workboat annual conference international …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days...

39

Upload: others

Post on 04-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair
Page 2: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Workboat Annual Conference – International Workboat Show

The Internet of Things Comes to the Workboat Industry

P. Jaime Tetrault

Director, Product Support & Asset Intelligence

Page 3: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

The global market is changing…

…are you ready?

UBER World’s largest taxi company

…owns no taxis Airbnb

Huge accommodation provider

…owns no real state

Skype, WeChat & Whatsapp

Mega communication companies

…own no telecom infrastructure Alibaba

Retailer more valuable than Walmart

…has no inventory

LendingClub & SocietyOne

Fastest growing lenders

…have no actual money NETFLIX

World’s largest movie house

…owns no cinemas

Page 4: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

1. Overview of Caterpillar Marine & Asset Intelligence

2. What is the Internet of Things or Industrial Internet of Things?

3. What does this mean for the Workboat industry?

4. What challenges need to be overcome and how do I get started?

What I am going to talk about today…

Graphic source: www.KPCB.com

Marine Asset

Intelligence

5. Conclusions & Questions

Page 5: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Introduction to Caterpillar Marine

How you might traditionally think of Caterpillar…

…where we are today and moving in the future

Uptime Total Operating Cost

Page 6: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

What is the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)?

What does it mean for me?

Machines & Sensors

Expert Advisors Intelligent analytics

EQUIPMENT

MANAGEMENT

• Avoid failures

• Reduce cost of

maintenance

PRODUCTIVITY

• Reduce downtime

• Increase productivity

• Increase fuel efficiency

SAFETY

• Reduce unsafe

operations &

conditions

SUSTAINABILITY

• Ensure environ-

mental compliance

Potential value in Workboat Industry

Page 7: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Twitter:

11 Accounts created,

5,700 tweets

YouTube:

2 video hrs. uploaded

2,314 video hrs. watched

Facebook:

52,196 likes

2,314 video hrs. watched

54,976 posts

6 GB of data

LinkedIn:

182

User searches

Pinterest:

238 pins

In the first second we spent on this slide… approximately 22,574 GB of

data was transferred over the Internet.

This is not just ‘social media’

1.7B pieces of industrial equipment expected to be ‘connected’ by 2020

23.6B sensors were shipped in 2014 (up from 4.2B in 2012)

What is Big Data?

Data generated every second…

Source: Peter Fisk, Genius Works, Gartner, World Economic Forum

Page 8: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

What is the impact of this?

2020

40ZB 2015

7ZB

2010

1ZB

Total cumulative data ever created 1 zettabyte = 1 trillion gigabytes

How do we avoid being overwhelmed?

Is there value in this?

What does this mean for the Workboat Industry?

Source: Peter Fisk, Genius Works

Page 9: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Capitalizing on the age of IIoT

• New departments with senior leaders • Goal of building an ecosystem of internal and external technology

solutions

Organizational changes

Traditional marine companies expanding through tech acquisition; examples include: • Caterpillar acquisition of ESRG to form MAI, PEPR in Oil & Gas • Wartsila acquisition of L3-Marine/SAM • ClassNK acquisition of NAPA and Helm • Many making investments in telematics, analytics, applications

Acquisitions / Investments

Partnerships Automation, equipment OEMs, class, shipyards, universities, software companies working together, examples include: • Caterpillar partnerships with University of Illinois, GTUIT, Modustri • Hyundai Heavy Shipbuilding partnership with Accenture • Lloyd’s Register partnership with University of Southampton

Focus on using technology to create value from growing data…

Page 10: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1

Total

Reduce unsafe operations

Avoid unsafe equipment condition

Reduce compliance/admin labor cost

Reduce risk of environmental fines

Reduce fuel burn at idle

Optimize vessel speed

Optimize vessel plant configuration

Reduce hull & prop fouling

Optimize equipment tuning

Improve maint. & dry-dock planning

Reduce crew costs/skills/risk

Reduce human error maint failures

Extend maintenance intervals

Minimize failure repair costs

Reduce downtime due to failures

Improve vessel productivity

Millions

What value can all this bring to the Workboat industry?

Value creation levers Illustrative OSV potential value Per vessel

SAFETY

EQUIPMENT

MANAGEMENT

SUSTAINABILITY

PRODUCTIVITY

Indicates range of potential value

Caterpillar estimates ~$6B in annual

value creation in the Workboat industry through application of IIoT

• Fewer failures • Less downtime • Lower maintenance costs • Better fuel efficiency • Risk mitigation for compliance & safety

Page 11: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Examples of how the IIoT is being applied by

Caterpillar Marine Asset Intelligence in the Workboat industry

Inland Tug: Predict and prevent engine failure

OSV: Identify fuel injector problem to avoid failure & save fuel

Harbor tug: Optimize operations & tune engine optimally

EQUIPMENT

MANAGEMENT PRODUCTIVITY SAFETY SUSTAINABILITY

Page 12: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Analytics for Equipment Management: How it works

Inputs:

• Electronic Data • Repair History • Fluid Analysis • Site Conditions • Inspections

Equipment

Conditions

Compared

to a

Standard

Equipment

Conditions

Compared

to Similar

Equipment

Equipment

Conditions

Compared

to Itself

Page 13: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Solutions & Analytics for Entire Vessel

• Controllable Pitch Propellers

• Torque meters

• Steering systems

• Main propulsion diesel engines

• Ship’s service diesel generators

• Emergency generators

• Gas turbine main engines

• Gas turbine generators

• Auxiliary gas turbines

• Gas turbine starting systems

Compressors

• High pressure

• Medium pressure

• Low pressure

• De-ballast

compressors

• Air conditioning

• Refrigeration

• Reverse osmosis

• Steam evaporators

• Reduction

gears

• Transmissions

Other auxiliaries

• Waste heat boilers

• Chill water pumps

• Cathodic protection

• Fuel & lube oil

systems

• Purifiers

• Service & transfer

pumps

• Ballast management

systems

• Oily water

separators

• Sewage / gray-water

systems

• Ballast water

treatment systems

• Waterjets

• Fin stabilizers

• Thrusters

Fuel flow

meters

• GPS / Navigation systems

• Control systems

• Environmental factors

• Feed & booster pumps

• Seawater service & fire pumps

• Deck equipment

Tanks levels

• Fuel oil

• Lube oil

• Cargo

• Ballast

Additional data inputs

• Fluid Analysis / SOS

• Visual (manual) inspections

• Additional / aftermarket sensors

(bearing, oil condition, vibration, etc)

• Hull resistance, cleaning,

technologies

• Specialized

equipment

Page 14: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case Study – Vessel Monitoring and Analytics

• Large inland river tug

and barge operator

• Trying to improve

maintenance, fuel

efficiency, and

operations using data

analytics

Page 15: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case Study – Avoiding Equipment Failure

Customer

Objectives

• Provide customer with comprehensive solution

– Equipment: Caterpillar and Non Caterpillar

– Vessel: Fuel performance and operations

Impact

• Identified ways to improve decision making

– Reduced fuel consumption

– Avoided failures and associated downtime

– Reduced operational costs

– Real transparency for senior management

Page 16: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Use Case Impact Applicability

Failing fuel pump and

dirty fuel filters

Avoid failure, downtime, additional repair

costs

Engine overspeed Identify potential heavy wear conditions,

reduce

Engine droop Identify high engine stress events (i.e.,

running over log in river)

Alarm monitoring Ensure onboard alarms receive attention

High exhaust temps Focus troubleshooting on specific equipment

in specific situations

Engine performance

vs. baseline

Focus troubleshooting, improve fuel

efficiency

High stress ops (high

power/rate of turn)

Identify potential heavy wear conditions,

reduce

Daily fuel

consumption

Monitor and benchmark fuel consumption to

help reduce

Long idle periods Monitor fuel consumption and high wear

operations

Duty cycle analysis Monitor fuel consumption and high wear

operations, better plan operational calendar

Maintenance

Fuel &

Productivity

One of many “Use Cases” identified for this vessel...

Page 17: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case study - Avoiding Fuel Pump Failure

Week 1 Week 2 Week 3

Fuel pump

failure & repair

Baseline

Low Fuel Pressure (2σ from ‘like-new’)

Like

New

7 days

before

failure

4 days

before

failure

2 days before

failure

Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

(vs. preventative) = $35,000 per failure

Fault New -7 days -4 days -2 days

Exhaust

Fuel Cooling Oil Turbo Aux

Page 18: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case study - Reducing idle time

• Extended periods (8+ hours) at idle while stationary alongside pier

• Multiple occurrences per week

Impact

Issue

• Configured Asset Intelligence analytics to automatically identify periods

greater than 3 hours

• Reducing just one of the extended idle periods per week saved $15,000

per vessel in fuel – over $2M when extrapolated across entire fleet

• Additional benefit of reducing engine hours, etc

Page 19: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case Study – Vessel Monitoring and Analytics

Customer

Objectives

• Trying to improve maintenance, uptime, and reliability

• Customer asking for increased focus on fuel efficiency

OSV: ~3500 DWT, CAT 3516 engines

Impact

• Identified ways to improve decision making

– Identified fuel injector problem prior to equipment

failure and increased fuel efficiency

Page 20: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Use Case Impact Applicability

Equipment failure Avoid failure, downtime, additional repair

costs

Engine overspeed Identify potential heavy wear conditions,

reduce

Over-cooling Improve engine performance, health and

remaining life

Faulty fuel injectors Avoid failure & associated downtime/repair,

improve fuel efficiency

High exhaust temps Focus troubleshooting on specific equipment

in specific situations

Engine performance

vs. baseline

Focus troubleshooting, improve fuel

efficiency

Daily fuel

consumption

Monitor and benchmark fuel consumption to

help reduce

Long idle periods Monitor fuel consumption and high wear

operations

Duty cycle analysis Monitor fuel consumption and high wear

operations, better plan operational calendar

Maintenance

Fuel &

Productivity

Range of Application – Specific Value Propositions

Page 21: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Caterpillar Case Study – Faulty Fuel Injector

• Automated analytics

identified fuel injector

issue

• High right exhaust

bank temperatures

• Erratic low speed

RPM

• Higher fuel

consumption

compared to other

engine

Impact

Issue

• Replaced faulty fuel injectors:

• Avoided potential catastrophic failure

• Improved fuel efficiency, resulting in $175/day in fuel savings

(>$50,000 per year) - fuel savings based on observed operational

duty cycle

Page 22: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Case Study – Vessel Monitoring and Analytics

Customer

Objectives

• Trying to improve maintenance, fuel efficiency, and

operations using data analytics

• New vessel – Cat® C175 engines and C9 generators

Impact

• Identified ways to improve decision making

– Optimized vessel speed and operations to reduce

fuel consumption

– Tune equipment to increase performance &

reliability

– Reduce risk of failure by identifying and resolving

issues early

Large harbor tug operator

Page 23: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Use Case Impact Applicability

Identifying potential

problems before

failure

Avoid failure, downtime, additional repair

costs

Engine overspeed Identify potential heavy wear conditions,

reduce

Engine droop Identify high engine stress events (i.e.,

running over log in river)

Alarm monitoring Ensure onboard alarms receive attention

Identifying faulty

sensors prior to failure

Focus troubleshooting on specific equipment

in specific situations

Engine performance

vs. baseline

Focus troubleshooting, improve fuel

efficiency

High stress ops (high

power/rate of turn)

Identify potential heavy wear conditions,

reduce

Daily fuel

consumption

Monitor and benchmark fuel consumption to

help reduce

Long idle periods Monitor fuel consumption and high wear

operations

Optimizing transit

speed

Decrease fuel consumption with optimal

transit speed

Maintenance

Fuel &

Productivity

Range of Application – Specific Use Cases

Page 24: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

• Port engine fuel pressure is 3 PSIG lower than starboard

• Similar operating situation & conditions

Port Engine

rpm vs. Fuel Pressure

Starboard Engine

rpm vs. Fuel Pressure

Impact

Issue

Tug Case Study: Detailed Engine Optimization

• Identify potential filter or fuel pump issues earlier, before failure

• Fine tune for optimal performance and increased fuel efficiency

Page 25: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

0

5

10

15

20

25

Gal

lon

s P

er

Mile

Power or RPM

Transit Speed Before RPM: 1250

~10 Gallons Per Mile

Optimal Transit Speed RPM: 600-800

~3 Gallons Per Mile

Power & RPM both analyzed vs. fuel economy with same outcome

Tug Case Study: Optimize transit speed

• Transit to operations at

1250 RPM, because it

sounds good

Impact

Issue

• Identified optimal transit

speed for situations that

are not time sensitive

• Created visibility for

onboard crew and

shore management

• $110,000 reduced fuel

by transiting at optimal

speed based on

operational profile

Page 26: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Technology

People Process

VALUE

• Varied equipment • Multiple OEMs • Varied sensors • Disparate data sources

& formats • Overwhelming volume

of data • Data transmission

• Different skill sets

• Lack of capacity

• Training • Limited

onboard capabilities

• Existing systems & processes

• Change management

This is not just about technology…

Page 27: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

• Varied equipment • Multiple OEMs • Varied sensors • Disparate data sources

& formats • Overwhelming volume

of data • Data transmission

• Different skill sets

• Lack of capacity

• Training

• Existing systems & processes

• Change management

Data collection for wide variety of equipment & data sources/formats

Automated analytics for different OEMs and types of equipment

Onboard analytics to only send valuable data Caterpillar

experts & Fleet Advisors

Expertise across range of equipment

Enable both onboard & shore teams

Local Dealer support

Flexibility to integrate with existing systems (CMMS)

Test Drive to build your business case, engage stakeholders, and develop process

This is not just about technology… How Caterpillar Marine Asset Intelligence

addresses these challenges

Technology

People Process

VALUE

Page 28: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Awareness

Understanding

Trial Use

Adoption Internalization

Time

Most marine operators have yet to adopt technology-based

solutions into their business processes.

2015 ?

2014

Where are you on the adoption curve for the IIoT

or technology enabled solutions?

Page 29: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

What is needed to get started?

Get right people

involved

Define your

objectives

Select right

partners

Start (defined

scope, then grow)

…Caterpillar has defined

a ‘Test Drive’ process to help get started

Page 30: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Caterpillar Marine Asset Intelligence Test Drive

helps customers get started and be successful

1 Kickoff &

Alignment

2 Use Cases &

Configuration

4 Validate

value & plan

roll-out

3 Onboarding

• Bring together all relevant stakeholders, including senior management & Champion

• Align on scope, objectives, resources, evaluation criteria and schedule

• Deliverable: Test Drive focus areas and future expansion options

• Define how equipment & vessel is

operated & maintained

• Identify pain points

• Include Maintenance & Operations leaders

• Deliverable: Clear input to assure proper

configuration

• Ship Survey

• Develop install plan

• Technical discussion with

customer IT team

• Configuration

• Deliverable: Installation

• Workshop to review Test Drive

output & validate value proposition

• All relevant stakeholders

• Identify lessons learned for

customer specific situation

• Deliverable: Clear business case

Page 31: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Conclusions:

• Early Adopters: “We’ve tried this and are struggling” – Advanced

Analytics may well be the solution to solving your ongoing challenges.

• New to Technology Enabled Solutions: “This sounds interesting” – Before

you try this on your own, speak to a supplier with experienced domain

expertise and analytics background

EQUIPMENT

MANAGEMENT PRODUCTIVITY

SAFETY SUSTAINABILITY

Asset Intelligence brings IIoT to Workboat Industry

Page 32: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

CAT, CATERPILLAR, BUILT FOR IT, their respective logos, “Caterpillar Yellow” and the “Power Edge” trade dress, as well

as corporate and product identity used herein, are trademarks of Caterpillar and may not be used without permission.

©2015 Caterpillar

All rights reserved.

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION

& PLEASE VISIT US AT THE

CATERPILLAR EXHIBITION BOOTH!

Page 33: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

BACKUP

Page 34: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

If you are using Technology Enabled Solutions, how far along

has your initiative progressed?

Regression

Corrective

Maintenance

Planned

Maintenance

Condition

Based

Maintenance

& Operations

Value Added Complexity

Don’t fix it,

delay the fix

Fix it after it

breaks

Fix it before it breaks

Don’t just fix it,

improve & optimize it

Reactive

Urgency

Overtime

Predict

Plan

Schedule

Cost Focus

Eliminate Defects

Shared Vision

System Performance

Value Focus

Rewards

Incentive

Behavior

Run Until Failure

Short Term Savings Overtime Heroes

No Surprises

Competitive

Best in Class

Competitive Advantage

Meet short term

budget Breakdowns Avoid Failures Business Growth

Survival Reactive Organized Optimization

Most companies fall within this range

Page 35: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

…creating significant value for

the customer Cat Marine Asset Intelligence

Advanced, automated analytics Based on 30M

hours of machine monitoring, analytics help identify

issues before they become a problem

Expert advisory services Experienced operators,

maintenance and repair technicians and data

analysts provide actionable advisories

Flexible functionality Analytics and advisory

services cover equipment condition, fuel

performance, operations and safety

Broad applicability Can monitor & analyze wide

variety of equipment, both CAT and non-CAT, diesel

engines and auxiliaries

EQUIPMENT

MANAGEMENT

• Avoid failures

• Reduce cost of

maintenance

PRODUCTIVITY

• Reduce downtime

• Increase productivity

SAFETY

• Reduce unsafe

operations &

conditions

SUSTAINABILITY

• Reduce fuel costs

• Ensure environ-

mental compliance

What’s the difference between Remote Monitoring and Asset

Intelligence with Technology Enabled Solutions?

Page 36: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Real Operational Transparency for Management

Recent operations including

position, course, speed, rpm,

power, fuel burn, etc.

Duty cycle analysis shows long periods

at idle, with short period of time at high

power; enables comparison across the

fleet as well as trend throughout time

Fuel and

productivity

analysis

enables

comparison

of boats

and

trending

over time

Page 37: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair

Sensor issue Potential impact if not resolved

Port engine coolant sensor spikes • Mask of pending failures

• Prevented control system logics from

protecting engine

Sustained high pressure differential for

#2 air filter

• Masked reduced air flow

• Decreased fuel efficiency

• Engine stall

• Crew bypass with unfiltered air

Cylinder exhaust temperature spikes of

over 400 degrees per second caused

by failed thermocouple

• No true monitoring of cylinder

• Unforeseen & unprotected failure

• None of these issues would have been readily apparent to onboard crew

• Likely first indication would be actual equipment issue or failure

• Resolving could help avoid catastrophic failure during operations

Tug Case Study: Resolving Undetected Sensor Issues

Page 38: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair
Page 39: Workboat Annual Conference International …...7 days before failure 4 days before failure 2 days before failure Potential Impact: $20k/day rev loss + $15k add’l for offsite repair