a gravity situation eastside trunk sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional wwtp • adwf: 3.3 mgd • pwwf:...

53
A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer Rohnert Park, CA Art da Rosa, PE | Civil Engineer | City of Rohnert Park Matt Winkelman, PE | Civil Engineer | GHD Inc. Jim Winter, PE | Construction Manager | GHD Inc. Dru Nielson, CEG | Geologist | McMillen Jacobs Associates

Upload: others

Post on 19-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

A Gravity Situation –

Eastside Trunk Sewer

Rohnert Park, CA

Art da Rosa, PE | Civil Engineer | City of Rohnert Park

Matt Winkelman, PE | Civil Engineer | GHD Inc.

Jim Winter, PE | Construction Manager | GHD Inc.

Dru Nielson, CEG | Geologist | McMillen Jacobs Associates

Page 2: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Presentation agenda

• Background

• Planning and Design

• Construction

• Conclusions and What’s Next

Page 3: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

Background

Page 4: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Rohnert Park

• Located in Sonoma County

• Population ~ 45,000

• Incorporated in 1962

City of Rohnert Park, California

Page 5: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Rohnert Park collection system - overview

• 80 miles of 6- to 42-inch gravity sewer

• 16 inverted siphons

• 1 collection system lift station

• All flow conveyed to Main Pump Station, which pumps flow to the

regional WWTP

• ADWF: 3.3 mgd

• PWWF: 14 mgd

Page 6: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Rohnert Park collection system goals

• Minimize the use of pump stations

• Reduce life cycle costs associated with I/I

• Improve collection system reliability

• Build critical infrastructure with a longer useful life compared to local

collector sewers

• Minimize impacts to the public

Page 7: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

System evaluation: 2003 - 2005

• Flow monitoring and field reconnaissance

• Hydraulic modeling and assessment

• Hydraulic deficiencies identified

• Opportunity identified to alleviate deficiencies by constructing a new,

gravity trunk sewer

Page 8: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

System evaluation: the result

• Construct a 3.5 mile trunk sewer to relieve capacity deficiencies in

the eastern portion of the collection system

• Convey up to 12.7 mgd to the Main Pump Station

• Project split into three phases

Page 9: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Rohnert Park trunk sewers

Page 10: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Eastside trunk sewer (2008-2015)

Page 11: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

Planning and Design

Page 12: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Geotechnical Setting

Berkeley

Rohnert Park

Page 13: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Geotechnical Setting

Page 14: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Geotechnical Setting

Page 15: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Geotechnical Setting

Page 16: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Geotechnical Setting

Page 17: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

A Gravity Situation

• What is the challenge?

• Is construction feasible?

• Does the project make financial sense?

• What are the project/municipality objectives?

• Comprehensive planning, then design

Page 18: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Gravity trunk sewers

• Utility conflicts

• Highway, railroad, and waterway crossings

• Flat and/or hilly terrain – deep trenching

• High groundwater and poor soils

• Community impacts

Page 19: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

An alternative – pumped system

• Shallower trenching

• Fewer potential utility conflicts

However…

• Pump station capital and O&M costs

• Local collection system needs

• Community impacts

Page 20: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Gravity or pumped system?

• Useful life of construction materials

• O&M costs

• System reliability

Page 21: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Page 22: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Page 23: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Page 24: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

LOW I/I / Corrosion / Community Impacts HIGH

Page 25: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

LOW I/I / Corrosion / Community Impacts HIGH

Page 26: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

LOW I/I / Corrosion / Community Impacts HIGH

Page 27: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Corrosive atmosphere in manhole

Unlined manhole Fiberglass base liner

Page 28: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Lined or unlined manholes?

Page 29: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Lined or unlined manholes?

Page 30: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Lined or unlined manholes?

Page 31: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Lined or unlined manholes?

Page 32: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Lined or unlined manholes?

Page 33: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Construction materials

• Integrated manhole systems

• Pipeline materials

• Trench materials

Page 34: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

• Water-tight design

• Improved quality control with factory fabrication

• Increased construction efficiency

• Reduced manhole diameter

Page 35: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

Construction

Page 36: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Phase 1 (2007) Manhole Base

• Precast with HDPE liner, polymer concrete coating, and “boot”

connection

Page 37: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Phases 2 and 3 (2013) Manhole Base

• Precast with fiberglass insert and gasketed connection

Integrated manhole systems

Page 38: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Phases 2 and 3 (2013) Manhole Base

• Gasketed pipe connections

Page 39: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Wall Liner

• Phases 1 and 2 – GSE StudLiner

• Phase 3 – Agru Sure-Grip Liner

Page 40: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Wall Liner

• Welded liner joints, including HDPE to fiberglass

Page 41: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Manhole Chimney

• Phases 1 and 2 – HDPE, wrap

• Phase 3 – fiberglass collar

Page 42: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Integrated manhole systems

Inside Lateral Drop Connections

• Welded joints

• Boot connection

Page 43: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Pipeline materials

• Phase 1 – HDPE-lined Concrete, double gasket

• Phases 2 and 3 – AWWA C905 PVC

Page 44: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Trench materials

• Controlled Low Strength Material (CLSM)

• Crushed rock bedding (3/4”)

Page 45: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Construction techniques

• Positive utility verification (potholing)

• Dewatering, shoring, soil stabilization

• Controlled low strength material (CLSM)

• CCTV inspection – allowable “bellies”

• Manholes testing

Page 46: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Positive utility verification

• Complete enough potholes to

identify alignment challenges

ahead of construction

• Coordinate with utility

companies

• Allow time for utility relocation

or modification

Page 47: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Dewatering, shoring, soil stabilization

• Dewatering wells at 50 to 100 foot spacing

• Shoring with soil stabilization

Page 48: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Manhole testing

• Manhole liner spark testing

• Manhole pressure testing

Page 49: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Pipe testing

• Joint Testing: vacuum, air testing

• Video: bellies

Page 50: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

Conclusions and What’s Next

Page 51: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

Conclusions

• Determine if system rehabilitation or conveyance is appropriate

• Evaluate life cycle costs for alternatives

• Evaluate available materials and techniques during project planning

• Learning curve for contractors

• I/I rehabilitation program could take 10 to 20 years to show tangible

benefits

Page 52: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

What’s next?

• Planning and assessment

• I/I rehabilitation

• Construction materials:

– Integrated manhole systems

– Pipelines: HDPE, plastic, fiberglass

– Trenches: CLSM

• Construction techniques

• Laterals

Page 53: A Gravity Situation Eastside Trunk Sewer · 5/5/2017  · regional WWTP • ADWF: 3.3 mgd • PWWF: 14 mgd . A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA ... •

A Gravity Situation – Eastside Trunk Sewer, Rohnert Park, CA

www.ghd.com