worksheet - how strong is the evidence

2
 !"# %&'"() *% &!+ +,*-+(.+ +/.+'0&% +/% 121 +/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 71 !" $%&'()*++& *),(-. (/0(-(01*+' %*-. * +"2.3 3('4 "5 0.-.+"$(/6 %.*3, 0('.*'. ,%*/ ,%"'. 2%" +(-. * '.0./,*3& +(5.',&+.7 8 91:;.0 '.*3)% 2*' )"/01),.0 1'(/6 ,%. ,.3<' )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.= $%&'()*+ .>.3,("/= */0 '.0./,*3&= 3.'1+,(/6 (/ ?@ 3*/0"<(A.0 )"/,3"++.0 ',10(.'= .*)% 2(,% BC ," ,%(3,& '1:D.),'E 8++ "5 ,%. ',10(.' '%"2.0 * /.6*,(-. 3.+*,("/'%($ :.,2../ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& +.-.+' */0 (/)(0./). "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. F%(6%.3 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& +.-.+' 2.3. *''")(*,.0 2(,% +"2.3 (/)(0./). "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.GE H1:D.),' 53"< *++ 5(5,../ ',10(.' 2.3. $""+.0 */0 ',*,(',()*++& */*+&A.0 ," 0.,.3<(/. ,%. ',3./6,% "5 ,%(' 3.+*,("/'%($ */0 ,%. */*+&'(' 3.-.*+.0 * IJK 3.01),("/ (/ 3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. *<"/6 ,%"'. (/0(-(01*+' ./6*6(/6 (/ *, +.*', IC <(/1,.' "5 <"0.3*,. $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& * 0*&E +/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 78 !".' 0*(+& $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& $3.-./, )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.7 8/ .>%*1',(-. +(,.3*,13. '.*3)% 2*' )"/01),.0= 3.'1+,(/6 (/ LM ',10(.' "/ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E N*)% ',10& 2*' ,%./ .-*+1*,.0 ," 0.,.3<(/. 2%.,%.3 (, (/)+10.0 * '.0./,*3& )"/,3"+= 3.'1+,(/6 (/ ,%. .+(<(/*,("/ "5 * ,",*+ "5 '.-./ ',10(.'E O%. 3.<*(/(/6 LC ',10(.' 3.-(.2.0 '166.', * ',3"/6 /.6*,(-. 3.+*,("/'%($ :.,2../ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E O%1'= %(6%.3 +.-.+' "5 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& *3. *''")(*,.0 2(,% * +"2.3 3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E +/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 79 O%. $13$"'. "5 ,%(' $*$.3 (' ," $3.'./, */ .-(0./).P:*'.0 3.-(.2 "5 ,%. )133./, ',*,. "5 4/"2+.06. "/ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. 2(,% '$.)(5() 3.5.3./). ," %1<*/ ',10(.'E 8 <1+,(0(')($+(/*3& $*/.+ "5 .>$.3,' F.>.3)('. $%&'("+"6(','= )*30("+"6(',' */0 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& .$(0.<("+"6(','G )"/01),.0 ,%(' 3.-(.2E O%. )*,.6"3(.' "5 .-(0./). $3.'./,.0 *3. ,%"'. "1,+(/.0 :& ,%. Q*,("/*+ R.*3,= S1/6= */0 T+""0 U/',(,1,.E T.)*1'. "5 ,%. 2.*+,% "5 (/5"3<*,("/ "/ ,%. )*30("$3",.),(-. .55.),' "5 3.61+*3 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,&= 2. 5")1' "/ ,%. :./.5(,' "5 *.3":() .>.3)('. (/ ,%(' 9"'(,("/ H,*/0E T*'.0 1$"/ ,%. )133./, .-(0./).= ,%. 5"++"2(/6 .>.3)('. $3.')3($,("/ (' 3.)"<<./0.0 ," $3.-./, )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.V  !"#$%#&'() "/ <"',= $3.5.3*:+& *++= 0*&' "5 ,%. 2..4  *&+#&,-+() <"0.3*,.P(/,./'(, ! #$%P!"#$ &' ( *BWG  .-/#) X IC <(/ "5 )"/,(/1"1' "3 *))1<1+*,.0 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& $.3 0*&  .(0#) $3(<*3(+& ./013*/). $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& +/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7: O" 0.,.3<(/. ,%. .55.),(-./.'' "5 *.3":() $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& (/ 3.01)(/6 ,%. 3('4 "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.= LC $*3,()($*/,' 2.3. 3*/0"<+& '.$*3*,.0 (/," .Y1*+ 63"1$' "5 ,2./,&V */ .>$.3(<./,*+ 63"1$ */0 * )"/,3"+ 63"1$E O%. )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% "5 *++ $*3,()($*/,' 2*' ,%./ .-*+1*,.0E Z"++"2(/6 ,%(' (/(,(*+ .-*+1*,("/= ,%. .>$.3(<./,*+ 63"1$

Upload: cody-lees

Post on 14-Jan-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Evidence based practice

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Worksheet - How Strong is the Evidence

7/18/2019 Worksheet - How Strong is the Evidence

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/worksheet-how-strong-is-the-evidence 1/2

!"# %&'"() *% &!+ +,*-+(.+ +/.+'0&%

+/% 121

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 71

!" $%&'()*++& *),(-. (/0(-(01*+' %*-. * +"2.3 3('4 "5 0.-.+"$(/6 %.*3, 0('.*'. ,%*/ ,%"'.

2%" +(-. * '.0./,*3& +(5.',&+.7 8 91:;.0 '.*3)% 2*' )"/01),.0 1'(/6 ,%. ,.3<'

)*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.= $%&'()*+ .>.3,("/= */0 '.0./,*3&= 3.'1+,(/6 (/ ?@ 3*/0"<(A.0

)"/,3"++.0 ',10(.'= .*)% 2(,% BC ," ,%(3,& '1:D.),'E 8++ "5 ,%. ',10(.' '%"2.0 * /.6*,(-.

3.+*,("/'%($ :.,2../ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& +.-.+' */0 (/)(0./). "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.

F%(6%.3 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& +.-.+' 2.3. *''")(*,.0 2(,% +"2.3 (/)(0./). "5 )*30("-*')1+*3

0('.*'.GE H1:D.),' 53"< *++ 5(5,../ ',10(.' 2.3. $""+.0 */0 ',*,(',()*++& */*+&A.0 ,"

0.,.3<(/. ,%. ',3./6,% "5 ,%(' 3.+*,("/'%($ */0 ,%. */*+&'(' 3.-.*+.0 * IJK 3.01),("/ (/

3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. *<"/6 ,%"'. (/0(-(01*+' ./6*6(/6 (/ *, +.*', IC <(/1,.' "5

<"0.3*,. $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& * 0*&E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 78

!".' 0*(+& $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& $3.-./, )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.7 8/ .>%*1',(-. +(,.3*,13. '.*3)%

2*' )"/01),.0= 3.'1+,(/6 (/ LM ',10(.' "/ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E N*)%

',10& 2*' ,%./ .-*+1*,.0 ," 0.,.3<(/. 2%.,%.3 (, (/)+10.0 * '.0./,*3& )"/,3"+= 3.'1+,(/6 (/

,%. .+(<(/*,("/ "5 * ,",*+ "5 '.-./ ',10(.'E O%. 3.<*(/(/6 LC ',10(.' 3.-(.2.0 '166.', *

',3"/6 /.6*,(-. 3.+*,("/'%($ :.,2../ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E O%1'=

%(6%.3 +.-.+' "5 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& *3. *''")(*,.0 2(,% * +"2.3 3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 79

O%. $13$"'. "5 ,%(' $*$.3 (' ," $3.'./, */ .-(0./).P:*'.0 3.-(.2 "5 ,%. )133./, ',*,. "5

4/"2+.06. "/ $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& */0 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. 2(,% '$.)(5() 3.5.3./). ," %1<*/

',10(.'E 8 <1+,(0(')($+(/*3& $*/.+ "5 .>$.3,' F.>.3)('. $%&'("+"6(','= )*30("+"6(',' */0

$%&'()*+ *),(-(,& .$(0.<("+"6(','G )"/01),.0 ,%(' 3.-(.2E O%. )*,.6"3(.' "5 .-(0./).

$3.'./,.0 *3. ,%"'. "1,+(/.0 :& ,%. Q*,("/*+ R.*3,= S1/6= */0 T+""0 U/',(,1,.E T.)*1'. "5

,%. 2.*+,% "5 (/5"3<*,("/ "/ ,%. )*30("$3",.),(-. .55.),' "5 3.61+*3 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,&= 2.

5")1' "/ ,%. :./.5(,' "5 *.3":() .>.3)('. (/ ,%(' 9"'(,("/ H,*/0E T*'.0 1$"/ ,%. )133./,

.-(0./).= ,%. 5"++"2(/6 .>.3)('. $3.')3($,("/ (' 3.)"<<./0.0 ," $3.-./, )*30("-*')1+*3

0('.*'.V

•  !"#$%#&'() "/ <"',= $3.5.3*:+& *++= 0*&' "5 ,%. 2..4

•  *&+#&,-+() <"0.3*,.P(/,./'(, ! #$%P!"#$ &' () *BWG

•  .-/#) X IC <(/ "5 )"/,(/1"1' "3 *))1<1+*,.0 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& $.3 0*&

 

.(0#) $3(<*3(+& ./013*/). $%&'()*+ *),(-(,&

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7:

O" 0.,.3<(/. ,%. .55.),(-./.'' "5 *.3":() $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& (/ 3.01)(/6 ,%. 3('4 "5

)*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.= LC $*3,()($*/,' 2.3. 3*/0"<+& '.$*3*,.0 (/," .Y1*+ 63"1$' "5

,2./,&V */ .>$.3(<./,*+ 63"1$ */0 * )"/,3"+ 63"1$E O%. )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% "5 *++

$*3,()($*/,' 2*' ,%./ .-*+1*,.0E Z"++"2(/6 ,%(' (/(,(*+ .-*+1*,("/= ,%. .>$.3(<./,*+ 63"1$

Page 2: Worksheet - How Strong is the Evidence

7/18/2019 Worksheet - How Strong is the Evidence

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/worksheet-how-strong-is-the-evidence 2/2

./6*6.0 (/ IC <(/1,.' "5 <"0.3*,. *.3":() $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& 0*(+& 2%(+. ,%. )"/,3"+ 63"1$

)"/,(/1.0 2(,% ,%.(3 /"3<*+ 0*(+& 3"1,(/.'E 85,.3 '(> <"/,%'= <*34.3' 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3

%.*+,% 2.3. *''.''.0 (/ :",% 63"1$' F:+""0 $3.''13.= */0 $+*'<* ,3(6+&).3(0.= R!S= */0

S!S +.-.+'GE O%. )"/,3"+ 63"1$ 0.<"/',3*,.0 * @K (/)3.*'. (/ 3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3

0('.*'.= 2%.3.*' ,%. .>$.3(<./,*+ 63"1$ .>%(:(,.0 * ICK 0.)3.*'. (/ 3('4 5"3

)*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7;

8 ',10& 2*' 0.'(6/.0 ," *''.'' ,%. (<$*), "5 $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& "/ )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% (/ *

63"1$ "5 S"/0"/ :1' 2"34.3'E O%. )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% F3.$"3,' "5 */6(/*= %.*3, *,,*)4'=

"3 0.*,% 53"< %.*3, *,,*)4G "5 :",% ,%. 03(-.3' */0 ,()4., ,*4.3' "5 ,%. S"/0"/ :1' '&',.<

2*' <"/(,"3.0 5"3 "/. &.*3E ["<$*3('"/' "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% 2.3. ,%./ <*0.E O%.

*/*+&'(' '%"2.0 * '(6/(5()*/, 0(55.3./). :.,2../ 63"1$' (/ ,.3<' "5 )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,%=

'1)% ,%*, ,%. :1' 03(-.3' 0.<"/',3*,.0 +"2.3 )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,%E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7<

8 '<*++ :"0& "5 3.'.*3)% '166.',' ,%*, +.*0(/6 * $%&'()*++& *),(-. +(5.',&+. <*& $3.-./,

)*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E O%(' ',10& )"<$*3.0 ,%. )*30("-*')1+*3 %.*+,% F:+""0 $3.''13. */0

$+*'<* ,3(6+&).3(0.= R!S */0 S!S +.-.+'G "5 * 63"1$ "5 '.<(P$3"5.''("/*+ *,%+.,.' ," * 63"1$

"5 '.0./,*3& (/0(-(01*+'= *++ (/ ,%.(3 +*,. 5"3,(.'E O%. '.<($3"5.''("/*+ *,%+.,.'

0.<"/',3*,.0 /" '(6/' "5 3('4 5"3 )*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'.E U/ )"<$*3('"/= ,%. '.0./,*3&

(/0(-(01*+' 0.<"/',3*,.0 .+.-*,.0 +.-.+' "5 $+*'<* ,3(6+&).3(0.' */0 S!S= +"2 +.-.+' "5 R!S

*/0 %(6% :+""0 $3.''13.E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7=

8 $%&'()(*/ *,,.<$,.0 ," ,3.*, * &"1/6 F?\ &.*3' "5 *6.G */0 ",%.32('. %.*+,%& $*,(./, (/)*30(*) *33.',E 85,.3 ":,*(/(/6 */ .>,./'(-. %(',"3& 53"< 5*<(+& <.<:.3' */0 53(./0'= ,%.

$%&'()(*/ +.*3/.0 ,%*, ,%. $*,(./, %*0 (/6.',.0 BL "1/).' "5 * /.2 ,&$. "5 ./.36& 03(/4 (/

,%. )"13'. "5 5"13 %"13'E U, (' '1'$.),.0 ,%*, ,%. ./.36& 03(/4 <*& %*-. )*1'.0 ,%. %.*3, ,"

6" (/," 5(:3(++*,("/= 1+,(<*,.+& +.*0(/6 ," ,%(' &"1/6 (/0(-(01*+]' 0.*,%E 9%&'()(*/' <*& '""/

:. '..(/6 ",%.3 $*,(./,' "5 ,%(' *6. .>$.3(./)(/6 )*30(*) *33.',E

+/.+'0& 3'"4 5'&*.6+ 7>

[*30("-*')1+*3 0('.*'. (' ,%. /1<:.3 "/. 4(++.3 (/ ,%. ^/(,.0 H,*,.'E H" %"2 )*/ &"1

$3.-./, * %.*3, *,,*)47 _/. "5 ,%. :.', 2*&' (' ," ',*3, * $%&'()*+ *),(-(,& $3"63*<E

8))"30(/6 ," * ',10& :& * 63"1$ "5 3.'.*3)%.3' *, R*3-*30= *' +(,,+. *' ,%(3,& <(/1,.' "5$%&'()*+ *),(-(,& * 0*& "/ <"', 0*&' "5 ,%. 2..4 )*/ 3.01). &"13 3('4 "5 * %.*3, *,,*)4 :&

IJK` H"= '(6/P1$ 5"3 ,%*, a1<:* )+*'' &"1 %*-. :../ ,%(/4(/6 *:"1, ,*4(/6= */0 (/)3.*'.

&"13 &.*3' "5 %.*+,%& +(5.`