vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

196
1

Upload: the-rba-group

Post on 24-Jul-2016

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

On 26 October 2016 we presented Draft recommendations at the Arch Street Meeting House. This slides show was accompanied by considerable narration, so condensed presenter's notes have been included for those not able to attend.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

1

Page 2: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

2

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: People are starting to think about the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. Vision2026 is meant to dovetail with that effort, asking people to think about how do to they want to present their neighborhood, city, and country to the world.
Page 3: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

3

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This is how planners imagined cities of the future in 1925. Vision2026 is about thinking big, but also thinking practically, and about the world we live in.
Page 4: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

4

Page 5: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

5

Page 6: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

6

Page 7: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

7

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The study area is a dynamic district with many definitions.
Page 8: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

8

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In our research, we wanted to learn and show how much Old City and its physical relationship with the rest of the City have evolved.
Page 9: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

9

Page 10: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

10

Page 11: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

11

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: By this point, Old City is an island in Philadelphia ... we think it's critical for a master plan to focus on helping people cross the divides that have been formed.
Page 12: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

12

Page 13: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

13

Page 14: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

14

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The previous slides show how Philadelphia was hollowing out its center during the twentieth century, reflecting continual drops in population. Now that population is growing again, and land values are rising, especially at the center and its edges, we need to begin thinking differently, and planning for a future that is no longer about decline.
Page 15: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

15

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Market opportunities in Old City are strongest around residential development and becoming a more densely populated neighborhood, complete with services supporting such development.
Page 16: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

16

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In our survey, we asked what people liked best about Old City. The top half of the list includes what we consider to be the most defining characteristics that are important to protect and further cultivate. We also believe that Old City's artistic and cultural identity extends beyond traditional arts uses like galleries and theaters, to include creative retailers, restaurateurs, and coworkers. The bottom half includes features that likely would benefit from some improvement.
Page 17: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

17

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The survey included open-ended questions, from which we distilled a series of concerns.
Page 18: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

18

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Here is a bird's eye view of Old City from the Delaware River
Page 19: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

19

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This is the same view, showing Old City in context of the rest of Greater Center City.
Page 20: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

20

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The City of Philadelphia is working to re-zone and redevelop a new neighborhood between Old City and Northern Liberties. We believe that this will be a positive development for Old City, both providing residents within walking distance to support Old City retail, and ease some of the development pressure in Old City that risks changing its character in unwanted ways.
Page 21: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

21

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In our survey, we asked respondents which neighborhood they would like to borrow any characteristics from. These were the top four.
Page 22: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

22

Page 23: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

23

Page 24: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

24

Page 25: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

25

Page 26: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

26

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Despite the improving market conditions, there is a certain (though declining) amount of vacancy throughout Old City, including first floors, upper floors, and unbuilt lots. In our survey, we found that people would like to see more activity in Old City rather than less.`
Page 27: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

27

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The question will be, how to accommodate such growth, which can often come with unintended consequences.
Page 28: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

28

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Using an online database, we identified over 6000 publicly available parking spaces between 7th Street and the Delaware River. Survey respondents, little to our surprise, said they would drive more if there was more plentiful and affordable parking. Is this a tenable outcome in a real estate market with increasingly valuable "human uses"? And... are people actually interested in having more drivers in Old City?
Page 29: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

29

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: During the previously described period of growth in greater Center City, driving has actually often been decreasing (something you'd be hard-pressed to find a traffic engineer ever predict), alongside robust growth in transit and bicycle ridership. Something is changing, and Vision2026 needs to recognize that and respond accordingly.
Page 30: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

30

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In our survey, we asked whether Old City would become a little better, a lot better, a little worse, or a lot worse if more people decided to travel by a variety of different modes. A strong majority of respondents said Old City would become a worse place if more people chose to drive. Not only that, but a significant proportion of respondents said they, themselves, would like to drive less than they do today.
Page 31: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

31

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Given that people are interested in growth, and markets seem able to support it, how will the district accommodate such growth without become a "worse place" with more people driving? To us, the answer is clear: provide much better alternatives.
Page 32: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

32

Page 33: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

33

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This is an historic image of the 500 block of Market Street, where Independence Mall currently sits. In the 19th century, the Pennsylvania railroad ran right down market street. It was eventually replaced by trolleys, including freight trolleys, delivering goods to market sheds. This street design made a lot of sense, but by the 1920s, its time had passed. The lesson learned here is that streets change over the generations, and it is important for neighborhoods to plan them to reflect the needs and preferences of the present and future, not the past.
Page 34: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

34

Page 35: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

35

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: When visiting several businesses, we found that people who work in Old City rarely commute by car already. Does the infrastructure reflect their needs?
Page 36: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

36

Page 37: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

37

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We often think of Amsterdam as a progressive planning paradise... but it wasn't always so. This street, in 1965, must have been almost indistinguishable from its American counterparts.
Page 38: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

38

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This is the same street today. The Dutch have made very deliberate decisions in transportation planning, and people's behavior has shifted. P.S. The success of businesses in the photograph is palpable.
Page 39: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

39

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Philadelphia is considering a VisionZero agenda. By shifting its transportation priorities, the Dutch achieved serious results.
Page 40: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

40

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The map above illustrates Old City's pedestrian infrastructure, especially its crosswalk network. Survey respondents overwhelmingly agree that more walking is good for Old City. What are the things that make for a more magnetic and comfortable walking environment?
Page 41: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

41

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Survey respondents agree that more bicycling would be good for Old City, and many would like to bicycle more, themselves. It's worth noting that 15% of respondents bicycle in Old City several times a week already. For the sake of comparison, about 30% say they drive several times a per week. Does Old City's Street infrastructure reflect this relatively comparable level of use? The map above illustrates existing bike lanes and Indego bike share stations, accounting for the neighborhood's bicycle-specific infrastructure.
Page 42: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

42

Page 43: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

43

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Indego's Market Street bikeshare station is heaviliy used. Especially noteworthy is the count of 76 daily trips accommodated by two-parking spaces worth of bikeshare docks. How many trips did the previously existing parking spaces support?
Page 44: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

44

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Bike parking, like car parking, is often hard to come by
Page 45: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

45

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Old City's current north-bound bike lane on 5th street jockeys for space with tour buses, horses with carriages, and bridge-bound vehicular traffic. The lanes are frequently obstructed.
Page 46: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

46

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: On 3rd Street, this is a common experience of city cyclists, also jockeying for position between traffic. Is this the safest, most visitor-friendly experience we can provide?
Page 47: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

47

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Survey respondents identified several things that would help them or make them more willing to bicycle in Old City. If we want more people to bicycle, which of these can we consider?
Page 48: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

48

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Even national retailers, reflected by this Banana Republic window art, are beginning to realize that shifting transportation priorities is good for business.
Page 49: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

49

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: And the numbers often bare it out. The reason for these spikes in sales are thought to be because of increased access to retailers, and because walkers and bicyclists make smaller but much more frequent purchases than drivers.
Page 50: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

50

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: 13th Street entrepreneur and Old City resident, Sarah Evancho says that she, her colleagues, and many customers bike to midtown village.
Page 51: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

51

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In terms of transit, the map above illustrates bus routes in Old City and subway stations. The two intersecting diamonds indicate a 7-minute approximate walking distance from each of the subway stations. Old City is among the most transit accessible places in Philadelphia. And though not as much as for walking or bicycling, survey respondents strongly feel that more people riding transit would be good for Old City. What are the things that need to happen to make behavior shift?
Page 52: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

52

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This modified version of SEPTA's center city bus map illustrates routes directly serving Old City. A map like this, where routes are color-coded, can help visitors know which routes take them where.
Page 53: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

53

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This modified version of SEPTA's center city bus map illustrates routes directly serving Old City. A map like this, where routes are color-coded, can help visitors know which routes take them where.
Page 54: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

54

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We also asked how people felt about various public spaces throughout Old City. Some, like Christ Church Park, jumped out as great opportunities for improvement with major impact.
Page 55: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

55

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Through our research, we distilled several core values, which come together to form the basis for a plan. The last item, anti-fragility, is a bit wonky, and worth clarifying. Beyond durability, which is about withstanding change, anti-fragility is about becoming better and stronger when stressors are applied. The suburbs almost invariably become worse places when more people are added to them. When cities function a their best, they become better and better when more people are added to the mix. The challenge is planning for shared assets that allow that to be the outcome.
Page 56: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

56

Page 57: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

57

Page 58: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

58

Page 59: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

59

Page 60: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

60

Page 61: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

61

Page 62: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

62

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: A few months ago, we decided to bring some chairs to Christ Church Park to simulate what a more activated space would feel like. Even though it was cheap and minimal, we thought it was pretty great. The National Park Service, which owns the space, is open to making more permanent improvements, and we think this should become a high District priority.
Page 63: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

63

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Jackson Square in New Orleans provides a nice model for how Christ Church Park can evolve. Like Church Street, the street between St. Louis Cathedra and Jackson Square is a "people street," featuring markets, music, and many pedestrians.
Page 64: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

64

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: On the other side of the Square from the Cathedral, and a larger street moves many people and good in a number of ways, not unlike Market Street. The green space, though larger than Christ Church Park and of a more southern character, is a very welcoming space, complete with walking paths and trees. `
Page 65: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

65

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Christ Church Park is a much smaller scale than Jackson Square. Fitler Square in southwest center city is a comparable size.
Page 66: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

66

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Rembrandtplein in Amsterdam is another square, comparable in scale with Christ Church Park. It sits and the junction of many tram lines, features an open plan, and eye-catching public art.
Page 67: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

67

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Paul Revere mall in the north end of Boston, next to the Old North Church is a hardscape public space, beloved by neighbors and visitors alike, commemorating a national hero.
Page 68: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

68

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Any future proposed improvements to Christ Church Park should reflect Philadelphia's character and rich tradition of great public space. Let's learn from the places we already love.
Page 69: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

69

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: If the Old City District and National Parks Services elect to plan improvements to Christ Church Park, the guidelines above are a starting point for crafting that plan.
Page 70: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

70

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Presently, Christ Church Park functions as a makeshift dog park for those who don't want to go all the way to Penn's Landing. If the transformation of Christ Church Park into a better "human park," at the expense of the dogs, we believe that a section of Wood Street Park could serve as an excellent space for a new dog park. It is close to both current residents in the northern section of Old City, and future residents around Callowhill, creating an opportunity for the neighborhoods to come together.
Page 71: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

71

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The dog park at Schuylkill River Park serves as a great model for a dog park in Old City.
Page 72: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

72

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The southeast corner of Elfreth's Alley and 2nd Street is currently an undignified gravel/asphalt lot. By upgrading it to a a small park, amenity could be provided to the National and residents of Elfreth's Alley, and visitors would have a more pleasant experience when visiting America's longest continuously occupied residential street.
Page 73: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

73

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Welcome Park, south of Market Street, seems somewhat purposeless today. Further study should be undertaken to determine how to better activate this a space and serve neighborhood needs.
Page 74: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

74

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Today, unlike Washington Square, Franklin Square is very disconnected from Old City. This is in part because of the Mint, but largely because of the highhway-like approach to the Bridge from Vine Street.
Page 75: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

75

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The Pennsylvania Horticultural Society is working with the Delaware River Port Authority to determine whether the landing of the bridge can be reconfigured to make for a better experience for pedestrians and motorists alike.
Page 76: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

76

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This rendering, by Olin Partnership, illustrates what that transformation could be like. We believe Old City should support PHS's efforts.
Page 77: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

77

Page 78: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

78

Page 79: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

79

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Despite the common urban experience and perception of lack of parking, there is a significant amount of parking available in Old City.
Page 80: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

80

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: As in other sections of greater Center City, many Old City parking lots are now being considered for development, given the strength of the real estate market and increased value of development in a growing city. In many cases, such as one project at 12th and Walnut, these developments don't include any parking at all. The shifting availability of publicly available parking means that Old City should carefully consider how to best utilize what can be considered a diminishing resource.
Page 81: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

81

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Customers, residents, and visitors can be delivered to and transported from Old City in a variety of ways. However, until drone technology really takes off, trucking will be essential for delivering goods and materials to busineses. When it comes to parking and complete streets, first and foremost, commercial loading needs to be priorities. The District should consider how to increase loading, in both space and time, to better serve business needs.
Page 82: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

82

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Passyunk Avenue, one of the neighborhoods survey respondents wanted to emulate, has done an excellent job of implementing district-based valet service.
Page 83: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

83

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The Ben Franklin Bridge is an opportunity for a certain amount of replacement parking. There are security concerns that would have to be resolved by the DRPA, but there are many examples of elevated highway structures accommodating parking below, including I-95 in Philadelphia.
Page 84: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

84

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: There are a few large-scale development sites available in Old City. Incorporating shared parking assets into them is an option to consider to provide a certain amount of public benefit without the frequently adverse impacts of parking facilities.
Page 85: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

85

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Shared car services like Zipcar help people make trips that are not convenient by foot, bicycle, or transit without needing to own a car. Studies find that each shared car can eliminate the need for 15 privately owned cars. We have been in touch with Zipcar in Philadelphia, and know they would like to establish a more robust presence in Old City. The District should help them find the space.
Page 86: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

86

Page 87: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

87

Page 88: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

88

Page 89: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

89

Page 90: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

90

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We want people of all ages and abilities to feel comfortable ridycing a bicycle in Old City. A silver lining of Pope Weekend back in September was that we were able to see how many more people would bicycle in Philadelphia when streets feel safe. How do we create this sense of safety and community in our daily lives?
Page 91: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

91

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We don't think the aforementioned existing infrastructure makes enough people feel safe or comfortable enough to bicycle regularly in Old City.
Page 92: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

92

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Today, there is limited "great" bicycle infrastructure connecting Old City to the rest of the City.
Page 93: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

93

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: But there are big plans on the table throughout the city, including a Spring Garden Greenway, the Delaware River Trail, and protected bike lanes on Market Street and JFK, west of City Hall.
Page 94: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

94

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We believe that worldclass bicycle infrastructure through the heart of Old City is key to becoming the place it wants to be.
Page 95: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

95

Page 96: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

96

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: The Delaware River Waterfront Corporation is in the middle of designing the Delaware River Trail. This built section on Penn Street, shows that type of infrastructure that can be expected up and down the river. Old City will benefit greatly from its implementation, especially if key connections are made.
Page 97: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

97

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: These key connections include resolving the last leg between the trail and the Spruce and Pine bike lanes, and a connection from the Riverfront to Franklin Square, building on the DRWC's Race Street Connector project.
Page 98: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

98

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Rather than expanding existing stations, a new Indego station north of Market Street would both draw visitors to a key shopping area of Old City, and provide residents with more convenient access to bikeshare. One site worth considering would be the corner of 3rd Street and Quarry Street.
Page 99: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

99

Page 100: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

100

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Market Street actually appears to be overbuilt for the amount of traffic traveling on it. By putting Market Street on a "road diet," it can become a safer environment for pedestrians, and space can be created for bicycle without compromising parking. Further evaluation and design need to be done, but this example from Hoboken shows how a street of a similar scale can be reimagined.
Page 101: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

101

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Old City's north and south streets, despite being important destinations, offer little bicycle infrastructure.
Page 102: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

102

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Protected bike lanes, created by a variety of physical divisions, make people feel safer and lead to increases in bicycle useage. If Pittsburgh can do it (shown here), why can't Old City?
Page 103: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

103

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Back in the summer, we decided to simulate a bike lane on 3rd Street.
Page 104: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

104

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: It worked out really well. Isn't this the street you'd like to bike on?
Page 105: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

105

Page 106: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

106

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Here's a mockup of how Old City's north-south streets might be reconfigured. This transformation will require careful planning to ensure that parking, especially commercial loading, is properly apportioned.
Page 107: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

107

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: South of Walnut Street, a Second Street bike lane would need to travel on the Belgian block of Dock Street. Fortunately, there's lots of space to a accommodate such a lane without sacrificing vehicular travel or parking, but creative material choices need to be make, in order to make the ride comfortable.
Page 108: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

108

Page 109: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

109

Page 110: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

110

Page 111: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

111

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: SEPTA is planning to renovate the 5th Street Station on the Market-Frankford line. This station is a key portal to Old City, and the District should support this project.
Page 112: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

112

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In a way, Market Street defines Old City. Today, it functions as much as a barrier between north and south.
Page 113: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

113

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: How do we transform Market Street into a place worthy of Robert Venturi's aspirations?
Page 114: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

114

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Given that the Market Street subway carries 180,000 passengers per day, we think the 200 block of Market Street can be reconceived, not just as an onramp to the highway, but a station plaza for the subway, and a public space for Old City. This doesn't mean that cars need to be eliminated, but that they ought to arrive as polite guests in a pedestrian-oriented environment.
Page 115: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

115

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Though not exactly how Market Street should look, this scene from Germany shows the feeling that a linear plaza can have. Notice that cars and deliveries still exists, but that the environment is principally designed for pedestrians.
Page 116: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

116

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: A few miles away, at 30th Street Station, the Porch now serves as a station plaza. There, however, the traffic volume is high enough that the plaza is still very much separated from the roadway.
Page 117: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

117

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In New York City, 33rd Street has been completely transformed. What was once a typical street outside Penn Station...
Page 118: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

118

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: ... Is now a completely pedestrianized environment. This isn't the right thing for Market Street, but demonstrates how cities are reimagining their streets. The project was led by surrounding property owners, who realized that a more pedestrian-oriented space was better for business.
Page 119: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

119

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In Amsterdam, Damrak, the City's main thoroughfare to and from Centraal Station provides almost no space to cars. The right of way, very similar in dimension to Market Street, provides primarily for pedestrians, bicycles, and trams, with a single vehicular travel lane in one direction.
Page 120: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

120

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We think Toronto provides the right example for Market Street in Old City. The street outside the City's Union Station used to include a raised median and several travel lanes.
Page 121: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

121

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Today, the street has been reconfigured as a curbless environment, with subtly differentiated pedestrian and vehicular domains, fewer travel lanes, and a pedestrian refuge instead of a raised median. With this transformation, the street becomes a public space.
Page 122: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

122

Page 123: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

123

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: To make a reimagined 200 block of Market Street really work, we actually recommend considering taking out the traffic signals at 2nd and 3rd Streets to allow for slower but more fluid processing of traffic, where drivers and pedestrians are meant to be more aware of eachother to make safe choices. Though counter-intuitive and requiring much further analysis and design, this technique has been demonstrated to work in many cities. Please see the videos we also posted on the District webpage, showing how uncontrolled intersections become much more pedestrian-friendly places.
Page 124: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

124

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In the 1970s and 1980s, Philadelphia made a bold experiment with the Chestnut Street Transitway. It didn't work for many reasons, not the least of which was the fact that it was the 70s and 80s, and with few exceptions, almost nothing in America's cities was working. Still, this is not what we are proposing today.
Page 125: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

125

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: We're recommending something you might call "transitway lite," akin to what New York City has implmented on 34th Street to improve crosstown transit connections. Today, it can frequently take just as long to walk from 4th and Walnut to 20th Street as it does to take the bus. To foster better connectivity between Old City and the neighborhoods to the west the District can work with SEPTA, the Parking Authority, and the Streets Department to restablish transit lanes with through striping, signal priority, and increased enforcement.
Page 126: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

126

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Configuring Walnut and Chestnut Streets for rapid bus service would not be very different from today.
Page 127: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

127

Page 128: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

Branding Route 51 ·---·

·---·

128

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Route 57, running on 3rd and 4th Streets is the only SEPTA route passing through Old City but not other core business districts. Key initiatives, including increasing service during off-peak hours, and visually branding it, can help better tie neighborhoods to the north and south to Old City.
Page 129: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

129

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Here is a simple example of how typical bus advertising could be purposed to brand Route 57 as the "Old City bus" between Northern Liberties and Pennsport.
Page 130: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

130

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Here are the rapid transit lines serving central Philadelphia.
Page 131: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

131

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Implementing rapid bus transit on Walnut and Chestnut Streets, and enhancing Route 57 would greatly improve access to and from Old City, but wouldn't fundamentally change geographic connections.
Page 132: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

132

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Some of Greater Center City's most substantial growth is happening in the corridors just north and south of the the core. New services to consider for Old City might be L-Shaped Christian Street and Spring Garden Street routes.
Page 133: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

133

Page 134: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

134

Page 135: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

135

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Old City is a very walkable district, but there are key enhancements to make that make the experience that much more pleasant and safe.
Page 136: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

136

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Several of the alley crosswalks on the south side of Market Street are not compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act. A great starting point for improved Old City walkability would be retrofitting these crossings. This can be done quickly and in advance of more transformative changes.
Page 137: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

137

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: An an example, side streets in Amsterdam frequently yield to the sidewalk when intersection with a major thoroughfare.
Page 138: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

138

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Pennsylvania vehicle code defines "unmarked legal crosswalks" as extensions of sidewalks at cross streets, even if they are not marked. Many of these exist in Old City, and should be formally marked. The photograph above illustrates such an implementation of a crossing of 20th Street between Spruce and Locust Streets.
Page 139: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

139

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In some places, it may be appropriate to add a midblock crossing. This example from NACTO shows how such a crosswalk could even be raised across a major street.
Page 140: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

140

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In New York City, Sixth and a Half Avenue is being proposed to receive a midblock crossing. While not featuring a raised crosswalk, it does include a visual narrowing of the crosswalk with the use of material changes and plastic bollards.
Page 141: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

141

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This crossing of 4th Street is a perfect example of a candidate for a midblock crossing. Pedestrians already frequently cross here, so formalizing the crossing with striping and bumpouts would let drivers know that pedestrians have the right of way. The Parks Service has considered requesting a traffic study here before. Collaboration between the NPS and the Old District on a package of such requests to the streets department would be a clear statement of policy priority.
Page 142: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

142

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Because of security concerns, the sidewalk of Independence Hall is closed to pedestrians. We believe that a walkable neighborhood would allow such pedestrian passage and that security needs can be met in other ways. A dialogue between Old City District, the City of Philadelphia, NPS, the necessary security agencies would be a good start to reclaiming public access to the cradle of liberty in America.
Page 143: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

143

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Once upon a time, you could even freely walk through the exterior grounds of the hall. This is another restriction worth reconsidering.
Page 144: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

144

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Walkable streets are well lit. The Philadelphia Streets Department has a good pedestrian light standard, which ought to be deployed on several streets throughout Old City.
Page 145: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

145

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: In addition to street lighting, the Ben Franklin Bridge provides an opportunity for public art that joins together Old City with neighborhoods to the north.
Page 146: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

146

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Lighting of the bridge would both highlight its stunning architecture and provide a greater sense of safety and community.
Page 147: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

147

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: While a Second Street station plaza is partly a transit enhancement, it its also a major pedestrian improvement. A "shared space" design would make Market Street much safer to cross more frequently, thereby eliminating the divide it inadvertently forms today.
Page 148: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

148

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Shared space is more typically deployed on smaller streets. Streets like Church and Quarry presentaly have a difficult time meeting requirements of the American's with Disabilities Act. Especially if they evolve to include more shopping or dining, they could be repurosed as curbless environments where cars pass through when needed, but pedestrians dominate the street.
Page 149: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

149

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: Quarry Street is a quiet street today, with a mix of uses, including semi-industrial ones. If property owners consider reinvestment and redevelopment on a more people-oriented basis, a shared space retro-fit would be very appropriate.
Page 150: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

150

Page 151: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

151

Jonas
Text Box
Presenter's Notes: This example from Germany shows how cars and pedestrians can share space on a small street, allowing space previously dedicated to sidewalk space to be more dedicated to retailing and dining.
Page 152: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

152

Page 153: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

153

Page 154: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

154

Page 155: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

155

Page 156: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

156

Page 157: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

157

Page 158: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

158

Page 159: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

159

Page 160: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

160

Page 161: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

161

Page 162: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

162

Page 163: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

163

Page 164: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

164

Page 165: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

165

Page 166: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

166

Page 167: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

167

Page 168: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

168

Page 169: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

169

Page 170: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

170

Page 171: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

171

Page 172: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

172

Page 173: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

173

Page 174: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

174

Page 175: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

175

Page 176: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

176

Page 177: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

177

Page 178: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

178

Page 179: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

179

Page 180: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

180

Page 181: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

181

Page 182: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

182

Page 183: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

183

Page 184: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

184

Page 185: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

185

Page 186: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

186

Page 187: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

187

Page 188: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

188

Page 189: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

189

Page 190: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

190

Page 191: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

191

Page 192: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

192

Page 193: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

193

Page 194: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

194

Page 195: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

195

Page 196: Vision2026 draft recommendations presentation

196