visayas base load power project: kspc multipartite ... · kspc multipartite monitoring team meeting...
TRANSCRIPT
Document Produced Under Loan
Project Number: 43906-014 December 2015
Visayas Base Load Power Project (Philippines) KSPC Multipartite Monitoring Team Meeting Minutes and Groundwater Monitoring 3Q2015
Prepared by KEPCO SPC Power Corporation for the Asian Development Bank. This report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “Terms of Use” section of this website. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.
Date:
Locatiorr
Conduct.
Activity:
Facilitatt
Facilitatii
KSPC Ml\4T held their second
Minutes of the 2015 Third euarter MMT Meeting
October 20,zotsKSPC 2nd Floor Conference Room
Time:
ed by: E&C and C&PR Department
2015 Third Quarter MMT Meetingor: Neil lawrence V. Miral/E&C
iing Attendees:
No. KSPC Representatives No. DENR-EMB Representatives
1 Victorio B. Naval 1 Marcelino Tabuco/ EMB-pcD
2 Jasmin Sumaoy 2 Ariel Gillera/ EMB-ElA
3 Klayd del Carmen 3 Luis Antonio Monisit/EM B-PCD
Neil Lawrence V. Miral
5 Joanne Claire T. Supnet-Simbajon
6 Gladys Auxilio
1400H
K5PL MN4 | neld thelr second quarter meeting last July ].6, 2Ot5 at the KSPC Basement Meeting R
started al- around 1000H and ended 1200H. Majority of the members were present and generally theThe follor,ving meeting agenda were discussed.
Agenda T
The meeting
ing went well.
No. Agenda Comments/SuggestionsP
{esponsible'srDn,/Due Date
I
Updates from Previous
Meeting Minutes- Second Quarter
Environ mental
Monitoring- Adopt an Estero
- PCG invitation
. MMT TechCom Members agreed to purchase
Ambient Air Sampling Equipment (1hr sampler forTSP only)
Forthe new adopted water body include DO, BOD,
COD, Fecal Coliform and Temperature for theparameters to be tested; Follow up Naga LGU orr
the issue regarding discharge of sanitary wastefrom households near the old SPC discharge
ch an nel
o KSPC will coordinate with the coal supplierregarding disposal plan of the vessel's operationaland sanitarv wastes.
sPc - E&c
;f,c - E&c &
aga -LGU
;FC- E&C
o Barangay Public
Consultation Minutes- Barangay Colon
- Barangay North
Poblacion
- Barangay Tangke
o MMT TechCom Members agreed with Brgy.
Tangke's request to transfer groundwater pamplin6g
point; KSPC will have to check the exact lodation ofthe new sampling point.
o Include summary of health report in each barangay
)P'C - E&C &'gy. Tangke
Comments/Suggestions
Second QuarterEnvironmental
Monitoring Results
- Ambient Air- Water Effluent
- Marine Water
- Ground Water
- River Water
- Marine Life Study
o Include no. of vessels during Marine Water
Sampling within the coverage area
o Include interpretation of air quality data uping the
KSPC - E&C
o Environmental
Activities
- Adopt an Estero
Activity
Include no. of sacks of garbage collected during the
Future Activities/OtherMatters
MMT TechCom Training will be by NovefiberFourth Quarter Monitoring by Decembef
National MMT Convention
Attachments: A. Photos
B. Attendance Sheet
C. Presentation Material
Prepared by: Reviewed by: N ted byr
?fi --'T-k' '//rt*r's\tnsAJor,r, r.c. MIRAL, N.L, SUMAOY, J -[nvnr, v.e. KIM, H,J,
,Attachment A:
T
I
KEICO SPC Power Corporation
Mr.lltipartite Monitoring Team
Cebu Power Plant
Colon, City of Naga
Cebu, Philippines
Tel. No,: (032) 272-6290-97,93
Fax. No. (032) 489-7010
ATTENDANCE SHEET
MMT MEETTNG; October 2o,2ot5; Kspc ADMIN BLDG CoNFECENcE
1 t{Ai"q qq7 DENR-EMB 7 EIA
(Chairman)
Mte. e\v DENR-EMB 7 PCD (Vice
Chairman)
3
4
$-I-r$g{P-&B DENR-EMB 7
lr EsFrZ,> CENRO
Barangay Colon
(.s("
5 1y rln Vrl d o qxlA 01+74rn
o Barangay Tahgke
Baranpay Nqrth
Poblacion
Parents Teachers &
Community Association
TCA)
KSPI. PCO
Rural Health Unit
Representative
Colon Elerqentary
School Representative
SPC Pow0r Corp. PCO
1s i Kott* 6"' p,tq^r*,)
16 U. Re7 o- m+-yzA' I - -L+\7 ilww D. Wtpl't--ur JW rt"u^l-'1
1e IEN( zr.sq&A ?G.
:oipo{ e*sni.qec.21. l<Uf r\ct\u PC.
22 lSUt crJS;r {C-r
23-"_ltlt- L NBE!!E_-
24 J AHV. eW^,F
,r ', y,F% g4;r+r-laty
Fisher Folks Assoc. from
Balafigay Colon
Naga City Sanitary
oepariment
8',76217M
-i- - s--
t--oyp@yt!to'!!!1+7:
N g-,k{
I
ri'r,i!';iiilf l
i1i'rl'r;; iil
ijl
\H(\
f\.\,US)
-14'Fl
ULoFSoooNhr\)\
F^tv Nt' trt= A\iv-Y .'Sto.l +lVUL AS) \Jf\\SoosRhl\)SfriS
F\
E
=OG-(ffV
ac){-,o)GccA.{-, LJ-
O-)o-a=b=e:>E\,, ';- +, a.l|
F '\
Y\-L\JO.6IitrIqgcu#bE'fiEE
LvR=bi-etsOE(upo-c.<Jtlt=ltuooooo
$ococt)
ct)cl-
+-,oo
u)C
!E
-l-,G)G)
F
3-(l)
{r,S-N:loE-L
N
o(J
tLoF(gT'
o
*EEEes,gE
oo-
odIJJ
I
q(./'t
>d
odl-u
I
o-
v
l-
zho
oo4)
UoALu
I
\JAV\>4
.ae.9at
{,uuo
=,41
Ul
tr(,EEo(J
PL
f;.€ #ry ?:sE fr8.=;82,. qEE=
Pg!--
€u€ 3bE5 t:HE.q 99t o o- or
"E5; i3=J t;Fh Einu ii'gv-J--!l-
E:P q66E J::3E :HryE H
O*€ I=.=# :. o.j
EUo i_'g- .i1 63 u* P; y ooF ! fl E
EI€€ €;E= nE€aIE= rE€E $$j=H:
=Esp ;E
mF*E E+rE 5teF€f :Fi[: *seE33 S;95 &3
a)
o
o@
o
(!
.E
E
3(E
@
(!(!
xc(uoatSP@troOL<s
6or-e !q(JY
CF.h
Y{r=+gE9'UoY q,=
€E:n o)
n,:=YZL:Y(!d{ rr<E9lF o'5>:c> o
o
th bOtr-JL
'3 I :=€:, o, (t'F}uVty.L=
^- O ,Y'l J- -)bPg
e=d\,FLLL;.= (! o oiSe -O.a\ts<iz-?vtbOO-\:=ot--v9vEF<
=tj , , ,
a
.9
@r
(!
oLI-
^P@J:LEoO;l>z |j>,E>(!v(!oo'u ooeaF
(!= (!(!oGd)q-6
ttl
E
o
c&It
:Fo
F*ln€f,na(9
rzg
9-qE@u
'Jo.
x
E
F!EEo
t, E, t P i+r
Et ii ti iq'IE [F i" i';rP$E ri il if g*t
!; ii ii it €fiif ;l it :u elI
U
I3.E
E
pEE
t:tr!'=tcsn€:l:,ocAororrE!.ro-:HatEEnl,oEI'UfitsxcE*O
trta-€
l!ri+ I5l ;T{ .i ?*P ll .;I.€.U!uNE O TsE t s
--qQ i t3b. t hrsI 1* {rli EE:5i r,t Ei_H: !: nrq 6 F io rt
[,i$ it #
5
t'tfi-aBtot:
"E:,o*ro9S9tr?s!E.qTr..tix EiEd'!!
faa
.-+.a)q)
F
Lq)*)Lf,l
-
fr
rult;gi*i'sFf!i;li.lE*, , ,
Pry
u!c9 !.tsE,! r* "I'Ei.5';,5d,
a,
.g
E{ttpb5tT*
UouLr".l
L}d.{,x
TJouttJ
LJd{,.l)€
ru
o
(ue,
I
-
I.= >E
#€ cHrE r.1
= (u
Pt \E5U F3:E .3E = AEEE gESp s g
E: gEts g;
t'= BeeEE 9YEE 'o Et E
EreEii=zPtlE
.!ltoo!o-E
o-FgtE(,.t
E(u
c(uYj
E
1a
qTiHN-tt=uq(U
Eo
bUE'6=(U6E-.oCrO'; rrU
o
(utr hro
sE E *CEOHfoP=Eu=P
H'H F :=c)b0Fr; h
3;EELJ5tr|E
Eqrll gFr|Q-CC
EBEpy a,z,=iSse;frFe+irEne
\g\t
E€.EFbE*rE0tE
cCo-{cd(9t*t cil,,u.drU1:d
U
c,oaruEJLJa{/)x
'PtJfr 3 o EE
E = E E ;5EE Eg
Tfl$ Egi6o oa^bo.uoFFcF u
EEfr E iFE E ; !HES E=qgs F3ucEEsgTi€
oo
o
z€:(uY!tE'6=(u:c(
.gug
c.-O5:GltY€r.-yEOuEP'-
5Es-
O|oo- a;O(uP(f.
fi;lF!1L1;E goLr.:a=.2c !1 t''l,b gi
o-
(l,
ll'Eeo=;i r'r.r
uE
(JourrJIJ6-v,v
L.|qur!{Jo-anY
qgoCL
uEja-
6EzE9uPE HE;E; 99e,g *6; Eg E::
isees
;gEEE;_5dFe
.E(u:sr"=9F ao9:,54;ES€ hs-EEHsEEE s{uc<,=:3EFi.-E E
i [E E
= O= ru
= h.3 5
(uIEO
@
Eots,4:dqJ .-
=a=.uECEo
(u
U
=d
ilE(u
;38=Qorug-c)aEoEQ9s,=IH;EF;oE9_nvEEggFsostoi9eb.
(u
|e3ltcJou0
(u
fiJ-FeOqo
=y0., ==tagF&s
oI
(.\a
tu
€q,
ru
3
Fu
u0c;o=oqJg
i,9|E
cu(u
EL
u
(u
aloEu3o6E
oc{,,o,oC
\l$
=o
E(U
EEo(J
(!cE
F
F{d
=t-zuJ
@
E
P
f,g
E.h
o-F
E
$a4l
z.Ltl-lt1lrrlfJt\an;irJ
tnrl
Efi
;iE
i
A.
=o
UzC.o
tsE
c-tr
t_=
A
u:]Edcrl f,
iE 'l; u+l:MfiHon!LCklr'>#9._sldFqD E.l
=E|:U,Fr'r' , ',n tl:: i: lll[' :- ,n|Ilpo
.-E r:r= EIL|f "' oij 0l ru
l! 'ri
!rHq5onEr\c rLl
affg,rii_l,fr F rf;^Hi"q;i
Eo_lnr-lc;jr-{
l]
4ulr{tir-"1
lnd
15
tn
;E
i
aotUztIt4l
b
l;t
,n
qlflJ
trl14L1|llo.gIEtJ
IU
clI
ol
,!:tlIIDLI
dOJ
L:'rU
_tr
+,rIlolC'uiulmo(U
E,. c-.-, tD
ur 14
rrtYfilqo{E 'EelUfE .ul
9o,!i bF.flc)'fir-,g!r d4"1FrO'.-. orE d,
HE'Esi'- o
=rDt, ,
,iri EAe
=r._1
CIrl,-i\-|c1-l
C:li-l
G;n
3g(,
E
,jlr'1
()
IU
=;Uu
rl
l.r;
,A
EPilEfetsDnlB g"ql- tr Lb'E'E;3--'Ernr- ,oo FPutE{"rSiru ,- c'iiFEF-l n{cZ qi- d,q it ".rfi .- ei'8fi,'.o-POLq F
..€.SEp b
"\F FAr{';
$<
(l)
<l\II
h0(-''1
$<
<-ta
()
;>
I-r I
'{flFl
tq
o-r;.E
(/)
.FU(U
(U
oE
E
5
Cm
x,zTIJo
+(\.E;
(uE
(E
zLUo
EI
ULL
Er.!
-E
(Il
-:lE.o6E
=o7
I
<ta',J
l)L
E(I'
't=
fit
E
(EIIJ
EEo3
f
g.I LJ
tlrl =E '.7
L tr, ilJ;1. -tt' rocn cD
m tl-'55*P i'ifEJJ;=fltLlll bqc=cCUUflLL'J'i:: u4 u k(DETULJz=l,i u:T1E F-
L L .'
-= cl qJ ':)'{uE-o-
o.l-c;(U
Eq
ftiEi! (It
ul:(u3':J
O
ru.,(U:Zi-
=o-{n11dacr'l
11r"lr1
--rll
-l+Frr\gilEtrA
F(4o
LUzfE;;fH
t=-E
=,.\
IE14
oilL
cPJ[E.F 11,ccdl ,!L1trrtl Lu+rEE.!,1 ,Dll
DN;
frlu=a} lrlFtPfiEE 'in'ij 1y
fiIEu,I UEtr [I-fiD1rED-t),E o.t
fi+^9,
q!
FI
n')
r{
U-l
.\.?fi-j-aor
TU
EFA
tstr)
LUzCo:lJ
U
EE
l-
EEPiug"fifi*El-ro
H [qPrrd--tL mrrt ul,J - FII
'HFtflE3;:t sH1EHgi,E!!'u,Lt ,L ,L'l,rvOi5E*cEO-o
frtruu'5 m' U ,]rJul-C,th,fi9
E.4r.JCJ,,'.iLJ
cjIJr-iTJ
:[nii
q"
;iE
A
=,flo+,lrlzt:fl
ticl,-;trl
;-l
A.
tu .*
Fr=0Jd$E,v
-8ftu|Drnc]rJ'r-g';F'" H E (/
fr6 E ErhEsgr: lu ,L'l L,a ;u ,91 ".1
,3Edilbr. H,,,
#HTE.;[ E E #Jtyr'.fru"uEi
MJJ
FpE "? I $.*jrEfi
F; fr P IJ
ft"#[EE^
of s b-
:t(Lln{tto(JL'\qt(aIf_:=Lrl-lr{-\3
"E
itEl..A
AVIrCl
+rtrJz;:r:l
ti4r
,-ticl-Et
5jl5
A
!trIE
ll.l hEO!' unE,C-.Js8llr oi,fiC
ciLDF6!11 1l-LOJ !UEfi
EIEE ru .!l!4 .r4 -cIirrUbnE>c'l; *dci,a 5F!uru=
I,i g
Jfi5igAsil
=(
(D
.(II
ho
$<
<-rta
()
S.r
;'l'r I
q\
.E
-vf,6ILbO r!
==E.9+ .l'Aq
=E,E ftr
-E-Li
1r4EEro5YL"
a 2,.,-tz -- -j--tJtUCr,!uo
E-:ruy,lElq
,rr (U O<g o-
=(EIfltrrq
roLft(f,
c(f
E\)IJ
(Url0m
=-E4t
ru(U
zi:t
HLo,rEulu(Jl
SEze
LI rE
Eh10O.TloL'bEca_Rii irl -*'L-t4n :: rof. r.lJ uol:,p
,:llc
|jrlub,l'.gE
rlt if,ErtsE<fu
i;iFg-.,)L:'.Fc:IDh,; ,CJ U
,E
E F E E.(.TqILrIPLu:i:--
= i: .t lri
m
o(n<nN
coN
r
(OLNO
tRg
ctx?
'tro
i\i c
NN
N
N
ot
€a
d
F{
chcl@N
FN
F€|l
c.l 6'.:, !
6
xo'- o-r.{d
N
N
0o
Eo+.(ELt>tcogEoL't\oz.=LottIE3C'stzFvl
tro+,ot-tPcoIJgo(,Novl-=LoPLIEJ(tqf
zFttl
=9 o^ g
-E 6: 3
Es ES Esll,,lt:
8S8Sg
J3ooJoTA
ozLoJPL(u5dsfzF.a
m
fn
(\
coN
NN,^ !-fn4-d:,!
!l o,\ a-
NN
iN
N
00
RP ARROx6tdF(:lunlFn
fi
fi(Jl
00a\l
l-=N
XO t.E
trl E;{Ecl 'E
'r L
Ntr{
q)
! o^ Y,OJ F_+ iJJ (/) r-t cn
"qE cc.-\ F -.H b =,4.
E !=F Hg Edin?1|tu
SgBRFc: tsB[i3$?8P
!ooJo.goz->LCJJPlF|E
=d(o
zFtn
rlrY)
(f,(Y)
(flr\
00c'l
t\a{
:YOtt!
;rj &si-oRSc'la'j
r-l[\(fN
oo
co+,.uLPcouqolJoF{
I
o-Er-o+,tE
=drozFUI
:^.:c
!!o6flss8!!:
:
i i fJF.f
I
zIgStooo-
-FEoz(9Ero
I
F{
zoF
F.Aah
Ed
,l
r.(-
,l,l'u
g
cld
DOA{
ail
.Y
,=i'
frfr'
DrlA'r
{aEr'
o,-ttsr\
F
E
3EEF
*
I
q3
4
:+r-:'
-f
I
,4d
la
r
f;r.f, u'' bFi ::-' fJ
(gpluolptporuo3
.I3A
Er/toz{ftE(tqq.
u7
ctNLttof
CT
!L
m
ttcL
o.!jco
=ca,
!t|rlL0t
f,
=
E
oclfl
arlFEt!oc
Nct!
!ELo6
oqI@
t:t)
(L)
l-r II
i=0)
;>(l)
(D()
(D
(D
;>
l'rl
O
E.dr
(,
oa,c
.Eo
!E
o6
Orv!nV!
@
rrlr-l
c!,!tut
of,3!!c=oo(J
ocN@
orNoi(DrA
o(D
EEd
tnnd
="trlt
E.
F
E
D-
oQ
:fb0
E
B
(U
(EU
(,.^oU q.
=tr
i.5
'ui
pi
.E
a
EE
.g :.SH@:U*
6o
+onH
DD:
;:ibEgaqdra@t
i r,";El't
d
bgYF--3 368a:.EE
E;9E!ho=Fo ,l 6zd:l-l
;iE2Eo-SEIUI.efE93Ede8g;uEh=i4690E-F:;;P:l; e r;E::E3E.iUr>H(rqzrtA:oou=r:=6C',r-oe!6l:E=q1'
;'iPd@!E::';fEatii9ao.{a.-8.=.ErrF;;5ood:.]codEEi:.r-ht,;EqJqooq
EI;ETEIE.iaR;;E;!|'Esort -to.,EEou
=!t/64;jir?or==
ETaqF(l:.EEe{:"roooo"C)=Zz=< tr (r tt rt I
o.
,G,
4l
{
==
=.t.9troEe€trgf(J
tnr-{aftJ
UF
ftr
=dE
Lgho
'foP.E
o
=OJL-
=PrUL
Uo_
L
d1
FL
UPm
BrDOJ(/)
F'oluo.luIs
o-rD
.E
=
\oo'rOO
I
c{#(:
=
;qclOr-l
i
==
\og\a
OO
I
NP
:tr
\c)o\OOr{
I
FI,tc:)
tq
(J
Ir!P
\d'o\OOrl
I
.=
:f
H(J
I
N.P-
)
N13FI
rr.ts
=
E.ET'cIE#utEzOpIJ(u
o
(ucF
:<IJ.l(u
+)
a(uVt(E
E.!F
=EoidrC#!
t(J
i=(1)
;>{)
{)()
(D
(D
l-r
;>
l'r I
qw
.= rJooo- .EUtro.6.otuF00-
LJlJ-
'orE
(EPala
.)4
(!r!-d
o
=
gEEFE +fiqE('tJo
ts
LNcn
I
OO'r
oU
Uo
.5Li
o,E0.iFTJ
EtuFU)
dzrtlo
OErub
UJ
4,aEF<z=6rE2tc<zc+UEF==<>utoz=oE(!,
@ttl::U
3!lro
oqJ
z
,P
o6D
EtozE0@
OJ
B
UUorlzt-'
c.o
0+oJ
so0i5
'!U(]
zt.-
qi
IFt.b!o l'.
u l.t+--OUil*,0teo::.igz'it6Eo :: ,._
,c:E8.EEoPt,"r|lo*tiflE,;$lgq-. o cI fiEU9U
il
', E-,-E
=E!
OJ
g
i
f31b0
.E
.t
sdJ
o]Efo(9
o
E
;E
;>(D
;>(D
(D()
$-{
c)
()
;'I'r I
E,oIE
d'
o
L'cE
o
uilE
iIz
(J
i!j: d'.-:.. ,
,iT
'r.' n
.i t'
i! ' .'-" -g ;:. f [': 1r' 9 i;r
'r[.rr.,iii,],l:mrlr'atr{-rir4 n trl>!L4r{r{r{rdl
ligf','.,'.d::fq{r{l4l
*;i:frll.sIlljr ; r n r{ m n q
Ar(lFF-Ftri.:-' ,- ,- r/l rrl vl 4 vl
'i,
F
t!
!e
!l
il
E{l
t
tlF
t:E
.;
?
i1'iji
I
Vl
O
ij
ft
'L
fi
l:
F
=
=oEEui
=E
.q
4!,
up
-tr
_t:
oEqJ
E
30'lr
E
o
Is.9r0
d
(l
(D
O9r
(n(D
$-{()
i=II
i;(l)
,>C)
c)()
t1
S-r
a)
C)
S<
l'r l
qd
(:l(:)
.,:
qlc)(:]
t
l, ',.,1
rl
nl .ilt; !'.
u0
l
l)
"rl,r.
' ' '.t;"(,.rrr{lf
'
"h,t';ft
F
FC)
==o.DE(llt=EC0u
ho-tfL.ll
eLogc,oELo,
o3oE
;cJocIE(t
UE
IU
q0
tr
m
ocU
Uj
uru
aEm
h0
T
Emtq
(l
U
EE@
l'0c'trl1:cU
m
U
0t0
Em
tlc
@
EnEh0
mrEmql
bxlE)o(J
\l
z
triEmEti0cmLEm&F
=m
=
'fE
+d:!f in
;ELdc-mElu 14
bor!!Eo?goP(J
"., t2
-otJt
m
{aEcXm.:EI'tt -:Jc uiimrd_cEtim
EHlc
roEro
dEz.Fo{/I C
c-ef,tro
J
Ea
$<G)
7>l-r()r>
(.)(:.1
{t
rlCfCt(l{:1
dC)(t
r.i
L(ll
oEoho-
J
90tCig
J,f'n
E
'4i'l
r-r[
E"
=)t-=i\
:a;
E.r
t::
\,
F&oFrr!&Fz14o()
zfrl
r!&trr
CJ3O.Ecn&gBItvUFNIN
Io+,-q)
LoccJN.=cfl.c)ri-ON(oo(--
-t-
.CU
o-oI-
tFol-
o*,oo-LL
oO
r_
O,PF --.-aCP
L'=omEbP-c --2b=o9Gt=oo '-^| '|.J--'t \-55q)-LL
i5--ro#oq)EE;\/t- !-
SUQO
bcn+, T)qCDor=
g Etr
cq)o-co+rEbO(--o69E35ctHsUcFOFl_xo
-Yo)Z, tlt- O)
,^r +'O .Y+,c) x(U\/ Fco :=irF
ij irb+ pd"9.-E EEOiFOo Eoa\.rcg frs,I fi-eiE \,, fn)Xo-E 5ei= E !
OtlLO
+,-ooC)-
;oq)
Etr,w
o)LOE_v,^\\/ -tNfi3FEE
==I' c)
PEoc)l-
=rd59X\-., 7rrbEs8$Eo
ww1
g.5S{rO c.)
PJtr.(sOJFEr:OqJH 9Px\v alt-,'| ,) \y
A.H=o65(V. 'i n.\J
.\ T E g;.t,.t, \l,, .{J li .- d )5: E F.E .9 E5EB EEirEEqEai ;"= i;
= 5 t;b 6 E * 7; r u 6 h
H ; H€ E HDE T E Y
FrE iH E.EF'E#EFil E,H U 8-3U€ F.g="*;
x
gI
AJ
J16F
bo6
c6
(c
I-r
>''o)
L)
-OF l-i
X-v7.cntr .F?
;) cJ
(/)AJ
s6UFr0)
3
9-.
a.)bo
(-.
6c
qnH
30 E(- 'l-r L aF Ar 6t .F
O Y.Y H.-J\aP.L) .-- -: r_'
t'\.)trOrrl,'F-vFr,o'.a H 0)
--\LJ'65|0otr 3)- eFTFJd
+vY.!='FF .Fr (J (l)boS-i-At (3 F (-.JE; qJ tr A:s.sts -oE'<= U >-., 5 G-) E od "a' U) O-,,
\oI
U
vr,.F
H .I.J \JFi a | .lFJov(6
JJ-\F<
H H 6 dU
d5EH=@&
c.*IL;UF
(J5O.=ch&
(..:f6CL. Fcrr &
FI BilL:iUF.NsIN
(Joo-=.t&
=o=EodEo(J
+,a
J :o OA = '1
qPa ;
=E 8.
-LF.-L o F Fo o-
oo oo o
(J5CI.-u)eREtt.HUFNIN
,.\.rr""."
1j
.{-)5rc(-t-{C)
tl
t-{d
rfi|)
.FldF{
lr{
>\€J
-F)V)
$-{rfi
.F)-lFl()
rp{s-l?-F{
o()
r!
(,5aE
RgUF
aoO
:oo-
$rts,(-
o(-Fo-oq)
c)a-9mo.J
l-
.=
at-
o1-
:I
Fl-
;o+,()
o1-
oO,l\ftl\|t
+,l-
-\Looo.l o-
9,E+o+,Fo1d tro=c)E-il:e ggEEUE^ed.qJ. o o_-o'c)
-l-tArl
oOc$+,
.9,
=3b*---l-EO Aoi .oo)x c$^ -cclr oGO .O
=1-OYu>'n C C.=; (U a)oo m E
==t'- o-o6 fi -er-O- F O
r(u_g-9-,o+J A \ :!,5=Fo_o -e F'o@2 O H Nrt'\ \v _ \J O-adm F u cu
?2 i;-l,$YS;r-$ i; m o-m.9, E - .>o;i 5.q E- 5 .9H: d o o 'd
--=t-t-f-t-F+lo- o- o_ o_
o @ow
c)=h=
a-\<al-
co+,$oI-l-ooc$a+,C)$o-
Etl
o+,coEa@o@@$ccG
o)qt-o
.=coEoc$JqoEoo)$c$E
@
.qo)o+,(Ul-+,aao
+foob-o
IFo+,coEo-oc)
oco(-
.ts,
l-
o)=ot-l-+,+,-oEc)
ol-o-
E
.=
$fol-
\
1[v
o)ct-o
.=coEcc.o
o)lD c)Ll-
ago=F
!-o.=lZ-(Ut+rva'Ec=oo6o-n\ .=-,Gl- tlool-
I r{-,+r-o6otr
F -=o\v o)
EEOG-otr- -FdP-
LtrG
F
oofiLrtsotztUoGOo
t{-o
.=ooo-$oo-+,ooc$l-
!
c|.U
o
Re+,
PgatrY.=.tooEo)(Uc-o
,-\v
9b-5oE5aoccgb-c
T;Eo cu-cohFtq=66bFP 3giFotsG+' -
3R=tr@bEEEo
a()aoo-l-
o-
G'=+,af1)l-
.-
ottsEc)a
o-Ocf)
-(u(-
rts,
Ot-ot-F(-
.=
-tt-
Ci (- (-
\ogE=9)$ o o-.F a a(\aTrOOOvl---C.IFE$5 rF' rts
,aoo\r'I- l- t^- F\
7=raFi
-. -l\l:l .FE _, _)l- \Lf l- F._ I. Iocr-'cN$P_ (u '= 'E\v+r 66lts(Ul^-
A:oO--'>\6\!-OE$ o).o .s .=PNE O oI--r^a--
!trEvFE= cO)\vrFr-AA-o \u.= N o@>'.qarcN= ooorr\-CCEEVJ /^\ t- l-gSU$cu
J- i^$v=E9rD\$$' .a t .9, .9.z;5Q
u u u:'-FRo o{)) o o
-1--F-
liL I
OFHFF
@.L-
.Fgc)
EEj<$
ESaI$Elz cDGCO O,9
388ooo-E6 ?FLtrHO'=;a
\.-
+$fiCUgC
l-Naac)(Jq)(-
t-o(-+,oc(-$
$o)CUz
IFo
.=Oo-+,
.=F
.=at-
.a(Uq)t-
.ebL
Lrool- +J
bso.=>.oF-
8'stu+l6oOS
H=ct&9BItHUF
E ,i L4 ii, I E l-1 r:, ,f] r\,rt-- lr L-) !: fr r'" \'. ti, :,J r i r!,: (v1 i, r.l
lllllliltittl-_-tI I i I i r r I I I t l _l_-l
-n
*iul:,-'
.I iD _'-
I
, !,..
I
-C)F'.:) \,,
ui^v(--rF
t-lfrl
;I O:i: .
-!., Aa\rJ \JU
rv
lll =
u)LJ \J d)
a
^=1il i: X -lrrj' :J \Lf -F,€ft
ill .\ rVr-\ q" dt
P'-., ! -!7'. l.i(-1
.J-) Friir 't'' C) "=l,l,i !i d :\r
F(r*t,-*c;I v _J-)
:t: \J h0r', n, f-{i-31 Fr(.i, <tt Fr 'I-,-cV,J'
ir -. i,)'J re. /-\ct vE'!i cn ,slV)
i'*'i!
- :>( \1I r\ f-1u- (+ .p-r
(-! rtrlFI\r' c-l
- f-!
\A\,/ \.ia-\ '7-lil\|\r,
I .i.
rf,:..f
r
EE*F
:- rll@(Li3;oq)o-+i;lo-{sAZYOfuO- Lrl
Utv
!-,X,
F_
q)
o0.,1
I-rl
frlrF)
ITI
r)f r I
['*Ir
III
I
Iqt;,B-s,{}At tunlufl I,j tE Lrd_Ltl
'lLU4J aleurpr(_)r}il, ,\
,l
oo -o
oP(AUa<A
(:.)
C)fll
ts l'r-- (L)
t-
<r .r-(A ;R'
4)X
();f1;*r i::::
U'J i,;i'
H"i:i
Hi5sii,iii11
:iili
--lrlIIll
I
riilrl
I
I
I
I
- ,rrr,
0,r,,, ,,r
r.r,,
*r_'r,tl,)"
,r,,o
rl_
:';:i,
ll ,,t/O:/
.?i.',,,r
' i:,, ',r.ri'-
!:;ail
iil .'=
(D (t)
"'t (lJrrl
cr:, .i--;L(i tfil
ur
Llt!:l ,.
T-
-ll
l:ur '-,j'): rr,
Gi
t;1_l
(l,, ,(-]
ut ,n
tl.FoI9sdX
=u[ C\ L)il c,o(;) E
LUfl OJ
IY;: O$^r""--Y
'l(
iii'ri
I
I
.\-_
\rl- r'l
I-r I
L.Q
r)l-r I
t.-L
[,l:,
f r'lI
(r178-S$/v\ r,unujcl Nltf) lry j.n lrul) iirsutt).100) .A
()+toFL
o+,Oo
.=EE-'=
Ec)c)o..aE-
=
N+,CU
F\t-t (J ,5, CLi=F CN&lll aR
= l{51- lld
lt=gR
qN
o-
Or
o_
NozNoacot--a$c)EO-oot,
al-ot,oE$r-$
o_
c)(-+,E-$
f fi=il 394 PgEJ:F
r-O-cF €E 3E E u) ?cu c o.E IEqS"-P#NE.EEo= Grht-5 U,=E POr^l E O-r-b: ge F, tq cf '+, +,O.= : \.c
PE =E3;E PQEc o'=.st cu-\
/t\ -r
= -15 A o a
= (l) -c r-f
I=E olg
=-c E $ r)'EiJ ^
-l
V -o€ cstu xm= o
c=O.= @
=OOJ.==E eEdl bec @'FOrl\\vcO'F= O O-c-u-E,
=E = F bc c Sl =\==
-=
=EEE F fu86E f nvc
g8 E E HcAG'ic;Ee = ef; q E sfi=O:o_ Etg
= Fa5--E irrc-
o-ar E) do J o
53r 5Ee gfi e f8=E Efj 6 3 5 E
l
{llrg6'F6= 5q 8.5 EAEil H(}4sc E
€c
a
=
|r)6)ll-)
$
s]t.1
H}r.D -
o
atiffi6
=f.-:.
UIdolf) o
Ed
aulr L)NinX
IBtu, /41
I
tr
d
?g-SSM u.rrueg 'N Lg tilln '(tuq) epurprooD A
Ji:)
i\2
(J5a=
R$UF
ELNEO9o- rFacY.9
+,'l-oE
tF!g-+t +,l- 1-
96r- (J
9al--#.-+-t.:t$a7rr a
U'tr5r-$ORc)v-
-+,
8BEEJ$ofOOcOo+,'FA(U (l).=
+t +, /t\a '6 \-'r1'{r
-lYO E=O-
c)F A O
o+,aco_Ol--O;c)c\./=P CIEr-
- -Oo- 1,
=*r.=-oqoA.=\'' C)(U0_
=.= t- (U.=$zoot-ccc$cECDO=
lEN$; O tuO$ o .o0-l-5 o c9,c -?
==I io aco = ocf-t^c$I 5 .9xXzr c HtUu 6 0 #=: 'E v) i;
=S S PUOaa=lr\ c +J li OE; E oo-
nrvt
c: c) 1=.!}E N
Il H, -E
ir € 6€ii E gii[t R ;rrEii riijDEiv nt i?
r1.."ir rrJ
1;j r,:ri J
-j'
.',j' : ,i;l
rii t..l
"r: i
Li.;
l'4 r&r--'t .1.\
Irt:l-l::lSirri rr.urrl|liil('l I,j ll,Li li,,!l"f I iLlllqlf ;r1uiltfi.il{_]L]ti.] ,1,
t;-,1i
:L-J\a
l
61,, :::
&t'l' ,rl
#:,1 :i:
iil|i,.,''ItllItrlJ .:l
|l | :.tfll :l
rl
L
I'r-l,1i.,
;,:)(,l'rl
r'{-
f r'
I J-.
''r7'
t ,*.L
('l
I
l-r I
Qr)
gc
.Fli-)d
-F)(-F{C)aC)$-r
Fr+io-c-Ft
r!
ATTACHMENlI
IEN.tN\.
e
oE6g
o
Io
N
=
-g
o
EDoEo ,.
AE;Hgd
}Poo6>O LIJ
azOUEA!;
,2
EE>ooqECoo
OO
coOoZZ
.g6g
o
;qN^
id6OE
o;oi
;o_=AENN
z.d!co9
x!Xn';v-oE6Ea2o
=cE=,-=P6 !i90-:Yc=s=3 EJts:
o
lv
oca
bida?ofox9
<ooozz
.E
a
6oE
o
I
Io
o
Eo
uogG
g
o
oog
Nc
O
o
;oPN
,P!
,pEo
oEoo
eo
o
o
E
P
oEo!ooP
Eo
=
o
1A
o
o
ofdzttYt
o0co
.tscoE
o
EUJ
q)
G
3
t=
?
(o
rJ)
Eqo
ON
EooN
C;
ot
=TU=o6ttl
o]A
3I
a
r)
Eo
ON
C)o
P3oOJ
c
Nc|!
!ttrovt
Go.T'n't
N
O
N+
()(l\+
OOOs
OqN
oON
No
CLovl
Nj
N
@
ooN
s6
j
o!J d
N
@ol
@
OoqNo c;
=
€n
O
o
O
c;r
O
'-
F.
;
t!I
ooE
r-{
tr
!tE
ovl
Lo4!tm
O
^lm
o4
c)
d; o
OOc
flf N
o
o.ottl @
o
h
NN O
O@
O
m
nO
o05
N\N
O
o)@
N@
ornnn
0o
Nr ct
: N
OOd)
r@
Oo6r
oNO.i
trof
uo,flt!3!!coo(,
Go-!l{n
OO@
OOc)Nm
Oo
(f(f
.1o
CL0)
atlm
O@q
ONN
@
O
qNr
O
ci
q03
oo?
6
Ooct
Oq 6q@@
O
oo
c;
f.'l6 N
OO
non€n
oor
4
oG}
EGL
A
Ezo
I
E-olLF,az
.>
fbt)
E
n
E
oU
='5od)
o6(u
od<
o5._= O ';
c,
o5
U
o)
G
3
OJ
-
Table 8. Seawater Temperature Monitoring
COOLING WATER TEMPERATURE AND RESIDUAL
CHLORINE SAMPLING POINTS
sPc
SeaWater Temperature Monitoring (3,rd euarter 2015)
Sampling
Loetiorn
(Temp. in'C)
Unit:.2-1.00%
Unil 1-100%,
Unit2-100'%
Unit 1-100%,
Unit2-LO0%
Unit 1-100%,
Unil:.2-tOO%
Unit 1-100%,
Unil.2-L00%
DENR Standard Temp. Inc. in'C (DAO 90-35)
World Bank Standard (lFC) llased on the EIA of the project (
M1
N42
M3
lv14
M5
POW€R CORPORATION
Table 16. Ambient Air
AMBIENT AIR qUAtrTY (Third rarty Conrducted by OMU)
Station/[ocation
PARAMEIERS
Observations during si rmpllng
PM.1O, Soz, Nor, Noise, CO'
UglNcm USlNcm UglNcm dB ppm
Minimum Detection
LimitL 0.01 0.01
DENR Standard, 1-hr 200 340 260 75 JU
DENR Sta nda rd, 24-h r 150 180 150 75 30
World Bank Standard
(l FC, 1-hr) 2ooc 70
World Ba nk Sta nda rd
(lFC,24-hr)50 20 40
Brgy. Ta ngke,
Basketball Court6 36 3 55 0
Y Time: (O9lO4/LE)/ ]t:zs-oz:zs
> Wind Directior NE to SW
> Sampling location, Brgy, Tangke L
near stage area. Slightly rainingat tsampling source ofnoise children I
sysrem,
asketba ll Court
: time of
rying& sound
\long National Road
lor., Al i nga nga St., Nea r
)eri meter Fence of SPC
)ower Corp.
2t) l <L 63 0
! Time:(09/04/ ;l/ LL:I'AM-IZ 5PM
> Wind Directiori: NE to SW
> Sampling location, Aliganga St. n(
Plant, alongthe roaF, Sources ofnopeople passingat the time of sampl
cars passed 88
r fence ofSPC
e from cirrs a nd
g. Total no. of
Near Pier Area inside
the power plant site141 L5 4 of, 0
> rime: (09/04/1 )/ 10:10-11:10
> Wind Directior NE to SW
> 5a mpling locatior
&YardArea Boiler
time of sampling. S(
r, Near PierArea,
l.&2 runnins. Slid..-,t,UrCe OT nOlSe lfo
WaterTreatment
htly ra ining a t the
n Boiler I &2,
I n front of Ma ngki ki s
Cha pel, Sitio Ma ngki kis72 37 3 56 0
> Ti me: (09/04/ il/ 1,2:1,c)-07 PIV]
> Wind Directio :NEtoSW
! Sampling locatio4, Brey. Mangkiki
Roque Chapel. Resitlential Area sli
tlme of sa ml)lins
nearSeniorSan
rltrainingatthe
At the Back of Kadi ng's
Residence (North
Pobl aci on )E
84 <1. 2 J6 0
> Ti me: (09/03-0 4 / ts)/ 7O:3O. ):30AM
) Wind Directior NE to SW
! Loocation is Nadiirg's residence, r
a rea, a pproxi mate lV 100m from KSP
Sources ofnoise: children playing, ar
ve h icl es,
ar the st ore
perimetrr r.
rlts talkiilgand
DColon Barangay Hall 18 62
Y Time:109/04/7 )/ 01:00-02:00t
> Wind Direction:NE to SW
} Sampling locatior
plant & outfall ofSP(
the area Sources ol
loiteringaround To
private cars,2traysi
, Back ofColon
) Plant. There ar
noise: te I evisio
:al vehicles:4 m
Kao
gy. Hall near the
bystanders in
radio, clrildren
:orcycle:,2
'Near Ash Village 52
Y rlmet:109/04/1 / 02:05-03:051
> Wind Directio NE to SW
> Sampling location, Relocation Site
Sources of noise: chif dren swimming,
roosters & vehicles
ide ofthe plant,
ocking of
Q,"f ,o*,^,o,,
' I nte rnationa I ly-a cce pted sta nda rds use a n a ve ra gi ng ti me of 24-hou rs
) US-EPA Na tiona I Ambie nt Air eua lity sta nda rds (NMeS)
WHO Ambi ent Ai r Qua lity Guid eli nes
)Add itiona I sa m pli ng station for a s h pond operation monitori ng.
24-hr monitoring period
sPcluTroN
$ENN\sr
6!
.(
:::i
;;ii
2l
ri,!1
ri
o-
I:
2i
t9
=::l
0)0)
zlF'
Cl
ii
lie9
=
CL
c'
2F
F
-c)
EI'o. c)
z:)q ,al
o.,q
X o.9o:t >
;.t"-
; EEo90
z=:
=Jo!!o
:U
o
ouco
=qd!!
o(9
3oz
@
@
{z \z {z z {z o nct
Noo
o eo e
coc
IJ
.9d
6
7
eo
h
ooI
oo
oaI
Nooo
4oo
ooo
clNooo
=N
Nooo
oqI A
ooo
N
c;
7
oN
o qaN
oN
q
@".i
NoqI
oo
oo
To No@
oN
e oNN i
N
ct
hoI
oo
ooqo
N
oRr
EN
qr @
o o q oo@
Noqo
Nqo
o
Iooqo
@
N
oro
7
o
hr
o@
c o i oN
co o
oo I ?
ooci
NN
oooo
ooI
o
I
I No o @
N@
ooo I c
6
oro o
Noqo
=nr
o o co N
oqrl I
ooo
ooco
N4
qoo
ooo
Noco
z
ccq
rr
qN
o q o@h
!)?)
o ooqo
oI@
or@
f
o NoN
o oN
o@
@
o l)f I
ooo o
o@
o@o
= No@
q o oqo@
on
|\()
INoo
ho
Iooo
@oN
7
qo
6N @
o o @N
oo@
(f() I
qo
N
@
o@
o@
od
tso o
oN@ V
C)C)() o
ooo o
o4
oro
EN
o@
o qo
e@@
()()(f
o oqo
ooqI
\ or@o
@
@
E
64
ro
E
o
E;o
o6
-bE
ciE
ui:
E
af
oo
d;E
oF
F]
.i>i:>
<i
EUE
z
bE
ME
-
E
2
zE
a
E E
I
!!oc,
oEoE
|!
3=t:o(9
OJ
4tGF
HE
R$
UF
N\IN
H-b;nti
zzi?-LFF.T-
E
zF
;e
I
f
6
E5
0
:j=1l
o
z
.;
i:
q
::o
;P
3n
5E;!
;!d io-9t6
ei^i
422
g5o
CE
oG
3o'tr6
=
-E
ot!
u
oq
u
oEoE
3o
G
'r6E !qZiluH E$
@
q N z(
UoJ
o
6zF
oo?n
N () o uoo
? N
ct
@() ci f\
oo
c)
oo
G
Ed
nt@ @
oo
C)F\
c)
I
zF
4o
@ o Io
N
Fi
o c)
T @
N
oo o
Ntr\
o c)
c)
gd
@ Voo
Nc)
oo
o ct
e
7
Ao
h
N N @ ooo
oo
@()N
o
? a @ o o o r.ooI
c)
sN
dl@ r o
oo
dlo o
F.N
^l6l
ooo
c)c,clc,
=
o@ o
oo c
I @6l
qo
clc,cl
@@ o q
oNN o cl
E'
d
EN
€ o aq?
N
N o
7
eo
@ @ oo
@
o o NcI q
?o o o o
o NN
oooqI
EEd
@r
d
ooo
N
ooo
oo
oICI
;iE
oo
E
o6
'bE
/icl
qt
(,
E
.9tr
;)tr>
E
t-
lFz
€
F
E
2E
oE E
u_)-qt
g-cl.G