application decisions - inis.gov.ie · decision visa type/refusal reason(s) ... - the granting of...

Decision Visa Type/Refusal Reason(s)

Refused ID:- You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of

Directive 2004/38/EC.
















Directive 2004/38/EC









21756342

21756012

21756162

21756282

21304472

21304712

21743482

21200022

21202472

21303822

21133862

21186962

21198912

Application Decisions:

Decisions for period from 06/03/2018 to 12/03/2018

Classification: DJELR

Mission: INIS Dublin

Application





















Refused ID - You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of
























Approved Join/acc.EU Cit (Spouse)

Approved Join/acc. EU Citizen Parent

Approved Join/acc. EU Citizen Parent










24566842

25367592

24546732

24565562

24566232

24323052

24325292

24325482

24223702

24319652

24320252

24066632

24066802

24066872

23775002

24062592

24062712

23664602

23697972

23774952

23160012

23440782

23448272

22659762

22728002

23149292

21756422

22135472




























Refused F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete

ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application/appeal. Additional information and documentation

was requested by way of correspondence dated 21st December

2017. None of the requested information or documentation was

provided with the exception of contact with the applicant. The

documentation provided to demonstrate ongoing contact and

communication maintained with the applicant since your arrival

in the State is deemed insufficient or incomplete.

PF:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public funds

PR:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public

resources







27417622

27417962

27418152

27053142

27218852

27298732

26575652

26706172

26999782

26009942

26193082

26193582

25488792

25579372

25668982

25488452










incomplete

FM:– There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals who are

family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long-term basis

to Ireland


application.



resources

Refused ID:-As per parent's refusal

Refused ID:-As per parent's refusal









27885472

27885592

27885662

27800202

27800262

27885332

27418312

27420852

27800062





Refused FM:– Family member - There is no automatic right for non-EEA

nationals who are family members of people who are Irish

Citizens to migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case

has been fully examined on the basis of the documentation

submitted and it has been decided not to grant your application.

ID:- This visa application does not meet the qualifying financial

criteria as per section 17.2 of INIS Family Policy Document on

Non--EEA family Reunification. An Irish citizen, in order to

sponsor an immediate family member, must not have been

totally or predominantly reliant on benefits from the Irish State

for a continuous period in excess of 2 years immediately prior to

the application and must over the three year period prior to

application have earned a cumulative gross income over and

above any State benefits of not less than €40K.

ID:- Quality of documents


application

INCO:- Inconsistencies e.g. contradictions in the information

supplied



resources















Refused ID:- The visa application does not meet the qualifying financial

criteria as per section 17.6 of INIS Policy Document on Non-

EEA Family Reunification.



resources

28385072

28474252

28946802

28026592

28377452

28384882

28001642

28003412

28026372





Refused F:- The reference has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria set out in paragraph 17.2 of the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification.

• As per the Policy Document: ‘An Irish citizen, in order to

sponsor an immediate family member, must not have been

totally or predominantly reliant on benefits from the Irish State

for a continuous period in excess of 2 years immediately prior to

the application and must over the three year period prior to

application have earned a cumulative gross income over and

above any State benefits of not less than €40k.’


family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long term basis

to Ireland.

• The case has been fully examined on the basis of the

documentation submitted, and it has been decided not to grant

the application. The application fails to satisfy the required

criteria to grant the visa applied for.

ID: Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application.

• Insufficient evidence of ongoing financial and social support

from the reference to the applicant..

PF: The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public funds.

• The reference has failed to show that he meets the financial

criteria set out in paragraph 17.2 of the Policy Document.

PR: The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public

resources.

• The reference has failed to show that he meets the financial Refused ID:- The visa application does not meet the qualifying criteria as

per section 15.3 of INIS Family Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification.

Approved Join Spouse

Refused ID:- As per parent's refusal reasons

Refused ID:- As per parent's refusal reasons

29434132

29434302

29112972

29130442

29303042





Refused F:- The reference has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria set out in paragraph 17.2 of the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification.

F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete


family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long term basis

to Ireland. The case has been fully examined on the basis of the

documentation submitted, and it has been decided not to grant

the application.


application:- please see link to "Documents Required" as

displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie


supplied


Approved Join Parent













incomplete





supplied

SP:- Previous educational or employment background is at odds

with course applied for

Approved Join Parent30694762

30046962

30047182

30501012

29783952

29784452

30003112

29708652

29708852

29749302

29707792

29708302

29708572

29434432





Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown. Sponsor has

failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial criteria as set

out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification

Section 17.2.

FM:- There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals who are

(extended) family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long-

term basis to Ireland.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie- Insufficient

documentation has been submitted as evidence of social or

financial dependency as per the Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification Section 14.1. Documentation requested not

submitted. Bio-data page of passport of sponsor not provided.

Marriage certificate not provided. Divorce certificate from

sponsor not provided. Up-to-date proof of address in Ireland not

provided from sponsor i.e. utility bill. Six month up-to-date bank

statements from sponsor not provided. Evidence of income over

previous three years from sponsor not provided i.e. P60 for

2014, 2015 and 2016. Three most recent payslips from sponsor

not provided. Employment letter from sponsor not provided.

Evidence of ongoing routine communication between applicant

and sponsors not provided. Evidence of financial support from

sponsor not provided. Evidence of sponsor having visited

applicant in country of residence provided. Birth certificate for

minor child not provided. Bio-data page of passport for minor

child not provided.

IH:- Immigration history of applicant.


supplied. Marital status of sponsor.

PF:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public funds.

Sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial

criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

30924312






incomplete

- The reference has failed to sufficiently demonstrated that he

satisfies 17.2 of the INIS Policy Document

- The applicant has not provided a 6 month bank statement in

her own name

- The bank statement submitted from the reference evidences

no earnings apart from social welfare payments, contrary to 17.2

of the Policy Document



to Ireland

- The application has not met the required criteria to grant the

visa




- The reference has not provided notices of Assessment of

income from self employment for the three most recent years,

and evidence of earnings in the period since the most recent tax

return was filed.

- The applicant has not provided full copies of her passports to

date

- The applicant has not provided sufficient information regarding

her dependent son who also resides in her country of residence.

It is unclear with whom he will reside should the applicant be

granted a visa.

- Insufficient evidence of on-going financial and social support of

the applicant by the reference has been provided

- The suitability of the proposed accommodation for the

applicant has not been evidenced. Nor has permission from the Approved Join Spouse

Refused ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the



IH:- Immigration history of applicant


supplied

IS:- Immigration status of the reference in Ireland. Evidence of

this has not been provided - Copy of GNIB card:- copy of

passport of reference

OC:- Condition - The applicant may work illegally in the State

OC:- Observe the conditions of the visa - the visa sought is for a

specific purpose and duration:- the applicant has not satisfied

the visa officer that such conditions would be observed.

R:- No clear link to reference has been shown

WP:- Work permit required

31069722

31080872

31063372





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient - Sponsor

has failed to meet the criteria set out in the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.2. The applicant’s

reference in Ireland has been in receipt of Social Welfare

payments.


incomplete

- As per INIS website applicant has not provided a detailed

statement of their sponsor’s bank accounts covering a six

month period immediately prior to their application.

- As per INIS website applicant has not provided evidence that

their sponsor meets the minimum level of earnings required -

P60s for the 3 years immediately prior to the date of their

application and 3 recent consecutive payslips or if self-employed

you must submit Notices of Assessment of income from self-

employment for the three most recent years, and evidence of

earnings in the period since the most recent tax return was filed.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown













31086572





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient / Sponsor


Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.6.


incomplete / Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in

sponsors bank account. / As per INIS website applicant has not

provided a detailed statement of their bank accounts covering a

six month period immediately prior to their application.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie / Applicant has

supplied a poor quality / illegible copy of their passport

Sponsor has not signed the letter of invitation

Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of

social or financial dependency as per the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification section 14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4 &

14.7.

If you are making your application on the basis of financial and

social dependency on your sponsor you must provide

documentary evidence to establish that you are actually

dependent on your sponsor. While the nature of the

documentary evidence may vary from case to case evidence of

the following will normally be relevant:

• Amount, frequency and duration of the financial support

provided by your sponsor (e.g. copies of your sponsor’s bank

statements showing transfers to your account, copies of your

bank statements showing receipt of those amounts),

• Any other sources of income that you may have,

• If you have no other source of income, evidence of why you

are unable to work, why you are not eligible for state benefits

etc.,

• Your living costs (e.g. evidence of mortgage/rent, utility, food,

medical, education payments).

31089512





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient - Sponsor


Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.6.




- It is noted the applicant is an adult and as such, is not normally

considered as an immediate family member for the purpose of

reunification. The Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification states in section 13.2a that immediate family

consists of a spouse and children under the age of 18. The

Policy Document further clarifies in footnote 11 that the

maximum age can be extended to 23 where the child is in full

time education. The applicant was 21 years old at the time of

application and has not provided a college letter confirming that

they are in FULL TIME education.




- Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of



14.7.








provided by your sponsor (e.g. copies of your sponsor’s bank Approved Join Spouse




31201672

31212362

31212672

31179472

31201272






incomplete

– Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in applicant’s

/ sponsors bank account.

– As per INIS website applicant has not provided a detailed

statement of their bank accounts covering a six month period

immediately prior to their application.







– Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of



14.7.














etc.,

• Your living costs (e.g. evidence of mortgage/rent, utility, food, Approved Join Spouse


31214582

31257632

31258192






incomplete. The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that he/she

meets the financial criteria as per the Policy Document on Non-

EEA Family Reunification section 17.2.



to Ireland. Your case has been fully examined on the basis of

the documentation submitted, and it has been decided not grant

your application.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie.

• Insufficient documentation submitted of on-going routine

communication between the applicant and the sponsor.

• Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of

social dependency as per the Policy Document section 14.1.

• Copy of birth certificate and passport not submitted for the

sponsor’s oldest child.

• Quality of the employment letter submitted by the applicant.


The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that he/she meets the

financial criteria as per the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification section 17.2.


resources. The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that he/she

meets the financial criteria as per the Policy Document on Non-


31264992






incomplete

- Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in applicant’s







– Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of



14.7.














etc.,



• Details of any other family members in your country of

residence.

• Your medical condition (where relevant), relationship with the

31267882





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient

- Sponsor has failed to meet the criteria set out in the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.2. The

applicant’s reference in Ireland has been in receipt of Social

Welfare payments.


incomplete

























you must submit Notices of Assessment of income from self-Refused F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete




OB:- Obligations to return to home country have not been

deemed sufficient




31319652

31276872






incomplete





deemed sufficient




Refused ID:- Applicant is travelling with parents whose visas have been

refused


incomplete

- Unexplained lump sum lodgements in sponsors a/c *****033

- Sponsor has not supplied 6 months statements for a/c *****574







14.7.














etc.,




residence.


sponsor including evidence of active and continuous

involvement in your life e.g. evidence of visits, correspondence.

31340572

31320152

31321592






incomplete

- Unexplained lump sum lodgements in sponsors a/c *****194

- Sponsor has not supplied 6 months statements for a/c *****194







14.7.














residence.


sponsor including evidence of active and continuous

involvement in your life e.g. evidence of visits, correspondence.


supplied

- Sponsor does not have written permission from landlord to

move applicant into their accommodation as per para 3.12 and

31341922





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient.


Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.6.


Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.2. The

applicant’s reference in Ireland has been in receipt of Social

Welfare payments.


bank account.




– Applicant has not provided a signed letter of application

including your full contact details

• Outlining your reason for coming to Ireland.

• Providing details of the family member in Ireland who is

sponsoring your application.

• Giving details of any other members of your family who are

currently in Ireland, or any other EU Member State.

– Sponsor has failed to supply evidence of their eligibility to

sponsor. In the case of a sponsor who is a non-EEA citizen

• a clear and legible copy of all pages of their passport,

• where relevant, a copy of their certificate of registration (a

document issued by the Irish immigration authorities)

• a copy of their current employment permit/researcher

(scientific) hosting agreement or other evidence of eligibility to

sponsor

- Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of

the claimed relationship. The onus of proof as to the

genuineness of the relationship rests on you and your sponsor.

• If your sponsor (spouse/civil partner) is residing in Ireland and

31352192






incomplete






month period immediately prior to their application. Statements

supplied have no name or address on them.


their sponsor meets the minimum level of earnings required - 3

recent consecutive payslips or if self-employed you must submit

Notices of Assessment of income from self-employment for the

three most recent years, and evidence of earnings in the period

since the most recent tax return was filed.









month period immediately prior to their application. Statements

supplied have no name or address on them.


their sponsor meets the minimum level of earnings required - 3

recent consecutive payslips or if self-employed you must submit

Notices of Assessment of income from self-employment for the

three most recent years, and evidence of earnings in the period

since the most recent tax return was filed.

– Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of Approved Spouse of Irish Citizen


incomplete


supplied

31399812

31433982

31442262





Refused FM:– There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals who are


to Ireland.

ID:- Authenticity of documents. Marriage certificate and birth

certificates submitted for all minors accompanying applicant.




• Quality of marriage certificate submitted.

• Quality of birth certificates submitted of all minors

accompanying the applicant.

ID:- It is noted that the applicant and sponsor were 15 years of

age and 14 years of age, respectively, at the time when they are

stated to have entered into marriage. For this reason, the stated

marriage between two minors is not deemed sufficient for

immigration purposes.


supplied. Inconsistencies found in the birth certificates

submitted for all minors accompanying the applicant.

Inconsistencies found in the spelling of the applicants name on

money transfers, previous visa applications, marriage/birth

certificates and current application.

VR:- Previous visa refusal not declared.



to Ireland.


certificates submitted for the applicant and all other minors

accompanying applicant.




• Quality of parents’ marriage certificate submitted.

• Quality of birth certificates submitted for the applicant and all

other minors accompanying the applicant.



submitted for the applicant and all other minors accompanying

the applicant. Inconsistencies found in the spelling of the

applicant’s mothers name on money transfers, previous visa

applications, marriage/birth certificates and current application.


31474892

31475102







to Ireland.


certificates submitted for the applicant and all other minors

















to Ireland.


certificates submitted for the applicant and other all minors















31475272

31475192







to Ireland.


















to Ireland.
















31475402

31475592






incomplete - Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in

both sponsors bank accounts.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie -

- Applicant has not submitted passport no: ******111 – as per

INIS website applicants must supply “Your current passport and

a full copy of any previous passports”

- Applicant has not signed their letter of application including

your full contact details - as per INIS website

– Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application. Insufficient documentation has been submitted as

evidence of social or financial dependency as per the Policy

Document section 14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4 & 14.7.














etc.,




residence.Approved Join Parent

Approved Spouse of Irish Citizen

Approved Join Parent31712982

31495812

31619712

31712122







meets the financial criteria as set out in the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification section 17.2.



to Ireland.




• P60s relating to the years 2014 and 2015 have not been

submitted by the sponsor.


routine on-going communication between the applicant and the

sponsor in Ireland.

• Insufficient documentation has been submitted to demonstrate

that the sponsor has been supporting the applicant financially

via remittances.

• The applicant has failed to demonstrate that he/she is socially

or financially dependent on the sponsor as per the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section 14.1.

• The application letter stated that the sponsor visits the

applicant once a year, insufficient evidence has been submitted

as evidence of these visits e.g. immigration stamps in passport,

photos of the applicant with the sponsor during visit.



financial criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification section 17.2.





31722372











to Ireland.




• P60s relating to the years 2014 and 2015 have not been

submitted by the sponsor.

• Insufficient documentation has been submitted to demonstrate

that the sponsor has been supporting the applicant financially

via remittances.

• The applicant has failed to demonstrate that he/she is socially

or financially dependent on the sponsor as per the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section 14.1.

• The application letter stated that the sponsor visits the

applicant once a year, insufficient evidence has been submitted

as evidence of these visits e.g. immigration stamps in passport,

photos of the applicant with the sponsor during visit.









31722692





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient- Sponsor

has failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial criteria as

set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.


family members of persons with temporary leave to remain to

migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland.






Family Reunification Section 14.1. Evidence of ongoing routine

contact/communication between applicant and sponsor not

provided. Insufficient evidence of sponsor having visited

applicant in home country provided. Insufficient information

submitted to show the extent to which family life has been

sustained since the reference first elected to move to Ireland.

Insufficient documentation has been submitted to show that the

sponsor has been supporting the applicant financially via

remittances. Marriage registration certificate not provided. Letter

of invitation from sponsor not provided. Letter of application not

provided.








resources. Sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the


Family Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.

31755972









FM:– There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals, who are

family members of persons with temporary leave to remain, to







Family Reunification Section 14.1. Insufficient evidence of

sponsor having visited applicant in home country provided.

Insufficient information submitted to show the extent to which

family life has been sustained since the reference first elected to

move to Ireland. Insufficient documentation has been submitted

to show that the sponsor has been supporting the applicant

financially via remittances. Letter of invitation from sponsor not

provided.











31756512
























provided.











31756782
























provided.











31756882





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient. Sponsor



Reunification Section 17.2.


incomplete. Sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet

the financial criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-

EEA Family Reunification Section 17.2.









Family Reunification Section 14.1. Evidence of income over

previous three years from both sponsors not provided i.e. P60

for 2014, 2015 and 2016. Insufficient evidence of self-

employment from sponsor provided. Letter from school of

applicant not provided. Evidence of ongoing routine contact and

communication since sponsor first elected to move to the State

not provided. Insufficient evidence of financial support from

sponsor provided. Insufficient evidence of sponsor having

visited applicant in home country provided.


supplied.

P: - Passport expires within 12 months of arrival in the State.




Reunification Section 17.2.

PR:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public Refused F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete

ID:- Documents provided not translated




SP:- Gaps in education or employment not accounted for







deemed sufficient




31874812

31848012

31864312





Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown from applicant.

Six month up-to-date bank statements.






displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie- Applicant does not

meet the qualifying criteria as set out in the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 13.2(a). Insufficient

documentation has been submitted as evidence of social

dependency as per the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification Section 14.1, 14.2, 14.3 and 14.4. Insufficient

documentation has been submitted to demonstrate that there is

no viable alternative to the applicant joining the reference in

Ireland. The application has further failed to establish or

evidence any special circumstances that would warrant an

exception to the general policy. Insufficient information has been

provided to demonstrate a level of dependency between the

applicant and sponsor which is considered to be more then

“normal emotional ties”. Evidence demonstrating emotional and

social support between applicant and sponsor not provided.

Evidence of ongoing routine communication between applicant

and sponsor not provided. Evidence of current education status

of applicant not provided.

Approved Parent of Irish Citizen Child

31874932

31893572





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient. Sponsor





(extended) family members of non-EEA nationals resident in the

State to migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie- Application does not

satisfy the criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-

EEA Family Reunification Section 15.1. Applicant was a minor at

time of marriage therefore the stated marriage is not deemed

sufficient for immigration purposes. Insufficient documentation

submitted as evidence of social or financial dependency as set

out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification

Section 14.1. Six month up-to-date bank statements from

applicant and sponsor not provided. Evidence of income from

sponsor for two years prior to application not provided i.e. P60s,

statement of earnings. Up-to-date proof of address from

sponsor not provided i.e. utility bill. Insufficient evidence to

demonstrate emotional and social support between applicant

and sponsor. Insufficient evidence of ongoing routine

communication between applicant and sponsor since their

arrival in the State. Evidence of financial support to applicant not

provided from sponsor. Evidence of sponsor having visited

applicant not provided.


supplied. Marriage registration certificate.





31897152






incomplete. The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they

meet the financial criteria set out in the Policy Document on Non-




to Ireland.





on-going routine communication between the applicant and the

sponsor.

• Insufficient documentation has been submitted to show that

the sponsor has been supporting the applicant financially via

remittances.

• Insufficient documentation has been submitted to show that

the applicant is socially and financially dependent on the

sponsor in Ireland as per the Policy Document on Non-EEA


• The sponsor has failed to submit P60s for the years 2014,

2015 and 2016.

• The sponsor has failed to submit 6 months consecutive bank

statements.

• The applicant has failed to submit a signed letter of

application.

• The applicant has not provided an explanation for their

absence from the State for an extended period of time over a

number of years.


The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA


31952932






incomplete














F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown -

Applicant has failed to provide any evidence that their sponsor

meets the criteria set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification section. 17.2.




Applicant has not supplied a signed letter of application

including their full contact details

• Outlining your reason for coming to Ireland.

• Providing details of the family member in Ireland who is

sponsoring your application.

• Giving details of any other members of your family who are

currently in Ireland, or any other EU Member State.

- As per INIS website applicant has not provided a detailed Approved Visit (Family / Friend)


incomplete


application


deemed sufficient

OC:- Condition - The potential cost of this trip is high in

comparison to the applicant's means, and given that no

compelling reasons for the trip have been displayed, the visa

officer is not satisfied of your intentions to leave the State

following your visit.



the visa appeals officer that such conditions would be observed.

32013862

32108492

31974042






incomplete


supplied


deemed sufficient










incomplete





Refused R:- Letter of invitation no longer valid - dates for course have

passed

SP:- English relevance

32305122

32342812

32110142









Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section. 17.2.


incomplete
























32347952





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient-from

applicant and from reference.


application:- Signed letter of undertaking from applicant.

Evidence of property owned/rented in home country from

applicant. Employment letter from reference. P60 from

reference. Utility bill from reference. Three payslips from

reference.

OB:- Obligations to return to home country not shown - e.g.no

social, economic or professional ties in home country shown.









R:- No clear link to reference has been shown.

Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient-from

applicant and from reference.

ID:- Quality of documents-Employment letter from applicant.


application:-Three recent payslips from applicant. Signed letter

of undertaking from applicant. Evidence of property

owned/rented in home country from applicant. Employment

letter from reference. P60 from reference. Utility bill from

reference. Three payslips from reference.


supplied-re dates of employment from applicant.


deemed sufficient.










32348602

32385072






incomplete








incomplete

ID:- Quality of Documents





deemed sufficient






incomplete

ID:- Quality of Documents - Employment letters


application




Approved Visit (Family / Friend)

Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown






deemed sufficient





Approved Family Reunification


Approved Study32660802

32612802

32613672

32613832

32516172

32559702

32611402

32423502






incomplete





deemed sufficient

OC:- Condition - The applicant may overstay following proposed

visit.






incomplete






deemed sufficient




R:- Letter of invitation no longer valid - dates for event/course

have passed

Refused R:- Letter of invitation no longer valid - dates for course have

passed








Refused ID:- Authenticity of documents

Please see comments below.

Approved Visit (Strictly No Extensions)32838122

32771362

32812702

32830132

32688232

32746932







incomplete: - large unexplained deposit and withdrawal on bank

statement (applicant), no bank statement submitted by sponsor.

ID:- Course start date has passed.

ID:- Quality of documents: - rent agreement document

(applicant), allotment letter (applicant).


application:- evidence accounting for all gaps since last period

of full-time education (i.e. employment letters for all stated

employment etc...) (applicant), evidence of ability to earn

sufficient funds to support stay in the state (property title deed,

evidence of earnings from this property) (applicant), letter of

sponsorship (sponsor), evidence of earnings (i.e. employment

letter, payslips, evidence of any additional sources of income)

(sponsor).

IH:- Immigration history of applicant.

SP:- Gaps in education or employment not accounted for.


with course applied for.


incomplete


application


deemed sufficient


visit.









Approved Study32872712

32844822

32846882






incomplete - from applicant.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown from the

reference.

ID:- Documents provided not translated. employment letter from

applicant, payslips from applicant, bank statements from

applicant, marriage certificate from applicant


application:- no utility bill from the reference, no wedding

invitation, no employment letter from the reference, no payslip

from the reference, no p60 from the reference


deemed sufficient


visit.










Approved Interview

Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown - applicant.


application:- no payslips.


supplied.

R:- Dates for course have now passed.

SP:- Relevance of English to employment.



incomplete



Approved Study


Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient - sponsor.

R:- No clear link to sponsor has been shown.


32981672

32984672

32996942

32908362

32908632

32933492

32894352

32896772






incomplete

- Bank statements submitted by the applicant are under the

applicant’s business’ name – funds may not be fully available to

the applicant.

- Large, unexplained transactions present on the bank

statement submitted by the reference.

- Large, unexplained lump sum deposits present on the bank



- Documents submitted by the applicant have not been

translated.


application:-

- No signed letter of undertaking submitted by the applicant

- No letter of employment submitted by the reference

- No marriage certificate submitted by the applicant

- No birth certificate submitted by the reference

- No evidence of residency for the applicant (i.e. property title

deed/renting lease and utility bills).


deemed sufficient.

OC:- Condition - The applicant may branch into the Common

Travel Area between Ireland and the UK.


visit.





VR:- Previous UK visa refusal not declared.

33008442






incomplete

- Bank statements submitted by the applicant are under the

spouse’s business’ name – funds may not be fully available to

the applicant and their spouse.






- Documents submitted by spouse.


application:-


- No letter of employment submitted by the reference.

- No marriage certificate submitted by the applicant.

- No birth certificate submitted by the reference.








visit.





VR:- Previous UK visa refusal not declared.


Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown.

ID:- Course start date has passed


application:- signed undertaking, evidence of having private

medical insurance for duration of stay in the state, evidence of

previous education, evidence accounting for gaps since

previous education, copy of electronic transfer of funds to the

Irish Bank of the College or a valid receipt showing that the

course fees have been lodged to an approved student fees

payment service, evidence you have the academic ability to

follow your chosen course.




33019652

33008562

33010632


















Approved Visit (Strictly No Extensions)


incomplete-Finances provided are insufficient from applicant.

Bank statements submitted must cover six months

consecutively from applicant.

ID:- Documents provided not translated.


application:-Evidence of property owned/rented in country of

residence from applicant. Letter of undertaking from applicant.

Evidence of social ties to country of residence from applicant.

IH:- Immigration history of applicant-not declared.


deemed sufficient.




visit.









Approved Training

33049932

33056162

33041152

33041512

33048342

33030502

33033812






incomplete :-

6 month bank statements not provided by host, Applicant states

on the invitation letter that host will be responsible for her

accommodation and living expenses etc.

Large unexplained lodgements in bank statements provided by

applicant.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie:-

No utility bill provided by the host,

No evidence of property owned/rented in home country from the

applicant,

No evidence of family/ family ties not established in home

country,

College letter does not provided dates of course, duration of

course, holiday periods, or state if applicant is currently

enrolled/expected to return after trip.


supplied:-

Crest on transcripts differs from letter of certification from

college.




visit.







specific purpose and duration:- the applicant has not satisfied Refused ID:- Quality of documents - passport photo unclear.


supplied.






33073332

33074112

33078562

33061042






incomplete - from the applicant and from the reference.

ID:- Quality of documents - employment letter from the applicant.


application:- no evidence of property owned/rented in home

country from the applicant, no evidence of any other family from

the applicant, no letter of undertaking from the applicant or from

the reference.


deemed sufficient.


visit.




Refused ID:- As per parent's refusal reasons.



incomplete: no bank statement submitted by applicant.

ID:- Quality of documents: - employment letter (applicant)


application:- evidence of stated educational history (applicant),

evidence accounting for any gaps in your educational history

(applicant), birth certificate (applicant), up-to-date employment

letter (sponsor), up-to-date payslips (sponsor).













33100222

33100842

33080612

33089582

33098712







incomplete: - no bank statement submitted (applicant), only 2

months of transactions shown on bank statement submitted

(sponsor), large unexplained deposit on bank statement

(sponsor).

ID:- Course start date have passed.


application:- evidence applicant and / or sponsor has ready

access to sufficient funds for each subsequent year of your

studies, if employed - employment letter, three most recent

payslips (sponsor), if self-employed - business registration

certificate, financial accounts, evidence of payment of tax

(sponsor).


Refused I have fully examined this application and have considered all

supporting documentation submitted. I have decided to refuse a

visa for the following reasons:

ID – Insufficient or incomplete documentation submitted by

applicant:

• There is no confirmation of hotel/hostel accommodation

booking for intended stay in Ireland.

• Evidence provided is deemed insufficient - no letter from

college detailing the course the applicant is studying , how long

applicant has been a student there, remaining terms left at the

college, and that the applicant will be returning to the college

following her visit to Ireland.

• Insufficient evidence of rental agreement – no evidence

provided to verify signature of the landlord. Applicants’

husbands’ name is not listed on the rental agreement.

F – Finances

• Evidence provided is deemed insufficient – bank statement is

an internet print out. Type of account is unclear, and there is no

accompanying letter from the bank stating that the applicant has

permission to withdraw funds from this account.

• Statement provided is not a detailed bank statement showing

what money has been paid into and out of the account over the

last six months.

• Source of applicants’ funds are not known.

OB – Obligation to return to country of residence not shown.

• The visa applicant has shown insufficient social, economic and

professional ties in country of residence.

OC - Observe the conditions of the Visa.

33115782

33116522

33102702






incomplete-Unexplained lump sum lodgements from applicant.

Unexplained lump sum lodgements from sponsor.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown-from reference.


Payslips from applicant.


application:- Utility bill from applicant. Insufficient evidence of

income earned from sponsor. Insufficient evidence of business

from sponsor. Tax documents from sponsor. Employment letter

from reference. Evidence of income earned from reference.

Evidence of family ties to home country from applicant.


supplied-re details on land document from applicant.


deemed sufficient.










33135672






incomplete for applicant, re. unexplained lump sum lodgements.


application:-

• Quality of lease agreement – no clear signatures.

• No details of accompanying person provided.

• Divorce certificate not provided with application.

• Bank statements did not cover one month prior to submission

of application.


supplied:

• Employment payslip is dated prior to commencement of

employment – no evidence of employment for dates of payslip

provided.

• Bank statements were not up to date at time of submission,

therefore cannot see lodgement of cheque from employment

payslip entering bank account.


deemed sufficient.




R:- No confirmation of hotel booking for duration of stay– dates

have passed and no updated details have been provided.

R:- No reference in Ireland.



incomplete-Insufficient explanation/documents provided to

account for lump sum lodgements from reference. Finances

provided from applicant is insufficient. Large unexplained

deposits in transaction history provided from applicant.

ID:- Application form unsigned-Signature provided is not

sufficient.


application:- Utility bill from applicant. Evidence that applicant is

of independent economic means e.g. pension. Signed letter of

undertaking from applicant. Signature provided is not sufficient.


deemed sufficient.




P:- Passport has not been signed.

33143132

33147272

33151502






incomplete-Unexplained source of balance from applicant. Bank

statements must be up to date and all bank certificates

submitted must be accompanied by six-month transaction

history.




application:-Utility bill from applicant.


deemed sufficient.










Refused ID:- Quality of documents-Employment letter from applicant.



application:-Evidence of property ties to home country from

applicant. Evidence of social ties to home country from

applicant. Family Registration Certificate from applicant.


deemed sufficient.












Approved Employment



33187792

33188302

33173062

33173172

33187042

33155222

33157202

33161682





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient- from

reference.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown- from applicant.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie- Evidence of

independent economic means from applicant not provided i.e.

pension. Evidence of family ties in home country not provided.

Evidence of property owned/rented in home country not

provided. Six month bank statements from applicant not

provided. Evidence of clear link to reference not provided.




comparison to the applicant's means and the visa officer is not

satisfied of your intentions to leave the State following your visit.





Approved Visit (Family / Friend)33201712

33193362






incomplete for applicant, re. no bank statements provided –

bank slips cannot be accepted in place on bank statements.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown by reference.

ID:- Documents provided not translated, re. family document.


application:-

• Six months bank statements not provided by applicant.

• Six months bank statements not provided by reference.

• No evidence of accommodation in country of current residency.

• No evidence of up-coming event plans, as stated.


supplied:

• Stated immigration status of applicant vs. evidence provided.












RH:- Relationship History - Have not shown evidence of a

relationship being in existence prior to visa application. Note:

For immigration purposes it is not sufficient for a relationship to

have developed over the internet or by telephone/sms. A

relationship must include a number of face to face meetings

(excluding webcam) between the parties. You must satisfy the

visa officer that the relationship is bona-fide.




incomplete: - less than one month of transactions shown on

bank statement (sponsor), statement submitted not up-to-date

(sponsor).


application:- copy of previous passport (applicant), birth

certificate (applicant), evidence accounting for gaps since

previous education (applicant), birth certificate (sponsor), up-to-

date employment letter (sponsor), up-to-date payslips (sponsor).





VR:- Previous visa refusal(s): previous refusals not declared.



33224852

33225252

33225512

33208792

33212382







ID:- Quality of documents-Bank statements from applicant.

ID:- Documents provided not translated- Employment contract

from applicant. Residence card from applicant


application:- Evidence of property owned/rented in country of

residence from applicant. Evidence of social ties to country of

residence from applicant. Previous visa refusal letters from

applicant.


deemed sufficient.






R:- No confirmation of hotel booking for duration of stay.

R:- No reference in Ireland.

VR:- Previous visa refusal(s)-not declared.


Approved Business



incomplete: - letter from bank confirming that you can take

money from savings account not submitted.

ID:- Documents provided not translated: - birth certificate,

savings account and related documents.


application:- signed undertaking, electronic transfer of funds to

the Irish bank of college or a valid receipt showing that the

course fees have been lodged to an approved student fees

payment service, evidence of having private medical insurance

for duration of stay in the State, evidence accounting for any

gaps in your educational history.






33247502

33253212

33226032

33240022

33245672






incomplete.

ID:- Quality of documents - Employment letter.


application:- No evidence of property owned/rented in home

country from the applicant.


supplied - employment.


deemed sufficient.


visit.






incomplete

- The required bank statement showing a 6 month period of

transactions has not been submitted by the applicant.


- Bank statement.


application:-



- No financial evidence provided by the applicant.

- No employment/source of income evidence provided by the

sponsor (spouse).


deemed sufficient.




visit.











resources.

33272292

33266162









supplied


deemed sufficient




R:- Letter of invitation no longer valid - dates for training have

passed


Approved Visit

Approved Study




F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown-from reference.

ID:- Quality of documents-Investment letter from applicant.


application:- Insufficient evidence of income earned from

applicant. Previous visa refusal letter from applicant.

Employment letter from reference. Three recent payslips from

reference. P60 from reference.


supplied-re where children are currently living based on

information/documents provided.


deemed sufficient.






33299512

33302862

33280022

33290072

33291852

33275292

33279562






incomplete-Finances provided is insufficient for visa purposes

from applicant. Bank statements provided do not cover six

months from applicant.


ID:- Documents provided not translated.


application:- Previous visa refusal letter from applicant. Letter of

undertaking from applicant. Evidence of property owned/rented

in country of residence from applicant.


deemed sufficient.











Approved Internship

Approved Employment

Refused ID:- Documents provided not translated

- Bank statement

- Payslips

- Preliminary certificate of a granted residence permit

- Rental contract

- “Studentenwohnung”

- “Extension of residence permits” letter


application:-

- No up-to-date evidence of residency for the applicant in their

country of residence (i.e. utility bills).


supplied. SEE NOTES.


deemed sufficient.




SCSTP:- It is not the general policy to allow spouse or partner

visas to accompany or join spouse or partner on short-term

business/training trips.


33324902

33334072

33337292

33313912

33314052

33316462

33310522






incomplete for applicant, re. unexplained lump sum lodgements.


incomplete for partner, re. unexplained lump sum lodgements.


application:-

• Previous visa refusal letters not provided with application.

• No guardian proposed to take care of minor child for duration

of proposed trip.


• Six months bank statements not provided by partner who is

funding the proposed trip.

• No evidence of accommodation in country of permanent

residency provided.

• Documents not translated, i.e. letter from employer, bank

statements, payslips, birth certificate.

• No business finances/documents from partner to show source

of finances.


supplied:

• Applicant states in application form that she plans to travel with

partner and child. No mention of child travelling with applicant in

statements provided with application. No passport provided for

child.


deemed sufficient.







specific purpose and duration:- the applicant has not satisfied Approved Visit (Family / Friend)


incomplete


transactions has not been submitted by the applicant.


application:-

- No up-to-date evidence of residency for the applicant in their

home country (i.e. utility bills).

- No business evidence provided by the applicant.




visit.




Approved Employment33344652

33340212

33341022

33341852






incomplete - From the applicant and the reference.

ID:- Quality of documents - Employment letter from the applicant.


application:- No evidence of property rented or owned in home

country from the applicant. No death certificate from the

applicant.


supplied - Length of service in employment from the applicant.


deemed sufficient


visit.










incomplete for guardian, i.e. Unexplained lump sum lodgements.


application:-

• No letter of consent to travel from parents.

• No letter of undertaking provided on behalf of the applicant.

• Six months bank statements not provided.

• No accommodation shown in country of current residence.

• No employment letter for guardian provided.

• Three consecutive payslips from guardian not provided.


deemed sufficient.




33346162

33347862






incomplete

- Large, unexplained lump-sum deposits present on the

personal bank statement submitted by the applicant.

- The required bank statement showing 6 months of

transactions has not been provided by the reference.

ID:- Application form not dated.


- document S & I research – yahoo email address.


application:-


- No birth certificate/family registration certificate that would

support the link

between the applicant and the reference’s spouse has not been

submitted.

- No full copy of applicant’s previous passport submitted.




deemed sufficient.





Refused IH:- Immigration history of applicant



33351122

33353212

33373392








Employment letter from applicant.


application:-Letter of undertaking from applicant. Three recent

payslips from applicant. Evidence of family ties to home country

from applicant. Evidence of property owned/rented in home

country from applicant. Copies of previous passport from

applicant.

IH:- Immigration history of applicant-not declared.


deemed sufficient.




visit.










33394402






incomplete

- No financial evidence provided by the applicant.




application:-

- No signed letter of undertaking submitted by the applicant.



- No marriage certificate submitted by the applicant.

- The required bank statement showing the transaction period of

the last 6 months not submitted.

- No full copy of applicant’s current passport submitted.

- No full photocopy of applicant’s previous passport submitted.




deemed sufficient.


visit.




Approved Visit33428082

33408782






incomplete for reference, re. unexplained lump sum

lodgements, no source of income shown.

F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown by applicant.


application:-


• Six months bank statements not provided by reference.

• Three consecutive payslips not provided by applicant.

• Quality of employment letter provided by applicant.

• Quality of holiday letter provided by applicant.

• P21’s from reference not provided.

• No evidence of accommodation in country of permanent

residency provided.

• No details of family members remaining in country of

permanent residency provided.


supplied:

• Applicant stated she is the eldest of her family – this is

inconsistent with information provided in birth certificate.


deemed sufficient.










RH:- Relationship History - Have not shown evidence of a

relationship being in existence prior to visa application. Note: Approved Spouse of Irish Citizen

Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown - from the

applicant.


application:- no evidence of any other family members in home

country from the applicant, no evidence of property

owned/rented in home country from the applicant, no copy of

passport from the reference, no up to date utility bill from the

reference.


deemed sufficient.


visit.




33466952

33434742

33443502









supplied






Approved Visit

Refused ID:- Quality of documents



supplied




visit.





Refused ID:- Documents provided not translated





Refused ID:- Quality of documents

R:- No reference in Ireland

Approved Interview

33504122

33518432

33550712

33482882

33490692

33493122

33476702

33477892






incomplete




transactions has not been submitted by the reference.


application:-

- No evidence of residency for the applicant in their home

country (i.e. property title deed/renting lease and utility bills).

- No source of income evidence provided by the applicant.




visit.

OC:- Condition - The applicant may work illegally in the State.





VR:- Previous visa refusal reasons letter not submitted.

Approved Internship

Approved Business





Approved Visit





33636622

33644862

33645282

33552492

33602512

33622702





Refused F:- Finances:- no evidence of finances shown - see comments

below.

ID:- Authenticity of documents - see comments below.


application:- full passport not provided.


deemed sufficient.

OB:- Obligations to return to home country not shown.













Approved Visit (Tourist)

Approved Employment



Approved Study





33781862

33782042

33784112

33740272

33740492

33781282

33692742

33701172

33701772