barzee state court docket

Upload: marcie-cancio

Post on 07-Jul-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    1/38

    3RD DISTRICT COURT - SALT LAKE

    SALT LAKE COUNTY, STATE OF UTAH

    PEALED: CASE #20060627

    STATE OF UTAH vs. WANDA EILEEN BARZEE

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Defendants BRIAN DAVID MITCHELL, WANDA EILEEN BARZEE, are

    linked.

    ARGES

    Charge 1 - 76-5-302 - AGGRAVATED KIDNAPPING 2nd Degree Felony

    Offense Date: June 05, 2002

    Plea: February 08, 2010 Guilty-Mentally Ill

    Disposition: February 08, 2010 Guilty - Mental Ill

    RRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE

    VERNICE TREASE

    RTIES

    Defendant - WANDA EILEEN BARZEE

    Represented by: DAVID V FINLAYSON

    Represented by: SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Plaintiff - STATE OF UTAH

    Represented by: DAVID E YOCOM

    Represented by: B KENT MORGAN

    Represented by: CLARK A HARMSRepresented by: JEFFREY W HALL

    Represented by: ALICIA H COOK

    Other Party - ELIZABETH SMART

    Represented by: GREGORY G SKORDAS

    Represented by: JACK M MORGAN JR

    Other Party - JEFFREY J HUNT

    Other Party - MICHAEL PATRICK O'BRIEN

    FENDANT INFORMATION

    Defendant Name: WANDA EILEEN BARZEE

    Offense tracking number: 13821582

    Date of Birth: November 06, 1945

    Jail Booking Number: 0306693

    Law Enforcement Agency: SALT LAKE CITY PD

    LEA Case Number: 02-96734

    Prosecuting Agency: SALT LAKE COUNTY

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:24 Page 1

    Page 1 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    2/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Agency Case Number: 03005553

    Sheriff Office Number: 0270457

    COUNT SUMMARY

    TOTAL REVENUE Amount Due: 1,654.25

    Amount Paid: 1,654.25

    Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE

    Amount Due: 2.75

    Amount Paid: 2.75

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: VIDEO TAPE COPY

    Amount Due: 15.00

    Amount Paid: 15.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE

    Amount Due: 1.50

    Amount Paid: 1.50

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 25.00

    Amount Paid: 25.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 35.00

    Amount Paid: 35.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 332.50

    Amount Paid: 332.50

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:24 Page 2

    Page 2 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    3/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Amount Due: 47.50

    Amount Paid: 47.50

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 27.00

    Amount Paid: 27.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 96.00

    Amount Paid: 96.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 96.00

    Amount Paid: 96.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 113.00

    Amount Paid: 113.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 419.00

    Amount Paid: 419.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: REPORTER FEES

    Amount Due: 419.00

    Amount Paid: 419.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: TELEPHONE/FAX/EMAIL

    Amount Due: 5.00

    Amount Paid: 5.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:24 Page 3

    Page 3 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    4/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY

    Amount Due: 10.00

    Amount Paid: 10.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY

    Amount Due: 10.00

    Amount Paid: 10.00

    Amount Credit: 0.00

    Balance: 0.00

    SE NOTE

    DAO 03005553 ATTONREY GREG SKORDAS TO BE SENT NOTICES OF

    HEARINGS

    OCEEDINGS

    -29-85 **** SEALED **** Filed: Custody Evaluation

    -29-85 **** SEALED **** Filed: City Counseling Clinic - Custody

    -29-85 **** SEALED **** Filed: Letter - Custody

    -29-85 Filed: Custody Evaluation

    -29-85 **** SEALED **** Filed: Custody Evaluation

    -29-85 **** SEALED **** Filed: Custody Evaluation

    -05-03 Filed: Media request for still photography in courtroom

    -18-03 Case filed-18-03 Filed: From an Information

    -18-03 Judge MICHAEL K BURTON assigned.

    -18-03 Notice - WARRANT for Case 031901886 ID 5548730

    -18-03 Warrant ordered on: March 18, 2003 Warrant Num: 981100339 Bail

    Allowed

    Bail amount: 10000000.00

    -18-03 Warrant issued on: March 18, 2003 Warrant Num: 981100339 Bail

    Allowed

    Bail amount: 10000000.00

    Judge: TYRONE E MEDLEY

    Issue reason: Based on the probable cause statement.

    -18-03 Note: CASE FILED BY DET. SHARMAN OF SLC POLICE DEFT IN JAIL

    WARRANT ACTIVE

    -18-03 INITIAL APPEARANCE scheduled on March 19, 2003 at 09:00 AM with

    Judge ARR.

    -18-03 Filed: Information

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:24 Page 4

    Page 4 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    5/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -18-03 Filed: Warrant of arrest

    -19-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Appointment of Counsel

    Judge: TYRONE E MEDLEY

    PRESENT

    Clerk: tinaa

    Prosecutor: HARMS, CLARK A.

    Defendant

    Video

    Tape Number: 9.22

    INITIAL APPEARANCE

    Advised of charges and penalties.

    APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL

    Court finds the defendant indigent and appoints Legal Defender

    Office to represent the defendant.

    Appointed Counsel:

    Name: Legal Defender OfficeCity:

    Phone:

    Affidavit of indigency is to be submitted by the defendant

    Conflict counsel may be assigned. Only Counsel of record and LDA

    staff may visit with defendant. Defendant is order to not have

    any contact with victim, victims family and witnesses. Waiver of

    10 day rule is stated.

    ROLL CALL is scheduled.

    Date: 04/01/2003

    Time: 02:00 p.m.

    Location: To Be Determined

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    Salt Lake City, UT 84111

    Before Judge: JOSEPH C. FRATTO

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 5

    Page 5 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    6/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -19-03 ROLL CALL scheduled on April 01, 2003 at 02:00 PM with Judge

    FRATTO.

    -19-03 Note: INITIAL APPEARANCE minutes modified.

    -19-03 Note: FILED: Affidavit of Indigency - Judge Medley signed and

    appointed LDA to represent defendant in this case.

    -19-03 Filed: Affidavit of Indigency

    -19-03 Filed order: Order

    Judge TYRONE E MEDLEY

    Signed March 19, 2003

    -19-03 Filed order: Order

    Judge TYRONE E MEDLEY

    Signed March 19, 2003

    -19-03 Note: Bail remain $10,000,000.00

    -19-03 Warrant recalled on: March 19, 2003 Warrant num: 981100339

    Recall reason: Warrant recalled because defendant was

    booked.

    -20-03 Filed order: Order prohibiting non-attorney of record contacts

    Judge TYRONE E MEDLEY

    Signed March 20, 2003

    -21-03 **** PROTECTED **** Filed: Affidavit of special agent Jeff R

    -24-03 Filed: Motion to Withdraw as Court Appointed Counsel and Notice

    of Next Court Appearance

    -24-03 Filed: Motion to withdraw as Court appointed counsel and noticeof next court appearance

    -25-03 Filed order: Order To Withdraw as Court Appointed Counsel

    (David C Biggs withdrawn; Scott C Williamson and David V

    Finlayson appointed)

    Judge JOSEPH C FRATTO

    Signed March 25, 2003

    -25-03 Filed order: Order to withdraw as Court appointed Counsel

    Judge JOSEPH C FRATTO

    Signed March 25, 2003

    -27-03 Filed: Appearance of Counsel

    -27-03 Filed: Formal Request for Discovery Pursuant to Rule 16 of the

    Rules of Criminal Procedure

    -27-03 Filed: Appearance of counsel

    -27-03 Filed: Formal Request for Discovery Pursuant to Rule 16 of the

    Rules of Criminal Procedure

    -27-03 Filed: Petition to inquire into competency of defendant

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 6

    Page 6 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    7/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -27-03 Filed: State's motion for an Order regarding further

    dissemination of discovery

    -27-03 Filed: FILED: PETITION TO INQUIRE INTO COMPETENCY OF

    DEFENDANT.

    -27-03 Filed: Motion TO COMPEL THE DEFDENDANT TO SUBMIT TO THE TAKING

    OF HANDWRITINGS, BLOOD, AND OR/HAIR SAMPLES.

    -27-03 Filed: STATES MOTION FOR AND ORDER REGARDING FURTHER

    DISEMINATION OF DISCOVERY.

    -31-03 Filed: STIPULATED MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING

    -31-03 Filed order: ORDER CONTINUING HEARING

    Judge JOSEPH C FRATTO

    Signed March 31, 2003

    -31-03 ROLL CALL rescheduled on April 22, 2003 at 02:00 PM Reason:

    Stipulation of parties.

    -31-03 Filed: Stipulated Motion to continue hearing

    -31-03 Filed order: Order

    Judge JOSEPH C FRATTO

    Signed March 31, 2003

    -01-03 Filed order: Order regarding further dissenination of discovery

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 01, 2003

    -01-03 Filed order: Order compelling the production of blood and hair

    samples and handwriting exemplarsJudge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 01, 2003

    -01-03 Filed order: ORDER REGARDING FURTHER DISSEMINATION OF DISCOVERY

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 01, 2003

    -01-03 Filed order: ORDER COMPELLING THE PRODUCTION OF BLOOD AND HAIR

    SAMPLES, AND HANDWRITING EXEMPLARS.

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 01, 2003

    -03-03 Note: Calendar Judge assignment changed from ROBIN W. REESE to

    JUDITH S ATHERTON for appearance on 04/22/2003

    -03-03 Note: ROLL CALL calendar modified.

    -03-03 STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled on April 10, 2003 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -03-03 Filed: Appearance of Counsel

    -03-03 Filed: APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL - GREG SKORDAS, JACK M. MORGAN FOR

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 7

    Page 7 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    8/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    ELIZABETH SMART

    -09-03 Filed: STIPULATION TO INQUIRE INTO COMPETENCY OF DEFENDANT

    -09-03 Filed order: ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR INQUIRY INTO

    DEFENDANT'S COMPETENCY

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 09, 2003

    -09-03 Filed order: CASE ASSIGNMENT ORDER

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 09, 2003

    -09-03 Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON assigned.

    -09-03 STATUS CONFERENCE Cancelled.

    Reason: Counsel's request.

    -09-03 Filed: Stipulation to inquire into competency of defendant

    -09-03 Filed order: Order granting petition for inquiry into

    defendant's competency

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 09, 2003

    -09-03 Filed order: Case assignment order

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 09, 2003

    -12-03 Filed: Motion for Order to stay all proceedings, to continue

    presently scheduled hearing and objection for transportation of

    defenant-21-03 Note: ROLL CALL calendar modified.

    -21-03 Filed: MOTION FOR ORDER TO STAY ALL PROCEEDINGS, TO CONTINUE

    PRESENTLY SCHEDULED HEARING and OBJECTION TO TRANSPORTATION OF

    DEFENDANT - DENIED BY JUDGE

    -22-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Roll Call

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: lorip

    Reporter: YOUNG, BRAD

    Prosecutor: CLARK HARMS

    KENT MORGAN

    JEFF HALL

    Other Attorneys: JACK M JR MORGAN

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT WILLIAMS

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 8

    Page 8 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    9/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Video

    HEARING

    COMPETENCY EVALUATION HAS PREVIOUSLY BEEN STIPULATED TO. NANCY B.

    COHN AND JEFFREY A. KOVNICK ARE TO BE EVALUATORS. ALL FURTHER

    PROCEEDINGS ARE TO BE STAYED UNTIL EVALUATION IS COMPLETED.

    COUNSEL WILL CONTACT COURT UPON COMPLETION FOR NEXT HEARING DATE.

    STATE REPRESENTS THAT COURT FOUND REASONABLE GROUNDS FOR ORDERING

    COMPETENCY EVALUATION.

    -24-03 Filed order: **SEALED** ORDER FOR TRANSPORTATION OF PRISONER

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 24, 2003

    -24-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transporation of Prison

    -01-03 Filed order: PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISSEMINATION OF

    DISCOVERY.

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed May 01, 2003

    -01-03 Filed order: Protective Order regarding dissemination of

    discovery

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed May 01, 2003-01-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -12-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -29-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -24-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -02-03 Fee Account created Total Due: 2.75

    -02-03 COPY FEE Payment Received: 2.75

    -17-03 **** PROTECTED **** Filed: Letter from Jeffrey A Kovnick, MD

    -21-03 Filed: LETTER TO COURT FROM DR. KOVNICK

    -12-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -25-03 Filed order: ORDER REGARDING COMPETENCY EVALUATIONS

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed August 25, 2003

    -25-03 Filed order: Order regarding competency evaluations

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed August 25, 2003

    -08-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order Judge: jatherto Date: 09

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 9

    Page 9 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    10/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -11-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Motion to Release Custody Evaluat

    -12-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order to Release Custody Evalutio

    -22-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -24-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -01-03 Notice - NOTICE for Case 031901886 ID 5740501

    STATUS CONFERENCE is scheduled.

    Date: 10/07/2003

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -01-03 STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled on October 07, 2003 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -06-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Motion for Order to Produce Docum

    -07-03 Fee Account created Total Due: 15.00

    -07-03 VIDEO TAPE COPY Payment Received: 15.00

    -07-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Law and Motion

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: lorip

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOKJEFFREY W. HALL

    CLARK A. HARMS

    B. KENT MORGAN

    Defendant not present

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    Tape Number: VIDEO Tape Count: 9:03

    HEARING

    TAPE: VIDEO COUNT: 9:03

    COMPETENCY EVALUATIONS ARE NOT COMPLETED ON DEFENDANT. COURT

    ORDERS THEY BE SUBMITTED TO COURT BY DECEMBER 1, 2003.

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:25 Page 10

    Page 10 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    11/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -10-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order (unsigned)

    -16-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Letter Dated 10/9/03 Re: Competen

    -27-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Motion for Order to Produce Docum

    -28-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order Judge: jatherto Date: 10

    -14-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -17-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Motion to Compel State to Produce

    -24-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -25-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Defen

    -25-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Request for Specific Findings in

    -25-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -25-03 Filed: Competency Evalution from Jeffrey A. Kovnick, M.D.

    (SEALED)

    -25-03 Filed: Competency Evalution from Nancy B. Cohn Ph.D. (SEALED)

    -26-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Minutes in Chambers

    -29-03 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -02-03 COMPETENCY HEARING scheduled on December 11, 2003 at 02:00 PM

    in FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -11-03 Filed: Motion for competency hearing

    -11-03 Filed: MOTION FOR COMPETENCY HEARING PURSUANT TO U.C.A. SECTION

    77-15-5(9)

    -11-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Competency Hearing

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENTClerk: lorip

    Reporter: YOUNG, BRAD

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    JEFFREY W. HALL

    CLARK A. HARMS

    B. KENT MORGAN

    Other Attorneys: JACK M JR MORGAN

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    HEARING

    DEFENSE MOTIONS COURT FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING PURSUANT TO U.C.A.

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:26 Page 11

    Page 11 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    12/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    SECTION 77-15-5(9).

    COURT GRANTS MOTION. EVIDENTIARY HEARING IS SCHEDULED.

    EVIDENTIARY HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 01/09/2004

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -11-03 EVIDENTIARY HEARING scheduled on January 09, 2004 at 09:00 AM

    in FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -15-03 Filed: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR LIIMITED

    INTERVENTION AND MOTION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO COMPETENCY HEARING

    -15-03 Filed: NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND REQUEST FOR NOTICE OF MOTIONS

    TO CLOSE OR SEAL JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS OR RECORDS

    -15-03 Filed: MOTION FOR LIMITED INTERVENTION OF DESERET NEWS

    PUBLISHING COMPANY, PUBLISHER OF THE DESERET MORNING NEWS,

    BONNEVILLE INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION d/b/a KSL-TV AND THE UTAH

    HEADLINERS CHAPTER OF THE SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISTS

    -15-03 Filed: PETITION FOR LIMITED INTERVENTION AND MOTION FOR PUBLIC

    ACCESS TO COMPETENCY HEARING

    -15-03 Filed: REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED HEARING AND RULING ON PETITION FORLIMITED INTERVENTION AND MOTION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO COMPETENCY

    HEARING

    -15-03 Filed: Memorandum in support of petition for limited

    intervention and motion for public access to competency hearing

    -15-03 Filed: Notice of appearance and request for notice of motions

    to close or seal judicial proceedings or recordings

    -15-03 Filed: Motion for limited intervention of Deseret News

    Publishing Company, publisher of the Deseret Morning News,

    Bonneville International Corporation

    Filed by: HUNT, JEFFREY J

    -15-03 Filed: Petition for limited intervention and motion for public

    access to competency hearing

    -15-03 Filed: Request for expedited hearing and ruling on petition for

    limited intervention and motion for public access to competency

    hearing

    -15-03 Filed order: Order granting motion for limited intervention of

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:26 Page 12

    Page 12 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    13/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Deseret News Publishing Company, publishe of the Deseret

    Morning News, Bonneville International Corporation dba KSLTV

    and the Utah Headliners Chapter of the Society of Professional

    Journalis

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed December 16, 2003

    -16-03 Fee Account created Total Due: 1.50

    -16-03 COPY FEE Payment Received: 1.50

    -16-03 Filed: MOTION FOR COMPETENCY HEARING PURSUANT TO U.C.A. SECTION

    77-15-5(9)

    -16-03 Filed: Motion for competency hearing

    Filed by: FINLAYSON, DAVID V,

    -16-03 Filed order: ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LIMITED INTERVENTION

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed December 16, 2003

    -18-03 Notice - NOTICE for Case 031901886 ID 5812279

    MT/PUBLIC ACCESS TO HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 01/05/2004

    Time: 02:00 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -18-03 MT/PUBLIC ACCESS TO HEARING scheduled on January 05, 2004 at

    01:30 PM in FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -18-03 Notice - NOTICE for Case 031901886 ID 5812397

    MT/PUBLIC ACCESS TO HEARING.

    Date: 1/5/2004

    Time: 01:30 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    The reason for the change is Correct Calendar

    -18-03 Note: MT/PUBLIC ACCESS TO HEARING calendar modified.

    -18-03 Filed: OBJECTION OF DESERET NEWS PUBLISHING CO., PUBLISHER OF

    THE DESERET MORNING NEWS, BONNEVILLE INTERNATIONAL CORP. d/b/a

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:26 Page 13

    Page 13 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    14/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    KSL-TV AND THE UTAH HEADLINERS CHAPTER OF THE SOCIETY OF

    PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISTS TO CLOSURE OF COMPETENCY HEARING

    -18-03 Filed: Objection of Deseret News Publishing Company, publisher

    of the Deseret Morning News, Bonnelville International

    Corporation dba KSLTV and the Utah Headliners chapter of the

    society of professional journalists to closure of competency

    hearing

    -18-03 Filed: SECOND HALF OF Objection

    -23-03 Filed order: ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LIMITED INTERVENTION OF

    DESERET NEWS PUBLISHING COMPANY

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed December 16, 2003

    -30-03 Filed: Response to Motions for limited intervention

    -30-03 Filed: Reply Memorandum in support of petition for limited

    intervention and Motion for public access to competency hearing

    -02-04 Filed: REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR LIMITED

    INTERVENTION AND MOTION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO COMPETENCY HEARING

    -02-04 Filed: Reply Memorandum in support of petition for limited

    intervention and Motion for public access to competency hearing

    -02-04 Filed: MEMORANDUM

    -05-04 Filed: Transcript of competency review hearing dated 12-11-03,

    Brad Young, Court Reporter

    -05-04 Filed: Memorandum-05-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for Law and Motion

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: lorip

    Reporter: WARNICK, SUZANNE

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    JEFFREY W HALL

    CLARK A HARMS

    B KENT MORGAN

    DAVID E YOCOM

    Defendant not present

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:27 Page 14

    Page 14 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    15/38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    16/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    CLARK A HARMS

    JEFFREY W HALL

    B KENT MORGAN

    Other Attorneys: GREGORY SKORDAS

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    HEARING

    DEFENDANT WAIVES RIGHT TO COMPETENCY HEARING. SHE WAIVES THE

    RIGHT TO CONFRONT EVALUATORS.

    SCOTT WILLIAMS PROFFERS TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF DEFENDANT.

    COURT ADDRESSES EVALUATIONS. COURT FINDS THAT DEFENDANT SUFFERS

    FROM MENTAL ILLNESS AND IS THEREFORE, NOT COMPETENT TO PROCEED AT

    THIS POINT.

    COURT ORDERS THAT DEFENDANT BE RELEASED TO THE DIRECTOR OF

    DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES FOR TRANSPORT TO UTAH STATE HOSPITAL

    IN AN EFFORT TO RESTORE DEFENDANT TO COMPETENCY.

    COMPETENCY REVIEW IS SCHEDULED IN 90 DAYS.COUNSEL TO SUBMIT STIPULATED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF

    LAW AND ORDER TO COURT.

    COUNSEL TO ALSO SUBMIT ORDER OF TRANSPORTATION TO UTAH STATE

    HOSPITAL.

    COMPETENCY REVIEW is scheduled.

    Date: 04/15/2004

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -09-04 Note: LAW AND MOTION minutes modified.

    -09-04 Filed: Signed minutes competency hearing notice

    -20-04 Fee Account created Total Due: 25.00

    -20-04 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 25.00

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:27 Page 16

    Page 16 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    17/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -20-04 Filed: Transcript of Motion by Intervenors for Public Access to

    Competency Hearings dated 1-5-04, Suzanne Warnick, Court

    Reporter

    -30-04 Filed: ORDER/MEDIA REFERRED TO JUDGE.

    -30-04 Filed order: ORDER GRANTING NEWS MEDIA PETITION FOR LIMITED

    INTERVENTION AND SETTING SCHEDULE FOR CLOSURE HEARING.

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed January 30, 2004

    -30-04 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Letter from Counsel

    -30-04 Filed order: Order granting news media petition for limited

    intervention and setting schedule for closure hearing

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed January 30, 2004

    -04-04 Filed order: Order Regarding Defendant's Current Competency to

    Proceed

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2004

    -04-04 Filed order: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law Regarding

    Defendant's Current Competence to Proceed

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2004

    -04-04 Filed order: Order regarding defendant's current competence toproceed

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2004

    -04-04 Filed: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law regarding

    defendant's current competence to proceed

    -13-04 Fee Account created Total Due: 35.00

    -13-04 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 35.00

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -23-04 **** SEALED **** Filed: Order for Transportation of Priso

    -07-04 Filed: MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING - REFERRED TO

    JUDGE/STIPULATED MOTION.

    -07-04 Filed: MOTION TO JOIN IN OBJECTION TO COURT ORDER GRANTING NEWS

    MEDIA PETITION FOR LIMITED INTERVENTION FILED BY CO-DEFENDANT

    BRIAN DAVID MITCHELL

    -07-04 Filed: Motion to continue hearing

    -07-04 Filed: Motion to join in objection to Court Order granting news

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:27 Page 17

    Page 17 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    18/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    media petition for limited intervention filed by co-defendant

    Brian David Mitchell

    -08-04 Filed order: ORDER TO CONTUE WITHOUT DATE

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 08, 2004

    -08-04 Filed order: Order

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed April 08, 2004

    -12-04 MOTION FOR CONTIN. ON COM.HR scheduled on April 15, 2004 at

    09:00 AM in FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -12-04 COMPETENCY REVIEW Cancelled.

    -13-04 Filed: Transcript of motion to continue hearing dated 1-22-04,

    Ed Midgley, Court Reporter

    -15-04 COMPETENCY HEARING scheduled on June 28, 2004 at 02:00 PM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S44 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -15-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for MOTION TO CONTINUE COMPENTEN

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: melanieb

    Prosecutor: HARMS, CLARK A

    Defendant not present

    Defendant's Attorney(s): WILLIAMS, SCOTT C

    Video

    Tape Number: VIDEO Tape Count: 9.50

    HEARING

    TAPE: VIDEO COUNT: 9.50

    PROSECUTOR MR. HARMS ADDRESSES THE COURT IN THE MATTER OF

    CONTINUING COMPETENCY HEARING. DEF WAS TRANSPORTED TO THE STATE

    MENTAL HOSPITAL ON 3-24-04. IN COMPLYING WITH STATE MANDATE, 90

    DAYS FOR COMPENTENCY

    COUNT: 955

    EVALUATION IS MANDATED BY STATE STATUE. THE 90 DAYS WILL BE UP BY

    6-24-04, CONTACT AT FORENSICS UNIT HAS REPORTED EVALUATION SHOULD

    BE COMPLETED AT THAT TIME.

    DEFENSE ATTORNEY CONFIRMS THE INFORMATION. COMPENTENCY HEARING IS

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:27 Page 18

    Page 18 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    19/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    SCHEDULED.

    COMPETENCY HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 06/28/2004

    Time: 02:00 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -22-04 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -22-04 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -22-04 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -22-04 Filed: Compentency Evaluation from Gerald Berge (SEALED)

    -23-04 Filed: Transportation Order

    -28-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for Competency Hearing

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: lorip

    Reporter: EDWARDS, JODY

    Prosecutor: JEFFREY W HALL

    CLARK A HARMS

    Other Attorneys: GREGORY SKORDAS

    DefendantDefendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V. FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    HEARING

    EVIDENTIARY HEARING IS SCHEDULED. COURT ORDER OF DEFENDANT NOT

    COMPETENT TO STAND TRIAL IS STILL IN EFFECT.

    EVIDENTIARY HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 08/10/2004

    Time: 02:00 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:28 Page 19

    Page 19 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    20/38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    21/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -10-04 **** SEALED **** Filed: Affidavit of Xavier Amador

    -10-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for Law and Motion

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: lorip

    Reporter: EDWARDS, JODY

    Prosecutor: JEFFREY W HALL

    CLARK A HARMS

    B KENT MORGAN

    Other Attorneys: GREGORY SKORDAS

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V. FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    Video

    HEARING

    DEFENDANT TRANSPORTED FROM UTAH STATE HOSPITAL.

    STATE CALLS DR. GERALD BERGE - SWORN AND TESTIFIES.

    STATE'S EXHIBIT #1 IS ADMITTED.

    CROSS EXAMINATION.

    REDIRECT.RECROSS.

    REDIRECT.

    RECROSS.

    FOLLOWING ACCESSMENT IS MADE BY THE COURT.

    DEFENDANT IS NOT CURRENTLY COMPETENT TO STAND TRIAL, BUT MAY

    BECOME COMPETENT IN THE FORSEEABLE FUTURE.

    CLOSING STATEMENTS BY STATE.

    CLOSING STATEMENTS BY DEFENSE.

    MR. MORGAN WILL PREPARE ORDER AND SUBMIT TO THE COURT.

    DEFENDANT WILL BE RECOMMITTED TO THE STATE HOSPITAL FOR ONE YEAR

    PERIOD. REVIEW WILL BE SCHEDULED.

    COMPETENCY REVIEW is scheduled.

    Date: 08/10/2005

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S44

    Third District Court

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:28 Page 21

    Page 21 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    22/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -10-04 Filed: Signed minutes Law and Motion

    -12-04 COMPETENCY REVIEW scheduled on August 10, 2005 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -18-04 Filed: Transcript of Pretrial Conference dated 8-10-04, Jody

    Edwards, Court Reporter

    -20-04 Fee Account created Total Due: 332.50

    -20-04 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 332.50

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -05-04 Filed: COVER LETTER TO COURT FROM B. KENT MORGAN.

    -27-04 Fee Account created Total Due: 47.50

    -27-04 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 47.50

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -04-05 Filed: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

    -04-05 Filed order: Order Regarding Defendant's Probability of

    Restoration to Competency to Proceed.

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2005

    -04-05 Filed: Findings of Fact/Conclusions of Law

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2005-04-05 Filed order: Order regarding defendant's probability of

    restoration to competency to proceed

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 04, 2005

    -07-05 Filed: MOTION FOR MEDICATION HEARING.

    -07-05 Filed: Motion for medication hearing

    -07-05 Filed: Memorandum in support of medication hearing

    -16-05 Filed: AMENDED MAILING CERTIFICATE

    -16-05 Filed: Amended mailing certificate

    -14-05 Filed: Faxed copy of discovery request

    -24-05 Filed: DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR MEDICATION HEARING

    -24-05 Filed: Defendant's response to Motion for medication hearing

    -05-05 Filed: REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR MEDICATION

    HEARING AND MOTION FOR HEARING/

    -05-05 Filed: Reply to defendant's response to Motion for medication

    hearing and Motion for Hearing

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:28 Page 22

    Page 22 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    23/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -22-05 Note: COMPETENCY REVIEW calendar modified.

    -30-05 Filed: Transport Order faxed to the Utah State Hospital.

    -30-05 Filed: Transportation Order

    -01-05 Filed: Notice to Submit for Decision (Motion Requesting a Sell

    Hearing) (Court takes no action at this time and will address

    it at the hearing on 8/10/05)

    -01-05 Filed: Notice to submit for decision

    -01-05 Filed: UNSIGNED Notice of hearing

    -10-05 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competence Evaluation

    -10-05 Filed: Competency Evaluation from Eric Nielsen (SEALED)

    -10-05 Minute Entry - Minutes for Competency Hearing

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: sunshinb

    Reporter: WARNICK, SUZANNE

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    JEFFREY W HALL

    B. KENT MORGAN

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    VideoTape Count: 9:06

    HEARING

    COUNT: 9:06

    This matter is before the Court for a Competency Review Hearing.

    Defense Counsel waives the defendants appearance at this hearing.

    Case set for a 1/2 day Evidentiary Hearing.

    1/2 DAY EVIDENTIARY HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 09/16/2005

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 23

    Page 23 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    24/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -10-05 1/2 DAY EVIDENTIARY HEARING scheduled on September 16, 2005 at

    09:00 AM in FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -10-05 Filed order: Order of Transport (Faxed to Transportation)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed August 10, 2005

    -10-05 Filed: Order of Transport

    -08-05 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -16-05 Minute Entry - Minutes for COMPETENCY REVIEW

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: sunshinb

    Reporter: WARNICK, SUZANNE

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    CLARK A HARMS

    B. KENT MORGAN

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    DAVID V FINLAYSON

    Video

    Tape Count: 9:18

    HEARING

    COUNT: 9:18

    Defendant transported from the Utah State Hospital. This matter

    is before the Court for a Competency Review. 9:30 Dr. Eric Nielsen

    is sworn and testifies. Cross-examination.

    Court finds that based on current reports Ms. Barzee is still

    incompetent to proceed and will stay at the Utah State Hospital.

    Case set for a Telephone Conference and Defense counsel waives the

    defendant's presence at this hearing.

    TELEPHONE CONFERENCE is scheduled.

    Date: 10/17/2005

    Time: 01:00 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 24

    Page 24 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    25/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -16-05 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE scheduled on October 17, 2005 at 01:00 PM

    in FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -23-05 Filed: Transcript, original, Review Hearing/Progress of

    September 16, 2005; 46 pages plus word index; Suzanne Warnick,

    Official Court Reporter.

    -14-05 Filed: Motion for Medication Hearing and for forced Medication.

    -14-05 Filed: Motion for medication hearing and for forced medication

    -17-05 Minute Entry - Minutes for TELEPHONE CONFERENCE

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: sunshinb

    Prosecutor: HARMS, CLARK A

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): FINLAYSON, DAVID V

    Video

    Tape Count: 1:07

    HEARING

    COUNT: 1:07

    This matter is before the Court for a Telephone Conference toSchedule a Hearing. Case continued to the following date:

    1 DAY MEDICATION HEARING is scheduled.

    Date: 02/16/2006

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    -17-05 1 DAY MEDICATION HEARING scheduled on February 16, 2006 at

    09:00 AM in FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -21-05 Fee Account created Total Due: 27.00

    -21-05 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 27.00

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -21-05 Fee Account created Total Due: 96.00

    -21-05 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 96.00

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 25

    Page 25 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    26/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -25-05 Filed: Motion to withdraw motion for Medication

    Hearing/referred to JSA

    -25-05 Filed order: Order withdrawing Utah State Hospital's Motion for

    Medication Hearing

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed October 25, 2005

    -25-05 Filed: Motion to withdraw Motion for Medication hearing

    -25-05 Filed order: Order withdrawing Utah State Hospital's Motion for

    Medication Hearing

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed October 25, 2005

    -23-05 Fee Account created Total Due: 96.00

    -23-05 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 96.00

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -15-06 Filed order: Order of Transport (faxed)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 15, 2006

    -15-06 Filed: Stipulation to Defendant's Motion to Secure an

    Out-of-State Witness (Dr. Amador)

    -15-06 Filed: Motion to Secure and Out-of-State Witness

    -15-06 Filed: Affidavit in Support of Motion to Secure Attendance of

    Out-of-State Witness-15-06 Filed order: Certificate of Judge Requesting State of Witness

    (Judge Himonas signed for Judge Atherton)

    Judge DENO HIMONAS

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed order: Order to Secure and Out-of-State Witness (Judge

    Himonas signed for Judge Atherton)

    Judge DENO HIMONAS

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed: Stipulation to Defendant's Motion to Secure as

    Out-of-State Witness (Dr. Morris)

    -15-06 Filed: Motion to Secure an Out-of-State Witness

    -15-06 Filed: Affidavit in Support of Motion to Secure Attendance of

    Out-of-State Witness

    -15-06 Filed order: Certificate of Judge Requesting State for Witness

    (Judge Himonas signed for Judge Atherton)

    Judge DENO HIMONAS

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 26

    Page 26 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    27/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed order: Order to Secure an Out-of-State Witness (Judge

    Himonas signed for Judge Atherton)

    Judge DENO HIMONAS

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed: State's Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Motion to

    Compel Medication

    -15-06 Filed order: Order to secure an out-of-state witness

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed: Stipulation to defendant's Motion to secure an

    out-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Motion to secure and out-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Affidavit in support of Motion to secure attendance of

    out-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Certificate of Judge requesting State for witness

    -15-06 Filed order: Order to secure and out-of-state witness

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 14, 2006

    -15-06 Filed: State's supplemental Memorandum in support of Motion to

    compel medication

    -15-06 Filed: Order of Transport

    -15-06 Filed: Stipulation to defendant's Motion to secure anout-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Motion to secure an out-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Affidavit in support of Motion to secure attendance of

    out-of-state witness

    -15-06 Filed: Certificate of Judge requesting for witness

    -16-06 Minute Entry - Minutes for MEDICATION HEARING

    Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: sunshinb

    Reporter: YOUNG, BRAD

    Prosecutor: ALICIA H COOK

    CLARK A HARMS

    B KENT MORGAN

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): DAVID V FINLAYSON

    SCOTT C WILLIAMS

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 27

    Page 27 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    28/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Video

    Tape Count: 10:25

    HEARING

    COUNT: 10:25

    Defendant transported from the Utah State Hospital. This matter

    is before the Court on the State's Motion for an Order requiring

    Medication. 10:32 Kreg Jeppson is sworn and testifies.

    Cross-examination. Re-direct. Re-cross.

    1:40 Paul D. Whitehead is sworn and testifies. Cross-examination.

    Re-direct. State Rests. 3:09 Raphael Morris is sworn and

    testifies. Cross-examination. Re-direct. 4:25 Xavier Amador is

    sworn and testifies. Cross-examination. Defense Rests.

    5:43 Rebuttal Witness for the State Paul D. Whitehead retakes the

    stand, still under oath and testifies. Cross-examination.

    Counsel's briefing is due on 4/14/06. The Court takes this matter

    underadvisement.

    -03-06 Filed: Transcript of Medication Hearing dated 2-16-06, Brad

    Young, Court Reporter

    -17-06 Fee Account created Total Due: 113.00

    -17-06 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 113.00Note: REPORTER FEES

    -17-06 Fee Account created Total Due: 419.00

    -17-06 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 419.00

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -17-06 Filed: Memoradum in opposition to State's Motion to compel

    medication

    -17-06 Filed: State's second supplemental Memorandum in support of

    Motion to Compel medication

    -17-06 Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to State's Motion to Compel

    Medication

    -17-06 Filed: State's Second Supplemental Memorandum in Support of

    Motion to Compel Medication

    -21-06 Filed order: Rulings on Motion to Compel Medication (State's

    Motion to Compel is Granted) (see file for full decision)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed June 20, 2006

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 28

    Page 28 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    29/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -26-06 Fee Account created Total Due: 419.00

    -26-06 REPORTER FEES Payment Received: 419.00

    Note: REPORTER FEES

    -13-06 Filed: Letter from Supreme Court - 20060627-sc - Petition for

    Interlocutory Appeal filed 7-10-06

    -13-06 Filed: Letter from the Supreme Court

    -07-06 Filed order: Order to Stay Order Granting State's Motion to

    Compel Medication

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed August 07, 2006

    -07-06 Filed order: Order to stay order granting State's Motion to

    compel medication

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed August 07, 2006

    -20-06 Filed: Utah Supreme Court - Order - the Petition for Permission

    to Appeal an Interlocutory Order is Granted - 20060627-SC

    -20-06 Filed: Index

    -20-06 Filed: Supreme Court Order

    -21-06 Note: INDEXED

    -21-06 Note: Cert/Copy of Record Index forwarded to Utah Supreme Court

    - 20060627-SC

    -21-06 Note: Record forwarded to Utah Supreme Court - Files-3, Tran-6

    paginated - 20060627-SC-21-06 Filed: Clerk's certificate

    -30-06 Note: Appealed: Case #20060627

    -08-07 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Affidavit of Kreg Jeppson

    -08-07 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Affidavit of Paul Whitehead

    -17-07 Filed: Supreme Court of Utah-Opinion-Affirmed-20060627-SC

    -17-07 Filed: Supreme Court Opinion

    -23-08 Filed: Remittitur

    -28-08 Filed: Supreme Court of Utah - Remittitur - Remittitur

    received; record received: files-3, transcripts-6, exhibits-2

    large envelopes; Affirmed. - 20060627-SC

    -08-08 Filed order: Minute Entry (see file for full decision)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 08, 2008

    -12-08 Filed: Motion to Stay Minute Entry Order Regarding Medication

    Filed by: BARZEE, WANDA EILEEN

    -06-08 Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Stay

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:29 Page 29

    Page 29 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    30/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Minute Entry Order Regarding Medication

    -06-08 Filed: Motion For Order Authorizing Utah State Hospital To

    Disclose Information

    Filed by: STATE OF UTAH,

    -07-08 Filed order: Memorandum Decision - Defendant's Motion to Stay

    Minute Entry Order Regarding Medication is Denied (see file for

    full decision)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed March 07, 2008

    -13-08 Filed: Supreme Court of Utah - Letter to Counsel - On March 11,

    2008 a Petition for Extraordinary Writ was received by the

    Supreme Court. The case number is 20080197-SC and should be

    indicated on future filings. - 20080197-SC

    -07-08 Filed: Supreme Court of Utah-Notice of Decision-Order-Petition

    for Extraordinary Write is Denied-Motion to Recall Remittitur

    is denied-Alternative Motion for a Stay of the Order for

    medication is Granted pending resolution of the Petition for

    Cert

    -11-08 Filed: Minute Entry

    -27-08 Filed: Letter From Utah State Hospital

    -04-08 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Utah State Hospital Progress Repo

    -05-08 **** SEALED **** Filed: Utah State Hospital

    -16-08 Filed: States Motion to Modify Order Regarding FurtherDissemination of Discovery

    Filed by: STATE OF UTAH,

    -25-08 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competency Evaluations-Mancy B Co

    -25-08 **** SEALED **** Filed: Competence Report-Jeffrey A Kovni

    -22-09 Notice - NOTICE for Case 031901886 ID 12428103

    COMPETENCY REVIEW is scheduled.

    Date: 10/23/2009

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    -22-09 COMPETENCY REVIEW scheduled on October 23, 2009 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -22-09 Filed: Transportation Order

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:30 Page 30

    Page 30 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    31/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -01-09 COMPETENCY REVIEW rescheduled on October 16, 2009 at 09:00 AM

    Reason: ATD requested continuance..

    -13-09 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -16-09 Filed: Transportation Order

    -16-09 Minute Entry - Minutes for COMPETENCY REVIEW

    Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: sunshinb

    Prosecutor: COOK, ALICIA H

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): WILLIAMS, SCOTT C

    Video

    Tape Number: S45 11:05:51 Tape Count: 11:10:00

    HEARING

    TAPE: S45 11:05:51 Defendant transported from the Utah State

    Hospital. Defense counsel would like some time to talk with the

    experts and review documentation, the State does not object. The

    Court will toll the time of the running of the statute re:

    competency issues.

    Case continued to the following date:COMPETENCY REVIEW.

    Date: 11/19/2009

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    -16-09 COMPETENCY REVIEW scheduled on November 19, 2009 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -13-09 Filed: Motion to Continue (Stipulated)

    Filed by: STATE OF UTAH,

    -13-09 Filed order: Order of Continuance

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed November 13, 2009

    -13-09 COMPETENCY REVIEW rescheduled on January 06, 2010 at 09:00 AM

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:30 Page 31

    Page 31 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    32/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    Reason: Stipulation of counsel.

    -19-09 Fee Account created Total Due: 5.00

    -19-09 TELEPHONE/FAX/EMAIL Payment Received: 5.00

    -05-10 Filed: Transportation order for 01/06/2010

    -06-10 Minute Entry - COMPETENCY HEARING continued

    Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: shantec

    Prosecutor: COOK, ALICIA H

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): WILLIAMS, SCOTT C

    Video

    Tape Number: S45-9.15.40 Tape Count: 9.19.30

    CONTINUANCE

    Whose Motion:

    The Stipulation of counsel.

    Parties are requesting additional time. Case continued to the

    following date:

    The motion is granted.

    COMPETENCY REVIEW is scheduled.Date: 02/08/2010

    Time: 09:00 a.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    -06-10 COMPETENCY REVIEW Continued.

    Reason: Stipulation of counsel

    -06-10 COMPETENCY REVIEW scheduled on February 08, 2010 at 09:00 AM in

    FOURTH FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -06-10 Filed: Transportation Order

    -08-10 Filed: PSR Referral

    -08-10 Filed order: Statment of defendant in advance of guilty plea

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed February 08, 2010

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:30 Page 32

    Page 32 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    33/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -08-10 Filed: Amended information

    -08-10 Charge 76-5-302 Sev F1 was removed.

    -08-10 Charge 1 Plea is Guilty-Mentally Ill

    -08-10 Charge 76-5-302 Sev F2 was removed.

    -08-10 Charge 76-5-405 Sev F1 was removed.

    -08-10 Charge 76-5-405 Sev F1 was removed.

    -08-10 Charge 76-6-203 Sev F1 was amended to 76-5-302 Sev F2

    -08-10 Charge 76-6-203 Sev F1 was removed.

    -08-10 SENTENCING scheduled on May 21, 2010 at 02:00 PM in FOURTH

    FLOOR-S45 with Judge ATHERTON.

    -08-10 Minute Entry - Minutes for Change of Plea

    Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: jennifaj

    Prosecutor: COOK, ALICIA H

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): WILLIAMS, SCOTT C

    Video

    Tape Number: s45 Tape Count: 9:20-9:40

    The Information is read.

    Court advises defendant of rights and penalties.Defendant waives time for sentence.

    A pre-sentence investigation was ordered.

    The Judge orders Adult Probation & Parole to prepare a Pre-sentence

    report.

    Change of Plea Note

    Defendant pleas guilty mentally ill to count one of the amended

    information

    Court finds defendant competent to proceed

    SENTENCING is scheduled.

    Date: 05/21/2010

    Time: 02:00 p.m.

    Location: Fourth Floor - S45

    Third District Court

    450 South State

    SLC, UT 84114-1860

    Before Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:31 Page 33

    Page 33 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    34/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    -08-10 Note: CHANGE OF PLEA minutes modified.

    -08-10 Charge 1 Disposition is Guilty - Mental

    -08-10 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Competency Evaluation

    -16-10 Filed order: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and Order

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed March 16, 2010

    -11-10 **** PROTECTED **** Filed: PSR

    -14-10 SENTENCING rescheduled on May 21, 2010 at 01:00 PM Reason:

    Correct Calendar.

    -17-10 Filed: Transportation Order

    -18-10 Filed: Letter from Curtis Jackson- Forwarded to Judge- No

    action

    -20-10 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: State hospital update

    -21-10 Fee Account created Total Due: 10.00

    -21-10 AUDIO TAPE COPY Payment Received: 10.00

    -21-10 Filed order: Order (regarding defendant's release on own

    recognizance)

    Judge JUDITH S ATHERTON

    Signed May 21, 2010

    -21-10 Minute Entry - Minutes for SENTENCE, JUDGMENT, COMMITME

    Judge: JUDITH S. ATHERTON

    PRESENT

    Clerk: jennifajProsecutor: COOK, ALICIA H

    Defendant

    Defendant's Attorney(s): WILLIAMS, SCOTT C

    Video

    Tape Number: s45 Tape Count: 1:06-

    SENTENCE PRISON

    Based on the defendant's conviction of AGGRAVATED KIDNAPPING a 2nd

    Degree Felony, the defendant is sentenced to an indeterminate term

    of not less than one year nor more than fifteen years in the Utah

    State Prison.

    To the SALT LAKE County Sheriff: The defendant is remanded to your

    custody for transportation to the Utah State Prison where the

    defendant will be confined.

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:32 Page 34

    Page 34 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    35/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    SENTENCE PRISON CONCURRENT/CONSECUTIVE NOTE

    Court orders term to run concurrent with federal sentence

    -21-10 Note: SENTENCE, JUDGMENT, COMMITMENT minutes modified.

    -21-10 Note: Audio request complete for ABC4

    -22-10 Note: Audio Request for DA completed for change of Plea

    -12-10 Filed: TRANSCRIPT for Hearing of 02-08-2010

    -27-10 Filed: Transcripts of Electronic Recording; February 8, 2010;

    Tamra J Berry, CSR/RPR

    -17-10 Fee Account created Total Due: 10.00

    -17-10 AUDIO TAPE COPY Payment Received: 10.00

    Note: Mail Payment;

    -02-13 Judge VERNICE TREASE assigned.

    -09-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -13-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -16-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)-17-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -19-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -20-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -24-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -03-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -04-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:32 Page 35

    Page 35 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    36/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -07-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -11-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -16-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -17-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -18-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -28-15 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -06-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)-08-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -19-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -27-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -02-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -03-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -04-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:32 Page 36

    Page 36 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    37/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -05-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -08-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -09-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -10-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -11-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -16-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -17-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)-22-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -02-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -04-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -09-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -10-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -14-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inted: 04/07/16 12:02:32 Page 37

    Page 37 of 38

  • 8/18/2019 Barzee State Court Docket

    38/38

    SE NUMBER 031901886 State Felony

    ______________________________________________________________________________ 

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -15-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -16-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -17-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -22-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -23-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)

    -30-16 Note: Case information transmitted electronically to DPS for

    inclusion on National Instant Criminal Background Check

    System (NICS)