Welcome

North Hastings School Group

Accommodation Review CommitteeOrganizational Meeting

May 13, 2008

6:00 p.m. – 8:00 p.m.

North Hastings High School

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Introductions

Administration

• Kathy Soule, Director of Education

• Jan Montgomery, Superintendent of Education (elementary)

• Rob McGall, Superintendent of Education (secondary)

• Dave Rutherford, Superintendent of Facility & Financial Services

• Don Tregenza, Controller, Facility Services

• Kerry Donnell, Communications Officer

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Introductions

ARC support

• Ernie Payette, ARC Facilitator

• Sandy Smith, Project Coordinator

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Introductions

School administration

School Principal Vice-principal

Bancroft Public School Suzanne Copeland Kendra Mihell

Bird’s Creek Public School

Olwen Therrien Lisa McKenna-Sutherland

Coe Hill School Suzanne Copeland Mike Love

Hermon Public School Debbie Speck Mike Daniels

Maynooth Public School Olwen Therrien Lisa McKenna-Sutherland

North Hastings Senior Elementary School Debbie Speck Mike Daniels

North Hastings High School

Nancy Quinn Lynn Andrews

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Introductions

Accommodation Review Committee membership

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Initial protocols

• Attendance and sign-in procedure

• Membership Meeting seating arrangements Contact information

• Visitors – protocol Seating Participation Rules for presentations

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Objectives for this meeting

• First meeting of the North Hastings Accommodation Review Committee (ARC)

• Organizational meeting which provides all members an opportunity to:Develop an understanding of ARC purpose

and functions Review the roles and responsibilities of

ARC membersElect the Chair and Vice-chairAddress initial business of the North

Hastings ARC

www.hpedsb.on.ca

What is an ARC?

• A committee appointed by the school board with the assigned task to prepare a school valuation report and recommendations

• The ARC mandate is to study, report and make recommendations on the accommodation options respecting the group of schools or single school, and will express a preference, if possible

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC role

1. To provide an opportunity for parents, students, educators, school board officials, trustees, business and municipal leaders to assess a school’s ability to provide the best educational opportunities for students while ensuring fiscal responsibility

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC role

2. To provide a means for collecting and distributing information and community feedback on options for accommodating student needs prior to making its recommendations to the Board

3. To objectively and fairly review each school in the ARC and report on the value of each school using the customized School Valuation Framework

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC role

4. To consider appropriate alternatives on such matters as realignment of boundaries, program changes, school organization, facility improvement, and the closure of school(s), where appropriate

5. To submit the School Valuation Report to the Board with recommendations regarding the future of the school(s) being considered

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Authority for ARC formation

• Legal reference: Education Act Section 8(1)26 School Closings Section 171(1)7 Power of Boards to Close

Schools Sections 194-196 Disposal or Purchase of a

School Site Ontario Regulations 444/98 Disposition of

Surplus Real Property Ministry of Education guidelines re: Loading

Capacity

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Authority for ARC formation

• School boards are responsible for establishing and following their own accommodation review policies (Ministry of Education)

• At a minimum, school board accommodation review policies are to reflect the requirements of the Pupil Accommodation Review Guidelines (Ministry of Education)

www.hpedsb.on.ca

What initiates ARC creation?

• The Board may initiate the creation of an Accommodation Review Committee when it receives information that causes it to consider the need to consolidate, close or relocate a school due to changes in curriculum, program demands, student enrolment, community demographics and other factors

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Why an ARC for North Hastings?

• Every school board in Ontario is required to complete a long term accommodation strategy in order to meet the parameters set out in the government’s capital planning tool

• This strategy may identify schools or school groups which may face challenges in providing a suitable and equitable range of learning opportunities for students in a fiscally responsible manner

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Why an ARC for North Hastings?• HPEDSB engaged Watson and Associates

Economists Ltd. to do the following: Prepare detailed 15-year enrolment projections

by school and by grade Identify planning districts for the purpose of

assessing capital planning strategies Recommend an accommodation strategy

consistent with provincial policy initiatives

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Impact of declining enrolment• Funding is provided on a per pupil basis with

additional funding for some rural schools.

• As enrolment declines funding levels drop

• Over time continued cost reductions will reduce service levels and impact on student programs

• Funding for facility maintenance as well as building renovations will decline

• Lower enrolment will mean fewer educational assistants and fewer support staff in schools

• If the same number of facilities is maintained it will be a challenge to keep existing levels of programs and supervision

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Watson findings for North Hastings

School name 2007-08

OTG 2007-08

ADE %

Utilization 2020-21

OTG 2020-21

ADE %

Utilization Coe Hill School (JK-6)

115.0 75 64.9% 115.0 73 63.5%

Hermon PS (JK-6) 159.0 60 37.8% 159.0 59 37.1% North Hastings Senior ES (7-8)

271.0 198 73.0% 271.0 160 59.0%

Bancroft PS (JK-6) 305.0 197 61.6% 305.0 199 65.2% Bird’s Creek PS (JK-6)

181.0 137 75.8% 181.0 146 80.7%

Maynooth PS (JK-6)

135.0 91 67.2% 135.0 104 77.0%

Review Area Totals:

1,166.0 758 65.0% 1,166.0 741 63.6%

North Hastings HS (9-12)

903.0 649 71.9% 903.0 418 46.3%

OTG – On the Ground CapacityADE – Average Daily Enrolment

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Watson findings for North Hastings1. Convert North Hastings HS to Grade 4-12

facility* and redirect Grades 4 to 6 pupils from Hermon PS, Bancroft PS, Bird’s Creek PS and Maynooth PS, as well as Grade 7 and 8 pupils from North Hastings Sr. ES

2. Retaining North Hastings HS as a Grade 9-12 facility would result in the facility utilization falling to 46 percent and would negatively impact the Board’s ability to provide breadth of programs to secondary school students in North Hastings

*Note: HPEDSB does not support a Grade 4 to 12 school

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Watson findings for North Hastings

3. Once North Hastings Sr. ES Grades 7 and 8 have moved, construct a 4-classroom addition and convert North Hastings Sr ES into a JK to 3 primary learning centre, then redirect JK to 3 pupils from Hermon PS, Bancroft PS, Bird’s Creek PS and Maynooth PS

It is important to note that these findings reflect the recommendations of Watson and Associates Economists Ltd. and not the Hastings and Prince Edward District School Board

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Board motion to create North Hastings ARC

“That the HPEDSB approve the creation of an

Accommodation Review Committee for schools

in North Hastings identified in the Watson study

as planning areas PE08 and PE05 as

contained in the Student Enrolment/ Capacity

Committee public session report no. B-1, dated

January 10, 2008.”

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC composition/members

• The appropriate school superintendent (or designate)

• From each affected school: The school principal or designate One teacher One non-teaching staff member Three parents, one of whom will be the school

council chair or designate Municipal and business leaders One intermediate or secondary student from

each school (NHSES, NHHS)

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC composition/members

• Other school board officials and trustees may attend ARC meetings as ex officio members

• The committee will be deemed to be properly constituted whether or not all of the listed members are willing and able to participate, but must include at least one member from the school community and one member from the broader community

• The committee may request that the Board appoint additional members

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC meetings

• ARC will meet as often as required

• ARC will hold at least six public meetings giving due public notice

• At the first meeting of the ARC a chair will be selected

• All meetings of the ARC will be open to the public

• Minutes will be kept and posted on the Board’s Web site (www.hpedsb.on.ca)

• Attendance of all persons at ARC meetings will be recorded

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC tasks

• To work collaboratively and cooperatively through adequate resources and reasonable responses

• Review and assess the current educational situation and future implications if the status quo is maintained

• ARC must complete a school valuation review and report for each school considered

• ARC will consider the questions set out in the School Valuation Framework and Resource Guide and may consider such additional questions as it determines to be relevant

www.hpedsb.on.ca

ARC report

• ARC will prepare a report based on the School Valuation Framework and Resource Guide

• ARC will deliver its report to board administration no sooner than 90 days* and no later than 110 days after the beginning of the ARC’s first public meeting

*Time calculations are based on 7 days per week including statutory holidays, excluding school holidays for Christmas, March Break, and summer vacation.

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Public input

• ARC will provide information on an ongoing basis

• Public meetings are to encourage an open and informed exchange of views

• ARC will have processes in place to receive public input and to respond to questions

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Public input

• Three ways for the public to provide input:1. Through a voting member – public may pose

questions and responses through the voting members on the committee

2. Questions and responses may be emailed or faxed to Sandy Smith, Project Co-ordinator, and brought forward to the committee for consideration (ssmith@hpedsb.on.ca)

3. Presentation to the ARC

www.hpedsb.on.ca

“And now to work!”

• Read and be knowledgeable of: HPEDSB Policy A-3 – Student Enrolment/School

Capacity Appendix A - Min. of Ed. – Public

Accommodation Review Guidelines Appendix B – Min. of Ed. – Administrative

Review of Accommodation Review Process Appendix C – School Valuation Framework Appendix D – Resource Guide including North

Hastings Information Package

www.hpedsb.on.ca

“And now to work!” (cont)

• Review weightings established by the Ministry for the School Valuation Framework and determine if modifications should be made

• Review items listed for the resource package and identify any additional information they would like provided

• Complete School Valuation Framework on the current educational situation for each school

• Project possible implications of continued enrolment decline on schools and student programs

www.hpedsb.on.ca

“And now to work!” (cont)

• Create possible alternatives that focus on school/student needs and recognize limitations

• Review and assess alternatives presented and determine preferred recommendation

• Prepare a report based on the findings of the North Hastings Accommodation Review Committee for submission to Senior Administration

• A review of the school board’s accommodation review process may be sought (refer to Appendix B)

Business portion of tonight’s meeting

www.hpedsb.on.ca

Business of the North Hastings ARC

• Review timelines

• Elect a Chair and Vice-chair

• Membership request

• Review the School Valuation Framework

• Requests for information by ARC

• Public input

• Questions and answers

www.hpedsb.on.ca

School Valuation Framework

• The School Valuation Framework was established by the Ministry of Education to ensure that the same model is used across the province

• In order to identify needs of all students, the ARC shall objectively and fairly review with respect to each school in the ARC and report on the value of each school in a School Valuation Report

• The ARC committee may review the weightings established by the Ministry for each category and determine if any modifications should be made

www.hpedsb.on.ca

• Meeting format: agendas

• Next meeting

Date

Location

Business of the North Hastings ARC

Thank you

for caring about

students and families

in North Hastings

Hastings and Prince Edward District School Board

1 800 267-4350www.hpedsb.on.ca