vision 1.1 strategic actions cover - casqa · vision and strategic actions for managing ... manage...
TRANSCRIPT
Vision and Strategic Actions for Managing Stormwater
in the 21st Century
Version 1.1
December 2017
Vision
Manage stormwater as a vital component of California’s water resources in a sustainable manner, to support
human and ecological needs, to protect water quality, and to enhance and restore our waterways.
California Stormwater Quality Association
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation i
VisionandStrategicActionsforManagingStormwater
inthe21stCentury
Vision
ManagestormwaterasavitalcomponentofCalifornia’swaterresourcesinasustainable
manner,tosupporthumanandecologicalneeds,toprotectwaterquality,andtoenhanceand
restoreourwaterways.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation ii
GuidingPrinciplesTheguidingprinciplestosupportthisvisionare:
Principle: Sustainablestormwatermanagementusesrunoffasaresource,protectswaterqualityandbeneficialuses,andefficientlyminimizespollution.
Principle: Policies,regulations,guidance,training,andfundingneedtosupportsustainablestormwatermanagement.
Principle: Publicawareness,understanding,andappreciationofthevalueofstormwaterisessentialtosustainablestormwatermanagement.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation iii
PurposeThisVisionandStrategicActionsweredevelopedtoaddresstheprimaryissueforstormwatermanagement:ThelackofconsensusonhowbesttomeetthegoalsoftheCleanWaterActforstormwater.CASQAdevelopedthisVisionandStrategicActionsforitself,itsmembers,andthepublictopursueacomprehensiveplanforstormwaterthatwillachievethegoalsoftheCleanWaterActandsustainablestormwatermanagement.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation iv
PrefaceThestormwaterprogramisinitsthirddecadeofimplementationbymunicipalseparatestormsewersystems(MS4s).Permitteeshavemadegreatstridestoaddresstheimpactofstormwateronlocalreceivingwatersthroughfocusedoutreachtothepublicandanincreasedknowledgebaseoneffectivepollutantremovalstrategies.MS4permitshaveevolvedsubstantially,generallybuildingontheoriginalapproachframedbytheU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency(EPA)forthePhaseIprogram.Theapproachdescribedincurrentpermitsistoreducepollutantsinrunofftothemaximumextentpracticable(MEP)throughtheimplementationofbestmanagementpractices(BMPs).MEPwasdesignedasaflexibletechnology-basedstandardthatwouldchangeovertimetoreflectevolvingunderstandingofpollutantsourcesandstormwatertreatmenttechnologies.Anadditionalrequirementinpermitsistocomplywithwaterqualitystandards,especiallyasimplementedthroughtotalmaximumdailyloads(TMDLs).
TheMEPapproachhasbeenappliedbypermitteestoboththebuiltenvironmentduringredevelopmentandtheurbanizingfringewithnewdevelopment,withvaryinglevelsofsuccess.Newdevelopmentprogramsforcontrolofrunoffwaterqualityfromtheurbanizingfringehavebeenrelativelysuccessful.Permitteeshaveusedlowimpactdevelopment(LID)orgreeninfrastructureandendofpipetreatment(grayinfrastructure)toimprovewaterquality.Permitteeshavebeenlesssuccessfulimprovingwaterqualityfromexistingdevelopment.Traditionalurbandesignprinciplesresultedinalandscapethatmovesstormwaterquicklyoff-siteforconveyancetoreceivingwaters.PermitteeshavefoundthatretrofitofthestormwatersystemwithLIDmeasuresandendofpipetreatmentsintheexistingenvironmentiscostly,technicallydifficult,andrequirestimetoplanandsignificantresourcestofundthecapitalimprovementprojects.PermitteeshavealsofoundthatitisnottechnicallyfeasibletoretrofitallexistingdevelopmentwithtreatmentBMPsandfurther,retrofittingisnotthemostenvironmentallyandcost-effectiveapproachforimprovingwaterquality.
DriversfortheNewApproachThereareseveraldriversforchangeforthestormwaterprogram.Atthemostbasiclevel,thecurrentprogramisfailingtomeetthegoalsoftheCleanWaterAct(CWA)withinatimeframedeemedreasonablebythestakeholders.Drivers–bothchallengesandopportunities–foranewapproachare:
Challenges
• 303(d)listingsandTMDLs.Moreandimprovedmonitoringhasidentifiedwaterbodiesthatarenotmeetingwaterqualitystandards.ThesewaterbodiesarebeinglistedasimpairedunderSection303(d)oftheCWAwithpollutant-specificwasteloadallocations(WLAs)incorporatedintomunicipalstormwaterNationalPollutantDischargeEliminationSystem(NPDES)permits.Thenumberof303(d)listedwatersandthenumberofexistingandproposedTMDLsaregrowingrapidly.The2008-2010303(d)listinCaliforniahas3,500waterway-pollutantlistings.AddingmoreTMDLwaterbodiesisultimatelyunsustainablefrombotharegulatoryandpermittee(implementation)standpoint.Therearefartoomanypotentialpollutantsintheenvironmenttoaddressthemonapollutant-by-pollutantbasis.
Additionally,theTMDLregulations(CWASections303(d–e);40CFR130.7)weredevelopedalmost20yearsbeforeEPAstartedtoregulatestormwater,thereforetheregulationsarebasedonawastewatermodel.Wastewateroriginatesinahuman-made,closedsystem(sinks,toilets,etc.,)thatisrelativelycontrollable.Accordingly,theTMDLregulationsarebasedonthepresumptionthatBMPsexistandarepowerfulenoughtoreducepollutantstoachieveWLAs.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation v
Ontheotherhand,stormwateroriginatesfromanatural,outdoor,andopensystemthatisinherentlylesscontrollablethanwastewater.So,thepresumptionthatBMPsexistforstormwater,letalonearepowerfulenoughtoachieveWLAs,ishighlyquestionable.Andyet,mostTMDLsarewrittenandadoptedasifthepresumptionofBMPsistrueforstormwater.Hence,theregulationofstormwaterseemstheoreticalandoutoftouchwiththetechnicalrealityofstormwatermanagement.
• CompliancewithWaterQualityStandards.AscurrentlyregulatedinMS4permits,stormwaterpermitteesmustcomplywithwaterqualitystandards.ThisinterpretationwassupportedbytheNinthCircuitCourtofAppeals.Thiscourt’sdecisionhasacceleratedtheneedtoidentifyalong-termsolutiontostormwatermanagementthatwillsupportaffordablecompliancewithnumericstandards.
• Waterqualityobjectiveswereinitiallydevelopedtoprotectwaterbodiesfromthecontinuousandrelativelyhomogenousdischargesofwastewater.LiketheTMDLregulations,thereceivingwaterqualitystandardsdonotreflectthedynamicconditionsfoundinstormwaterdischarges,ortheintermittentnatureofthedischarges.Asaresult,stormwaterprogramsstruggletoattaintheexistingstandardsinBasinPlansastheyprovidelimitedvalueindefiningstandardsforwetweatherconditions.Thepublicwillnotinvestresourcestocorrect‘administrative’waterqualityproblemswhennoactualbeneficialuseimpairmentsexist,ortheexistenceofthe‘impairment’isduetonaturalsources.Thisproblemtendstobeparticularlyacuteforrecreationqualitystandards,whereregulationtoprotectswimmersisnotapracticalbeneficialuseduringperiodsofhighflows.
• ProgramFunding.Sufficientresourcesneedtobededicatedtowaterquality.Moststormwaterprogramsarefundedthroughmunicipalgeneralfunds.Thecurrentfundingstructurepresentsamajorchallengeforelectedofficialsastheymustbalancethefundingofthestormwaterprogramwithotherprogramssupportedbythegeneralfund,includingsuchthingsaslawenforcement,fireprotection,andotheressentialservices.Permitteesmustbeabletoclearlycommunicatetheneedandconsequencesofinactiontothepublic,sothatresourcesforstormwaterprogramscanbeprioritizedalongwithothersocialprogramsfundedbylocalandstategovernments.
Opportunities
• Stormwaterasavaluableresource.RecurringdroughtconditionsinCaliforniahavespotlightedthevalueofstormwateraspartofthesolutiontoprovidingareliableandsustainablewatersupply.Stormwaterneedstobeaddressedmoreasanimportantresourceandlessasasourceofpollution.
• Ascentofsource-basedBMPs.BMPsareanotherareawherethewastewatermodelismisleadingifappliedasistostormwater.Firstandforemost,theBMPsforwastewateraretreatment(e.g.,primary,secondary)andimprovedBMPstendtobemoreorhigherlevelsoftreatment(e.g.,tertiary).Ontheotherhand,thebestmanagementpracticesforstormwatertendtobethosefocusedonthe‘sources’ofstormwaterpollution.Stormwaterpollutionismadeupoftwopartsorsources–stormwatercombiningwithpotentialpollutants.Minimizethechancesforthatcombinationandstormwaterpollutionisavoidedorpreventedwithlittleornopollutionreductionrequired.Preventioncanbeaccomplishedbyreducingeitherorbothofthetwoparts.GreenInfrastructurereducestheamountofstormwaterandTrueSourceControlreducestheamountofpotentialpollutants.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation vi
o GreenInfrastructure–EPAstates“Greeninfrastructureisacost-effective,resilientapproachtomanagingwetweatherimpactsthatprovidesmanycommunitybenefits.Whilesingle-purposegraystormwaterinfrastructure—conventionalpipeddrainageandwatertreatmentsystems—isdesignedtomoveurbanstormwaterawayfromthebuiltenvironment,greeninfrastructurereducesandtreatsstormwateratitssource…”Greeninfrastructureslowsrunoffbydispersingittovegetatedareas,harvestsandusesrunoff,promotesinfiltrationandevapotranspiration,andusesbioretentionandothergreeninfrastructurepracticestocleanstormwaterrunoff.
o TrueSourceControl–Truesourcecontrolfocusesontheoriginalsourceofpotentialpollutantsbyeliminatingorsignificantlyreducingtheexistenceofpotentialpollutants,therebynegatingtheneedtopreventcontactbetweenpotentialpollutantsandstormwaterortotreatthepollutantsoutofstormwater.Thatfocusisdifferentthanthatofoperationalsourcecontrols,whichphysicallykeepthepotentialpollutantsfromcontactingrainfallandstormwaterrunoffthroughcovering/containing,berming,orcleaning.Thatdifferenceinfocusbetweenthecurrentsourceandtheoriginalsourceissimilartothedirectionaldifferencebetweencompassnorthandtruenorth.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation vii
TableofContentsVision......................................................................................................................................i
GuidingPrinciples....................................................................................................................ii
Purpose..................................................................................................................................iii
Preface...................................................................................................................................iv
TableofContents..................................................................................................................vii
Principle–Sustainablestormwatermanagementusesrunoffasaresource,protectswater
qualityandbeneficialuses,andefficientlyminimizespollution...........................................1
Action1.1–DevelopGuidanceforIntegratedManagementofWaterResourcesthatPromotes
StormwaterasaResource.......................................................................................................................1
Action1.2–IdentifyConstraintsandOpportunitiesforMaximizingStormwaterasaResource............3
Action1.3–ProvideEffectiveandEfficientSolutionsthroughTruePollutantSourceControl...............5
Action1.4–WorkwithDPRtoControlToxicityinReceivingWatersfromPesticideApplication...........6
Principle–Policies,regulations,guidance,training,andfundingneedtosupportsustainable
stormwatermanagement....................................................................................................8
Action2.1–ClarifyRegulations................................................................................................................8
Action2.2–ArticulateStormwaterProgramPriorities............................................................................9
Action2.3–AugmentandImplementBasinPlanAmendmentProcess................................................10
Action2.4–DevelopPoliciesandPermittingFrameworktoSupportSustainableStormwater
Management.......................................................................................................................................12
Action2.5–EstablishGuidance/ToolstoSupportSustainableStormwaterPrograms.........................14
Action2.6–EstablishWatershed-BasedorEquivalentProgram...........................................................15
Action2.7–CreateFundingOpportunities............................................................................................16
Action2.8–SurveyNeedsandIdentifyCosts........................................................................................20
Principle–Publicawareness,understanding,andappreciationofthevalueofstormwateris
essentialtosustainablestormwatermanagement..............................................................23
Action3.1–CreateOpportunitiesforMultipleAgencyandCollaborativeEffortstoDemonstratethe
ValueofStormwatertothePublic......................................................................................................23
Action3.2–CreateStatewideMessagethatEstablishesStormwaterasaResource............................24
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 1
Principle–Sustainablestormwatermanagementusesrunoffasaresource,protectswaterqualityandbeneficialuses,andefficientlyminimizespollution.Stormwaterisaresource,withsocial,economic,andecologicalvalueandshouldbemanagedinasustainablemanner.DomesticwatersupplysourcesinCaliforniaarestrained,andstormwaterwillplayanimportantroleinmaintainingaconsistentandresilientdomesticsupply.Using,andreusingwaterwithinlocalwatershedswillhelpmaintainlocalwaterbalance,reduceenergyuse,andavoidenvironmentalimpacttogroundandsurfacewaters.
Stormwaterprogramsmustprotecttheenvironmentandbecost-effectivetoimplement.Foreachpollutant,thereisamostcost-effectivepointofcontrol.Formanypollutants,themostcost-effectivepointofcontrolwillbeatthesource,beforethepollutantcontactsstormwater.Forotherpollutants,acombinationofsourcecontrols,treatmentcontrols,andregulatoryapproachesorbeneficialuseassessmentmaybeneeded.
Action1.1–DevelopGuidanceforIntegratedManagementofWaterResourcesthatPromotesStormwaterasaResource
Background
ExcellentworkhasbeencompletedonplanninganddevelopingCalifornia’swatersystem,butplannersandengineersneedaframeworkthatdescribeshowourwatersourcesworktogether.Theintegratedregionalwatermanagementplans(IRWMPs)haveprovidedapartialanswertowaterplanning,butcanbeimprovedtoincludemoreinformationforstormwatertoensurethatitsupportsthehighestuseofotherwatersourcesinurbanareas.BetterguidanceisneededforthedevelopmentofthestormwaterportionofIRWMPs,totrulyintegratestormwaterwiththeotherwaterresourcesinCalifornia,andtohelpagenciesunderstandhowstormwaterwillbeusedasaproductivepartofthestate’swatersupply.
Similarly,theSustainableGroundwaterManagementAct(SGMA)1requirementsandGroundwaterSustainabilityPlan(GSP)regulationspresentopportunitiestocoordinatestormwaterandgroundwatermanagement.Forexample,underSGMA,GroundwaterSustainabilityAgencies,astheydeveloptheirGSPs,mustaddressanysurfaceandgroundwaterinteractionorinterconnection.Additionally,theremaybeotherintegrativeeffortsinwhichstormwatershouldbeamoresignificantelementandthatwouldbenefitfrommoreinformationandguidanceonstormwater.
Note:ThisactioniscloselyrelatedtoAction3.1–Createopportunitiesformultipleagencyandcollaborativeeffortstodemonstratethevalueofstormwatertothepublic.Theactionssharethesubjectofstormwaterasaresourcebuttheydifferintheirfocusandaudience.ThefocusofAction1.1isinwardtowardpublicagenciesandtheproductionofguidanceforpublicagencies.ThefocusofAction3.1isoutwardtowardthepublicandthepublicityofprojectsandprograms.
Goal:TodevelopguidanceforIRWMPsandsimilareffortsthatintegratesallofCalifornia’swaterresourcestoachieveoptimumusewhileprotectingthebeneficialusesofreceivingwaters.
1Thelegislativeintentofthe2014SGMAisforgroundwatertobemanagedsustainablyinCalifornia’sgroundwaterbasinsbylocalpublicagenciesandnewly-formedgroundwatersustainabilityagencies(GSAs).InthebasinsdesignatedbyDWRasmediumandhighpriority,localpublicagenciesandGSAsarerequiredtodevelopandimplementgroundwatersustainabilityplans(GSPs)oralternativestoGSPs(Alternatives).PursuanttoWaterCodeSection10733.2,DWRdraftedandadoptedemergencyregulationsinMay2016fortheevaluationofGSPsandAlternatives,theimplementationofGSPsandAlternatives,andcoordinationagreements.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 2
RelatedSTORMS2Project(s)
1a. PromoteStormwaterCaptureandUse,2016-2018(projectterm)2a. IncreaseStakeholderCollaborationtoPromoteStormwaterasaResource,2019-20214a. ImplementSenateBill985–IncorporatePrinciplesofStormwaterResourcePlanGuidelinesinto
StormwaterPrograms,2016-2018
RelatedCaliforniaWaterActionPlan3Action(s)
2. IncreaseRegionalSelf-RelianceandIntegratedWaterManagementacrossAllLevelsofGovernment6. ExpandWaterStorageCapacityandImproveGroundwaterManagement
ProposedEfforts
IRWMPs
Objective1. MeetwithStateWaterBoardandDepartmentofWaterResources(DWR)stafftodiscussthegoalofAction1.1anddevelopaproblemstatementaswellasgeneralstepsforcorrectiveaction.DeterminethemostappropriateapproachtoguidethedevelopmentofthestormwaterportionofIRWMPs.
Objective2. WorkwiththeStateWaterBoardandDWRtodevelopaguide(model)forthe
integrateduseofallwatersourcesinCaliforniathatwillserveasarequiredreferencedocumentduringthedevelopmentofIRWMPs.Theguideshouldaddressthefollowingitems:
o Potentialwaysthatstormwatercaptureandusecancomplement,ratherthancompetewith,recycledandgreywateruse
o Incentivesforcaptureanduse§ Methodstoencouragesitebasedcaptureanduse,includingdistributed
greeninfrastructureandinfiltrationstrategiesinurbanareas§ AWaterRightsdefinitionforcapturedstormwater,eitheratthesurfaceor
afterinfiltrationo Potentialconflictsbetweenuses(stormwateruse,habitatprotection,flood
control)andproposedsolutionsforconflictso CriteriaforapplicationofmodelguidelinestoIRWMPso Stepsforintegratedplanningwithotherorganizationsandagencieso Requiredpartnerssuchaswateragencies,etc.o KeyfindingsoftheSTORMSProject1a/1breportandrecommendedactions
relevanttoIRWMPguidance
2STORMSisastrategy-basedinitiativedevelopedandmanagedbytheStateWaterBoardthatiscloselyrelatedtothisVisionandStrategicActions.ThemissionoftheStrategytoOptimizeResourceManagementofStormwater(STORMS)is“toleadtheevolutionofstormwatermanagementinCaliforniabyadvancingtheperspectivethatstormwaterisavaluableresource,supportingpoliciesforcollaborativewatershed-levelstormwatermanagementandpollutionprevention,removingobstaclestofunding,developingresources,andintegratingregulatoryandnon-regulatoryinterests.”3TheCaliforniaWaterActionPlan–originallyreleasedbytheadministrationofGovernorBrowninJanuary2014–is“aroadmapforthefirstfiveyearsofthestate’sjourneytowardsustainablewatermanagement.”
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 3
Objective3. WorkwiththeStateWaterBoardandDWRtofinalizetheguide(model)byadoptingitasarequiredreferencedocument.Developanimplementationplan,includingscopeofwork,schedule,resources,androles(includingleadandsupport),andresponsibilities.
SGMA
Objective1. MeetwithStateWaterBoardandDWRstafftodiscussthegoalofAction1.1andhowstormwateragenciescanplayasignificantroleinthedevelopmentofvariousGSPs4(statewideandlocally),andincorporatestormwatercaptureandrechargeprojectsintothoseGSPs.Furthermore,identifyactionstocoordinatewiththoseDWRandStateWaterBoarddivisionsresponsibleforSGMAimplementation.
Lead:CASQA
Support:DepartmentofWaterResources;StateWaterBoard
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
IRWMPs1 MeetingswithStateWaterBoard,DWR,andothersasappropriate.
DevelopstrategytoincorporatestormwatermanagementintoIRWMPs.2018
2 DevelopguidancetobetterintegratestormwaterintoIRWMPs. 20193 FinalizeIRWMPstormwaterintegrationguidanceandbeginimplementation. 2020
SGMA1 MeetingswithStateWaterBoard,DWR,andGSAsasappropriate.
IdentifyactionstocoordinatewithDWRandStateWaterBoardandascheduleofimplementation.
2018
Action1.2–IdentifyConstraintsandOpportunitiesforMaximizingStormwaterasaResource
Background
MS4permitprovisionsandotherregulatoryrequirementscanresultinunintendedconstraintsontheuseofstormwaterasaresource.Additionally,asnewregulationsaredevelopedinotherareas,suchaslocalsiteuseorSGMA,considerationofstormwaterasaresourceisnotalwaysmaximizedorconsistentlyincorporated.Thisactionwilldemonstratehowlocalagenciescanimprovetheiruseof
4UnderSGMA,Section10721.Definitions–UndesirableResults,(w)“Undesirableresult”meansoneormoreofthefollowingeffectscausedbygroundwaterconditionsoccurringthroughoutthebasin:(6)Depletionsofinterconnectedsurfacewaterthathassignificantandunreasonableadverseimpactsonbeneficialusesofthesurfacewater.
SGMASection10727.2.RequiredPlanElements(d)Componentsrelatingtothefollowing,asapplicabletothebasin:(4)Howrechargeareasidentifiedintheplansubstantiallycontributetothereplenishmentofthebasin.(5)Adescriptionofsurfacewatersupplyusedoravailableforuseforgroundwaterrechargeorinlieuuse.
SGMASection10727.4.AdditionalPlanElements,agroundwatersustainabilityplanshallinclude,whereappropriateandincollaborationwiththeappropriatelocalagencies,allofthefollowing:(f)Activitiesimplementing,opportunitiesfor,andremovingimpedimentsto,conjunctiveuseorundergroundstorage.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 4
stormwater.TheSTORMSProject1a/1breporthasbeguntoidentifybarriers,drivers,andfactorsaffectingsuccesswithstormwatercaptureanduseandwillbeusedasaresourceforimplementingAction1.2
Goal:Toidentifyexistingconstraintsandopportunitiestoincentivizeuseofstormwaterasanaturalresource.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
1a.PromoteStormWaterCaptureandUse,2016-20181b.IdentifyandEliminateBarrierstoStormwaterCaptureandUse,2016-20191c.IncreaseStormwaterCaptureandUsethroughRegulatoryApproaches,2019-20211d.DevelopandEstablishaMonetaryValueofStormwater,2019-2023
RelatedCaliforniaWaterActionPlanAction(s)
1. MakeConservationaCaliforniaWayofLife
ProposedEffort
Objective1. SurveyagenciesandreviewrecentlyadoptedMS4permitstoidentifykeyconflictsandconstraintsforidentifyingandimplementingprojectsthatusestormwater.UsetheSTORMSProject1a/1bReportasastartingpointtodevelopthesurvey.MeetwiththeStateWaterBoardandDWRtodiscussthefindings.
Objective2. Basedontheresultsofthesurvey,meetingswithDWRandStateWaterBoardinObjective1,andtheSTORMSProject1a/1bReport,developrecommendationsforwaysinwhichfutureregulationsandguidancecanmoreeffectivelysupportuseofstormwaterasaresource.ProvidetheStateWaterBoardwithwaystoincentivizetheuseofstormwaterasaresourceandremoveconstraintsthatcurrentlyexisttosupporttheStateWaterBoard’sSTORMSprogram.
Objective3. WorkwiththeStateWaterBoardandDWRtoincorporateconsiderationofstormwaterasaresourceintodevelopmentofnewregulationsandguidancewhereappropriate.Establishastatewidegoalforcapturingstormwaterandusingitasaresource.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateWaterBoard
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
1 Surveyandtechnicalmemorandumidentifyingconstraints. 20182 Recommendationsforincentivizingstormwateruseandremovingconstraints. 20183 WorkwithStateWaterBoardandDWRtoincorporateconsiderationof
stormwaterasaresourceinfutureregulationsandestablishastatewidegoal.Ongoingasneeded
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 5
Action1.3–ProvideEffectiveandEfficientSolutionsthroughTruePollutantSourceControl
Background
Asustainablestormwaterprogramwillimplementcontrolsthatarerecognizedaseffectiveandeconomical.Forexample,itisdifficulttoremovenutrientsfromstormwater.Themosteffectivepointofcontrolforthispollutantisatthesource(e.g.,application).Thecontrolofsomepollutantsinstormwaterisbeyondthedirectcontrolofthemunicipality.Truesourcecontrolandtheuseofalternativeproductsandgreenchemistry5mayultimatelyofferthemosteffectiveandeconomicalapproachtotheeliminationofmanypollutantsthatimpairbeneficialuseofwaters.Newlegislationmaybeneededtoimplementthisaction.
Goal:Developalistofpollutantsinstormwaterthatshouldmostappropriatelybecontrolledatthesource(truesourcecontrol).Determinethecommercialuseofeachpollutant,andoutlinearecommendedsourcecontrolapproach.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
6b.IdentifyOpportunitiesforSourceControlandPollutionPrevention,2016-2020
ProposedEffort
Objective1. Assembleascopeofworkforatechnicalreporttoidentifypollutantsinstormwaterthatimpactlocalreceivingwaters.ThiseffortwilllargelybeacompendiumofMS4annualreportsaroundthestate.Assembleatechnicaladvisoryteamtooverseethedevelopmentofthetechnicalreport.
Objective2. Prepareatechnicalreportpersignificantpollutantthatdescribesthecausesof
receivingwaterimpairmentinurbanareas,defineseachpollutantandassessesthedegreeofpollutantcontrolavailabletomunicipalities.Asanexample,eachpollutantmaybeassessedaccordingtothefollowingcategories:
o Sourcecharacterization–sources,pathways(e.g.,stormwater,airdeposition),fate;relativeamountsofpollutant/uncertaintyperpathway
o Whetherremovalisavailablethroughcosteffectivetreatmentcontrolso Whethertruesourcecontrolisfeasibleorcosteffectiveo WhetheraGreenChemistryapproachisappropriate,andforwhatindustry
Thereportsshouldidentifypartnersforcollaborationtoimplementthecontrolforeachofthecategoriesdefinedabove.Thereportsshouldalsoincludeaprioritizedimplementationplan.
Objective3. ProvideStateWaterBoardwithrecommendedactionstosupporttruepollutantsourcecontrolconsistentwithSTORMSProject6b.WorkwiththeStateWaterBoard,DepartmentofToxicSubstancesControl(DTSC),andotheragenciestosupportdevelopmentofpartnershipsandcollaborationandotheractionsidentifiedinthe
5EPAdefinesgreenchemistryas,“thedesignofchemicalproductsandprocessesthatreduceoreliminatethegenerationofhazardoussubstances.”Truesourcecontrolistheeliminationofthepollutantatitssource,asopposedtophysicallykeepingthepotentialpollutantfromcontactingrainfallandstormwaterrunoffthroughcovering/containing,berming,orcleaning(i.e.,operationalsourcecontrol).
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 6
technicalreportstosupporttruepollutantsourcecontrol.WorkwithEPAtoimplementtruesourcecontrolworkthrougheducationandregulation.
Lead:CASQA
Support:Pollutant-dependent
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1–2 TechnicalReport(s)onpollutant(s)sourcesandcontrols. 20183 CoordinationwithStateWaterBoard,DTSC,andEPA. Ongoing
Action1.4–WorkwithDPRtoControlToxicityinReceivingWatersfromPesticideApplication
Background
PesticidesrepresentaspecialandspecificchallengetomunicipalstormwaterprogramssincetheyarelicensedforusebytheStateandEPA,arepresentinconcentrationstoolowtobepracticaltoremovefromstormwaterbutarecommonlyfoundinsufficientquantitiestocausetoxicityinreceivingwaters.Theymayalsobesynergisticineffect,combiningtocausegreatertoxicity.Widespreadtoxicityduetourban-usediazinonandchlorpyrifosinurbanwaterbodieswasdiscoveredinthemid1990s.Toxiclevelsofotherurbanusepesticides,includingpyrethroids,fipronil,andimidacloprid,continuetobefoundinurbanrunoffandreceivingwaters.
Inresponse,CASQAaswellasWaterBoardstaff,haveactivelyadvocatedformoreeffective,proactiveregulationofpesticidesbytheCaliforniaDepartmentofPesticideRegulation(DPR),andtheEPAOfficeofPesticidePrograms(OPP).Inthe2000s,DPRbegantoimproveitscapacityandproceduresforprotectingurbanwaterquality,andcurrentlyhasamuchmorerobustandeffectivesystemforidentifying,preventing,andmitigatingpesticideimpacts.Currently,theStateWaterBoardisdevelopingtheUrbanPesticideAmendments(Amendments)totheOceanPlanandInlandSurfaceWaters,EnclosedBays,andEstuariesPlan.TheAmendmentsprojectisoneoftheinitialprioritiesoftheStateWaterBoard’sSTORMSstrategicinitiative(Project6a-EstablishStatewideFrameworkforUrbanPesticideReduction).TheAmendmentsareexpectedtohelpinstitutionalizeDPR’smoreeffective,proactiveregulationofpesticides.Additionally,theAmendmentsareexpectedtoinclude:
• PesticideregulatoryauthoritywillberecognizedstatewidebyStateWaterBoardpolicyascriticalforaddressingpesticidesinurbanrunoff.AsstatedintheSTORMSfactsheet,“Themosteffectivewaytoreduceurbanpesticide-relatedimpairmentsnowandintothefutureissourcecontrolthroughcoordinationwithstateandfederalpesticideregulators.”
• Astatewideregulatoryframeworkforaddressingurbanpesticideimpairmentswillbeestablishedthatsupplantstheneedfordevelopingmultiplewatershed-specificTMDLs.
• AstatewidemonitoringframeworkwillbeestablishedtobettercoordinateWaterBoard,DPR,andMS4pesticidemonitoringtoutilizepublicresourcesmoreefficiently,satisfyCleanWaterActrequirements,andsupporteffectivepesticideregulation.
• Consistent,reasonablerequirementsforMS4implementation.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 7
Goal:DeveloparegulatorysystemimplementedbyEPAOPPandCaliforniaDPRtoidentifywhetheruseofapesticideposesathreattowaterquality,andthenrestrictordisallowthoseusesproactivelysothatwaterqualityimpactsareavoided.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
6a.EstablishStatewideFrameworkforUrbanPesticideReduction,2016-2018
ProposedEffort
Implementthefollowingkeyobjectives(fordetails,seePesticidesSubcommitteeAnnualReportandEffectivenessAssessment,2016-2017,CASQA,August2017)
Objective1. RespondtotheimmediateneedtoparticipateinEPApyrethroids,fipronil,andimidaclopridreviews(theonlysuchopportunityforthenext15years)andtosupportandencourageDPRstepstowardexpandedpyrethroidsandnewfipronilmitigationmeasures.
Objective2. SeekEPAriskmitigationformalathionandcarbarylinurbanrunoffandthe
continuationoftraditionalwaterqualityriskassessmentsintandemwithEndangeredSpeciesAct(ESA)evaluations.
Objective3. Continuetoleveragesuccessesatthestatelevelasakeystakeholderinthe
developmentofstatewideWaterQualityControlPlanAmendmentsforurbanpesticidesreduction.
Lead:CASQA
Support:DPR;StateWaterBoard;EPA
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 Registrationreviewsandmitigationmeasures. Ongoing2 Riskmitigations,andwaterqualityassessmentsandESAevaluations. Ongoing3 Amendmentsadoption. 2018
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 8
Principle–Policies,regulations,guidance,training,andfundingneedtosupportsustainablestormwatermanagementThereisafundamentalflawinthecurrentapproachtoimprovingwaterquality–municipalitieshavelimitedcontroloverthegenerationandreleaseofpollutantsintotheenvironmentandalimitednumberofcost-effectivetoolstoimproverunoffwaterquality.Thenewoutcome-basedpermitstrategiesdevelopedbytheWaterBoardswillrequireincreasedaccountabilityofthepermittee,butthecurrenttechnicalandlegalconstraintswilllimitimprovementsinreceivingwaterquality.Stormwaterprogrammanagersneedregulatoryassistancealongwithnewsourcecontrolandtreatmentcontroltoolstocomplywithpermitrequirements.
Toachievesustainablestormwatermanagement,are-examinationofregulatoryandmanagementstructuresiswarranted.Regulationsmustsupporttheuseofadaptivemanagementandalternativecontrolapproaches.Thepublicwillsupportprogramsthataddressdemonstratedwaterqualityissues.Theseeffortswillrequirecollaborationamongagenciesandindustriestoaffectthebiggestchangeforthelowestcost,aswellasmodificationtoregulatoryrequirementstoaccommodatebeneficialusesofreceivingwatersthataredeemedessential.
Action2.1–ClarifyRegulations
Background
Stormwaterislegallydefinedaspointsourceandisaddressedthroughapointsourceregulatoryprogram(i.e.,theNPDESprogram).Inreality,stormwaterisanon-pointsource(diffuseinnature).SomeofthecomplianceissuesthatMS4sarefacingcanbetracedtotheapplicationofthecurrentregulatorymodel,whichisbasedon30+yearsofexperiencewithpointsources(e.g.,wastewater),withlimitedacknowledgementforthenon-pointsourcenatureofstormwater(e.g.,MEPandBMPconcepts).CourtcaseshavestipulatedthatstormwaterisapointsourceandsubjecttotheNPDESprogram,thereforetheonlyoptionavailabletomodifythisinterpretationistoclarifythroughrulemakings,oramendtheCleanWaterActtorefinetheregulatoryapproachtobettersupportthenon-pointsourcenatureofstormwaterpollution.
Thischangerequiresasignificantundertakinganddiscussionswithallinterestedpartiestodevelopabroad-basedconsensusofhowbesttoclarifyregulationstoreducepollutioninstormwaterandimprovethecostefficiencyofstormwaterprograms.
Goal:Proposerulemakingorlegislationthatclarifiesstormwaterasanon-pointsource,andclearlyoutlinesexpectationsofstormwaterasdifferentfromwastewaterandotherpointsources.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3a.DevelopGuidanceforAlternativeComplianceApproachesforMunicipalStormwaterPermitReceivingWaterLimitations,2016-2019
3b.DevelopWatershed-BasedComplianceandManagementGuidelinesandTools,2016-20193c. AssessMunicipalStormwaterProgramMonitoringandEffectiveness,2019-20223d. EstablishStatewideRegulatoryFrameworkforMunicipalStormwaterPrograms,2019-20243e. StandardizeMinimumControlMeasuresforSpecificMunicipalProgramElements,2022-20235c. EstablishSector-specificTechnology-basedNumericEffluentLimitationsforIndustrialand
ConstructionStormwaterPermits,2022-2028
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 9
ProposedEffort
Objective1. Conferwithnationalstormwaterorganizations(e.g.,NationalMunicipalStormwaterAlliance(NMSA),WaterEnvironmentFederation(WEF),NationalAssociationofFloodandStormwaterManagementAgencies(NAFSMA),NationalAssociationofCleanWaterAgencies(NACWA),NaturalResourcesDefenseCouncil(NRDC))toexploreideasaboutrulemakingorlegislationthatwouldredefinestormwaterasanon-pointsourceofpollutants,orchangehowstormwaterispermittedasapointsource.Developaconsensusstrategywithinterestedstakeholderstoaccomplishthisobjective.
Objective2. Reachouttostateandnationalgovernmentalorganizations(e.g.,LeagueofCalifornia
Cities(LCC),CaliforniaStateAssociationofCounties(CSAC),CountyAssociationsofGovernment)toeducatelocalandstateelectedofficialsontheissue.CoordinatewithEPAandNGOs.
Objective3. Developandimplementastrategythatwouldredefinestormwaterasanon-pointsourceofpollutants.
Lead:NMSA;WEF;NAFSMA;NationalLeagueofCities;NationalAssociationofCounties;EPA
Support:CASQA
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 Conferwithnationalorganizationsanddeveloplegislativestrategy. 20192 Educatepublicofficials. 20203 Developandimplementlegislativestrategy. 2020-2021
Action2.2–ArticulateStormwaterProgramPriorities
Background
Municipalitiesfacemanychallengesindevelopingandimplementinganeffectiveandsustainablestormwaterprogram.Suchchallengesmayberegulatory,technical,orfinancialinnature.Itisimportanttoidentifythewaterqualityprioritiesthatmunicipalitiescanbestaddresssothatresourcesareallocatedaccordingly.Thefirststepincraftingalong-termsustainableapproachtostormwatermanagementistoidentifythechallengesandthentoidentifystrategiestoaddressthesechallenges.TheStateWaterBoardcanhelpprovideguidance/policytoaddresscriticalwaterqualityissuesassociatedwithstormwater.Forexample,theStateWaterBoardiscurrentlyaddressingtrashthroughamendmentstotheWaterQualityControlPlansfortheOceanWatersandtheInlandSurfaceWaters,EnclosedBays,andEstuariesofCaliforniaandhasinitiatedeffortstodevelopabacteriainitiativerelevanttowetweatherconditions.Similareffortsarealsounderwayforbiologicalobjectives.TheStateWaterBoardalsodevelopedandisrunningtheSTORMSprogramthatwillhelpprioritizetheState’sactions.
Goal:Toensurethemostcriticalwaterqualityissuesassociatedwithstormwaterareidentifiedandcorrespondingstrategiesdevelopedtoaddresstheissues.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 10
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3b.DevelopWatershed-BasedComplianceandManagementGuidelinesandTools,2016-2019
ProposedEffort
Objective1. IdentifythehighestpriorityissuesforthestormwaterprogramasapartoftheTriennialReviewprocessortheothermechanism(e.g.,StateStormwaterPolicy–seeAction2.4,Objective4).
Objective2. Engagestakeholdersinacollaborativeefforttoprioritizethewaterqualityissues
associatedwithstormwaterdischargesrelevanttotheregionorState.Theeffortmaybeledbyanyofthestakeholders(e.g.,RegionalWaterBoards,permittees,environmentalnon-governmentalorganizations(NGOs)).
Objective3. Identifyprioritiesoftheregionorstatebyconsideringimpactsonbeneficialuses,
maximumbenefitofthewaterbody,wateruseopportunities,andotherconsiderationsthataffectprioritization.Prioritizepollutantsbasedonconsiderations.
Objective4. Collectivelydevelopstrategiesforhighprioritystormwaterprogramissues.Such
strategiesmayincludedevelopingconsistentpermitrequirements,modifyingBasinPlans,andprovidingguidancetosupporttechnicalandregulatoryissues.
Objective5. Developanddelivercommentsandtestimonyontechnical,regulatory,andlegal
aspectsofpriorityissues.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateandRegionalWaterBoards
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 Identifyamechanismtoaddresshighpriorityissues. Ongoing2 Engagestakeholderstoprioritizeissues. 20183 Identifyhighprioritystormwaterissues. 20184 Developstrategiesforidentifiedissuesthroughacollaborativeprocess. 20195 Developanddelivercommentsandtestimony. Ongoing
Action2.3–AugmentandImplementBasinPlanAmendmentProcess
Background
PorterCologne(Section13240)providesanopportunityfortheRegionalWaterBoardstoperiodicallyreviewtheirBasinPlanstoensuretheplansreflectthenewestinformationanddata,arecurrentwithStateandFederalpolicies,andsupporttheprioritiesoftheRegionalWaterBoard.BasinPlanswereprimarilydevelopedinthe1970sand1980sandasaresulthavelimitedconsiderationofwetweatherissues.Thisactionwillreviewadoptedwaterqualityobjectivesandbeneficialuses(i.e.,waterqualitystandards)toensuretheyareapplicableforwetweatherconditions.SomeRegionalWaterBoardshavestartedtoaddressthisconcern.Thisactionwillbedesignedtosupportthoseefforts.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 11
Goal:Modifywaterqualitystandardstoreflectsustainablebeneficialusesandthenatureandimpactofstormwater.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s):
3d.EstablishStatewideRegulatoryFrameworkforMunicipalStormwaterPrograms,2019-2024
ProposedEffort
Objective1. InitiatetheBasinPlanamendmentprocessorequivalentstateorregionalplanningeffortbasedonrecommendationsandprioritiesestablishedunderActions1.3and2.2respectively.
Objective2. AssesswaterqualitystandardspertheCaliforniaWaterCodeSection13241.Working
withtheStateWaterBoard,developanassessmentmethodreflectiveofwetweatherconditionsthatwouldaddressthefollowingfactorstosupportaBasinPlanamendment:
o §13241(a):past,present,andprobablefuturebeneficialusesofwater.§ FurtherguidancebytheStateisneededtoassistRegionalBoardsindefining
“existing”and“probable”usesasthisfactorisoneofthemoredifficultfactorstoevaluate.
o §13241(b):environmentalcharacteristicsofthehydrographicunitunderconsideration,includingthequalityofwateravailablethereto.
o §13241(c):waterqualityconditionsthatcouldreasonablybeachievedthroughthecoordinatedcontrolofallfactorsthataffectwaterqualityinthearea.
o §13241(d):economicconsiderations.§ FurtherguidancebytheStateisneededasthereissignificantdisagreement
betweenpermitteesandenvironmentalcommunityregardingthemethodusedtocomplywiththissection.Theneedforfurtherguidancehasalsobeenidentifiedbyotherorganizations(e.g.,LittleHooverCommission,CaliforniaCouncilforEconomicandEnvironmentalBalance(CCEEB)).
o §13241(e):theneedfordevelopinghousingwithintheregion.o §13241(f):theneedtodevelopanduserecycledwater.
Objective3. Developanimplementationprogramconsistentwith§13242tosupportrevisedwater
qualitystandardsincludingascheduleandmonitoringprogram.WorkingwiththeStateWaterBoard,developaframeworkfordefiningtheimplementationprogramrequiredtosupporttherevisedwaterqualitystandards.
Objective4.AmendBasinPlansconsistentwiththeassessmentandframeworkdevelopedabove
forwetweatherconditions.Duringthetriennialreviewprovideinputanddatatosupportthereconsiderationofwaterqualitystandardsincludingassessmentofcurrentbeneficialusesandapplicationofwaterqualityobjectivesduringwetweatherconditions.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 12
Lead:RegionalWaterBoards
Support:CASQA
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 InitiateBasinPlanningstatewide. Ongoing2 Develop13241Assessment. 20193 Develop13142Framework. 20204 AmendBasinPlans. Ongoing
Action2.4–DevelopPoliciesandPermittingFrameworktoSupportSustainableStormwaterManagement
Background
WhatconstitutesastormwaterprogramhasevolvedconsiderablysincethestormwaterregulationswerepromulgatedinNovember1990.Inthealmost30yearssince,stormwaterprogramshavechangedfromrelativelybasicprogramsfocusedonstormwaterqualitytorelativelycomprehensiveandcomplicatedprogramsaddressingeverythingfromAreasofSpecialBiologicalSignificancetowatershedmanagement.Despitetheevolutionofwhatconstitutesastormwaterprogram,theregulationshavenotchangedandalthoughthepermitshavegottenlongerandmorecomplex,theyarestillessentiallybasedonthePartIandPartIIpermitapplicationrequirementsfromthe1990regulations.
EPAregulations,policies,andguidanceprovidetheopportunitytoaddresswaterqualityissuesthroughanadaptivemanagementandsustainableprocess.Forexample,EPAadoptedastrategytosupporttheadoptionofgreeninfrastructureasameansofsupportingwaterqualityandcommunitydevelopmentgoals.TheseactionswillprovidepolicyguidancetoassistMS4andotherpermitteeswithanoverallapproachtoprotectwaterqualitythroughanadaptivemanagementprocess.Thisguidancemaybeprovidedinastatewidestormwaterpolicy,standardpermitconditions,orequivalentdocument.
Goal:DeveloparegulatoryframeworkforstormwaterthatwillprovidestatewideconsistencyinpermittingandTMDLimplementationandsupporttheimplementationofsustainablestormwaterprograms.ProvidedefinitionsandrequirementsasneededtoclarifyexpectationsforMS4programs.Ensurethattheframeworkisimplementedstatewide.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3c. AssessMunicipalStormwaterProgramMonitoringandEffectiveness,2019-20223d. EstablishStatewideRegulatoryFrameworkforMunicipalStormwaterPrograms,2019-20245d. AlignWaterQualityStatewidePlanningEffortswithStormwaterProgramImplementation–Pilot
ProjectUsingtheBiologicalIntegrityPlan,2019-2021
ProposedEffort
Objective1. Identifyconstraintsandinconsistencies.UsethefirstoftwoEPA-sponsoredMunicipalStormwaterPermitEvolutionworkshops(December2017)toconferwithinterestedpartiestoidentifytheconstraintsandinconsistenciesaswellasbenefitsandchallengesofexistingpolicyandpermittingefforts.PrioritizethechallengesforsubsequentattentioninObjective2below.Itislikelythattwoofthemostimportantchallenges
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 13
willbedefiningMEPandcreatingsustainablepathwaysforachievingTMDLwasteloadallocations(WLAs)andcomplyingwithreceivingwaterlimitations(RWL).
Objective2. DefineMEPandRWLcomplianceandTMDLimplementation.StipulatethemandatoryrequirementsforstormwaterprogramimplementationtodefineMEPusingtheworkalreadycompletedbyCASQA,StateWaterBoardexecutivemanagement,RegionalWaterBoardsExecutiveOfficers,andEPARegionIXstormwaterstaff,(StatewideStormwaterPermitDesignReview,2011-2012).Likewise,developanadaptivemanagementapproachforTMDLdevelopmentandimplementationandcompliancewithreceivingwaterlimitations.DefineanyadditionalprioritiesidentifiedinObjective1,anddevelopascope(s)andschedule(s)toaddressinsubsequentobjectives.
Objective3.Definebaselinemonitoringrequirements.UsethesecondoftwoEPA-sponsored
MunicipalStormwaterPermitEvolutionworkshops(March2018)andfollow-uptoconvenestakeholderstoclarifypurposeofthemonitoringeffort,toclarifystandardmonitoringmethodsandprocedures,andestablishmandatoryreportingrequirementsandformat.
Objective4. Developastatewidepolicyforstormwater.Thepolicyshouldsupportanapproachthat
incorporatesadaptivemanagement,providesalogicalandprogressivepathwaytowaterqualityprotectionandpromotesgreeninfrastructure.Assuch,theapproachshouldprogressfromanarrativedefinitionoftechnology-basedeffluentlimits(TBELs)tonumericbasedtechnologybasedeffluentlimitstonarrativewaterquality-basedeffluentlimits(WQBELs)andultimately,ifrequired,numericWQBELs.
Objective5. Incorporateadaptivemanagementasapathwayforcompliancewithwaterquality
standardsandTMDLsintoallMS4permits.ThisapproachwouldalsoincludetheneedtoprovideoptionsforreviewingandmodifyingTMDLsbasedonnewinformation,technology,monitoringresults,etc.
Lead:StateandRegionalWaterBoards
Support:CASQA
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
1 Identifyconstraints. 20182 DefineMEPandRWLcompliancestrategies,andTMDLimplementation;Define
anyadditionalpriorities.2019
3 Developbaselinemonitoringrequirements. 20184 Developstatewidepolicyforstormwater. 20245 Incorporateadaptivemanagementascompliancepathway. Ongoing
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 14
Action2.5–EstablishGuidance/ToolstoSupportSustainableStormwaterPrograms
Background
Continuouslyupdatedtechnicalguidanceisnecessarytosupportthelong-termsuccessofthestormwaterprogram.Someofthecurrentguidanceisdatedanddoesnotreflectnewprioritiesofsustainablewateruseandafocusonlowimpactdevelopment,greeninfrastructure,assetmanagement,andtruesourcecontrol.ItwillbenecessarytoprovideupdatedoradditionalguidancetoaddresstheseprioritiesandstrategiesidentifiedinAction2.2.Additionally,informationandguidanceisneededforadaptivemanagement,whichinturnsupportssustainablestormwatermanagement.
Goal:Toensuretechnicalandregulatoryguidanceisprovidedtosupportsustainablestormwaterprograms.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3f. DevelopGuidanceforImplementationofPost-ConstructionRequirementstoImproveWatershedHealth,2019-2023
3g. EstablishGuidanceforStormwaterProgramAssetManagementPlanningandCostEstimation,2022-2023
5a. CreateStormwaterProgramDataandInformation“OpenData”,2016-20205b. EvaluateandIncreaseStormwaterPermitCompliance,2019-20216c. EvaluateandImplementTrashControl,2019-2022
ProposedEffort
Objective1. UpdateCASQABMPHandbooks.Asnewinformationbecomesavailableandtechnicaladvancestakeplace,theCASQABMPHandbookswillneedtobeupdated.Suchupdatesshouldcoincidewiththeupdatesoftherelevantpermitsandpermittingapproaches.
Objective2. Developguidanceforregulatorypriorities.PendingtheresultsofAction2.2,itmaybe
necessarytoprovideguidancetodevelopsitespecificobjectives,developtechnologybasedeffluentlimits,characterizenaturalsources,supportahighflowsuspension,ordevelopwetweatherstandards.
Objective3. UpdateCASQAProgramEffectivenessAssessmentManual.MS4sarecontinuallytrying
toimprovetheirstormwaterprogramsbothineffectivenessinaddressingwaterqualityissuesandinefficiencyinminimizingprogramcosts.TheCASQAprogrameffectivenessassessmentprovidesthebasisforsuchimprovementsbutshouldberevisedtoreflectthewatershedapproachcurrentlybeingprovidedforinpermits(seeAction2.6below)thatallowagenciestofocustheirresourcesonwaterqualitypriorities.
Objective4. Developcasestudiesofadaptivemanagement.Adaptivemanagementisasmuchartas
scienceandtheprocessandformittakescanvaryfromsituationtosituation.Casestudiesimproveourunderstandingofadaptivemanagementbyshowcasingthewaystheprocessmaybeusedandtheresultsitcangenerate.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 15
Objective5. Developandhostevents(e.g.,quarterlymeetings,annualconferences)onaregularbasistoassiststormwaterprofessionalstoremaincurrentonthelatestissuesanddevelopments.Identifyandengagehighqualityandrelevantsourcesofinformation.
Objective6. Createandhostinformationplaces(e.g.,websites,forums)wherestormwater
professionalscanaccesscurrent,relevant,andhigh-qualityinformationandinteractwithlikeprofessionals.
Objective7. Createandprovidetrainingforstormwaterprofessionals.Createcurriculafrom
current,relevant,andhigh-qualityinformationsources.Identifyandengagehighqualityandexperiencedtrainers.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateandRegionalWaterBoards
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 UpdateBMPHandbooks. Ongoing2 Guidanceforregulatorypriorities. Ongoing3 Improve/ReviseProgramEffectivenessManual. 20194 Developcasestudies.Ongoing5 Developandhostevents. Ongoing6 Createandhostinformationplaces. Ongoing7 Createandprovidetraining. Ongoing
Action2.6–EstablishWatershed-BasedorEquivalentProgram
Background
TheNationalResearchCouncilnotedthegreatestpotentialimprovementtoEPA’sstormwaterprogramwouldbetoconverttoawatershedbasedpermittingsystem.TheLittleHooverCommissioninCaliforniahasalsorecommendedtheStateemphasizeawatershed-basedapproach.RecentMS4permitsinCalifornia(e.g.,LosAngelescountywideandSanDiegocountywide)havereflectedafocusonwatersheds.
Goal:DevelopprocessforimplementingwatershedbasedapproachesfortheMS4program.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3b.DevelopWatershed-BasedComplianceandManagementGuidelinesandTools,2016-2019
ProposedEffort
Objective1. AssesseffortsinLosAngeles,BayArea,andSanDiegotoidentifythebenefits,thechallenges,andanyrecommendedchanges.
Objective2. WorkwiththeStateWaterBoardtoincorporatewatershedbasedplanningintoall
MS4permits.Thepermitsshouldhighlighttheneedtoprioritizewatershedbasedwaterqualityissuesandencourageimplementationofstormwaterprogramsatthe
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 16
watershedlevel.ReviewandincorporatetheEPAsIntegratedPlanningFrameworkintopermits.
Objective3. Createopportunitiesforregionalsolutions.Initialstormwaterpermitsdiscouraged
regionalsolutionstowaterqualityissuesbutmorerecentlythisapproachhasbeenupdatedandregionalapproachesareallowed.TheStateWaterBoardshouldbeencouragedtofindwaystoincentivizeregionalsolutionsaspartoftheState’sSTORMSprogram.IncorporaterecommendationsfromEPA-sponsoredMunicipalStormwaterPermitEvolutionworkshops(December2017).
Objective4. Createapollutanttrading/creditprogramframework.Waterqualitytradingisan
innovativeapproachtoachievewaterqualitygoalsmoreefficientlyandisespeciallysuitedforprojectsandprogramsthatarewatershedbasedandsubjecttoaTMDL.Apilotprojectshouldbeidentifiedandimplemented.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateandRegionalWaterBoards
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate1 Conductassessmentofwatershedprograms. 20182 Incorporatewatershedplanningintopermits. Ongoing3 Createopportunitiesforregionalsolutions. Ongoing4 Createpollutanttradingframework. 2019
Action2.7–CreateFundingOpportunities
Background
SB231Implementation
Municipalstormwatersystemsarepublicfacilities,buttheydifferfromotherpublicutilitiessuchaswater,sewer,gas,electric,andtrashinonekeyaspect:otherutilitiesexistedpriortothepassageofProposition218andarefinanciallysupportedbyservicefees.Bycomparison,moststormwaterprogramsrelyonthepublicagency’sgeneralfund.Thisfundingstructurepresentsamajorchallengeforelectedofficialsastheymustbalancethefundingofthestormwaterprogramwithotherprogramssupportedbythegeneralfund,includingsuchthingsaslawenforcement,fire,paramedics,parks,streetlighting,andlibraries.
Proposition218(1996)requireslocalvoterapprovalofcertainproperty-relatedfees.Theimpositionorincreaseofapropertyrelatedfeeorchargemustbeapprovedbyamajorityvoteofthepropertyownerssubjecttothefeeorchargeor,attheoptionoftheagencyimposingthefeeorcharge,bya2/3voteoftheelectorateresidingintheareaaffectedbythefeeorcharge.Proposition218exemptscertaintypesoffees,suchasthoseforwater,sewer,andrefuse,fromthevoterapprovalrequirementsofProposition218.
RecentlegislationhasclarifiedthestandingofstormwaterwithinProposition218andtheaccompanyingOmnibusImplementationActof1997,includingrelativetothewaterandsewerexemptions.ThepassageofAB2403(2014)providesanoptionunderthewaterexemptionfor
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 17
fundingthecapitalportionofprojectsthatconserveorusestormwaterforwatersupply.Similarly,thepassageofSB231(2017)providesthesameoptionunderthesewerexemptionforprojectsthatbenefitsewerservices.To-date,theoptioncreatedbyAB2403hasnotbeenusedbyaMS4toraisestormwaterfeesbutCASQAexpectsthepassageofSB231toencourageMS4stodoso.
Theuseofeitheroptionisexpectedtobecloselywatchedbyinterestgroupsinpreparationforbringingoneormorelawsuitstotrytorestrictorreversetheinterpretationofthelegislation.Asaresult,theSB231ImplementationWorkingGroup,acoalitionexpectedtoincludethelegislator’soffice,thesponsorsofthelegislation,LCC,CSAC,environmentalNGOs,andothersaredevelopingastrategytotrytoensurethatagenciesusetheoptionsappropriatelyandavoidengenderinglawsuitsthatcouldsetlegalprecedentsunfavorabletotheneedsofstormwaterprograms.Toimplementthisaction,CASQAwillworkcloselywiththecoalitionandCASQAmemberstohelpensurethatallMS4sareaware,understand,andfollowthestrategy.
JointPowersAuthority
AnotherapproachtocreatingfundingopportunitiesistoformaJointPowersAuthority(JPA).Overthelast25yearstheStateWaterBoardandCASQAhavepartneredonseveralstatewideprojectsandprogramstoassiststormwaterpermittees(e.g.,BMPHandbooks,ConstructionGeneralPermitQualifiedSWPPPDeveloper(QSD)/QualifiedSWPPPPractitioner(QSP)trainingprogram,IndustrialGeneralPermitQualifiedIndustrialStormwaterPractitioner(QISP)TrainingProgram).However,restrictionsandbarrierstocollecting,combining,orreceivingfundsfromagenciestoconductstatewideprogramsandprojectsthroughCASQAasanon-profitorganizationorthroughathird-partyagencyactingasCASQA’sfiduciaryagentmaketheseapproachesdifficult,inefficient,andofteninfeasible.AJPAisapublicagencyandassuch,underStatepolicies,theStateaswellaslocalagencieswouldbeabletofundprogramsandprojectsthroughaJPAmoreeasilyandefficiently.
FundingInformationOnlinePortal
Therecurrentlyexistmanysourcesofinformationonstormwaterfunding,howevergiventhespecificCaliforniaconstraintsandopportunitiesandthroughcollaborationwiththeStateWaterBoardandEPAthedevelopmentofonelocationforstormwaterpermitteestoidentifyandevaluateopportunitiesforstormwaterfundinginCaliforniahasbeenidentified.TheportalwillfunctionastheprimarylocationforinformationonfundingopportunitiesinCaliforniaandprovideanopportunityforstormwaterprojectproponentstoevaluatemultiplebenefitsofproposedprojectsandidentifyfundingsourcesassociatedwithmultiplebenefits.TheportalwillalsolinktotheEPAwaterfinancingportalandtheportalwillserveastheprimaryrepositoryofinformationrelatedtoCASQAstormwaterfundinginitiativesincludingtheCASQAfundingwhitepapersdevelopedaspartoftheLIDBarriersGrant.Akeyelementofthefundingonlineportalwillbemaintenanceoftheportal,whichCASQAwillneedtoidentifyhowtheportalwillbemaintainedincludingevaluationofhowtheStateWaterBoardcanpotentiallycontributeresources.
FundingforSustainableStreets
SustainableStreetprojectsareprojectsthatincludebothactivetransportationimprovementsandgreeninfrastructure,andthataremaintainedinastateofgoodrepair.SustainableStreetsareimportanttostormwatercompliance,duetothewaterqualityimpactsofvehicles,thefactthatstormwaterrunofffromadjacentpropertiesisoftenroutedtoroadways,andtheintegrationofstormdrainsystemsintostreetsandroads.However,thefundingofSustainableStreetsprojectshasprovenchallenging,duetothetendencyforvariousfundingprogramstofocusonlyononeorafewofthemultiplebenefitsprovidedbySustainableStreets.Itmaybepossibletoachieveeconomiesofscalebycombininginvestmentsinreducingwaterpollutantloadsandgreenhousegasemissions
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 18
withfundingforactivetransportation,pavementrehabilitation,andwatergrantstofullyfundSustainableStreetsprojects.Tothatend,EPARegion9fundedagrantprojectthatwasusedtoconvenemeetingsofrepresentativesfromfederal,state,regional,andlocalagenciestoproducearoadmap6ofspecificactionsforfundingSustainableStreets.TheproposedeffortsbelowregardingSustainableStreetsaredrawnfromthatroadmap.
Goal:Toassistwithuseofoneormorefundingoptionsformunicipalitiestosupporttheirstormwaterprogramstoreduceoreliminaterelianceongeneralfunds.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
1d.DevelopandEstablishaMonetaryValueofStormwater,2019-20234b. EliminateBarrierstoFundingStormwaterProgramsandIdentifyFundingforStormwaterCapture
andUseProjects,2016-2018
RelatedCaliforniaWaterActionPlanAction(s)
10. IdentifySustainableandIntegratedFinancingOpportunities
ProposedEfforts
SB231Implementation
Objective1. ParticipateinSB231ImplementationWorkingGroupandtheplanninganddevelopmentofthestrategy.
Objective2. Developanddisseminateinformationregardingthestrategyanditsimplementation.
JointPowersAuthority
Objective1. AssistformationofJPA,includingauthorizationofStateWaterBoardparticipation,executionofJPAformationdocuments,constitutionofgovernance(e.g.,BoardofDirectors),developmentofgovernancedocuments(e.g.Bylaws,PoliciesandProcedures),andestablishmentofAdministeringEntity.
Objective2. AssistwithsecuringfundingandimplementationoffirstJPAproject.
FundingInformationOnlinePortal
Objective1. DevelopincollaborationwiththeStateWaterBoardandasaninitiativeassociatedwiththeSTORMSFundingSubcommitteeastormwaterfundinginformationonlineportal.
FundingforSustainableStreets
Objective1. UpdateProposition1StormwaterGrantGuidance.Inthe2018StormwaterGrantProgramsolicitation,provideguidanceonhowtodemonstratetheeligibilityoftransportationelements,includingperviouspavingandactivetransportationandtransitimprovementsthatreducegreenhousegases(RoadmapSpecificAction1.3).
6DraftRoadmapofFundingSolutionsforSustainableStreets,UrbanGreeningBayAreaInitiative,BayAreaStormwaterManagementAgenciesAssociation,2017
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 19
Objective2. Clarifygreeninfrastructureeligibilityinthelocalstreetsandroadsprogram.AsguidelinesaredevelopedinaccordancewithSB1(2017)clarifytheeligibilityofgreeninfrastructureelementsinpavementrehabilitationandotherapplicableprojects(RoadmapSpecificAction1.4).
Objective3. Prepareguidanceforpackagingprojects.Preparestatewideguidanceonhowto
packageSustainableStreetsprojectsforspecificgrants(RoadmapSpecificAction2.4).
Leads:
SB231Implementation:SB231ImplementationWorkingGroup
JointPowersAuthority:CASQA
FundingInformationOnlinePortal:CASQA
FundingforSustainableStreets:StateWaterBoard(Objective1);CaliforniaTransportationCommission(Objective2);CASQA(Objective3)
Support:
SB231Implementation:CASQA
JointPowersAuthority:StateWaterBoard,AlamedaCountyFloodControl&WaterConservationDistrict,FresnoMetropolitanFloodControlDistrict
FundingInformationOnlinePortal:StateWaterBoard
FundingforSustainableStreets:CASQA(Objectives1-2);Fundingagencies(Objective3)
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
SB231Implementation1 ParticipateinSB231ImplementationWorkingGroupdevelopingthestrategy. 20182 Developanddisseminateinformationaboutthestrategyandits
implementation.Ongoing
JointPowersAuthority1 AssistwithformationofJPA. 20182 AssistwithadministrationoffirstJPAproject. 2019
FundingInformationOnlinePortal1 DevelopincollaborationwiththeStateWaterBoardastormwaterfunding
informationonlineportal2018
FundingforSustainableStreets1 UpdateProposition1StormwaterGrantGuidance. 20182 Clarifygreeninfrastructureeligibilityinthelocalstreetsandroadsprogram. 20183 Prepareguidanceforpackagingprojects. 2019
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 20
Action2.8–SurveyNeedsandIdentifyCosts
Background
AnMS4’sdefiningcharacteristicisthatitisanopensystem,whereinflowsaredeterminedbytheamountofprecipitationandinputsintothesystemareopenandaccessibleoneverystreetandproperty.Discharges(stormwaterandotherflows)intoanMS4representthediversityofactivitiesandbehaviorsconductedbyhumansandotherspeciesfromthesurroundingwatershedandtheairshed.Toaddresssuchanopensystem,regulations,permits,andprogramshavebeendevelopedthatmatchitsscope.Accordingly,thescopeofamunicipalstormwaterprogramcutsacrossalldepartmentsandprofessionaldisciplines.Moststormwaterprogramsdonothaveadedicatedfeeorassessmentandarefundedoutofanagency’sgeneralfund.Additionally,manyoftheactivitiesofastormwaterprogramareconductedaspartofotherexistingmunicipalservices(e.g.,streetsweeping,catchbasincleaning).Finally,thesizeoftheagenciesimplementingtheprogramrangefrompopulationsof10,0007tomorethan10million.
Allofthesefactors–diffusepollutionsources(includingcrossmedia,sources),broadscope,multipledepartmentsandbudgets,integratedtasks,widerangeofagencies–makedeterminingtheneedsandcostsofthestormwaterprogramanaccountingchallengewithinanyoneagency.Betweenagencies,differencesinprogramdesignandorganizationmakeitdifficulttocombineinformationfrommultipleagenciesintoalarger,consistentdatabasefromwhichtoreportaverageresultswithoutsignificantvariability.Withoutareliableaccountingoffundingandfundingneeds,itisdifficulttoidentifyfundingtofillthegaps.
Atthenationalscale,thereareseveralattemptstogatherinformationonneedsandcosts:
• EPACleanWatershedsNeedsSurvey(CWNS)-Inpartnershipwithstates,territoriesandtheDistrictofColumbia,EPAconductstheCWNSeveryfouryears.CongressrequiresEPAtoconducttheCWNSundersections205(a)and516oftheCWA(33U.SCode§1375).TheCWNSisacomprehensiveassessmentofthecapitalcosts(orneeds)tomeetthewaterqualitygoalsoftheCWAandaddresswaterqualityandwaterqualityrelatedpublichealthconcerns.Everyfouryears,thestatesandEPAcollectinformationabout:
o Publiclyownedwastewatercollectionandtreatmentfacilitieso Stormwaterandcombinedseweroverflowcontrolfacilitieso Non-pointsourcepollutioncontrolprojectso Decentralizedwastewatermanagement
EPAcollectsinformationaboutthesefacilitiesandprojectsincluding:
o Estimatedneedstoaddresswaterqualityorwaterqualityrelatedpublichealthproblems.o Locationandcontactinformationforfacilitiesandprojects.o Facilitypopulationsserved,flow,effluent,andunitprocessinformation.o Non-pointsourcepollutioncontrolbestmanagementpractices.
EPAdocumentsnationalandstateneedsinaReporttoCongressusedbyCongressandstatelegislaturesintheirbudgetingefforts.Thedataarealsousedto:
7AlthoughthelowerpopulationthresholdforPhaseIIStormwaterProgramis10,000,manymunicipalitieswithpopulationslessthan10,000arerequiredtoimplementstormwaterprograms.Thisisthecaseinheavilyurbanizedareaswheresmallermunicipalitiesarecontiguouswithlargermunicipalities,ortheyarepartofregionalprograms,ortheWaterBoardsdesignatedpopulationareasbasedondensityorwaterqualityconcerns.
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 21
o Helpmeasureenvironmentalprogresso Contributetoacademicresearcho Provideinformationtothepublico Helplocalandstategovernmentsimplementwaterqualityprograms
• WEFNeedsAssessmentSurveyofMS4s-WEF’sStormwaterInstituteisdevelopinganationalneedsassessmentofMS4s.Thenationalsurveywilldeterminewherepotentialprogramthemegapsmayoccur,identifyopportunitiestosharelessonsamongpeers,andprovideacatalystfordevelopingnewprogramstomeetthestormwaterchallenge.TheMS4surveywillbeconductedinearly2018andbecompletedbymid-2018.TheStormwaterInstitutewillworkwithpartnerstoimplementindicatedimprovementstobothenhanceexistingprogramsanddevelopnewtoolstohelpthemunicipalsectormeettheirpermitrequirementsandcommunitywaterqualitygoals.
Goal:Toidentifyordevelopasystemforcollectingandanalyzinginformationonneedsandcostsofcomplianceforstormwaterpermittees(construction,industrial,andmunicipal),andimplementitinCalifornia.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
3g. EstablishGuidanceforStormwaterProgramAssetManagementPlanningandCostEstimation,2022-2023
4c. IdentifyMunicipalStormwaterPermitComplianceCost,2019-20214d. IdentifyIndustrialandConstructionStormwaterPermitComplianceCost,2028-2030
ProposedEffort
Objective1. ResearchtheEPAandWEFsurveysanddeterminetheextenttowhichtheyaddressmunicipalstormwaterinCalifornia.Identifyanygaps.
Objective2. DependentontheresultsandrecommendationsfromObjective1,developand
conductasurveyforMS4sinCalifornia,andanalyzetheresults.Objective3. DevelopandconductasurveyforconstructionstormwaterpermitteesinCalifornia,
andanalyzetheresults.Objective4. DevelopandconductasurveyforindustrialstormwaterpermitteesinCalifornia,and
analyzetheresults.Objective5.Determinethemanagementquestionsandutilityofconductingthesurveysonsome
regularbasis.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateWaterBoard,WEF,EPA
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
1 TechnicalMemorandumdescribingresearch,results,gaps,andrecommendations.
2018
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 22
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
2-4
Reportsdescribingtheconstruction,industrial,andmunicipalsurveys,results,andrecommendations.
2018
5 TechnicalMemorandumdescribinganalysis,results,andrecommendations. 2019
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 23
Principle–Publicawareness,understanding,andappreciationofthevalueofstormwaterisessentialtosustainablestormwatermanagement.Stormwateragenciesneedtoeducatethepublicaboutthevalueofwater.DomesticwaterisrelativelyinexpensiveandabundantintheU.S.TherecurringdroughtandpopulationincreaseshavebeguntostrainthestorageanddeliveryinfrastructureinCaliforniaandthesouthwest.ManagementofwaterresourcesinCaliforniamustchange.Tomakethenecessarychanges,theremustbepublicsupport.
Action3.1–CreateOpportunitiesforMultipleAgencyandCollaborativeEffortstoDemonstratetheValueofStormwatertothePublic
Background
Thepublicismorelikelytosupportinfrastructureprojectsthataremulti-objectiveandmulti-benefitascomparedtosingle-purposeprojects.Thepotentialnumberoffundingsourcesisgreaterformulti-objectiveprojects.Multi-objectiveprojectsaremorecomplexowingtodisparatefundingsources,andtherequirementsofvariouspublicagencies.However,multi-objectiveprojectshaveadditionalbenefitsascomparedtosingleuseprojects,andgenerallywillhaveacomparativelyhigherreturnoninvestmentforthepublic.Anexamplewouldbeagreenstreetprojectthatisalsoacompletestreettoenhancemobility,oragreenstreetwithasaferoutestoschoolsproject.
Note:ThisactioniscloselyrelatedtoAction1.1–Developguidanceforintegratedmanagementofwaterresourcesthatpromotesstormwaterasaresource.Theactionssharethesubjectofstormwaterasaresourcebuttheydifferintheirfocusandaudience.ThefocusofAction3.1isoutwardtowardthepublicandthepublicityofprojectsandprograms.ThefocusofAction1.1isinwardtowardpublicagenciesandtheproductionofguidanceforpublicagencies.
Goal:Establishanddefineabasicsetofmulti-benefitprojectsandprogramsthatastakeholderagencycaninitiate.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
1d.DevelopandEstablishaMonetaryValueofStormwater,2019-20232a.IncreaseStakeholderCollaborationtoPromoteStormwaterasaResource,2019-2021
ProposedEffort
Objective1. Identifystakeholderagenciestoparticipateinthisaction.Potentialcandidateprojectsandprogramstoconsider:
o WaterSupplyo GroundwaterRechargeo RecreationalFacilitieso Transportationo MunicipalInfrastructure
Identifyfundingsourcesthateachagencyusesforcapitalimprovements,programs,maintenance,andlandacquisitionandthelimitationsontheuseofthosefunds.
Objective2. Identifyatleastonemulti-benefitprojecttypeorprogramthatincludestwoormoreagencieslistedinObjective1thatcanbeimplementedbymunicipalitiesorother
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 24
stakeholders.Createordocumentdemonstrationprojectsthatcanbeimplementedbypermitteesstatewide.Foreachmulti-benefitprojectorprogram,developadetailed‘roadmap’ormodelmanualfortheprojectdescribing:
o Approvalprocesseso Fundingsourcesandlimitationso Benefitsofprojecto Preferredapplicationenvironmento Idealizedschedule
Multi-benefitprojectsshouldfocusonurbaninfrastructureandincludethefollowing:o Transformexistingfloodcontrolfacilitiestooptimizeuseofstormwatero Daylightingofstreamso Volumeandflowreduction–hydromodificationcontrolso Protectorrestorestreamhabitato ConvertingstandardstreetstoSustainableStreets
Objective3. Publishareportonthefindingsofthisactionwithcompletedprojectscenarios.Objective4. TrackplansforSTORMSProject2a.IncreaseStakeholderCollaborationtoPromote
StormwaterasaResource,anddependingonthecircumstances,scopeoutatask(s)tocoordinatewith,support,orhelpimplementSTORMSProject2a.
Lead:CASQA
Support:Agencies–Tobedetermined
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
1 Identifystakeholderstoparticipate. 20172 Identifymulti-benefitprojects–ProduceTechnicalMemorandumsummarizing
results.2018
3 Publishreportoffindings. 20184 Trackandscopeouttask(s). 2018
Action3.2–CreateStatewideMessagethatEstablishesStormwaterasaResource
Background
MS4programsshouldhaveaconsistentmessagetouseinpubliceducationandoutreachtocreatethebestpotentialforchangeinpublicopinionandeducation.Ideally,acommonmessagewillbeusedacrosslocalagenciesaswellasStateagencies,includingtheStateWaterBoard,RegionalWaterBoards,Caltrans,DepartmentofParksandRecreation,andDepartmentofWaterResources.ThestatewideconsistentmessageshouldbesupportedbytheStateandRegionalWaterBoardsthroughMS4permits,asarecommendedoptionavailabletopermitteesforpubliceducation.
Sinceversion1.0ofthisVisionwasofficiallyadoptedbyCASQAinJanuary2015,Caltranshasdevelopedastatewidemessageandcampaign–“ProtectEveryDrop”–thatappearstohavemettheintentofthisaction–aconsistent,statewidemessagethatcanbeusedbyallagenciesandyetthemessagecanbe
Version1.1 VisionandStrategicActions
December2017 CaliforniaStormwaterQualityAssociation 25
combinedwithcomplementary,customizedsub-messagesasdesiredbypartneragencies.Thesubjectofthisaction–promotingstormwaterasaresourceissuchasub-message.
Goal:Withinthecontextofthe“ProtectEveryDrop”campaign,developamessageandoutreachmaterialspromotingstormwaterasaresourceforuseinpubliceducation.
RelatedSTORMSProject(s)
1a.PromoteStormwaterCaptureandUse,2016-20182a.IncreaseStakeholderCollaborationtoPromoteStormwaterasaResource,2019-2021
ProposedEffort
Objective1. Conveneasteeringcommitteetoagreeontheconceptframeworkanddirectthedevelopmentofthe“stormwaterasaresource”message.Thesteeringcommitteewillbecomprisedofmembersfromthefollowingentities:
o Municipalitieso StateandRegionalWaterBoardso DepartmentofWaterResourceso WaterDistrictso GroundwaterSustainabilityAgencies
Objective2. Draftaworkplan.Thesteeringcommitteewilldraftaworkplantodevelopthe“stormwaterasaresource”outreachmessage,anymaterials,andmethodofdisseminationtothepublic.Theworkplanwillincludeanactiontoidentifytheappropriateanduniquetargetaudiences,andmessagesanddeliverycustomizedtoeachtargetaudience.Workwillalsoincludeapublicoutreachplanthatusesalltraditionalandsocialmediaformats.
Objective3. Implementthepublicoutreachplan.Coordinateoutreachstatewidewithallcooperatingagencies.
Lead:CASQA
Support:StateWaterBoard;Caltrans;EnvironmentalNGOs
Schedule
# Objective/Deliverable CompletionDate
1–2
Scopeofworkandselectionofconsultant,completionofstatewide“stormwaterasaresource”message.
2018
3 IncorporationofoptionintoMS4permits,implementrecommendedplan. Ongoing