a design/build approach to stream restoration for flood ... · stream restoration for flood control...

25
1 A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon Presented by: Paul Agrimis, RLA, PE, PWS, and Adam Zucker, PE, CWRE, from Vigil-Agrimis, Inc. and Mike McCallen from Clean Water Services Project Team: CLEAN WATER SERVICES Tom Lawler - Project Manager Mike McCallen – Construction Leader VIGIL-AGRIMIS, INC. Paul Agrimis, RLA, PE, PWS – Principal-in-Charge Adam Zucker, PE, CWRE - Project Manager

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jun-2020

14 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

1

A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for

Flood Control & Erosion Controlon Willow Creek,

Washington County, Oregon

Presented by:

Paul Agrimis, RLA, PE, PWS, andAdam Zucker, PE, CWRE, from Vigil-Agrimis, Inc.

andMike McCallen from Clean Water Services

Project Team:

CLEAN WATER SERVICESTom Lawler - Project Manager

Mike McCallen –Construction Leader

VIGIL-AGRIMIS, INC.Paul Agrimis, RLA, PE, PWS –

Principal-in-ChargeAdam Zucker, PE, CWRE -

Project Manager

Page 2: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

2

Vicinity Map

Watershed Map

Page 3: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

3

•Design Objectives

•Design/Construction Process

•Owner Perspective

•Performance to Date

•Conclusion

DESIGN OBJECTIVES:

1. Relocate Three Sections of Willow Creek Away from Properties Prone to Flooding

2. Grade and Plant Sections of the Abandoned Creek Channel to Create Backwater Sloughs

3. Remove Invasive Species and Replant with Native Species.

Page 4: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

4

DESIGN OBJECTIVES:

4. To Increase Flood Storage Capacity by Reclaiming Old Floodplain and Creating New Floodplain to Dissipate Peak Flows with Decreased Erosion Risk

5. Restore Wetlands by Removing Fill Previously Placed in the Floodplain

Eroding Bank Along Residence Fence

Page 5: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

5

Incised Channel With Limited Floodplain Access

Channel With Ready Floodplain Access

Page 6: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

6

Neighbor “Solution” to Bank Erosion

PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION:

1. Analysis, Design, and Permitting by Vigil-Agrimis, Inc.

2. Construction Based on 90% Plans by Clean Water Service

3. Construction Collaboration By Clean Water Services and Vigil-Agrimis, Inc.

Page 7: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

7

BASIN and STREAM CHARACTERISTICS and ISSUES:

1. Basin Rapidly Urbanized

2. Cove Soils Dominate in Floodplain

3. Channel Incision And Loss of Floodplain Access

4. Infrastructure and Utility Constraints

DESIGN PROCESS:

1. Address the Acute Concerns:– Relocating Three Sections of the

Channel– Stabilizing Eroding Banks

2. Address the Long Term Systemic Issues

– Increase Floodplain Storage– Improve Channel/Floodplain

Connectivity

Page 8: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

8

Willow Creek – Existing Alignment

Addressing the Acute Concerns

Page 9: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

9

Stream Diversion Bioengineering Design

Stream Diversion Bioengineering Construction

Page 10: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

10

Improved Floodplain Access and Shear Stress Reduction

Improved Floodplain / Channel Connectivity

Page 11: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

11

CONSTRUCTION PROCESS AND IMPLEMENTATION:

Need to be FLEXIBLE Implementing the Design

• Survey Discrepancies

• Utility Conflicts

• Address Vulnerable Areas

Site Conditions/Challenges

• Improve Understanding of Site by Clearing/ Mowing Prior to Construction

• Find Opportunities to Minimize and Avoid Impact to Large Oaks and Ash

• Take Advantage of the Existing Microtopography

Page 12: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

12

Pre-Construction Cleared Conditions

Constructed Creek Relocation

Page 13: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

13

Peak Event Overflow Channel

Summer Storm

• Can Slow Construction

• Cause Erosion

• Identify Vulnerable Areas in the Construction

Implementation of Brush Mattress

Page 14: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

14

Brush Mattress after Peak Event

Dan and Mike - Clean Water Services Construction Crew

Page 15: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

15

OWNER PERSPECTIVE:

1. Performance Driven Construction, Not Financially Driven Construction

Pre-Construction Brushy Conditions

Page 16: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

16

OWNER PERSPECTIVE:

2. No Change Orders – Just Adjustments in the Field

Changes in the Field to Fit Opportunities and Needs

Page 17: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

17

Implementation of Brush Mattress as Erosion Control

Rootwad Adjustments Needed

Page 18: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

18

Repair of Rootwad

OWNER PERSPECTIVE:

3. Value and Long Term Success

Page 19: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

19

Dan Enjoying his Work

PERFORMANCE TO DATE:

1. Several Peak Events2. Relocation Has Successfully Relieved

Property Impacts3. Stream Pattern Appears Stable4. Floodplain Access Not Achieved Universally

Page 20: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

20

High Velocity Reach Below NW 143rd Box Culverts

Extent of November 2006 Highwater

Page 21: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

21

Location of Slope Area Calculation Cross Sections

Cross-Section 1

Page 22: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

22

Cross-Section 2

Cross-Section 3

Page 23: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

23

Cross-Section 4

Cross-Section 5

Page 24: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

24

Falls at First Log Structure

Falls at First Log Structure from Downstream

Page 25: A Design/Build Approach to Stream Restoration for Flood ... · Stream Restoration for Flood Control & Erosion Control on Willow Creek, Washington County, Oregon ... • Survey Discrepancies

25

CONCLUSION:

• Cost Effective Stream Relocation ~ $250/LF

• Many Floodplain Opportunities Realized Despite Some Utility Challenges

• Additional Habitat Creation Facilitated