welcome. welcome – new members murray scott – buropak steve hattersley & john bottreill –...
TRANSCRIPT
Welcome
Welcome – New Members Murray Scott – Buropak Steve Hattersley & John Bottreill – Cognitronics Stephanie Wilson – SK Chase Rob Frome & Fatima Wessom – New Look Nicky Tollafield – Shoe Vouchers Carly Wickenton & Nick Warren – Starbucks Cassandra Cavanah - SpaFinder
Welcome – Guests
John Gaukroger – Joe Browns Debbie Hughes – Ten Pin Dominic Peachey – Financial Services Authority Diane Jackson - BAUGUR Group Susi Pink - Lavish
Membership Issuers - 40 Service – 38
78 total
New Members Murray Scott – Buropak Steve Hattersley & John Bottreill – Cognitronics Stephanie Wilson – SK Chase Rob Frome & Fatima Wessom – New Look Nicky Tollafield – Shoe Vouchers Nick Warren – Starbucks Ken Pearceson – Royal Mail Kevin Turnbull & Cassandra Cavanah – Spa Finder
New Executive
Natasha Toothill – payzone (S) - Chair Arun Glendinning – B&Q (I) - Vice Chair Philip Shelley – Voucher Central (S) Yvonne West – Sainsbury’s (I) Caroline Watson – Voucherline (S) Rachelle Smith – PPT (S) Denise Porter – Treatme.net (I) John Davis – Argos & Homebase Business Solutions (I) Bill Alexander – Red Letter Days (I)
Cabinet Roles
Regulation & Legal – John Davis PR & Research – Yvonne West & Denise Porter Liaison with other Associations & Membership Development &
Recruitment – Rachelle Smith & Bill Alexander Finance & Constitution – Philip Shelley Social Events & Marketing (web, exhibitions) – Caroline Watson Conference – Arun Glendinning (Vice Chair) Secretariat Liaison – Natasha Toothill (Chair)
Achievements membership year 2007/08
Natasha Toothill
Highlights
Increased membership Refreshed Aims & Objectives
Aims & Objectives
Promoting the use of vouchers and gift cards to business and consumers
Enhancing the standing and raise the profile of our industry, internally and externally through leadership and advocacy
Provide a forum for networking, training, events, best practices, information and education
Addressing consumer and regulatory issues relating to the industry
Highlights
Increased membership – Should be 100 in 2009 Refreshed Aims & Objectives Networking & Communication – meetings, social events, Voom!, BRC dinner, members
website Research – YouGov, Giftex Prepay PR – day-to-day, Christmas activity, Negative press at Christmas Speaking opportunities – NIS, PME, Retail Industry Forum, Prepaid Expo, Gift Cards
Europe Marketing – consumer website Legal – VAT, Fraud, Royal Mail, FSA Industry data – change in IRI data Conference – increase in delegates Liaison with other associations – PIF, BRC, MAA
New Fee Structure
Social membership phase out All members (Issuers & Service) pay same membership
fee - £2200 + VAT Complementary place at conference for all paid up
members Fee of £800 for Issuer members to collate IRI data
(reduction of £50 on last year) Only paid up members will be eligible to attend meetings,
social events and vote
The Future of The VA five year plan
The Executive
Five Years Ago
31 members (Full members £2600, Associate £1000)
Exec included: Sainsbury’s, M&S, High Street Gift Vouchers, Arcadia Group, Virgin, Capital Incentives.
Debenhams had launched gift card
What do you want from the VA?
Research Networking PR Marketing Website Special offers Conferences Exhibitions
Tax updates Legal advice Market news Newsletter Market stats Education Training Lobbying
Budget of £180k pa to manage VA activities gets you:
Doubled membership again in 5 years
What would budget of £300 000 buy you?
Do we?
Increase the membership? Stay where we are? More social events? Increase our lobbying power? Offer market specific training? Try to change consumer buying habits? Self regulation? Network new markets? Create member forums to share issues? To be the market spokesman for prepaid? Grow awareness in the B2B market? Pack it all in……?
What do YOU want from the VA over the next 5 years?
Ask yourself:
What are your 3 main requirements this year from the VA? In 2013 – what should the VA be offering members? Which areas of membership need to be developed? How do we categorise our members?
Brainstorm these areas in 3 groups
Brain Storming results – What VA members would like to see in 08/09 It was agreed that increasing the membership is key, encouraging the missing large retailers to join, but
that we do not grow too big that we dilute the message of the VA, we should enrich rather than simply enlarge membership
Up to date Legal Issues and a snapshot of how it applies to our market Lobbying – Concerns on Non-redemption Sub groups and Forums to share issues People from outside the sphere to learn about the market Accreditation / self regulation Research – Consumer (YouGov) & Supplier led Get the VA into the consumer eyes – use the Logo as a ‘Seal of Approval’ Like to see the website used as a resource Like to see Conference 09 address member issues –
back to the ‘dynamics in paper’ maintain a balance gift card / V New technologies and better understanding – more education More on prepaid Keynote Speaker – new blood
Plans for 08-09 continued
Members would welcome Industry related training programmes so they could send teams of people Voom! too big a file. Send email with link to website? Would like to see more PR on the website Need more instructions and procedure for negative PR to be sent to members Good mix of priced social events, like to see more, maybe include outside of London.
Brain Storming 5year Plan
We should understand more of the Market, understand how the market has changed from 2007 – 2013 Consumer Research Education Lobbying Voice of the Industry VA logo to represent ‘Seal of Approval’
Q&A FSA
Dominic Peachey
LEGAL & REGULATORY ISSUES IN PREPAID
The Financial Services Authority Prepaid - Q&A -
Dominic Peachey, FSA
The Regulatory Minefield
Why is the FSA addressing a retail conference?
Innovative Electronic Payments Products have attracted the EU
E-Money Directive (2000)
Payment Services Directive (2007)
Need to rationalise these two (2009)
Watch this space
Those EU Directives:
E-money directive currently in force
Regulates third party pre paid
Due for revision by Q2/2009
Payment Services Directive
Became European law on Xmas Day
Must be implemented in UK by 11/09
Will eventually absorb the revised e-money directive
E-money Directive
If you issue a prepaid card that is not closed loop you are forced to become a financial institution (or hire a bank)
The consequent regulation is prescriptive and onerous
But the EU is taking a long hard look at the future of EMD and is looking to ease the burdens
Payment Services Directive
Will apply to all payment services, not just prepaid
Is more principles based and less prescriptive than EMD
Contains a lot of Conduct of Business regulation
Likely to be a complaints led regime
Mediated by Financial Ombudsman
A Word On Principles Based Regulation
Instead of issuing detailed rules (could encourage a box-ticking mentality)
You issue a set of high level principles
And switch the focus of regulation to desired outcomes
Leaving Senior Management in firms with the freedom to choose how best to achieve those outcomes
PBR – The Example of Hong Kong
The HK Monetary Authority has adopted a Principles Based regime for e-money
Octopus is the ticketing system adopted by the HK Mass Transit Railway
Includes Pre Pay purse which can be used outside the basic transport system
OCTOPUS
Regulated by HKMA
Code of Practice drawn up by OCL and endorsed by HKMA
www.info.gov.hk/hkma/eng/bank/value_cards/code_of_practice_OCL_.pdf
“manage float prudently”
“back with sufficient, liquid, low risk assets”
“ensure sufficient cash flow to handle daily operations”
By Contrast with Hong Kong…
….and its 3 golden principles…
The European liquidity regime…
….as enacted by the FSA’s Handbook
Runs to 17 pages of rules and guidance
This is the difference between rules based and principles based regulation
Prepaid and E-money
Most (but not all) prepaid is e-money
Open, closed and restricted loops
Definition of e-money
Who can issue e-money?
Oyster
Storecards
Gift cards
Group Schemes and Cross Border
Exploring Those Loops
An open loop scheme is a network branded product (VISA, Maestro &c) that may be used virtually anywhere
A restricted loop implies the issuer has negotiated contracts of acceptance with a limited group of merchants
A closed loop scheme is one where issue and acceptance is limited to the same person
Definition of E-money
E-money is monetary value (as represented by a claim on the issuer) which is:
Stored on an electronic device Issued on receipt of funds Accepted as a means of payment by persons
other than the issuer
Surrogate for coins and banknotes
Not deposit taking
Who Can Issue Electronic Money?
Banks
Building Societies
Specialist e-money issuers (ELMIs)
Waivered firms
EEA firms who passport into the UK
Products Which Are Not Prepaid
Debit and credit cards
Mobile based proximity payments
Account based mobile payment schemes
These products are not currently regulated
But will become so from 1 November 2009
Oyster
2 elements – travel card and pre pay
Pre pay may only be used to buy travel rights from Transport for London
So it is a ticketing system and not a stored value product for paying third parties
Has escaped financial regulation to date
Despite extension to TOCs
Oyster Involves:
No straight revenue pass through
Discontinuity between transport services consumed by cardholder and payments received by operators
Use of parallel operators to complete same journey
Use of sequential operators to complete same journey
Effect of daily price capping
Storecards
Accounts mutated into charge cards and credit cards
If they only operate within the one store chain, they are not regulated
Intra-group and cross-border edge towards regulation
Commission says storecards exempt unless co-branded with VISA or MasterCard
Gift Cards
What exactly is a gift card?
Is it a token or voucher of nominal value or
Is it an electronic purse with a running balance
With whom can it be redeemed?
If in doubt, seek advice
Group Schemes and Cross Border
Whether a scheme is regulated or not often hinges upon third party acceptance as payment
That means legal third parties
Including acceptance by subsidiaries and by other group companies
This may cause problems cross border – even the Anglo-Scottish border
Limited Network Exclusions
Article 3 (k) of PSD
Excludes: limited networks of service providers limited range of goods or services
Commission guidance intends the exemption of storecards, canteen cards, petrol cards, transport cards
BUT
The Exemption Does Not Run To…
Cards which can be used in a long list of big chains of merchants
Because they are typically designed for a growing network of service providers
Which could take them out of scope of “limited network”
But shopping mall cards should be clear
Websites
These can be virtual marketplaces
So apply the same principles
Can the payment instrument only be used for purchases through a specific website?
Or can it be used for a certain range of goods and services offered over the Internet?
Questions
B&Q asked Dominic to confim the regulation of B&Q gift crads in different sceniros: Only in B&Q stores is OK B&Q on a Mall in another store – regulated B&Q merged with another company on a card – regulated
PPT would like shopping centre cards regulation confirmed. If it can only be used in the one centre it falls outside regulation.
payzone asked if the new directive will be down to legal interpretation? Yes! FSA will give support and advice, and essentially the European Court makes the decision on
how its run.
IRI Figures
Andrew Johnson
Figures
VA collate sales data from all members Recently reformatted data collected First draft of 2007 full year data including
gift voucher, gift card and e-voucher sales
Paper v Plastic v E
Paper 65% Gift Cards (closed, open, restricted) 32% E-vouchers 3%
Plastic Only
Closed 97% Restricted 0.5% Open 2.5%
Consumer
Paper 50.63% Gift Cards (closed, open, restricted) 45.05% E-vouchers 4.32%
B2B
Paper 90.4% Gift Cards (closed, open, restricted) 9.22% E-vouchers 0.38%
Total Sales by Channelincludes paper, plastic & e
Direct 93.21% On-Line 3.58% Gift Card Centre 0.59% Third Party 2.62%
Gift Card Only Sales by Channel
Direct 98% On-Line 0.78% Gift Card Centre 0.97% Third Party 0.31%
Category Breakdown
Retail 76% Agent 21% Leisure 3%
Conference 2008Conference 2009
Arun Glendinning
Conference 2008Feedback
244 delegates 16 exhibitors Excellent feedback Less panel sessions Free drinks in the evening!
Conference 2009
Wednesday 29th April 2009 QEII Conference Centre, London All members one complementary delegate (subject to
Terms & Conditions)
Member rates for colleagues & guests Exhibition area Sponsorship opportunities Free evening drinks! More information in Voom!, and members website
Housekeeping
Andrew Johnson
Calendar of Events
Pizza Fest – this eveningNext members meeting –
Wednesday 8th October
VA Endorsed Events
Prepaid 08 – this week – feedback Facts from conference
VA Endorsed Events
Prepaid 08 – this week – feedback Facts from conference Eastern Europe has the biggest market for prepaid as most government benefits are paid on prepaid cards Prepaid is forecast 23% annual growth rate globally 2008-2012, particularly unbanked and youth Gift cards are the entry point into prepaid, particularly youth 19.6% growth in prepaid card numbers and 40’5 growth in tranx value in Europe Turkey, Greece then UK are top three opportunities Transport cards will have big impact on UK market In rest of Europe prepaid is heavily bank orientated In Germany 75% of debit cards have prepaid function Consumers 8% growth in non-store vending and 0.8% growth in in-store vending Retailers through their distribution and brand strength hold the key to the success of prepaid in UK By 2015 the market will be dominated by open loop
British Retail Consortium DinnerWednesday 24th September
VA booked a table Members can book places at £210 + VAT
Over 1000 key retail figures meet for annual dinner
Grosvenor Park Lane, London
Prepaid Cards Summit22nd & 23rd October
Prepaid Conference The Brewery More details in Voom! Organised by VRL Knowledge Bank
Prepaid Awards Inaugural Gala & Gallery
Prelude to Prepaid Awards 2009 Wednesday 22nd October 2008 Sheraton Park Lane, London Member discounts to attend Awards voted on the night Event joint endorsement from VA & PIF More at www.prepaidawards.com
The Motivation Awards
Awarding motivation & incentive programs In association with the ISP 20 awards Discounts for members to attend and sponsor Wednesday 5th November, Royal Garden
Hotel, London More at www.motivationawards.org
Umbrella Association covering whole Prepaid Market Working Groups:
Business models – Rachelle Smith Legal & Regulatory – John Davis Consumer & Education – Andrew Johnson Transportation – available Two places available to VA members should any other member
wish to attend
Updates in Voom! PIF newsletter from VA office – includes profiles of
the Prepaid market in other European Countries More info on PIF website
PIF is looking at self regulation and accreditation for all PIF members
The VA needs a definitive guide on negative balances
PIF Code of Conduct has been incorporated into VA Code of Conduct
Research
Executive
Research membership year 2008/09
2007 – YouGov & Giftex Prepay YouGov - PR lead, gifting trends Giftex Prepay – research focus, gift cards and
voucher trends 2008?
Research Brain Storm results Consumer Questions Repeat questions from 2007 so results are
measurable and get Trend Data Consumer: Reasoning behind purchase? Why do you choose gift card / Voucher over
product? Awareness of Gift card? E-voucher / Mobile? Perceived value of all these? Are they buying by Brand? Do they repeat purchase? Do you find it difficult to understand value of gift
card? How many Voucher or gift cards not used? Do they ever club together? What is normal purchase value? Age of the purchaser?
How important is packaging? Have you recived gift card voucher? Would you
have preferred cash? What does the value tell you perception of the
giver? Appetite for Open Loop
Research Brain Storm resultsB2B Questions Why do they not like cards? What do they want from plastic? – top up /
reload / denominated Can they be used to increase brand loyalty Offer additional benefits for plastic Is presentation / packaging important?
Any Other Business?
The BBC’s the one show has been approaching Large Retailers for figures regarding non-redemption. The VA & Clareville are happy to field these questions, so that we deliver the same answer. Please call Andrew if you would like advice