youth development guide 2 - expanded learning 360/365 · youth development guide 2.0 produced by...
TRANSCRIPT
2
YouthDevelopmentGuide2.0ProducedbyTemescalAssociates467RichStreet,Oakland,CA94609info@temescalassociates.comwww.temescalassociates.comTemescalAssociatesisdedicatedtobuildingthecapacityofleadersandorganizationsineducationandyouthdevelopmentwhoareseriousaboutimprovingthelivesofyoungpeople.Ourclientsincludeleadersofyouthservinginstitutionsandorganizations,schoolandyouthprogrampractitioners,publicandprivatefunders,intermediaryorganizations,andpolicymakers.Theirworkrangesfrombuildinglargescaleyouthandcommunityinitiativestoprovidingservicestoyoungpeopleonaday-to-daybasis.
AcknowledgementsWe’dliketoacknowledgeTemescalAssociatesstaffwhocontributedtothisguide:RozelCruz,StaceyDaraio,LeslieGravino,andSamPiha.We’dalsoliketoacknowledgeRebeccaFabiano(FABYouthPhilly)fordraftingChapters3and9andcontributingtootherchapters.We’dliketothanktheS.D.Bechtel,Jr.Foundation,whoprovidedtheresourcestocompletethisproject.SpecialthankstoSueEldredge,FounderoftheCommunityNetworkforYouthDevelopment(CNYD),forherpermissiontouseportionsoftheYouthDevelopmentGuideforAfterschool,originallypublishedbyCNYDin2001.We’dalsoliketoacknowledgethosewhocontributedtotheCNYD’soriginalYDGuide:AnneTamar-Mattis,SamPiha,AmyAdams,JudyVandegrift,SuzanneWest,JoeSikoryak,JoetteTizzone,FranklinAvery,JoeyWatanabe,St.John’sEducationalThresholdsCenter,SanFranciscoBeaconInitiative,ParkDaySchool,DestinyArts,JenniferBarros,JenniferFornal,StaceyDaraio,MorvaMcDonald,andOrenSlozberg.ThankstoourAdvisoryGroupfortheirvaluableinput.Theyinclude:KatieBrackenridge(Non-ProfitandPhilanthropicConsultant),BillFennessy(THINKTogether),CoreyNewhouse(PublicProfit),GilNoam(HarvardUniversity),PilarO’Cadiz(UCLA),MichellePerrenoud(LosAngelesCountyOfficeofEducation),andCharlesSmith(QTurnLLC).Lastly,wewouldliketoacknowledgethoseindividualsandorganizationsthatprovidedphotographs:Spotlight:Girls;LA’sBEST;TemescalAssociates;EverForwardClub;YouthInstitute–YMCAofGreaterLongBeach;WINGSforKids;YouthRadio;andNHPFoundation.
Contentscopyright©2018TemescalAssociatesandCNYDexceptasindicated.AllRightsReserved.
UsersoftheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0mayphotocopythesematerialsforthenon-commercialpurposeofeducationaladvancement,butinnoeventforcommercialorotheruseswithoutthewrittenconsentofTemescalAssociates.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
3
WhatFieldLeadersareSayingAboutthe
YouthDevelopmentGuide2.0Theprinciplesundergirdingthisyouthdevelopmentframeworkareasrelevanttodayaswhenitwascreated.Itiswellalignedwithournewlearningsfrombothresearchandpractice--fromtheimportanceofrelationshipsandsocialemotionallearningtoconsideringthekindsofshortandlongertermoutcomesweseekthatenhancesuccessinschool,workandlife.Itremainsespeciallyimportantforincreasingintentionalityaroundboththeprogramopportunitieswecreateforandwithyouthandespeciallythewayscommunitiescontributesystematicallytoensuringtheseareavailable.Thisisyouthdevelopmentandcommunitydevelopmentframingatitsbest.
-DR.DALEBLYTH,UNIVERSITYOFMINNESOTAThisframeworkcontinuestobeanimportantlensthroughwhichtobuildhigh-qualityyouthexperiencesthatpromotepositivedevelopmentaloutcomes.
-DR.HELENJANCMALONE,INSTITUTEFOREDUCATIONALLEADERSHIPAspartoftheLosAngelesCountyOfficeofEducation(LACOE)RegionalSupportTeam,weusedtheYDguideasthebasisfororganizingfulltrainingworkshops.IhaveusedchaptersoftheYouthDevelopmentGuidewhenteachingstudentsatUCIrvineaspartofanAfterschoolcourseforundergraduateswhospentpartoftheircourserequirementworkinginanafterschoolprogramsite.Ihavealsouseditfortrainingteacherswhendiscussingassetsbasedapproaches.IbelievethatthisupdatedYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0willbeavaluableresourceforthefield.
-DR.PILARO’CADIZ,UNIVERSITYOFCALIFORNIA,LOSANGELES
Thisupdatedversionofthepioneeringandcomprehensiveyouthdevelopmentguidedemonstratesthecontinuedalignmentbetweenpositiveyouthdevelopmentandthelatesttrendsinexpandedlearningprograms;includingsocialandemotionallearning,traumainformedpractices,andqualitystandards.Aswepromotetheintegrationofthesetrends,wetrytoemphasizethatthesepromisingpracticesaren’tnew,evenifthelanguageis.
-DARENHOWARD,PARTNERSHIPFORCHILDRENANDYOUTHTheprincipleshighlightedinthisyouthdevelopmentframeworkareattheheartofahighqualityafterschoolandsummerlearningexperience.Researchcontinuestoclearlysupportwhatpractitionersinherentlyunderstand-programsthatreflecttheseprinciples,canprofoundlyimpactchildrenandyouthexperiencingrisk,promoteyouthsuccess,andsupportsocialemotionallearning.
–JEFFDAVIS,CALIFORNIAAFTERSCHOOLNETWORKIwastrainedovertwelveyearsagoalongwithahandfulofothersatLACOEbySamasatrainerofthismaterial.Ihavecitedthiswork,useditinmyownpractice,andalsoshareditwithothersthroughmyconsultingwork.TheyouthdevelopmentprinciplescitedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0areasimportantnowastheywerein2001andtheupdatedversiondiscussingimportanttrendsandchangesintheafterschoolmovementmakethisYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0evenmorerelevant.
-MICHELLER.PERRENOUD,LOSANGELESCOUNTYOFFICEOFEDUCATIONIusedtheoriginalguideasthemaintextforaFoundationsofYouthWorkcourseItaughtfornearlynineyearsattheCommunityCollegeofPhiladelphia.Whilethefieldhasevolvedinmanyways,withanemphasisonthingslikecorecompetenciesforyouthworkersandprogramquality,thecoreelementsofthePositiveYouthDevelopmentframeworkisjustasrelevanttodayaswhenthisguidewasfirstpublished.Ithinkthisistherighttimetoupdatetheguidetoempoweranewgenerationofyouthworkers.
–REBECCAFABIANO,FABYOUTHPHILLY
4
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
5
TableofContents
Introduction2 Acknowledgements
3 WhatFieldLeadersareSayingAbouttheYouth DevelopmentGuide2.07 OpeningRemarks
8 AboutThisGuide
AboutYouthDevelopment
11 Chapter1TheYouthDevelopmentApproach19 Chapter2IntroducingaFrameworkforYouthDevelopment27 Chapter3RecentAdvancesinAfterschoolthatAlignwith YouthDevelopmentPrinciples
YouthDevelopmentPractices
43 Chapter4PromotingaSenseofSafety65 Chapter5EncouragingRelationshipBuilding87 Chapter6FosteringMeaningfulYouthParticipation117Chapter7ProvidingOpportunitiesforCommunity Involvement137Chapter8CreatingLearningExperiencesThatBuildSkills
163Chapter9AfterwordandAdditionalResources
6
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
7
OpeningRemarksIplayedbasketballincollegeandalsocoachedhighschoolbasketballearlyinmycareer.WhatwastheonethingIlearnedfrommybestcoachesandappliedtomyownapproach?Alwaysstartwiththefundamentals.Nomatterhowlongyouhaveplayedthegame,starteachseason,infact,eachpracticewiththefundamentals.GoldenStateWarriorStephenCurrydoesamazingthingswithabasketballthatarebeyondbelief.Whatyoudon’toftenseearetheendlesshoursofpracticeheputsineachdayofthefundamentalsofballhandlingandtheproperformforajumpshot.Ifitworksforhim,itworksforme!
TemescalAssociates’YouthDevelopmentforAfterschoolPrograms2.0isthedefinitiveplaybooktocoachothersinthefundamentalsofyouthwork.Infact,thefundamentalsofworkingwithhumans!ThisisatimeofunprecedentedopportunityforafterschoolandsummerprogramsorExpandedLearningaswesayinCalifornia.WiththerisinginterestinSocialEmotionalLearning,schoolclimateandculture,andwholechildapproachinourschoolsystemtheExpandedLearningfieldisdiscoveringstrategicwaystocollaboratewiththeschoolday.MoresothanIhaveseenatanypointinmycareer.Itisexciting.Let’snotblowtheopportunity!Startwiththefundamentals.Realizethatallofthenewtrendsineducationsharethesame“DNA”outlinedinthispublication.Realizethatalloftheexcitingnewdevelopmentsinneuroscienceand,forexample,the“generativesocialfield”(TheoryU,C.OttoScharmer)alsohavethesameDNAasyouthdevelopment,whichareoutlinedinthiswork.SamPihahasbeenapropheticvoiceinthefieldofExpandedLearningsincetheearly1990’s.This,hislatestwork,willcontinuetoinfluencethedevelopmentofhigh-qualityopportunitiesforourchildrenandyouth.IrecommendthatthisGuidebeusedtogetherwiththeLearninginAfterschool&SummerprinciplesandtheQualityStandardsforExpandedLearninginCalifornia.Let’sgetbacktothefundamentalsandwinforandwithourkids!
--MICHAELFUNK,DIRECTOROFTHEEXPANDEDLEARNINGDIVISION,
CALIFORNIADEPARTMENTOFEDUCATION
I’msoappreciativeofTemescalAssociatescontinuingworktoupdateCNYD's(CommunityNetworkforYouthDevelopment)originalYouthDevelopmentGuidetoreflectthecurrentcontextofyouthdevelopmentpractice.It'satributetoresearchersJimConnellandMichelleGamboneandthemultitudeofpractitionerswhocreatedtheoriginalYouthDevelopmentFramework.TheFrameworkremainsasrelevanttodayasitwasin2001,withitsuniquefocusontheyouthdevelopmentexperienceswewantforyoungpeopleandtheorganizationalsupportthatenablethesepracticestothrive.
–SUEELDREDGE,FORMEREXECUTIVEDIRECTOR,CNYD
8
AboutthisGuide
WhatisthePurposeofthisGuide?ThisGuideisdesignedtoofferanintroductiontoyouthdevelopmentprinciplesandpracticestothediversegroupofpeopleinvolvedincreatingandimplementingafterschoolprograms—programdirectors,schooladministrators,teachers,staff,volunteers,communitypartners,andothers.Webelievethatadoptingayouthdevelopmentapproachwhendesigningandimplementingafterschoolprogramscanhelpensurethatyoungpeoplegetthemostoutoftheseprograms.Ifyouareinvolvedwithanotherkindofyouthprogram,orareafunder,aparent,apolicymaker,orsomeoneinterestedincommunitydevelopment,thisbookcanalsoserveasagoodbasicintroductiontothefieldofyouthdevelopment.TheGuidedrawsonyouthdevelopmentprinciplesandtheunderlyingresearchtohelpafterschoolprogramleadersandstaffanswertwofundamentalquestionstheyfaceastheydesignandimplementafterschoolprograms:
1. Whatexperiencescanweprovideforyoungpeopleinourafterschoolprogramsthatwillhavethegreatestpositiveimpactontheirlivesandcontributetosuccessfullearning?
2. Whatpracticescanweuseinourafterschoolprogramstocreateenvironmentsthatprovidetheseexperiences?
WhyNow?TherearemanyreasonswhywethoughtthatnowisagoodtimetoupdatetheoriginalYouthDevelopmentGuide.Someofthesereasonsarediscussedbelow.
• Socio-politicalContext:Wecurrentlyliveindivisiveandviolenttimes.Thisismarkedbyharshrhetoricandaggressivepoliciestargetingimmigrants,peopleofcolor,theLGBTQcommunity,andMuslims.Thenewsisalsofilledwithreportingonmassshootingstargetingmusicvenuesandschoolcampuses,aswellasescalatinggunviolenceinmanyofourcities.Thus,itismoreimportantthaneverthatweintentionallyofferpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesforourparticipants.
• AfterschoolStandards,YouthWorkerCompetencies,andProgramQualityTools:
Manystatesandafterschoolorganizationshavedevelopedandpublishedstandards,youthworkercompetencies,andqualitytoolsforafterschoolprograms.Theseareveryusefulasreflectionandself-assessmenttools,andinsupportingtheworkofprogramimprovement.Allofthesearebasedonandwellalignedwithyouthdevelopmentpractices.
• NewConcepts,Trends,andFrameworks:Therearemanynewconcepts,trends,andframeworksthatarenowembracedbytheafterschoolfield.Theseincludesocialemotionallearning,growthmindsets,workforceskills,andothers.ThesearediscussedingreaterdetailinChapter3.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
9
HowthisGuideisStructuredChapters1and2provideabriefhistoryleadingtotheyouthdevelopmentapproachandoffersanoverviewofyouthdevelopment.Chapter3listsanddescribesrecenttrends,concepts,andframeworksinafterschoolthatalignwiththeyouthdevelopmentapproach.Chapters4-8offerguidanceonhowtoimplementfivekeyyouthdevelopmentpractices,whicharecrucialtopromotingyoungpeople’shealthydevelopmentandcreatingsuccessfullearningenvironments:
• Promotingasenseofphysicalandemotionalsafety;• Encouragingrelationshipbuilding;• Fosteringmeaningfulyouthparticipation;• Providingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvement;• Creatingchallengingandengaginglearningexperiencesthathelpparticipantsbuild
skills.WhiletheoriginalYouthDevelopmentGuidepublishedbyCNYD(2001)includedanextensiveresourcesection,wehavedecidedtolimitthissectiontoincludeonlyimportantwebsites.Thisdecisionisbasedon:
• Thereisanabundanceofnewliterature,research,andreportsbeingpublishednearlyeveryweek.Thus,anyextensivelistingofresourceswouldbequicklyoutdated.
• Today’sinternetsearchenginesofferanuptodatelistofresourcesbysimplyenteringrelevantkeywords.
• WehavecitedanumberoforganizationsandwebsiteswithinthetextoftheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0andChapter9.
ThisGuideisjustanintroduction.Ongoinglearningandassessmentarevitaltothesuccessofanyafterschoolprogram.Westronglyurgeyoutoutilizethisguideasastartingpointandtodeepenyourunderstandingoftheyouthdevelopmentapproachwhileprovidingyourstaffwithengagingtrainingopportunities.
WhattheGuideisNotThisGuideisnotmeanttopresentaprescriptivesystemthattellsyouexactlyhowyourprogrammustbestructuredinordertobesuccessful.Therearemanydifferentroutestosuccessforyoungpeopleandprogramsalike;andindividualyoungpeopleindifferentcommunitieswillhavedifferentstrengthsandneeds.Rather,regardlessofprogramdesignorcontent,thisapproachhelpskeepthefocusonthedevelopmentaloutcomeswewantforyoungpeopleandthekeyexperienceswecanprovidetohelpthemreachthoseoutcomes.
10
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
11
THEYOUTHDEVELOPMENTAPPROACH
ABOUTTHEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
APPROACH
AbriefhistoryofyouthandafterschoolprogramsinAmericaleadinguptotheyouthdevelopmentapproach
Chapter
1
12
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
13
FromChildLabortoYouthProgramsandthe
YouthDevelopmentApproach
AnEarlyHistoryofYouthProgramsandAfterschoolTounderstandthehistoryofafterschoolandyouthprogramsinAmerica,itisusefultoconsidertheseismicchangesinAmericanculturethatservedasthepreconditionsfortheafterschoolmovement.Thesechangesweretheresultoftheindustrialrevolutionbetween1880and1920.Thisresultedinheavymigrationoffamiliestobigcitiesinsearchofworkinthenewfactories,alargenumberofnewimmigrantsthatprovidedalaborpoolforthecountry’sgrowthandtheuseofchildlabor.By1938,mostofthestatesoutlawedchildlaborandrequiredthatchildrenattendschool,whichresultedinthedevelopmentofthepublicschoolsystem.Thiscreatedanewdilemma:thelargenumberofunsupervisedyoungpeopleintheafternoonshoursandearlyevenings.
Thisgaverisetoagrowingnumberofyouthprogramstoserveunsupervisedyouth.Itisimportanttonotethattheearlyyouthprogramsemergedasareactiontoasocietalchallenge.Thisreactivetendencycontinuedasafterschoolprogramschangedaccordingtothechallengesofthedayandthepursuitoffunding.Duringthegreatdepression,youthprogramsfocusedonhunger.DuringWWII,aswomenpouredintotheworkforce,thefocuswaschildcare.Inthedecadesthatfollowed,programsfocusedonpreventingproblemssuchasteendelinquency,teenviolence,alcoholanddruguse,pregnancy,andlaterschoolfailure.
14
TheDeficitApproach
Thedeficitapproachcalledforinterveningwhenyoungpeopleexhibitedproblems,orforidentifyingthoseyoungpeople“atrisk”forproblemsandtryingtopreventthemfromengaginginspecificnegativebehaviors.Thisnarrowfocusonyoungpeople’sdeficitsandspecificproblembehaviorsledtothecreationofayouthservicessystemthatwaslargelyfragmented.Categoricalfundingoftendictatedthatprogramsbenarrowlyfocusedinordertofitwithinspecificfundingcategories.Theresultwasasystemcomprisedofmanysingleprogramsfocusedonisolatedproblems:oneprogramfocusedonpreventingdrugabuse,whileanotherfocusedonreducingteenpregnancyrates,andyetanothersoughttoreduceviolenceamongadolescents.
ResiliencyDuringtheearly1990sexpertspromotedtheterm“resiliency”whichisthecapacitytoadapt,navigateandbouncebackfromadverseandchallenginglifeexperiences.Researchersandpractitionersalikeclamoredoverstrategiestobuildmoreresilientyouth.Thismarkedamovefromadeficitapproachthatfocusedonpreventingyouthproblemstoanassetapproach,whichfocusedontheresiliencyandyoungpeople’sassets.Thus,youthprogramsshiftedtheirattentiontoaddressingyoungpeople’sdevelopmentalneedsandsupportedtheirgrowthtohealthyadulthood.Thisbecameknownastheyouthdevelopmentapproach.Bythemid-1990s,theyouthdevelopmentmovementwasincreasinglyinfluencingpolicynationwide.Policymakersbeganbreakingdownthebarriersofcategoricalfundingandallocatingresourcestosupportcollaborativeeffortsbetweencommunitybasedorganizationsandotherpartsoftheyouthservingsystem.
FederalpublicagenciessuchastheDepartmentofHealthandHumanServicesandtheOfficeofJuvenileJusticeandDelinquencyPreventionbeganembracingtheapproachandshiftedresearchandprogramdollarstowardcommunitysupportsforyouthdevelopment.Evenhistoricallyrisk-focusedfederaleffortssuchastheCenterforSubstanceAbusePreventionandSafeandDrug-FreeSchoolsandCommunitiesrespondedtothecompellingresearchonresilienceandthepressurefrompractitionerstoimplementamorepositive—andeffectiveapproach.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
15
Atthestatelevel,agenciesbeganshiftingfromstrictlycategoricalfundingtosupportingbroaderbasedyouthdevelopmentefforts.Privatefundersincreasinglyrecognizedthevalueoftakingayouthdevelopmentapproach.Public-privatefundingpartnershipsworkedtosupportyouthandfamilyfocusedpoliciesandfundingstrategies.Thiskindofsystem-levelchangenotonlyhelpedexistingneighborhoodyouthorganizationsexpandtheirsupportforyoungpeople,butalsofosteredthecreationofnumerousbroad-based,collaborativeyouthdevelopmenteffortsinlocalcommunitiesacrossthecountry.
TheGrowthofSchool-BasedAfterschoolProgramsAmidthispolicyshift,publicconcerncontinuedtogrowaboutyouthviolenceandotherdangers.Addedtotheseconcernswasgrowingpublicconcernoverperceivedwidespreadacademicunder-achievement.Theseconcernsledtoasurgeoffundingfromfederal,stateandlocalsourcesforthedevelopmentofschool-basedafterschoolprograms.
Atthefederallevel,inFY2000,theU.S.DepartmentofEducationlaunchedthe21stCenturyCommunityLearningCenters(21stCCLC)initiativetoschoolsnationwidetoimproveacademicachievementandstrengthencommunitysupportsforyoungpeople.Today,Congressappropriates$1.2billiontothisinitiative,intheformofstateblockgrants,enablingstatestocreateschool-based“learningcenters”.
16
InCalifornia,avoterinitiative,Proposition49(passedin2002),requiredtheCaliforniaDepartmentofEducationallocateover$550millioneachyeartofundnearly1,000school-basedafterschoolprogramsacrossthestate.TheseprogramsaredesignedtoimprovestudentperformanceinschoolandprovidesafeenvironmentsafterschoolforstudentsingradesK-8.Later,legislationrequiredthatCaliforniaallocate½ofits21stCCLCfundsforafterschoolprogramsinpublichighschools.
Atthelocallevel,publicfundswereincreasinglydevotedtocity-wideandcommunity-wideafterschoolinitiatives.Manycitiesbeganestablishingprotectedfundingpools,throughtaxesorothermeans,specificallydesignedtosupportyouthdevelopmentefforts.Citiesandschooldistrictsbegantoseethegrowthofpublic-privatepartnershipsdesignedtosupportyoungpeople’shealthydevelopment.
Youthdevelopmenttheoryandpracticecanserveasabridgebetweenschoolandcommunity-basedefforts.Becauseyouthdevelopmentfocusesonfundamentalexperiencesthatfosterbothlearningandbroaderhealthydevelopment,thisapproachiswellsuitedtoaddressthetwingoalsofnewlycreatedschool-basedafterschoolprograms.
WhatDoWeCallIt?Whatdowecallthelearningtimeoutsideoftheclassroom?Thistimeisknownas“afterschool”,or“after-school”,“out-of-schooltime”(OST),“expandedlearningopportunities(ELO)”,or“expandedlearningtime”(ELT).Formanyyears,theprogrammingthattookplaceoutsideofthetraditionalschooldaywascalled“afterschool”.Inhis2002essay,ADifferentKindofChildDevelopmentInstitution:TheHistoryofAfter-SchoolProgramsforLow-IncomeYouth,RobertHalpernrichlydescribesthehistoricalrolethatafterschoolprogramshaveplayedandhowtheyemergedasearlyastheturnofthe19thCentury.Theterm“afterschool”remainedcommonuntilthe1980s.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
17
Theterm“outofschoollearning”wasfirstcoinedinthelate1980sbyaneducationalpsychologistforwhomthetermmeant“curricularandnon-curricularlearningthattakesplaceoutsideoftheschoolenvironment.”Thefieldofyouthdevelopmentadoptedtheterminthelate1990s,early2000sas“outofschooltime”(OST)aroundthetimeofthepassingoftheNoChildLeftBehind(NCLB)Act,whichprovidedfundingforcreationof21stCenturyLearningCenters(21stCCLC).Theterm“expandedlearningtime”(ELT)tookoffinthemid-2000swithfundingtosupporttheredesignoftheschooldayorschoolyeartoprovidestudents,especiallythoseincommunitiesthatareimpactedbysystemicpoverty,withmoreandbetterlearningtime.Itisoftenacoreelementofschoolturn-aroundefforts.ELTdiffersfromafter-schoolprogramsorexpandedlearningopportunities(ELOs)becauseELTrequiresallstudentsatagivenschooltoattendthelongerdayand/oryear,andtheadditionaltimebecomesadependentcomponentoftheschool’seducationalpracticesandobjectives.Youth-servingorganizationsoftensupplementthe3-6hoursorsummerschoolwithprogrammingandactivitiesthatuseapositiveyouthdevelopmentapproachandarebasedinplayfullearningorsocialemotionallearning(SEL).
TheYouthDevelopmentApproach
Tosummarize,theyouthdevelopmentapproachdrawsonasubstantialbodyofresearchaboutyoungpeople’sdevelopmentalneedsandtherolethattheenvironmentplaysinyoungpeople’slivesastheymovethroughchildhoodandtowardadulthood.Italsodrawsonyearsofevidencefromthefieldabout“whatworks”increatingenvironmentsthatpromoteyoungpeople’shealthydevelopmentandlearning.Thekeyyouthdevelopmentprinciplesandpracticesoutlinedinthisguidecanbeusedtomeasureprogrameffectiveness,andprovideclearstandardstowhichwecanholdourprogramsaccountable.
Theseprinciplesandpracticescanbeappliedtoallafterschoolprograms—regardlessoftheprogram’scontent;theyareequallyapplicabletoprogramsfocusedonboostingacademicachievement,astheyaretosportsandrecreationprogramsortoprogramspromotingcommunityservice.Ayouthdevelopmentapproachhelpsunifyallofusaroundthehealthylongtermoutcomeswewantforyoungpeopleandourcontributionsalongtheway.
18
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
19
FRAMEWORKFORYOUTHDEVELOPMENT
INTRODUCINGA
FRAMEWORKFOR
YOUTHDEVELOPMENT
Chapter
2
20
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
21
AFrameworkforYouthDevelopmentTheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0isbasedupontheyouthdevelopmentframeworkcreatedbyresearchers,JamesConnellandMichelleGambone,whichisdescribedindetailbelow.Drawingonourunderstandingofthefundamentalideasunderlyingtheyouthdevelopmentapproach,wecannowbegintolookmorecloselyatthekindsofexperienceswecanofferyoungpeopleinafterschoolprogramstohelpthemlearnandgrow.WhyaFramework?Thereareseveralwaysthataframeworkisuseful.Tobegin,itsummarizesexistingknowledgeandhelpsusbycreatingacommonlanguage.
Aframeworkalsogivesdirectionandpurposetoaprogram.Knowingtheimportantcomponentsofhealthydevelopmentcanhelpguidestaffandvolunteerstowardprogrammingintendedtoachievespecificpositiveoutcomes.Aframeworkcanhelpprovidedirectionforprogramevaluation,aswell,toidentifyitemsonwhichanevaluationcanfocus.Finally,aframeworkwhichisvalidatedandaccuratecanidentifymoreclearlywhatthelongtermoutcomesarethatyouthdevelopmentprogramsarehelpingtocreate.Itisimportanttonotethatthereareanumberofframeworksforyouthdevelopment.ArecentframeworkistheFoundationsforYoungAdultSuccess,developedbytheUChicagoConsortiumonSchoolResearch,whichincorporatesmanyoftherecenttrendsinafterschoolandyouthdevelopment.)
EarlyAdultOutcomes
Beforewebeginthinkingspecificallyabouthowbesttosupporttheyoungpeoplewhoparticipateinafterschoolprograms,weneedtohaveavisionofwhatwewantallyoungpeopletolearnandmasterbythetimetheyreachearlyadulthood.Inotherwords,weneedtoknowwherewewanttogoinordertoknowhowbesttogetthere.Atraditionaldeficitapproachmightdefinedesiredoutcomesforyoungpeopleintermsoftheavoidance,orreductionof,specificproblembehavior:forexample,youngpeopledon’tdropoutofschool,don’tcommitcrimes,orrefrainfromabusingdrugs.Asdescribedintheprecedingchapter,theyouthdevelopmentapproachsetspositiveoutcomes,notonlytheavoidanceof
22
problems,asourgoalforyoungpeople.Fromayouthdevelopmentapproachtheoverallgoalishealthydevelopment,butwhatdoesthismean?Onewaytodefinehealthydevelopmentisintermsofwhatwewantyoungpeopletobeabletodoastheyenterearlyadulthood.Thesedesiredachievementsaregroupedinthreebroadcategories:
• EconomicSelf-Sufficiency:allyouthshouldexpectasadultstobeabletosupportthemselvesandtheirfamilies,andtohavesomeresourcesbeyondbasicsurvivalneeds.Theyshouldhavedecentjobsandtheeducationoraccesstoeducationtoimproveorchangejobs.
• Healthy Family and Social Relationships: young people should grow up to bephysically andmentally healthy, be supportiveparents if theyhave children, andhavepositivefamilyandfriendshipnetworks.
• ContributingtoCommunity:Thiscantakemanyforms,butwehopethatouryoungpeoplewilllooktodomorethanbetaxpayersandlaw-abiders—tocontributeatalevelwheretheygivesomethingbacktotheircommunity,howevertheydefinetheircommunity.
Inotherwords,wewantyoungpeopletohavedecentjobs,goodrelationships,andplaypositiverolesintheircommunities.Thesearetheearlyadultoutcomeswewantforyoungpeople.Thisisnotanexhaustivelist;ratheritisoneattempttobroadlycategorizewhat,ataminimum,wehopeallyoungpeoplewillattain.Itisclearthatoneafterschoolprogramcannotberesponsibleforyoungpeopleachievingallthesegoals.But,knowingwherewewanttoendup—thelongtermoutcomesweultimatelywantforyoungpeople—canhelpdeterminethepathwetaketogetthereandhelpusassessanafterschoolprogram’scontributionsalongtheway.Withthisinmind,itisimportantthat—earlyonintheplanningprocess—afterschoolpartnershipspulltogetherthediversestakeholdersinvolvedandbuildconsensusaroundthecommunity’sdesiredoutcomesforyoungpeople.
DevelopmentalYouthOutcomesOnewaytounderstandhowafterschoolprogramscancontributetotheselong-termoutcomesforyoungpeopleistoconsiderwhatyoungpeopleneedtolearnatdifferentagesanddevelopmentalstagestoimprovetheirchancesofachievingtheselongtermoutcomes.Thesearedevelopmentaloutcomes—theymeasureyoungpeople’sdevelopmentalprogresstowardmeetingthechallengesofadulthood.Theyincludelearningto:
• BeProductive:toengagepositivelyanddowellinschool,tousetheirsparetimewellandtakecareoftheirbasicneeds;
• ToBeConnected:toformattachmentsandhavesupportiverelationshipswithadultsandpeers,toidentifywithalargercommunity;
• ToNavigate:throughdifferentsettings,situationsandchallenges;thistaskencompasseslearninghowtomove:
o Amongtheirmultipleworlds—peergroups,families,schools,neighborhoods—eachofwhichmayrequiredifferentbehaviorandevenlanguage;behavinginwaysthatareappropriatetothesetting;
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
23
o Aroundthepressuretoengageinunhealthyandriskybehaviors;o Throughtheirowntransitions—forexamplethetransitionfrombeingtakencare
oftotakingcareofothers.
Anotherwaytothinkabouttheseoutcomesisastheintermediatemilestonesormarkersthatindicatethatyoungpeopleareonthepathtosuccessfulearlyadultoutcomes.Theseareobviouslyverybroadcategories,whichencompassawiderangeofaccomplishment,butwecanidentifyconcreteindicatorsofyoungpeople’sprogresstowardeachofthesedevelopmentaloutcomesatanyonepointintime.Youngpeople’sprogresstowardaccomplishingtheseoutcomescanbemeasuredatanystageofayoungperson’slife.Forasixthgrader,“learningtobeproductive”mightmeandoinghisorhermathhome-work.Foran18yearold,itmightmeanhavingapart-timejobordoingregularvolunteerwork.Thesedevelopmentaloutcomesareproductsofmultipleexperiencesinmanyenvironmentsovertime—inyoungpeople’shomes,schoolsandcommunities.
ExperiencesthatPromotePositiveYouthDevelopmentNowthatwehaveanideaoftheoutcomeswewantforyoungpeople,wecanbegintoexaminemorespecificallyhowwhatwedoinourafterschoolprogramscancontributetoyoungpeoplereachingtheseoutcomes.Inotherwords,wecanbegintoanswerthequestion:
Whatexperiencescanweprovideforyoungpeopleinafterschoolprogramsthatwillhavethegreatestpositiveimpactontheirlivesandcontributetosuccessfullearning?
24
Resiliencyresearchaboutyoungpeople’sprocessofdevelopmentoffersimportantinsights.Fromtheseresearchfindings,aswellaspractitioners’knowledgeinthefield,wecancreateafairlyshortlistofthekindsofkeyexperiencesthatyoungpeopleneedinallsettingsinordertodevelopintohealthyadults.Infact,youngpeople’sneedfortheseexperiencesissostrongthattheywillseekthemoutwhetherweprovidethemornot.
Foryoungpeoplewhodonothaveaccesstoexperiencesthatpromotepositiveyouthdevelopment,wemayseethemseekingtheseexperiencesintroublingways:lookingforchallengeinwaysthatputthematrisk,belongingtogangs,orseekingsafetythroughviolence.Clearly,afterschoolprogramscanprovidethesepositiveexperiences.Theycanofferyoungpeoplethechancetoformstrongrelationshipswithadultsandpeers,andprovidechallenginglearningexperiencesandavarietyofopportunitiesforyoungpeopleto“testtheirwings”inasafesetting.Thesearetheexperiencesthatallowyoungpeopletolearnandsucceed.Fromayouthdevelopmentperspective,providingtheseexperiencesforyoungpeopleiscritical—regardlessofaprogram’sspecificcontent.Inaddition,meetingyoungpeople’sbasicneedsfortheseexperienceswillhelptoensurethattheyfeelinvestedandengagedinyourafterschoolprogram.Theseexperiencesaredescribedintheboxbelow.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
25
OrganizationalPracticesThatHelpAfterschoolPrograms
SupportYoungPeopleItisworththinkingaboutwhatprogramsneed—atanorganizationallevel—inordertosucceedinprovidingyoungpeoplewiththekindsofexperienceswehavedescribed.Whatcanwe,asprogramleadersandplanners,dotodesignafterschoolprogramstoensurethattheyofferparticipantstheexperiencesdescribedabove?Forexample,howcanwesetupprogramssothatyoungpeoplehavethechancetoreallygettoknowadultsandviceversa?Howcanwehelpensurethatprogramsofferarangeofdiverseactivitieswhichareinterestingtoyoungprogramparticipants?
26
TheContinuumofSupport:AFinalReminder
Itisimportantforeveryonetorememberthatafterschoolprograms,nomatterhoweffective,cannotprovideeverythingthatyoungpeopleneedforsuccess.Justaspolicymakershavebeguntorecognizethatschoolscannot“doitall,”somustweacknowledgethatneithercanafterschoolprograms.Afterschoolprogramscanmakeimportantcontributionstoyoungpeople’shealthydevelopment,butyoungpeoplehavethebestchanceforsuccesswhentheyexperiencethesupportsandopportunitieswedescribeacrossmanydifferentsettings:intheirfamilies,inschools,afterschoolprogramsandintheircommunities.Theentirecommunityisresponsibleforpreparingyoungpeopletosucceedinearlyadulthood.
Source:FoundationsforYoungAdultSuccess,UChicagoCCSR
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
27
NEWTRENDS
RECENTADVANCESIN
AFTERSCHOOLTHAT
ALIGNWITHYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
PRINCIPLES
Recenttrends,concepts,andframeworksforafterschoolprograms.
Chapter
3
28
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
29
RecentTrends,Concepts,andFrameworksInthischapter,weintroduceyoutosomeafterschooltrends,concepts,andimportanttermsthathaveemergedsincetheoriginalYouthDevelopmentGuideforAfterschoolwaspublished.Whenreviewingeachofthese,askyourself,“howdoesthistrendorconceptalignwiththeyouthdevelopmentframeworkdiscussedinthisguide?”Wealsodisplayanumberofrelatedframeworksandgraphics.Frameworksaredesignedtoprovidefoundationalinformationaboutaconcept,systemoridea.Theyoftenserveasaroadmap,allowingustointentionallydesignprogramming,establishandnurtureeffectivepartnerships,hirestaff,assesseffectivenessandensureprogramquality.Frameworksmaybedevelopedatthelocal,stateornationallevel.TheDevelopmentalFrameworkforYoungAdultSuccessWhilethisguideisbasedontheyouthdevelopmentframeworkcreatedbyresearchers,JamesConnellandMichelleGambone,amorerecentframework(seebelow)wasissuedbyUniversityofChicagoConsortiumonChicagoSchoolResearch(UChicagoCCSR).Itoutlinesthe“ingredients”necessaryforyoungpeopletosucceed.Thisframeworkcullsfromthebestof“researchevidence,theory,expertopinion,andpracticewisdomintheserviceofidentifyingthebroadrangeoffactorscriticalforyoungadultsuccess”.
QualityStandardsforAfterschoolQualitystandardshavebeendevelopedbyorganizationsatthelocal,state,andnationallevels.Thepurposeofqualitystandardsistodescribetheattributesofaqualityafterschoolprogram.Forexample,theCaliforniaQualityStandardsforExpanded
30
LearningPrograms(http://bit.ly/CalQSELP)isdividedintopoint-of-serviceandprogrammatic(ororganizational)standards.Theyalignwellwithyouthdevelopmentframeworksandotherprogramqualitystandards.Thepoint-of-servicestandardsincludesafeandsupportiveenvironment,activeandengagedlearning,skillbuilding,youthvoiceandleadership,healthychoicesandbehaviors,anddiversity,accessandequity.LearninginAfterschool&SummerLearningPrinciples
(www.learninginafterschool.org)TheLearninginAfterschool&Summer(LIAS)Projectisaneffortbyafterschooladvocatesandleaderstounifythefieldofafterschoolandfocusthemovementonpromotingyoungpeople’slearning.Whatthisprojecttriestodoisfocusnotonwhatyoungpeopleshouldlearn,ratherfocusonthehow-programapproachesthatpromotelearning.Youwillnoticethattheexemplarafterschoolprograms-theonesthatarethedarlingsoftheafterschoolmovement-areallexceptionalinhowtheypromoteyoungpeople’sexcitementinlearning.Thesameistrueofthoseexceptionaleducatorswhoarenamedasteachersoftheyearinlocal,state,andnationalceremonies.Whatwehearmostabouttheseacclaimedclassroomteachersaretheirabilitiestomotivateandexciteyoungpeopleinlearning.Butsomehowwebypasstheprinciplesthattheyapplyinpractice.TheLIASprojectaimstofocusourattentionandpracticeonafewlearningprinciples:Learningactivitiesshouldbe1)Active;2)Collaborative;3)Meaningful;4)Supportsmastery;and5)Expandshorizons.
SocialEmotionalLearning(SEL)(www.casel.org)Oneofthethingsthathasoftendistinguishedthefieldofyouthdevelopment,out-of-schooltimeandafterschoolfromthetraditionalschoolday,hasbeenthewaysprogramminginherentlysupportsyoungpeople’ssocialandemotionaldevelopment.TheSELframeworkcontainsfivecompetenciesforthedevelopmentofSEL.CASEL(www.casel.org)definesSELas:theprocessthroughwhichchildrenandadultsacquireandeffectivelyapplytheknowledge,attitudes,andskillsnecessarytounderstandand
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
31
manageemotions,setandachievepositivegoals,feelandshowempathyforothers,establishandmaintainpositiverelationships,andmakeresponsibledecisions.Thecompetenciesare:Self-awareness,Self-management,ResponsibleDecisionMaking,RelationshipSkillsandSocialAwareness.
Whathaschangedinrecentyearsisthewaystheschooldistrictsandyouthprogramshavebeguntoorganizetheirstrategicplanning,budgeting,curriculumandstaffingtointentionallyintegrateSELcurriculum.Theyhavecometorealizethecompetenciesinthisframeworkareessentialtonotonlysuccessinschool,butinlifeandintheworkplace.
EmployabilitySkillsTheOfficeofCareer,Technical,andAdultEducation(OCTAE)developedanemployabilityskillsframeworkdesignedtooutlinetheskillsandqualitiesrequiredforthoseenteringthe21stCenturyworkforce.Thisframeworkhelpsout-of-schooltimeprofessionalsdesignandimplementworkforcedevelopmentprogrammingandactivitiesthatprepareyoungadultsforvariouscareers.Theframeworkisdividedintothreemaindomains:AppliedKnowledge,WorkplaceSkillsandEffectiveRelationships,withmicrocategoriesineachofthedomains.Evidence
32
showswhattheprogrammingafterschoolandOSTprogramsdotosupportanddevelopparticipantsSELenhancestheirreadinessfortheworkplace.WhenthisframeworkandtheCASEL’sSELframeworkareplacedsidebyside,aswasdoneinareportbyBeyondtheBell,AmericanInstituteforResearchthereisalotofoverlap,whichbuildsastrongcaseforintentionallyintegratingprogrammingthatsupportsSELaspartofaneffectiveworkforcedevelopmentcurriculum.TheU.S.DepartmentofEducationcompiledtheEmployabilitySkillsFrameworkhasdevelopedrelatedtools,mediaandresourcesavailabletoOSTprograms.
CharacterBuilding(www.character.org)Attheheartofayoungperson’sdevelopmentandeducationischaracterbuilding.Essentialtothesuccessofademocraticsociety,“educatingforcharacter”buildscivicvirtue,compliancewithlaws,respectfortherightsofothers,andconcernforthecommongood.Morebroadlyexplained,charactereducationisaboutpromotingmoralvirtues(honesty,compassion,empathy,andtrustworthiness)andperformancevirtues(effort,diligence,andperseverance).Charactereducationisaboutdoingtherightthingandthebestworkpossible.Afterschoolprogramsareperfectlypositionedtopromotecharacterbuildingbyexplicitlycommunicatingandmodelingvaluesandofferingactivitiesthatpromotecharacterbuilding.YouthActivismAndCivicEngagementAccordingtoChildrenInternational,“youthcivicengagementactivitiesandprogramsarecriticalforempoweringyoungpeopletodeveloptheirskillsandtalents;participateinpolitical,economicandsocialconversations;andbecomeagentsofpositivechangeintheircommunities”.Wealsoknowthatsupportingyouthineffortstobeactiveandcivicallyengagedpromotestheirsenseof“agency”,areimportantcomponentsoftraumainformedpractice,andhelpsthemacquirevaluableknowledgeandexperiences.Activitiesrangefromhelpingotherswithintheafterschoolprogram(readingbuddies,tutoringandmentoring,etc.)toeffortstoimprovethelocalcommunitytoorganizingactivitiestoadvocatefortheirviewsonsocialissues.
ExpandedLearning:360°/365
(www.expandedlearning360-365.com)Expandedlearning:360°/365isacollaborativeprojectdedicatedtopromotingthedevelopmentofcriticalskillsbeyondacademicsthatresearchhasidentifiedasessentialtoyoungpeople’ssuccessinschool,work,andlife.TheExpandedLearning:360°/365projectpartnershavedesignedanumberofsupportsforeducatorsandleadersofexpandedlearningprograms.Thisprojectisbasedontwostronglyheldbeliefs:
• 360°–Inorderforchildrentogrowintohealthyandproductivecitizens,theymustlearnandpracticeawidevarietyofinter-relatedskills–social-emotional,characteraswellasacademic;
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
33
• 365–Childrenlearninavarietyofsettingsandyear-round.Thisincludesformalsettings,suchasschool,andinformalsettings,suchasafterschool,extracurricular,andsummeryouthprograms.
21stCenturySkills
(www.p21.org)ThePartnershipfor21stCenturySkillsworkedwitheducators,businessesandinstitutionsofhighereducationtoidentifythe“skills,knowledgeandexpertisestudentsshouldmastertosucceedinworkandlifeinthe21stcentury”andcameupwiththeframeworktotheright.Itoutlinestheoutcomesdesiredandthesupportsystemsnecessarytoeffectivelymeetthoseoutcomes.These21stCenturySkillscan,andshouldbepartofanyapprenticeshipprogrammingandorganizationthatseekstoalignwiththeemployabilityframework.AfterschoolprogramsarewellpositionedtohelpfostertheLearning&Innovationskills(whichincludescriticalthinking,collaboration,creativityandcommunication)andtheLifeandCareerSkills(suchasflexibility,adaptability,initiative,andself-direction,tonameafew).Afterschoolprogramswoulddowelltopartnerwithschoolsanddistrictsondevelopingthese21stcenturyskills.Theseskillsmapbacktotheotherframeworkswe’vediscussed,aswellastheyouthdevelopmentframework.
34
WorkforceDevelopment:ApprenticeshipsOthereffortshaveemergedwhichoftenalignwithorcanbeutilizedtoaddressqualitystandards,supportSELoralignwithworkforceskillsdevelopment.Forexample,thereiscurrentlyastronginterestin,aswellasstateandfederaldollarsavailabletodeveloppre-apprenticeshipandapprenticeshipprogramming.Forthoseworkingwithmiddleschoolagedyouth,apre-apprenticeshipmayfocusonexposuretoawiderangeofcareersandworkforce-relatedskills(sometimescalled21stCenturySkills)suchasteamwork,collaborationandcommunication.Anapprenticeshipoftencoupleson-the-jobtrainingwithsometypeofaccompanyingstudy(classroomworkandreading)andacertificateorcredential.Forindustrieslookingtodiversifytheirworkforce(thinkGreenEnergy)anapprenticeshipcanconnectyoungpeopletoacareerpathorpipelinetowhichtheymaynottypicallyhaveaccess.Apprenticeshipsrequirestrongpartnerships,includingwithcredential-bearingentitiesandmaystrengthenorcomplementyourcurrentworkforceprogramming.
DigitalBadges(www.centerfordigitalbadges.com)Digitalbadgesemergedinthemid-2000sasawayforyoungpeopletoshowcasetheiraccomplishmentsbothinandoutofschool.Whiledigitalbadgesemergedfromthegamingindustrytoreward/awardaccomplishments,theyaresimilarinconcepttothetypesofbadgesyouthintheBoyandGirlScoutsearneduponsuccessfullydemonstratingaskillorcharacteristic.Digitalbadgingissometimesconsidereda“micro-credential”andcanbeincorporatedintopre-apprenticeship,apprenticeshipandworkforcedevelopmentprogramming,aswellascollegepreparationprogramming.Itcanbealow-costadditiontoaprogramasmanyoftheresourcesarefree.Aprogramcancreatetheirowndigitalbadgingcurriculumorcanutilizeopen-sourcecurriculum.OnesuchplatformisBadgrhttps://badgr.com.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
35
Source:CenterforDigitalBadges
Bullying(www.stopbullying.gov)Bullying,whichoftentakesplacebetweenschool-agedchildreniswhensomeoneusestheirpoweroversomeoneelsetointimidateorcauseemotionalorphysicalharm.Bullyingnolongertakesplaceonlyontheschoolyard,intheschoolcafeteriaorontheschoolbus.Withmorechildrenandyouth(atyoungerandyoungerages)havingaccesstoonlinetechnology,includingandespeciallysocialmedia(Facebook,Instagram,SnapchatandTwitter)weareseeingtheemergenceandprevalenceofcyber-bullying.Cyber-bullyingistheuseofelectroniccommunicationtobullyaperson,typicallybysendingmessagesofanintimidatingorthreateningnature.Bullyinghasanegativeimpactonone’ssocialandemotionaldevelopmentandcansometimeshavedireconsequences,includingsuicide.Afterschoolprogramscanuseayouthdevelopmentapproachtohelpensureasafeenvironmentandfosterpositiverelationshipsbetweenchildrenandtheirpeersandchildrenandadults.Theycanestablishclear,fairandhighexpectationsabouthowpeopleintheprogramtreateachother.Andtheycancreateopportunitieswherechildrenandyoutharelearningtonavigateandexploretheirownpower;wheretheyareconnectingtopositiverolemodelsandproductivelyworkingthroughdifferencesbylearningaboutrespect,effectivecommunication,problemsolvingandconflictresolution.OrganizationslikeNoBullyprovidecurriculumandtoolsforschools,especially,tohelpstaffreduceandaddressbullying.CommonSenseMediaalsoprovidesresourcesinmedialiteracy,whichcanhelpdiminishcyber-bullying.
ServiceLearningServiceLearningtakestheideaofcommunityservice(thinkcleaninganabandonedlotorcreatingacommunitygarden,readingtoseniorsorchildren),andaddstoitacademics,assessment,andreflectiontypicallyseeninproject-basedlearning(PBL).TheCorporationforNationalServiceLearningisafederalagencythatleadsservice,volunteering,andgrant-makingeffortsintheUnitedStates.TheyoverseemanyprogramsyoumaybefamiliarwithincludingAmeriCorps,SeniorCorps,theSocialInnovationFund,andtheVolunteerGenerationFund.Servicelearningisappropriateforallages,thoughmostlyseenintegratedintomiddleandhighschoolafterschoolandsummerprograms.
36
ServiceLearningeffectivelyaddressesallthreeprinciplesofpositiveyouthdevelopment(relationships,expectationsandopportunities)aswellasthefiveLIASprinciplesforqualityafterschoolprograms.Muchofthefundingisdependentonvariouspoliticalfactorsandcomeswithrigorousexpectations.STEMandSTEAMSTEMstandsforScience,TechnologyEngineeringandMath.Inthemid2000’san“A”wasaddedfor“Arts”toaccountfortheimportanceofcreativityinaninterdisciplinaryapproach.AnimportantpremisebehindSTEMorSTEAMisthatinsteadofteachingdisciplinesinindependentsubjectsilos,lessonsarewellrounded,projectandinquirybased,withafocusoninterdisciplinarylearning.STEMactivitiessupportthedevelopmentof4C’sthathavebeenidentifiedaskeyina21stcenturyworkforce:Creativity,Collaboration,CriticalThinking,andCommunication.ProgramsthatofferSTEM&STEAMprogramming(inotherwords,thatintentionallyseekoutandintegratescience,technology,engineeringandmathintotheiractivities,notjustofferingaroboticsclub,forexample)cultivatestudents’interestinSTEMandSTEM-basedcareers,andbuildSTEMskillsandproficiencies.InSTEMinAfterschool:ChangingPerspectives.ShapingLives.,itisdocumentedthatafterschoolprogramscanplayamajorroleinsustainingyouths’interests,buildingrealskills,helpingyouthconnectSTEMtotheirlivesandcommunities,andintroducingyouthtoadiversearrayofprofessionals.STEMcaneffectivelyincorporateallfivetheLIASlearningprinciples.OneofthebiggestchallengeswithintegratingSTEMislackofqualifiedandconfidentafterschoolstaff.Whenconsideringintegratingthistrendmakesureyou’veconsideredstaff’sskillandinterestinSTEM/STEAM,andmakesureyouallocatesufficienttimeforstafftolearnnewconceptsorskills,topracticeandtoshareamongeachother.ThisisanareawherepartneringwithotherorganizationsorhiringparttimeortemporaryexpertscanbeagoodwaytointegrateSTEM/STEAMintoyourafterschoolprogram.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
37
MindfulnessThereisagrowinginterestinresearchandpracticethatshowsthatmindfulnessisaveryusefultoolinyouthprogramsettings.Thereisnewinformationandgrowingevidencethatconfirmsthatmindfulnessexerciseswithinschoolandafterschoolsettingsareexcellentwaystopromotethehealthandwell-beingofadultstaffandincreaseimpulsecontrolandabilitytostayfocusedamongyouthwhoparticipateintheexercises.
TraumaInformedPracticesTraumaInformedPracticesiswhenanorganizationorindividualappliesaframeworkthatinvolvesunderstanding,recognizing,andrespondingtotheeffectsofalltypesoftrauma.Itincludespolicies,practicesandprotocolthatemphasizesphysical,psychologicalandemotionalsafetyforbothpatientsandproviders,andhelpssurvivorsoftraumarebuildasenseofcontrolandempowerment.Manypeoplehaveexperiencedsometypeoftraumaintheirlife.TheACES(AdverseChildhoodExperiences)studyofmorethan17,000participantsshowedadirectcorrelationbetweenadversechildhoodexperiencesandlongandshort-termhealthdisparities.
EquityandInclusionOut-of-schooltimeprogramsprovidebenefitstomillionsofchildrenandteensannually.ResearchshowsthatOSTprogramscanhelpdecreasethegapinopportunitiesbetweenchildrenfromresource-richfamiliesandcommunitiesandthosefromunder-resourcedcommunitiesandpoorfamilies.Nearlytwodecadesagoourfieldbeganlookingatissuesofequityandinclusionbyaskingthequestion:“Isafterschoolforall?”Whiletheevidence
38
pointstowardspositiveoutcomesforchildrenandteenswhoparticipateinhighqualityafterschoolprograms,notallchildrenandteenshaveaccesstotheseprograms.Andnotallprogramsimplementapedagogythatembracesfairtreatmentofallchildren.Theexplosionof21stCenturyLearningCommunitiesintheearly2000’sprovidedunprecedentedfundingforafterschoolprogramming.However,childrenfrompoorandruralcommunitiesdidn’talwayshaveaccesstotheseorotherafterschoolprograms.
Barrierstoaccessingafterschoolprogramsinclude:cost,geography/transportation,language(forchildrenofimmigrants,lengthyapplicationsthatarenotintheirnativelanguagecanbeoff-puttinganddiscourageparticipation),andschedulestonameafew.Anotherelementofequityisthetypesofactivitiesofferedwithinprograms.Forexample,accordingtotheForumforYouthInvestment,“theartsprograminalow-incomecommunityconsistsofbasicartsandcraftsactivities,whiletheartsprograminawealthycommunityprovidesopportunitiesforexploringanddevelopingspecificskillsinareassuchasceramics,dramaordrawing.”Also,therearefeweropportunitiesforolderyouththanyoungerones.Oncepartoftheseprograms,thephysicalandemotionalsafetyofparticipantsiscritical.AccordingtotheNationalInstituteonOut-of-SchoolTime,thismeansensuringthatprograms“activelyvalueandrespecttheidentitiesoftheyoungpeopleweserve,includingtheirrace,religion,ethnicity,gender,socioeconomicstatus,sexualorientation,appearance,andability.”ThesesixtipsfromJenniferSiacaCurrycanbefoundinherarticle:EquityandInclusionanActionAgendaforYouthDevelopmentProfessionalsfortheJournalAfterschoolMatters:
1. Buildapersonalunderstandingofourcountry’shistoryofoppression2. Adjustlanguagetoensureinclusivity3. Worktoeliminateimplicitbias4. Useculturallyresponsivepedagogy5. Addressidentity-basedbullying6. Recruitanddevelopstaffwhobuildandmaintainapositiveenvironmentforall
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
39
GrowthMindset(www.mindsetworks.com)PioneeredbyDr.CarolDweck,theconcept“growthmindset”challengesthewayswethinkabouthowpeoplelearnandintelligence.AfteryearsofresearchDweckconcludedthatchildrenwhowerepraisedforbeingsmart,tendedtohaveamore‘fixed’mindset,whereaschildrenwhowerepraisedforhardworkandeffortresultedinyouthbeingmorelikelytotakeon(academic)challengestheymayface,thereforeincreasingtheirabilitiesandachievement.So,whatdoesthismeanforafterschool?First,itmeansthatstaffcontinuetocultivatestrong,trustingrelationshipswiththeyouthintheirprogram,acoreelementofpositiveyouthdevelopment.Second,itmeansshiftingthewayadultsinteractwithyouthinlearning/teachingenvironmentsandtrainingstafftodeveloppracticesthatencourageagrowthmindset.UsingagrowthmindsetapproachfitswellasprogramsareseekingtointegrateconceptslikeS.T.E.M(Science,Technology,EngineeringandMath)intotheirafterschoolprograms.Somechildrenmaythinktheyaren’t“good”atscienceordon’tknowhowto“domathwell”,sotheymaynotseethemselvesascapableoreligibletoparticipateinS.T.E.Mrelatedactivities.Staffthatpromoteagrowthmindset,whichencouragesyouthtodevelopstrategiesforlearning,revising,andadapting,mayfindsomeyouthmorewillingtotakeon(greater)challengesandstepoutoftheircomfortzone.Tobesure,growthmindsetisn’tjust“good”forchildrenandyouth.Afterschoolprograms,canalsoemployagrowthmindsetamongstaff.Thiscouldincludeaskingquestionsduringaninterviewthatgetattheirphilosophyaboutlearning(others’andtheirown);anditmeansbeingintentionalaboutprovidingstaffwithprofessionaldevelopmentandtrainingtodevelopnewskillsandstrategies,allowingroomformistakes,revisionsandadjustmentsastheylearn.
GritWhileAngelaDuckworthbeganshapingherframeworkthatwouldlaterinfluenceherresearchon‘grit’in2007,thetermwouldn’thittheOSTfielduntiltheearlytwenty-teens.Duckworthdescribesgritasthe“perseveranceandpassionforlong-termgoals.”Gritcanbeconsideredanelementofsocialandemotionallearningandsometimesfoundincharactereducation.ExtendEdNotessuggestsincludingthesefourelementsinyourafterschoolprogramtohelpfosteringgrit.
1. Presentstudentswithchallengesthattakethemoutoftheircomfortzonesandincreasetheirfrustration.
2. Observestudents'reactionsandhelptoguideandmotivatethosewhoareeasilydiscouragedordefeated.
3. Encouragestudentstosetgoalsforthemselvesanddemonstratehowtoactivelyworktowardsachievingthosegoals.
4. Helpstudentsunderstandthe"growthmindset,"andasexplainedbyDuckworthinherTEDTalk,that"theabilitytolearnisnotfixed;itcanchangewithyoureffort."
40
Whiletheseareworthwhileelementstoincludeinafterschoolprograms,this2016articlefromTheWashingtonPost:TheProblemWithTeaching‘Grit’ToPoorKids?TheyAlreadyHaveIt.Here’sWhatTheyReallyNeedprovidesacautionarytaleaboutgrit.Sincemanyofouroutofschooltimesservechildrenwhoareraisedinpovertyorcommunitiesthatareunder-resourced,weneedtoconsiderthattheyalreadyhavegrit.Theauthorofthisarticlesuggests,“Anoveremphasisoncharactereducationmeansthatfewerresourceswillbespentonteachingdisadvantagedstudentstheskillsandknowledgetheyneedtoactuallysucceedacademicallyandprofessionally.”Likeanytrend,it’simportanttoconsidervariousperspectiveandthewaysthatclass,culture,privilegeandopportunitymaybiasourbeliefaboutwhetheratrendis‘good’forthepeopleweserve(participants,staff,families,partners,etc.)
RestorativePracticeRestorativepracticeisagoodfitandpracticalstrategyforafterschoolprogramsbecauseitalignswithpositiveyouthdevelopmentprinciplesincluding:fosteringpositiverelationships,upholdingclear,fairandhighexpectations,andsupportingopportunitiestoconnect,navigateandbeproductive.Itisalsoastrengths-basedapproachtoengagementanddiscipline.AccordingtotheAfterschoolAlliance,“unlikepunitivejustice,whichfocusesonpunishingtheoffender,restorativejusticefocusesonrepairingharmdone.Thegoalistoidentifywhowasharmed,explorewhyithappened,andsolvetheissuebyconsideringtheneedsofallindividualsinvolved—thevictimsandoffenders.Threeimportantprincipleswithinrestorativejusticeinclude:involvingtheentirecommunity,encouragingequity,andutilizingaproactivestrategy.”Restorativepracticealsosupportsthedevelopmentofsocialandemotionallearning(SEL)byhelpingdevelopconflictresolutionsskillsandcompetence.Implementingarestorativeapproachrequiresashiftinmindset,andprobablysomepolicies,too.Staffneedtrainingandsupportthroughouttheprocess.Therearemanyresourcesavailableatwww.healthiersf.orgtohelpyougetstarted.
TheImportanceofPlaySummer,2018theAmericanAcademyofPediatricsreleasedareportontheimportanceofplayentitled,ThePowerofPlay:APediatricRoleinEnhancingDevelopmentinYoungChildren,inwhichitsuggeststhatpediatriciansshould‘prescribe’playtotheirpatientsbecauseofitsknownpositivebenefits.Benefitsfromplayincludethedevelopmentofsocialandemotionalskillsaswellascognitivedevelopmentincludingproblemsolvingandcriticalthinking.Playcanalsohelpdeveloplanguageskills,andphysicaldevelopmentincludingfineandgrossmotorskills.Playfullearningisaconceptthatidentifiessixkeyelementsinwhichplayfacilitatesmeaningfullearning.ThesixCsinclude:Communication,Collaboration,Content,CriticalThinking,CreativeInnovation,andConfidence.Whileweoftenthinkaboutplay“astheworkofchildren”,thereisampleevidencetoshowthatplaybenefitsteenagersandhelpsthemtodevelopkeyworkforce
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
41
skills,suchasteamworkandproblemsolving.Regardlessofage,playalignswithpositiveyouthdevelopmentbyfosteringpositiverelationshipandcreatingopportunitiesforyouthtoconnect.SummerLearning(www.summerlearning.org)Theresearchonsummerlearningsuggeststhatchildrenwhoattendsummerprogramsfairbetteracademicallyandsociallywhentheyreturntoschoolinthefallthantheirpeerswhodonotattendsummerprograms.Duringthesummer,somechildren,especiallythosefromunderresourcedschoolsandcommunitiesareatriskforsomethingcalled‘summerslide’.ThisiswhenastudentlosessomeoftheiracademicgainsoverthesummerandmayreturntoschoolinSeptemberbehindtheirgradelevel.Onaveragestudentsfrommiddle-incomefamiliesexperienceslightgainsinreadingperformanceduringsummervacation.Studentsfromlow-incomefamiliesexperienceaboutatwo-monthlossinreadingachievement.AccordingtoMakingSummerCount(WallaceFoundation),“educatorsandpolicymakersareincreasinglypromotingsummerlearningasakeystrategytoimprovingtheachievementoflow-performingstudents.”Utilizingpartnershipcanhelpwithdesignandimplementationofhighqualitysummerprogramming.Partnerscaninclude,schooldistricts,summerlearningproviders,andothercommunitybasedorganizationsoryouth-servingprograms.Thisallowsforavarietyofprogrammingtobeofferedandforcreativewaystofinanceprogrammingfromvarioustypesofsources(public,privateorstateorlocalfunds).
IncorporatingNewTrends:AFewTipsEveryfewyears(andsometimesmoreoftenthanthat)newtrendsemergeinthefieldofafterschool.Manyofthesetrendsofferare-articulationofandarewellalignedwithyouthdevelopmentprinciples.Theyarealsooftenaccompaniedbyfundingopportunities,whichmakesthemveryenticingtotrytoadopteachone.Someofthesetrendsstickaroundforawhileuntilsomethingnewer,youngerandsexiergetsintroduced.Sometrendsseemtocomearoundincycleseveryfewyears.
42
Dependingonthegroupyouserve,sometrendsmaybemorerelevanttoyou,buthowdoyouknowforsureifit’sworthittomakesmallorwhole-scalechanges?Hereareafewtipsfordecidingifatrendisforyou:
• Doesthistrend(orthemoney,resourcesoropportunitiesthatcomewithit)supportyourprogrammissionorgoals?Ifnot,thenaskyourselfwhyareyoudoingit?Isthereanothergoalthatitsupports?Doesitcreateanopportunityforyoutoshiftortrysomethingyou’vebeenwantingtotry?And,askyourself,whatwillittaketosustainthetrendgoingforwardaftertheinitialgrantisover?
• Doesthistrendalignwithpositiveyouthdevelopmentprinciples?Inotherwords,doesithelptofosterrelationships?Doesitsupportoralignwithclear,fairandhighexpectations?Willitallowyoutodevelopopportunitieswhereparticipantsareconnecting,navigatingorbeingproductive?
• DoesthistrendsupporttheLearninginAfterschool&Summer(LIAS)
learningprinciplesforhighqualityprogramming:1.Learningthatisactive,2.Learningthatiscollaborative,3.Learningthatismeaningful,4.Learningthatsupportsmasteryand,5.Learningthatexpandshorizons.
• Doyouhavetherightstafftotacklethistopic/trend?BeforeswitchingovertoSTEMprogramming,assessyourstaff’sabilitytolead(andinterestin)STEMactivities?DoyouhavetheappropriatespaceandresourcestoimplementSTEMprogramming?Willyoubeabletosustainthetechnologyorwillitquicklybecomeoutdated?
• Canyouallocatetimeforstafftomeetandplanhowtoimplementneeded
changes?Inordertosuccessfullydesignandimplementnewprogramstrategies,staffneedtomeetovertimetoensurethattheyfullyunderstandwhattheyaretryingtodo,howtheywilldoit,andhowtheywillknowiftheyaresuccessful.
• Whatkindofpartnersmightyouneedtotakeonthistrend?Doyouhavethetimeandcapacitytoidentify,fosterandnurturethoserelationships?
It’seasytofeellikeyoumustintegrateeverytrendintoyourprogramandworrythatyoumightmissanopportunity!Butthecleareryouareaboutwhatyoudo,forwhomyoudoit,andthecapacityofyourstaffandpartnerstodothatworkwell,theeasieritwillbetosay“yes”totherightopportunitiesandstayfocusedonyourwork.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
43
SAFETY
PROMOTINGASENSEOF
PHYSICALAND
EMOTIONALSAFETY
Ensuringthatyoungpeoplefeelbothphysicallyandemotionallysafe.
Chapter
4
44
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
45
WhatisSafety?Ascaretakers,wegenerallythinkofsafetyintermsoftheprecautionswemusttaketoensurethephysicalsafetyoftheyoungpeopleunderourcare.Thisincludesminimizingdangerswithinthesurroundingenvironment,providingadequateadultsupervision,andbeingwellpreparedtoaddressemergencies,suchasfires,earthquakes,andmedicalcrises.Thereareestablishedlocalstandardsaddressingthesesafetyissuesandexcellentresourcestoguideprogramleadersinensuringthatprogramfacilitiesaresafeandthatadultsworkingwithyoungpeoplecanensurethephysicalsafetyofparticipantsincaseofemergencies.However,promotingasenseofsafetyinaprogramservingyoungpeoplegoesbeyondcreatingaphysicallysafeenvironment.Aprogramcanprovideasafephysicalenvironmentandstillbeexperiencedbyyoungparticipantsasanunsafeplace.Foryoungpeopletoexperienceaprogramassafe,theymustfeelpersonallysafe—bothphysicallyandemotionally.Theexperienceofphysicalsafetymeansthatyoungpeoplefeelsafefromphysicalharm,confidentthatthesurroundingadultswillprotectthemfromharmandassistthemiftheyarefeelingthreatened—whetherbytheirpeersorbyotheradults.Further,youngpeopleknowthattherearerulesthatgovernbehaviorandthattheseruleswillbeconsistentlyandfairlyenforced.Theexperienceofemotionalsafetymeansthatyoungpeoplefeelsecurethattheywillbevaluedandacceptedbythegroup;thattheycanparticipatefullywithoutfearofteasing,harassment,orostracism;thatracialandculturaldifferencesbetweenindividualsareembraced.Individualdifferences,suchasbodytype,ordifferencesinabilityorinterestsarealsoacceptedandyoungpeopleknowthattheywillbetreatedwithrespect.Inanenvironmentthatpromotesemotionalsafety,youngpeoplefeelsafetotryandsometimesfailbecausepositiverisk-takingissupportedand“mistakesareOK.”
46
WhyisSafetyImportant?Theresearchonchilddevelopmentandresiliencyidentifiestheexperienceofphysicalandemotionalsafetyascriticaltosupportingyoungpeople’shealthydevelopment.Youngpeoplemustexperienceasenseofpersonalandemotionalsafetyiftheyaretolearnimportantlifeskillsandcompetenciestheywillneedinadulthood.
Programsthatholdincreasingorenhancingyoungpeople’slearningasanimportantoutcomeshouldbeparticularlyinterestedinpromotingastrongsenseofsafety.Recentresearchintobrainfunctionrevealsthattheexperienceofsafetyisanimportantcomponentinaperson’sreadinesstolearn.Whenpeoplefeelunsafe,theirbrainactivityactuallychanges.Higher-levelbrainfunctionssuchaslearning,cognition,andlanguageabilityarereducedorshutdownasattentionisdivertedtoa“fight-or-flight”response.Thus,feelingunsafecanactivelyinterferewithlearningandtheintegrationofnewinformation.Becausesomuchofthelearninginafterschoolprogramsoccursinasocialenvironment,asenseofsafetyiskey.Ifweareexpectingyoungpeopletotakethepositiverisksneededtopracticenewlylearnedskillsandtakeonleadershiprolesandresponsibilities,wemustprovidethemwithasettingwheretheyfeelsafe.Youngpeoplearemorewillingtotaketherisksnecessaryforlearningandgrowthwhentheyknowthattheir“falls”willbecushionedbytheacceptanceofthegroup.Asenseofsafetyisalsoaprerequisiteforbuildingthekindsofpositiverelationshipswithadultsandpeersthathelpyoungpeoplelearn(SeeChapter5,EncouragingRelationshipBuilding).Establishingyourafterschoolprogramasasafeplaceintheeyesofyourparticipantsbringsnumerousimmediatebenefits,bothforprogramparticipantsandfortheadultsmanagingtheprogram.Whenprogramsaredesignedtopromoteasenseofsafety,youngpeoplefeelmoresecureandtrustingofothers.Promotingasenseofsafetyandacceptanceservestoreduce“actingout”behaviorsandunderlyinganxiety.Whenstaffmembersmakeitclearthateveryoneisincludedintheemotionalsafetynet,youngpeoplefeelsafesharingtheirwholeselveswiththegroup.Astheyinteractauthenticallyandrespectfullywithothers,theylearnacceptanceofdifferencesandgaintheabilitytoworkandplaywithpeoplefrombackgroundsdifferentfromtheirown.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
47
Whenalltheyoungpeopleinyourprogramfeelsafe,theyaremorelikelytotelladultswhattheyarereallythinkingandfeeling.Asyougainadeeperunderstandingoftheiropinionsandwants,youcanbettermeetyoungpeople’sneeds.Afeelingofsafetyamongparticipantsreducesconflictsamongyoungpeople;andwhenconflictsdoarise,theyareresolvedmorereadily.Italsoenablesadultstoreaptherewardsofauthenticrelationshipswithyoungpeople.
PromotingaSenseofSafetyinYour
AfterschoolProgram
OrganizationalPracticesthatSupportSafety
Promotingasenseofsafetybeginswithsoundpoliciesandpracticesoftheorganizationthatemploysthestaffwhoworkwithyoungpeopledirectly.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.StaffDiscussionsandPlanning
Promotingasenseofsafetywithinyourprogramrequiresdiscussionandconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.
MakingSafetyaPriority
Foryoungpeopletofeelsafe,theyneedtoknowthatthereisasetofclearrulesthatgovernbehavior,andthattheseruleswillbeappliedconsistentlybyadultswhoarecommittedtotreatingyoungpeoplefairly.Makesafetyaprioritybymakingsureeveryoneisfamiliarwitheverydayrules,procedures,andagreementsabouthowstaffshouldrespondwhenyoungpeoplebreaktherules.Thisincludesallprogramstaff,security,administration,janitorialstaff,volunteers,andanyotheradultswhomightcomeincontactwithyoungpeopleintheprogram.Planhowyouwillrespectfullydevelopandreviewtheruleswithyouryoungprogramparticipantsandhowyouwillsecuretheiragreement.(Thebestwayistoinvitethemtohelpincreatingtherules.)Itiscriticalthatyoungpeopleinyourprogramknowwheretoturnifsomeone—whetherapeer,staffmember,orsomeoneoutsidetheprogram—ismakingthemfeelunsafe.Staffmembersneedtotakeseriouslyanyreportsofbullying,teasing,abuse,harassmentorotherunsafebehaviorandlettheyoungpersonwhofeelsunsafeknowwhatstepswillbetakentoensurehisorhersafety.Itisimportanttoraisethisissueingroupdiscussionsfromtimetotimebyasking,“Whatwouldyoudoifabullytriedtobotheryouonyourwayhere?”and“Whocouldyoutalktoifoneofthestaffmembersdidsomethingthatyouthoughtwasunfair?”Alsobegintoplanwaystoensurethatawidevarietyofyoungpeoplecanexperiencesuccessinyourprogram.Onewaytodothisistomakesurethatyourprogramincludesawiderangeofactivitiesthatdrawondifferentskills,knowledgebases,andabilities.Itisalsoimportanttopayrespectfulattentiontotheindividualparticipants,learningwhatmotivatesthemandbetter
48
understandingthecontextinwhichtheyhaveformedtheirbeliefs.Whileitisessentialforprogramleaderstoplanhowbesttopromotesafety,thepolicies,proceduresandresourcesofthelargerorganization(whetheraschool,schooldistrict,oragency)mustbeinconcertwiththeworkofprogramstaffmembers.Therearecertainstructuralfeaturesaprogramneedstohaveinplaceifitisgoingtoconsistentlyprovidephysicalandemotionalsafety.
HelpingYoungPeopleResistBias
Creatingemotionalsafetyisaboutcreatingaclimatethatvaluesdiversity.Thegoalisforeverychildtofeelcomfortablewithandacceptedforwhoheorsheis.Childrenarebornloving,curious,andopentotheworld.Theystarttonoticedifferencesingender,race,class,andfamilystructureasearlyasagethree,andtheyturntotheadultsaroundthemforcluesaboutwhatthosedifferencesmean.Intheabsenceofpositive,affirmingcuesfromtheirrolemodelsaboutdifference,theylearnwhattheycanontheplaygroundandfrommassculture.Sadly,manyofthemessagestheyreceivearefullofsubtleandnot-so-subtlebiasesandstereotyping.Biasisoftensubtle,andiscommunicatedthoughtlesslyifwearenotcareful.Itisasmuchaboutwhatwedon’tsayaswhatwedo—toleratingloudnessfromboysbutnotfromgirls,makingassumptionsaboutachild’sinterestsorskillsbasedonhis/herrace,orpostingimagesonthewallsthatleaveoutsomeyoungpeople.Itisimportantforeveryoneattheschooloragencytohaveagoodunderstandingofbiasandhowitworksifyouaregoingtoworktoeliminateitinyourprogram.Agoodfirststepisanti-biastrainingforallprogramstaff.Learningbiashurtsyoungpeople,andtheytrytoresistit—theywanttoremainopen,loving,andkind.Helpthembymodelingacceptanceandbyaddressingalltypesofslursandstereotypeswhenevertheyoccur.Rememberalsotobemindfuloftheyoungpersondisplayingthebias,strivingtorespectthecontextinwhichtheydevelopedtheirbeliefs,whilemakingitclearthatbehaviorandwordsthathurtothersareunacceptable.Inanage-appropriateway,youcanalsohelpthemlearnhowbiasworksandhowtorecognizeit.Oneofthemostchallenging,andfrequentlyunacknowledgedissuesthatmanyadultsfaceishelpingyoungpeopledealwithsocietalhomophobiaandheterosexism.Thetollintolerancetakescanbedevastating:itisestimatedthatgayandlesbianadolescentsaccountforone-thirdofteenscommittingsuicide.Homophobicenvironmentsareespeciallyhurtfultoyoungpeoplewhosensethattheymightbe“different”insomewayorwhohavegayorlesbianfamilymembers.Youcanhelpcreateasenseofsafetyforalltheyoungpeopleinyourprogrambyusinginclusivelanguageandbyrecognizingandrefusingtotoleratehomophobicstereotypesandslurs.Asoneexperiencedyouthworkerputit,“challengingheterosexismcreatessafetynotonlyforyoungpeopleoftheseidentitiesandotherswhoarequestioningtheirsexuality,butalsoforheterosexualyoungpeoplebeingpressuredtobeviolentto“prove”theiridentities.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
49
KnowingandInvolvingYourCommunity
Everycommunityhasitsownparticularissues,history,andculturalheritage.Itisimportanttoknowwhatgroupsarerepresentedinyourprogram,soyoucanbefamiliarwiththehistory,issues,andrelationshipsbetweenthosegroups.Thisisimportantforinclusion,soyoucanbesurethatyouryoungpeopleseefamiliarimagesonthewalls,thattheyhavesomerolemodelsthatcomefromasimilarbackground,andthatculturalcelebrationsreflectthegroup.Knowingyourcommunityisalsoimportantforreasonsofphysicalsafety.Forexample,isyourprogramlocatedingangterritory?Doyoungpeoplehavetocrossterritoryofrivalgangstogettoyoursite?Doyoungpeopleinyourareasometimescarryweaponstofeelsafe?Aretherecurrenteventsinlocalornationalnewsthatmayhaveanimpactonhowstudentsgetalongatyourprogram?Whatisthelocalhistoryofrelationshipsbetweendifferentgroupsrepresentedinyourprogram?Parentsandcommunitymembersarewonderfulresourcesforidentifyingbias,providinginsightintothehistoricalandculturalbackgroundofthecommunity,andcreatingsolutionstoavarietyofproblems.Someprogramshaveformedparent“safetycommittees”thatlookatvarioussafetyissuesandworktogethertofindsolutions.Besurethatsuchworkinggroupscontainabalanceofthedifferentgroupsrepresentedinyourprogram.
AWordAboutConfidentialityandReferrals
Asyougettoknowyoungpeopleintheprogramandtheydeveloptrustwithyou,manymaysharepersonalinformation,assumingitwillbekeptconfidential.Olderyouthinparticularmayfeelsaferknowingthatyoucanandwillkeeptheirconversationsconfidential.However,therearecertaintimeswhenyouwillnotbeabletokeepconfidentiality—suchaswhenayoungpersonletsyouknowthatsomeoneishurtingthem,orthattheyaregoingtohurtsomeoneelse.Itisimportantthatadultstaffunderstandthelegalreportingresponsibilitiesregardingchildabuseandendangerment.Ifyourprogramisaddressingpersonal,sensitiveissueswithyoungpeople,itisimportanttohaveaclearpolicyonconfidentialitythatyoucanshareopenlywithparticipants.Itisparticularlyimportantwithadolescentsthattheyunderstandyouwillrespecttheirprivacy,andthattherearelimitsinregardstoensuringtheirsafety.
50
Therewillbetimeswhenayoungparticipant’sissuesarebeyondthescopeofyourprogrampractice.Itisimportantthatstaffmembersreceiveguidanceonhowtohandlethesesituationsandhaveaccesstotheirprogramsupervisorstodiscusssituationswherereferralstootherprofessionalsmaybeinorder.
ThingsYouCanDoNOWtoEncourage
RelationshipBuilding
1.Developgroupagreementsorrulesregardingsafetyand
regulargroupmeetingstoensurethateveryonefeels
physicallyandemotionallysafe.Conductameetingwiththeprogramparticipantsearlyontoexpressthecommitmentthatinyourprogram“everypersonhastherighttofeelsafe,included,andaccepted.”Askparticipantstodefinewhatthesetermsmeantothem,andwhatagreementsandrulestheywanttomaketoensuretherightofsafety.Decidetogetherwhathappenswhenthesafetyagreementsarebroken.Trainyoungpeopleinaprocesstoresolvedifferencesanddecideatwhatpointanadultshouldbeaskedtointervene.
2.Institutearegulargroupor“community”check-inmeeting.
Ifissuesofsafetyandrelationshipbuildingareimportant,setasidearegulartimeforthegrouptoreflectontheirexperienceintheprogramandtosuggestwaysinwhichthepeergroupcanworktogetherevenbetter.“Everyyearinthefirstweekofschool,Igathermystudentsinourbookcorner,whichisacozyspotcoveredwithanicethickrug.Wesitinacirclesothatwecan
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
51
seeeachother’sfaces,andItellthechildrenthateveryweekwewillmeetasagrouptodiscusshowwellwearegettingalong,whatisworkingandwhat’snotworking,andhowtosolveourproblems”writesMonaHalaby,authorofBelonging:CreatingCommunityintheClassroom.Makeroominthemeetingforpeopletoshareappreciationsfortheirpeerswhoarecontributingtomakingtheprogramapositive,safeplace.TheTribesbook(JeanneGibbs)andTribestrainingsarealsoexcellentresourcesforhowtoconductcommunity-buildingmeetingswithyoungpeople.
3.Include“noput-downs”inyourgroupagreements.
Whendevelopinggroupagreementswithyoungpeople,arequestfora“noput-down”agreementwillusuallysurfaceearlyinthediscussion.Itisimportanttodiscusswiththeyoungpeoplehoweveryonewillsupportitsenforcement.Thistakesrealcommitment,asmanyyoungpeoplehavelearnedtouse“put-downs”asadefenseagainstbeinghurtthemselves.Adultstaffmemberswillhavetofollowthroughwithgreatconsistency,offeringremindersthataskmemberstoholdtothisagreement,especiallyinthebeginning.Takeeverysluryouhearseriously,evenifitisinateasingtoneorparticipantsclaimitisokay.Itisnotokaybecauseslurshurt.Itishelpfultoholdgroupdiscussionsoractivitiesaround“put-downs”,whytheyhurt,andwhatwecandoinstead.Asyoungpeoplecometotrustthatyouwillenforcethispolicy,youwillseeareductioninthenumberof“put-downs”,andthesenseofsafetyintheprogramwillgrow.Learningthebenefitsofinteractingwithoutthiskindofhurtfulbehavioratanearlyageteachesyoungpeopleaprofoundlessoninthevalueoftoleranceandmutualrespect.
4.Assessthecultural,gender,ethnic,andfamilystructure
backgroundofyourgroup.Withoutaskingunnecessarilyprobingquestions,dowhatyoucantolearnwhoisinyourprogram.Dothestaffmembersandvolunteersreflectthesebackgrounds?Doimagesandbooksintheclassroom?Programactivitiesandcelebrations?Aretheredifferencesinwhocomestoprogram,whoparticipatesinwhichactivities,whichparentsfeelwelcomeatevents?
5.Expandthegroup’sknowledgeofparticulargroupsand
cultures.Startbyeducatingyourself.Avoidtokenizingyoungpeopleorothersinyourprogramorschoolbyaskingthemtoexplaintheirculture.Instead,gotothelibrary,lookontheinternet,attendlocalculturalevents,andcallorvisitorganizationspromotingequityforthegroupyouareresearching.Learnwhatyoucanaboutthehistory,art,literature,music,food,celebrations,andstrugglesofacultureorgroup.Thenhelptheyoungpeopleinyourprogramstudydifferentculturesandcelebratethecontributionsofdifferentgroups.Youmightlearnaboutwomen,peopleofcolor,andgaypeoplewhohavecontributedtoyourneighborhood.Celebratevariousholidaysastheyarecelebratedindifferentcountries.CelebrateBlackHistoryMonth,Women’sHistoryMonth,GayPrideMonth,
52
orCesarChavez’sBirthday.Youngpeoplecanpresentwhatthey’velearned,andadultsmaybewillingtosharefood,decorations,ormusic.Don’tmakeassumptionsaboutwhatanyparticularpersonmightshare.Besurethatthesecelebrationsarepartofanongoingprocessofinclusionandeducation,andthatsomegroupsaren’tjustsegregatedtocertain“diversitydays.”
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
53
HowDoYouKnow?
TakeYourProgram’sTemperature:Self-Assess
Youcanself-assessyourprogrambyusingobservationsandreflectionsurveyswiththeafterschoolstaffandyouthparticipants.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperienceswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromotepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiences.WhatYoungPeopleSay
Youngpeoplecantellyouiftheyhavepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessfortheseexperiencesistoasktheyoungpeopledirectlyabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatementsbelow?
54
SAFETY:HowDoYouKnow?
DirectionsSelfassessyourprogramusingobservationsandsurveys.Youcanidentifyindicatorsthatwillallowstaffandyouthtoselfassessthedegreetowhichtheprogrampromotesasenseofphysicalandemotionalsafety.Youcanuseindicatorsfromprogramqualitysurveys.Belowareafewsuggestionsofwhatyouwouldseeandwhatyouthwouldsay.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingasenseofsafetyamongitsparticipantswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive,becausetheenvironmentisclearlyaplacewhereallareincludedandrespected:
• Programgroupagreementsandschedulesareprintedinmultiplelanguageswhenappropriate,soallyoungpeopleandparentscanreadthem.
• Youmightalsoseesignscreatedbyyoungpeoplethatreflectthevaluesoftheprogram,like“RESPECTYOURSELF;RESPECTOTHERS”and“MISTAKESAREOK.”
• Iftherearedisplayscelebratingyoungpeople’saccomplishments,everyyoungpersonisrepresentedatonetimeoranother.
• Theimagesonthewallsrepresenttheparticipants’racialandethnicdiversity,andpresentdiverserolemodels(intermsofrace,culture,age,gender,sexualorientation,familystructure).
• Booksontheshelvesandotherprogrammaterialsareequallyrepresentativeoftheparticipants’diversity.
Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromoteasenseofsafetyinthewayeveryoneinteracts.
• Aspeopleenteritisclearthattheyknowwhattodoandwheretogoandtheydemonstrateasharedunderstandingofthebehavioralexpectations.
• Adultstaffmembersgreetyouthastheyarrive,andregularlyusefirstnamesinthecourseofconversation.
• Youngpeopleofdifferentbackgrounds,ages,andgenders,aswellasadultstaffmembers,interactcomfortablywithoneanother.
• Adultsonstaffrepresentthediversityoftheyoungparticipants.• Youngpeopleandadultsspeakrespectfullytoeachotherevenwhendisagreeing.• Youngpeopleandadultsdonotuseputdowns,calloneanothernames,orintentionally
embarrassoneanother.• Youngpeoplearenotteasediftheystruggletocompleteatask,butinsteadreceivepeer
supportandencouragement.• Eachparticipantappearstohaveapositiveroleinthegroup.• Thereisaconsistent,predictableresponsefromadultstaffwhengroundrulesare
brokenorignored
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
55
• Adultstaffrespondtoconflictcalmly,askingthoseinvolvedfortheirversionofeventsandsuggestionsabouthowtomakeitright.
• Conflictsaremanagedwithwords,andyoungpeoplehelpeachotheroraskforadulthelpinmanagingconflictasnecessary.
WhatYoungPeopleSayYoungpeoplecantellyouiftheyfeelsafeintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessforphysicalandemotionalsafetyistoasktheyoungpeopleabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatements?
• IfeelsafewhenIamhere.• Ifsomeonewantedtohurtmeorbeatmeupheresomeonewouldstophim/her.• Rulesabouthowtotreateachotherhereareenforced.• It’sokayformetomakemistakeshere.• ThereisatleastonethingthatIdowellinthisprogram.• Ilearnthingshereaboutpeoplewhoaredifferentfromme.
ReflectionWhataresomethingsyouseeinyourprogramthatindicateyoungpeopleexperiencesafetywhentheyarethere?Whataresomethingsyouwouldliketosee?
56
StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities
PromotingtheyouthdevelopmentexperiencesdetailedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0requiresconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.Belowaresometoolsforpromotingdiscussionwithyourstafforothersatyouragencyorschool.ThefollowingPersonalReflectionExercisesareagoodwaytosparkdiscussion.Ifthereisalocalyouthservingagencythatisknownfortheiremphasisonandsuccessinpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentforyoungpeople,youmaywanttoinvitesomeonefromthatagencyinasaguestspeakertoofferinspirationandsharetheirexperience.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
57
SAFETY:PersonalReflectionDirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelppeopleinyourprogramidentifythefactorsthatmakeanenvironmentfeelemotionallysafe.Itisagoodopeningtofocusthegroupontheimportanceofsafety.Beginbytellingparticipantsthatyouaregoingtodoapersonalreflection.Askthemtoclosetheireyes,andspendafewminutesthinkingabouttheirownexperience.Thenreadthefollowing:Imagineatimewhenyouwerewithagroupofpeopleandyoufeltthatyoudidn’tfitin.
• Wherewereyou?Whowereyouwith?Wereyoufamiliarwiththehabitsandstyleofthegroup?
• Didyoushareinterestsandvalues?• Howdidyoufeelinthatsituation?• Wherewasyourattentionfocused?• Howdidyourespond?
Nowthinkofatimewhenyouwerewithagroupofpeoplewithwhomyoufeltcompletelyathome—whereyoucouldletyourhairdownandbetrulyyourself.
• Wherewereyou?• Whowereyouwith?• Wereyoufamiliarwiththehabitsandstyleofthegroup?• Didyoushareinterestsandvalues?
GroupDiscussionBeforeholdingagroupdiscussionyoumightwanttogivetheparticipantsanopportunitytowritedownsomehighlightsofwhattheylearnedinthePersonalReflectionExercise.Thenholdadiscussionusingthefollowingquestionstofacilitatesharingandlearningfromeachparticipant’sexperience.
• Whatweresomedifferencesinyourrelationshipswiththetwogroups?• Howdidyouthinkdifferentlyinthegroupyouwerecomfortablewithvs.theonein
whichyouwereuncomfortable?• Howdidyouactdifferently?• Inwhatwaysdidyoufeelsafeorunsafeinthetwogroups?• Whatarethequalitiesofanemotionallysafeenvironment?• Howcouldayoungperson’sfeelingsofbeingsafeorunsafeaffecttheirabilitytolearn?
58
SAFETY:Inclusion
DirectionsUsethischarttoexamineinclusionandrepresentationinyourprogram.Recordthepercentagesofeverygrouprepresentedatvariouslevelsoftheprogram.Youcanaddgroupsasneededtofitthedemographicsofyourcommunity.Youcanalsouseamodifiedversiontolookatrepresentationinprogrammaterialsandimagesonthewalls.Thisisatoolforbeginningadiscussionandidentifyingareasforaction—youcanmodifyitanduseitinthewaythatmakesthemostsenseforyourprogram.
PermissiontousegrantedbyJeanneGibbs,authorofTribes:ANewWayofLearningandBeingTogether.CenterSourceSystems,Sausalito,CA.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
59
SAFETY:ConflictIntervention
DirectionsThisexercisewillhelpstaffmembersthinkaheadabouthowtheymightinterveneinaconflictorinterruptbias.Divideintoteamsoffiveorsix.Eachteamhasfiveminutestoplanaroleplayinwhichtheyareyoungpeoplefromtheprograminvolvedinasituationthatrequiresstaffintervention.Thesituationscanbearguments,fights,teasing,slurs,oranysimilarsituationthatmightoccuramongyourprogram’syoungpeople.Doeachroleplay,oneatatime,withthestaffmemberplayedbysomeonefromoutsidethesmallgroup.Aftereachroleplay,holdalargegroupdiscussiontoconsiderthesequestions:
• Whatdidthestaffmemberdothatwashelpfulinthesituation?• Howdidthestaffmemberfeelbeforetheintervention?During?After?• Howdidthe“youngpeople”feelbeforetheintervention?During?After?• Whatelsecouldthestaffmemberhavedonetohelpeachofthe“youngpeople”feelsafer
intheprogram?• Wasthissituationrealisticforyourprogram?• Isfurtherstafftrainingordiscussionnecessary?
60
SAFETY:StaffTrainingTopicsDirectionsCreateastaffdevelopmentplanthatincludestrainingtopicsthatwouldensurethattheyoungpeopleinyourprogramarephysicallyandemotionallysafe.Togetherwithyourstaffandprogramleadership,identifytrainingtopicsthatarerelatedtosafety.Belowareafewsuggestions:
• Resistingbias• Specificworkshopsonracism,classism,sexism,homophobia,ageism,andothertopicsas
needed• Activelistening• Conflictmediationandde-escalation• FirstAid• Earthquakepreparedness• Childabusereportingrequirements
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
61
SAFETY:ChecklistforActionDirectionsDocumentwhatstepstheprogramhasmadetoensuresafety.Workwithyourprogramstaffandleadershiptodeterminewhathasbeendonetodatetoimproveprogramsafety.Thischecklistwillhelpyoustayfocusedandorganizedasyoubeginmakingsafetyapriorityinyourprogram.Haveyou:
o Assessedyourprogram’sorganizationalpracticestoseeiftheypromotesafety?
o Lookedathowyourschooloragencyallocatesresources(time,space,andmoney)topromoteasenseofsafetyforparticipants?
o Assessedtheneedforstaffdevelopmentandplannedfortraining?
o Definedspecificallyhowyouexpectsafety-promotingactivitiestopositivelyimpact
youngpeople?
o Setasideongoingstafftimetothoroughlyprepareforandimplementinclusionstrategies?
o Assessedtheculturalandfamilybackgroundsrepresentedinyourprogram?
o Educatedstaffaboutdifferentgroupsrepresentedinyourprogram?
o Educatedallprogramstaffaboutbias?
o Educatedvolunteersaboutbias?
o Instituteda“noput-down”agreement?
o Takentimetohaveyoungpeoplereallyexplainwhattheyarethinkingwhentheybreak
programagreements?
o Assessedprogrammaterialsforinclusion?
o Involvedparentsandcommunitymembersinplanningtopromoteandensuresafety?
o Incorporatedoutcomesrelatedtopromotingsafetyintoprogramevaluation?
62
ForOrganizationalLeaders
OrganizationalPracticesThatPromoteYouthDevelopmentSuccessfulyouthdevelopmentprogramsarebornoutofaculture,policies,resourcesandstructuresthatareestablishedbytheprogramprovider’sparentorganization.Asanyonewhohasstruggledwithtoofewresourcesormismatchedorganizationalprioritiesknows,thebeststaffintheworldworkingwiththedeepestknowledgeandunderstandingcannotcreatehighqualityexperiencesforyoungpeoplewithoutcertainorganizationalsupportsinplace.
Manyteachersandyouthworkershavenotedthatthekindsoforganizationalpracticesdescribedontheleftworkbestwhentheyareappliedconsistentlyatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Forexample,thesponsoringschooloragencymustcommittoholdinghigh,clear,andfairstandardsforthestaff,justastheydofortheyoungparticipants.Inthisway,staffexperiencewhattheyneedtosucceed,andthefunctioningoftheorganizationatamacro-levelmirrorsthefunctioningattheprogramlevel—everyone“walksthetalk.”Puttingtheseorganizationalpracticesinplacetakestime,energy,andresources.Inparticular,programstaffmusthavethetimeoutsideoftheirprogramdutiestotalktoeachother,talkinformallywithyoungpeople,gettoknowthecommunity,plan,evaluate,andlearn.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.Thefollowingaresuggestedorganizationalpracticesthatarerelatedtoyouthdevelopmentpractices.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
63
OrganizationalPracticesThatSupportSafety
LowYouthtoStaff/VolunteerRatioAlowyouthtostaff/volunteerratioisnecessaryforbothphysicalandemotionalsafety.Activitiesandspacesneedtobeadequatelysupervisedandprogramleadersneedtohaveanadultclosesotheycanbeavailableforsituationsthatrequireone-to-oneinteractions.Itisalsoimportanttohaveenoughtrainedadultsaroundtoaddressissuesofemotionalsafetywhentheyariseandtoformthekindsoftrustingrelationshipsthatallowyoungpeopletofeeltrulysafe.
Safe,Reliable,andAccessibleActivitiesandSpacesSafe,reliable,andaccessibleactivitiesandspacesarecrucialforyoungpeopletohaveasenseofsafety.Areprogramspacesclean?Doesthelayoutofthespaceandfurnitureallowadultstafftokeepchildreninview?Arethereplaceswithintheprogrammingspaceforadultstaffandyoungpeopletohaveone-to-onediscussions?Hasyourorganizationworkedtoensurethatyoungpeoplearesafewhengettingbothtoandfromtheprogram?
ContinuityandConsistencyofCareYoungpeoplefeelsafestwhentheyhaveongoing,trustingrelationshipswiththeadultsintheirprogramandwhenthereisasenseofroutine.Continuityandconsistencyofcarearecrucial.Organizationsmusttakestepstominimizestaffturnover.Makesurethereisaback-upplanwhenkeystaffmembersareabsent.Whenstaffmembersorvolunteersleavetheprogram,doallyoucantomakecareful,smoothtransitions,includinggivingyoungpeopleachancetosaygood-bye,whenpossible.
Ongoing,Results-BasedStaffandOrganizational
ImprovementProcessBothphysicalandemotionalsafetyarecomplextopicsthatrequireagreatdealofattentionandplanning.Anongoing,results-basedstaffandorganizationalimprovementprocessisonewaytobesurethatsafetyissuesdon’tfallthroughthecracks.Itisalsoimportanttohaveaprocessforimprovementthattakesyoungpeople’sinputintoaccount.Doesyourorganizationhaveaprocesstoassessthedegreetowhichparticipantsfeelphysicallyandemotionallysafeintheprogram?
CommunityEngagementYourcommunityhasagreatstakeinthesafetyofitsyoungpeople,andagreatdealofexpertiseandenergytohelpbuildasafeenvironment.Asdiscussedthroughoutthisguide,strongcommunityengagementisvitaltocreatingaprogramthatisinclusiveofallyoungpeopleandhelpsthemfeelsafe.
64
ProvidingOpportunitiesForSafetyAtAllLevelsOfThe
OrganizationSafetyismosteffectiveandmeaningfulwhenitismodeledatalllevelsoftheschooloragency.Thismeansthatallstaffmembers,parents,andvolunteershavetheopportunitytofeelphysicallyandemotionallysafeintheprogram.Adultswhodon’tfeelsafewillhaveahardtimehelpingyoungpeoplefeelsafe.Thismeansaddressingeverythingfromphysicalsafetyonthegroundstomakingsurethereisawayforprogramstaffmemberstofreelysharetheirthoughtsandconcernsabouttheprogram,agency,orschool.Fortunately,muchofthelearningthatgoesintomakingasafeprogramforyoungpeoplewillalsomakeitsaferforeveryone.
ReflectionArethereotherwaysyourorganizationcouldsupportstaffmembersinpromotingasenseofsafetyinyourprogram?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
65
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING
ENCOURAGING
RELATIONSHIP
BUILDING
Fosteringcaringandsupportiverelationshipsinyourprogram.
Chapter
5
66
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
67
WhatisRelationshipBuilding?Relationshipbuildingisthedevelopmentofcaring,supportiverelationshipsbetweenadultsandyoungpeople,andamongyoungpeopleandtheirpeers.Weknowrelationshipbuildingishappeningandyoungpeoplefeelsupportedwhentheyreportthattheyfeel“known”andacceptedbyothersintheprogram,whentheyexperiencetheprogramasaplacewheretheyreceiveemotionalandpracticalencouragementandsupport,andwhentheycanturntoadultsforpersonalguidanceandassistance.Whatdoesrelationshipbuildinglooklikeinaneffectiveafterschoolprogram?Staffmembersspendtimewithyoungpeople,gettingtoknowthemanddevelopingtrust.Adultsrespectyoungpeopleandtreatthemwithcourtesyandcare.Youngpeoplelearntotreateachotherwithrespectaswell,anddevelopagroupidentitythatincludesallmembers.Staffmembersknowthatbuildingpositive,trustingrelationshipswithyoungpeopleisnotaseparatepartofthework,butratheranintegralpartofeveryactivityandinteraction.
WhyisRelationshipBuildingImportant?Thereisoverwhelmingevidencethatthepresenceofcaring,supportiverelationshipsbetweenyoungpeopleandadultsisoneofthemostcriticalfactorsinthehealthydevelopmentofyoungpeople.Inresearchonchildhoodresiliency,thepresenceoftheserelationshipsistheleadingindicatorthatyoungpeoplewillbehealthyandproductiveadults,regardlessoftheireconomiccircumstancesandotherriskfactors.Byprovidingopportunitiesforrelationshipbuilding,weensurethatourafterschoolprogramsarecontributingtotheimportantdevelopmentalneedsoftheyoungpeopleweserve.Itisimportanttonotethatrelationshipbuildingisalsoacriticalfactorinwhetherornotyoungpeopleexperienceasenseofphysicalandemotionalsafetyintheirafterschoolprogram,asdiscussedinChapter4,PromotingASenseofSafety.Canafterschoolprogramsreallymakeadifference?Whenadultsareaskedtoreflectontheexperiencesthatweremostinfluentialintheirchildhoodandadolescence,theyalmostalwaysciteanimportantrelationshipwithacaringadultwhotookthetimetoknowthem,andoffered
68
guidanceandencouragement.Thispersonwasoftenanindividualoutsideofthehomeandclassroom:acoachoryouthworkerwhotookaspecialinterest,ateacherwhotooktimeafterschool.(Seethe“CookieLady”exerciseinthischapter,StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities).
Thefirstchallengeinrunningsuccessfulafterschoolprogramsisattractingandretainingparticipants.Thisisespeciallychallengingwithadolescentswhocan“votewiththeirfeet”iftheydonothaveapositiveexperienceintheprogram.Whenyoungpeoplefeelrespectedandhavecaringrelationshipswithadultsandpeersinanafterschoolprogram,theyfeelmoreincludedandinvestedintheprogram.Astheydevelopasenseofgroupmembership,theyaremorelikelytoattendregularlyandparticipatemorefullyintheprogram.Whenyoungpeopleareengagedindecidinghowtheywanttobetreated,theyhavethechancetoreflectontheirownbehaviorandhowitimpactsothers.Theybecomemoreawareoftheneedsandfeelingsofothers,andmoreacceptingofdifference.Workingtogethertobuildrelationshipsinastructuredenvironmentalsogivesyoungpeoplethechancetolearnandpracticetheircommunicationskills.Mostimportantly,creatingopportunitiesforrelationshipbuildingensuresthatyoungpeoplewillhavesomewheretoturnwhentheyneedhelporarefacedwithdifficultdecisions.Relationshipbuildingiscitedasacriticalfactorintheeffectivenessofpreventionprogramsdesignedtoreducehigh-riskbehaviors.Supportiverelationshipswithbothadultsandpeersaresourcesofemotionalsupport,guidanceandinstrumentalhelpthatcancontributetobetterdecision-making,lowerlevelsofstress,higheracademicachievement,healthierrelationshipsandlowerlevelsofdrugandalcoholuse.Manyafterschoolprogramsofferextendedlearningopportunitiesforyoungpeoplewiththehopeofimprovingacademicskills,whichcanleadtoimprovedschoolperformance.Theexperienceofemotionalsafetyandsupportiverelationshipsaremajorfactorsincreatingsuccessfullearningenvironments.Recentresearchonlearningrevealsthatmostlearninghappensinasocialcontext.Theseexperiencesserveasturnkeysinyoungpeoples’willingnesstotakepositiverisks,suchasacceptinghelpandfeedbackfromothersandopenlyriskingfailureinordertolearnnewskills.Astheexperienceofmutualrespectandtrustincreasesbetweenprogramleadersandyoungparticipants,disciplineproblemsdiminish.Itbecomeseasiertogetyoungpeopletovoicetheirideasandopinions,andeasiertofacilitategroupactivities.Programassessmentbecomesmoremeaningfulasyoungpeopleareempoweredtorespondhonestly.Inaddition,whenstaffmembershavethetimeandorganizationalsupportnecessarytodeveloprelationshipswithyoungpeople,theirjobsatisfactionincreases.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
69
EncouragingRelationshipBuildinginYour
AfterschoolProgram
OrganizationalPracticesthatEncourageRelationship
BuildingEncouragingrelationshipbuildingbeginswithsoundpoliciesandpracticesoftheorganizationthatemploysthestaffwhoworkwithyoungpeopledirectly.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.
StaffDiscussionsandPlanning
Encouragingrelationshipbuildingwithinyourprogramrequiresdiscussionandconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.
MakingRelationshipBuildingaPriority
Manyindividualeducatorsandyouthworkersknowintuitivelythatbuildingstrong,positiverelationshipsisoneofthemostimportantthingstheydo.But,istherevalueplacedonthisattheprogramandorganizationallevel?Areprogramleadersandstaffawareofitsimportanceinsupportingyoungpeople’slearningandgreaterdevelopment?Isrelationshipbuildinganexplicitprogramobjective?Isitreflectedinthedesign,implementationorevaluationoftheafterschoolprogram?Allocatetimeinaprogramstaffmeetingtoconsiderthesequestions.Ifstaffmembersagreethatrelationshipbuildingisimportant,considerhowtheprogram’sstructureandpracticescurrentlysupportit.Forexample,doesthedailyscheduleofactivitiesallowforopportunitiesforrelationshipstodevelop?Istheretimeforparticipantsandadultstogettoknowoneanother?Istheretimeforsmallgroupdiscussionsandforyoungpeopletohaveone-to-onecontactwithadults?Howcanyouassessyoursuccessinachievingthisimportantobjectiveandhowarestaffevaluatedontheircontributionstoencouragingrelationshipbuilding?
EstablishingGroupAgreements
AsnotedinChapter4,PromotingaSenseofSafety,creatinggroupagreementsorguidelinesforhowpeopleintheprogramwilltreatoneanotherisanimportantfirststepinencouragingrelationshipbuildinginanafterschoolprogram.Brainstormgroundrulesasagroup,andbesureeveryoneinthegroupfeelsthattherulesarefair.Trytobespecific,anddiscusswhatvariousrulesmean.Forexample,“respecteachother”isoftenofferedasagroupagreementbutwhatdoes“respect”meantotheyoungpeopleinyourprogram?Doesitmeanno“put-downs”?Somethingelse?
70
Askyoungpeopletoconsiderwhosejobitistoremindgroupmemberswhengroundrulesarebroken,andhowtodothisinagenuineandrespectfulway.Ifappropriate,youngpeoplecansuggestpossibleconsequences.Thisprocessgetsthemthinkingabouthowtheywanttotreateachother,letsthemknowaheadoftimewhattheexpectationsare,andgivesthemownershipoverprogramguidelines.Oncegroupagreementsareestablished,postthemprominentlyandrefertothemoften.Havingyoungpeoplethemselvesmakeagroundrulesposterwillgetthemmoreinvolved.Itiscrucialthatalladultsintheprogramenforcegroupagreementsconsistently.
GettingtoKnowEachOtherasIndividuals
Iftheonlywayforyoungpeopletogetindividualattentionisforthemtoactout,theywilldoit!Trytogivethemopportunitiestointeractwithadultsone-on-oneinpositiveways.Findoutwhattheyliketodo,whotheimportantpeopleintheirlivesare,andwhattheydreamforthefuture.Groupmembersalsoneedtimetogettoknowoneanother—allowsomeunstructuredtimeforsocialinteraction.
BeingGenuine
Youngpeoplerespondverypositivelytohonestyandsincerity.Youngerchildrenareexcitedwhentheyhaveaglimpseoftherealpersonbehindtheadultleaderrole.Youngpeoplewanttogettoknowyou,andlovehearingaboutyourchildhoodexperiencesonceinawhile.Letthemknowalittlebitaboutyourlikesanddislikes,funnyhabits,orhopesforthefuture.Foradolescents,whenadultsarehonestandsincere,itcommunicatesthatadultsvalueandrespectthem.Allowtimeforrealrelationshipstodevelop—don’ttryforinstantconnections.
OfferingPraise
Everyoneappreciatespraise.Trytosayfivewordsofpraiseforeverywordofcorrection.Don’tjustsaveyourpraiseforbigaccomplishments,butnoticeallstepsalongtheway,sayingthingslike“Keesha,you’reworkingsohardonthatpainting!”and“Look,theRedTeamgotalltheirequipmentonsoquickly.Nowwe’rereadytoplay!”Whenyoupraise,makesureyourwordsaretrueandyouarepraisingarealaccomplishment(althoughitmaybeasmallone).Foryoungchildren,praiseisalsoanalternativewaytorefocusnegativebehaviorwithoutscoldingandsinglingoutindividuals:insteadof“SitdownRobert!”try“Almosteveryoneissittingquietlyinthecircle.Soonwecanbegin.”
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
71
UnderstandingthePaceofGroupRelationshipBuilding
Trustingrelationshipsbetweenindividualsandwithingroupstakestimetodevelop.Thiscanbesupportedthroughtheuseofactivitiesdesignedtostrengthenrelationshipbuilding.Whendecidingongroupbuildingactivities,makesurethatpersonalrevelationsandgroupactivitiesarelowrisk.Especiallywithadolescents,itisimportanttolettrustdevelopbeforeyouaskthemtodoanythingthatmaymakethemfeel“silly”orvulnerable.TribesTLC®hasdescribedaprocessofgroupevolutionthattakesplaceinthreestages:Inclusion,Influence,andCommunity.
IncludingRitualsforRecognitionandReflection
Youngpeoplerespondpositivelytoknowingtherewillbeanearlyopportunityto“voice”theirarrivalandpresence,especiallyastheymakethetransitionfromonepeersettingtoanother,fromtheschooldaytoanafterschoolsetting.Thismeansthatindividualsdonothavetofindnegativewaystobeacknowledged.Beginningtheprogramwithsmallgroupcirclesfor“check-in”isagreatwaytogiveyoungpeopleopportunitiesforvoice,recognitionandreflection.Justbytakingafewminutestoletyoungpeopletalkabouttheirdayorhowtheyarefeeling,youcancreateacalmtransitionintotheday,getafeelforthegroup,andgiveeachpersonachancetofeelimportantandincluded.Manygroupsalsoliketohaveacheck-outattheendofthedaytosaygood-byeandtakeanopportunitytoreflectonhowthegroupworkedtogetherthatday.Oncetheseritualsareestablished,carryingthemoutcanbeturnedovertotheyoungpeople.(FormoreinformationaboutTribesTLC®,visitwww.tribes.com).
KnowingYourLimits
Itisrespectfultosetappropriateboundarieswithyoungpeopletoletthemknowwhatyoucanandcan’tdoasastaffmemberofyourschooloragency.Itisalsoimportanttorecognizewhenayoungpersoncomestoyouwithaproblemthatrequiresprofessionalhelp.Staffmembersneedtobepreparedwithalistofresourcessotheywillknowwhattodowhenayoungpersonisfacingacrisis.Thisway,whenyoungpeoplereachoutforhelp,theywillbemetwithsupportandencouragement,ratherthanbeingpushedawaybyanadultwhoisfrightenedorunsure.
ThingsYouCanDoNOWtoEncourage
RelationshipBuilding1.Makesurethateachyoungpersonhasoneadultwho
knowshimorherwell.Anongoingpartofencouragingrelationshipbuildingismakingsurethateveryoneisconnectedinsomeway.Youngpeopleneedtohaveapositiverelationshipwithanadultiftheyaretogetthemostoutoftheprogram.Atastaffmeeting,gooveryourattendancelist.Istheresomeoneon
72
stafforavolunteerwhoisconnectedwitheachyoungperson?Iftherearesomeprogramparticipantswhohave“slippedthroughthecracks,”decidewhowillmakeaspecialefforttogettoknowtheseyoungpeople.It’sagoodgoaltobesurethateachyoungpersonhasone-to-onetimeeachweekwithanadult.
2.Instituteacheck-incircle.
Acheck-incircledoesn’tneedtotakeverylongandcangreatlybenefitbothyoungpeopleandprogramstaff.Insmallgroups(20orfewer),beginthedaybysittingquietlyinacircleandlettingeachpersonspeakbriefly.Sometimesithelpstohaveaspecialitemtopassaroundthegrouplikeatalkingstickthatidentifiestheonewhohasthe“raptattention”ofthegroup.Whenyoufirststartinstitutingthecheck-incircle,ithelpstoplanasafeandinterestingcheck-inquestion,suchas,“Whatisyourfavoritethingtodoatrecess?”or“Ifyoucouldgoanywhereintheworldforoneday,wherewouldyougo?”Lateron,aftersomepractice,youmighthaveeachpersonshareonethingabouttheirdayorsayhowthegroupisworkingtogether.
3.Developgroupagreementswithyoungpeople.
Havethegroupbrainstormalistofgroupagreementsforhowyouwilltreateachotherintheprogram.Askthemtoexplainwhyeachagreementmightbeimportant.Narrowthelisttonomorethansevenitems,sothattheagreementscanbeeasilyremembered.(Onewaytodothisistogiveeachpersonthreestickers.Askthemtovotebyplacingtheirstickersnexttotheagreementstheythinkaremostimportant.)Askthegroupiftheyallfeeltheycanagreetotrytolivebythesegroupagreements.Promisethatyouwillhelpthemrememberandletthemknowthattheycanremindeachotheraswell.
4.Holdaconflictresolutiontrainingforstaffandyoung
people.Whenyoungpeoplehavetheskillstoresolveconflictinhealthyandrespectfulways,theyarekinderandhappier,andrequirelessadultintervention.Theyalsofeelsaferintheafterschoolprogramknowingthattheycansolveproblemstogetherandthattheycangethelpiftheyneedit.Youcanalsotrain“conflictmanagers”tohelppeersoryoungerchildrenresolveconflict.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
73
5.ParticipateinaTribesTLC®trainingoranothertrainingin
groupprocessandcollaborativelearning.Buildinghighquality,positiverelationshipsinyourprogramtakescarefulplanningandattention.Supportingrelationshipsrequiresanumberofskills.Professionaltrainerswhohavestudiedthisprocess,suchasthoseworkingatTribesTLC®,canhelpstaffmembershonetheseskills.Ifnotthisparticulartraining,besureyourprogram’songoingcommitmenttoorganizationalimprovementincludessometypeoftrainingingroupprocess.
74
HowDoYouKnow?
TakeYourProgram’sTemperature:Self-Assess
Youcanself-assessyourprogrambyusingobservationsandreflectionsurveyswiththeafterschoolstaffandyouthparticipants.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperienceswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromotepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiences.WhatYoungPeopleSay
Youngpeoplecantellyouiftheyhavepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessfortheseexperiencesistoasktheyoungpeopledirectlyabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatementsbelow?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
75
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:HowDoYouKnow?
DirectionsSelfassessyourprogramusingobservationsandsurveys.Youcanidentifyindicatorsthatwillallowstaffandyouthtoselfassessthedegreetowhichtheprogrampromotespositiverelationshipbuilding.Youcanuseindicatorsfromprogramqualitysurveys.Belowareafewsuggestionsofwhatyouwouldseeandwhatyouthwouldsay.
WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramencouragesrelationshipbuildingwhenyouwalkintotheprogramroomandsee:
• Groundrulesorguidelineposterscitinghowyoungpeoplewanttobetreatedandwilltreatothersareprominentlydisplayed.Thesedisplaysareclearlyhandmadebytheprogramparticipantsandsometimesindifferentlanguages.
• Picturesonthewallscelebratingprogramparticipants,theircultures,andthegroup’saccomplishmentswithintheprogram.
• Ascheduleoftheweek’sactivitiesincludingstructuredtimeforone-to-onecontactbetweenadultsandyoungpeople,forgroupdiscussions,andopentimeforyoungpeopletosocializewithoneanotherandhaveinformalcontactwithadultstaff.
Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatyourprogramencouragesrelationshipbuildingbythewaytheyengagewitheachother:
• Youngpeopleandadultsaretreatingothersrespectfully.• Adultssquatdownwheninteractingwithsmallchildren,tospeaktothemattheireye
level.• Theprogramcreatesongoingopportunitiesforyouthtogettoknowoneanother,not
justduringthefirstfewweeksofthesession.• Youngpeopleremindeachotherofthegroundruleswhenneeded.• Conflictsareresolvedwithwords,notraisedvoicesorfists.Ifneeded,adultsareaskedto
assistwiththesituation.• Youngpeopleareabletoworktogetheringroupsandacrossdifferencesofage,gender,
ethnicbackground,ability,andsocialstatus.• Thereisatimeinthedaytoreflectonthegroup’saccomplishmentsandinteractions.• Adultsareavailablebeforeandaftertheprogram,forinformalconversationwith
participants.
76
WhatYoungPeopleSayThemostreliablewaytojudgeifyourprogramisencouragingrelationshipbuildingistoasktheyoungpeopleabouttheirownexperiencesoftheprogram.Ifasked,wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatements?
• PeopleheresaysomethingnicetomewhenIdosomethinggood.• Thereareruleshereforhowpeoplearesupposedtotreateachother.• Rulesabouthowtotreateachotherareenforcedbyadultsandotherkids.• Igetchancesheretolearnaboutyoungpeoplewhoaredifferentfromme.• Ifeelrespectedbystaffhere.• Ifeelrespectedbyotherkidshere.• Peopleherepayattentiontowhatisgoingoninmylife.• ThereissomeonehereIcouldtalktoifIwasupsetormadaboutsomething.• Someoneherewouldsaysomethingtomeifsomethinginmylifewasn’tgoingright.• ThereissomeoneherewhoIcouldgotoforhelpinacrisis,orifIneededtotalkabout
personalproblems.ReflectionWhataresomethingsyouseeinyourprogramthatencouragerelationshipbuilding?Whatthingswouldyouliketosee?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
77
StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities
PromotingtheyouthdevelopmentexperiencesdetailedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0requiresconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.Belowaresometoolsforpromotingdiscussionwithyourstafforothersatyouragencyorschool.ThefollowingPersonalReflectionExercisesareagoodwaytosparkdiscussion.Ifthereisalocalyouthservingagencythatisknownfortheiremphasisonandsuccessinpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentforyoungpeople,youmaywanttoinvitesomeonefromthatagencyinasaguestspeakertoofferinspirationandsharetheirexperience.
78
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:PersonalReflection–
MyStoryMaterialsNeeded
o PersonalReflectionExerciseI:MyStory,1copyperperson.DirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelppeoplepresentthemselvesandbeheardinthegroup—thefirststageofbuildingrelationships.Itisagoodopeningtofocusthegroupontheimportanceofrelationshipbuilding.GiveeachparticipantacopyofthePersonalReflectionExerciseI:MyStory.Asktheparticipantstotaketenminutestocompletethehandout,lettingthemknowinadvancethattheywillhaveanopportunitytosharewithasmallgroup.Thenbreakthegroupintosmallergroupsoffourorfiveandaskthemembersofeachgrouptosharewhattheywrotewitheachother.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
79
HANDOUT
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:MyStoryPurpose:Toguideyouthroughthinkingabouthowyouworkwithyoungpeople.1.Whatbroughtyoutoworkingwithyoungpeople?2.Whatareyourguidingprinciplesinworkingwithyoungpeople?3.Howdoyoubringthoseprinciplesalivewithyoungpeopleinyourprogram?4.Whatkeepsyouworkingwithyoungpeople?
80
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:Personal
Reflection-ImportantEventsandPeopleMaterialsNeeded
o Flipcharto Markers
DirectionsThisexercisehasthesamepurposeastheoneabove,andisusefulingroupsthatincludepeoplewhodon’tworkwithyoungpeopleonaregularbasis.Postsheetsfromaflipchartonthewallsaroundtheroom.Labeleachsheetwithanage,onesheetforeveryagerepresentedinyourprogram(5yearsold,6yearsold,andsoon).Passoutmarkers,andaskpeopletomovearoundtheroom,writingonthechartsimportanteventsandpeopleintheirlivesatthedifferentages.Itisnotnecessaryforeverypersontowriteoneverychart.Afterawhile,askpeopletostopwritingandallowafewminutesforthemtoreadwhatothershavewritten.GroupDiscussionGatherthegrouptogetherandholdadiscussionbasedonthefollowingquestions:
• Didthisexercisehelpyourememberanythingyouhadforgottenaboutbeingyoung?• Whatwastherelationshipbetweenimportantpeopleandimportanteventsinyour
childhood?• Whatkindsofpeoplewereimportanttoyouasyougrewup?Didthischangeasyougot
older?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
81
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:CookieLadyMaterialsNeeded
o Flipcharto Markers
DirectionsThisexerciseisusefulforidentifyingthefactorsthatmakearelationshipmeaningfultoayoungperson.Readthefollowingtothegroup:
Thinkofayoungpersonyouworkwithinyourafterschoolprogram.Howoldisthatperson?Nowthinkofyourselfwhenyouwerethatage.Wasthereanadultwhohadapositiveinfluenceonyou?Itcouldbeanyone—ateacher,relative,coach,theladywhogaveyoucookiesatthecornerstore.
Askthegrouptocalloutthedifferentrolesofpeopletheythoughtof(sister,friend’sparent,cookielady).Listtheseonaflipchartorblackboardandlabelthem“Relationships.”Nowaskthegrouptocalloutwhatthesepeopledidthatwassupportive,andlisttheseitems(listenedtome,trustedmewithresponsibility,pushedmetotryharder).Labelyoursecondlist“Supports.”GroupDiscussionBeginadiscussionwiththefollowingquestion:Whatissoimportantaboutthesupportsyoulisted?Itisinterestingtonotethatthisexercisehasbeendonewithhundredsofpeopleanditisrareforanyonetosaythattheimportantthingabouttherelationshipwasthespecificskilllearned.Inotherwords,itisunusualforsomeonetosay“taughtmemath”or“taughtmetoplaybasketball”whenaskedhowtherelationshipwassupportivetothem.Youmightbringthisupwiththegroupandaskthemwhytheythinkthisistrue.
82
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:StaffTrainingTopics
DirectionsCreateastaffdevelopmentplanthatincludestrainingtopicsthatwouldensurethattheyoungpeopleinyourprogramarebuildingpositiverelationshipswithstaffandpeers.Togetherwithyourstaffandprogramleaders,identifytrainingtopicsthatarerelatedtorelationshipbuilding.Belowareafewsuggestions:
• Agencyorprogrampolicies,groundrules,andenforcement• Activelistening• Positivediscipline• Conflictmediationforyouth• Crisisintervention
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
83
RELATIONSHIPBUILDING:
ChecklistforAction
DirectionsDocumentwhatstepstheprogramhasmadetopromotepositiverelationships.NowyouarereadytostartincreasingRelationshipBuildinginyourprogram!Thischecklistismeanttohelpyoustayorganizedandfocused.Usingitwillhelpyouensurethesuccessofyourprogram.Haveyou:
o Setasideongoingstafftimetothoroughlyplanforrelationshipbuilding,andtospendone-on-onetimewithyoungpeople?
o Assessedyourprogram’sorganizationalpracticestoseeiftheysupportrelationshipbuilding?
o Lookedathowyouragencyorschoolallocatesresources(time,space,andmoney)tosupportrelationshipbuilding?
o Assessedtheneedforstaffdevelopmentandplannedtraining?o Ensuredthateachyoungpersonhasatleastoneadultwhoknowshim/herwell?o Createdgroupagreementswiththegroup?o Preparedtofollow-throughconsistentlyinenforcinggroupagreements?o Plannedwaystomanageconflictamongyoungpeople?o Scheduledtimeforrecognitionandreflection?o SelectedafewpromisingareastobeginincreasingRelationshipBuilding?o Definedspecificallyhowyouexpecttheseactivitiestopositivelyimpactyoungpeople?o Identifiedskillsyoungpeoplewillneedtobuildontheirrelationshipsandplannedto
trainyoungpeopleintheseskills?o Createdaplantocoverstaffabsences?o Preparedstafftohelpyoungpeopleinpersonalcrisissituations?o Createdaplantokeepstaffandvolunteerturnoverlow?o Incorporatedmeasuresofhowwellyourprogramencouragesrelationshipbuildinginto
programassessment/evaluation?
84
ForOrganizationalLeaders
OrganizationalPracticesThatPromoteYouthDevelopmentSuccessfulyouthdevelopmentprogramsarebornoutofaculture,policies,resourcesandstructuresthatareestablishedbytheprogramprovider’sparentorganization.Asanyonewhohasstruggledwithtoofewresourcesormismatchedorganizationalprioritiesknows,thebeststaffintheworldworkingwiththedeepestknowledgeandunderstandingcannotcreatehighqualityexperiencesforyoungpeoplewithoutcertainorganizationalsupportsinplace.
Manyteachersandyouthworkershavenotedthatthekindsoforganizationalpracticesdescribedontheleftworkbestwhentheyareappliedconsistentlyatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Forexample,thesponsoringschooloragencymustcommittoholdinghigh,clear,andfairstandardsforthestaff,justastheydofortheyoungparticipants.Inthisway,staffexperiencewhattheyneedtosucceed,andthefunctioningoftheorganizationatamacro-levelmirrorsthefunctioningattheprogramlevel—everyone“walksthetalk.”Puttingtheseorganizationalpracticesinplacetakestime,energy,andresources.Inparticular,programstaffmusthavethetimeoutsideoftheirprogramdutiestotalktoeachother,talkinformallywithyoungpeople,gettoknowthecommunity,plan,evaluate,andlearn.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.Thefollowingaresuggestedorganizationalpracticesthatarerelatedtoyouthdevelopmentpractices.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
85
OrganizationalPracticesThatEncourage
RelationshipBuilding
LowYouthtoStaff/VolunteerRatioItiscrucialtohaveenoughadultsintheroomtoencouragerelationshipbuilding.Howmanyisenoughdependsonyouryoungpeopleandyourprogram,butthereisalimittohowmanyrelationshipsonestaffmembercansustainwhilefacilitatingprogramactivitiesandensuringrespectfulbehavioramongprogramparticipants.Planaheadforsituationswhereayoungpersonneedsimmediateone-on-oneattention.
Safe,Reliable,andAccessibleActivitiesandSpacesAfterschoolprogramsareoftenrelegatedtounusedanduncared-forspacesthatarepoorlyoutfittedandinappropriateforworkingwithyoungpeople.Opportunitiesforrelationshipbuildingcanbegreatlyaffectedbythenatureofaprogram’sphysicalspace.Whatisthenatureofyourspace?Isitdependableandreliableeachday?Doesitcommunicaterespectforprogramparticipantsandprogramstaff?Isthereacomfortableplaceforprogramparticipantstoparticipateinmeetings?Isitquietenough,freeenoughfrominterruptionsanddistractions,foryoungpeopletoexpressthemselves,feelheardandlistenedto?Doesthespaceallowforsmallgroupsofyoungpeopletoworkonprojects,andforadultsandyoungpeopletotalkquietlyone-to-oneifneeded?
ContinuityandConsistencyofCareYoungpeople,especiallyadolescents,needtotrustthatstaffmemberswillbethereforthembeforetheycanallowrelationshipstodevelop.Onaday-to-daybasisitisimportanttohaveabackupplanandsufficientstafftokeeptheprogramopenincaseofillnessorotherstaffabsence.Theturnoveramongadultstaffcanbedeeplyfeltbyyoungpeoplewhoinvestthemselvesinrelationshipswithadultprogramleaders.Organizationalleadersandprogramstaffshouldconsiderhowtoimplementpracticesandpoliciesthatsupporttherecruitmentandretentionofqualifiedstaffandvolunteers.
High,Clear,andFairStandardsYoungpeopleneedtoknowwhatisexpectedintermsoftheirbehaviortowardthemselvesandothers.Whenadultsholdhighexpectationsintermsofyoungpeople’sbehaviorandabilities,theyoungpeoplefeelrespectedandvalued.Standardsforyoungpeople’sbehaviorshouldbeclearlyandregularlycommunicatedalongwithclear,consistentconsequencesforviolations.Standardsaremorelikelytobeperceivedasfairifyoungpeoplehaveinputincreatingthem,iftheyareevenlyappliedtoallyoungpeopleandstaff,andiftherearegrievanceproceduresforyoungpeoplewhofeelunfairlytreated.Clearandfairalsomeansthattheadultsinandaroundtheprogramsknowandsupporttheprogramstandardsandexpectations.Inanafterschoolprogram,adultsinandaroundthe
86
programincludeclassroomteachers,administrators,andjanitorswhodonotparticipateintheprogramdirectly,butwhohavecontactwithprogramparticipantsinthebuilding.Supportingprogramexpectationsmeansholdingyoungpeopleaccountablefortheirbehavioranddoingitinawaythatmodelsthevalueofrespectingothers.Itisalsoimportanttonotethatexpectationsaroundhowadultstreatyoungpeoplearesometimesdifferentinanafterschoolprogramthanduringtheschoolday.
Ongoing,Results-basedStaffandOrganizational
ImprovementProcessRelationshipbuildingrequiresdetailedattentiontoindividualandinterpersonaldynamics.Staffmembersneedtohavetimetocommunicatewitheachotherandwithsupervisorsaboutwhatisgoingonwithvariousyoungpeople.Staffmembersalsoneedtraininginarangeofskillstoeffectivelybuildrelationships.Theseskillsincludecommunication,positivediscipline,facilitation,conflictresolution,andactivelistening.Itisalsoimportanttohaveaprocessfororganizationalimprovementthattakesyoungpeople’sinputintoaccount.
ProvidingOpportunitiesforRelationshipBuildingatall
LevelsoftheOrganizationEffortstoencouragerelationshipbuildingaremosteffectiveandmeaningfulwhentheyaremodeledatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Thismeansthatallstaffmembers,parents,andvolunteershaveopportunitiestogettoknoweachother,toreceiveemotionalandpracticalsupport,andtoreceiveguidancefrommoreexperiencedpeoplewhennecessary.Workingwithyoungpeopleinanafterschoolprogram,likeparenting,isemotionallydraining,andprogramleadersandvolunteersneedsupportfromtheirpeers.Staffmemberswhofeelisolatedinaprogramoragencywillquicklyburnoutandleave.Manyorganizationsprovideopportunitiesforstafftobuildsupportiverelationshipsthroughstaffandorganization-widesocialevents,regularstaffmeetings,andgroupandindividualcheck-ins.Otherwaystosupportstaffinbuildingrelationshipsincludeholdingregularsupportivesupervisionmeetings,structuringworksothatitisdoneinteams,andsendingstaffmemberstooutsidetrainingswheretheycanconnectwiththeirprofessionalcolleagues.
ReflectionArethereotherwaysyourorganizationcouldsupportstaffmembersinencouragingrelationshipbuilding?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
87
YOUTHPARTICIPATION
FOSTERING
MEANINGFULYOUTH
PARTICIPATION
Promotingleadership,decision-makingandasenseofbelonging.
Chapter
6
88
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
89
WhatisMeaningfulYouthParticipation?Whenprogramleadersspeakofyouthparticipation,theyareusuallyreferringtowhetheryoungpeopleshowupfortheprogramandthedegreetowhichtheybecomeengagedinprogramactivities.However,researchtellsusthatifwehopetomakeadifferenceinyoungpeople’sdevelopment,simpleparticipationisnotenough—weneedtoprovideopportunitiesformeaningfulyouthparticipation.Ifyoungpeopleareengagedinmeaningfulparticipation,theyareempoweredtobeself-directed,makeresponsiblechoicesabouthowtousetheirtime,andparticipateasgroupmembersinmakingdecisionsthatinfluencethelargerprogram.Theyarealsogiventheopportunitytolearngroupleadershipskillsandtoassumeleadershiprolesinplanningactivitiesandprojects.Theyhaveopportunitiesto“giveback”bycontributingtotheprogram,tootheryoungpeople,ortotheirlargercommunity.Weknowthatyoungpeopleexperiencetheirparticipationasmeaningfulwhentheyreportfeelingasenseofbelongingandownershipintheprogram.Whentheyareparticipatinginmeaningfulways,theyfeelthattheircontributionsarevalued,and,byparticipating,they“makeadifference.”Inaprogramthatfostersmeaningfulyouthparticipation,adultsserveasmentorsandfacilitatorstobuildtheskillsoftheyoungpeople.Whilethistakesdifferentformsdependingontheageoftheyoungpeopleinvolved,thegoaloffosteringmeaningfulparticipationisappropriateforallages,andespeciallyimportantifwehopetoengageandsupportadolescents.
90
Astudyofclassroomteachersrevealedthatwhenteachersrelyontraditionalwhole-classinstructionmethods,theteachersaretalkingmorethantwo-thirdsofthetime.Ofthistime,morethan70%isspentdisciplining,lecturing,givinginstructions,andaskingquestions.Whentheclassroomshiftstoamoreparticipatorystudent-centeredstructure,“teachertalk”timeisreducedto25%,and75%ofthistimeisspentpraising,encouraginginitiatives,givingfeedback,facilitatingstudentcommunication,andhelpingstudents.
PermissiontousegrantedbyJeanneGibbs,authorofTribes:ANewWayofLearningandBeingTogether.CenterSourceSystems,Sausalito,CA.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
91
WhyisMeaningfulYouthParticipationImportant?Resiliencyresearchaffirmsthatyoungpeople’smeaningfulparticipationservesasacoreprotectivefactorforyoungpeople.Inotherwords,regardlessoftheirindividualcircumstances,meaningfulparticipationhelpsyoungpeopleovercomerisksandobstaclesintheirlives,increasingtheirresiliency.Offeringyoungpeopleopportunitiesformeaningfulinvolvementandresponsibilityispartofcreatinganenvironmentthatconveyshighexpectations.Drawingontheirsubstantialbaseofresearch,theSearchInstituteemphasizestheimportanceofviewingyoungpeopleasresources.Wecandothisbygivingthemusefulroles,involvingtheminleadership,programplanningandothermeaningfulactivitiesrelatedtoprogramgovernance.
Increasingmeaningfulparticipationinaprogramtakescarefulplanningandcanpresentchallengesforprogramleaders.However,therearemanybenefitsfortheprogramaswellasforindividualyoungpeople.Whenyoungpeopleparticipateinplanningandimplementingtheirafterschoolprogram,theprogrambecomesmorealignedwiththeirinterests.Attendanceandinterestincrease,especiallyamongolderyouth,andthenewideasbroughtbytheyoungpeoplecanresultinnewandexcitingactivities.Asyoungpeoplebecomemoreinvolvedinarticulatingwhatisimportanttothem,programgoalsandobjectivescanbecomemoreyouth-centered.Asaresult,theprocessofprogramassessmentandevaluationbecomesmoremeaningfulforeveryoneinvolved.Asyoungpeopletakemoreresponsibilityfortheiractivities,staffmemberscanreducethetimespentondiscipline.Programstafffeelrewardedastheirrolechangesfromsupervisortofacilitator.Youngpeoplecanbegintotakeonleadershipandteachingrolesandworkinpartnershipwithadultstomaximizetheopportunitiesforlearningandgrowthforallparticipants.Whenwegiveyoungpeoplethetoolstobeself-directedandinvitethemtotakepartinshapingtheirprogramsandhelpingothers,wecommunicatethemessagetoyoungpeoplethat“whatyouthinkandwhatyoudomatters.”
FosteringMeaningfulYouthParticipationinYour
AfterschoolProgram
OrganizationalPracticesthatSupportMeaningfulYouth
Participation
Supportingmeaningfulyouthparticipationbeginswithsoundpoliciesandpracticesoftheorganizationthatemploysthestaffwhoworkwithyoungpeopledirectly.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.
92
StaffDiscussionsandPlanning
Promotingasenseofsafetywithinyourprogramrequiresdiscussionandconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.
ReadinessforMeaningfulYouthParticipation
Meaningfulparticipationisdependentonasolidleveloftrustbetweenadultsandyoungpeople.Participantsmustfeelsecurethatdifferencesinopinionsandvaryinglevelsofskillwillbeaccepted,andthattheirpeerleaderswillusetheirleaderstatuswithsensitivity.(SeetheprecedingchaptersonPromotingSafetyandEncouragingRelationshipBuilding.)Newlyformedgroupsneedtofirstestablishthemselvesandpacethelevelofparticipationwiththegroup’sdevelopment.(FormoreinformationaboutTribesTLC®,visitwww.tribes.com).Thelevelofparticipationalsodependsontheexperienceandskillsoftheadultprogramleadersandyoungpeopleinvolved.Importantskillsforadultleadersincludeactivelistening,groupfacilitation,techniquesforbuildingconsensus,projectplanningandconflictresolution.Programstrategieswillalsovarydependingontheageoftheyoungpeopleinvolved.Rememberthatitisequallyimportantforbothyoungchildrenandolderyouthtolearnskillsforgreaterself-relianceandtotakeonleadershiprolesinage-appropriateways.Foryoungerchildren,thismaybeassimpleasteachingthemaskillthatwillcontributetotheprogram(suchassweepingthefloor),orhelpingthemfigureouthowtheycanbestcontributetothegroup.Smallchildrenspendalotoftimereceivinghelpfromothers,andtheylovetoknowthewaystheycanbeself-sufficientorhelpfultoothers.
YouthParticipationwithAdultSupport
Teachersandyouthworkerswithlessexperiencemayconfuseyouthempowermentandleadershipstrategieswiththeabsenceofrulesandboundaries—”youhavetostepoutoftheway,lettheyoungpeopledowhattheywantandhopetheyfigureitout.”Thisapproachmayprove—atbest—highlyfrustratingfortheadultsandtheyoungparticipants.Whileitistruethatadultstaffmembersmustletgoofcontroloversomeaspectsofthegroup’sprocess,participantswillstillneedthefacilitativesupportofadultstaffandtheexpectationthatagreed-upongrouprulesmustcontinuetobehonored.
ChangeOverTime
Asolidplanforincreasingmeaningfulparticipationwillincludefadingfacilitationandcascadingleadership.Fadingfacilitationhappenswhenstrongadultleadersallowtheirpresencetorecedeintothebackgroundastheyoungpeoplebecomemorepreparedtotakeresponsibility.Onecanthinkoftheyouthleadersasapprentices,attimesneedingmoreorlesssupportfromtheiradultmentors,dependingontheirabilities.Cascadingleadershipoccurswhenyoungpeoplepasstheirleadershipontootherscomingupafterthem.Thisoftenhappensnaturallyinagroup,asyoungpeoplelookuptothoseafewyearsolderandpicturethemselvesinthesameroleinthenearfuture.Staffmemberscansupport
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
93
cascadingleadershipbygivingyoungerorlessexperiencedmembersofthegroupopportunitiestolearnleadershipskills,andbyencouragingolderormoreexperiencedmemberstopassontheirskillstoothers.
StylesofParticipation
Itisworthnotingthatyoungpeopleshowtheirparticipationindifferentwaysandthatdifferentculturesdefineparticipationdifferently.Someyoungpeoplemayliketolistenandlearnbeforesteppinguptotakeanactiverole,whileothersmaywanttoleaprightinandstartdoing.Insomecultures,participationisdemonstratedthroughquietattention.Youngpeople’sstyleofparticipationmayalsovarydependingontheirlearningstyleandpersonality.Forexample,somechildrenaremosteasilyengagedverbally,othersphysically,othersthroughartormusic.Itisimportanttobeawareofthedifferentculturesandstylesoftheindividualsinyourprogramwhenplanningopportunitiesforparticipation.
StylesofLeadership
Leadershipcanalsotakemanyforms.Teamcaptains,classpresidents,youngpeopleoncouncils,andyoungpeopleinpositionsofvisibilityareoftenpointedoutasleaders.However,notallyoungpeoplearegoingtotakeonsuchroles.Whenwerestrictourvisionofleadershiptotheperson“leadingthecharge,”weautomaticallylimitthenumberofyoungpeoplewhocanbeleaders.Amoreencompassingvisionofleadershipincludesthechildwhostaysafteranactivitytohelpclean,theonewhointerveneswithpeerstomediateadisagreement,thecommitteewhoplansaparty,andthepairwhocreatesaflyer.Groupscanexhibitleadershipwhentheyplantheirownactivitiesorwhentheyworkwithgroupsofyoungerchildren.
Thewisestaffmemberwillalsomakeuseofthenaturalleadershipabilityoftheclassclown,theleadersofgroupopinionandfashion,andeventheonewhoregularlyvoicesgroupresentments.Sometimesyoungpeoplearelabeled“trouble-makers”whentheyarereallyjustenergetic,orexpressinganeedtopracticetheirindependence.Whenyoungpeoplelackpositiveopportunitiesforleadership,theywilltakeonnegativeleadershiproles.Trygivingthemapositionofresponsibility.Letthemhelpayoungergroupwithanactivity,puttheminchargeofthejobchart,letthemteachaskillordistributethebasketballs.
94
ThingsYouCanDoNOWtoFoster
MeaningfulYouthParticipation
1.TrainParticipantsinGroupDecisionMakingSkills.
Agoodplacetostartistotrainyoungpeopleintheprocessofbrainstormingandgroupdecision-making.(SeeTribesTLC®forusefulguidanceonthistypeoftraining.)Groupdecisionmakingskillscanbeputtouseimmediatelyindevelopingtheneededgroupagreementsregardinghowpeoplewanttobetreated,howtheywillcarefortheirmaterialsandsupplies,etc.Makesureadultstaffmembershaveskillsforleadingbrainstormingsessionsandfacilitatinggroupdecision-makingbeforeyoustart.
2.EncourageSelf-RelianceandResponsibilitytotheGroup.
Allowyoungpeopletoresponsiblyaddresstheirownneeds,whetheritisaccesstothedrinkingfountainortoartsupplies.Designyourprogramspaceandstoragesysteminawaythatallowsyoungpeoplefreeaccesstoneededprojectsupplies,materialsandequipment.Theprivilegeofaccesscomeswithresponsibilitiesofcaringforandreturningthingstotheirproperplace.Brainstormtheneededagreementswithyourgrouptoensuretherespectfuluseofthesematerials.
3.GiveYoungPeopleChoices.
Youngpeoplefeelmoreinvolvedinaprogramwhentheyaregivenrealchoices.Scheduleprogramtimeswhentheyoungpeoplecanindividuallychoosewhattheywishtodo.Somemayprefergroupgames;othersmaywishtoworkalone,drawingorreading,whilesomemaysimplywanttosocialize.Youngpeoplecanparticipateinplanningprogramactivities.Youmaywanttostartwithasmallactivityorblockoftimethattheyareresponsibleforplanning,andthenbuildup.Letthemknowaboutanyconstraintsfromthebeginning.Withinthoseconstraints,trytoreallytrusttheirideasandenthusiasm.Ifaplannedactivitydoesn’twork,itpresentsanopportunityforthegrouptoanalyzeandlearn.Onceaprocessforreflectionhasbeenestablishedwiththeyoungpeopleinvolvedinplanning,itcanbeusedregularly.
4.ProvideOpportunitiesforYoungPeopletoHelpOthers.
Everyonefeelsmoreinvolvedwhentheyhaveresponsibilitiestothosearoundthemandareabletousewhattheyknowtohelpothers.Allowparticipantstoshareresponsibilitiesforthepropercareandmaintenanceoftheirprogramassets,makingandservingsnacks,andassistingpeerswithintheirprograms.Youngpeoplecanbetrainedtoeffectivelyassistpeersduringhomeworktimeandduringotheractivities.Trytogiveeverychildoryoungpersonanopportunitytohelpanother,sothatsomearen’talwaysinthehelperpositionandothersalwaysinthepositionof
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
95
beinghelped.Newcomerstotheprogramcanbeassignedbuddiestoshowthemaroundtheroom,explaingroundrules,andhelpthemlearntheroutine.Youcanalsoteachaskilltoasmallgroup,andthen“deputize”themtoteachothers.
Olderyoutharealsoexcellenthelpersforyoungerchildren,andthehelperroleoftenbringsoutthebestinthem.Dutiescanincludeservingas“readingbuddies,”homeworkhelpers,escorts,ormakinginformationalpresentationstotheyoungergroups.Providingservicetothelargercommunityisalsoanexcellentwayforyoungpeopletoapplytheirplanningandleadershipskills,whileexperiencinghowtheireffortsimpactothers.(SeeChapter7,ProvidingOpportunitiesforCommunityInvolvement,formoreaboutengagingyoungpeopleincommunityservice.)
5.InvolveYoungPeopleinServingonFormalDecision-
MakingBodies.Therearemanywaystoinvolveyoungpeopleinanorganization’sdecision-makingbodies.Theycanserveonplanning,safety,fundraising,hiringorothercommittees.Withexperienceandsupport,theycanalsoserveasyouthrepresentativesontheorganization’sBoardofDirectors.However,theplacetobeginisnotwiththeyoungpeople,butwiththeadultswithintheorganization.Aretheycommittedtotakingthetimeandefforttoinvolveyoungpeopleanddotheyhavetheskillstoknowhowtodothiseffectively?Beforeinvitingyoungpeopletoserveoncommitteesorboards,itisimportantfortheadultsinvolvedtodotheirhomework.Thismeansgatheringinformationandbuildingtheircapacitytofacilitatetheinvolvementofyoungpeopleindecision-makingandgovernance.Considerthenecessarytrainingtoprepareeveryoneforthisworkandgiveyourselvessufficienttimetopreparesothatyouwon’trushtheprocess.
96
HowDoYouKnow?
TakeYourProgram’sTemperature:Self-Assess
Youcanself-assessyourprogrambyusingobservationsandreflectionsurveyswiththeafterschoolstaffandyouthparticipants.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperienceswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromotepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiences.WhatYoungPeopleSay
Youngpeoplecantellyouiftheyhavepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessfortheseexperiencesistoasktheyoungpeopledirectlyabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatementsbelow?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
97
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:HowDoYouKnow?
DirectionsSelfassessyourprogramusingobservationsandsurveys.Youcanidentifyindicatorsthatwillallowstaffandyouthtoselfassessthedegreetowhichtheprogrampromotesmeaningfulyouthparticipation.Youcanuseindicatorsfromprogramqualitysurveys.Belowareafewsuggestionsofwhatyouwouldseeandwhatyouthwouldsay.
WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramsupportsmeaningfulparticipationwhenyouwalkintoaprogramroom,becausetheenvironmentsupportsself-directed,purposefulactivity.Examplesofwhatyoumightsee:
• Groupagreementsorguidelinesareposted,announcingtheyoungpeople’sownrulesabouthowtheywanttobetreatedandhowtheywillusetheirprogramspaceandmaterials.
• Everyoneiskeptinformedbyapostingoftheprogram’sactivityscheduleandupcomingevents,andanyindividualorgroupresponsibilitiesthathavebeenassigned.
• Theprogramscheduleallowstimeforparticipantstomakechoicesabouthowtheyusetheirtime.
• Therearedifferentareasfordoingdifferentkindsofwork,includingworkingindividuallyandingroups.
• Storageareasforsuppliesandmaterialsareclearlylabeledsoeveryonecanfindthemandputthemawaywhenfinished.
• Evidenceofyouth-runprojectsandartworkareprominentlydisplayed.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearriveandtheprogrambegins,youcanseeevidenceofmeaningfulparticipationinhowpeopleinteractwithoneanother:
• Transitionsinandoutoftheprogramspaceandbetweenactivitiesaresmoothbecauseyoungpeopleknowwhattodowithoutongoingadultdirection.
• Youngpeopleareworkingwithinterestonactivitiesandthereisanacceptanceofpurposefulnoiseandenergyintheclassroom.
• Youngpeoplearedirectingthemselves.Theyknowtoaskpeersandadultsforassistance,andhowtofindandcareforthematerialsandtoolstheyneed.
• Youngpeoplearetakingsignificantresponsibility,helpingeachother,leadingactivities,planningprojects,anddemonstratingleadershipskillslearnedwithintheprogram.
• Staffandvolunteersarelisteningtoideasfromyoungpeopleandarewillingtoincorporatechangesintheprogramaccordingly.
• Whenaskedforanswerstoproblemsorchallenges,staffandvolunteersoftenrespondbyposingaquestionthatwillhelptheyoungpersonfindtheanswerindependentlyorsensitivelyengageothersinidentifyingpossiblesolutionstotheoriginalquestion.
98
WhatYoungPeopleSayThemostreliablewaytoassessformeaningfulparticipationistoasktheyoungpeopleabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththefollowingstatements?
• Ihelpdecidewhathappenshere.• IoftengettochoosewhichactivitiesI’mgoingtodohere.• Ifeellikemyideascounthere.• Ihelpedsetrulesfortheprogram.• Ihavebeentheleaderofanactivityinthisprogram.• Ihavebeeninchargeofsuppliesorequipmentinthisprogram.• IfeellikeIbelonghere.• IfIdidn’tshowuphere,peoplewouldmissme.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
99
StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities
PromotingtheyouthdevelopmentexperiencesdetailedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0requiresconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.Belowaresometoolsforpromotingdiscussionwithyourstafforothersatyouragencyorschool.ThefollowingPersonalReflectionExercisesareagoodwaytosparkdiscussion.Ifthereisalocalyouthservingagencythatisknownfortheiremphasisonandsuccessinpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentforyoungpeople,youmaywanttoinvitesomeonefromthatagencyinasaguestspeakertoofferinspirationandsharetheirexperience.
100
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:PersonalReflection
MaterialsNeededo Paperandpencils
DirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelppeopleinyouragencyorschoolrememberwhatitwasliketobeyoung,andtobefacedwithchoicesorthelackofchoices.Itisagoodopeningtofocusthegroupontheimportanceoffosteringyouthparticipation.Beginbytellingparticipantsthatyouaregoingtodoapersonalreflection.Askthemtoclosetheireyes,andspendafewminutesthinkingabouttheirownexperience.Thenreadthefollowing:Thinkofoneofthechildrenoryoungpeopleinyourprogram.Nowthinkbacktowhenyouwerethatage,andtrytorememberyourexperiencesofschool.Whowasyourteacher?Whatkindsofthingsdidsheorhesaytoyou?Whatdidtheclassroomlooklike?Whatdidyouwear?Nowthinkforamomentabouthowyouparticipatedinthatsetting.
• Whatkindsofchoiceswereavailabletoyou?• Whatkindsofthingswereyouresponsibleforinthatsetting?• Ifyouneededsomething,howdidyoufulfillthatneed?Ifyouneededadrinkortouse
thebathroom,orapencil,howdidyougoaboutthis?• Whatkindsofthingscouldyoudowithoutadultdirection?• Whatkindsofthingsdidyouandyourpeersgettodecide?• Wereyouencouragedtopracticeindependence?Howdidyoureceiveguidancewhen
youfaltered?• Howweremistakesviewed?• Whenyouweren’tallowedtomakedecisions,whodid?Whatempoweredyoutomake
thosedecisions?Didyoucooperateorresist?• Whatdidyoudowhenyoudidn’tlikewhatwasgoingon?Whendidyoufully
participate?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
101
GroupDiscussionBeforeholdingagroupdiscussionyoumightwanttogivetheparticipantsanopportunitytowritedownsomehighlightsofwhattheylearnedinthePersonalReflectionExercise.Thenholdadiscussionusingthefollowingquestionstofacilitatesharingandlearningfromeachparticipant’sexperience.
• Whataresomeofthethingsthatyourememberedaboutyourownexperiencesasyouwerereflecting?
• Whymightitbeimportantforyoungpeopletohaveinputintodecisionsthataffectthem?
• Howmighttheygrowiftheyareallowedtotakeresponsibilityforfulfillingsomeoftheirownneedsandguidingsomeoftheirownactions?
• Whymightitbeimportantforthemtohaveopportunitiesforleadership?• Howdoesthisrelatetothedevelopmentaloutcomeswewantforallyoungpeople
(learningtobeproductive,tobeconnected,tonavigate)?Whatistheimpactonyoungpeoplewhentheyspendmuchoftheirtimeininstitutionsthatdon’treflecttheirinput?
102
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:LocatingOpportunities
MaterialsNeededo Flipchartorbutcherpapero Markers
DirectionsThisexercisewillhelpyourschooloragencylookfornewwaysyoungpeoplecanbeinvolvedinyourprogramsateveryage.Havestaffmembersbreakintosmallteams.Oneteamwillfocuson5-7year-olds,oneon8-10year-olds,andoneon11-14year-olds.(Ifyourprogramdoesn’tservealloftheseagegroups,focusontheagesyoudoserve.)Eachgroupbrainstormsanswerstothefollowingquestions:
• Whatthingscanchildreninyouragegroupdo?• Howcanwebuildontheseskillstodevelopparticipationandleadership?
GroupDiscussionHaveeachgroupsharetheiranswerswiththelargergroup.Discusshowyoumightincorporatetheseideasintoprogramactivities.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
103
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:Practitioner
AssessmentandLeadershipDevelopment
MaterialsNeededo PractitionerAssessmentofYouthParticipationandLeadershipDevelopment(1copyper
person).o ContinuumofYouthParticipation(1copyperperson).
DirectionsThisexerciseprovidesanopportunitytoexplorewhetheryourafterschoolprogramisprovidingoptimalopportunitiesformeaningfulyouthparticipation.Asagroup,lookattheContinuumofYouthParticipationonpage108.Considerwhereyourprogramfallsonthescale.Wherewouldyoulikeittofall?Howdoadults’roleschangeastheyoungpeople’sroleschange?GiveeachparticipantacopyofthePractitionerAssessmentofYouthParticipationandLeadershipDevelopmentonpage104and105.Askeachparticipanttogothroughtheexerciseandanswereachquestion.GroupDiscussionHaveadiscussionwhentheparticipantshavefinishedfillingoutthequestionnaire.Youmaywanttobeginthediscussionwithageneralquestionaskingparticipantswhattheylearnedwhenfillingoutthequestionnaire.Thiscouldbefollowedupwithafocusonspecificquestions.
104
HANDOUT
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:
PractitionerSelf-AssessmentPurpose:Toguideyouthroughthinkingabouttheopportunitiesthatyouprovideforyouthparticipationandleadershipdevelopment.1.Howdoyoumotivateyoungpeopletojoin?Totakeresponsibility?2.Doyougetyoungpeople’sinputintoactivityplanning?How?3.Doyougetyoungpeople’sinputintoprogramdesign?How?4.Doyougetyoungpeople’sfeedbackaftertheyhaveparticipatedinactivities?How?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
105
HANDOUTYOUTHPARTICIPATION:PractitionerSelf-Assessment5.Doyouensurethatyoungpeople’sinputhasimpactontheprogram?How?6.Doyouidentifypotentialleaders?How?7.Whattraining/assistance/supportmightyoungpeopleneedtotakeleadershiprolesinyourprogram?Isthissupportprovided? 8.Doyoungpeoplegetinvolvedinassessmentandevaluationdevelopment?9.Whatleadershiprolesdoyoungpeopletakeinyourorganization?Inyourprogram?(Interns?Staff?Boardmembers?Mentors?,etc.)
106
HANDOUT
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:AttitudinalPrinciplestoMaximizeYouthParticipationPurpose:Thisisausefulhand-outsummarizingguidelinestohelpstaffandvolunteersthinkabouttheirdailyinteractionswithyoungpeople.
• Nevergiveanorderordirectionwithoutareason.
Youngpeoplewillrecognizeyourauthorityaslegitimatewhenthereisareasonbehindwhatyouaskofthem.“BecauseIsaidso”isoneoftheworstthingsyoucansaytoayoungperson.
• Lookforplaceswhereyoungpeoplecantakeresponsibility.
Neverunderestimatethecapabilityofyoungpeople.Givingresponsibilitycreatesasenseofownershipandpride.Don’tforgetthelittleresponsibilitiessuchastakingattendanceandcleaningup.Assignrolesaccordingtointerestandtalent,andtrytobesurethereisaroleforeveryone.
• Makeprocessesexplicit.
Explainhowyoumakedecisionsandwhy(betteryet,involvetheyoungpeopleintheprocess).Bereadytoanswerquestionsaboutagencyorprogrampolicy,budget,andgoals.
• Allowforfailure.
Ofcourse,wehavearesponsibilitytopreventmajoraccidents.However,itcanbedisempoweringifwestepintooquicklytomakesureeverythingworksoutright.Sometimestheprocessandthelearningexperiencearemoreimportantthanreachingyouroriginalgoal.Besuretohelpyoungpeopleanalyzesetbacksinsuchawaythattheybecomelearningexperiences.
• Practicecommoncourtesywithyoungpeople.Youngpeopledeservethesamecourteoustreatmentwewouldgiveparents,supervisors,orfunders.Listentothelanguageyouusewhenspeakingtoparticipants.
• Approachtheworkwithhumility.
Thismeansbeingwillingtoletgoofourideasaboutwhatthegroupshouldbedoing,orwhatthegoalsshouldbe.Italsomeansnotbeingoverlyinvestedinhowmuchyoungpeoplelikeourideasorus.Wehavetobeabletoletgoofourplansandletrelationshipsdevelopattheirownspeediftheyoungpeoplearetotakethelead.Ontheotherhand,itisimportanttoknowwhentobeanadult,steppingintoprotectvulnerablemembersofthegroup,forexample.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
107
HANDOUT
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:StepsTowardIncreasingMeaningfulYouthParticipationPurpose:Youcanusethislistandassesswhereyourprogramisonthefollowingcontinuum:
• Gettingyoungpeopleinvolvedinstatinggoals/needs• Gettingyoungpeopleinvolvedinactivityplanning• Gettingyoungpeopleinvolvedinprogramassessment/evaluation• Identifyingleadersinthegroup• Trainingyoungpeopleinleadershipskills(facilitation,conflictresolution,peer
counseling,advocacy,activityplanninganddesign)• Havingyoungpeopletrain,recruitandsupporteachother(olderyouthtrainand
supportyoungeryouth)• Involvingyoungpeopleinprogramplanning/strategicplanning,evaluation,
development,staffhiring,and/ordevelopingprogramgoals• PlacingyoungpeopleontheBoardofDirectorsorothergoverningbodies
108
HANDOUT
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:
ContinuumofYouthParticipation
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
109
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:
StudentSurveyofProgramPreferences
DirectionsThisisasurveyofyoungpeople’sinterestswhichyoucancustomizeforyourprogram.Weneedyourhelp!Wewanttocreateanafterschoolprogramthatisexcitingandusefulforyou.Pleaseanswerthefollowingquestionstotellusaboutyouropinionsandideasforafterschoolactivities.Ifyouwouldliketogetevenmoreinvolvedinplanningafterschoolactivities,orbeingaclubofficer,askyourteacherformoreinformationabouttheafterschoolprogram.1.Pleasecheckthesentencethatbestdescribesyourfeelingsaboutattendingan
afterschoolprogramatourschool.(checkone)
o Ialreadyparticipateinafterschoolactivities.o Iwoulddefinitelybeinterestedingoingtoanafterschoolprogramatourschool.o Ihaveotherresponsibilitiesafterschoolandcouldnotgotoanafterschoolprogramat
ourschool.o Iamnotinterestedingoingtoanafterschoolprogramatourschool.
2.Whatkindofactivitieswouldyouliketodoafterschool?Feelfreetoaddyourown
ideas.(checkuptofour)
o Chesso Communityserviceo ComputerClubo Homeworkhelpor
tutoringo JuniorAchievemento Photographyo Poetrywritingo Schoolnewspapero Scienceexperimentso Aerobicexerciseo Basketball
o Cheerleadingo Gymnasticso Martialartso Soccero Softball/baseballo Volleyballo Yogao Artsandcraftso Cardandboard
gameso Cookingo Dance
o Dramao Fieldtripso Musico Peercounseling/
conflictresolutiono Woodworkingo Youridea:___________________o Youridea:___________________o Youridea:__________________
3.Whataresomewaysyouwouldliketogetinvolvedintheafterschoolprogram?
(checkallthatapply)
o Decidingwhatprogramstooffero Planningafterschoolactivitieso Beingaclubofficero Advertisingtheafterschoolprogramo Youridea:____________________________________________________o Iamnotinterestedingettinginvolved.
110
4.Whichtypesof“advertisement”wouldconvinceyoutoparticipateintheafterschool
activities?(checkallthatapply)
o Student-designedposterso Flyersmailedhomeo Presentationsbystudentswhoareintheafterschoolprogramo Articlesabouttheprogramintheschoolnewspapero Dailyannouncementsabouttheprogram(readbyanadult)o Dailyannouncementsabouttheprogram(readbyastudent)o Rewards—suchashomeworkpasses,giftcertificates,orothertreats—forstudentswho
regularlyattendactivities.o Youridea:____________________________________________________o Youridea:____________________________________________________
Yourname:______________________________________________________________
ThankYou!
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
111
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:StaffTrainingTopics
DirectionsCreateastaffdevelopmentplanthatincludestrainingtopicsthatwouldensurethattheyoungpeopleinyourprogramhaveopportunitiesformeaningfulyouthparticipation.Togetherwithyourstaffandprogramleadership,identifytrainingtopicsthatarerelatedtoyouthparticipation.Belowareafewsuggestions:
• Groupdecision-makingprocesses• Activelistening• ProjectPlanning• GroupFacilitation• Teachingconflictresolutiontoyoungpeople• Teachingfacilitationskillstoyoungpeople• Childandadolescentdevelopment• Peereducation• Resistingageism
112
YOUTHPARTICIPATION:
ChecklistforAction
DirectionsDocumentwhatstepstheprogramhasmadetopromotemeaningfulyouthparticipation.Thischecklistwillhelpyoustayfocusedandorganizedasyoubegintomakemeaningfulyouthparticipationapriorityinyourprogram.
Haveyou:
o Setasideongoingstafftimetothoroughlyplanforfosteringmeaningfulyouthparticipationandleadershipdevelopment?
o Assessedtheneedforstaffdevelopmentandplannedfortraining?o Assessedyourschooloragency’sorganizationalpracticestoseeiftheysupport
meaningfulyouthparticipation?o Lookedathowyouragencyorschoolallocatesresources(time,space,money)tosupport
meaningfulyouthparticipation?o Askedtheyoungpeopleabouttheirinterestsandtheirideasforprogramming?o Plannedwaystoensurethatyoungpeople’sinputaffectsprogramming?o Definedspecificallyhowyouexpectyouthparticipationactivitiestopositivelyimpact
youngpeople?o Plannedwaysfordifferentstylesofleadershiptoemerge?o Identifiedleadershippotentialinyoungpeopleofdifferentages,styles,and
personalities?o Identifiedskillsyoungpeoplewillneedtotakeonleadershiproles?o Scheduledtimeforrecognitionandreflection?o Plannedtotrainyouthintheseskills?o Plannedforfadingfacilitation?o Preparedyoungpeopleforcascadingleadership?o Createdwaysforyoungpeopletoparticipateinprogramevaluation?o Incorporatedoutcomesrelatedtofosteringmeaningfulyouthparticipationintoprogram
evaluation?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
113
ForOrganizationalLeaders
OrganizationalPracticesThatPromoteYouthDevelopmentSuccessfulyouthdevelopmentprogramsarebornoutofaculture,policies,resourcesandstructuresthatareestablishedbytheprogramprovider’sparentorganization.Asanyonewhohasstruggledwithtoofewresourcesormismatchedorganizationalprioritiesknows,thebeststaffintheworldworkingwiththedeepestknowledgeandunderstandingcannotcreatehighqualityexperiencesforyoungpeoplewithoutcertainorganizationalsupportsinplace.
Manyteachersandyouthworkershavenotedthatthekindsoforganizationalpracticesdescribedontheleftworkbestwhentheyareappliedconsistentlyatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Forexample,thesponsoringschooloragencymustcommittoholdinghigh,clear,andfairstandardsforthestaff,justastheydofortheyoungparticipants.Inthisway,staffexperiencewhattheyneedtosucceed,andthefunctioningoftheorganizationatamacro-levelmirrorsthefunctioningattheprogramlevel—everyone“walksthetalk.”Puttingtheseorganizationalpracticesinplacetakestime,energy,andresources.Inparticular,programstaffmusthavethetimeoutsideoftheirprogramdutiestotalktoeachother,talkinformallywithyoungpeople,gettoknowthecommunity,plan,evaluate,andlearn.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.Thefollowingaresuggestedorganizationalpracticesthatarerelatedtoyouthdevelopmentpractices.
114
OrganizationalPracticesthatFosterMeaningful
YouthParticipation
YouthInvolvementattheOrganizationalLevelItiscriticaltoinvolveyoungpeopleinprogramplanningasyourschooloragencyinitiatesitsafterschoolprogram,inon-goingimplementationactivities,andinprogramassessment.Youngpeoplecanofferinputinbrainstormingorgroupplanningsessions,onsurveys,orasrepresentativesinagencyorprogramplanningsessions.Theycanplan,co-lead,orleadactivitiesastheirinterestsandskillsallow.Theycanhelpsetgoalsfortheprogramandparticipateinprogramevaluation.Whenyoungpeoplearepresentandinvolvedateverystage,programsareboundtobetterreflecttheirinterests.Particularattentionshouldbepaidtohowyouinvolveyoungpeopleinplanninganddecisionmakingsettingswherethemajorityoftheparticipantsareadults.Itishighlyrecommendedthatadultplanningparticipantsbetrainedinhowtoeffectivelymakeroomforandengageyoungpeopleinplanninganddecision-making.
ProvidingOpportunitiesforMeaningfulParticipationatall
LevelsoftheOrganizationStrategiesforfosteringyouthparticipationaremosteffectivewhenmeaningfulparticipationismodeledatalllevelsofthesponsoringschooloragency.Thismeansthatallstaffmembers,parents,andvolunteersinvolvedintheafterschoolprogramhaveopportunitiesfordecision-making,leadership,andbelonging.Inparticularitisimportantforpeopletohaveinputintothedecisionsthatwillaffectthem,andforevaluationandplanningeffortstoconsidertheexpertiseanduniqueperspectiveofallstakeholders.Organizationscanprovidetheseopportunitiesbyensuringthatplanningcommitteesincludemanyperspectivesandthatevaluationeffortsreceiveinputfromdiversestakeholders.Implementingsite-baseddecision-making,creatingparentinvolvementcommittees,andholdingagencyorprogram-widesocialeventsalsoofferopportunitiesformeaningfulparticipationbystaff,parents,andothers.
FlexibilityinAllocatingResourcesFlexibilityinallocatingresourcesisclearlyimportantinprovidingopportunitiesformeaningfulyouthparticipation.IfprogramparticipantswantaDJcluborahip-hopdanceclassandyouhavefundingonlyforasoccerclass,itisgoingtobedifficulttoengagetheseyoungpeople.Whenyouaskyoungpeopleabouttheactivitiestheywant,letthemknowwhatthefinanciallimitationsareupfront.Ifyoungpeopledocomeupwithideasthatcan’tbeimplemented,givethemhonestreasonswhytheirsuggestionscan’tbeputintopractice.
AccessibleSpaceProvidingaccessiblespaceisfundamentaltosupportingyouthparticipation.Thismeanspreparingthespacesoyoungpeoplecanuseitasindependentlyaspossible.Thereisanimportantdifferenceforyoungpeoplewhentheycangetthepaintsthemselvesandstart
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
115
painting,ratherthanhavingtoaskanadult.(Imagineiftheadultstaffhadtoasktheirsupervisoreverytimetheyneededtousethestapler).Preparingthespacemaymeanloweringshelves,teachingyoungpeopletheproperuseofmaterials,andcreatingsignsorwrittendirectionsforuse.Italsomeansmakingthespacelooklikeaplaceforyoungpeople,wheretheycanlaugh,makeamess,puttheirfeetup.
LowYouthtoStaff/VolunteerRatioAnappropriatelylowyouthtostaff/volunteerratioisalsoimportanttomaintainingmeaningfulparticipation.Thefactthatyoungpeoplecanincreasetheirindependenceandtakeonleadershiprolesdoesnotmeanthattheydon’tneedadultsupport.Itsimplymeansthattheadultroleshiftsfrombeingtheleadertoprovidingtheconsiderablesupportnecessarytomaintainyouthleadership.
Ongoing,Results-BasedStaffandOrganizational
ImprovementProcessTheabilityofanagencyorschooltoengageyoungpeopleinmeaningfulparticipationdependsontheorganizationallocatingtimeforprogramplanningandreflection,providingtrainingopportunitiesforadults,andimplementingaprocessforauthenticprogramassessmentandevaluation.Involvingyoungpeopleiscriticaltoassessingtheimpactofyourprogram.Themostaccuratewaytomeasureprogramqualityistoaskyoungpeopleabouttheirexperienceswithintheorganization.Youngpeoplecanalsobeinvolvedinthedesignoftheassessmentorevaluation.Waystoinvolveyoungpeopleinassessmentinclude:
• Engagingyoungpeopleindevelopingandreviewingthemeasurableindicatorsofmeaningfulyouthparticipation,safety,positiverelationships,challenginglearningexperiences,andopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvement.Askyoungpeoplewhatthesetermsmeantothemandwhattheywouldlookfortomeasureprogramqualityintheseareas.Askthemwhattheythinkisimportantabouttheprogramsinwhichtheychoosetoparticipate.
• Involvingyoungpeopleinpilotingassessmentsurveys.Feedbackfromyoungpeoplewillensurethatassessmentsurveyquestionscarrythesamemeaningsfortheyoungpeoplesurveyedastheydofortheadultswhodevelopedthetool.Pilotingsurveyswithyoungpeoplewillensurethatthelanguageisappropriateforthosebeingsurveyed.Also,youngpeopleoftengiveexcellentfeedbackonhowtomakethesurveyseasierandmoreinterestingtouse.
116
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
117
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT
PROVIDING
OPPORTUNITIESFOR
COMMUNITY
INVOLVEMENT
Helpingyoungpeopleconnecttothecommunity.
Chapter
7
118
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
119
WhatIsCommunityInvolvement?Providingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementinafterschoolprogramsmeansofferingyoungpeopleactivitiesthatincreasetheirknowledgeoftheircommunitiesandpromoteasenseofpositivebelongingtothecommunity.Communityknowledgeincludeslearningaboutthecommunity’shistory,itspeopleandthediverseculturestheyrepresent,anditsresources.Itmayalsoincludelearningaboutthereallifechallengesthecommunityanditsresidentsface.Opportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementallowyoungpeopletogivebacktoothersthroughcommunityserviceactivities.Foryoungpeoplethismeansmovingfromtheirmoreusualroleofbeinghelpedtobeingsomeonewhocancapablyhelpothersandpromotechange.Forprogramleaders,providingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementrequiresfindingwaystobringthecommunityintotheafterschoolprogram.Onewaytodothisistorecruitcommunitymemberstointroduceyoungpeopletotheirculturalhistoriesandtraditions,tosharetheirtalentsandexperiencesthroughpresentations,toteachclasses,ortoserveasvolunteermentorsortutors.Creatingtheseopportunitiesalsorequirestakingtheafterschoolprogram“beyondtheprogramwalls,”outtothecommunity.Thismeanscreatingopportunitiesforyoungpeopletomeetcommunityleadersandresidents,toexplorethecommunity,andtoresearchtheproblemsfacedbythecommunityandidentifywaysthattheycanactivelybepartofthesolution.
120
WhyisCommunityInvolvementImportant?Researchonchildhoodresiliencyandyouthdevelopment,aswellasstudiesonthepreventionofhighriskbehaviors,affirmstheimportanceofyoungpeoplefeelingaconnectiontotheircommunity.Further,involvementinactiveandusefulrolesinservicetoothersis“associatedwithhigherself-esteem,enhancedmoraldevelopment,increasedpoliticalactivism,andtheabilitytocreateandmaintaincomplexsocialrelationships.”
Inadditiontocontributingtoyoungpeople’shealthydevelopmentovertime,communityinvolvementcanalsohelpprogramsmeettheirmoreimmediateoutcomes.Communityinvolvementcanofferyoungpeopletheopportunitytolearnabouttopicsthatarenotusuallypartoftheschooldaycurriculum.Thiscanincreaseyoungpeople’sengagementintheafterschoolprogram.Thisisparticularlytruewhentopicsarekeyedtotheirowninterests.Whenyoungpeoplecanseetheconnectionsbetweentheprogramactivitiesandtheirownlivesinthecommunity,theirinterestandmotivationtoparticipateisenhanced.Astheymeetandlearnaboutpeopleinthecommunitywhoaredifferentthanthemselves,theydevelopagreaterunderstandingandappreciationfordiversity.Whenactivities,suchasyouth-ledcommunityserviceprojects,requirethatyoungpeopleworktogethertoaccomplishtheirgoals,participantshavetheopportunitytolearnandmasterimportantlifeskills.Theseincludespecificskillsincommunication,problemsolving,decision-making,andthemanycollaborativeskillsnecessaryforsuccessfulteamwork.Astheirgroupsexperiencesuccess,youngpeopleformdeeperbondswiththeirpeersandtheircommunity.Perhapsmostimportantly,activitiesthatinvolveservicetoothersallowyoungpeopletofeelvaluedforthecontributionstheymake.Youngpeoplearenottheonlyoneswhobenefitwhentheyengageinameaningfulwaywithcommunityresidentsandorganizations.Whenadultsandcommunitymembershavepositiveexchangeswithyoungpeople,everyonerevisitstheirstereotypesofthe“other.”Adultsaremorelikelytoholdapositiveviewofyoungpeople,voicetheirsupportforresourcesdedicatedtoyoungpeople,andevendecidetoplayanactiveroleinsupportingtheneedsofyoungpeople.Inmanycommunities,therearesignificantbarriersbetweenthecommunityresidentsandtheirpublicschools.Afterschoolprogramscanbreakdownthesebarriersbyinvitingcommunityagenciesandresidentsintotheirschool-basedprograms,workingto“bringthepublicbackintopublicschools.”Communitymembersbringspecializedknowledge,wisdom,newperspectivesandvaluableexperiences.Theyserveasresourcesforprogramstaff,aswellasyoungparticipants.Finally,whenweprovideopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvement,weaffirmthatyoungpeoplearecriticalassetstothecommunitiesinwhichtheylive.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
121
ProvidingOpportunitiesforCommunity
InvolvementinYourAfterschoolProgram
OrganizationalPracticesThatSupportCommunity
Involvement
Supportingcommunityinvolvementbeginswithsoundpoliciesandpracticesoftheorganizationthatemploysthestaffwhoworkwithyoungpeopledirectly.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.
StaffDiscussionsandPlanning
Promotingasenseofsafetywithinyourprogramrequiresdiscussionandconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.
BeliefsAboutYoungPeople
Itisimportantforthestafftoreflectontheirunderlyingbeliefsaboutyoungpeopleandtheirreadinessandinterestinservingthecommunity.Inwantingtoprotectandteachyoungpeople,adultsoftenoverlookopportunitiesforyoungpeopletoassumerolesthatcanbringthemasenseofvalue.Theseopportunitiespromoteanimportant“Icandoit.Imakeadifference.”attitude.Howdoyouradultstaffviewyoungpeople?Doesstaffseeyoungpeopleasproblemsabouttohappen,asaresourcetobedevelopedforfutureuse,orasacommunityresourcethatcanmakeadifferencenow?
ConsideringtheManyWorldsWithinaSingleCommunity
Beginbyworkingwiththeyoungpeopletocreateageographicdefinitionofwhatyoumeanby“community.”Onceyouallagreeonageographicdefinition,itisimportanttorememberthatpeople’sexperienceofthisgeographiccommunitymaybeverydifferent.Forinstance,youngpeoplewhoarerecentimmigrantsandwhoprimarilyinteractwithneighborsandbusinessestablishmentsthatsharetheirculturalbackgroundmayhaveaverydifferentexperienceofcommunitythanyoungpeoplewhoarenative-bornEnglish-speakers.Whenplanningforcommunityinvolvementinanafterschoolprogram,considerthemanydifferentaffiliationsyouryoungpeoplemayhaveandallowtimetoexplorethesedifferences.
122
Beforeconsideringwaystoincreaseyoungpeople’sinvolvementwiththesurroundingcommunity,itisagoodideatoconductsomegroupdiscussionsabouthowdifferentpeopleexperiencetheircommunity.Whatarethedifferentaffiliationsyouryoungpeoplehave?Youngpeople’scommunitiesmaybeorganizedaroundmusicscenes,sportsteams,clubs,ortherecreationalactivitiestheyfeelhelpdefinethem.Whatarethedifferentaffiliationsyouryoungpeoplehave?Howdoesthisdifferfromthoseofyouradultstaff?Rememberthatpeopleofdifferentageswillalsodefinecommunityandcommunityneedsdifferently.ItisnotsurprisingthatwhenagroupofyoungpeopleinAlameda,Californiamountedasuccessfulpublicsupportcampaigntobuildanewkindofpublicpark,itwasanoutdoorskateboardparkthattheyenvisioned.(Imaginehowdifferenttheoutcomewouldhavebeenifseniorcitizensorparentsofnewinfantsweregiventhechargeofdesigninganewparkforthecommunity.)Youmightusealargewallmaptoidentifytheareasofthecommunitythatyourparticipantsaremostandleastfamiliarwith.Perhapsyoucanidentifytheareasaboutwhichtheyoungpeoplewouldliketolearnmore.Iseveryonefamiliarwiththelargercommunity’s“mainstream”resources,suchasthemuseums,artcenters,parks,andseniorcitizencenters?Whatabouttheresourcesthat“insiders”ofdifferentgroupscansharewithyoungpeople,suchassmallculturalartstheatresfocusedonpreservingagroup’scultureandtraditionsorgroupsworkingonaparticularcommunityissue?Aretherewaystointroduceyoungpeopletootherinformalresources,suchasthespecialtystoresanddeliciousrestaurantsinparticularethnicareasofthecommunity?Aretherelocalresidentswhohaveamazingexperiencesandstoriestotellorspecialtalentsaboutwhichfewknow?
InvolvingYoungPeopleinDesigningServiceProjects
Programleadersoftenviewcommunityserviceasprojectsthatadultsplanandyoungpeopledo.However,thisapproachfailstodrawupontheperspectivesandinterestsofyoungpeople.Whentheprojectideascomefromtheprogramparticipants,theyaremoreinterestedintheprojectandthishelpsbuildanaturalmomentumforprojectactivities.Keepinginmindthathowyougatheryoungpeople’sinputwilldependontheage,interests,andstructureofthegroup,hereareafewsuggestions:
• Beginwithaconversationaboutcommunity.Asktheyoungpeopleinyourprogramhowtheydefinecommunity.
• Bealerttotheinterestsoftheyoungpeopleinyourprogram.Aretherewaystoconnecttothecommunitythroughtheseinterests?
• Involvefamiliesindiscussionsaboutcommunity,inplanningforcommunityinvolvement,andintheactualactivitiesyouplan.Theyareanimportantresource,andcankeeptheideaofcommunityaliveathome.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
123
• Youngpeoplemaybeinspiredifyouletthemknowthattheirhelpisneededinthecommunity.Letyourenthusiasmshowandpointoutfrequentlythecontributionstheyaremaking,whetherbigorsmall.Ensurethatothersoutsideoftheprogramknowoftheirworkandrecognizetheireffortspublicly.
StartSmall
Asyouprepareforincreasingopportunitiesforcommunity,itisagoodideatostartsmall,andbuildonyoursuccesseswithlargerefforts.Thisistrueforinvolvingcommunitymembersorgroupsinyourprogram.Itisagoodideatogivenewcommunitypartners,whetherindividualsorgroups,relativelysmallresponsibilitiesuntilyoufindouthowtheyworkwithyourprogram.Ensurethattheyarerecognizedandappreciatedfortheircontributions.Itisalsotrueinbeginningserviceprojects.Youngpeoplecanbediscouragediftheirfirstprojectistoobiginscopeandtheydon’tseeresultsquicklyenough.
DotheNecessaryHomework
Whencommunityinvolvementactivitiesincludecommunityserviceprojects,itisimportantthatyoungpeoplehaveachancetounderstandtheunderlyingissuestheirserviceismeanttoaddress.Forexample,ifstudentsplantohelpcleanupalocalplayground,theycouldspendsometimeexploringquestionssuchas:“Whatistheimpactoflitteronourcommunity?”“Wherearethesafeplacesforchildrentoplayinthisneighborhood?”and“Whywasthisplaygroundallowedtobecomesodirty?”Thisprocessteachesyoungpeopletothinkcriticallyandexerciseproblem-solvingskillsevenastheybecomepartofthesolution.Youngpeople,likeadults,willbringtheirownsetofbeliefsandassumptions,alongwithconcreteknowledgeoftheparticularissue,toanyserviceproject.Allowtheyoungpeopletodoresearchsotheycantesttheirassumptions.Inconsideringsolutions,findoutwhatexistingcommunitygroupsarealreadydoingtotackletheseproblems.Whatotherstrategieshavealreadybeentried?Howcantheyoungpeopleimaginecontributingtotheeffort?Forexample,byinterviewingpeopleatahomelessshelter,youngpeoplefromoneafterschoolprogramlearnedthattheiroriginalideaofcollectingcannedfoodwasn’twhatwasmostneeded.Shelterresidentstoldthemthattheirmorepressingneedwaswarmclothing,especiallycoatsandgloves,forthecomingwinter—somethingthathadnotoccurredtotheprogram’syoungpeopleoradultstaff.Withthisnewinformation,theyoungpeopleenthusiasticallychangedtheirprojectaccordingly.Whenyoungpeoplelearntotakeathoughtfulapproachtoaddressingproblems,theybecomepreparedtofunctionasleadersincreatingeffectivecommunitysolutions.
124
ThingsYouCanDoNOWtoIncrease
CommunityInvolvement1.Inviteaspeakerfromthecommunitytocometoyour
program.Thiscanbemosteffectivewhenthetopicislinkedtosomethingthestudentsarestudyinginschool,ortoaprojecttheyareworkingonintheprogram.Forexample,iftheyarelearningabouttheCivilRightsmovement,youmightinviteneighborswholivedthroughthosedaystotalkaboutwhatitwaslike.Iftheyarestudyingbutterflies,youmightfindalocalentomologisttovisit.Firefightersandotherpeoplewithexcitingjobsarealwayswelcomespeakers.Communitycolleges,museums,parks,volunteercenters,communitycenters,andeventhephonebookareallgoodplacestostartlookingforspeakers.
2.Encourageparents,oldersiblings,andneighborsofthe
schooltobecomeinvolvedintheprogram.Parentscanprovidewonderfulsupportforculturalactivities.Membersofthecommunitymightvolunteerastutors,mentors,orforsnackpreparationorstoryreading.Oldersiblingsandrecentprogramgraduatescanserveastutorsorhelpers,andthiscanprovidealinkbetweenthehighschoolsandmiddleschool-agedyouth.Thesevolunteerswillrequiretrainingandsupport,buttheinvestmentpaysoffinadecreasedyouth/adultratioandinincreasedrelationshipbuildingopportunitiesfortheyoungpeople.
3.Invitethecommunityintoyourprogramtocelebratethe
talentsofyouryoungpeople.Stageanopenhouseorperformanceatyourprogramspace.Shareyoungpeople’sart,theater,dance,music,orotherperformancewiththecommunity.Publishanewsletter,‘zine,orcollectionofpoetry.Inviteparentsandneighborstoseehowyourprogramworks.Thisisonewaytoletyouryoungpeopleshineandgivebacktothecommunityatthesametime.
4.Getoutofthebuilding!
Anytimeyouleavefamiliarspaceyouareallowingyoungpeopletoexpandtheirhorizons.Takeafieldtriptoaregionalparkormuseum.Visitalocalestablishment,service,orbranchofgovernmenttolearnhowitworks.Attendaprogramoractivityatalocalnon-profitorganizationsuchastheRedCross,SierraClub,asocialjusticeorcivilrightsorganization,oralocalartscenterorlibrary.Practiceusingpublictransportation,andletyoungpeoplehelpfigureouthowtogetwhereyouaregoing.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
125
5.Planaprojectthatwillbenefitthecommunity.
Cleanuporplanttreesorflowersatalocalpark,speakoutatapublicforumonayouthorcommunityissue,visiteldersattheseniorcenter,servesnacksataneighborhoodfair,designandpaintamural…thepossibilitiesareendless!Trytomatchprojectstotheinterestsoftheyoungpeople,andlookforexistingprogramsthatcanhelpyouprepareyoungpeopleforameaningfulexperience.
126
HowDoYouKnow?
TakeYourProgram’sTemperature:Self-Assess
Youcanself-assessyourprogrambyusingobservationsandreflectionsurveyswiththeafterschoolstaffandyouthparticipants.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperienceswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromotepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiences.WhatYoungPeopleSay
Youngpeoplecantellyouiftheyhavepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessfortheseexperiencesistoasktheyoungpeopledirectlyabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatementsbelow?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
127
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:HowDoYouKnow?
DirectionsSelfassessyourprogramusingobservationsandsurveys.Youcanidentifyindicatorsthatwillallowstaffandyouthtoselfassessthedegreetowhichtheprogrampromotescommunityinvolvement.Youcanuseindicatorsfromprogramqualitysurveys.Belowareafewsuggestionsofwhatyouwouldseeandwhatyouthwouldsay.WhatYouSeeYoucanseethatyourprogramoffersyoungpeopleopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementbylookingatwhoisintheroomandwhatishappening.Examplesofwhatyoumightsee:
• Thereareobjectsandwalldisplaysthatreflecttheprogram’sinterestinthesurroundingneighborhoodandcommunity:neighborhoodmaps,itemsreflectingtheculturaldiversityofthecommunity,listingsofcommunityresources.
• Thereareavarietyofcommunityresidents,familymembersandagencyworkerswhoparticipateintheprogramaspresenters,instructors,volunteertutorsandmentors,andinotherways.
• Programparticipantsaretravelingbeyondtheprogramsite,outtothecommunitytomeetpeopleandlearnaboutthecommunity’sresourcesandneeds.
• Programactivitiesincorporateopportunitiesforyoungpeopletolearnaboutculturesandcommunitiesdifferentfromtheirown.
• Youngpeopleareactivelyinvolvedinresearchingthechallengesfacedbytheircommunity,andhowbesttheycancontributetoaddressingtheissues.
• Youngpeopleareengaginginprojectsthatmaketheircommunitiessafer,morebeautiful,fun,caring,andjust.
• Youngpeoplearethinkingcriticallyaboutproblemsintheircommunity,andactingtoparticipateinsolutions.
WhatYoungPeopleSayThemostreliablewaytoassesswhetheryourcommunityinvolvementeffortsaresuccessfulistoasktheyoungpeopleabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Whenasked,youngpeopleinanafterschoolprogramthatmakescommunityinvolvementaprioritymightsay:
• I’vehadachancetodothingstohelppeopleinmycommunity.• InthisprogramIgettogoplacesthatIdon’tusuallygo.• Inthisprogram,I’velearnedaboutthingsthatyoungpeoplecandoinmycommunity.• Iknowmoreaboutwhatisgoingoninmycommunity.• IknowmoreabouthowtogetthingsIneedinmycommunity.• I’velearnedaboutwaysIcanmakethingsbetterinmycommunity.
128
StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities
PromotingtheyouthdevelopmentexperiencesdetailedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0requiresconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.Belowaresometoolsforpromotingdiscussionwithyourstafforothersatyouragencyorschool.ThefollowingPersonalReflectionExercisesareagoodwaytosparkdiscussion.Ifthereisalocalyouthservingagencythatisknownfortheiremphasisonandsuccessinpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentforyoungpeople,youmaywanttoinvitesomeonefromthatagencyinasaguestspeakertoofferinspirationandsharetheirexperience.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
129
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:Personal
ReflectionDirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelppeopleidentifywhatmakescommunityinvolvementrelevant.Itisagoodopeningtofocusthegroupontheimportanceofcommunityinvolvement.Beginbytellingparticipantsthatyouaregoingtodoapersonalreflection.Askthemtoclosetheireyes,andspendafewminutesthinkingabouttheirownexperience.Thenreadthefollowing:Takeamomenttothinkaboutagrouporcommunitywhereyoufeelyoubelong.Itcouldbeageographicarea,aculturalorethnicgroup,agroupthatsharesanactivityorsetofbeliefs,oranyothergroupthatfeelslikeacommunitytoyou.
• Thinkofsomethingyoucontributedtothecommunitythathadanimpactonit.• Whydidyoucontributetothatcommunity?• Whatwouldhappenifyouwerenotthere?• Whatmakesitfeellikecommunitytoyou?
GroupDiscussionBeforeholdingagroupdiscussionyoumightwanttogivetheparticipantsanopportunitytowritedownsomehighlightsofwhattheylearnedinthePersonalReflectionExercise.Thenholdadiscussionusingthefollowingquestionstofacilitatesharingandlearningfromeachparticipant’sexperience.
• Whataresomeofthethingsthatyourememberedaboutyourownexperienceasyouwerereflecting?
• Whymightitbeimportantforyoungpeopletohaveaconnectiontocommunity?• Howdoesthisrelatetothedesiredoutcomesofaneffectiveafterschoolprogram
(learningtobeproductive,tobeconnected,tonavigate)?• Whatistheimpactonyoungpeoplewhentheydon’thaveapositiveconnectiontothe
community?
130
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:
IntroducingOurCommunities
MaterialsNeededo Instantcameraandfilmo Cutoutstickfiguresofpeopleinmanycolors,about5”tall,oneperperson(makein
advanceofexercise)o Tapeo Fine-pointmarkers
DirectionsThisisanotherusefulexercisetogetagroupofadultsoryoungpeopletalkingaboutwhatcommunitymeanstothem.Askthegrouptoreflectsilentlyonthefollowingquestions:
• Whatcommunitiesdoyouservethroughyourjob?• Whatcommunitiesdoyouidentifywithorfeelapartof?• Whatcommunitiesdotheyoungpeopleyouworkwithcomefrom?
Afterafewminutestoreflect,havethegroupgetintopairs,preferablypairswhodon’tknoweachotherwell.Partnersgetafewminutestotalkaboutcommunityandwhatitmeanstothem,speakinginturns.Partnerstakeinstantpicturesofeachother’sfacesandattachthepicturesoftheirfacestothepaperfigures.Onthebodyofthestickperson,theywritedownthewordsthatdefinecommunityforthemandwhichtheyarewillingtosharewiththerestofthegroup.Wheneveryoneisfinished,partnersgoaroundthecircle,introducingeachothertothegroup.Afterwards,postthefiguresonthewallforeveryonetosee.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
131
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:Brainstorm
Opportunities
MaterialsNeededo FlipCharto Markerso Tape
DirectionsDividetheparticipantsintofivegroupsforbrainstorms.Ifyouhavedifferentprograms,agelevels,ormanagementlevelsrepresented,trytomixthemupinyourgroups.Eachgrouptakesonetopictobrainstorm.Topicsare:
• Possiblecommunitypartners(Includeagenciesthataremembersofyourcollaborative,agencieswhereyourstaffmembershaveconnections,agenciesthatmayhaveareasofprogramoverlap,communityserviceagencies,andsourcesforindividualvolunteers.)
• Communityserviceactivities(Besuretothinkofactivitiesforyoungeraswellasolderchildrenifyouservemultipleagegroups.)
• Youngpeople’sintereststhatcouldbeconnectedtothecommunity(i.e.,Agroupinterestedindancemightenjoyavisitbyalocaldancetroupe,whichmightleadtootheractivities.)
• Othercommunityissues/programs/activitiesthatmightinterestyouryoungparticipants.
• Waystoletthebroadercommunityknowwhoyouareandwhatyoudo,sothatyoucanstrengthenyourrelationshipwiththecommunity.
Remember,thisisabrainstorm,sotrynottoruleanythingoutrightaway.Makeyourbrainstormsasbroadaspossible.Theideaistogeteveryonethinkingofyourprogramasanintegratedpartofthecommunity,withinformationandknowledgeconstantlyflowingintoandoutofyourprogram.Afterthesmallgroupshavecompletedtheirbrainstorms,stepbackandgiveeveryonetimetocirculatearoundtheroom,lookingateachother’scharts.Makeadditionstoothergroups’charts.Circletopicsthatcomeuponseverallistsorseemespeciallypromising.
132
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:StaffTrainingTopics
DirectionsCreateastaffdevelopmentplanthatincludestrainingtopicsthatwouldensurethattheyoungpeopleinyourprogramhaveopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvement.Togetherwithyourstaffandprogramleadership,identifytrainingtopicsthatarerelatedtocommunityinvolvement.Belowareafewsuggestions:
• Specifictrainingonculturesrepresentedinthestudentpopulation• Volunteermanagement/appreciation• Speakingtothemediaandgeneratingpublicity• Youngpeopleasvolunteers• Specifictopicsrelatedtopotentialprojects• Programsofferedatschoolandbyagencies
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
133
COMMUNITYINVOLVEMENT:Checklistfor
ActionDirectionsThischecklistismeanttohelpyoustayorganizedandfocusedasyoubeginincreasingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementinyourafterschoolprogram.Itwillhelpyoustayfocusedandorganizedasyoubegintomakecommunityinvolvementapriorityinyourprogram.Haveyou:
o Hadastaffdiscussionabouttheimportanceofcommunityinvolvementandhowtheyviewyoungpeople?
o Dotheyviewyoungpeopleasacommunityresourcethatcanmakeadifference?o Setasidestafftimetothoroughlyplantheincorporationofcommunityinvolvement
activities?o Assessedtheneedforstaffdevelopmentandplannedfortraining?o Lookedathowyourschooloragencyallocatesresources(time,space,andmoney)to
supportcommunityinvolvement?o Familiarizedprogramstaffwithlocalculture(s)andcommunities,includingthe
immediateneighborhood?o Familiarizedprogramstaffwithofferingsofcollaboratingagenciesandothercommunity
groups?o Consideredbothopportunitiesforyoungpeopletobeinvolvedinthecommunityandfor
thecommunitytobeinvolvedwithyoungpeople?o Askedyoungpeoplewhattheyconsidertobetheircommunityorcommunities?o Gatheredyouthinputandideasaboutcommunityinvolvement?o Madeconnectionswithotherlocalcommunitygroups?o Checkedthatpotentialcommunityserviceactivitiesaregroundedinasolid
understandingoftheissuesyouareaddressing?o Involvedfamiliesinplanningandimplementation?o Selectedthemostpromisingareastobegincommunityinvolvement?o Definedspecificallyhowyouexpecttheseactivitiestopositivelyimpactyoungpeople
andthecommunity?o Trainedsomeoneonstaffinvolunteermanagement,ifyouareplanningtouseoutside
volunteers?o Metwithpossiblecommunitypartners,agreedonresponsibilities,andoutlinedaplan?(It’sagoodideatohavethisinwriting.)o Incorporatedoutcomesrelatedtocommunityinvolvementintoprogramevaluation?
134
ForOrganizationalLeaders
OrganizationalPracticesThatPromoteYouthDevelopmentSuccessfulyouthdevelopmentprogramsarebornoutofaculture,policies,resourcesandstructuresthatareestablishedbytheprogramprovider’sparentorganization.Asanyonewhohasstruggledwithtoofewresourcesormismatchedorganizationalprioritiesknows,thebeststaffintheworldworkingwiththedeepestknowledgeandunderstandingcannotcreatehighqualityexperiencesforyoungpeoplewithoutcertainorganizationalsupportsinplace.
Manyteachersandyouthworkershavenotedthatthekindsoforganizationalpracticesdescribedontheleftworkbestwhentheyareappliedconsistentlyatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Forexample,thesponsoringschooloragencymustcommittoholdinghigh,clear,andfairstandardsforthestaff,justastheydofortheyoungparticipants.Inthisway,staffexperiencewhattheyneedtosucceed,andthefunctioningoftheorganizationatamacro-levelmirrorsthefunctioningattheprogramlevel—everyone“walksthetalk.”Puttingtheseorganizationalpracticesinplacetakestime,energy,andresources.Inparticular,programstaffmusthavethetimeoutsideoftheirprogramdutiestotalktoeachother,talkinformallywithyoungpeople,gettoknowthecommunity,plan,evaluate,andlearn.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.Thefollowingaresuggestedorganizationalpracticesthatarerelatedtoyouthdevelopmentpractices.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
135
OrganizationalPracticesThatSupport
CommunityInvolvement
LowYouthtoStaff/VolunteerRatioMaintainingalowratioofyoungpeopletoadultswillhelpcommunityinvolvementactivitiesrunmoresmoothly.Moreactivelyengagingthecommunitycanalsohelpprogramslowertheirratioofyoungpeopletostaff.Itdoestaketimeoutsideoftheprogramtorecruitandpreparevolunteers,buttherecanbemanybenefitsasyoungpeoplegetmoreone-on-oneattention,andhavetheopportunitytoformrelationshipswithmanydifferentadults.
FlexibilityinAllocatingAvailableResourcesAsyoungpeoplegetcaughtupinacommunityproject,itmaytakeadirectionthatstaffneveranticipated.Itisimportanttohavetheabilitytochangeplansandreallocateresourceswhenthishappens.Activitiesthatinvolvethecommunitycanalsotakeonalifeoftheirown,bringingnewresourcesintotheprogram.
ContinuityandConsistencyofCareMeaningfulcommunityinvolvementprojectstaketimetodevelop.Youngpeopleneedtimetounderstandandexploretheissues,plananactivity,learnanyneededskillstocarryitout,andreflectafterwards.Theyalsoneedconsistentstaffsupportthroughoutthisprocess.Inaddition,ittakestimeandefforttobuildtrustingrelationshipsinthecommunity.Whenthereishighstaffturnover,theserelationshipsaredamaged.Itisimportanttotakeappropriatemeasurestoretainqualifiedstaff.
Ongoing,Results-BasedStaffandOrganizational
ImprovementProcessPrioritizingcommunityinvolvementopportunitiesmeansensuringthattheseactivitiesreallyengageyoungpeopleandhelpthembuildknowledge,feelconnected,andgivebacktothecommunity.Toensurethatyourprogramisbeingeffectiveinofferingthesekindsofopportunities,youneedtoincludeevaluationofcommunityinvolvementeffortsinyourongoingprogramassessment.Doyoungpeoplereportthattheyfindcommunityinvolvementprojectsmeaningfulandrewarding?Howmanyconnectionsdoesyourprogramhavewithothercommunityorganizations?Howclosearetheseconnections?Alsoexaminethequantityandqualityoftherelationshipsbetweenyoungpeopleintheprogramandcommunityvolunteers.
YouthInvolvementCommunityinvolvementactivitiesaremostpowerfulwhentheyaremeaningfultotheyoungpeoplewhoparticipateinthem.Theirinvolvementinplanningandimplementationensuresthatprojectswillberelevanttothem.
136
CommunityEngagementCommunityinvolvementactivitiesworkbestwhenthecommunityisengagedwiththeafterschoolprogramatadeeperprogramororganizationallevel.Forexample,itismosthelpfulwhenstakeholdersinthecommunityareengagedinearlyplanningandgoalsetting,andhaveon-goinginput.Inthisway,providingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementcanbeanintegralpartoftheprogram,andnotanadd-on.
ProvidingOpportunitiesForCommunityInvolvementAtAll
LevelsOfTheOrganizationProgramsaremosteffectiveatlinkingyoungpeopleandthecommunitywhenthecommunityisengagedatalllevelsoftheorganization.Thismeansthatallthoseinvolvedintheprogramhaveknowledgeofthecommunitywheretheyarelocated,haveconnectionswiththecommunity,andhaveopportunitiestogivebacktothecommunity.Thismaymeangivingstaffmemberstimetoattendcommunitymeetingsandeventsandinvolvingparents,volunteers,andnon-programstaffinholdingeventsforthecommunity.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
137
SKILLBUILDING
CHALLENGINGAND
ENGAGINGLEARNING
EXPERIENCESTHAT
BUILDSKILLS
Providingopportunitiesforyoungpeopletoexpandtheirskillsandknowledge.
Chapter
8
138
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
139
WhatisMeantbyChallengingandEngagingLearningExperiencesthatBuildSkills?Learningexperiencesprovideyoungpeoplewithopportunitiestoexpandtheirunderstandingandknowledgeofthemselvesandtheworldinwhichtheyliveandtomasterspecificnewconceptsandskills.Theseexperiencesarechallengingwhentheyrequireparticipantstostretchbeyondtheircurrentrangeofknowledgeandskillsandofferopportunitiestotestandmastertheirskillsintherealworld.Youknowthatyoungpeoplearebeingchallengedwhen,uponsucceeding,theyexpressagenuinesenseofprideandaccomplishment,andareadinesstosharetheirlearningwithothers.Learningexperiencesareengagingwhentheytapintotheyoungparticipants’naturalcuriosityandinterestindiscovery,andwhentheyservetomotivate,ratherthandiscourage,theireagernesstotrynewactivities.Howcanyouensurethatyouarecreatingactivitiesthattapintoyoungpeople’snaturaldesiretolearn,givingthemopportunitiestostretchthemselvesandgainnewknowledgeandskills?Todothiswemustconsciouslyintegratelearningopportunitiesintothefullrangeofactivitiesweoffer.AndwemustdrawonalloftheyouthdevelopmentpracticesdiscussedinthisGuide.Promotingsafety,buildingpositiverelationships,fosteringmeaningfulyouthparticipationandofferingopportunitiesforcommunityinvolvementareallpartofcreatingsuccessfullearningenvironments.
140
WhyisitImportantthatLearningExperiencesareChallengingandEngaging?Toprepareyoungpeopleforadulthood,wemustprovidethemwithmultipleopportunitiestobroadentheirknowledgeoftheworld,developnewskills,andincreasetheircompetenciesinanumberofrealms.Werecognizethatyoungpeoplearearound-the-clocklearners,makingtheafterschoolhoursaperfecttimeforyouthtoaccessrichandvariedopportunitiesfornewlearning.Ourchallenge,asprogramleaders,istocreatechallengingandengaginglearningexperiencesthatwillbothattractandretainyoungpeoples’participation,andsupporttheminacquiringnewskills.Whenyoungpeoplearebothchallengedandengaged,theybecomeattentiveandreceptivetolearning.Whentheselearningopportunitiesarecoupledwiththesupporttheyneedtosucceed,theiraccomplishmentstakeonanimportancelargerthantheparticularskilltheyhavelearned—theseexperiencescontributetotheirperceptionsofthemselvesasablelearnersandpromotean“Icandoit”attitude.Thisinternalizedsenseofcompetenceandmasteryservestofueltheirdesireandmotivationforfuturesuccessandtoassumeactiveresponsibilityfortheirownlearning.Researchalsotellsusthatfeelingsofcompetenceandaccesstoengagingopportunitiesarecriticalfactorsinyouth’savoidanceofhighriskbehaviors,suchastheuseofalcoholandotherdrugs.AsresearchersJamesConnellandMichelleGambonenote,youngpeople“aremorelikelytoavoidthesedangersiftheyhavehealthieroptionsintheirlivesthatcontaintheappropriateblendofchallengeandaccomplishment.”
Afterschoolprogramsthatofferdiverseandengaginglearningopportunitiesallowyoungpeopletoexplorenewsubjectsanddisciplines,whichtheymightnotbeabletoexploreelsewhere.Forsome,thiswillbeachancetoshowcasetalentsthatwerenotpreviouslyseenorappreciatedinothersettings.Providinglearningexperiencesthatbothchallengeandengageyoungpeopleisalsothebestwaytoattractandsustaintheirparticipationinafterschoolprograms.Thisisparticularlytrueinthecaseofadolescents,whotypicallyhaveahigherlevelofchoiceovertheirparticipationandcan“votewiththeirfeet”iftheydon’tfindprogramsengaging.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
141
Usingarangeofapproachestoreachyoungpeoplewithdiverselearningstyleswillalsohelpyourprogramattractandsustaintheparticipationofyoungpeoplewhohavenothadsuccessintraditionalclassroomsettings.Asallparticipantsfeelmoreinterestedandsuccessfulaslearners,theirconfidence,enthusiasmandinterestinparticipatingwillgrowandmisbehaviorwilldiminish.
ProvidingChallengingandEngagingLearning
ExperiencesthatBuildSkills
OrganizationalPractices
Providingchallengingandengaginglearningexperiencesthatbuildskillsbeginswithsoundpoliciesandpracticesoftheorganizationthatemploysthestaffwhoworkwithyoungpeopledirectly.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.
StaffDiscussionsandPlanning
Promotingasenseofsafetywithinyourprogramrequiresdiscussionandconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.
BuildingaSafeandLearningFriendlyCommunity
Beingsupportiveandinclusiveofparticipants’differentlearningstylesandintelligences.Youngpeoplemustfeelsafeinordertotaketherisksnecessarytolearnnewthings.Youcancreateanenvironmentthatsupportslearningby:
• Buildingstrongandtrustingrelationshipswithyoungpeopleandfosteringpositiverelationshipsbetweenyoungpeopleandtheirpeers(seeEncouragingRelationshipBuilding);
• Promotingtheexplorationofideasandthepracticeofnewskills—withoutcensuringyoungpeoplefortheirerrorsormistakes;
• Explicitlyplacingahighvalueonthesearchforanswers,discoveryandlearningtogether,includingaskingforandgivinghelptoothers;
IncorporatingtheInterestsofYoungPeople
Regardlessoftheteachingandlearningmethodsyouemploy,itisimportanttoincorporateyoungpeople’sinterestsinyourprogram.Youmaywanttosurveytheyoungpeopleinyourprogramabouttheirinterests,andthenworktoincorporateopportunitiestolearnacademicandlifeskillsintoactivitiesthatreflecttheseinterests.
142
Youcanalsobuildonlearners’existingknowledgeandskills.Whenintroducinganewtopicorproject,beginbyallowingyoungpeopletoshowwhattheyalreadyknow.Theremaybesometrue“experts”amongthem.Bybuildingoffthemomentumoftheirknowledgeandpriorexperiences,youcanhelpthembothtestanddeepentheirpresentunderstanding.Equallyasimportanttodesigningprogramswithyoungpeople’sinterestsinmind,isensuringthatprogramsarerelevanttothelearners.Itiscrucialthatstaffunderstandyoungpeople’slifecontexts,includingtheirculturalandsocioeconomicbackgroundsandhavetheflexibilitytodesignprogramsthatarerelevanttoparticipants.Hiringworkersfromthecommunity,involvingcommunityvolunteersandparents,anddrawingontheirexpertisewillhelpyoushapeamoresensitiveandeffectiveprogram.
GettingToKnowtheYoungPeopleInYourProgram
Promotingsuccessfullearningexperiencesbeginswithfocusingonthelearners—theirinterests,needs,andabilities—thenincorporatingthisknowledgeintodecisionsabouthowbesttoengagetheminactivitiesthatwillachievethelearninggoalsoftheprogram.Choosinglearningstrategiesandactivitiesthatareageappropriatebasedonyoungpeople’sneedsandinterestsandtheirstageofdevelopmentisanimportantcomponentofcreatingchallengingandengaginglearningenvironments.Taketimeinastaffmeetingtoconsidertheyoungpeople’sstageofdevelopmentandvariedlearningstyles,andtheimplicationsforyourprogram.Failingtotakeyoungpeople’sdevelopmentallevelintoaccountwhendesigningactivitiescanleadtoexperiencesofboredomorfailure,whichcanunderminetheirconfidenceintheirownlearningabilities.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
143
LearningStylesandIntelligences
Inordertoconnectwithavarietyoflearnersinyourafterschoolprogramyouwillneedtobeknowledgeableaboutthedifferentwayspeoplelearn.Thisiscrucialwhenplanningskillbuildingactivities.Somepeoplearevisuallearners,learningbestfromreadingbooks,writteninstructions,andvisualdemonstrations.Othersareauditorylearners,processinginformationbestfromoralexplanations.Andstillotherpeoplearekinestheticlearners,learningbestfromphysicalexperience.Mostofuslearnbestthroughacombinationoftheseapproaches,andfromrepeatedencounters.AccordingtoHowardGardnerandotherscientists,thereareninedistinctformsofintelligence,whicheachindividualpossessesinvaryingdegrees.Asyouunderstandtheseconceptsmorefully,youcandesignactivitiesthatdrawonthemanydifferentkindsofintelligencesandtalentsofyouryoungpeopleindifferentareas.Bydoingthisyoucanchallengeandengageadiverserangeofyoungpeopleandcreateopportunitiesforeachtoshine.
IntegratingLearningIntoAllActivities
ResearcherMilbreyMcLaughlinhasspentoveradecadestudyingcommunity-basedyouthprograms.McLaughlinfoundthatyouthprogramswhicharehighlyeffectivetendtocreateenvironmentswhereyoungpeoplearealmostalways“engagedinactivitiesthatdeliberatelyteachanumberoflessons…andbuildarangeofacademiccompetenciesandlifeskills.”Inmanycases,leadersoftheseprogramsbuiltonalreadyexistingprogramsthathadcapturedtheinterestofyoungpeopleandexpandedlearningactivitiestoincludeothercontentareas.McLaughlincitesexamplesofanartsprogramthatasksyoungpeopletoresearchtheirculturalhistoryandthenworktogethertocreateamuralexpressingthethemestheydiscovered;adanceclasswhereparticipantskeepjournalsandbeginrehearsalsbyreadingaloudfromtheirwritings;andsportsprogramsthatincorporatelessonsonpersonalresponsibilityandteamwork.Tomaximizelearninginyourafterschoolprogram,beginbyintentionallyintegratingmultiplelearningopportunitiesintoallprogramsandactivitiesandsettinglearninggoalsforeach.Asyouplaneachactivity,identifyhowyouwillweaveopportunitiesforlearningintotheactivityandidentifythespecificstrategiesyouwillusetohelpyoungpeoplemeetthelearninggoals.Allowenoughtimeforstafftoplaninterestingandmeaningfullearningexperiencesthatincorporateavarietyoflearningstylesandintelligences.Itisoftenagoodideatotryoutanewactivityonasmallergroupofyouth,andaskfortheirfeedback.Staffshouldalsohaveopportunitiestodiscusswhatskillsandknowledgetheybelieveyouthintheprogramneedandtogetherdeterminehowtheseskillscanbeincorporatedacrossallprogramactivities.Someoftheexercisesattheendofthischaptermaybeusefulinbeginningthisdiscussion.Ultimately,youth,parents,andcommunitymembersshouldalsobeincludedinthisplanning.
144
InstructionalStrategiesthatEngageYoungPeople
Afterschoolprogramscandrawonanumberofinstructionalstrategiesandlearningmodelsfromthefieldofeducationthatservetoactivelyengagelearners.Bothcooperativelearningandprojectbased-learningprovideopportunitiesforyoungpeopletobeengaged,toworkandlearntogether,andtospendtimenotonlylearningnewthings,butacquiringabetterunderstandingofhowtheylearn.(Formoreinformation,seeChapter6,FosteringMeaningfulYouthParticipation.)
CooperativeLearning
Youngpeople’slearninginschoolistypicallystructuredbyeachworkingindividuallyorincompetitionwithoneanother.Afterschoolsettings,however,offertheflexibilityforyoungpeopletolearninalternativeways.Cooperativelearningisaninstructionalmethodinwhichyoungpeopleworktogetherinsmallteamstopromotetheirownlearningaswellasthelearningoftheirpeers;andwherestudentsperceivethattheycanreachtheirlearninggoalsifandonlyiftheotherstudentsinthelearninggroupalsoreachtheirgoals.Cooperativelearninghasbeenshowntobeahighlyeffectivewayforyoungpeopletoachievetheirlearninggoals.Theyareabletoengagewithadiversegroupofparticipantswithdifferentviews,backgrounds,ideasandquestionsprovidingrichlearningopportunities.AccordingtotheCaliforniaDepartmentofEducationandothers,cooperativelearningisalsoviewedasa“powerfuleducationalapproachforhelpingallstudentsattaincontentstandardsanddeveloptheinterpersonalskillsneededforsucceedinginamulticulturalworld.”
Programleadersmayengageyoungpeopleincooperativelearningformomentsatatimetosharetheirthoughtsandexperiencesorparticipateinagroupdecision.Cooperativelearningcanalsobemoreformalized,lastingforanentireactivityperiodorforseveralweeks.Inanafterschoolsetting,youngpeoplecanengageincooperativelearninggroupstocompletehomework,makegroupdecisionsordoproblemsolving,researchtheanswerstoquestions,conductasurveyorexperiment,orcompletecomplexprojectstogether.(Formoreinformationongroupprojects,seeProject-BasedLearning,below.).Itisimportanttonote,however,thatcooperativelearningrequiresthatthegroupmembersareabletoengageinactivitiesinateamworksetting.Alsoimportantisestablishinganenvironmentwhereparticipantsfeelsafe,butchallengedandkeepingthegroupssmallenoughsothatallcancontribute.“Socialskillsforeffectivecooperativeworkdonotmagicallyappearwhencooperativelessonsareemployed.Instead,socialskillsmustbetaughttostudentsjustaspurposefullyandpreciselyasacademicskills.Leadership,decision-making,trust-building,communication,andconflict-managementskillsempowerstudentstomanagebothteamworkandtaskworksuccessfully.”
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
145
Project-BasedLearning(PBL)(www.bie.org)
Project-BasedLearningisateachingandlearningmethodthatactivelyengagestheparticipationandexcitementofyoungpeople,andiswellsuitedtoafterschoolsettings.Inproject-basedlearning,youngpeopleworkcollaborativelyoveraperiodoftimetoinvestigateatopicarea,focusonthedevelopmentofaproductorperformance,orsolveaproblemrelatedtorealworldissues.Intacklingtheirprojects,youngpeopleareprovidedwithaguidingframeworkinwhichtowork,butalsothefreedomtoorganizetheprocessandactivitiesnecessarytoreachasolution.Thisusuallyinvolvestheirorganizingtheiractivities,conductingresearch,solvingproblems,andsynthesizinginformationacrossdisciplines.Project-basedlearningrequiresthatyoungpeoplehavestrongcommunicationandteamworkskills,andareabletoconsiderdifferentpointsofview,andmakedecisionswithoutconflict.Italsorequiressoundplanningonthepartofprogramleaders.Youcansolicitideasforprojectsthrough"brainstorming"activitieswithprogramparticipantsorbuildoffofearlierprojectsandinterests.Whenselectingprojectideas,keepinmindthatthetopicshouldbecloselyrelatedtoayoungperson’severydayexperiencesorinterests,sothattheywillbeabletoraiserelevantquestionsandthereforeactivelyengagewiththesubjectmatter.Project-basedlearninginafterschoolsettingscanalsopromotealinkwithformallearningtopicsduringtheschoolday.Leadersshouldanticipaterequestsbyparticipantstogatherinformationormaterialsoutsideoftheprogramfacilities.Project-basedlearningoffersgreatopportunitiestoconnectwiththegreatercommunity.Attheconclusionofaproject,participantswilloftendevelopagroupreport,exhibitionorperformance,whichwillservetomotivateparticipantstoachieveahighqualityproduct,andoffersthemanopportunityforrecognitionandcelebration.
146
ConnectingSchoolDayLearningtoAfterschoolActivities
Increasingly,afterschoolprogramleadersarebeingaskedtosupportschooldaylearning.Thiscanbeaccomplishedwithoutloosingyour“youthfriendly”afterschoolenvironmentorduplicatingthelearningmethodsoftraditionalclassrooms.Beginbybecomingknowledgeableaboutthecurriculumcontentthatwillbecoveredintheclassroomsofyourparticipants.Aretherethemes,projectsoractivitiesyoucanincorporatetoenrichyoungpeople’sinterestandunderstandingoftheirclassroomcontent?Teachersarewonderfulresourcesforbrainstormingideasandprogramplanningresourcesandmaterials.Publishedacademicstandardsarealsoagreatresourcetohelpyouincorporateclassroomlearningwithafterschoollearninggoals.Eachschooldistrictandstatedepartmentofeducationpublishesstandardsthatdescribethedestinationsatwhichstudentsshouldarriveattheendofaunitorterminreading,writing,math,finearts,performingarts,fitness,andmanyotherareas.Notonlywillyourknowledgeofthesestandardsprovideideasonhowtoenrichyourprogramactivities,buttheywillprovideyouwithacommonlanguageandframeworkthatschooldaypersonnelwillunderstandasyoudescribeandpromoteyourprogram.
ProvidingOpportunitiesforAssessment,Feedbackand
Recognition
Youngpeopleareintrinsicallyinvestedinmakingprogressandachievingtheirgoals.Programleaderscansupportyoungpeople’slearningbyestablishingprogramlearningobjectivesinadvanceofactivitiesandhelpingyoungpeopletosettheirownpersonallearningobjectives.Youngpeoplethenneedopportunitiestomeasuretheirownprogressandrefineandimprovetheirwork,aswellasreceiveon-goingfeedbackfromadultsandrecognitionfortheiraccomplishments.
• Assessmentandfeedbackcantakeavarietyofforms,including:• Informalcoachingandfeedbackbetweenyoungpeopleandadults;• On-goingstructuredopportunitieswhereyoungpeoplewriteaboutordescribetheir
viewoftheirownprogress;
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
147
• Theuseofindividualportfoliosthatdemonstrateimprovementovertime;• Peerreviewandgroupreflectionsonjointprojects.
Opportunitiesforpublicrecognitionarealsovitaltobuildingyoungpeople’ssenseofconfidenceandaccomplishment.Thesemightincludeyouthpresentations,publiccelebrationsofaccomplishments,andeventsandperformancesthatshowcasethenewskillsandtalentsthatyoungpeoplehavegainedthroughtheirexperiencesintheprogram.Rememberthattheabilityofyoungpeopletoacceptandmakeuseofcandidfeedbackfromadultsandpeersisdependentonthetrustandsenseofsafetyyoungpeoplefeelintheprogramandtheexplicitvalueprogramleadersplaceonlearningandself-improvement.
TakingAdvantageoftheStrengthsofAfterschoolPrograms
Afterschoolprogramshavesomeuniquefeaturesthatmakethemdifferentfromschoolsettings.Byfocusingonthesecharacteristics,wecan“playtoourstrengths”indesigningourprogramstoberichlearningenvironmentsthatalsosupportyoungpeople’shealthydevelopment.Aswedesignourprograms,weneedtobearthesefeaturesinmindsothatwecantakeadvantageoftheuniqueopportunitiesthatafterschoolsettingsoffer,andusethesestrengthstocomplimentandexpandwhatgoesonintheclassroom,notmerelyreplicateit.
ThingsYouCanDoNOWtoCreate
ChallengingandEngagingLearningExperiences1.Createasafeplacetolearn.
Whatmakesaprogramasafeplacetolearn?Whobettertoaskthanyouryoungparticipants?Whatdotheyoungpeopleyouworkwiththinkaboutmistakes?Togetdiscussionstarted,readabookonfamousmistakesthatresultedinamazinginventions.Usingthisinformation,developagreementsandruleswiththeyoungpeopleinyourgrouptoensuretherightofsafety.Decidetogetherwhattodowhenagreementsarebroken.Postanyagreementsonthewallandrefertothemoften.Andwhataboutprogramstaff?Howdotheyrespondtoyoungpeoplewhenmistakesaremade?Considerhowyoucanestablishaprogram"culture"whereeveryone’smistakesareseenasopportunitiesfornewlearningandtheprocessofinquiryanddiscoveryismoreimportantthanalwayshavingthecorrectanswers.
148
2.Planfortheskillsandknowledgeyouwantyour
participantstoacquireinyourprogram.Oftenwhenplanningprograms,staffpeoplegostraighttoliningupactivitiestofilladeterminedstretchoftime,withoutthinkingthroughwhatthelearninggoalsareforaprojectortheoverallprogram.Insteadofidentifyingactivities,workwithstafftodeterminewhatkindsofknowledgeandskillsyouwantyouryoungpeopletoacquireovertimethroughtheirparticipationinyourprogram.Theymightbeacademicskills,studyskills,leadershiporteamskills.Now,considerwhatkindsofexperiencesandactivitiesyoucanprovideovertimethatwillmeetyourlearningagenda.Don’tfeellikeyouhavetodoitalone!Youcanuseoradaptcurriculummaterialstoalignwithyourparticipants’interestsandneeds,anddrawonteachersandothersaroundyouwhomayhavemoreexperienceinplanningagainstlearningoutcomes.
3.Useportfoliostohelpparticipantsreflectontheirprogress
andaccomplishments.Ifyourparticipantshaveconsistentenrollmentovertimeorifparticipantsengageinlongtermprojectswheretheyincreasetheirskillsongoing,considerhowyoumightcollecttheirworkovertime.Youcancreateaportfolioorpersonalfilewithyouryoungparticipantstoserveasanon-goingrecordoftheirwork.Afterseveralmonthsorattheendofaprojectsitdownwiththemtoreviewtheirrecordofaccomplishments.Whatdotheythinkaboutit?Whatdoestheirportfolioreflectbacktothem?Whatkindsofrecordscanbestored?Foryoungerchildren,itmightbeaportfolioofselfportraitsthatweredonemonthly,orsimplytheirownfiletheyuseovertimetostorethingstheyhavedoneofwhichtheyareproud.Forolderyouthwhomightbedevelopingasetofskillsovertime,sayintheartsortechnology,communicateyourprojectlearninggoalsandaskthemtodeveloppersonallearninggoals,ifappropriate.Assisttheminassessingwhichgoalstheyhavemetovertime.
4.Increaseindependentaccesstodiverselearningmaterials.
Withinyourprogram,provideaccesstolearningmaterialsthatyoungpeoplecanindependentlyaccess.Thisallowsyoungpeopletopursuetheirowninterestsorengageintheirowninquirywithouttheneedforadult-ledstructure,andisperfectforyoungpeoplewhofinishtheirworkaheadofscheduleorwhowanttodisengageforaperiodoftimefromgroupactivities.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
149
Thesemaytaketheformofreadingmaterials(books,magazines)orwebsitesthatarerelatedtotheirinterestsortopicsofstudywithinyourprogram.Theycanalsobeintheformoflearningkitsthathaveinstructionsandexperimentswithwhichtheycaninvolvethemselves.Itisimportantthatthematerialsarediverseandrepresentativeoftheculture,gender,andabilitiesofyouryoungpeople.
5.Recognizetheaccomplishmentsofyouryoungpeople.
Putinplaceopportunitiesforyoungpeopletoberecognizedfortheiraccomplishmentsbyothersoutsideoftheprogram.Thiscantakeplacethroughperformances,exhibits/presentationsofcompletedprojects,orcelebrationswhereeachchildisacknowledgedforhisorherspecialaccomplishmentsandcontributions.Sharingaccomplishmentswithoutsidersraiseseveryone’ssenseofaccountabilityfordeadlinesandexcellence.Afterasuccessfulevent,thepositiveeffectonagroup’ssenseofcommunityandtheindividuals’experienceofaccomplishmentcanbequiteprofound.
150
HowDoYouKnow?
TakeYourProgram’sTemperature:Self-Assess
Youcanself-assessyourprogrambyusingobservationsandreflectionsurveyswiththeafterschoolstaffandyouthparticipants.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceonpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentexperienceswhenyouwalkintotheroom,evenbeforetheparticipantsarrive.Aftertheadultsandyoungpeoplearrive,youcanseethatstaffhaveworkedtopromotepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiences.WhatYoungPeopleSay
Youngpeoplecantellyouiftheyhavepositiveyouthdevelopmentexperiencesintheprogram.Themostreliablewaytoassessfortheseexperiencesistoasktheyoungpeopledirectlyabouttheirownexperienceoftheprogram.Wouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramagreeordisagreewiththesestatementsbelow?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
151
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:How
DoYouKnow?
DirectionsSelfassessyourprogramusingobservationsandsurveys.Youcanidentifyindicatorsthatwillallowstaffandyouthtoselfassessthedegreetowhichtheprogramhelpsyoungpeopletobuildnewskills.Youcanuseindicatorsfromprogramqualitysurveys.Belowareafewsuggestionsofwhatyouwouldseeandwhatyouthwouldsay.WhatYouSeeYoucantellthataprogramhasplacedimportanceoncreatingchallengingandinterestinglearningexperiencesforitsparticipantswhenyouwalkintotheroomandsee:
• Programmaterialsselectedbasedontheages,abilitiesandbackgroundsoftheparticipants.
• Activitiesorganizedtoincludeyoungpeoplewithawiderangeofskills.• ActivitiesorganizedusingSAFEfeatures–Sequenced,Active,Focused,andExplicit.• Activitiesprovideopportunitiesforyoungpeopletoworkontheirownandinsmall
groups;thesizeofthegroupislinkedtothepurposeoftheactivity.• Opportunitiestolearnacademicandlifeskillsthroughprogramactivitiesthatappealto
youngpeople.• Youngpeopletryingavarietyofproblem-solvingstrategies,includingaskingforhelp
fromadultsandpeers,whenfacingchallengesinactivities.• Youngpeopledemonstratingnewabilitiesandapplyingtheirskillstonewtasks.• Theprogramdrawsonthetalentsofmanydifferentkindsof“teachers”whosupportthe
participants’learning:communityworkers,parents,olderor“expert”peers,aswellasclassroomteachers.
• Youngpeoplereceivingrecognitionfortheiraccomplishmentsinformallyandthroughcelebrationsandperformances.
• Youngpeoplereceivingon-goingfeedbackfromadultsandreflectingontheirownprogress;andyoungpeopleregularlysharingtheirfeedbackontheprogramwithprogramleaders,includingwhetherornottheyfeelchallengedbyactivities.
WhatYoungPeopleSayThebestwaytoassesswhetheryoungpeoplearelearningnewskillsandfeelchallengedandengagedintheprocessistoaskthem.Howwouldyoungpeopleinyourprogramrespondtothestatementsbelow?Wouldtheyagreeordisagree?
• Ilearnhowtodonewthingshere.• Theactivitiesherearefun.• Inthisprogram,IlearnthingsthatIhaveapersonalinterestin.
• IgettodothingsherethatIdon’tgettodoanywhereelse.
152
• Inthisprogram,IgettolearnhowtodothingsIdidnotthinkIcoulddo.• Staffherechallengemetodomybest.• Inthisprogram,IamgettingbetteratdoingthingsIcareabout.• IamabletosetmyowngoalsaroundthethingsIlearnhere.
ReflectionWhataresomethingsyouseeinyourprogramthatindicatechallengingandengaginglearningexperiencesarebeingoffered?Whataresomethingsyouwouldliketosee?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
153
StaffDevelopmentToolsandActivities
PromotingtheyouthdevelopmentexperiencesdetailedintheYouthDevelopmentGuide2.0requiresconsensusamongstafftomakethisaprogrampriorityandtodevelopstrategiestomakeithappen.Belowaresometoolsforpromotingdiscussionwithyourstafforothersatyouragencyorschool.ThefollowingPersonalReflectionExercisesareagoodwaytosparkdiscussion.Ifthereisalocalyouthservingagencythatisknownfortheiremphasisonandsuccessinpromotingpositiveyouthdevelopmentforyoungpeople,youmaywanttoinvitesomeonefromthatagencyinasaguestspeakertoofferinspirationandsharetheirexperience.
154
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:
PersonalReflectionDirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelpprogramstaffthinkaboutwhatgoesintoahighqualitylearningexperience.Itcanserveasagoodopeningtofocusthegroupontheimportanceoflearninginanafterschoolcontext.Beginbytellingparticipantsthatyouaregoingtodoapersonalreflection.Askthemtoclosetheireyes.Readthefollowingaloud:
Takeamomenttothinkaboutanengaginglearningexperienceyouhavehad—atimewhenyouwerefullyinvolvedinwhatyouweredoingandtherestoftheworldseemedtofallaway.Thinkaboutwhatyouwerelearning,whowasthere,andhowyoufelt.
• Whatdoyouthinkledyoutobesodeeplyengagedinthisexperience?• Whatwasinterestingtoyouaboutwhatyouwerelearning?• Howdidyoubecomeinterestedinwhatyouwerelearning?• Wereyouinagrouporalone?Didyouhaveateacher?Whatwashis/herstyle?• Ifyouhadateacher,didyoutrustthatperson?Whydidyoutrustornottrustthat
person?• Whatmodesoflearningwereyouusing(visual,auditory,physical)?• Whatelsestandsoutforyouabouttheexperience?
GroupDiscussion
BeforeholdingagroupdiscussionyoumightwanttogivetheparticipantsanopportunitytowritedownsomehighlightsofwhattheylearnedinthePersonalReflectionExercise.Thenholdadiscussionusingthefollowingquestionstofacilitatesharingandlearningfromeachparticipant’sexperience.
• Whymightitbeimportantforyoungpeopletohavechallengingandengaginglearningopportunitiesoutofschool?
• Whymightitbeimportanttoaccountfordifferentstylesandmodesoflearning?• Howdoesthisrelatetotheoutcomesofyourafterschoolprogram?• Whatistheimpactonyoungpeoplewhentheydon’thaveengaginglearning
opportunitiesoutofschool?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
155
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:
BrainstormforIntegratingLearning
Opportunities
Materialsneededo Flipcharto Markers
DirectionsThisexerciseisintendedtohelpstaffunderstandhowtomakelearningmoreintentionalinyourprogram,andtobegindevelopingprogramgoalsthatarerelatedtocreatingchallengingandengaginglearningexperiencesthatbuildskills.Oncestaffhavebeguntounderstandhowprogramactivitiesprovideyoungpeoplewithlearningexperiences,theywillbeabletotalkwithparents,funders,andcommunitymembersabouttheimportantrolenon-academicprogrammingcanplayinfosteringlearning.Asagroup,brainstormforfiveminutesaboutthemostfundamentalthingsyoungpeopleinyourprogramneedtoknowinordertoleadhappyandproductivelives.Labelthese“LearningGoals.”Trytobespecific:Ifyouthinkthatyoungpeopleneedtolearn“responsibility,”doesthismeancleaningupafterthemselves,timemanagement,moneymanagement,oralloftheabove?Don’ttrytocomeupwithacompletelist,justabroadlistofthedifferentkindsofthingsyoungpeopleneedtolearn.Postthebrainstormedlistonthewallandthenchooseoneofyourprogramactivitiestohighlightinagroupbrainstormingsession.Forexample,homeworkclub,athleticprogramsoracookingclass.Forfiveminutes,askgroupmemberstotrytolistallofthethingsthatayoungpersoncanlearnthroughtheselectedactivity.Iftheactivitychosenisdesignedtoteachaspecificskillorconcept,thinkbeyondittotheotherlessonsandskillsyoungpeoplecanlearnthroughtheactivity.Forexample,iftheactivityisasport,whatmighttheactivityteachyoungpeoplebeyondtheparticularrulesofthegameandthephysicalskillsrequired?Labelthese“LearningOpportunities.”
Groupdiscussion
Comparethetwolists.Isthereoverlap?Aretherewaysthattheactivitycouldbestructuredtohelpyoungpeoplelearnmoreofthethingsonyour“LearningGoals”list?Arethere“additionallearningopportunitiesavailableintheactivitythatyoucouldhighlightorreinforcemoreeffectively?How?Whatsignswouldindicatethatyoungpeoplearelearningtheselessonsthroughthisactivity?Canyoubuildtimeintotheactivityforyoungpeopletoplan,practiceandperformtheseskills?Istheretimeforyoungpeopletoreflect,receivefeedback,andberecognizedfortheiraccomplishments?
156
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:
PracticeTeaching
DirectionsThisexerciseoffersachanceforstaffworkinginyourafterschoolprogramtolearnnewteachingstrategiesfromeachotherandtogetfeedbackontheirteachingstyles.Breakintoteamsoftwoorthree.Giveeachteam15minutestoplanathree-minutelessonfortherestofthegroup.Itdoesn’tmatterwhattheyareteaching—itcanbesomethingsimpleorsillylikethewordstoanewsongorhowtopassnoteswithoutbeingcaught.Youcaneventeachsomethingthegroupalreadyknows,suchashowaseedgrowsintoaplantorhowtocrossthestreetsafely.Trytocreateyourlessonsothatitaddressesarangeoflearningstylesandintelligences.Aftereachlessontaketimeforgroupfeedback.Whatworkedwellaboutthelesson?Whatlearningstylesandintelligenceswereaddressed?(Unlessthegrouphasdevelopedahighleveloftrust,focusonlyonpositivecomments).Iftherehadbeenmoretime,howcouldyouhaveengagedotherlearningstylesandintelligencesinthislesson?
Variations
1. Ifyoudon’thavetimefortheentiregrouptopresent,haveoneteampresentateachofseveralmeetings.
2. Ifastaffmemberhashadaparticularlysuccessfulteachingexperiencewiththeyoungperson,havethempresentthatlessontotheentiregroup,andanalyzewhatmadeitwork.
3. Doapracticelessoninwhichparticipantsareunabletousetheireyes,ears,hands,orvoices,etc.toforcethe“teacher”toconsiderhowtoreachthemthroughothermeans.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
157
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:StaffTrainingTopicsDirectionsCreateastaffdevelopmentplanthatincludestrainingtopicsthatwouldensurethattheyoungpeopleinyourprogramhaveopportunitiesforbuildingskills.Togetherwithyourstaffandprogramleadership,identifytrainingtopicsthatarerelatedtobuildingskills.Belowareafewsuggestions:
• Creatingalessonplan• Engagingmultipleintelligencesandlearningstyles• Cooperativelearningstrategies• Projectbasedlearningstrategies• Teachingliteracyandmathskills• Traininginspecificskillstosharewithyoungpeople
158
ENGAGINGLEARNINGTHATBUILDSSKILLS:
ChecklistforActionDirectionsNowyouarereadytostartincreasingthelearningopportunitiesinyourprogram!Thischecklistismeanttohelpyoustayorganizedandfocused.Usingitwillhelpyouensurethesuccessofyourprogram.Thischecklistwillhelpyoustayfocusedandorganizedasyoubegintomakebuildingskillsapriorityinyourprogram.HaveYou:
o Setasidestafftimetothoroughlyplanhowtointegratechallengingandengaging
learningexperiencesintoyourprogram?o Learnedaboutdifferentlearningstylesandhowtoteachinavarietyofways?o Askedtheyoungpeoplewhattheywanttolearn,whattheirinterestsare,andwhatthey
thinkyoungpeopleintheirparticularagegroupneedtoknow?o Learnedabouttheculturalbackgroundsoftheyoungpeopleinyourprogramandabout
theirdailylivesoutsideoftheprogram?o Learnedaboutthedevelopmentalneedsoftheagegroup(s)yourprogramserves?o Assessedthedifferentlearningstylesofyourgroup,anddiscoveredwhattheyare
alreadydoingintheclassroom?o Lookedforwaystointentionallyembedlearningopportunitiesintoyourprogram
activities?o Includedlearninggoalsinyourprogramgoalsandoutcomes?o Consideredwaystoincludecyclesofplanning,practicingandperformingindifferent
programactivities?o Establishedopportunitiesforyoungpeopletoreflectandassesstheirownprogressin
activities?o Discussedyourchallengeswithco-workersandclassroomteachers?o Incorporatedongoingevaluationoftheextenttowhichprogramactivitiesoffer
challengingandengaginglearningexperiencesandtheiroutcomes?
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
159
ForOrganizationalLeaders
OrganizationalPracticesThatPromoteYouthDevelopmentSuccessfulyouthdevelopmentprogramsarebornoutofaculture,policies,resourcesandstructuresthatareestablishedbytheprogramprovider’sparentorganization.Asanyonewhohasstruggledwithtoofewresourcesormismatchedorganizationalprioritiesknows,thebeststaffintheworldworkingwiththedeepestknowledgeandunderstandingcannotcreatehighqualityexperiencesforyoungpeoplewithoutcertainorganizationalsupportsinplace.
Manyteachersandyouthworkershavenotedthatthekindsoforganizationalpracticesdescribedontheleftworkbestwhentheyareappliedconsistentlyatalllevelsoftheagencyorschool.Forexample,thesponsoringschooloragencymustcommittoholdinghigh,clear,andfairstandardsforthestaff,justastheydofortheyoungparticipants.Inthisway,staffexperiencewhattheyneedtosucceed,andthefunctioningoftheorganizationatamacro-levelmirrorsthefunctioningattheprogramlevel—everyone“walksthetalk.”Puttingtheseorganizationalpracticesinplacetakestime,energy,andresources.Inparticular,programstaffmusthavethetimeoutsideoftheirprogramdutiestotalktoeachother,talkinformallywithyoungpeople,gettoknowthecommunity,plan,evaluate,andlearn.Theseorganizationalpracticesrequirethecommitmentofeveryoneattheagencyorschool,fromtheadministrationtothejanitorialstafftothevolunteers.Thefollowingaresuggestedorganizationalpracticesthatarerelatedtoyouthdevelopmentpractices.
160
OrganizationalPracticesthatSupportEngaging
LearningandtheBuildingofSkills
LowYouthtoStaff/VolunteerRatioThemorestaffandvolunteersintheroom,themorelearningexperiencescanbetailoredtotheneedsofindividuallearners.Lowratiosofyouthtoadultsarealsovitaltopromotingasenseofsafetyandencouragingrelationshipbuilding,bothofwhicharecrucialprerequisitestohigh-qualitylearning.
Safe,Reliable,andAccessibleActivitiesandSpacesItisnotunusualforafterschoolprogramstobeassignedmeetingspacesthatareinadequate,duetosurroundingnoiseordistractions,thelackoftablespaceorrunningwater,orotherproblems.Topreventfrustrationonthepartofallparties,ensurethatyourmeetingspacesupportsthelearningobjectivesandactivitiesyouhaveplanned.Ifitdoesn’t,considerreorganizingyouractivitieswherepossibleand/orhavingyourorganizationalleadernegotiateforbetterspace.Youngpeople,especiallyadolescentswhoaregoingtobepracticingnewskills,oftenpreferspacesthatoffersomeprivacyfrompeerswhomaynotbepartoftheirprogram.
RangeofDiverse,InterestingLearningActivitiesWhentherearemanyopportunitiestoengageindifferentareasoflearning,youngpeoplecanfocusonthelearningthatseemsmostrelevanttothem,andonmodesoflearningthatworkbestforthem.Likeadults,theyaremostlikelytotakeontheworkandtheriskoflearninganewskillwhenitisinterestingandwhentheyfeelitwillhelpthemintheirlives.
FlexibilityinAllocatingResourcesThemoreflexibilityyourprogramhasinallocatingresources,themoreyouwillbeabletotakeadvantageofunexpectedteachingandlearningopportunitieswhentheyarise.Couldyourstaffandprogramchangethefocusofactivitiesforfiveminutes,oneday,ortherestoftheyearifyoungpeople’sinterestsorneedsindicatedthatthiswouldincreaselearningwithinyourprogram?
ContinuityandConsistencyofCare Ittakestimetobecomefamiliarwiththelearningstyleofanindividual,andtodevelopthetrustnecessarytofosterlearning.Itishelpfultorememberthat,unfortunately,manyyoungpeoplehavehadnegativeexperienceswithadultsinteachingroleswhohavenotsupportedtheirlearning.Onceayoungpersonhashadasuccessfullearningexperiencewithanadult,theyaremorelikelytogivethatpersontheirbesteffortinthefuture.Itisimportantforthatadulttoremainavailableconsistentlyforthatyoungperson.Organizationalleadersandprogramstaffneedtoconsiderhowtoimplementpracticesandpoliciesthatsupporttherecruitmentandretentionofqualifiedstaffandvolunteers.
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
161
High,Clear,andFairStandardsOnceyoungpeoplehavehadsuccessaslearners,itisimportanttokeepinspiringthemtogrowintheirskills.Whenwelayoutstandardsclearly,youngpeoplecanseetheirintermediatesuccessesonthewaytolargergoals.Successcanalsobedefinedintermsofindividualgrowth,ratherthanadoptingonestandardagainstwhichallaremeasured.Manyprogramsuseindividualgoal-settingasawaytohelpyoungpeoplemeasuretheirownprogress.
ProvidingOpportunitiesforLearningatAllLevelsofthe
OrganizationWhentheentireagencyisalearningcommunity,everyoneisengagedinaprocessofsettinggoals,learningskills,andevaluatingprogress.Learningbecomesafullyintegratedpartofprogramming.Additionally,whenprogramleadersviewthemselvesaslearnersandlearningasaconstantprocess,theymodellifelonglearningforyoungpeople.Inparticular,itisimportantfororganizationstoprovidestaffwithopportunitiesforon-goingtrainingtostrengthentheirteachingskills.
162
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
163
AFTERWORD
AFTERWORDAND
ADDITIONAL
RESOURCES
Chapter
9
164
Copyright ©2018TemescalAssociates and CNYD
165
AfterwordThisversionoftheYouthDevelopmentGuideispossiblethankstotheeffortofmanyindividualsrepresentingvariousperspectivesofthefieldofyouthdevelopment.WehopethisGuidechallengessomeoldassumptionsorhabitsandreplacesthemwithconcreteinformation,strategiesandtools.Eachchapterismeanttobuildonthepreviousonetocreateastrongfoundationalknowledgeofthefieldofyouthdevelopment.Theworkofyouthdevelopmentprofessionalsiscriticaltosociety.Don’tstophereatthisGuide!Thefieldcontinuestoevolve,whichrequiresustopauseandreflectonbothfromwherewe’vecomeandwheredowewanttogo?Takethetimeforyourself,orwithyourteamoryourorganizationorschooltocontinuetodeepenandexpandyourlearning.Theresourcesareoutthere.Whetherit’sanotherbookoracertificateprogramatthelocalcommunitycollegeoronlinecourses-evenMastersandDoctoraldegreeprograms.Theworkofsupportingyoungpeoplethroughtheirmoral,social,cognitive,emotionalandphysicaldevelopmentrequiresskilled,thoughtful,knowledgeableandinnovativeindividuals,likeyou!UsefulWebsitesBelowareahandfulofwebsitesthatareworthcheckingout.Theyareoftenexcellentsourcesofthelatestresearch,evaluation,andfieldreports.
• AfterschoolAlliancehttps://www.afterschoolalliance.org/• AspenInstitutehttps://www.aspeninstitute.org/• BuckInstituteforEducation(Project-basedlearning)http://www.bie.org/• Character.orghttp://character.org/• CollaborativeforAcademic,Social,EmotionalLearning(CASEL)https://casel.org/• ExpandedLearning360°/365http://www.expandedlearning360-365.com/• ForumForYouthInvestmenthttp://forumfyi.org/• GreaterGoodScienceCenterhttps://greatergood.berkeley.edu/• InnerExplorer(Mindfulness)https://innerexplorer.org/• LearninginAfterschool&Summer(LIAS)Projecthttp://learninginafterschool.org• NationalAfterSchoolAssociation(NAA)https://naaweb.org/• PartnershipforChildrenandYouthhttps://www.partnerforchildren.org/• TemescalAssociateshttp://temescalassociates.com• TribesTLC®www.tribes.com• WallaceFoundationhttps://www.wallacefoundation.org/• YouthDevelopmentStrategies,Inc.http://www.ydsi.org