visual politics2014

25
c9 e):) /5J G,I -J Mh ^ a-E Ye)J {- .- >P l5l =^ e' oJe <( f,D 9D= ce eI\:) c9J d3= #2 E Ll_._ elD- (U = PJ-) .{- ! Ga E g3- 9t .-+ $l- Ee r.t' 5- C9- a t' v a-K :i- o 0. gp LLT\ \JT It* oi .V \., {t M{ g1r )L S \, -) st u.\ i?, hf- rY -i1 AJ lh ?' t, I I fr t a g e ?e f lp il .u S = *a- Qo-si P r. :) = i ="2 q:# 2 j 4: *=z'z j 3-{e 3B=: rE-5='fi= il'J:-+'5rT)se) s'E = +,='s ? 3 ; E"5e.--i=!3J=c 53 =,i'z d {e E 9l- ShD.+^)--\_;L E-rr6ajEddEqg! ce- f,- 5) o e) *"8 33 E g, F $r H. E sr -E'il' sd5-9,="d*1 *Y FrDeoc)gteoJt 3. - -"=" ; rr _j" c.r 5a = = 5 5.{ f, 5*9 e" P _i * 14 r ts'="eE i j"eb"or-dE.-c/t ;';=dilalH" H S; J--.>1!=*qfi,e)p E:H,?-9.ry8^H" H S- -X = 5ah q 3'c fr- ry -=a)=h_.JSOc) i--aO='5"=S aEl_ee:r!_f-:JD .lD3 NJ d d qr+oJ I q, N.P & ,) =.1 E)t'Dd, H ?e -- bia. c=P;P-er o; C Eri tsre E _= S eJeL-l*5 f3rf.r5j"i spus; u--uoJa5- -;bJiLr! qrc\eqJ_- d L? l-= e - 35.5 E: f,S. A = *;"9t5 { "? Ei3 3 b jj-lDer5 a^ F,. * J 3" =.. -"d.-.i D fi r J d* i P a" S;=4cee= J :JI :q^ l- e)" "* N) g'S F-ili='l F ( =;r5 E'& i, F *,gEH3r' 5ro 9e- 6 q D I ts ; u"i = d H&E 3 8', ? q 5 9(E 4 -'=-o = )e ,-- a-,: q c'-i '4. e 2: * "! 3 ca&:, - 3 F ii E =a_: -| = >eej = a L=e + 1.e 1u"r O >0d J r o d ^r dr"a P : z 4; { g cD C--,L^DJJ ee q 5 I r:- lP q ueeM 9 d ca E:,"5" 5 u f r -,- :j o lrr;i^^ ,fr< oD3 -" <+eo JSEHo = i'' c-"F o Z--e'E"-r 3E: ;59*p *,8.j:$,;8. :q*s3,r6 iB, *F.P { I 5'g { e5'fi = i,i E ; *flg.E,5f, $-.*F" "5"8 5r 5 5 p, F * f f s, 5:, ; e ;.q i; a i + a^$ $, = a s'= s i: g ; +* H r i x'.i : *: E,*, a:= = $ A"a si s'q5'$ia.{, +g' e'p=; $.5';3'il*'3.=g $.{ s"* B'i k rr r# H'F E"*'='$a =:3J $il:'a 1* = u5"sri: E il g'r-* i: s,F;' iflE'E' 3.*'s =," ( 5l "5- : ;; E *H: e'i' s. =.;g'E' $'lg;p"g'gilflg,* t J'iil551 *f 5**s.i+: ff;;fr.s'fl*'t. =: F={'.1 t,;+ H*ig'H*+$, =83'3'*'gq E^ 5 s s'-H = 5,=,q"=,EEi e..+.g.fi.*' $fl+;=g*;g, g" s; Er=x,i.c ; * 5 a i=;i s'uE i ='H,*; g' u. $ @ -. f E IN O Nb oj oL tud oe) :!. a lo 0 r); OO n:_ o9" ^t qi o= -J o9[ OE .o F-a rD x" Nlf*a Ee) LJI = 9[ -e ..J olt --rL Ni a d o 9[ o a o o (, rD rD. l !4 Z rD = o -

Upload: pandit-chan

Post on 27-Dec-2014

106 views

Category:

Government & Nonprofit


2 download

DESCRIPTION

This is an article titled "A Landscape of Resistance: Visual Politics of 1932 Siam Revolution in Contemporary Media," in From 100 years of Ror Sor 130 Rebel to 80 Years of Thai Democracy. edited by Suthachai Yimprasert and Thippapron Tantisoonthorn, 2014. Bangkok: The Institute for Public Policy Studies, 2014.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Visual politics2014

c9e):)/5J

G,I

-J Mh^ a-E

Ye)J{- .- >Pl5l =^ e'oJe <( f,D9D= ceeI\:)c9Jd3=#2 ELl_._elD- (U

=PJ-).{- ! Ga

E g3-9t .-+ $l-Ee r.t' 5-C9- a t'

v

a-K:i-o0. gpLLT\\JT

It*oi.V\., {tM{g1r)L S\, -)stu.\i?,hf-rY

-i1AJlh

?'t,

IIfrtage?eflpil.u

S =

*a- Qo-si P r. :)

= i ="2 q:# 2 j

4: *=z'z j 3-{e3B=: rE-5='fi=il'J:-+'5rT)se)s'E

= +,='s ? 3 ;E"5e.--i=!3J=c53

=,i'z d {e E 9l-ShD.+^)--\_;LE-rr6ajEddEqg!ce- f,- 5) o e) *"8 33 Eg, F $r H. E sr -E'il'sd5-9,="d*1 *YFrDeoc)gteoJt3. - -"=" ; rr _j" c.r 5a == 5 5.{ f, 5*9 e" P_i * 14 r ts'="eE ij"eb"or-dE.-c/t

;';=dilalH" H S;J--.>1!=*qfi,e)pE:H,?-9.ry8^H" H S-

-X = 5ah q 3'c fr- ry-=a)=h_.JSOc)i--aO='5"=SaEl_ee:r!_f-:JD

.lD3 NJ d dqr+oJI q, N.P &,)=.1

E)t'Dd,H ?e -- bia.c=P;P-er o; CEri tsre E _= SeJeL-l*5f3rf.r5j"ispus;u--uoJa5-

-;bJiLr!qrc\eqJ_-d L? l-= e -35.5 E: f,S.A

= *;"9t5{ "? Ei3 3 bjj-lDer5

a^ F,. * J 3" =..-"d.-.i D fir J d* i P a"

S;=4cee=J :JI :q^ l- e)" "*N) g'S F-ili='lF ( =;r5 E'& i,F *,gEH3r'5ro 9e- 6 qD I ts ; u"i

= d H&E 3 8',? q 5 9(E 4-'=-o

= )e,-- a-,: q c'-i'4. e 2: * "! 3ca&:, - 3 F

ii E =a_: -| =>eej

= a L=e +

1.e 1u"r O>0d J r od ^r dr"a P: z 4; { g cDC--,L^DJJ

ee q 5 I r:-lP q ueeM 9d ca E:,"5" 5 uf r -,- :j olrr;i^^,fr< oD3 -"<+eoJSEHo

= i'' c-"F oZ--e'E"-r

3E: ;59*p *,8.j:$,;8. :q*s3,r6 iB,*F.P { I 5'g { e5'fi

= i,i E ; *flg.E,5f, $-.*F""5"8

5r 5 5 p, F * f f s, 5:, ; e ;.q i; a i + a^$ $,

= a

s'= s i: g ; +* H r i x'.i : *: E,*, a:= =

$ A"a si

s'q5'$ia.{, +g' e'p=; $.5';3'il*'3.=g $.{s"* B'i k rr r# H'F E"*'='$a

=:3J $il:'a1*

= u5"sri: E il g'r-* i: s,F;' iflE'E' 3.*'s

=,"

( 5l "5- :

;; E *H: e'i' s. =.;g'E'

$'lg;p"g'gilflg,* tJ'iil551 *f 5**s.i+: ff;;fr.s'fl*'t.

=:F={'.1 t,;+ H*ig'H*+$, =83'3'*'gq E^

5 s s'-H =5,=,q"=,EEi e..+.g.fi.*' $fl+;=g*;g, g" s;

Er=x,i.c ; * 5 a i=;i s'uE i ='H,*;

g' u. $

@

-.fEINONbojoLtudoe):!. alo 0r);OOn:_o9"^t

qio=-Jo9[OE.o

F-arD x"Nlf*a

Ee)LJI

= 9[

-e..Jolt--rLNi a

do9[oao

o(,rDrD.

l!4ZrD

=o-

Page 2: Visual politics2014

"si 4:'5 g * *' ?.E

=.3.+ t t' #;,5 a; q"a s,9 * i' g

1 =,

E = = *,

= f E d

="S =.H E 4"q

= =, B'3 : =, ='

="='=-g t}a'*,gr e=; xxs8fl5; ;,.=i

='

Iqa e

E"5d,3i =-o

sil^rrp,$-Eaila.5: =;'"E";SI-4"

{

= = + H +, = s

= x * F.* E e

=, # g'

5: ;-g f; a $, n

=

"=;

H, * E^ ='

* =* ='

i' 5, e'E *,.$. =*

H' E-*.ai E, g' f

1.g a 3.=' "fi:8 $*'=*x'3'5.iq H a Tt+; €,

=a=g-2 gi"=H,"="iEafr"=, al Bgill= tE= * e.H' c, .E g "=.

s F g fi ? i =:

H"3 =

#"=, $$.il.*, *<.gEH.u*=,Faq' u=.='$-=,=i g.

H:

=,3

3, 3. * *"8,$ 5,e

=;

g"=,=. H"* =',+

e' r;

=. =. H, $ = = =

E. =,

d, r= 5 * 5: 5. * * i- +"E t

zSLrD -a)<9-fr-< D,Oe)=b.}J

N{lOrc\dfzSao ,^ lni

AUJ

^C'o2di++au-JsE]J.a)peeie 5=

N \*,,uo. s;of

hF^- 9)

=eeALCYEci s-J

'. JTUilFaU/-

^'D,u ee

UJ\u<Jp-' c'h CJPh <r'>6>JrU rcla.EQD--5

g; ##*^"ff izF" =u 3$ru3 3

# =""a

i a: E,i x' j* a s"q.# r * e; $ * q s'r

='H E fi^5 5'3 a: $ i"5,"{ E x;

= 5 f, E :3 : "S =

q"6 b ; ff'S-F'4*3 5r e s =

+; :: *,

"3.1"g";'5ag'

=,

65,5,34' 5 ig.+ y

3 E ?, t"{ =^

E*.=r + ="

A .*' il,. 3:*,.= P &3 d p""J J^= 2'I * 3 3e? c =:5"*3,^Q:; (}u.-e_5=-=l EdS-4" aSE:

E^=

r * il *FE gE.H 7,2i;: =

s gql*o -E

=, =-= H A- g 3. $

-t -* H" f ; "g' $tq : B I 3 fi' * q--B i =';

0 5,.+4"* +I = =" = 5'i,j i 3, -i ; il= 4. 5" =' n c;.q i i il s *-$'-=.de- z"Ao€-H, i;^dE,al ilfl,Hffi'rc

=' 5 5s5..5 p,3"ilJ= E.*n="-s 3p=J'?3 A: 9Ei-I H€i, =q-q'.E'

*'=+ ==,Eflg5' ;:€S ritE i3i 3s; eEs= #l5e il.d=E B=* t*o B*=E S,

CDAQ)dT=q-955rNJ

$i;:HJrEt3D'- e'P:: = dFler:#")QS i 3.5"q' j - -$qi,$3$o+sJ,3E'f=#a.n#,--F:3d*H':lei=",nor+ F"e'{' 5'.3 Q 5G *, d -q =,tE I" T 3"3'r q'= {"{H,h$'8,:"i*] h '4'-$. ?" i' - oa"3Jea*,its

N) s"i q X q =.5

3--i 5",U" 5 *

='# F d!'HdcLp+"

-i i7 :;- S k fD rD u:.F :lcG P o 3-.Srtlno

i"Ba$e"Elx-:s==99oaqH*i;=3"JT4JSB.;,S1.-a j-r ", =cg gt. F'{ d'1 ":

;aspljc:: -"p U": - u

; q I t errP =uilHSs:I

H:r=H'j;;

Page 3: Visual politics2014

3 3*-* F=5.3 3-S O SF a,=; *:5 3 3"3 F"3 q.3 = {eE E 5 J^* $fr F + (-: H S,: $^${ 3"5.$ i "= =" ="

g^t q.e 3u- lo- 5

= *q*3- * E'4 B =.gio'; H";'qt5 *f,tr"$fl"l $. $e.g'; iq$q 3,$5 $"i.+,'#E*,q.;^*

= q"*_8"ril=^.=: E,h^u^.g: q"

* E, i^ a. s Bros" * c 5 a ; j, J*B. fr +"€,"9 q 5 f; fi i 4fi" ;

= ;

= 3' 5^ S' p j, F 6"=.5 H, j j' i e' H;"H F 6 { y 3, 3 = z'3 ; A q S.5 J 3 * j tr:.5:* *.8 q 5':':d { 3 3 .-s q e"

rs,6,=x.g"*s.flEi $:E,5.$: #le, q,ag#; €.fl.;;.A aH 3^o5d'w i#i^e$.g1 $$5165"3;' $'58;{E'*e- 5$.4.# q

S E =:q

s!,*3,i #="q s i : 5'F #*Elt * * i E.g. ?

$ g 5'*"s S, q:g^€u},*;I *"ff i E q i-Fi 6 q. H ? # is s

=""4 s p: H F E, q, r E, s $ <' 5 E"H"d n g i :=' ; 3 5- Ei

+i*.43, Cq^=g*f";="$, 5'55";5,g.$.il s, gH' $ il.r 5a ZoSr5-S * = = i3k5,3',

H 3.5 j e =,a

H + t"i E g g q,g;i e.r.$;, :'#"3 s E

:s3 t*3I.fi H'S 0 ;o* x $ ryefr fr s9qE g flg ++g'g $€ E,3 a3,*a-= j

6 3 3 a i.€l :'3 i E"3 Fg ? =

g'q'* H'$=,PesrpEy.

=, E =

il_= F g'3'H p =

i"u *i.; g"+4 a ail='a 5,= :

= 1 i:{; F rt3 *ia * a F 3.; ;"=.8 # f =;il',=,?

-d G E*s A F,=

= 4I i il e-i".fi

= i".E q'=.-3 E'* + E P 5 E

4[ --l {: 6rn

F; e, il B' Ee F 1 6. 3 i "g q -; { * B'5, 1 i' [ 3 "E E, ] i B itEt _ S" q".E i H, d ,, 9."=- i * t F A S, ts = = I, ffi" E i : ; E'ftG l:i :"1"3 =*1 F'6, E"5 s " "5

=.5 Z FE j E ;; $" :3 ? {6 F'E: ; A'{ F3 g; 5'?

="a \ EoT * E e -, E,ai'E, lg,s

=l= E 5:=,i $i

=

q E E r n =*H,$a =*

€'F; c^=5 5,-3 i = br";-E i A

='

g A i,.E-:'q E H a:g * -g

q'AH i E"h {'i i 3 *'-i ;zry i ;i z =*,;,5 = i 3.= B\o = =^s = n

= i s E"E S.E 5 H *; E $.ilL=,= E"s

=.

=l H,E453'HA; g;=,+ E;;h.aq'=; 3E,:F?a=',5re3 r:a**.5: *=3*: + 5*.i?,ss;;8,=53.qi"= =

d i yF,= 5 + g *:=' F,*,E Eti";"= =

FE $*<* q5 =:ia, e=,**#E'+i3q,* =ix:*'E; =Lil=g, H*q: Y

=H9D;t a;:q-*l e!:.:: *tt;' = g'xse.s.={E3E' a: a: g' t

Page 4: Visual politics2014

a58! =;

H,g; f"i.-j=,qilE $: $; ='

sB.-(s,ss;;. +Hg*: E. 3*.ei; *il; g*35,=;,

eE, .8. * EI

$;, E 5 $$' $,$ = ; t + H' g 3'

=.

g' aH g; 3; H, * +il # ;s s E s'E s*s- =

x Ia *:*,E I $* *"=:g:T{= i F.t,;*.:l-*3.$3 6a5 4n.$* $:.x^$'3 ; s E'B,A Sts q * ? i #F

= =.=

g ;N $ $r g'$i s:$ il* +"; a

=

gre*=E $"t E;s

=,g its H$^;.t$i .5.$ q$ l-EA

= gHa:IB :,y1"8 e.s :

S $^ * *'8, i $ X f =

q *" 3 =

Ei1=' **B *,_ 3 d

= h^ H'.d €;Su-s* (

=s*rs*"_X.*t.:. i=,gi $,"Hi*lE *;: i€=+aS t&" sa h- 'ss sss^3:5 s.B^ *tg:.3. 5^A,"il=l ti: a $€ 3: 3 5'

*' u:

S S'R_8,$^*Fi E S. E 3od E"=

s'$-$s s"p;E $tc E +E *i,*

==$t,s e

*:,.E.H$-$-* ,H5*='i =3

q-4 qfr=*H-d"

B -d',.B' j 3'*fi',3 $r r 3 6 7 ir+'E'*si "*=,{E: q=,5H,; -4 * 3,aa:ssD" F=-:5= H 4; +U"'.u-^^s i B s. =-

e = r. s * E 7 E f I $" =^-il

d j" H-.$-*B'J 3, 1e-j "===:S^aJ = ;j-dnj.rql63e j*:_s

* i 5, f ; i-* fl' $'A.g I 6 u.g il.5'g ='*' $".i.;

S';' ,g'

2 s, t 3:

'il i..5' g' s,

=-

q' ="

B, *. i ='. * pi $ $' $

N Eil r=*13EEil}+ g#+*3E, $s, $$N

= 3 Ai- H=* H""E jg-; 5,='.Th

=3 q-iis45"5a*i

= {'I;*E"uE $'SS^Hf5 3=, H'6.;,E.i3i E E' g'i=,$^*S $Ei $,*:?* ii.E"U:ilfl5'+q E hil+iE*uo r3'i,.r Fa #='.H's il f,"- E. il-= p g$ -$. fi 1B-:

5"=*tg,.c: il 'i=g€i f ? Eag+=$.*ls' s;

=S .*:I.*aq3E'E]= =3q=iS NE-Ei ;

$i +H.*,:*,=, g*.EB Er*rgg sis, s g

Page 5: Visual politics2014

?.-=H3 3'3"'$Ei=:'il, 5="33 A: f,qF" F'P E:

5,H s E ? 3 4 g'E,:l a Z*:* g N, g'l aE' ;E

=

f, :- .'*re*2.-3 s ie it=$gg j { =':= :+eii7*= 3E i$sF.Hu$^=g: EiHe$.ZE^6f,"il E: $,it"il \3* B,Sr- Jr #=a-pi3 ? .rDcsE z T"f ::-=4 XE -4,5_h #3 =

=3t:"=i i3' =s=d= A2e.=.i33= F=^34= *6oi dz ?"& :i e&d=1s1F4: 5qE;fdHEg*,: Ee, * ;nF$tH +f, i a^:cte99#

E a='.$3*--.*=*,aH,BE r:^r5"# A *EE,-r, s

5A$.5.s-il q^g.E; 6a'*'g';:"B'q,E A?93"gB EN E'1^$"3aB $H.13;"3.+x.ilE:"e^g 3'iHi$.a; =E,+=r g'$E S3="+€r"H: E5=-El tp trE*E,J^5'*_*q" = 6,.5 : zi q ?o*d

=:'=:5 4e*"qii5 c o- rD -1 il a'i f*ri: *5"$g"t'tE d; +A'a $,{:r"?; E ;

3' ==6a i: =iga=n "H 1i,[ ='3-fi,=*:

5 il"s: 3;;€ Eli-**Ed,E,.?' il,;,ar* ilA-q3l A E.

E: *' +?2. FI':'*.a.I$ ;gu^3"il.rie I=9D9H E=38^ eE"i=;B'3"; =+;# AE,.sa E

= > # F S' j 3"-E 3-et -'E F.P-=-5" tr-5-6 f, ee

E,u 3'1;E I,E F= il*$$+ilE?3 H'*g =

[ +*:

a.#.8 = =,a

E E+ q^$. 3'$'d.= ? ="i,i

qt{'* * ='

$,

n+€ 4 i' 3 ililH; a $l 3' yililE

H' E H'

=

il+til 3"z."t S E'= H ff5'=45"g a'1'*ap <'#9"3.i+il E"

ur=:'rx' =^e"a.=

$,g"g.3' =i

$i".#3 H i5a,g{=

s =.3.;^ry

r'#: il il: * =

E H : q,$ f; p s il; 3 +a1a,

='

3*g,i.$ a^fi,H,="'3 ['il*+r=tH,3'il* $E.= H tH a e^ E E'l'il 4 gifr il i *5 e g,='3:"3 i 8, 5 +

=

**l # E 3 * 3 * *, ? n 5, H'q, E *" $: * s;

i=c1EHH,,3l i'+i; H4Eg{itilH+ig+ *

e9J

!\rDfk-orDqoi)

=.{N6;(r.J r}

I

orDo

J5,[

2jDc)

t''SD

,:t-1)E:Je5iN

Page 6: Visual politics2014

il0E'.5 s= 5.9,8',. il^i * y= = ea- 3 d s:3I $ $;

= 5 *g+='< i -,tr $, c- *=,5: d * F E ., c,,j:3 3f,s H'( j 1

$.e="i $15 #$.e'E g.=.H,A'i'3 $ 3i: z E.B =

**; !'A

=:.$'.="4,4

i E,H Ei il^il..5 =^H^=.H,

I q:) = s3i i Hi g" ;'=' =-.aH:

s ei'H IF *: *6' = a;3:,5 f,+ ;i"4f,1"5 r' 3' F' 3 H^ H' $ F a;

= a s 3 g ; 4 $' 3' 5 3. g. 3: u 3''*. t'-=

= 3" ?n,65=-i-Sg^-5")

H ? ==,

H S *^ H, p^"d $ $ H, E, : =.

; 3 d g, P= E ?,9 E' H. i+ 3 q E,**

7,C:,=* S:

='9.:';A"8."2g,3 5-i 0 H q f, j" e

= J q PN g 5, a =

5 i a# 3, 3' 5- 3 =

5' C r,F' =" d il j,, f* E # 3o E*

=F,rr -t' * "* g. E ; ? a_;H" E E H-

- * B"€ H p

=,

I = i l Y E" AN s

=&?E H'H"='.E E'r e,i $"H"H 5 q :">3r9 E y =

g; s = a; 7' E E 5l 5 *- 3.-p $. *""9, # C = q di g 3 s ;B' 3- a' 3 =-;

=""ff ; e'5 - E,*3?,-s"B^i*^Ea*=E'H^H: + 5l*=,FF5,$ li'3f'* ti t=,3"3 it =:3 =6.*- : =-E;; 3" 3 gF3_i--

E

d, *. -. + i = x, u' E, 5,

g,

=" t, 5,6; g

=*i i i 3.

g^ e'€o- 5, *#='flE.pl T5il.fr,B,H.a;

=E'.n€0s.8 *

=a,5,;" H, gj"=,

H i ;" X, 3 5 $

=' I,

= + B € q i $, g E

=

="s'==; q=-;h='fr 3;p'*-=;i" e:fi g'=teri-!;--s i fra -Ei ={s ee -{ = r.

= E A i P l,f; * *3 ;: *03'"=. *qr* E q i "-5. 413 =

6 3 F' a r --c-JKFCE# R A = s il *"d-i g,3,E,U.B': e i : 3 = F e. J 3 E,lH9- J&'\^sor:- E'Eck'^r^i *,4*q A.E' ==l

BE.

=" * F i B. 4' 3' 3- S L F : $, *,.$ i, *# S $"p E, B, +?sH E'E'E'd,= -.d.5

= = E 5,= =,3"F Et:-= r -, y g j, =-9,i 4 5 q-o^n-3 5 6 5 <D E-e3 3r=o*q A E

= ?-g Ei= i*. ',, = ? ) * B 5 d"$ S" = 5'='a* il -: o-n =.4 T =--l-='30il =q:? a iry js:t+*r^qe-=A=;5*E= €F 'e \h'#

= = a A -=, ! 3, E e;

= 5,"= E *.€.

="H + *' g ff H3+bq 2,3,6"* jJ qg 33i ='riZ 53q 3 *'br-S,Ei'=FH dq=H?58 i;E'="HBE f, *$5-N g'AUE-ea.*3,HES:6* $'a-Z^5.*"F E q.aA'N=Jef,--.;^G }q'=f*'*kE*'"Xi"pg :t'.5-='=+= ? ,,e8"91r"9+-49="-:elr"js;"-;9=3[-fi==:)c)AEEs#:"fl=; H=".=+=B 8,"9.$=8..4:

"C. *ua;.-J,L;\r =.-,,8 3'E u:= E'q':;-.8 $,='=,8.H g, ir ; = Boq""Sg"Ia] eerEA-'$5

=*^E'fr'H,i" 3 e^=i;'=-q E 3,.3'

='E = b *')e 6 4L = = = ) er )af, rdn la_d =ra-E"nE3' *"Hq=;{-Hfr=E$31 3* rje.4-?-4'?1"8,

="39a{id' 333#'=i; HH: E:r.b^-1 D":{'

=EA-d i"$: i( F, 1.S,8'= Zo3" EsDItd#ii =e

-aB="=; $8,3.8,8,9 , s*disuk=,=' .$fr=^ir"=:'iB;.=;il ;q" g3* :'* j3r"E'3-;tH,-i; $H".$5'3,*, $3=*g= 3-* $

Page 7: Visual politics2014

= u = = 3 5ra -)ed an e F P z[= d- Be-b6 ? * =

g'd $a E.d a i P il 4^ fD'!lJf;^gDeZ<)J"f,:irt:D[.rizaN :J N I 5l-S 3'^ ='f 9.5 ei'"AB'* Et =

I E 5 r P c al 8"" j a) ee i * F' 5 4 lt f Z e e;- o

= 3

= g 3

= j E,do3 E-5"3-8. A.3"Y

= = t = =

g. a i, =,"e

y ; q E.'g e. B q +,-iF 5 q- q, { E. 3

d.E t, =_e

g, a, il I I .d.a'il E r E,E; * fr : 5. *,

3i r g"$ ; A

=';, i A.E F F t "q

il; E-8"; g 3 e'

3'4. il' ; g' H. H; F *- il,

u fi" 5^ e' 3""+-= x $"? roF* ,-P"P =i q aL5"5rE- rPQ r i?('E; #,

=i 34 j:I:t^E'"8- 5'fr g$.;3'i.E^3: ?s E,=._- j *=: aE. +"H F"g: 6"d j 3=d a

= 5$ F=d3=8, CH E=F5igf, Z€ I ui = r-2 * 3 e d = G ei - ) -

d

= q; E- - --> -T a -i;- L I 5ne E:DZ. d ,qg #'E.rl#4'5: p.pa: F:;ufrl s; F-a flq Sli *-$ Hr!l 5

=,.d-uApsdr7il E,

E, q.*'43' fl3'e* ?.8; H"il$'H.fl3^ H,

q :-ll

=" \d, =ei "3-++ H"5 3l jg*+I"

= e-i N* H'5= *-H.'"1 #{Aiis dDb o c- c J Ei z f, t' r ee deE r[

uo.S dc3 l()-ra"J

fEParls---u)S9=d .c P Ea -^,2t-"t

= o -JVdFo="?o<

P- !i"1 -e S q? 4^' -l- c)

a 5 ts u 1 -r--5.=;;5j.Is" -o" 'a ar H 5 JrJ---LgDJ,

2o= N 3.*30frEri! : e ai ? +I S.:,,_s =

; Ab ='4'4 ri s €raB q 3 { ird"

-n Eqf q - l

5 =;(ni = q 5

es}E:-=jqi"ee+--L=\".-r_5 5 H a F_lY C J ee =

J rN u I :, 5,.$^ * 5z^3-- t l-4DJ u <qjo=19=rw t' g. -zl :a" Z(naJ

E P E = F.B'Y J J J J,iree4F5,{NGi 2 E-:4 i N-e(=2(Ln{ 3r5,15 #"; F" $o< 5--- DD d

',n = --

- Y;] a f[# tH(r9r--rJeiii Jc' ]tO;/).rq

=.P':i =J ntr q.-z e 2; = s;3*2I *A ? 5t a riy:;eaN

=Et'f:n

-ta)Dg--.,"i"-rr.q:n E^='^"{* i,.i 3^ B :'- B *,8 5'5[3 3^= = = Fa&9)'.-C@::

s*aHH',i,=d[H ]siE"=n=Hs=-="d=1,A * $*f,:E,E'3-$^=8.+55

= $0a-F',qu:fr q.xfi3-:ER

+rL-s)CE'aar-i orF f, q.Xi"5"ts 2 5 r z*:, + z n'---,- F 3'd'7t+=g==3H.3:$-ft $.

d =" g. 5.il

=,

q,'i, a $ $

="= :gf5fie'",Fa eq,.-3i P"53=;t'Bo' !6ig U'rt jSa1; = P5.5^e* q 5"? j j"ee 3 PrFE'=' 'H-.i-J{$,F- $$a6 fr ='3 *: ="sE E s'

$,= e;;'"e."ilf8- 5--Bd rD z *, I A H F = E.E'SSE Ss;py.'ce;rEq , Z;o=.5;s q E: .B-5,C1-PrDe)-F5t i = 1 s'{*H3" r'sxB \*Hi^G=; ::2 E i 3*2ts-5't:, le

C)rD;.1 @

-Y-UrD=lrd'lo-OaON!a

;o--loloP

oa-rD

N)-!+

,.

rlr"_ :.: .:

a&,

i.-4:

' .B i'.r-q [-.

--.1]oofq;J0-oZrD:o-odo_

& I**%*

,@r '**e& Se

So

sl1r

w

Page 8: Visual politics2014

aHi.$,ae =a.x'e.q.$4,i'*#

f E; e.E,='E'f;i "x g;

=":Y i {

H'$ q i r E $ B.+:'"i t x r n g.s e''$ +'i $.$ g' s'E: ;' a

3, i 6 fr a,"5: * f'3.=,+ ;: =^

r, $. # 5,s a'.* + ; $- ; A * =;

q'

E'=.= i $.E..al "i

5..5 E;.+5'+= 3 g"E 3'il.= 5-E =E F s" E.

= $5 &

F;: g"$="E=='i'+.$.il-a5, r =$t=^"$

3,4;.;'g"H i il g

N 5'* =;.i,

f 5, $ tF.E,.iiil= a^*..q;.c..3' i $'.$'*, = *fl

=N fi-* i g"r' ;,.#*.$q p.'fi 5-g f H,pE fr H6 $:"t;*, 1= oi :6.E., 1.f F*3 i i,d

s; $.p$T g$E, "€ ii$.$a$.$ E g.sD*4fi

5, ?, A. 3 ; $='c 5 * =^"a == ;- = =: d_ j q S # r g t'r t'. saD=.

ix $ frl $: 5 *, a g'.*' 5, H F,.q, i, 5'"H' E i ;S' * 4F. 5' ilE 3-l'=.= e E' E:"U i-ff;: * $ E"H,'$s"S fr.F-E fr.5,.5" il.

= d,E5;,8.-[ i-"1+q*3q5, SaS g=R+.3,H3,5 =qDSs,xsss"="* :.8,.8:"*kgi- z g="

*'HsEaAS'- g'5E*3'E:= ;$-il* ;-gi S:"H$,=,,sHE.=il=q" *l p:F=g=i. ggp.g: -=,$,A-fi*p

SrSrs

s5llD

fL5f,-:)l)e)cgdSr-fL)JJ6F\r

= a"a s,5 3;5 F -.

*-.: a$"e =

q:: $ q. +aa 5

= S P 5 *" 3

=" Ei.s =' -r '"3. !

= z.;3 f'q $'fi 3"=* E.$,*. :i,E*+fr 5"#"3+-3= *t3, S3 E-3 F E J B'q =; s,= $nE2 i;#q;'B.Hg- H;a: s^!:i gi<-$d'5"4, +g Ei-Bt= J+HIE=...3 fj sN ; S a 3 B'd'= Fle H,H 5,\o a = 72 c-$ $ a'E' q,+ $,

E-? .5'iB.=5^-HE +{ sZ -) -e) y { J

= ? !: i -1t *

=-t, 4s'31$+-= Er Fi--l e --.: k

= g c L: 3 'q H'

1qp_9." "-a -) =" = = 9e - e re"F P.E i';.il €_ ;9, S-* B', E j 1d.3 i"qF 5* E3-iq =i N

=,8. H.H, #'S,i= i,il

F€' 3'?;" = ca'i H*& 3 = = ; g,=

= !"H

Page 9: Visual politics2014

oJ 6)tr Jo +g €^H'fr=.d. g;-?J+rt6:cjeS.":)--)di*I 5)eJ +Lb C E 1i Z"fr-** $,=*: e i

=. #fiT 3.?-= *o giltL zo r

= 6. = ee F) i=t H', H

"5 *,.d: i. E ;^$, F4 Etar*s = s.

ry 5;+235{$ F

= 4- 3 rt'=* 4 ( to, c- -i ) 9 ie-Cfp:? oo.,l .) Z '- c. ? *-'9 iT #S_dH'S*g :t -a---? = a. = r I 2

= E 5 =.=

i s.5' is c'Fu J t--l a)

= 3tS

= r--$ 3"3 H.3; 3

$ igB'il+?e $:

5 H.4t+H,Hil8 H.

i 3 q:-J ; q c oL-\J)\-9,6i3"* H = d'E F= {'3'#il R

= 3-- q-*lSo3

l"r E ZC5"sl

SLEJJ:)

=J.

Y.sjJ'sC!I5e3r(5)3a"JJ+

i E4-JN)

!rdN)HF!!-sU f. u)e

;JW5\Q':\la)(_J:l"Jt

.4 .lD 3A e) t t =D 5" r,4 t F I 3- 4 5^ 5^ = F Y Ae

=" = d/l

:=E ==, j.=.q'=,g=,"84q$*'€l :gi i=-Ejb *, 3., il,

='oH.p ='A d'=

='"i, F $ A t i H # * ", so 5 I *3 B', t

= = r e ^ - -5 n d : i' *i i 5. i:* I $, z = ="

x 3 3N\ e a L l- De J Ea =: -* ?e 5o S

=. * *ilt F B B f' u,

= q 3X b-**-= o-:_ &'-,1 .c z: d *) = 6'Si-_z ii b ?

= S"= i,5,BrEg

= H,1 Srye a fl,= il'e a'E i1 il r i nil + q 6-z';E

,,P"= I =-+ 1 3 4 i T

= i s 3 3:S

="8-H'= $,

= F e g 4:*;M

= a 6 #;,u x e"r b d FE.E_E { 6_e s = D q s;

$'E i'x E.=s E q H e:'.fl.i E H:,iH t#+,ryi *P55,39eN' H a, il $; ;-B u qil=,*d

=, I =,2 =:*=:

*:.$,5*,5 H: "F flBN q t"A, * + g ae

$ fl . = =

:= "$ s z qr r. +. ilE; =,

* a =;Z+ =,; r : H. e j 3 I 5

= B 2t"5,= ; Sq"$"fl'tF-E'

.6D-qli5 p {"P E*1* 3a:rarr* Nr re ?*:,tH'+u".a'f;r! $i l,A-* ?., ee r"r J' -. N z-i s t. 3,-$, H E $ *, f ="E

E' 5, \ 3 *" =

f 3=3 5 &k n r," o-\ a h y S S, S .' ", \ -fi,4,$r_#, g" + ; a^ H F a ;=Js,;r"q.E {E E^;i iiSS'.=E: H,i; E"*"=s3"p-rE,re a\ a-4.r- d d, treB 5 2,5 ? B'a--, L"g E 5'F'l;5 o-s s"

L$E: P3' F-fA:!=3v:r rira"!;=='E'=-49?' S'cL3)6 ra- r B h'5 S S Sti 1 5 r 4 ceL 5 5ab f, 5"",rIE'96*,'" - 4e 3, lFt5^qd3 qf,5bs=-="d e* 3 S:p 5 s,s. il"S'

=:.8_F"= J-H =S"f

il gU i J E. Z g ^ y9,il a = i'"H .d,#"= i ?:,-B;r-i X.*5 ='il s i 3 dD :,

I

=l5r! ^)! =r,iPio 3e B,

c-r,

t

JD

+S^. o.

co 3,69 e

l

5lc-t'

3:1PPr!D,!D

l

?:5rc3D5-l

=PNs!o

:l

t3-9c

E"

=fDIId

-oIDJslt

zt'lc-ee

Pr3Icl

r

3oeeu:i-@D5

a

-)ru25-\lJGJ

e

!5

cJ

333)I

s3$e'eNt'F l:fu3l

a

35a3ENf@15uaD

D

Page 10: Visual politics2014

+$-.H'39,9' ;H"?="H,.3. ='E {'

J - L l_ -J- ^ z: .ap-{ - r e-

=;:5 h-5, 1"4 f de4'ir*- 5'o --r ) d"5 q 3,{ i "s +* vd F.E- r 4 ; x q i+ t D ee F 6oJa 9 :4 YJ- -- ? r) Y = g

il^ E" u:."9 Z i i 3.,8 5. $ E. * 3. = s:_\\ _f,) ) < e4 _"<= cg 3 l_4-=_

= f

2^* Eri*5"3S'=='=,;iiE= * =,i io1*3 S,\ d E,5-r : 3*6 =

E 3.

B^q E =,

4"i-= #-= 8" =

*"8 i, F :-' i o-F- E t 3 :i # r.-: -- i :

= q

i *, 3 = E, H,.8, S, N E[ & 5. 5. 3. "ro E

5==s--Fi+-5=qr-D=-ox,E.=,E E =

E-E ="J 5 # E T B, E

'== $,

='

; u. =-

E,-3 =

f; r =

r F 5 4o^ i B ts ="P.5-d,=

Z j i"*o-*^ $e 4

= g fr;.;^"=

= *aE'+*'3 s' E" FQo"5 --- j. 4- # q^ E F'

= 5: ? i,.1 = H'L d--J 9^ee [i---J" ^SaC-? e) I ^^ d-r (-,3fl**3le s.Ji=,;#

= A" E.:rnf =

D I r* r'd = 5 ai ei-)e r- g .r.e\ I j- F

= E fi_e "{e =r

= S a.s q Er5 = j e- ce -r z =F z e '. # 4-; t 3"-5'c - c d{

3-#, 5 x 5 g : .,- 9'"< H"{ dr NF = C P --f - ;l r ct u- 3 - !!s- f, *a-S? r s J Z t' f, - 5 sL I

eesee)

E.JJtsr--)eeo

- eae

bct)c4oJl

teCe-

[':

Ffri9el=

Jr9 DqE)e) )P)

zo = -.1 r'33e)=;;

G, ee pPzb :-

b-*"J 4!"'[email protected]

c9[- I I)b^ \o 7i5c'J"Bia d';)" r l')='

c) c,Il-,* 3 S[-a{-="9--)

+sL(!

ac9€3e)l5=

:? eh e)Se ei- *"* S.G

9lr 5GJ'S*GSHD

-5EJJ'

C!Jf

'51

;(,F!a'sLE

N)J()) +N) UI

F: eD?4 F sr- a-?.8 "s13"4' t"3'F?ie84"HiF'B A $; a S.:"- 5, H $ o "3" 6, il $. o a E,

*-' =.

3. i =a H r-t' a)p c" --:"= $E' ,.v4* ?,?'ts,g,4,6.+Ei.H $=a'a a''i'A* =

E€'*tg*=.o'=,9 E e'H $ fl,"a

-. =

-=:si 8."=#_ f 35-f; E.E q"E"E I5 T e'* = =

P = *B'i E"B Q-r L' H.= =

3 5 E"* E'L,y#" = 7.*F =r 3- 3 = { e j -=" Z^ )' -. = ;. i :iH0.4, "- ? b" -i E, ft E d H.-N B,q K h < il_ =, a: # g B E ! +

=--,'sB---.l

x'g,x' gi a g B,

3 E ; r : g t * E H e, * +.* * gl g' * *

H 3'E ;;; 3 S 7 s S 3 A.E'r H F: s q,$ =,

$ A: E,A QN 5""+ B p, F ;, 3 g ; =

I -z''-" 3 P "="

=, 4 5 # E $ s; B.-A's ?"=-F.'"=$f""$P xa^- E'i-E: "u* Fg'g-=;-38"q,3.#z,E_H

= e, ; E :', :" = E, q- e=, H E,

=.

4:B A, B' a .?

E'q.g,i.V,* E E'se 5r5nE-30 E'5"SI-*"*:;"E-Bs;: .q;+i=* igi +gg; * H*, g.efr;$5+i,"ubC-R-.H=gj;,e.c$ :+"e #+aE r=€*a.z'qE3 =

=B'5',fl.E: dE =*-gi a: :^.Fi; E,i,p*5'*, =F'=u* $

u,-9,_,i-E,$t9 #"*,q^ gl -3-ti HE.h"HB'ilgE" s'

-,(ni-9"50!-Z

Page 11: Visual politics2014

5 S.SSq z5 5 B F' d,6 =,E.5

B #.3 =

6 5 f"B s 5.-="#E-B=.$"9fid'=. *,'+B*-= 3 3,3'ip ^- *,.!"$;z d'N 2 ilEs,=i4.fi.8,5,55: =

*,ig^=E+rFHF=: "9..$;: e ;; ci # E E,+ r g^* $ z F 5 $ 5 8 B,u

= ;^ $ E.F- i s.i ;3 * E, a = * =

a xi g g 5.x, f =

E" r; il ="+

q: e,+ gl 1' 5s,

=) ='=;= B.'E ? :; a"3iq^H#

E' g'E: 8.='i, x f'x gg,..;q,## ii c 3 e

d Hl:4r$ #; E;5,i,8^,F n =" fr $ 5 5. g. H * ; 5, J. xfg 2 ;; g 3'

=' P: 5,

"g q. E B. iN "5 3-=:B =

e $ i $:3 =i="{*a

a, e ? Q;+= a+i *,3;E' g'd g B Ag" 5 =

8 :"8 A:."S i e 3' 5'"8 3'g 5'E'E, i 3 E =.

i $" 3 .-€ 6+'i H S 3 * #"8"* 1 d.'H'E g s B i"=t H -=; $; E"3"4 = i( d,: ; > ;'H 2 =

s n "H,N 5,# -a,* q j * s + L"F -3-= "*g il 3 g.;^8,5 3 E ; 5 2 E + $ $ 3I d S E,- j H F * H" -E;

t,F 3 *. -" ; 3 + a 5 a e, g t^ f, *. $"q

=' *, f, i

= # fr^ il

+"3, = g, q "$"#' $ $ # * # r 5;

= 3, 3. + fr-B tr F 5, t,"g s.

a'"i A'r e =

+; s =. *, e:9.

= * e 3; { il H- B, S a E Et E' t h' H

= g s $. H' =' sr

=' 3, *

= =. * ; S il

j il-

=, A-e)--Jc.rlC

=j SfUfr=il€t ;=-: fl3i gii; EF:EB F&a*-.?; o" 3

= ; E S, { g E $'$ E'*, E H, 3't

=^ ='F ="*,i H"Hl * P.E = =,i Z 5. H E 5,3" i,L H t^ + fi,3 * u-

$, fr E'"d E, E'E' ; * il *' s H' i^d {"p il S H *, * f, E'

il"$i

=

rl'.+ I^E g '*,s, 8 I H' *, + E'i B.* f; 5 ; H'='

=

'9,

= H,#,

q s E P =

1 "= 4 i "= p'=^"9 f,"* E: ; g

* E"il,= =

ilU: E f,fi 1^; s,5,H,"{ 5 =*?H""5j

qH, I3 8"5 s"= $ B, 5 ; s. H g^eir

=-, * $.I.= 3 S $ u $

e-3 *, E'3 1="91 fi^?f =

E,E q q =

kil H 7='= 1

$ t,$ ; il il * g e:; i a ;,; i, # q; n eE +

=;

H,*

+ $ H "

$ i B $ E: i'il t * f, [ ' 5'= $ *.i'E; 5 $

iE^s su**ilE: u$5y#= g.+9..qiil55u^H,H 4F"H;"f4?5; *;

=g,F ilFql i$,=i+' $

='==.q. B.a^$$t['$r=: HqE, H'E,"a*gnE' E{ :

rD

=ZrD

=€o c9--oX.aZ^\rD '=5-#Gt'P3'G -,1uiloO\:ovP;+u+AYo!-IV.T(, s-m(n :;'-dtr

4JFr ^,o'N"9t'a

-lFa

eYJ\re\=lre9ui!n

"6Y' olnoi+fnsloC

Page 12: Visual politics2014

i E-3'+B'fl3'3"3,5E""35" o3F B3='G X^o.i, Io-&_ 5:5, e 3E #E'; {'5.F8-=,fi E Z'-*= F,E H""B 5,? =- g',

ra$'ii gH 5;.8.P.a: a"="9"*{q gE i,:'$; ='= B

={TE d i {- 5,.il'F =

E H"= *q"q'u *= H: 8"*; # 5E e,

= 15 d'**"H"t't'H.,H

='+..il'; H,;' q"g 5,=: * e $"r'S

= A'"?, ;.

t3 x"{.S S b'a ? i*E 2*ile'*,"i \ru 5#,8.q

= u*:i^g.g'a"F"*'r * q; [fi I

=. **'a=,.* t *"#=, i

N * =

$* g:i 3B$= a,E E i $3 E E $'I,il3:*g,+='g E

X +'- a'X E-= E'-f *"=t'5 \ i. 1""4€ 5.$"8 E E-';5 t,J'* E3 E 3 i l.i,= 2 H'=H J.*E,i !;E'="3"3 { '= 3-s * il,= s_4s==,a+s?EsBq=l =3.8,*H "=,

g,E.$ -E.;n= s i-E {'g$,8-H H,=.9"= r'* p,Fos r,4 * E 6 ., d.fl"H qi-id,U"ig,+f g'i'5 33.6^(,.P's F:iq, $il'3 *.d5-+S-#4'E53qE', E=-gg3'i,

=-"{&ua *fi=, 3'31-j;-H,a5r*U== 5d'=h-s+ il32 *' E

fr $; * #*E q.g:g H"i5.E E. $aP5

=

E, E [= =

$

;=' 3..E,il'=: *,;E3..$;E.E'" H"=hf,H,= 3n3a.

-B G = =

B 3"4, E F', A 203 E a 3 H'S:P'

3;= xtEgE; n*a **eg+ *'* *te B-S, g I'I p'

= ED s e^ 5" S 5'E .E,= "q H d'3-=E; E

=; i i S 5 S + e e, d. 5' e, 3'3i =" =

*d

=:

E3$e;,AqE il:A; HTa.T,E-E+ q''$.B.

tf H 5 S c iE: g ="

;, ; n*,E^E'H' E" t E A-"940r eus5r2'i 1.3; <;"*.F,d E'=s

=="25,Hi(:IiE3: F=,Htri'.=: #i.E. s;$3s"4; s3';;B='qi ,shil*."i3f;= g; n?^6 E' E =" ; * + g,.4, A: :, g 3

-i'"H, H' i B # 5: *lY- 3 ;.. g y ;' q g:.'= il q', B g *" i g "+

= "3'

3, q.

tii';'=; ;E: = ilq, E: B"a*2

d't s^= $

E-d'e=p="qft;" ii' =i+9, { $.1, ;:3ge\g:he="E-gB,."Fi H== EE.=t" d ='3 r3:'u?F Z= ? F* 5P"3t5 "d- ) g' 5'

oe9l4do\J

=.-!rDoPo

==L' 5'

I

9oee

a),opo';JDIrL.o@ED

-3

e

N

Page 13: Visual politics2014

f1g, *, flE' ralt =

g$*;gtiHg;+,a, +s s'

E.$* H 5: J g"s g,i * i 3 H $,8 "i

*s*s;E*ni,sH gFE:a*rfH;'E;s *a;$- *

$$: Er ; $gE'€ fl*-gf,rf,Eg.$*5i$€' f, F

a.fi €'5' g,$, i $.n r;:E $q E a,s.*+;,* g.f,d,*E *$Ht* H'=,E g

"3 il ="

*' g" g'"'E. # H' 3' g $ a- * a, s. g" F frs" g'g ;: g"ga'F='eis.e,=$,'4 g,$$.g:

5=5, E;.f *5x fl

=,

pg,.8,6,g; }9.5, sl Ff,$=-$Bq,+"rd E+r *

='r' =u;:;?Ea 3.3.8.it s*,5"9]=$i, E* a'

[ + g: + rg $'g =.

6'. g pg"+i.fl fr"g^*'p *++

N(,(,!,

c9{Je5e(e)DeI

=),t3't#

f-'i:)

SN=(r€@-

!-rDo-P.o

@\€==J':),=

l'r,A

e)

-9DJaY

:) 9. F 8jD =" F :l :;r.ie =- 41 ="3&"$a

ir=6.P' =-s D-s

J _i"^*5,$_{Z g = * i=

=^#

r x4fr,$gi

=,.t.1'3' g.3.F $nus.$ . $tCD,"

^ o-

=""3 ='€*e E ilE E r s s'u $ R'S x u \ x d tu.€

$= "3,.Hr'g g='E fi =

H =', F H.s'$."3.3 $$ E',EEs ."'a e"E.S3lq; g" ;S: F^S,S*$#s. Hg,{' {r E- + # $,.$, d. r* J" ra P* #- D €-d p tr"r'r 5 ge"E is B'.Et F: S"*E'$S .il3f--< f-- J I i-reD De iN e^s ;EH:Ti'i,3-"8 ?G q.S^"_E'ilH^qS.g q, 1:(, =' -' "9- :re 5 J ;i tD6 {i fr; gX,ilE,H=='qH efi'E: =B"i,uFH:.;-*9--.:--->O= r 4 E'"3=p-5'=-! -r S; $$-S'*-*,ERQ^E

=:=$* $-9,E, I$a: 3'+ Y'is'*.5s:;$ x'q;"t i"r'"q-qE=.uF: $SS:;pgl i8.**, A*F S=,H.A"iB;v!)u f E,*a.Sqs,S..-d.p:Be.= e.*:+,+FigF'H S,$'$-<BB.i-$H'9"e E

=r, 5$3"9.=$fil k:8,]$.i.i$*i3,;"=E;

F: F'5=ag**?i S'9,S"i.!-H; ** $=; +A; f *E r il,-ur= e e s-d 5 s-X-S = F- S'

Page 14: Visual politics2014

..- i. -. --...--,. ...- . -..---^

,-,:.5-,.--,-,-- .- -.-r..-:-l*:*-'-*-.*-._-.--.-,--.;*:-€*+.+*-@. re-.BArsP

e' g"Bs s'$: $ E;.i: ; .i; ; "i:;.8.9;'5RH,g.A ge-a e-"a f*.dl

=:

E =

;, *. # E q.

=l";16J"g=4"qF rerere)0." " 5. Id"EE=== l+D.-:-E'ez. F =,

E ?. : ='. fl ; +'=[ + E"E-i 3 ; g "e -F g g F *,5^= \ E i S 3 H"Q $.3- *= S = =z t z ( A 5a 6 e E z":R-.J.+*5.JEP -=Ju-= : -:*q. { =-sl^Qej-8e5.= {e

a**==u. =" =; +r 5 4 q- = E'5. ! c_ (-L :)& a H', 3, 3r_ *- # 3

=5ni==Ei=eg;6-= = = e( h f,- "= = s. 3,

=, 3 S'A= =. P$ a"F"-a c) lxSaZ D o -^ i d R- J

= *i 3" 3 il" 3N) -='-.j J.F ...:) --) =!-5- 5 a e---3 5 5 = c_ -Fi cr 2e -r s s_

=E 4 q=_ Y.-a eec '*"* j 3,i Bu'l.r3 r 94 d*,i; Q-5""6"8 H,r :H ,=',=^ * 3 n;'E a g H

o\f,E 4"F' f,{-f 3 3'3 '3 ?.=^ 3 !,i E.q1 H i 3Be"H' E'F. "H"q 5; 5 =

6=i 1";*g-* 5r $_>i : ce*-g B"= ; b'= i ,: * k # q q -L o - zn * = 3'

3sE *==: * E,# =: ft"*- "*":"=8..H: =3 +Oa^=P';F-e)G)z; c- nretr"{ F.=. E

=;'q: 'E[R3,E'-H" "ilH- g:

E.3P q.H$F^ s.f, e E,{. +oHFa"gE. B'fs)-.-:p"--t'I ce f F5o= 3 q.< U q E 3 1" q-=

= 3,-1 .-t Bqe"1 := =Eg';

"a5"" $;-#^{""5 .='=*$' #ar-s^c r f, =.* Ei- H^= ;^ =

5 =. ='=

5a: 9,fi"H; Q- E'ZAl {ih E: s5ee -=-': H'a' "= il $-3-5'-* ErE..E*- c=E s-3D i- "-

.{

?, lP*J f a ='"5 Ero-=-dL: =* 61 "g: -,3.e-=H,=df iq'd*.Efi=i3qA =i *fiF ii * +a-# 3 i 3"J^pnb B 5 41 er-- :; cj e9n- ] ; "E .nD --l - qs Ei-- -aD -->

A s'E'g.*S'H-5'g-; i:E.f'5 [,.: A' ,i.---_ ,!BJS?"2 Ld-3E'5^h*v f ;4, S'F$3"= i'='dE r{ "E E E'F$'H =.

-r - >,.'r-5 5 5'=* 5 = 7'4 i q *ce-6 Ei

"F H H,q r :

='5,"3,E,e g-=- S 8...= :"5*H, *"d=9,--.lC:J=e +.5 zE,

= S 8,4.=

= f ="il; i,-S B'ft# H'*H'

E"*'*: 3,il=i. 36'3"f H, ?{"5 -""1 E?"iu+r"i3'"-4,q ? d z -"-E = Ht5" q

= E. 3: b*Et i =*=.N)

=L-ie=- FA Fq,:f,]5 P.*=' ee=J'11a ?eJE Hld,++5q :g; :3i

=: 5,5. g.i.tE.g

=:.$,

* 3 sr-r9"H.{=.-4sq fi='-q-=.f g#= 5: e.$$*H: t3lHe;B::

=,5" ZiS=^il s*3"* F,'?'uEi P-u: s

5. f; t a..*."a g. g, f = i i

=' E ?. 5:ri-*,

=*- * il"E;

5."P5;3F'-52-u :"r,-*3S aF= iq'Hz" -qE*E" E;E,E,i3"FEE" 5iAi=5 -.ro.h .i-r p*. E.* ;,B'B,Fr4-E'i{ iB.Egli 1*; H, '?*HE,il

3.-=.$,E#H1zgit aSE,5.# n4* 3dts= 'F, 3,

Page 15: Visual politics2014

aU- N Fc=(P S 3 i(E Ef s:* 3'H g'- = br'{

=s ." R a-s ( u= H, eEe ? E .. r .)

u-BS-J:")=-i-='e 5r 8E^;: =$"8,8

q:)-?^{ "-3Ri.?,5 : J-iSE'itE? g4<Fr*FR 5*:..-$'E^$.F;H

**-"*tE:38..8- ;$:$ B: s+*.q; $g, E' q=5$'='*,c= = ts -21[

H:S,.B $s-$-il;d"E-ge :=-g-H'kE' :s'? E s 5;z 5 S 6 p ;'= a -.-4 el E

l*f;.J 5*S= G *^6 ee +. = r s c4- er

8."$'* FFF-E E^E,a =^,q'f A *=.( \ :) & F ^r ;tC Eu q;,= $ E !-*:Bu- R-S,S-H 3-E"g- i,3:g,ir ; E<.'t c. -5j*-X - b

=- \ --) I =Ese- :.-5.$S A,-q 5"="iA + "*-5i's' RF$ls 3.-3" 53; 38, .*',Er

6 E S B =-s'Q^ r E 5 =o-,!

&" ile:De -.55# j b- 13-{E z ==-

sDcq- jR Q) r ci; ;s f, K ; * e) P 5DF-*=r --s$*$* *g; 5;Eq A g:

F h u s 3.E S: 3n c E,S *= = i5E- Ss-$'H', H^. . SaA= q ne

.$,-*'s 3^.8--:.8- a, *F=il #'SH-*. SJBe, d, 3q -d jRs--s s{Ee E' 5,il+g 5;-ss3. $eetaS-B 2 ,.5"ffi f, re n

A=Da=p-)JrJ2-"^r-Frls^3; i, '-)-5 e

==t a}-+n =

*ed r\_L = u N+i7D-rq"c95

=" s:- ;\, o ct

= P'5: #'3 %s u ='!;, q-Sq:rEF'JJaaii^-

fjj*.r."1ceer).g_':l

5,- 3' d" S' S' F{.;* * t, 3' 'uia-a € 5 =e d= ? 9"D"9- oI i 9- D'.ea?O Z - 7p ?rr h.E( _jE-Y--,J-5iau 5 7a- er i" il1.r>ee7-

Nl ; t-D'Ftr3 t' e)'.< r &i 5' Ei :n ?.i-i SprDl, d! 5, Srv !'9:t = o E

=otsE?a-: ec:. "- Z ) ")fo.E. Jr.f * 3,F\Ab-L--;9)cFq::t

" 9.:,.<: a6 3.or[E' cra 5'J =p \t'a:lr"a3 Y,i pD:* €rDJi9(ta

rr'--.o5 e'"fi" :i =eeE='JO

<J;;9--ol::.D>eo ;

^ (}

"2eC-,i-a+q-o"a(r\fD=?"5 €5 n <-) 0=<

ee <rT7(6F?Si* ee J rd'rsi^

":qel) - sD r

-r;,= =" S *"=,' E: S E_:43 *

3x+=,' =.a=..tH: ='$'3^5$t.i=,

3 sRs,xr.g.F'=5,=; 5*'TB; **H._i-Ex3_; g, HSHB_'3fr1=Ei_E;a_:."5' 3: X; =sHf,*^$ st a'? R F T'3 H 1- E 5 E '. S *E*' ;5;qi*;e aEr sF$.?il s $;ils-$;^eI3,=*q.3HE gE'=,8,;"Et 5; 5; $g*.=;Hi.E:a:g:=uB

gH"a'Fs'EF e, $

ila,*g=;*a * x = $**$$a' *;; $s s$-

a=f=gil=Hfl *'H: pr' slf iilssE'.-E=,5,8 ?; ={=; E 3 E-5"F; *- B

="frH=; *' =...Hh H+*'=' s$= t3' $'ftB

qHsfi:r "E.hH il.$nE*$i 3.fr" tHs B;

Hgag'U'$B; E=E'Es' *i, qt $$-$ *

3[l

IsOlq3)9+ 5l) o"

=rc'(eEq. El<5',e%-

=" .i

1)\ b^cFnro;^)p f5^ oD_'lN)Jb{lel

N)E:+ s-(r.i-

-auaUOl-" il

-<

oo_oft?no3\NJoN)\OA\NO\

Page 16: Visual politics2014

a'e3

of

9-o3.jIL0s"

c

to4_

l

dDD9i$c

=D}o

Ea

g,E: 3-E"5?: $H '=-;-*' rq-20='iP'-' gD

E s^ ; ;'3 g p s="i'i r =

$ 3.= 3 *l"i' il 8 io-,s ("e.E-P 5 5I;0il 5 zl$od * = j fio_I o\

* a:" $,s E"h *.8,;E.fi -5

r'$E'E $ fr: q^=,;

H _E-.3, e g"<'g"H

= {,=: E' H E

='"* E;

=, u ? d I.;\r= == = o, 3 e) 9D = C

= D i-o - : --J

- * i ;]e; * .t E'r^ & 5 = 2 g, Z. = F" x, 9e*E 5 b f,

=

H 5" S: 3 A" Z # tr + = 3o s' ! ti e"; = E,2'-5 sr.

-H Hi s =,$9,$,g,*=$;

E'*l$ g'33.E; =,"q."$E'F'F E:-3.F3€'E#,s Ea3= qA::iB2: 9 s 3==e= c- P =-4[X ) = J = : Z (, 2"'

i,c..$ tiH"$ E'g ;,* g.i g u ; *; #is f,-'d r'r-6 -* "= H 5 + = +="3" H'q 3 S E'3-8,$ S'S.$: S, -=^==*,i"5Ai i;=,. I8,3'+iEi Jt(e xo$ J S * E"5r$ B

= aao Lo-o = = -T-s-F "a

*sq^ =1.g"*eZ:r5"

*l: Fa.=;€i:*su :j,e"ffX*'Eg'H" E.E": 1fr;.4'd:q s = 5.8,2 s I il I 3 F3 U ** S S d

oN=-0tnai.beOa"l( EA-sL'4b

{.! p,-ff q.9r.-\ 5 J z2 3 F-* 9!rL< 9r - €-o>t'N-<Jp:l * U Fs: J s $ 3--=r o a

-+ED:)Dg;irr))9or-:fiv

i,i>rr *>

5ZXN)tl-x

odvDdqDoi O-

-;5OiO ." qo

'!."=

6rc)ii5 5Plle(J r uexr J c9-s9)9

:Jo a)etu*e-ba-Ix=' 5tcbr=aag:o?- o" -rqqf-t{ J5-OJPDFr

;'5 E'E$'3 *53B3Sq-f =^.8-Fo rl el E ? pe i $ d ; 5-.3*f, ei + 5 5?e? -r H

=-i *.e*td -

=r-?aq'1"5 c il i il"=

E'*-i ? E,.,1 E q-? = =

4'-1 i'= P s"3*'-2i g.'$ i*F FFk E n i H Es i 6, s. q: r $'.J" # $ q g; e * t S E S H s'Ss 3 E -; 3 3 A H. *. :: g' *, 3'* I F il q 3 r n S' + l-"3" d s5, E,. F .E' =" I g "$. fi g' e B H #

= = e e a F F- E E

-s F. 5"

2, *,. A,'*, s, 5 *'$ 5 t 3. ; A E. 5 ; + f i 3- "' s B^ 5 g .E;D":! " FS su-t 3 !, I e 5:i.P d'3 h 3'* 5- 5 X":: $

H-"4,;. $ *i'ic, #i=.8""3,; .z"Z tr q: 3'q- $,F$*$: $;B-H

='d,* =,'p'g, I E'*uE;"3.'E'='3:

="a.="#*

$.$$'Fi.*,=g,i $

=r="F; H *; = H:

= = p,=t-=;"5,.E: il"s, +RH S_R-"q3fr'€$E^r=

=; uilF=.a=H: 6<.i H$$5.s,f3 ? *^=sRE, 57 $,9i,*sisi",a $,S5-,

= i 1 4' =r Z z z' .) , c =e

.,. =r

fl 5, T { B5:

''=*;'Ha=: u,i=g, ilfl*n,**i' s: $$s*, .E:''^F5a,Y.33 i.;,={sssE'="q+ g.*: $,SlH' iiDEJ ., " -'Eo 6 5 ,. 3"I 3 {[ =" ==, T ._a *

c.E. ft.3="* =-fh*38,5i*BB s'E. .3fr.s'

$

Page 17: Visual politics2014

3' =0.3_

r c =e

pr Z. ;;. S;sE; = ?E $e3 g

==*q pro"lere:nKr 3'=.5-E F'c2= Ef ed J .r' e4D (' e) I S-'

E.E,*+ si.$.$; aIui: . a#x3."1,=a=: I' e,5fi5r4 -:.rr.\E5*"f +"=.$: H'B=,!3I =*: e"g' * $ $ 5 s. s..

g *- 3 =, E 6. ; f E^: H: d' t,

*;E"$il $,SS; .$.ht$e..*'e grEelj$; H, E'e) -? s*< q-+ *"=..d s E.-$"$ $ ;- $- S E *"* $i.=, =:=""5 H q( d En.3- \ h i5 5 P S?f.=:'=- ";$3"8S;E$'e i 'd3'A ='5i ?z : c) F s s-F (as

=-S H 3 S-; A d

=1 4 L

= s.a"J s-E E-E-s"R s S 3; =,.H E, *e-S q

t3i.x s: $t*s$*.$-*g*, f,g =.*r

B# 5 F*-3- ; S *'R:\;"8-$ E" 3 e) E E rd:r =S 5*r"H H'* s-r-ii ='-*.S " 3 ".1- j fu3l j a"jtr * z p * i'S = $'Eit5 1n 5 sr- cr z7 Y

H,?:"=- ,tr-S..S E,.( =-

p*$ 5i4,.-rd' E*8 T E.* ? =

E *- =:n {-'s q. 5 * 5 5 k e aD Z d4f"If = o+*;SS.:":'S-S

=Fr*=r =..S:z,= +.*I ,.;dS dnq S_e*$,

="p"H % EoS a=$ 5 €f d3;3.i 8a-Hd'{ j '='3 q- q-= f,ei 5 r(- s"{: el F.$,S 3E i j}-3 5,(*2,2 * 3- 3\S 3 3 E *5\ ee c3 r-c f, z sD-

NNJPuuf'HH<D-

(,I

-9€ @< {

+;+Po;YYNra-

ooGS!33Eont'JJgD==66.1-rDon<a{

oosw6v9!.iN)OOC UOo.::Aooo

o\\3\\n-lOO;T(nbn;,il{

lt

5-5-Cf':'69qDL&4b-fL f[_

-oe)6o5- j

SDrl?jEo

3 d 5 i"Hrf 'U: 3 6:' 5 r)Re) t'nu3*s 4E q Z3 =^ q ? qL

" $B't, $A-F--*^il F 3 A i'H .'i g i F r * = e"- .8.$'i-'E-

=ft3 =;, x"i * a aE:g +e; +'a

u: i$;:E,H'E"H=";'4ri'5.Se"i,**l

= 3:

= ?8.

3' H. E."+: 3 3 il a, ;,E; H, fl $ s.= i 3. * ili: ='8"5,g"1

#"$ a'*'{ Bus *r*:. *e.;Ii-64'F*3-"f; 3 i.3'F ': So=' q]E ei_"il6ru5J2''= +"='fih U,iE "#P'3

aVft$H'+i: j.fi.3;Sq -E; aB=fr'.sa.{D- : n "4* y r: ED J Z, * ^ S- 6 5, i + iilH"il 3'flre='.s:."s1*, i*,' ='

s"BrC e"SaJ 5ol

il. Ii *: 5 "$;.=' #*.$ 's;

*, q i' $ g, i' i, * *, s;3: 3^. 3' A E-'?,

= ( H A * p. ":3 Bl"=_ E' [, g.

$.

3: 5;."8,*,ai B i =o€'5 i, B,*'"=: 5..g,u' $

N"ANNulD(,(n -r- =. Ub..oF'^il-

-vo-{ NH d N

o.9 ] q O 10.F 6\ ee r' -N6Dt[/-1t^-'b<fu:ipE^rsDN r-h"< CT@rPpl-- : 1- :-O s- S[-o or-jFnYD:?"6iO9D,-.je-9hpe^, P A -J*dYtu,(6Na^f.-q6?*nfu--;o 9D- u X ;f r' ._ ,J ':'?U(

N)b-.t"-i (-r(l-

o,L:--9[;-NdY+[] .,1" P, cu-oe

--r:;ao-Z a =u5 ,i5a

9ar-C.]oNJc9c J ia, 9D) 9c?r.P- 6t:c@2:f[o u :,ae4^id,, i,- il E'

s[-r q oUL-s*oH'.,-ll r5=-5F < & 9^

Page 18: Visual politics2014

Sp {e-)' Ea

rD=MJ5EJ]19-90 9.e)jZo-.) l-r :!;5039_ 2.e)3-9eiJ!2Lb

;s=.aIdol

5,JF9,aeE*ca!od_Jrae'

e e)o f 5n De-5'E c q 5" slaa 5 3 E3DL- d" ? d" 3-^- 3- r ee- H'=" =

E rL =

*a.a tq=, *;^il, il,r a ilu *a,; =.a' =

$-*" =;

*.8'E i E* =

* -S'E: >-= 5 =

A" 5 i * r5"3=

5 p f I r -- =..) p) ea) z, i" E =

F =i-

b .=."F_

E6 3,.="e"E: "El-g: 5i*E:' aas&-.i t"B'El :"

="i E- g il, Z'8, Sj 5, i{ I * E g F" E: S-il F: jN, ="'96'"= i""3s=3#,5" 5b=1I-Q"-*h-E ?5 *.= -1,8;..d,.;^B$E+* =J3, 1=r *1 ='p.a e

IH. ir*"q.; $,L*HB "f;$ =^9.

ft8"=: Ed="*^j,q-=t =H;"!"F*g$t'=

-,'i, =S

-. lg ;e_d"e.Di.--^*F'St-# 3E= qF== ih ;$-*' 2fA=.=f;ilE" E,g'i? s*i i 8qHg

=t'.a *=.ie,.* s. t+*E' +[s

{ > 5 = -.="= *6-"5- X 5'-E;E ;; dR q qBo=,. pil g< j s Ee{_ A =

f;g i q- B;dr r:,=5=alS"5, B==-+ ,gF^ =Y2

= g;t! 3 3 E o, r e r -/, "-^ E- u b q :

E*H.E je*su. 3+UF' =..'*SA-F.'.4, i.*e. = g F_H e^ *, a. ?F;-. E

3'*Efi *"A-"A: q-*8"=.?"i$ ?1 fi gg $ *"H".*4.3-f $ a's, ;i,. ** 3'=^4€;-u*i* t.soF-E-

;,E:a.g' ='*,fi: =$aa.i

*"* = ='c'q *.$;5: i'."11C-f,jJrr5" = Bo*3f i-LH'*;4i,-'r S-A: $l E-

: A.E =

5-f; #;-p^E E S z":$.q;g A$, H'$.* fi. q:pH;;;;+=,Eq'5.; = 6ff*;*.+3- 5$q;

t*"1 35'= :, A 3..8 fr ;*H"='Fz:x: +-R+i5 gF 3

= f H'E "3 \ E'-=."=;5-e =*E e e cu

EB,=s4H="*ilj*; "="="q"*;.5; f, F*H' . =9,i-e *E B 3o -"^5 5

E' =;.a.

; i ="

-z-E i e, q" -5. +"i. 3 3

^*' I + ='

g' 5. +c- 5r*P- -'" i . e N) Eu 6- -r yi I* 3u*1 *-E R

= i SoT=;3-#ed,x';o=€ t z'f ;=; EE=, "8-*"=,i$58'F'q-+IfF-=" {'=\-5,-*.5 sh..P s=,p E'p-i boi q.4 aetd E'=i- 5 8 *"5-'#'; =' -u = = s,dY-- d'ErG,i-85'=i-'* h.,32 ilB = s

E* h; E- ctpe.il=€-^->5+E=- aq=-.i; =

E3.fu ==:SnEF.oqg*,"?,59* E:3*^-ilq-a e='=" Y

B: F+i* e P3',3 -:58 i. ffH=s "R.q; :,-!'\:L= 3'; 5o*2 d -t E- *[.?

Page 19: Visual politics2014

gl B' ax:$i#;Es'q++"xHE: * E#*: a $;-,o^-z r r EoE f r,o'S o" 5-S.i.S g.E,! fi^= =i*f;.U Eg. P * il f t + 5

= = e. E'

=. g 3 fi. d, H" i s 9"8-H; ;

F' 5 i"fl ;. E $' 3 5 I 3,.3 * +:r ;. a =:*'

s' e,€ f, =e i ;. "$ 3. + i' B,

= g" ;

= s E:'=; E" g' 5 $ $^ i 5' *

2 g'g $,$.5i53F#.#:fr"il5,.g8 =- H'5 i'c.

='e "n=

= 5 $ s 5 x*"s g ; 5 I p i $ + g:A' $ $# 5^fi {-3ffY" sia'5+3"EPg"qHF+g=: $8.H q

E"gg =;$^.ie*F-d5j? R=: = e-E_E 36 *= 2

$,8.8 "E'*i*g5^g'isl s="f,$g=.s- g: $3 x,

=,ii 355H=7't+E'*3.T9;; 5ra? r*

H.'i*'3 * 5''E =P' 3 Eil.'F'E. a=.Ea=:**,$'c, .$'p' r^5, $= *J$ g$:j3 FHi A;3=l *H,E:s=<.s*flE. ff-,=^sa_$ * -= o -uJ ;

=^:,,3,9- 3 P* ?r 3'b'-? =.

5a-C 5^ie= + d r - 6 Bosir"#*fl*g'P'8.5 3 5-'

E 3 * "q, i,a $c"si 5. E' E +E, *.E *e # B,

=:

ON!-uoult uo"--si

4N5- -If N-i. r -Aqn\ d,

5"a esF\<

=(i s"Srd s^-au'n

-sf:-DO;

3hELOJN:+l-uf5tn \ >li;f40:OJ

€ge6e)N)l^iLn 6- j:voS"

=Dlqr-!D_!oID F'

!1. 5)OeilJudAilFeem5(!:NPSoiNr ="!.o e

6:O (ndorl4OJ?oDAE

9-FF-c9{=o-Dfe):)eeec9ee'4 i- 9D " 5n -o-(-bSpl-p9"a,rl I -a- \ :1-

=<hL) ="*=;-E 2icb r fl ry9e=;--a';srJ--)EUp)-e)Jeec;9)h.ae Sa f

= ct- ce2 {a*ts E E I

[^-2eLJu- sa I =^

E:- geo <,.K ='€

q Lifiti^=,]5'a, p) -+l]- F I ;.a=@)6- { e-la 2- "J1 9e9*D f, I e:FnS"rtle)

Fe)3. l3*i "r" r.) J --J;=^sr-'4e/"4 LaL -1\ -): a

={r sl dJ Lr'9) f -9::.LE+rC)aLif-9 e) I

=2<ndt)

)G:a"a" i Sr- *Je &-r5F5:3LS"eee='r-r&^9-n = =

a,t1-r 5"-')hefi_- =. E"il-;=:c)--Js{"922-lrH1=q)-Jp"-)DYPe .3 ---r asr' S Fe?C(*-ed,

5lc)fcrl-Jb19c

tcrl-)reeJ&rSL3Jqrt9_c)9qJda/l-.)E9)tseco

3,5 P.3-= AS=eec.'--JeeE9

*-e'='fr E-H"4 r = B B B

: s, i.H ;'s $ =, F fi 3 e 33" = = s #;

=^"e S i t i :

=d'q s ? EoE,*8" i:'tr5e.5^3'z,d^ HiE[=3, H',S i, d +"= I. 3 + s Q 15 q 5*$i.H;:8"E" q. il q

B R t I='fffi=E*16 6 t=s3* 3J ^= r SsU a @ b cr-\< o

e;=="g*;.i5i * *qIE5 5 *-5r*-{ F*;- ",

as.g,*'q,'* *H $ $$Hid: g'=,8'il"95fi i 3€igJar-9 F gr-':

=i f,.Filp*H=: E g$EH

$F.5ErE'E,A.E3"E hlEdI-- _et j)e -" -. r; ._rD clD" (, O :r + CJ-d) 9 C- si -n Z e" Sr N G' rD !1 rD

€Nl!

€L!N)o cr->o>o=.;2A{D0@oogdi= o(-f.< _-]rDf;rD.d ,n-oqt2-=>--Ln=VrDGo:oo<o ll.-om:{;c.-oo€m$x'a o

6?6rD

rDr)rDo_

=--l@

Page 20: Visual politics2014

Si; 3"5,G"sx le e1) s E-s

=;=fi H.='F";i'=; $*8; '$,3'Ef"=i'fi$9--+Ef =

q'

l a^8, I E"l; 8 E'+"x $ i'$'5. =.p

c"$"i 5 q"g^E E."e fi g 33 E E- f e)"; 5 J

? I == $, e- 65- E e- ^:$ E^ E F "E"* + ,'. l g i

= q *6 $ *'

A. g *,E' = EH'! * c3, =

s + E.g *Ht i; g ; f.=^.e ;.EI E-"9:' f,ft;,p$I1'$'5q # b-ie.*s3;*'!s"e*sr E'

E" F' u,

= $ =.

$ 5^.8 $ ; .g * *,.+ Sr$. #,.a ; ; F H r i t is B = s * +_g fr E"<

= Sfi"B,d B"I_3;A = -.ao^ = ;: N, # F

3D S_ 9tr "j

u $: 5 $'.* H^d 3,E : H H A; q i'5 3, 3"g"q 4.4 ei ;.$i 5, g

3H,=,B F.s; 33.E*H$g.Hfrfl.q,fifrE"*s' r$;Hi 3,e=*o6 E_-Ei-r-q_i j-+."*

=,"H e; ig ),:"Fg; tr"E,Us H,

$;e' a*g"5.3;aH#"$,e' $+3fl8,.5: g,asl'!'x F

== H 3"3;=iFg#"=5'#( r; ;fl"3-3: F-E';o H

= * q $;; g$'-;'t$,3qS""8-8" E-,d,553"=ri; H'

==i ilrs=q*: i&i cv3 f = U*; g.$3^H"3'il"9

*g+'*=,"+*a,=.-fr"f.t .g's eg"s .;.5=:

;,$"*

= g a"?"'*rHI;. 5 3 s s "E S3lrya gE.E

= E H'5 5 E':S; - = & ., =' -* E -H 5 =

g, B d F g^ { *. 5u ra * e

3 g"*^.3 fir =

3-- * i: $-a 5,^** $ H'H'q 3 F^'E'q 4-H r H'+ ,.=

# 3, 9 p" & =

f *l :-= F j r y-fi.d B,il5 Hu i ; :,8.E ^i

S,j.;; #AgI,*FE. aq c' s^+a$$ilfli'+.=flff'fl=:, =,FI i'B 3 5a ; d,E.E $ HE 6;.Se='= 1E'f.=

=.;,+n,="q E

=

q =

#;^E flc"E: ; =.2

$'*,s #^E i3 * 5- E 3; ; il ; il."4 =""3

i ; i =,'F *'= fi, i, 3 * 3"6 +N = S.-3 &--, ?: G

=' & {

=.J # H *"Hti q H"=,.= N H H gs f, E, q = a s. a, ; q-

=; E q F,

=:.? "q E 5, E i E- * F

-ili * fq f, Ja:r I d.: g": e, =":=

q H ?D t u[ c- e z fi, i. - s rr (5 Ho P i 3 a, t E =

-- ts. + ua G 6, *, p N. F h S" - q = "6' !,-rE 315'r=3s,5.3e A f *: =F,q:

+35i#8,=:yilJ#e=;!3h*-,s;33.,=

+5.s {- = =;$'=*, =,=*eilH*,=:=

g 3 $ i e*=,*;a'.;1= j Ej 3*Jar

["qa+q =i*.i *t: $l

='Hrg: E's."#E=?.fi 8

i.*.qi s,* E,til"*, x, #$H..E$i*i=,.a,*-=; tt' E' il3,g I e;q. iJ A=

= rie;' +=.$$= E,#i:8"= gl :,

Page 21: Visual politics2014

H'5,5933 3"2:==3H*ts "S'rD=5)s bo{ =.==eeSJf,f,e=*-aP

H u: u: =

H.= ( 3 *r E,3,Ei'51 = *.H,E,"q $= ;c ='

rsr_ 3DAF. jrgt'"*? i^_ _=f-s5=-3-a \7 ?r-j ?Hrs #B A B'=.FH a=: $ B'="='"E"=E-! g; *$"*, 3

=."i F.g.?1-"= a'E g sFE^E s E:E'"8 $ 5'FB;i r,- 5=

Z P :; b- A e H 3 =, a F" =-: =.

5 "E 5'= =;_=

q P H,. j* ['H =:9.i fro-*."3 E "F

$ E 5 * 5 5 $iqi * +E' e F- $ * q E.rt T, * i g i

=

3 A' =

q'E F +r a B + = =

ff #, A" = q d" B. r. i s.-o r

q * ="i

*,8: =

H""* H, j D F €"d' Q ;"'= fl q 5-"E g

g.B; ;=.#'#: H,.$"3 ii'=+=.g,g.xr$,H'+,=g q

5: :Eq*=.8,#i'8if;5-A'Hs 3ti5-ils. p *E*&-*F5;:d'*St,=,EEH*=J, 3^= -d5r' = E;-EJS-f il.frt$€d-3 s5;- == 3"8'3 ua a

e - e-d ; s,g+ s =.H"1 $ ;' g;= i;E'B U $

+ $ i'*"= i * d 5 E H.-#' 5"9 fi' H:'"E H,"= "H' F. E.-l-ra j ?*5'='e-H FS S E =c

5*z I H Y el

5.='-tB=HE,a, I;-*"J$i"5: eEIH= 3sa=.''.':9 e i = E 6-H N j'= d^:rsiE_fl. ilH il =

3= i-=*3rfr =,8..8 =,* s_.3 5 B B E

Qo N)

!le

rqOANPoEE8u3.^b51f-b=.(,=Y

\:)_\D:a3_;]Jgd

Joot';JrE>sfiZt-

6i 6"--o3fc):o Dp-=t5o L=e

rr EoioPuf

Ggrod6t:

rI-o.-Je;r1 e9<DuOC

-s a)Dee*5,N)C(, e)

'9

PJe<,fN) ;I(, l?F\:J'k-oaoPo

-\2:so

I

=-)pD'

Srsr's

t:lD

J

cgQ)

.Q5

uc'

# =

5"E B i 3. s'fi- F = t+s 6oc.E"3 t-g P'# g .-*..Ji -_ Eou'-d2 2

=._3 )*?,-- PB,F:E

g H'= #'7 E^="3;='H='t, aa?g?.E C i;,d 2"=-q A^A-9,? iiEiS"? fr 4a*9 = 5 3 -i 5'H 4, Pr = 3 B 3 r? J C-f, /) L d rh rc\ -D S ei * 3 - g d*'e=^; g"q E 3; = =:"

SsErxfl ="8"9

HE n'g"d H,*.8 aa=(=3=

j 3. E q' S, = =-_$ z = 1 E g J1+B-l F 3-4.q^q-?,"f P"3.d, {3P 3

tn Eff:-doz:- n=i"I'sa alai 3Ln en FF"r #d4u*f 3-5k- 71X :s E- a'.r^ F il. 3 ;^ i" ? E ? 3 <E BP"5,?..+ i-u'l sS.Ld !' f![ := =

Et-5', j. E, * 3t =,

q- s i- a a 3 a

=-_ **,8=E:q<_dB* s6J j_

"Zt"-=_e; ji6-^ i.=-15' =?-?- €re_? s" = 1 za = p -J "S S* ?" t g F n

E = =

F; E fl,fl"q*-3 ?; + sNF 3P 5:E-=

= e 5 3"8 5

= i Ha= t

e)" Ltr C rlu Z e) zi =

-f e) Sl- S [ ?- NjB,E?B,x+g=F*ui =;? I 5 H

=5=*-Eu5A1LF3 = j d'-E"=iS22 HdEErr E"Y

Page 22: Visual politics2014

39,=c.'t g*{ E S 3;

o ="=

E,"il E'- 3 a ="

.=En43t-.t;;=*3O B- f;. *""s e" 5' Eo H

"Jls E -)- d- o, C) 5eccD" -?- F e) -.1- c-*e C dg'a#E= g fe

=:f--".ac)=DE,-"an_4_eeb)fz

= r2 Pr;j g r'- 3

= S l + =^1" -3 i: qa-; d -'6 t' 6O & F e Jr^- ts q

O 19 C 'rrrc) d- F !"d1*(.Jf,'Z'=*Z='z<..n_a)e)-;Y P 5 -rt) i Z 2

6H'E^e33 E d=

=}l't"tr["<nJH 3 Fr1 El q' +- '5g L ;\-J ir'3- =? gSJ g;3=; +. = E.

--Jrq"f-:->#-i. d_ L 31 9e :_ *"+bt-3-"3 ai"q z g

Sfi"H I J,3 n e' E"5-'= E d- * Et =.

E'sD-r F 3 = c)afi3

= d q" €. Jo?1 t' = sr =- 5' ei-E $,5 *sr.S

=R g-=, S, E" = s"3-e>Zlf,t'l)-

ae9Q)

+N[1-e:o<c)-oc,

SLe.J

=-3"5l' 9e- n'-Eoaoe-J -:)J

Y-

tlo !(<=S)D >,

J(E

F u**3*

SL<P(DJ

ba-r

5rii oF"S=_- fl) >9-.-\N)<=\^ < rU

:;lN =H b.(I !i o !i-O\)il'

Eb-6N>u<(n=u<

rl6rDa@

I

o)I

_;6:)o_o,aO-Ovo

-=a U.dZ'5."=3"3f A:"3H5, I-=r.'^fi H'=.F*31,.E,$,_€ H [ =

q E'F B"=

=li G e= 5:;'*E I *

= 6;$; i $E gE E"

H F *- * s 5 s + i"*.-i'6 ; { =

i E"?' j.

+il S;.E-q: 3: E'= ( Z"= A =

E[ qt;.*;i e F R *i_ 5 o rD :. _1 3 3 F 3 5t 3"-g' il, BaU-q S= q C^r€ i S ts E*5 g *tE'-* =i-"

='d sa -4.

="= ir 3 $ d" H. tr[ 5 ] g

?46 <) =,r'dd_t+ro

&eF-c'JddoU.J"*il, *,H=;?3"*3 dnE=i

=_A'itS3 .g' ?, 3', *, E- H H F g 6 Z =

E #- B= q', =g.E. q$='=,;:

.il4* 3;E,a^;H"=i {.dEd -{'3F=1'"7 b3 5i*4a3 i,RJE^?a B*B*"4;EH,$ EH; rH,qq*^="

^= E' *: g E, E- g =r

E, t 1,^'^=^

=l C, *r"='"9 3' E"E,= fl'f -.q5*F"E:; =q=':'=r=="= s'2=? =-Eb 3?#oe* )- d^F*#5,*.="3 -.

E' 5*,=Ag*.*H; *,$E+;Ea* p-* ='Etq=z'3

B-H-E" q'=; 5= s = z'-E' :'f-z'

ca ccgoeSzrP:)Jelo.{e c).+ln-Ex&troSD- v<rc)K9e :lj eIIGEJ

9-JZb3cce),rse)oJlq

fnIpeSq!.CDc9:,J

=.

J- c)D--)q€^ 9)&r')

=r- J e)

eF)te)=^=.LUJ

J)

-9iq--)--n d,9.K5).eJfr--)9e sru- 'l---l rcr odJ,2)ii+

F)P

49Jor:rD +-" slgerc\

YFN\L ))N)6nCb-

Lng;5:) >J:sC)rGot^_

- Cn Sl)D

begJqan

-)_ ci- -nr-<,@ )-?-=pdl c>

D,L)-Jez+- g --.1

&u_-En uf6-oL ^. r5_-

-9n ; -'.i<!-^- ="-

dPe L_- qtnrclZgeg

Page 23: Visual politics2014

i*: -,.- ;,- - - , .--,----+=.+.u....--*-,*-.--.--." -*----,. -,- , ---- -.--,, .- .-. - --

=E, =i;&f-E=FRl 33i0s2',.23"83$ H'5=q$ E;5*," e

=.a._: F * {.= ;-+?^E H B-

= t ; X

= *.=i = $Iq H'"gH

==

'I.s u F f I # + I q,= B,+E, 6^5, g: S H 3- g e *, fr.;:.H g,ugjsl

=g'fl$I;,q3,

q=:

=:

*s' i' 1$flg;,3, F';'=';: 55: H, is, i"E :., * a,"f

=" = =.

e 5 = =

? $ = I.j s e 3 ; s"="fr; 3.7"9@

= *o3,l= ;: g"H:=-5;;.#= Fg''$: i'i

=^*"= i^= * 3:H"p-a-H :P.E X-5 ( I 6"'3r= ?g +* g il $B +*il= =

3 s H,g:E :'-q' *N - j i "{"6 5 b ; i tsn--i } = d&eE-eEec er 3.fr,Ko* #{ri 6 As

=,q^f*j q.q$: $r *l**^$=ia;:; fr,fl="t $=: =i e.3 H i n 5

="*."i on5'E :i'? ,. *gil*'5:=-H:

= \.-f z Ei

H* 3'E *.a s S,U:"p P'3'a 3 -s E *- ll E.-3 ; H. pp *-3" EEas * ="P=;;"= H:5 ? E 5"5 "P !fiq'.qr" ea-E- F { -3 H :

B"a: B. H ==?i6.*x;i2: s, I,"j; fr;:€'1.q"q: ;^C, i=i il* il il ; **"&*. a q ; 5 f.: "5' 3' H, # ="

*"'+ i" # * ; 3 e'N 3'5 eE aB E * s i z= u"*.5,3

= E"d =

-q SH,Ed3.2 Yi = i-Ar(;.3; 5,{,il*.*: fr"3 ;=aP"=; H=i*;= #="E=

==B =s,nB,-3 1"=$^==B'=; g,A'3.4-€"S" #qE; q'I -a e9ie

=. ce d_ 3 h p = $s8if F s $,=: g 3"5_="*.qt 5.H. l=' e) tcrtf, 4"4 ;: E"i r='p-,5-5 5:E

*. s d = x B H il = B" g i d *i ="S

fiiB H E_ g "3 E' $^

=, g

g ; 5- e = e, b 5" f ; *"rA g' B =

"H, = Z S""=i *o B i 3 .qa-E

il i q.3 H..i*Ee'q +: "t-i ilri"q E'i

=; =;

fi: q"iS *: +il&,*i j b=(,d"=e j-3E=Z #=.q,H,38,-* Eo 6,-ae"$ *E:*,i =.*d L=,H.H'*.d.4 == ts^E

E" E;: E*' S,-?-; * H f $ t F

= Ht i s'_ fr * e. # # i^ q: ; X Er

L e Sr;.,,5 a. 8.5'=.9 =,';-*{E;:=

* ='r =.f 3"i i =-J 3.x

t ; i =' x* u, + u' f;

='

4^ 5. $ q" e: t c $ $ =i F"B' g E'

g 3 E E' H'5 5 r D Zt3o = s e b b j {;+g { fl5s,s'E= [ A3#"ls=*!;-5? .E-,{5dL: gafire3,*: E ;it'3';, i;'=id **g:.=s\"=;.;il:,5rf,r

=qq. o. iF,i3,'B r=' =s$'

Ir=^i,fr.[-$f,x=^j,( v

=,= F S=E;H-L"+.s3j *.;,;#.:-J'Eil"F"].= t' ", a'gd=^85358$, 8-h"g*.H,=: +'=8il $:33" StsE: f,a ==,?S-Glg dd; =i =.'E+'5'3,JNB ;"E.*3 k" -! 5=,E-*=,;4+c, ) P.e-S(3,8-=S"H"

5"

E'E, = ?-; i!,g; r.3fr-:'=Jg a'3i="#;^:6;$; $

Page 24: Visual politics2014

5 di==. SoF^"H*hE" H.{EE' +"5" ;A il S P E'aq,$^ B ==

-, =5*,*E*'**i.= =E,E'bE,=

+:;= =e: t"a"g"e =E"E'HE =={

=^.a ; B == B" q

5ua E

=*5,q-*'g$; 3 5 $'g.6:i3: *E* d-r-z=u E'Eti

6 *:r"i'

=.4' =ii^il i5i HHA+ 3il,+il=r,A.aE ?b -5 "^^ 3:9" *-roe-*i 2^^ 3-E L

E *"?F=' dgi il^*-6ng='; q

e "4,8"$5t 3.;; t=Z =*'A'8, 8,6 E = ='= =qf, Jo3 q-t_4 g*, -E

A" +$FE agg'1-* t,="= F^a ="8

B k =ti;,-= 3o 6-":B Ha_E.E'"=-=: H: i: = f€: q r\ A,=; #:= +El F"='T HEE, H'

"* 3."?q-1 =5'E;

"B* E=,=?i s"q zl* E*5oF Y'3- 5 = ieD j".d frB- i^p: TE d U;.4_$ F=='* 1"?,E-H'# l=-o'-^

J

s, r't - 1 d EE -; q €

J-r'tSr4'qrsi#iE tE-+8'*i" +i1,*. $$c==1;,e.p JE : 3 i3 Off i g e*6 [3 Aig$g n f.t : i E H $E e;; \ E d + ! i i\=:nEr(ror

F':,F -q s E ; = =

e E + E: G i i G fi :3$"Y..j q r, =H =!

[: i1$ :# [: Eil3 c[-il' ;, i *" =fr [ E : r t g i q i [ "T S

P ( -: $E"He=:i'ii'1 n safl:Eq{ro E

-3.Q:;""rE a; € t i TE G a5Hi gi "g

=S'il-=igg{[ i:?{;iB= i= il

igrqa.Hqil;$ .+ Fd5$=d =;5's*i=; #rF;3 =q HA €;iq !u

E: E'+="#qH S q F=3tE-" ed;$FEs-il od il ; ami6 :r= s:

JcPi+ 4 q I E i ifr6] ei *s+ s q T 5 5 fis { qi :'4d""

NJ(nLnI

C1Jt:e)p

3)J

=-)pc'AD

I:)j

J9'

f9aLegq,

Icee

":le R Qu 3-'V i.' el t:r+!"enee S :4 ?:.aAs)ce'Jo<JA"erSE='Cqqei

:-i qr YbJPhav"=.h"2-. (-e ;6ClY

=r-c)rE *3)-\DpN:iiSr'O\e'Yd

= "s" p"J i+^'

-at--q:-J')Q

JDS#Ae "Jf- r"

:=56)- Qe :)4oU'35r(-Y

OLJ :^' ep.€-9-'-.lJX*B'3 E3)saq)Jq

="-,i^ED1*{e(Ea

Page 25: Visual politics2014

g, '8, -Bo E' S" # dB =, d E, S;

c,D e q = r^ 5 s E' =D E, E'

-$; B +, E' p, s ;' s,"$" H' R,E n,'5 R A r * .1 ; =D

* ='fi . I' 4j,E,3; =

aiE == ="385= =="2* i5""a',p=5 <L \ e *

u jx.E"3$E"ag,i 3* a t+$ =;=.='a =

3'i ?* q:

5€t * "$.xg e: H *l H =,=

i ls t =.F*s r5 A,:sr jH u "*q'Bs i 5 -r E, ; E. 5 $ i S q4 5 z !' ' S' S .*{ I . 3' U S'

E"):E,g SS €; Et S 5qs i,S es,S_5 '-ga5,Hs i\-!x"Rs F.€, iq $, :-;S"EA^ E: E5.u' n =50o E.e{8" aE;ss ssl3-d.E-$,f$I#, F='i^fi a

N) O F' JE'E* [ S F-:r q \ ="" S N a$"u-a- 5-". uo [;= :e5 ; 5*l;; s.$;.q,5.s,ils,q[33;ir, Fsl $sEi 1o "€ t=,9 "=,RUi *$- $.98,$"+ f c$; s*,:. d j= =,H"5, "l: *= S gg;,e":r< ili+ .3,i'8. :, ?;3" :J

=g; ;g $35; S" **J'fiH,d =; B'$eE, B,$' ls s= -i*s* i. $'J:' a$I ; frE" S"1 E,*I E.= "e#:,, s 3'E.fi, t FF s. H

=' s8. a"s, ;: * =*= \ 5='q; "n$"i =; e'E: p.s; =: $ 5: ; sg, l I ;j1 q$'s. ;

3* *: $ *,.E. *+5 = iz: .3 a.g, 3B6r?.F#'-='3.=aJ43f,-d.z@

)Jc/l-=ccff

=a/l--ff..)5D9c--/lee-9Jc/tDc-esICP

d c9 =

Se"5 N) -) l) -;s-A :)cr o cf z^-= F r r "E 9 D_b b ) dr -lJ --l o_/l ", Ddl

= - & r :) G a il.-:i c r"= "= E *, il l. p* T 6' s 3--o = S"r; -? --.) -i 9p n e e) =*- S[-Y8.8"6-< 3'= = !, s f$l3 --1 et a -D ") --) --J e = 3. t" s3;: il

"t; !o- 5 5. il

-*,"$ .F ltr's .d $ E"';^ .d; H !',"= 5 e ]erD cft.__ L _

=".= _ h U ;erf J--? 5a;FH,=ata.E$.8,8'F' i

ig^H;;="=.EIgg,? N H'*=;r:-_->=h3'PJPq 6"- (E 1'='-3,:=i- T g

=='58;5,*"X'Fgo?=

E c'I'ee b q F"D.g z:e Tt *o.E,d F.; e"i i = E- $'N sc.;.-J S"+-ra fiE q N

= BGil*S="= psi,?; _ r- 55*; E,-*=r F5E$-"5,- B: S 5,tSis=3qE*i'5: s d 2qr#"k; = c) Ln,_1 b j 5 t N g

E,3".38=,= t*,E'-+; x, \b trrz-.d'd"ESpe2.j =S

q: oe)

El)9i,Id

ePePI

53J'

-ee

9,3

N) -^O\ dq(,E

pCE

eJpl'

3a)9

*Dlp"tsJJD

cJa)qe