945 halley presentation

Integrated Governance & Integrated Governance & Management:Management:

A Leadership Challenge!A Leadership Challenge!

Presented by:Presented by:

Marc D. Halley, MBAChairman and CEO

The Halley Consulting Group, Inc.

Percival Kane, MHASVP & Network AdministratorNorth Oaks Physician Group

Healthcare Financial Management AssociationRegion 5

February 20, 2015

Discussion Topics

I. Our Business Imperatives

II. The Physician Integration Continuum

III. The Critical Role of Governance

IV. Management Styles and Power Bases

V. Vertical Governance: The Council Model

VI. Horizontal Governance

VII.Q&A

2

Our Business Imperatives

Strategic Imperatives – Organizations Must Do These Things

4

The Concept of “Value”

5

Clinical Process

Clinical Outcome

PatientExperience

Effective

CostPerUnit

Utilization Efficient

The Physician Integration Continuum

Common Integration Options(Multiple “Plugs”)

Inte

gra

tion

Sustainability/ Infrastructure

Medical Staff

PHO/IPA

Medical Directorships/

Co-management

Joint Venture

Independent

Contractor/ PSA/SBS

Employee

H

HLHalley, Marc D. 2011. Owning Medical Practices: Best Practices for Sustainable Results. Chicago, IL: AHA Press. 67. 7

Physician Integration Economics –

Fee for Service

8

Capture &Retain

Market Share

Hospital Capital

Generator

Capital Preservation &

Investment

Market Manage

rPrim

ar

y Car

e

Subspecial

ty

Physicians

Potential Capital Loss

Potential Capital Drain

Potential Capital Drain

Referral Path

8

© 2008 The Halley Consulting Group, LLC

Halley, Marc D. 2011. Owning Medical Practices: Best Practices for Sustainable Results. Chicago, IL: AHA Press. 10.

Physician Integration Economics –Risk Payment Model

Panel Size Access Time &

Materials

Hospital Risk Pool

Capital Potential

Capital Preservation &

Investment

Market Manage

rPrim

ar

y Car

e

Specialty

Physician

sPotential

Capital Loss

Potential Capital Drain

Potential Capital Drain

Referral Path

9

© 2008 The Halley Consulting Group, LLC

Halley, Marc D. 2011. Owning Medical Practices: Best Practices for Sustainable Results. Chicago, IL: AHA Press. 10.

Moving Up the Integration Pyramid

• Population-centered care• Personal accountability for

healthy behaviors and lifestyle• Population health management• Chronic disease prevention &

management• Access and information = value• Risk-based payment

• Choreographed care (Accountability)

• Improving process and outcomes• Clinical quality commitments• Transparent flow of clinical

information across care continuum• Managing an episode of care or

chronic disease using clinical metrics

• Individual and joint accountability to live by established metrics

• Collaborative care (Trust)

• PCMH & “Choice” Initiatives

• Vital behaviors (“We”/“Our”)

• Service quality extension of referring provider’s office

• Information lubricates the Referral Path

• Referral management

• Coordinated care (Silos)

• Basic form of integration• Legal

structure/Organization chart

• Payroll silos (“Me”/“You”)

• Referral leakage

10

© 2013 The Halley Consulting Group, Inc.

The Critical Role of Governance

Fiduciary and Operational Governance

• Select and evaluate the chief executive

• Enterprise vision & strategies

• Capital formation and allocation

• Mergers & acquisitions• Regulatory compliance• Enterprise financial &

quality oversight• Enterprise policy• Etc.

• Sponsor, direct & oversee implementation

• Operating policies, procedures

• Performance improvement tactics and timing

• Key stakeholder engagement

• Performance accountability

12

Vertical Governance(Formal Authority or Authorization)

13

OwnersOr

Fiduciaries

Employees

Management

Horizontal Governance(Common Consent)

(* Potential future members)

Service Line Council (SLC)

Clinical Process Teams (CPT)

(Functional Integration)

(Clinical Integration)

14© 2014 The Halley Consulting Group, Inc.

Management Styles and Power Bases

“Knowledge Workers…”

• Own the means of production – unique knowledge and practiced skill

• Highly mobile• Independent judgment (“professional”)• Need tools of production – capital

investment• Exceptional clinical opportunities =

loyalty• Compensation “hygiene” factor• Define their own level of contribution• “Cannot be supervised effectively”

Adapted from: Drucker, P. 1998. Peter Drucker on the Profession of Management. Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing. 122-124.

16

17

Power Bases

• Legal Power: official authority & position

• Expert Power: knowledge, ability, information

• Reverent Power: respect, personality, charisma

• Reward Power: ability to give or withhold incentives, capital, etc.

• Punitive Power: impose penalties

18

Gilson Leadership ScaleWays Leaders Make Decisions

• Tell: Identify the problem, discern the alternatives and make the decision

• Persuade: Add “sell” to above• Discuss: Identify the problem, discern the

alternatives, propose a tentative solution, gather input from those who will need to implement the solution, make the final decision

• Consult: Present the problem and background to the group, solicit alternative ideas and solutions from the group, leader makes the final decision

19

Gilson Leadership Scale (Continued) Ways Leaders Make Decisions

• Join: Manager participates as a member of the group in identifying the problem and alternatives, while agreeing, in advance, to carry out the decision of the group

20

Matching Leadership Styles and Power Bases

• Tell Legal, Expert, Punitive• Persuade Reverent, Reward• Discuss Reverent, Reward• Consult Expert, Reverent• Join Expert, Reverent

The Council Model: “Partnership” Led

Network Operations Council (NOC)

• Composition– Physician Chair– Physician representation from Primary Care Clinics, Medical

Specialty Clinics, Surgical Specialty Clinics & Hospital-based Services

– Executive Team representation: Executive VP/COO, SVP/Chief Legal Officer, SVP/CFO, SVP/CMO & SVP/Network Executive

• Purpose– Provide governance for overall physician network– Determine the strategic direction of the physician network– Make clinical/quality, operational, financial, strategic &

policy decisions globally for the physician network• Value

– Decision-making forum for the entire physician network that inherently has credibility & buy-in from other network providers

• Tools– Agenda comprised of standing reports from subcommittee

chairs & SVP/Network Executive, a review of monthly financial performance & new business.

– Supporting information: dashboards, Net 1, Net 2 Financials, action plans, policies, etc.

22

Network Operations

Council

Practice Operations

Council

Practice Operations Council (POC)• Composition

– Physicians within the practice– Mid-level providers within the practice– Practice Leadership Team: Practice Manager, Supervisor,

Regional Director & SVP/Network Executive• Purpose

– Provide governance for the practice– Determine the strategic direction of the practice– Determine how to adopt & execute NOC-approved directives– Make clinical/quality, operational, financial & strategic

decisions for the practice• Value

– Provider engagement with decision-making for the operations of the practice

– Provider awareness: operations, policies, performance, initiatives, challenges, etc.

– Accountability• Tools

– Site-Specific Action Plans– Net 1, Net 2 Financials– Supporting materials: dashboards, policies, presentations,

etc.

23

Network Operations

Council

Practice Operations

Council

Network Operations Council Subcommittees

24

The Extension of the Physician Governance Model into General Operations

25

North Oaks Physician GroupGovernance Structure

Horizontal Governance

The Limits of “Pay for Performance”

• Mind or heart?• When you pay for everything you

get, you get only what you pay for…

• From incentive to entitlement• Upping the ante…• Stifles innovation

27

Horizontal Integration

• A common interest– Chronic disease– Episode of care– Referrals

• Clear and compelling vision– Common cause is the glue– “An offer too good to refuse”– Overcomes tactical disagreement

28

Horizontal Integration

• Shared tenets (ground rules)– Clinical quality– Service quality– Productivity– Collaboration– Cost per unit– Process efficiency– Utilization– Financial viability

29

Horizontal Integration

• Working together– Individual roles– Shared commitments*– Performance targets– Performance management– Individual accountability– Joint accountability– Appropriate incentives/rewards

30

Shared Commitments…

• N,W,P’s– Needs (clinical)– Wants (preferences)– Priorities (constraints)

• Written Service Commitments– Extension of PCP– Referring physicians/providers/staff– “Their” patients

31

Shared Commitments…

• Clinical integration– Chronic– Complex Chronic– Episode of Care

• Clinical protocols/processes– Clinical Management Teams– Care Management Teams– Standards of care– Best practices

32

Shared Commitments…

– “Certification”

• Clinical outcomes– Effectiveness– Efficiency

• Critical nature of self-reporting

33

Questions and Answers…

34