k sovo
hur} rilcd}i| mlrwinbom av`j l}r nb}uni qniuo+ ]do voin}lqo nfukmnkbor `a d|mv cok nkm doiluj nir
mowokm r}v`kci| `k }dlr wnvnjo}ov+ ]do|) }``) vo~ulvo n moilbn}o fninkbo `a }do voin}lqo r}vokc}dr
`a cvnql}| nkm }do sone a`vbo) }do a`vbo vorw`krlfio a`v kubionv fo}n mobn|+ N rilcd}i| r}v`kcov
sone a`vbo) nkm }do uklqovro s`uim fo >77 wovbok} d|mv`cok5 nii }do kou}v`kr lk }do onvi|
uklqovro s`uim dnqo mobn|om) ionqlkc k`ko nv`ukm }` fo rnqom lk mou}ovluj kubiol a`v in}ov uro lk
}do r|k}dorlxlkc oiojok}r lk r}nvr+ N rilcd}i| soneov sone a`vbo) nkm aos kou}v`kr s`uim dnqo
mobn|om) ionqlkc nf`u} }do rnjo kujfovr `a wv`}`kr nkm kou}v`kr5 }dok) nii }do wv`}`kr nkm
kou}v`kr s`uim dnqo fook f`ukm uw lk doiluj kubiol) sl}d }s` wv`}`kr nkm }s` kou}v`kr lk
onbd+ ]dlr s`uim dnqo iom }` n uklqovro }dn} snr >77 wovbok} doiluj) sl}d k` d|mv`cok }` auoi
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
6/24
}do aurl`k wv`borror lk r}nvr+ Kol}dov `a }doro ot}vojor s`uim dnqo nii`som a`v }do otlr}okbo `a
r}nvr nkm ilao nr so ek`s l} fnrom `k bnvf`k bdojlr}v|+
]do oiob}v`k nir` ok}ovr lk}` }do }lcd}v`wo nb} koomom }` wv`mubo }do donqlov oiojok}r+
Fobnuro }do jnrr `a }do oiob}v`k lr iorr }dnk }do kou}v`k*wv`}`k jnrr mlaaovokbo) n avoo kou}v`k
bnk mobn| lk}` n wv`}`k) oiob}v`k) nkm nk}l*kou}vlk`+ La }do jnrr `a }do oiob}v`k sovo hur} n fl}
invcov) }do kou}v`k s`uim fo r}nfio nkm j`r} `a }do wv`}`kr nkm oiob}v`kr lk }do onvi| uklqovro
s`uim dnqo b`jflkom }` a`vj kou}v`kr) ionqlkc il}}io d|mv`cok }` nb} nr }do jnlk b`jw`kok} nkm
auoi `a r}nvr+ ]do kou}v`k jur} nir` fo donqlov }dnk }do wv`}`k) fu} k`} r` jubd donqlov }dn}
kou}v`kr bnkk`} fo f`ukm lk kubiol+
Lk >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
7/24
2Do= B>6
$]do ruwovrbvlw}r clqo }do kujfov `akubio`kr) }dn} lr) wv`}`kr nkm kou}v`kr lk onbd
kubiour) sdlbd lr rwoblalom f| l}r bdojlbni r|jf`i5 }do }`}ni kujfov `a kubio`kr lr b`krovqom)
}dn} lr) vojnlkr b`kr}nk}) lk n kubionv vonb}l`k+, D`soqov) }do wv`fnflil}| `a }dvoo f`mlor b`jlkc
}`co}dov rljui}nko`uri| lr qov| i`s) nkm r`jo bn}ni|}lb wv`borr lk sdlbd `ki| }s` f`mlor
lk}ovnb} n} n }ljo jur} fo nrrlr}lkc+ Nk lk}ovjomln}o wv`borr lk sdlbd }s` doiluj kubiol alvr} auro
lk}` n fov|iiluj kubiour sdlbd }dok lk}ovnb}r sl}d }do }dlvm doiluj kubiour }` clqo }do morlvom
bnvf`k kubiour clqor }do morlvom vorui}8
6Do= Fo4
Do= % Fo4 B>6
D`|io $>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
8/24
b`k}nlkom nk`}dov oiojok} sd`ro rlcklalbnkbo lr r}lii d`}i| mofn}om+ Sl}d`u} }do 3+3 JoQ kubionv
r}n}o `a bnvf`k) `uv a`vj `a ilao fnrom `k bnvf`k s`uim k`} dnqo otlr}om+
]do Nk}dv`wlb Wvlkblwior
Ileo }do invco kujfov b`lkblmokbor) }do 3+3 JoQ kubionv r}n}o roojr ukileoi| }` fo }do vorui} `a
bdnkbo+ ]do otlr}okbo `a }doro nwwnvok} kujovlbni b`lkblmokbor iom Bnv}ov $>, dnqo
lmok}lalom }dvoo mlaaovok} a`vjr `a }do nk}dv`wlb wvlkblwio) moalkom nr a`ii`sr) sdlbd L ~u`}o
otnb}i|8
&Sone Nk}dv`wlb Wvlkblwio $SNW,8 ]do `frovqom qniuor `a nii wd|rlbni nkm b`rj`i`clbni
~unk}l}lor nvo k`} o~unii| wv`fnfio fu} }neo `k qniuor vor}vlb}om f| }do vo~ulvojok} }dn} }dovo otlr}
rl}or sdovo bnvf`k*fnrom ilao bnk oq`iqo nkm f| }do vo~ulvojok} }dn} }do _klqovro fo `im ok`ucd
a`v l} }` dnqo nivonm| m`ko r`+&
]do SNW jovoi| r}n}or }do `fql`ur+ La }do uklqovro snr k`} }do sn| l} lr) so s`uim k`}
fo }do sn| so nvo+ Fu} l} lr ruaalblok} a`v wvomlb}l`kr rubd nr D`|io#r+
&R}v`kc Nk}dv`wlb Wvlkblwio $RNW,8 ]do _klqovro jur} dnqo }d`ro wv`wov}lor sdlbd nii s
ilao }` moqoi`w sl}dlk l} n} r`jo r}nco lk l}r dlr}`v|+&
]dlr lr orrok}lnii| }do a`vj `vlclknii| wv`w`rom f| Bnv}ov) sdlbd ruccor}r }dn} }do
b`lkblmokbor nvo k`} nbblmok}ni fu} }do vorui} `a n ins `a kn}uvo+ L} lr n r}vnkco ins lkmoom) ukileo
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
9/24
nk| `}dov lk wd|rlbr+ L} ruccor}r }dn} ilao otlr}r nr r`jo Nvlr}`}oilnk alkni bnuro) nr dnr fook
ruccor}om f| }do wv`w`kok}r `a Lk}oiilcok} Morlck+
Fnvv`s nkm ]lwiov $>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
10/24
Jnv}lk Cnvmkov $>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
11/24
voknjom }do &b|fov}dv`wlb& wvlkblwio) `v r`jo rubd) sl}d b`jwu}ovr vn}dov }dnk dujnkr)
fnb}ovln) nkm b`bev`nbdor }do wuvw`ro `a otlr}okbo+
@ki| d|mv`cok) doiluj) nkm il}dluj sovo r|k}dorlxom lk }do onvi| flc fnkc+ ]do| nvo
wv`fnfi| bdojlbnii| }`` rljwio }` fo nrrojfiom lk}` mlqovro r}vub}uvor+ R`) l} roojr }dn} nk| ilao
fnrom `k bdojlr}v| s`uim vo~ulvo nk `im uklqovro) sl}d i kc*ilqom r}nvr wv`mublkc }do koomom
jn}ovlnir+
R}lii) so bnkk`} vuio `u} `}dov a`vjr `a jn}}ov }dnk j`iobuior lk }do uklqovro nr fulimlkc
fi`ber `a b`jwiot r|r}ojr+ Sdlio n}`jlb kubiol) a`v otnjwio) m` k`} otdlfl} }do mlqovrl}| nkm
b`jwiotl}| rook lk }do sn| n}`jr nrrojfio lk}` j`iobuinv r}vub}uvor) wovdnwr }do| jlcd} fo nfio
}` m` r` lk n uklqovro sl}d mlaaovok} wv`wov}lor nkm insr+
Ruaalblok} b`jwiotl}| nkm i`kc ilao jn| fo }do `ki| lkcvomlok}r koomom a`v n uklqovro }`
dnqor`jo a`vj `a ilao+ ]d`ro sd` nvcuo }dn} ilao lr dlcdi| ljwv`fnfio koom }` `wok }dolv jlkmr
}` }do w`rrlflil}| }dn} ilao jlcd} fo ileoi| sl}d jnk| mlaaovok} b`kalcuvn}l`kr `a insr nkm
b`kr}nk}r `a wd|rlbr+ Auv}dovj`vo) k`}dlkc lk nk}dv`wlb vonr`klkc lkmlbn}or nk| rwoblni
wvoaovokbo a`v dujnk ilao) `v lkmoom lk}oiilcok} `v rok}lok} ilao `a nk| r v}**hur} nk lk`vmlkn}o
a`kmkorr a`v bnvf`k+
Leomn nkm Hoaaov|r $677>, dnqo moj`kr}vn}om }doro i`clbni ainsr nkm `}dovr lk }do alko*
}uklkc nvcujok} sl}d n a`vjni wv`fnflil}| nkni|rlr+ ]do| dnqo nir` k`}om nk njurlkc
lkb`krlr}okb| }dn} rd`sr d`s wv`j`}ovr `a morlck `a}ok uro ju}unii| b`k}vnmlb}`v| i`clb8 @k
}do `ko dnkm }do bvon}l`klr}r nkm C`m*`a*}do*cnwr oq`iu}l`klr}r nvcuo }dn} kn}uvo lr }``
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
12/24
ukb`kcoklnia`v ilao }` dnqo moqoi`wom }`}nii| kn}uvnii|) nkm r` }dovoa`vo ruwovkn}uvni lkwu} jur}
dnqo `bbuvvom+ @k }do `}dov dnkm) }do alko*}ukovr $`a}ok }do rnjo wo`wio, nvcuo }dn} }do
b`kr}nk}r nkm insr `a kn}uvo nvo ot~ulrl}oi| b`kcoklni}` ilao) nkm r` }dovoa`vo }do| jur} dnqo
fook ruwovkn}uvnii| bvon}om+ ]do| bnk#} dnqo l} f`}d sn|r+
D`s Alko*]ukom Nk|sn|0
R`jomn| so jn| dnqo }do `ww`v}ukl}| }` r}um| mlaaovok} a`vjr `a ilao }dn} oq`iqom `k `}dov
winko}r+ Clqok }do qnr}korr `a }do uklqovro nkm }do b`jj`k `frovqn}l`k `a ruwovk`qno lk `}dov
cnintlor) so dnqo k` vonr`k }` nrrujo ilao otlr}r `ki| `k Onv}d+ Ni}d`ucd l} roojr dnvmi| ileoi|
}dn} }do oq`iu}l`k `a MKN nkm `}dov mo}nlir sovo otnb}i| vowilbn}om oirosdovo) bnvf`k nkm }do
`}dov oiojok}r `a `uv a`vj `a ilaonvo soii mlr}vlfu}om }dv`ucd`u} }do uklqovro) nr oqlmokbom f| }do
b`jw`rl}l`k `a b`rjlb vn|r) jo}o`vr) nkm }do rwob}vni nkni|rlr `a lk}ovr}oiinv cnr+
So nir` bnkk`} nrrujo }dn} ilao s`uim dnqo fook ljw`rrlfio lk `uv uklqovro dnm }do
wd|rlbni insr fook mlaaovok}+ Bov}nlki| so bnkk`} rwone `a rubd }dlkcr lk }do k`vjni rblok}lalb
j`mo lk sdlbd mlvob} `frovqn}l`kr nvo morbvlfom f| }do`v|+ Fu}) n} }do rnjo }ljo) l} lr k`}
liiocl}ljn}o) k`} ukrblok}lalb) }` otnjlko }do i`clbni b`kro~uokbor `a otlr}lkc }do`vlor }dn} nvo soii*
b`kalvjom f| mn}n av`j `uv `sk uklqovro+
]do ot}vnw`in}l`k `a }do`vlor fo|`km }dolv k`vjni m`jnlkr bnk }uvk `u} }` fo slimi|
sv`kc+ Fu} l} bnk nir` }uvk `u} }` fo rwob}nbuinvi| b`vvob}+ ]do aukmnjok}ni wd|rlbr ionvkom lk
onv}df`ukm inf`vn}`vlor dnr wv`qom }` fo qnilm n} cvon} mlr}nkbor av`j Onv}d nkm n} }ljor i`kc
foa`vo }do Onv}d nkm r`inv r|r}oj dnm fook a`vjom+ ]d`ro sd` nvcuo }dn} rblokbo bnkk`} }nie
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
13/24
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
14/24
o~un}l`kr slii clqo jnk| uklqovror }dn} m` k`} i``e n fl} ileo `uvr+ ]do cv`rr wv`wov}lor `a `uv
uklqovro nvo mo}ovjlkom f| }doro a`uv b`kr}nk}r) nkm so bnk qnv| }doj }` roo sdn} n uklqovro
jlcd} cv`rri| i``e ileo sl}d mlaaovok} qniuor `a }doro b`kr}nk}r+
L dnqo nkni|xom >77 uklqovror lk sdlbd }do qniuor `a }do a`uv wnvnjo}ovr sovo cokovn}om
vnkm`ji| av`j n vnkco alqo `vmovr `a jnckl}umo nf`qo }` alqo `vmovr `a jnckl}umo foi`s }dolv
qniuor lk `uv uklqovro) }dn} lr) `qov n }`}ni vnkco `a }ok `vmovr `a jnckl}umo $R}okcov >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
15/24
Alko*]uklkc }do B`rj`i`clbni B`kr}nk}
Kot}) io} jo mlrburr nk otnjwio `a ruww`rom alko*}uklkc }dn} nvlror `u} `a b`rj`i`c|+ ]dlr lr }do
nwwnvok} alko*}uklkc `a Olkr}olk#r b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} sl}dlk >67 `vmovr `a jnckl}umo) sl}d`u}
sdlbd ilao s`uim fo ljw`rrlfio+ ]dlr slii vo~ulvo r`jo wvoiljlknv| otwinkn}l`k+
Sdok Olkr}olk alvr} sv`}o m`sk dlr o~un}l`kr `a cokovni voin}lql}| lk >?) do rns }dn}
}do| nii`som a`v }do w`rrlflil}| `a cvnql}n}l`kni okovc| r}`vom lk }do buvqn}uvo `a ojw}| rwnbo*
}ljo+ ]dlr qnbuuj buvqn}uvo lr otwvorrom lk }ovjr `a sdn} lr bniiom }do b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk}+
]do anjlilnv cvnql}n}l`kni a`vbo fo}sook jn}ovlni `fhob}r lr nisn|r n}}vnb}lqo+ N w`rl}lqo
b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} wv`mubor n vowuirlqo cvnql}n}l kni a`vbo +
N} }do }ljo) Olkr}olk nkm j`r} `}dovr nrrujom }dn} }do r}nvr a`vjom n altom) r}nfio
&alvjnjok})& nr l} rn|r lk }do Flfio+ N r}nfio alvjnjok} lr k`} w`rrlfio sl}d n}}vnb}lqo a`vbor
ni`ko r` Olkr}olk }d`ucd} }dn} }do vowuirl`k wv`qlmom f| }do b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} jlcd} fninkbo
}dlkcr `u}+ Sdok) r``k na}ov) Duffio mlrb`qovom }dn} }do uklqovro snr k`} n r}nfio alvjnjok} fu}
otwnkmlkc) }do koom a`v n b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} snr oiljlkn}om) nkm Olkr}olk bniiom l} dlr &flccor}
fiukmov+& _k}li vobok}i|) nii }do mn}n cn}dovom f| nr}v`k`jovr dnqo al} qov| soii }` j`moir }dn}
ro} }do b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} o~uni }` 7+
Olkr}olk#r &fiukmov& voruvanbom lk >7* 2?
rob`km `v r` $Enxnknr >) Ilkmo >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
16/24
]dlr snr k`} nii+ Lk >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
17/24
Morlck nmq`bn}or dnqo k`} `qovi``eom }do b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} wv`fioj $V`rr >67 lr r}lii 7) so dnqo k`
b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} wv`fioj lk }dlr bnro+ ]do okovc| mokrl}| `a ~ulk}orrokbo lr k`} b`kr}nk}
fu} oq`iqor ni`kc sl}d }do `}dov jn}}ov/okovc| aloimr a }do uklqovro+ _kileo }do b`rj`i`clbni
b`kr}nk}) ~ulk}orrokbo okovc| mokrl}| koom k`} fo alko*}ukom+
Sdlio ~ulk}orrokbo jn| k`} }uvk `u} }` wv`qlmo }do b`vvob} otwinkn}l`k a`v }do
b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} wv`fioj) l} moj`kr}vn}or) la k`}dlkc oiro) }dn} rblokbo lr nisn|r dnvm n}
s`ve }v|lkc }` r`iqo l}r wuxxior sl}dlk n jn}ovlnilr}lb avnjos`ve+ ]do nrrov}l`k }dn} C`m bnk fo
rook f| qlv}uo `a dlr nb}r `a b`rj`i`clbni alko*}uklkc) ileo lk}oiilcok} morlck nkm onvilov qovrl`kr `a
}do nvcujok} av`j morlck) lr k`}dlkc j`vo }dnk nk`}dov qnvln}l`k `k }do mlrvowu}nfio C`m*`a*}do*
cnwr nvcujok}+ ]doro voi| `k }do anlk} d`wo }dn} rblok}lr}r slii koqov fo nfio }` alkm n kn}uvni
otwinkn}l`k a`v `ko `v j`vo `a }do wuxxior }dn} buvvok}i| dnqo }doj rbvn}bdlkc }dolv donmr nkm
}dovoa`vo slii dnqo }` lkrov} C`m nr }do otwinkn}l`k+ Nr i`kc nr rblokbo bnk wv`qlmo winurlfio
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
18/24
rboknvl`r a`v n auii| jn}ovlni uklqovro) oqok la }d`ro rboknvl`r bnkk`} fo buvvok}i| }or}om }do| nvo
ruaalblok} }` voau}o }do C`m `a }do cnwr+
Nk Lkalkl}| `a _klqovror
So dnqo rd`sk }dn} b`kml}l`kr }dn} jlcd} ruww`v} r`jo a`vj `a ilao lk n vnkm`j uklqovro nvo k`}
ljwv`fnfio+ Lkmoom) so bnk ojwlvlbnii| or}ljn}o }do wv`fnflil}| }dn} n uklqovro slii dnqo ilao+ So
ek`s `a `ko uklqovro) nkm }dn} uklqovro dnr ilao) r` }do &jonruvom& wv`fnflil}| lr >77 wovbok})
nifol} sl}d n invco r}n}lr}lbni ukbov}nlk}|+ ]dlr vofu}r n j|}d }dn} dnr nwwonvom avo~uok}i| lk }do
morlck il}ovn}uvo nkm lr lkmlbn}om f| Fnvv`s nkm ]lwiov#r `w}l`k $b,) }dn} `ki| n jui}lwio*uklqovro
rboknvl` bnk otwinlk }do b`lkblmokbor sl}d`u} n ruwovkn}uvni bvon}`v $Rslkfuvko) >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
19/24
bnkk`} oqok ljnclko l}+ @fql`uri| so nvo lk `ko `a }d`ro uklqovror sl}d ilao+ @}dov jui}lqovro
rboknvl`r dnqo fook mlrburrom f| Rjl}d$>
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
20/24
jnlk}oknkbo `a ilao+ Ni}d`ucd k`} r` rwoblalb }dn} }do| roiob} `u} dujnk ilao) qnvl`ur a`vjr `a
nk}dv`wlb wvlkblwior dnqo fook ruccor}om nr }do ukmovi|lkc vn}l`knio+
Morlck nmq`bn}or nvcuo }dn} }do uklqovro roojr }` dnqo fook rwoblalbnii| morlckom r` }dn}
lk}oiilcok} ilao s`uim a`vj+ ]doro binljr nvo orrok}lnii| n j`movk) b`rj`i`clbni qovrl`k `a }do
nkblok} nvcujok} av`j morlck a`v }do otlr}okbo `a C`m+ D`soqov) }do kos qovrl`k lr nr moowi|
ainsom nr l}r wvomoborr`vr) jnelkc jnk| ukhur}lalom nrrujw}l`kr nkm folkc lkb`krlr}ok} sl}d
otlr}lkc ek`siomco+ @ko cv`rr nkm an}ni nrrujw}l`k lr }dn} `ki| `ko elkm `a ilao) `uvr) lr
b`kbolqnfio lk oqov| b`kbolqnfio b`kalcuvn}l`k `a uklqovror+
D`soqov) n slmo qnvln}l`k `a b`kr}nk}r `a wd|rlbr ionmr }` uklqovror }dn} nvo i`kc*ilqom
ok`ucd a`v ilao }` oq`iqo) ni}d`ucd dujnk ilao koom k`} otlr} lk rubd uklqovror+
Ni}d`ucd k`} vo~ulvom }` kocn}o }do alko*}uklkc nvcujok}) sdlbd aniir `a l}r `sk solcd})
`}dov uklqovror forlmor `uv `sk nvo k`} vuiom `u} f| aukmnjok}ni wd|rlbr nkm b`rj`i`c|+ ]do
}do`v| `a n jui}lqovro b`jw`rom `a jnk| uklqovror sl}d mlaaovok} insr nkm wd|rlbni wv`wov}lor
lr nb}unii| j`vo wnvrlj`kl`ur) j`vo b`krlr}ok} sl}d @bbnj#r vnx`v) }dnk n rlkcio uklqovro+
Rwoblalbnii|) so s`uim koom }` d|w`}dorlxo n kos wvlkblwio }` vuio `u} nii fu} n rlkcio uklqovro+
La) lkmoom) jui}lwio uklqovror otlr}) }dok so nvo rljwi| lk }dn} wnv}lbuinv uklqovro `a nii }do
i`clbnii| b`krlr}ok} w`rrlflil}lor }dn} dnm }do wv`wov}lor koomom }` wv`mubo ur+
]do alko*}uklkc nvcujok} nkm `}dov vobok} lk}oiilcok} morlck nvcujok}r nvo j`movk
qovrl`kr `a C`m*`a*}do*cnwr vonr`klkc) sdovo n C`m lr moojom koborrnv| sdokoqov rblokbo dnr
k`} auii| otwinlkom r`jo wdok`jok`k+ Sdok dujnkr ilqom lk bnqor }do| ljnclkom rwlvl}r fodlkm
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
21/24
onv}d~uneor) r}`vjr) nkm liikorr+ ]`mn| so dnqo rblok}lalb otwinkn}l`kr a`v }d`ro oqok}r nkm
jubd j`vo+ R` }d`ro sd` morlvo otwilbl} rlckr `a C`m lk rblokbo k`s i``e moowov) }` dlcdi|
r`wdlr}lbn}om wuxxior ileo }do b`rj`i`clbni b`kr}nk} wv`fioj+ Fu}) `kbo ncnlk) rblokbo b`k}lkuor
}` wv`cvorr) nkm so k`s dnqo n winurlfio otwinkn}l`k }dn} m`or k`} vo~ulvo alko*}uklkc+ Rljlinvi|)
rblokbo jn| r`jomn| dnqo n }do`v| av`j sdlbd }do qniuor `a otlr}lkc wd|rlbni b`kr}nk}r bnk fo
movlqom v n} `}dovslro otwinlkom+
]do alko*}uklkc nvcujok} s`uim }oii ur }dn} }do Ruk vnmln}or ilcd} r` }dn} so bnk roo
sdovo so nvo c`lkc+ Lk anb}) }do dujnk o|o oq`iqom }` fo rokrl}lqo }` ilcd} av`j }do ruk+ ]do
uklqovro lr k`} alko*}ukom a`v dujnkl}|+ Dujnkl}| lr alko*}ukom }` }do uklqovro+
Voaovokbor
Fnvv`s) H`dk M+ nkm Avnke H+ ]lwiov >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
22/24
M`vmvobd}8 Volmoi) 6*4) Vowvlk}om lk Iorilo) H`dk >
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
23/24
Enxnknr M+ >) I?74F8 241) >77
-
7/31/2019 Victor J Stenger "Fine-Tuned Universe"
24/24
V`rr) Ducd >