were the assyrians at ecbatana

» » » » »

Sign up for a free, 7-day trialSign up for a free, 7-day trial

Home Publications Academic journals History journals International Journal of Kurdish Studies

January 1, 2002 | Medvedskaya, I.N. | Copyright

Were the Assyrians at Ecbatana?

The historical geography of Media of the 9th-7th century B.C. presents one of the most

complicated problems in the history of the Ancient Near East. The toponyms of Media testified

by Assyrian sources do not coincide with the later Median toponyms of the Achaemenid period

known to Ancient Greek, Roman and Armenian geographers (1). This leaves us with very few

place-names of the 9th-7th century to locate on the present-day map of the region.

Meanwhile, the existing relative topography of Media and the regions adjoining it, based on

detailed descriptions of Assyrian campaigns there, need only to have some of the place-names

connected with a modern map. Thus far the identification of only one name has been suggested:

Mt. Bikni, or the Lapis Lazuli Mountain "in the land of the remote Medes"--the furthermost

point in the east of Media ever reached by the Assyrians. Bikni is usually identified with one of

two mountains in Iran: either the Damavand mountain to the north of Teheran, or the Alvand,

one of the peaks of the Zagros bordering on the Hamadan plain, not far from the city of

Hamadan. Those suggesting the first attribution obviously take it for granted that the limits of

the region known as Media to the Assyrians were the same as those in the later period, and that

the Assyrians were able to launch long-range military expeditions. In Russian historiography,

this view has been held by I. M. Diakonoff (2). He did not suggest any specific arguments to

identify Bikni with Damavand; in his opinion the Assyrians were mistaken in calling it the Lapis

Lazuli Mountain. "All the lapis lazuli known to the Ancient East was of Badakhshan origin, i.e. it

was brought through Media from Bactria" (3). The research done in the last few years reveals a

tendency to accept the view that the Assyrian penetration to the east, namely to the Iranian

plateau, was not so extensive (4). Many scholars now recognise the historical geography of Iran,

including Media, as developed by L. Levine. In his opinion, since the Assyrian texts do not

mention Ecbatana, the capital of Media (modern Hamadan), the Assyrians had never been there

and never reached the plain of Hamadan. Consequently, all of the Median toponyms known to

them must be located to the west of Hamadan. Bikni must then correspond to the Alvand

mountains (5). This identification goes back to F.W Konig (6). Levine assumes that a certain part

of Media laying east of the Zagros range remained unknown to the Assyrians. He draws the

following conclusion: if Bikni = Alvand marks the easternmost point of the Assyrian expansion,

then it explains why the Medians built their capital on the plain of Hamadan: it was a region safe

from Assyrian raids (7).

The illusory nature of this conclusion is evident. Rejecting some very inconclusive arguments for

Bikni = Damavand, which though never stated seem rather obvious, the Lapis Lazuli Mountain,

being the most glorious mountain of Iran, must be a metaphor for the ice-clad peak of

Damavand, which lies on the way towards the lapis lazuli of Badakhshan (8). Levine provides us

with counter-arguments of the same impressionistic kind (9). They can be disproved easily (10).

The most serious of his arguments against Bikni = Damavand, at first glance, appears to be the

absence in the Assyrian sources of the name of Ecbatana, ([Ha.sup.n]gmatana-), which lay on

Publication FinderBrowse back issues from our extensive library of

more than 6,500 trusted publications.

Popular publications

The Christian Science Monitor

Religious magazines

The Economist (US)

Political magazines

The Nation

Political magazines

Harper's Magazine

Cultural magazines

Newsweek

National newspapers

Help us improve our websites

Become a member of our Customer AdvisoryPanel. Your opinion matters!

ریسمون مهجو

بياب جاماسپ

دسترس� به تارنمای فراخوانده شده امكان پذیر نم

ریسمون مهجو

بياب جاماسپ

دیتایاب پارسی جو

جستجو

دسترس� به تارنمای فراخوانده شده امكان پذیر نم

International Journal of Kurdish Studies

SaveSave ExportExport PrintPrint CiteCite

Publications Publications Research topics Research topics

Publications homePublications home Journals Journals Magazines Magazines Newspapers Newspapers Reference works and books Reference works and books

Subscription benefits Log inFollow us:

Were the Assyrians at Ecbatana? - International Journal of Kurdish Studie... http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-132797080.html

1 of 4 4/29/2013 10:33 PM

See all related articles »

the way to Damavand. This, however, proves nothing. Now, after additional arguments for Bikni

= Damavand have been put forth by E.A. Grantovskij, there is no way to prove the opposite.

These arguments are as follows: by the Lapis Lazuli Mountain the Assyrians were locating the

land of Patus'arra. The name of the region of Patishvar in Mazandaran, near Damavand, appears

in the Early Medieval period. It is the direct transcript of the Akkad, Patus'arra. In Patishvar,

according to Kazvini, lapis lazuli was still mined in the Early Medieval times (11). Levine failed to

notice that the land of Bit Tibti, the Salt Desert, modern Dasht-i Kavir, had been placed by the

Assyrians near Patus'arra. It seems evident, after all, that the identification of Bikni with Alvand

can not be accepted.

According to Levine, the Assyrians were aware of only that part of Media, which corresponds to

the mountains of Luristan along the Great Khorasan Road. Clearly such short-distance raids by

the Assyrians into Iran seem rather strange, if we compare them with the extension of their

military expeditions to Urartu, to the north of the Lake Van, or towards the Mediterranean, not

speaking of Egypt. What could have been the reason for the Assyrian expansion to the East if,

after crossing the mountain range with so much effort, their armies just turned back instead of

entering the broad and fertile plain of Hamadan? The scheme suggested by Levine makes a

blank space for the major part of the Iranian plateau, since he is locating practically all of the

lands of Ancient Iran known to the Assyrians along the Zagros range. Some scholars, who accept

his view, define the material culture of that part of Luristan where Levine locates Media as

Median culture. This attribution, however, seems very doubtful (12). In fact, Levine's entire

reconstruction follows from his negative answer to the question we chose for the title of the

present article. Is it possible to give …

To read the full text of this article and others like it, try us out for 7 days, FREE!

Related articles

'Les Mite D'Assyrie': Moths in the Assyrian Texts of the Second Millennium B.C

The Journal of the American Oriental Society; July 1, 1998

Secrets of Sargon. (Mesopotamian art at the newly opened Iraq Museum)

The Economist (US); January 20, 1990

Look on my works, ye mighty. (effects of the Persian Gulf War, 1991- on archaeological sites)

The Economist (US); February 9, 1991

Galleries Gift for Museum

The Middle East; October 1, 1993

A Timeline of Art Materials: Technology Includes Both High and Low Versions in the Development

of Art Materials and Processes. Let's Take a Look

School Arts; October 1, 2006

Recently viewed itemsArticle: Were the Assyrians at Ecbatana?


2 of 4 4/29/2013 10:33 PM

Company

About us

Subscription benefits

Group subscriptions

Partnership opportunities

Careers

Privacy policy

Terms and conditions

Contact us

Help topics

FAQ

Search tips

Using the Research Center

Billing questions

Rights inquiries

Customer Service

From our blog

All posts

Trending news

Research

How-to guides

News and updates

Testimonials

Cengage Learning Network

Questia

CengageBrain.com

HighBeam Business

Encyclopedia.com

ed2go

HighBeam Research is operated by Cengage Learning. © Copyright 2013. All rights reserved.

Follow us:


3 of 4 4/29/2013 10:33 PM

The HighBeam advertising network includes:


4 of 4 4/29/2013 10:33 PM

were the assyrians at ecbatana

Documents