yt wy2013 fall operatoins meeting (nov 8 2012) · 08/11/2012 · water year 2012 oct-mar actual...
TRANSCRIPT
RECLAMATIONC ONManaging Water in the West
Yellowtail Dam & Bighorn LakeYellowtail Dam & Bighorn Lake Water Year 2013: Fall Operations Meeting
Billings, MontanaNovember 8, 2012November 8, 2012
Agenda
W l & I t d tiWelcome & Introductions
R i f W t Y 2012 O tiReview of Water Year 2012 Operations
Preview of Water Year 2013 Fall & Winter Operations
Open Discussion
Yellowtail Dam & Afterbay
BIGHORN LAKE2012 Operations Review
BIGHORN LAKE CONDITIONSNovember 1 2011
Elevation 3639 30 ft – 0 7 ft below full pool
November 1, 2011
3639.30 ft – 0.7 ft below full pool
Storage 1,011,836 acre-feet (99% full)
Inflows = 2 600 cfsInflows 2,600 cfs
Total Outflow = 3,500 cfsfRiver = 3,500 cfs
BIA Canal = 0 cfs
BIGHORN LAKE FALL OPERATIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2012 Plans
BIGHORN LAKE FALL OPERATIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2012 Plans
STEP 1
Operating Criteria Used for 2012 Plans
2011 April-October Gain = 806,500 acre-feet2011 End-of-October Storage = 1,011,836 acre-feetUpstream Reservoir Fall & Winter Releases =
Boysen = 950 cfsB ff l Bill 350 fBuffalo Bill = 350 cfs
Projected End-of-March Target Elevation = 3617Calculated November-March Gain = 339,300 acre-feetCalculated Fall & Winter Release for Yellowtail:
River = 3 175 cfsRiver = 3,175 cfs
BIGHORN LAKE FALL CONDITIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2012 Plans
STEP 2
Operating Criteria Used for 2012 Plans
Since Calculated Fall & Winter Release was > 2,500 cfs
Set End of March target elevation @ 3619Set End-of-March target elevation @ 3619
Calculated New Fall & Winter Release for Yellowtail:River = 3,130 cfs
Bighorn Lake November-March Inflow
Recap of Water Year 2012F.C. – 733 kaf
1400
Bighorn Lake November March Inflow1967-2012 2012 – 726 kaf
Ave. – 696 kaf
1000
1200
low
(kaf
)
600
800
er-M
arch
Inf
200
400
Nov
embe
0
200
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Years
Bighorn Lake 2012 Nov-Mar Operations
3640
3645
et
3630
3635
evat
ion
fee
3620
3625
Lake
Ele
3610
3615
Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar
2012 Top of Joint Use
November-March OperationsNovember March Operations
Target Actual
Oct 31 Lake Elevation 3635-3640 3639.30
Mar 31 Lake Elevation 3619 3619 58Mar 31 Lake Elevation 3619 3619.58
Nov-Mar Release 3,130 cfs
Spring Runoff ConditionsSpring Runoff Conditions
Recap of Water Year 2012
2012 Valley Precipitation
6.57.07.5
2012 Valley Precipitation
4.55.05.56.0
n (In
ches
)
2 02.53.03.54.0
Prec
ipita
tion
0 00.51.01.52.0P
0.0Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept
Month
Average Valley Precipitation Actual Valley Precipitation
Recap of Water Year 2012
2012 Mountain Precipitation
6.57.07.5
2012 Mountain Precipitation
4.55.05.56.0
n (In
ches
)
2 02.53.03.54.0
Prec
ipita
tion
0 00.51.01.52.0P
0.0Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept
Month
A M i P i i i A l M i P i i iAverage Mountain Precipitation Actual Mountain Precipitation
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on January 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on January 1
2012
AverageSE = 99% of average
April-July Forecast = 1,131.4 kaf (99%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast , 3 a (99%)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on February 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on February 1
2012
AverageSE = 96% of average
April-July Forecast = 1,212.2 kaf (102%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast , a ( 0 %)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on March 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on March 1
2012
AverageSE = 116% of average
April-July Forecast = 1,344.3 kaf (118%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast ,3 3 a ( 8%)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on April 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on April 1
2012
AverageSE = 86% of average
April-July Forecast = 1,064.0 kaf (93%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast ,06 0 a (93%)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on May 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on May 1
2012
AverageSE = 63% of average
April-July Forecast = 749.7 kaf (66%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast 9 a (66%)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on June 1
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions on June 1
2012
AverageSE = 55% of average
April-July Forecast = 690.4 kaf (61%)
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
p Ju y o ecast 690 a (6 %)
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
2012 Mountain Snowpack Conditions
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
2012 Mountain Snowpack Conditions
2012
AveragePeaked on March 22, 2012
1 6” b l k A il 15
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
1.6” below average peak on April 15
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Mountain Snowpack Conditions
Recap of Water Year 2012
20
22
24
Mountain Snowpack Conditions
20112012Average
14
16
18
20
quiv
alen
ts)
Average
8
10
12
ow W
ater
Eq
(Inch
es
2
4
6Sno
0
Recap of Water Year 20125-17-2012
Recap of Water Year 20126-8-2012
Recap of Water Year 20126-15-2012
Recap of Water Year 20126-20-2012
Recap of Water Year 20116-30-2011
Rule Curve Operations April-JulyRule Curve Operations April-July
2012 April-July Forecasts &Rule Curve TargetsRule Curve Targets
Rule CurveDate Forecast % of Avg Min Elev. Date
Jan. 1 1,131,400 99% 3613.4 5/03F b 1 1 212 200 102% 3612 6 5/08Feb. 1 1,212,200 102% 3612.6 5/08Mar. 1 1,344,300 118% 3611.1 5/13April 1 1,064,000 93% 3614.4 5/02p , ,April 15 903,900 79% 3616.6 4/26May 1 749,700 77% 3619.0 5/01May 15 641 800 56% 3622 1 5/16May 15 641,800 56% 3622.1 5/16June 1 690,500 61% 3626.1 6/01
Actual 693,100 61%
Bighorn Lake Rule Curve Operation 2012
15000
16500
18000
3,640
3,645
3,650
10500
12000
13500
3,625
3,630
3,635
e (c
fs)
on (f
eet)
6000
7500
9000
3,610
3,615
3,620
Dis
char
ge
Elev
atio
1500
3000
4500
3,595
3,600
3,605
03,590Apr May Jun Jul
Elevation Rule Curve Top of Joint Use Inflow River Release
Bighorn Lake April-July Inflow
Recap of Water Year 2012
3000
g p y1967-2012 2012 – 693 kaf
Ave. – 1,138 kaf
2000
2500
(kaf
)
1500
-Jul
y Inf
low
(
500
1000
Apr
il-
0
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Years
Bighorn Lake Inflows 2012
Recap of Water Year 2012
20000
22000
Bighorn Lake Inflows 2011Average
Peaked Inflow = 6,527 cfs on June 713,826 cfs lower than in 2011WY 2011 Total Inflow: 3,817.0 kaf (162% of average)
WY 2012 T t l I fl 1 850 0 k f (78% f )
14000
16000
18000
cfs)
WY 2012 Total Inflow: 1,850.0 kaf (78% of average)
Average Total Inflow – 2,337.7 kaf
8000
10000
12000
Inflo
ws
(c
2000
4000
6000
8000
0
2000
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
Bighorn Lake River Release 2012
Recap of Water Year 2012
140001500016000
Bighorn Lake River Release 2011Average
1000011000120001300014000
cfs)
6000700080009000
10000
r R
elea
se (
c
10002000300040005000
Riv
er
01000
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
Bighorn Lake Storage 2012
Recap of Water Year 2012
3655
3660
Bighorn Lake Storage 20122011Average
Peaked on June 25 at 3635.58 feet4 42 f t b l f ll l
3640
3645
3650
et)
4.42 feet below full pool19.45 feet lower than in 2011
3625
3630
3635
evat
ion
(Fee
3605
3610
3615
3620Ele
3600
3605
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
BIGHORN LAKE2013 Fall and Winter Operations2013 Fall and Winter Operations
Preview
BIGHORN LAKE CURRENT CONDITIONSNovember 1 2012
Elevation 3630 85 ft – 9 15 ft below full pool
November 1, 2012
3630.85 ft – 9.15 ft below full pool8.45 feet lower than last year
Storage 919,886 af – 90% full
Inflows = 2,000 cfs
O f fTotal Outflow = 1,750 cfsRiver = 1,750 cfsBIA Canal = 0 cfsBIA Canal 0 cfs
End of October StorageEnd of October Storage
Storage Lake ElevationWater Year Acre-feet Feet
2012 919,225 3630.85
2011 1,011,836 3639.30
2010 938,169 3627.72
2009 1,063,770 3639.50
*Area-Capacity Table Changed January 1, 2011
NWS Long Range Temperature Forecasts
Nov-Dec-Jan
NWS Long Range Temperature Forecasts
Feb-Mar-Apr
NWS Long Range Precipitation Forecasts
Nov-Dec-Jan
NWS Long Range Precipitation Forecasts
Feb-Mar-Apr
3 0
2012 Valley Precipitation
2.5
3.0
es)
1.5
2.0
atio
n (In
che
1.0
Prec
ipita
0.0
0.5
Jun Jul Aug SeptJun Jul Aug Sept
Month
Average Valley Precipitation Actual Valley Precipitation
3 0
2012 Mountain Precipitation
2.5
3.0
es)
1.5
2.0
atio
n (In
che
1.0
Prec
ipita
0.0
0.5
Jun Jul Aug SeptJun Jul Aug Sept
Month
Average Mountain Precipitation Actual Mountain Precipitation
Bighorn Lake ‐ Snow Water Equivalent
14
16November 7, 2012 was 55% of average
10
12
hes)
6
8
SWE (in
ch
2
4
0
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
Average Water Year 2012 Water Year 2013
Inflow Conditions September
Bighorn Lake• September: 119 KAF (69% of Ave)p ( )
– 6th Lowest
Boysen ReservoirBoysen Reservoir• September: 29 KAF (53% of Ave)
– 6th Lowest
Buffalo Bill Reservoir• September: 12 KAF (45% of Ave)• September: 12 KAF (45% of Ave)
– Lowest
Inflow Conditions October
Bighorn Lake• October: 132 KAF (75% of Ave)( )
– 9th Lowest
Boysen ReservoirBoysen Reservoir• October: 24 KAF (41% of Ave)
– 3rd Lowest
Buffalo Bill Reservoir• October: 13 KAF (52% of Ave)• October: 13 KAF (52% of Ave)
– Lowest
4 000 000
Bighorn Lake Cumulative InflowOctober 1 - September 30
3,500,000
4,000,000Water Year 2012 Total Inflow: 1,854 kaf (78% of average)
Average Total Inflow: 2,389 kaf
2,500,000
3,000,000
acre‐fe
et)
1,500,000
2,000,000
Inflo
w (a
500,000
1,000,000
0Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
Average Cumulative Inflow 2012 Cumulative Inflow 2013 Cumulative Inflow
1 000 000
Bighorn Lake Cumulative InflowOctober 1 - March 31
800,000
900,000
1,000,000Water Year 2012 Oct-Mar Actual Inflow: 726 kaf (121% of average)
Water Year 2013 Oct-Mar Inflow Forecast: 558 kaf (71% of average)
600,000
700,000
acre‐fe
et)
400,000
500,000
Inflo
w (
100,000
200,000
300,000
0
,
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr
Average Cumulative Inflow 2012 Cumulative Inflow 2013 Cumulative Inflow
1 000 000
Bighorn Lake Cumulative InflowOctober 1 - March 31
800,000
900,000
1,000,000Water Year 2012 Oct-Mar Actual Inflow: 726 kaf (121% of average)
Water Year 2013 Oct-Mar Inflow Forecast: 558 kaf (71% of average)
600,000
700,000
acre‐fe
et)
400,000
500,000
Inflo
w (
100,000
200,000
300,000
0
,
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr
Average Cumulative Inflow 2012 Cumulative Inflow 2013 Cumulative Inflow
BIGHORN LAKE CURRENT CONDITIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2013 Plans
BIGHORN LAKE CURRENT CONDITIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2013 Plans
STEP 1
Operating Criteria Used for 2013 Plans
2012 April-October Gain = -61,400 acre-feet2012 End-of-October Storage = 919,225 acre-feetUpstream Reservoir Fall & Winter Releases =
Boysen = 500 cfsB ff l Bill 205 fBuffalo Bill = 205 cfs
Projected End-of-March Target Elevation = 3617Calculated November-March Gain = 213,500 acre-feetCalculated Fall & Winter Release for Yellowtail:
River = 1 859 cfsRiver = 1,859 cfs
BIGHORN LAKE CURRENT CONDITIONSOperating Criteria Used for 2013 Plans
STEP 2
Operating Criteria Used for 2013 Plans
Since Calculated Fall & Winter Release is < 2,000 cfs
Set End of March target elevation @ 3615Set End-of-March target elevation @ 3615
Calculated New Fall & Winter Release for Yellowtail:River = 1,904 cfs
OPERATION SCENARIOS
Most Probable Inflow Conditions
• Nov–Mar Inflow forecast at 425 kaf (61% of ave).
• Reservoir level expected to reach end of March target elevation of 3615
• River release maintained @ 1,900 cfs during November-March
• Generation during November–March would total 192 GWHrs192 GWHrs.
Maximum Probable Inflow Conditions
• Nov–Mar Inflow forecast at 504 kaf (73% of ave).
• Reservoir level expected to reach end of March target elevation of 3615
• River release maintained @ 1,900 cfs from November-February and gradually increased in y g yMarch to control storage
• Generation during November March would total• Generation during November–March would total 226 GWHrs.
Minimum Probable Inflow Conditions
• Nov–Mar inflow forecast at 390 kaf (56% of ave)
• Reservoir level expected to reach end of March target elevation of 3615
• River release maintained @ 1,900 cfs from November-January and gradually decrease y g yreleases in February and March to conserve storage
• Power generation during November–March would total 176 GWHrs.
3645
Bighorn LakeTop of Joint-Use Conservation - Elevation 3640 (1,020.6 kaf)
12,000
14,000
3630
3635
3640
10,000
3615
3620
3625
w (c
fs)
n Fe
et
6,000
8,000
3600
3605
3610
Riv
er F
low
Elev
atio
n in
4,000
3585
3590
3595E
0
2,000
3570
3575
3580
Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 Nov-13
Most River Most Elev
3645
Bighorn LakeTop of Joint-Use Conservation - Elevation 3640 (1,020.6 kaf)
12,000
14,000
3630
3635
3640
10,000
3615
3620
3625
w (c
fs)
n Fe
et
6,000
8,000
3600
3605
3610
Riv
er F
low
Elev
atio
n in
4,000
3585
3590
3595E
0
2,000
3570
3575
3580
Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 Nov-13
Max River Most River Max Elev Most Elev
3645
Bighorn LakeTop of Joint-Use Conservation - Elevation 3640 (1,020.6 kaf)
12,000
14,000
3630
3635
3640
10,000
3615
3620
3625
w (c
fs)
n Fe
et
6,000
8,000
3600
3605
3610
Riv
er F
low
Elev
atio
n in
4,000
3585
3590
3595E
0
2,000
3570
3575
3580
Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 Nov-13
Most River Min River Min Elev Most Elev
3645
Bighorn LakeTop of Joint-Use Conservation - Elevation 3640 (1,020.6 kaf)
12,000
14,000
3630
3635
3640
10,000
3615
3620
3625
w (c
fs)
n Fe
et
6,000
8,000
3600
3605
3610
Riv
er F
low
Elev
atio
n in
4,000
3585
3590
3595E
0
2,000
3570
3575
3580
Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 Nov-13
Max River Most River Min River Max Elev Min Elev Most Elev
Summary of Current Conditions
• Lower carryover in Boysen, Buffalo Bill, and Bighorn Lakeg
• NWS forecast through March is for higher chance of warmer than normal temperatureschance of warmer than normal temperatures
• Inflow forecast through March is below normalg
• Below normal valley and mountain precipitation
• Below normal inflow in Boysen, Buffalo Bill, and Bighorn Lake in September and October
Recommended Operating Plan
• Nov–Mar Inflow forecast at 425 kaf (61% of ave).
• Reservoir level expected to reach end of March target elevation of 3617
• River release maintained @ 1,850 cfs during November-March
• Generation during November–March would total 186 GWHrs186 GWHrs.
Recommended Operation Plan
STEP 12012 April-October Gain = -61,400 acre-feet2012 End-of-October Storage = 919,225 acre-feetUpstream Reservoir Fall & Winter Releases =
Boysen = 500 cfsB ff l Bill 205 fBuffalo Bill = 205 cfs
Projected End-of-March Target Elevation = 3617Calculated November-March Gain = 213,500 acre-feetCalculated Fall & Winter Release for Yellowtail:
River = 1 859 cfsRiver = 1,859 cfs
3645
Bighorn LakeTop of Joint-Use Conservation - Elevation 3640 (1,020.6 kaf)
12,000
14,000
3630
3635
3640
10,000
3615
3620
3625
w (c
fs)
n Fe
et
6,000
8,000
3600
3605
3610
Riv
er F
low
Elev
atio
n in
4,000
3585
3590
3595E
0
2,000
3570
3575
3580
Nov-12 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 Nov-13
Max River Most River Min River Max Elev Min Elev Most Elev
Reclamation’s Internet Website
http://www.usbr.gov/gp/water/
l ti d t il bl th h th HYDROMET d t t• near real-time data available through the HYDROMET data system• summaries and plots of historical data• annual reservoir operating plan publication• monthly water supply reports• monthly water supply reports• project data• snow plots• links to related internet sites
CommentsThe information presented at this meeting can be found on the Montana Area Office website at:
Comments
Montana Area Office website at:
www.usbr.gov/gp/mtao/yellowtail/index.cfm
Please mail comments to:
Ms. Paula A. Holwegner
Bureau of ReclamationBureau of Reclamation
2900 4th Avenue North, Suite 501
Billings, MT 59107
fax your comments to: 406-247-7338
or email your comments to: [email protected]