’c w - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prl ’7‹(...

24
!"#$%& !"#! '( $ ) 'C_W nopq rst&'uvw ">é)*×QB'Æ/ x0 áâã *+ £ X ù F ÞP á s ;K Q / Ü Û J ¡ )*×Q °b s( Ã45/ª«¶ ~ D / âa IJ ° >? 3 )*×Q/B'Æ Ò ò ' à ãäå È/ æ RS m ">?(Ã)*×QB'Æ ~ < _ / | h FGÞ×  çá o ª i % )*×Q2 è Q )*×Q2)q )*×Q /ûü½¾e)*×Q/ ió' é ,-. ãäå È % )*×Q % B'Æ /0123 ="'%%%%%%%%% 45678 * 49:3 #$+, -!,)$ ! !"#! " "$ -"##) -!, x# ®ê%6L&'ÀëRüY322QÚs# Utu0 ¼½°% tuÈnoJ[à©Ä; ." 8(+,xy# ¡Þ¡(=9 bctu+~(¬WJ¶#®%L}Ô<& tu<çiÉÍe (̾Pü&'̾(R% #G# Å(:D3Àë ' §r¬Ô( (Î ÈÚ¨% GH®êýþ7'T5T ' §r¬Ô( Àë1'À(VW2* V ( ! ! Ûêë 'ÃìÁÀw'c# )*×Q&'Âà Å8ÆÇØÈp/

Upload: dangthu

Post on 05-Nov-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

'C_W

#

nopq

$

rst&'uvw

)))

">é)*×QB�'Æ/x0

áâã

!

!

*+

"

�£X(ÃùFÞPás;KQ/ÜÛJ¡

"

)*×Q°bs(

Ã45/ª«�¶~D/âa

"

IJ°>?3)*×Q/B�'Æ

#

��Ò

ò'ÃãäåÈ/æRSm

"

">?(Ã)*×QB�'Æ~<_��/|

hFGÞ× çáoª

"

i%)*×Q2èQ

!

)*×Q2)q

!

)*×Q

/ûü½¾e)*×Q/�ió'é

#

!

,-.

"

ãäåÈ

%

)*×Q

%

B�'Æ

!

/0123

" ="'%%%%%%%%% !

45678

" *

!

49:3

" #$+, -!,)$ !!"#!" "$ -"##) -!,

x8Þ

#

®ê%6L&'ÀëRüY322�Ú(¸s

#

U��tu��0

¼½°�

%

tu�ÈnoJ[à©Ä;

."

�8(+,xy

#

¡Þ¡�(=J¨9

bctu��+~(¬WJ�¶#�®%L�}Ô<

&

tu<çi���ÉÍe

(̾P�ü&'̾(��

%

#G

#

Å(�(:D�3Àë

'

§r¬Ô

(

ÈÚ¨

%

GH®êýþ7�'T�5T

'

§r¬Ô

(

Àë1�'À(VW2

*

V

(!!

! Ûêë

"

'ÃìÁÀw'c#�

"

)*×Q&'ÂÃ

#

Å8ÆÇØÈp/_É

#

Page 2: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

�JT

#

FÛ(��gh��Àë×$%ýþ7��Ãw�

%

#Tza

!

&s

"

./�½¾{z2È�JH5(gh

#

!�Ã./�D�wß(��Ú¨iRS

#

²�ÒÄwßñ7izî�ò(fB+{zç$(gh

#

�D�jkÍ}

#

7!

z{f{z(\¡

%

#G

#

;ÀLÀ((ýþ7��Ãw�(`�)

#

®ê��

[ãJàF�$%(£Vgh

#

ýþ7�fVQgh(\�B93JH1¯

%

ü

G��99̾(ãFÍ~

%

QF(�

#

Ä;�<8$ÎDóôw�(vwÝ L$%ýþ7�£�:

7d6

#

fÀÌ4×tuy±à(

'

( '

ã 

( '

ý\�

(

É��w&ä

v,�

#

7!IJko3ýþ7��Ãw�(+,

%

�×

#

x<8Þ¡Þ¡

�(ÁÂnoJ¨9V¬gh

#

���Î�Ãw�(./

#

�f�Ã./(w

�[ÀÍy

&

íKÔ»i./âe173ï�Õæ

!

§�

&

�XÙ

# !""')

��o

&

�4C

# !""')

øÆ

# !""#) !""'" %

U�VQ./UVRzSµ

üD�gh

#

9ÚÛTÜzÈÀè9ÁÂ�ªD�¬ï»|(

&

Óñ$%%�

(ýþ7��Ãw�

%

V�«¬Cq4%

!"

2l

)"

8�D�(�A¤"(©q

#

fÀÌ$%ý

þ7��Ãw��QÕæ

%

HÂÝÚ�A¤"(c©q��¸Ô»

#

ÀI¾

(âLñò

#

ÎD��w&izçÑZñ

#

�LoQÍeBvÓñ$%%�

%

UqüHÂ./(�µ�

#

V�00�D�¬W�$($%ýþ7�(�Ã

w�

#

dÝ�Ú(zLüD�¬W»|(./©qigm

#

SÐÑV��ª

Y���

#

ý+H�(©u

#

¬B����

#

þH�3$%ýþ7��Ã

w�

%

;

#

���4�ÒC��=ÁÂ

'

�A¤"

(

�`4%��WXwuÁ΢�Ì:Á

!e?56?D?>N:B;<7FGD?F

)!!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 3: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

OD8<?<4<7>D\ I<><7AD?E758?<;"

ý þ 7 � F � Q $ �

! &7D<75]:5N4SB?F

*\C?D?8<5><?:D >D\ N:B?F;"

����

!H>5;@K2>C8B7;" &

̳¦

!&G>5B78[K

H::\87BB" &

�¦

!M:GD *K_:G5" &

�`

!U5?:D RK2G?<7" &

�¦�

!M>C78RK

2:B]"

§r[¥ñò(¬6�0

-

ýþ7�F}wÄÅ

$

Ìs�}f%

.

!)#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"% &%. 134E"64$%&%,4)$",400$ >3+(1+%; 134)"'+1+,&'D+&'";#4" %

#T1ÂÁ·yLªT

'

�A

( !3B>FV8S456" #

´ôT

'

�A¤"

( %

�A¤"(+WÝ�ÀLWI�tS

$

��

#

Lz�qe

#

4%�}�/

$oL#¬�£ÝS5(à�³

&

à´,i�λ¼(

! S457>4F5>F;S>8G?D6"

(K|

%

V�K|L0Hųå_;oLÅçR(0H

#

LÈÀVípe

#

º

�\ÝÅ(×`

#

z�þiÅ(¤£L=>IëÒÄ:��:»¼Ô»ÞI

ü>¯

#

R*�Üf:±ý�»²Oq

#

¥a�³(¬�i=²

%

Zf0U

�jkgh

#

à!͸3�³u1(ºÂ

&

#

�³(}w�í\9I

JúC

%

#

Lýþ7�ÁÈ

#

ª«(&Óýþ7�w�ÀÌL7�

J

�}

��(¶ùåR

#

vwÝ i7TÝ :7d6

%

V�37�SSè1\>

c[�zì7Â(u^�w�Ãy®Yýþ7�ºmf

!"

2l

$"

8�QÞ(

�]

&

�³�/Étugh��À(½'

%

#G

# #'$)

8T¬Ï�Wn�¨

u¡D�3

'

:ýþ7�

(

(w&

%

�A¤"(Lr1Âr�3VÏu¡

%

:ýþ7���ýþ7�+,Õ2�}��(æ�

#

ävÙÉ

&

\ÝÉ��

%

U:ýþ7�(w&Äü±©

#

D�

#"

�8�fz�£�(z{Ú²7

8˵

%

qüfVQgh(��

#

����idéÕr¤"1µl3¬Ï[²ç

·u¡Þæ�þHäv(gh

%

éêL̳¦yò(

-

T»¼0G

. !234

<&04("$N#$4&#,$&,8"

UÀR

#

Õæ3´,

&

aVÝ 

&

ýþ�½

&

�ww�

&

7��íÉgh

!2>C8B7;T2:B]# #''$$ #. " %

VÏæ�å�

#

����Ý

H�é3ï�

% #').

#

�¯4%ýþ7�Áu8uL@A27(cu

#

*"!

"'C_W

Page 4: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

éêµl37ãy(+Wu

#

üY3�¦('

%

T�ãy+Wü

#')+

8wä

m

!_>BYG &K&G>D\B75"

Ý~(

-

4%7�%c8Ê

. !-<4%14%%+&'O+01"$8"(

134-/4$+,&% -./+%+01$&1+64>1&14"

$

!2>C8B7;T2:B]# #''$" %

#''"

8

#

¤"1Âi·*MrH�f¤"�d173hÝ2(Ð*

#

73

-

JÀýþ7�

. !54("#%.+%; )#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%" %

�Þ

#

T3½'t

u��~�{�(rs

#

�AÁÂêÜ3¤"(�d1¬�+,

#

ü

#''$

8

�73

-

JÀ\Ý(ýþ7�

$

{�(��

&

�{�(¨Î

. !54("#%.+%;

D4/",$&1+,)#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%$ 9".4$% )&$&."F40# )"01/".4$% <3&''4%;40" %

V

¬»q(ò1[¸3�AÁ³(©ßUÀ

%

P

#

��B�C�{��

$

;

%

ÚÛ£z

&&&

ïx?@C�EFG=�Ý��

RÛy*

#

�A¤"(D�b�1Âêf{zgh(äv

#

éê©u4%

tu(£Vgh9¤�JH

#

!jkgh(¾}ÜL'¤

%

����L

-

ýþ7�

.

(Û"$²9

#

Fé3Tì��+P¬W�7t�

#

~ò­gé

ê(�ÁUÀ�JH

%

V�¬W{ãF(gh

#

î�0�1Âê��{�I

_Þ� (gh

%

F{�Áô./0H

#

�A¤"(©q0�7�Á+,9z

ç

%

ãv{�=JTV'T�w�iz纻(Íy

#

U�A¤"1Âê0

JTV�¬�ãF(©q

%

�A¤"(D�;L¬ã�R�Áôu1(à�

#

h��Þ�üéêrF�³zîu1If{zgh(�¡ià©

%

κÏg

#

�A¤"Àd�ÁUÀ

#

U1ÂêJT

#

0'T«½Äè;D¢VQ�ÁU

À

!2>C8B7;# #''">" %

�A¤"V�\�üzç(©q�F4%À%I«%

6w�(+,i4%z¯Ý �Á¬aÑ�(

%

0ã#TV¬`d®¤\�

!"!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 5: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

3ýþ7�Áô£�(Ã>

%

zîR¤D�3¬Wjk4%tu£Vgh(

%6w�i�}¤"

%

�AÁ³JT4%tu(£Vgh�

'

�¿Ý 

( !NB45>B?8C"

�}Ô<

iÎ:(ë]¬¸z{(Zñ

#

0s�� 

!@:d?# #'+' "

D�(

'

�½�

¸�ÛÝ 

( !OD<7578<H5:4Y @?S75>B?8C" #

!0��³

!

ýþ7�

"

V�

%

V

��}Ô<(¨¸Ý��Uü4%À%(ÉÊi�}K|

%

4%%6(+,

�¬W�)!R(�+ÄÅ

#

ãKÿ!�³ftu(øå

%

·*

#

�üfW

=�Û(~k

#

4%(�}K|`qé£�´î�bc(+�

#

#GÎDÒ

Ä�´´ÜuSã�ª8Î:(´í

%

V��}Ô<(¶ùs�ÒÄ`ë�

ð(�³c[

#

k���½�¸îQ90H(c[;D�d��

#

!ýþ�

½uL��½�¸(=­$�+\�

%

UzîR

#

V�Ô<bc3ýþc[

Äü�ð

#

�c[i�½�¸~vü®¤(�¸�½

#

!0�h�·(ýþ

�½

%

V�Ô<zîRÀ�ütuR(ήúÔ

#

#TéêÀh�(abÞ

z{�³�Q

#

7!úC3=®i�JúÔ(�½

%

в7

#'

2l�«no

#

4%«¬ÒÄÀÌýþ7�Ô»Þjk�½�

¸�ÛÝ ïÞ(gh

#

UL��()i+,(I�tS)

#

�Ràf�´

(�}K|

#

ýþ7�óp Lu^w�(rx

%

0s�m

#

RfÅb$�

�³Î:�´0îÿ!

#

GHfd<A(Î×s�µ<d�Û}K´

#

3d

prL

'

7�

(

£�

#

0rF�}��

#

;+Dóô

&

u^�(H®

%

Zf

#

ýþ7�óÊTdé¾m�p(|}c[

!

Ìm

&

7��O

&

km

"

(

34

#

!0�|}c[(¬ã�

%

!"

2l

+"

8��

#

L:�ÛÝ ©v(z{)

#

f�³(�:i�w1

¬��Î

%

ÎDÁîë]vw

&

ýþi�\�/(

'

�³«Í

( '

:ýþv

w

(

R7¬I

%

�Å03�:�³1TIY>2(Î×

%

\Ü0I9VQ�

}f%ieÔ('b

#

f�³�U�Ï

%

=\f�³(ÒuBC7

!"

2l

$"

""!

"'C_W

Page 6: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

8�(

. J,

)æ9

'"

8�(

# J, !2>C8B7;T2:B]# #''$" %

õ�ªm

#

4%(ghs�&�¬W��µlc[�ª\¡�ų

&

®¤

�¸�½

#

!ävOlýþ�½

%

�w�³(R®�:\ÜÈ�èà4%

gh(£VyL

#

#G0È�D�ãF(jkÍ}

%

LÀ�º�ª�w�³

iÎDóô�u^(B�å)

#

�³(}w�íóIJ¥=

#

¥T3ýþ�

%

VQghÈÀY9¢Ijkã�bc

!"")

84%ÿ=âcH+(¶#

å¬

%

Lèà34%(£Vghå�

#

�AÁ³D�ýþ7�0U0�gh

#

z

�jk£Vgh(ä3

#

s��3ýþ7�1T\¡Å³�½

&

«1ýþ�

½(��

%

T3Y9VWÚ(

#

���Ìsà�³(B���

#

z�³Qà

2

%

éêJT\Üf�³(0U�J�Þ�üeÔö��f�W�Ô(¦§

#

!7$ÔRè¢:�J=f�³�U�(

%

̳¦

-

T»¼0G

.

“L.

/3{�\�D-J¤�+{

#

\Üf�³i�(U�ç¬ÈîQY9

+"/

QR

#

{ � � � Y 9

'"/ ! H::\78BB# #'). " %

· *

#

Ì ³ ¦

! H::\87BB#

#')."

zÎD

#

вÀ=±]�³Lu1$oL¨Ê{©

#

é(./+{V

Q¨Ê�Wq(

#

!0�»|�(

%

{�U�çD-jGT�=É�J�]

iwñ2úÔt�DO(ýþi�íKFdét�ÈÀVípq

%

¢:�J

Iæ(=®úÔ00JTI930ýÙ(G°

%

²�

#

�AÁÂ�FÌýþ7�L4%%6|}$(ñwªr

%

Vs�Ì

s3ýþ7�SSè1u^(�&

#

!�ÌsV¬�&s�JÀýþ7�(

ÉÊUÀ

#

Ìs3ýþ7�ÀÌL

#'

2l�no(vwÝ åR(�&

#

!

3dBd�©9<¾À%I«

%

�AÁ³JT4%¾m(P�$вÈÀ�

Fm�

#

UÀ%ÂL<¾ÄÅ(­�$

#

`q�Q_¾¦XT�W(ºvÝ

 Â

#

�dÎDýþ7�(ä31¯

%

ãR�¦

!_:G5# #''"$ 0! "

ym

$

'

RfºvÅ=���¾m<p©߳î¿(àá(%

#

×(ýþ7�¢f

#"!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 7: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

�éê³äv(ghå¬

%(

�¦f4%¾m<pÄÅ(./+{

#

À%Â3

��ýþ7�({�`aëyLr¡Îå$

%

BR

#

¾m�pr¡²u«T

$

8

#

!NîQ�u

#

ÈÀu«µ<

#

Vbc�zR{�r¡²#TV�(z

{íîQn�u�

%

V�0�À%Â(ª�

#

!�À�Tå

#

éês�ß"

#r¡²(Âp�

#

®éê�ªª8nwýþ��(|÷

#

íô

'

M*H+

!ïÀ+í�~(ý�yïÞ(¯:

( !_:G5# #''"$ $!" %

L<¾I«

#

fýþ7�(æ��Q

'

�³

(

(E �{(

%

FI

#

f

�³(1¯iªrÝ�ÀL��d

#

¬�Qþ�ÜT�W(àºvÝ Â

#

éê`qÎDÒÄ=\(ñ1if%Þ"#ýþ��

%

!V�f%iñ1;

�oLün�(

&

«~íÎ(t�$

#

d$�³i=\^À+ä

&

¾¿(º

»

%

!Q_¾¦XT�W(ºvÝ ÂÝÃÀÌÎ:($��³Þ´Üâã

i*ã(,¬

#

jkݬ�

#

«1&'+,

%

VL�túwßiu^Ý 

f4%�³iýþ7��WÖ×(+,ë\�3J�z{

%

#G

#

fýþ7

�(Õæ±¼½Æ9VQ¾�<ç(æ�å$

%

GHTJH�ýþ7�!0�déc[

!

BR

$

�Å

&

�½�¸

&

\��

W

"

�ª¸T!G³�·ýþ�½(}w��2

*

�AÁ³JTýþ7�Bd

éc[h��W4%=\

%

º��¾m(�#Âz�àfÂëýJ�W�0

V�4%¾m(¬WJ�&T

#

0s�

$0

W%u¡²�5�W\Ä

.""

P4

%=\

#

{LÞms�

,.0

W¡²�5�W

.

à=>

%

m»�n�<(

#

¬

W%u¡²;�{n¬W>�=\>2�Þ(

#

ó>2(A|î�zîY¯

)0V

0#/#

00�Z¬WúÔë�Û�½�¸Þ�W

!2>C8B7;7<>B(#

#''"" %

U:K(

&

:n�ª(ýþ7�=²LUVRîQàá4%yÀ=>

(`a

%

·*

#

�AÁ³zJTýþ7�^À0Hüdéµlc[(¬W`d

%

ý

þ7�Ô»�ÀÌL{�0H7�cä

!*67DF;"

åR(

#

#Gýþ7�Ô»

$"!

"'C_W

Page 8: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

0��:¬�

#

!�#Tvw0Htu��!¨¸(0Hã�

%

ZWcäs

>¬W¹­

#

òo#äüVW£�(~]M¨

&

<�=�u)Þ(ÉÊJ¾

iýþ�½(þ¨

%

Lcäâ(u1=²ù�VQM¨

&

&siþ¨(�w

=

![548<77" %

ã#TRG

#

ýþ7���L�Þ�ð(�}Ô<å$¨¸¬

�«~(íK

#

¤²0Äü�ð00�@�´

%

ÈÀV5(ýþ7�

#

L�

�ÑЯ°(�½��å)

#

yjýþ�½;���:�½�¸�½(³w

!2>C8B7;# #''"S" %

$

P

%

¤¥&

&&&

ò#�=µÎCù�X_~�

RÛy*

#

^À�®�¨(ýþ7��

#'

2l�\�QÞ®¢üu^w

�å$

%

UfV¬K|(u^w�w&(±]07©<ÜÄ

%

`q�

!"

2l

$"

8��{(:ýþ7�¥¦fV¬K|173¯þ(±]

#

!�AÁ³ã

�f:ýþ7�¥¦(ú�i+,

%

����

!2>C8B7;# #''"S"

L

-

JÀýþ7�

.

Â"$j¦9

#

�A

Á³i:ýþ7�°#ÑH(��w&

#

U�AÁ³JT:ýþ7�åyQ

�Lz�$\�{:z{

#

�#T&�<ç(�#

%

;ÒÄ[�;Ìsý

þ7�=²(����ll0ª(

#

#T=�tu(\Ù

#

�ØLtu<ç

å$

#

W=6äituë�Ltuzç$7§iAÍ(

#

#Gtus¾±¼7

W=itu<çLWÍeÞHI17

%

¬Íe�ÌsW=(�&i7T

#

HI

z�̾tu<çZ[

%

tu<çZ[kk�úÔ�&i��(Ô{

#

!VQ

<çZ[0�ªAÍW=(�&i7T

%

ULLÂå$

#

�AÁÂ�JT�

<çÝ Â

#

yQh�JÊ<ç(1¯

%

#G

#

�AÁ³�

'

<ç/(�Wn

�¨

( !2>C8B7;# #''"S$ !#" %

�AÁ³�ô(<çÝ 4ü

!"

2l

+"

8�

/)"

8�LtuÁ£�é

B(

'

:<çÝ 

( !P7:?D8<?<4<?:D>B?8C" %

K|(<çÝ Ý�ÎD<çf

%"!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 9: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

=(<A

#

3<çh�ªè1�tus¾(�o

%

!:<çÝ Ip<çZ[

\�(c±ÄÅ

#

JT<çiW=^ÀÑÐÀ[(1¯

%

:<çÝ (�W

�w���J�(

'

Z[�

( ! I<54F<45><?:D" !H?\\7D8# #')," % '

Z[�

(

(

$��d�tuZ[(

'

BJ�

( !=4>B?<;" %

s�mtuZ[0�ËÌü=

(�¨i7T!��oL(

#

!�L=(¼�¬¼(zçئ$+8)Þ(

#

�oLü=@²$(7T�ù

#

VQ@²$(

'

tuZ[

(

uz{=¼�(

7T

#

UHI=ÜLzç$0Ä"ã�Ââ�(

'

Z[

( %

#

�AÁ³J

Êtu<çs¦tus¾(1¯

#

ÎDÒÄ<çs¾Þz{=(�&

#

!=

ê:(�&iJMÔ»îQ1¬�s1tu<ç(Û1

%

$

Z

%

ER&

&&&

�ÎJ�¸ 

VÔ��`f2ÈoL(èm

%

K|ýþ7�κÏg�4ü{�Ý 

(

%

{�ݠJT2���oL(

#

Ä"0�ËÌü=!oL

#

�ªàá

���z

%

#G�QîQëpàÁ(Ú¨

#

²�ÒÄw�òÁ(Î×Þz{

VQÚ¨

%

U{�Ý L«13tu+,(HI0ïÞÜ�gh

%

ãR��

��i�¦�ym

$ '

{�Ý üY3{�¸s

#

BR÷}§¥³(nÒ

&

ö

´½in2:µå´v¶

&

�îýq(éÀÉ

%

U{�Ý 0P=}ïÞ3Ó

C

#

BR�oK(+,i�ð

&

·÷b�âc

&

¡Î

&

��(n�É

%

HI

#

Òø{�Ý ¶ùÀÌ(µli<ç0U0��¸²pÚ¨

#

à!fd¸²

irFÂ͸3�wi��R(úC

%

{�Ý s>¬3B¸¹

#

ïÞ(�½

iºC0ÑR)

%( !2>C8B7;T2:B]# #''$$ !."

�AÁ³LVÔ�R(Ì-0�4ü{�Ý (

#

U�¬�

'

)ç({�

Ý 

( !9?6G C:\75D" #

�{�Ý (³�¬Ó

!2>C8B7;T 2:B]# #''$$

!." %

V�#T

#

�AÁ³0�3ýþ7�è1�jktuâc

&

«1tus

¾(u^

#

V¬©ß�{�(

%

U�AÁ³L«¬ÒÄ�2�{�(�&

#

&"!

"'C_W

Page 10: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

àfQ�þ(òÁiw�Þ�ã{�Ý (âC

#

#GóôT�

'

)ç({

�ݠ

( %

{�Ý JT2ÈRoL�åÕz!­r([wi¶ù

#

¤êîQ`�=

(7T

%

!�{�Ý àf9:�([wi¶ù(oL

#

JT=ê;�ÒÄ

zîÔsià©Þ+{^Ô

'

��

(

)(Ñf[w

%

#G

#

�{�Ý Â0

ÝÃÛ±©

&

9:Ó¯([wÞ`�=ê(7¦

#

!�ÎDÒÄrF`p(

zçئ$¨¸(Ôsiþ¨1T=ê7¦(rù

%

yQ

#

�{�ݠ3{

�ghè1¬WÄÅ

#

V�(#jkÍ}�ÈÀn,¾}(

#

;ÀÒÄ0Ä

ª«s

&

f%if^Ô��(j¦ÞM9

%

�{�(w&Týþ7�DO3

`Í�i«1\Ý(b»

%

K|ýþ7�#TÎDw�ióô(`d

#

{e

¹®o��¨¨7?¤g'�ªr

#

7!¸Tkotus¾(íK

%

!�{

�(�&îQL�{À�d(=¼

#

;£¤F)(^Ô�¨Þ]ü7¦

#

!

0�±©(¶ù

%

V5su>½¨��`

!WFId?<7# #''$$ !#' "

Ë*(G

5

'

�¨¨7(g@

#

�U��(i�:(y%

#

Q¢ÛG\�(ÓE�w

'ëÃ0�oL

( %

�AÁ³(�{�Ý ��$Ô{Lf

'

ýþ�½

(

V¬%&(J¨R

%

7{�Ý æçè

# '

ýþ�½

(

V¬%&oL{:gh

#

#T¤Äüx�

#

&'rFp 

%

U�AÁ³7�{�(Ì-JTýþ�½%&(x��0U

0�gh

#

à!DO3cuis¾(î��

%

#TJ¨9ýþ�½%&(0

Fp�

#

u´ÜfSTýþ�½(oÄ'p

#

�b¬�ÕÖ

&

±'i0ÄÁ

î(��

#

¾J0H(Áj

#

��bWÔrFf%Þæ�ýþ�½(âW

!2>C8B7;7<>B(# #''"" %

#G

#

�AÁ³0ÝÃ��ýþ�½%&(zíâW

#

!�]ü¬�ÄÅ

/(Êæ

%

ýþ7�=²LkQI'Tv�]üQ)(ÄÅ

$

7¬Wgh(�

Íe!0��J<ÍeÞuK

)

3Ol(¿]�2f%å$

#

ÿ!Äçu�

'"!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 11: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

É«�½

)

uK��ÑЯ°(��

#

!0;êL¬WÌ-R

)

LkQÄÅ

$ãî�v�h�M¨iÒÓ

!2>C8B7;7<>B(# #''"" %

Rfýþ7�=²�

ª×#]¯VQÄÅ

#

ýþ�½(z{0s`¼îG3

%

$

%

!"#$Ëx¡ef/C~�

�AÁ³3ýþ7�L%6|}$'À(ªri1¯%�T

'

ßT�

(

!*67DF;N758Y7F<?E7" #

s�+,«1s¾(�©

#

VzîRWY3�AÁÂê

fýþ7�c['T+D�5+,1¯(«�

%

�AÁÂÝÃ�+Dýþ7

�(+,1¯

#

s�¯¬W^À+,6 (©Þ�Àü&óÁÂ(

'

»¼

(

!3457>4F5>F;" %

£¤����

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" # *67DF;

¬©ÀQ)MW

#

���`zß´í�\�¬p(z{

#

dÏ�`f�Â7Tyt

#

²

��

'

�w

( #

s�Tq=�Lq=(¥´ÃÄâ7¦

%

�AÁÂJTVM�

6 îQrFWYéêfýþ7�+,1¯(«Ñ

%

s�ýþ7�=²(n

,±Ì=

!N5?DF?YB7"

�=\

%

ýþ7�=²L=\(¥´)

#

L¾mm¦y

Åb(�´â7®´í

#

³n(Ú(��«1ýþ�½(z{

%

L�AÁ³èÞ

#

ýþ7�L|}$(��ªrÔ{L~R�ä¾�Ô

<

#

~)�ä=\úÜ

#

L$_�«1Qýþ7�cäT$�(tú(¨¸

#

³nÚ(�z{³�·(ýþ�½

%

0

#%

!"#$C¢�=~�

�*b�

(

�HVC

#

("!

"'C_W

Page 12: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

#K

)*×Q2èQ7C

�AÁ³füýþ7�L4%¾�Z[$ynªr(�ÄÝ��Þ�üf

<¾I«ÉÊ�W(j%

#

`q�ºvÅ=iàºvÅ=��

%

Q_¾¦X

T�W(ºvÅ=ÝÃÀÌÎÀí($��³«1&'+,

%

!Qþ�ÜT

�W(àºvÅ=ÝÃÒÄ"#n�(túÞ«1f%iÐÒ

#

�!Gýþ

��

%

àºvÅ�W=Ùÿ}

1

ÃW

!H7:567W>8:D"

f\��W(èmà

á3àºvÅ=(��

#

ém

'

éê'Ti=\L¬B

#

ßdyß

#

Údy

Ú

#

féêyt

#

��ÝÝÔu9éê(�½in�

( !2>C8B7;T2:B]#

#''$$ #!" %

�AÁ³JTºvÝ iàºvÝ �0�¢ffÌ(

#

�«¬ÃLÂ,

ñBÞ

%

�AÁ³�JT7£VRméê4üàºvÝ Â

#

#TéêÎD"

#ýþ��itúw&(J��

%

U�AÁ³«¬ÒÄÀÌÎÀí�^Àñ

m�(ýþ7�Þ«1ýþ��itúw&(z{

%

0s�mÚ(�àºv

Ý (

#

UÎ×�ºvÝ (

%

�AÁ³èÞ

#

²²ýþ7�(ñm�Þbü¾m

#

doL(� sLü

!G¾�ÁÂ

%

VÍeÝ�Ô{LRSnwidéM´(ä»Q¢RS¥¯

�Û}K´R

%

ýþ7�0�Ìm

&

A|imÎ(34c[

#

¤^À¾mÅ

b(ËÌ(ªr

#

¤ê'TÇ3'¯�Â(~]M¨

#

£¤¾m(��

#

À

I�#%u

#

ÀI�#A|

#

ÀI�#mÎ

#

dÚ(�!G¾�<ç

#

´Ü

�(�{

!2>C8B7;T2:B]# #''$" %

·*

#

Ûüm¦m�Ò8Bvx�

#

ý

þ7�=²^À�·(�Û}K´

#

LVWI¸éê'TQJHT`b2

*

�AÁ³JTéê'TQ¾m��T`b

#

s��Û

&

ÙÉ

&

=´É��

%

Vs��¦

!_:G5# #'+)"

ym(

'

�´��

( !_76?C7e>B47" %

!K

)*×Q2)q

RÛy*

#

�AÁ³ÎD<çF=(ÐÑÀ[1¯

%

¤ú�3Åù¬

&

X

)"!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 13: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

¤¹�ä·Ó�}Á(��

#

JT%6(n,Ú(�7§ý\(4ä

#

!%

60à�^À4ä(=Þ}w

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" %

�}ÄÅs�7§ý\6

äiAÍ=Þ(Á·

!a7BC>D# #')+" %

LF�tu

#

VW7§ý\��³Ý�(Á·s�ýþ7�3

#

#Týþ

i�F�:úÜ(�ØÓÓÑä

%

#G

#

ýþ7�=²'T³:ÅçR«1

ý\rFÀä�Q(æ�

#

7§=ênwýþ��(|÷

%

!{�:(�d

ijkÍ}0uLf%$�²\�

%

·*

#

Ûüýþ7�cä�äüo¬�

Q£�~]M¨iÉÊ&s(òí­

#

ýþ7�=²�çè[�Âi�#Â

(æ|

#

TrFæ�(=DO�#i~]M¨itS

#

Qìéê�ª��³

�|(>?

%

R����

!2>C8B7;# #''"F$ #,) "

ym

# '

�۳�(W

{�>?

#

î�>?à�M¨

&

�íiab(�#

#

!VQã�7�cä³

�ªDO(

%(

0s�m

# '

ýþ7�=²iý\'TÐTö�

%( !2>C8B7;#

#''"F$ #0."

����

!2>C8B7;# #''"F"

JTýþ7�(´,0'Þ�üfq=(

Îí;<

#

!�Þ�ü`ÍÀ�üW=+,(PÔ

#

7§d�Ò

&

ËÌ(=

Þ

#

¦�ý\(�í

#

7!Y9W=i�Ô�½(=ñ

%

Vã�

'

þi

(

(

[�yL

# '

þi

(

(wßs��ký\rF%6(|}

#

Þ«1ý\=Þ(

+,

%

V5(%6�uó=êyÖGiÒÆ

#

7!R�Týþ(�½!1�

±�(ÇÈ

%

.K

)*×Qe)*¹º

ýþ7�1T%6|}(��

#

d³nÚ(�«1³�·ýþ�½(z

{

%

LVÍe

#

ýþ7�^Àdéc[ºmBß(1¯

#

#TuSm¦m�

imÎ('kë0u{^Ô

#

¤ê(��±¼127�£�

#

¸T^Ô(�

Qö�Ú��+D1¯

%

!JH�¬W�Q£�(ýþ�½à�7�cä�

*#!

"'C_W

Page 14: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

�{�^Ô(Èp

#

BR^Â$§Ù6K(¨r

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" %

ýþ7�cä�ÒÄ�bý\i�½�¸(rFÞæ�ýþ�½

%

V€

Å$�v�

$

!0�ÉiüÉ«(gí

#

u�Ol�½

%

"0Su��½+

äÑä(¸Ô

#

0��b0$ÑäúÔ(rF

#

��z�u�ÈÀ��(�

�(�½

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" %

#0�¬(ã'�:úÜ(��

#

#Téê(

��00¬pëÍñOlýþ�½

%

ýä7�=²'T^À�Â(]'¨r

#

éê'çè

'

�(�J

( !c4\?F?:48]7d" #

!0�"f�Ç

'

ËÌ(�J

(

!E:F?]75:48C>D;"

ö

'

À´(�J

( !<G7Y:d75]4B]7d" !2>C8B7;7<>B(#

#''"" %

$v�3f%�b9ýþ�½()ç

#

¯&'w�i�½^q(©!

Þ17f%�ºmz{ýþ�½(

#

#Týþ�½0�yÀrFÂW=S×

(³ w Z ñ ã

#

ý þ � ½ ( f % à � � b = ê ä I W = � ½ ( ú T

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" %

,K

)*×Qe46

Ûeym(!G¾�Ô»

&

7§ý\��

&

«1ý\rF

&

z{³�·(

ýþ�½

&

«1tus¾ë�ÒÄÀÌtúÞz{(

#

!ýþ7�c[#T

^À~]R(H®im¦¥´(`ͪr�³�ª¸Ttú��(c[

%

L

V¬dR

#

�AÁ³«Ïú�3àºvÝ (��

%

ºvÝ �ÒÄ�¯=ê

��(�wÞY9A=q=(Ú(

#

;<íÞ�übÎX($��³

%

ºvÝ JT�³�þxúÜ

#

f=7T(A=�ÒÄÀÌtú$=F=(

º»Þz{(

#

;<íoLü=(�$

!H><78# #'')" %

#Ttú$(=^À

ÑH(w&

#

=êu�üftú(JH

#

!#¸Td$¬²(�´!���

Â(�½

#

V0�&'w�y�wj(

!2>C8B7;# #''"F" %

0K

)*×Qpñ/ÀÊ

&&>BB?D6'

,Ry*

#

�AÁ³Åbýþ7�=²¬�\¡�®Ì

%

éê0'3�Â

!#!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 15: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

è1u^

#

¬(gÌü\>�W

&

7��Oö��»²

%

ýþ7�=²'T

f=\(��^À½'�

#

U0�¬(ã'

%

éê'T^ÀËÌ(�¨

&

®à©(��

#

�bý\rFýþ��

#

«1tú(ÀÌ

#

7§ý\jký

þ��(|÷

#

ý+äüýþ�½(æ�

#

!G¾m��i¾�<ç

%

��

��É

!2>C8B7;7<>B(# #''""

JT

#

ýþ7�=²'TÒÄzçi�®à

©Þz{\¡�®Ì

%

zç�±'�ª

&

À�¨ª��Ú¨

)

�®à©�f

]ü(7¦Ý©0�

#

à�]�

#

�7&s$0ÄÁîiÌ1

%

;ÀV5

#

ýþ7�=²��f{À<ç�IÀ�ü�Û

&

ÙÉ

&

ã 170Äà©

%

Z

#

X,/x!"#$]£B&

�A¤"(D��°f4%tu(gh

#

0�ÀÌL4%�}<çi�}

K|åR(

#

#G

#

¤({�Z�{E+äÓ¯ü$%

%

UV�0Ïo®êÁ

î�AÁ³(©qi��Þ[À$%ýþ7��Ãw�

%

!N¤(¬Q©q

0ÀÓñ$%%�ån

#

BR

#

�AÁ³JT4%�³Äü�ð

#

ÎD¯Î

:(�³Þ"G=\(�ÛiÆÇ

%

®%ÖÀ¬WÎ:(�³

#

Vdz�®

ê(H®

#

gh�®ê'T�5Þ+DdH®

#

a�dâC

%

)eÃ÷ø�

AÁ³(©qD�ÀÌ$%ýþ7��Ãw�'©u(¬Qgh

%

$

;

%

/xC�EFG=�Ý��¤¥¦

-

�A¤"(ñòBd�f4%tu£Vgh(à©

%

GH{Ö×$%tu

(£Vgh�JH

#

!jkÍ}ÜL'¤2

*

HÂJT

#

F�AÁÂf4%

ghèmÍÍÑà

#

ÚÛ$%tu(£VghÝ�Lü�³

%

ãv�³Ls

¦&'+,R�0îÈ

#

UxQ8LÄç��&'�½(:®å)

#

ÀQ�

³ã�öýþc[V�L{:ÅçRÐT¬WÎ:(�½�¸

#

¥T3ýþ

"#!

"'C_W

Page 16: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

��

%

¤êÒÄfab(_Ä

#

<pi!GÀ�ü���½(�Q

#

��

��®¤(ã��½

#

7!úC3�:=\úÜi%6(Ol�½

%

V¤0�m�³�f®%ÚÛyÀ(ghyt

#

�zR

#

®êeì({�

gh�@tu�(

#

®ê%\�$({�`azºmÓ'Àë{�%6(à

#

`q�I9K|Ñ66]Cw(z{

#

%=(ý\6ä9:&'

%

K|

6]Cw�QÚ�T@ï

#

ÎDi7n�Ô(Ú¨

%

!ý\Cw�Q�ùT

#

��=êabÒÒ

&

�¦

&

ýã

&

ÐÔ(7Trù

#

7!¨¸ÀÂ(

tuÁÂ

%

LK|6]Cw(z{)

#

®ê{�=;JÊ=�i�Ân¸Ô

(�½

#

7!ÓÊq=(�Riýþ�ù

%

U�7�AÁ³yÝÃ(:<çÝ Þè

#

®ê'TJ¨9�³(7Ti

<çF%\ÿ�å_^ÀÑÐÀ[1¯

#

!N�³(7Ti<çÕüÝbª

r

%

Rf®ê��(�³<çi7T$Ú²�U¨Êi0ÙÉ

#

VQ<çi

7Tsu3¨Êi0ÙÉ(�&1¬�5/L=ê(�uå$

%

RfV5

#

®ê(%\�ÃÔlºm1�

#

!V0uàÄÞko<ç(1�

%

Rf®ê%6ÚÛ(£VghLü�³i%\LWÍe

#

!�³�Ý�

Íe

#

GHjkÍ}L'¤2

*

�AÁ³`�4%(£Vgh0��³

#

#

GîQ3ýþ7�1Tjkgh(¾}

%

GH

#

²²®ê(�³�ghy

L

#

®êz�Ò¿�³Þjkgh:

*

�0�®ê'Tp:�ÛÝ åq

#

ÀÌn�³

#

²�k{�ýþ��ÒÄ.-Þjk2

*

HÂJT0�V5

%

L$%

#

�³(ghzYÒ¿�³Þjk

%

��

#

�³´,L$%^Àº

îÀ�(1¯

#

L®êý\6äz{&'(�ò)

#

z�à��³´,Þ

!GýþÁÂ

)

#

Ûü�³(Î:z{í

#

RfÈÀ�³w&(rs

#

®êtu{�Íe(Àë¢Ì¾sÃ{E@e

&

Ý2ª17

)

³�

#

ãR

Ûeym

#

�³7Ti<çf%\�^ÀJ:z{

#

RfÈÀ�³(Ìs

#

$%(%\�0{E1�

%

#G

#

jk$%FÛ(gh

#

z��7�³n

##!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 17: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

o

#

ÒÄ�³(̾ޫ1tui%\�&(s¾

% ."

�8Û

#

®êD�

ÀëÕW{�/

!

u]

&

t]

&

&

òó

" #

VWÚ¨®êü&öÂäx

z{3

#

{L®ê'TD�(�Àë<çi=({�/

%

LVWÄÅ$ý

þ7�:ÀîT

%

$

P

%

!"#$N§$µÎ

�AÁ³7f4%¾m(./�a3ýþ7�L4%¾�Ô<$(ªr

%

²²ýþ7�F¾�U¾Ñ�

#

ýþ7�(./s0�ºÊVWº»

%

QF

(�

#

füVWgh(./L®%ýþ7�£�<Þs�^2

%

#

"#

tu��¼½°�

#

��s1¾�̾(��¼V)Õ

#

efV¬­®

#

ý

þ7�ÁÈ'T+D�5(1¯2

*

F4%0H(�®%(¾�<çzÈÀ[ãY9Pz

#

yQHÂJTFÛ

ýþ7�ÁÈ'T#J©u�5ÒÄýþ7�Þ«1¾�Ô<(�3

%

ãv

�³Òm7�ü&À3{:1�

#

U1Týþ7�./f©(�³»²L{

:ÅçRÚ�¾�Ô<(Ö~ø

%

#T¾�(��w&�µ<�³´í

#

V

5s=¼3»²(Î~

#

yQéêf¾�A�#ûÎ7ç

%

GH%Âî�u

g

#

k»²�R��´í

#

äI¾m(A=

#

î�:

*

HÂJTRf®êýþ7�ÁÈ�\(M¨

#

Pýþ7�=²DO(7m

ë�äü¸Vñ½�#

&

|(i�Ú]�Éóô

#

!0��5Fý\CÀ

&

"�=´

&

!GtuýÙÉ

#

GH®ê(»²Ü�H�^Àýþ��!�R

17̾2

*

yQ

#

HÂ��ýþ7�ÁÈ�:f¾�

&

&

ã Éw&

(äv

#

Rfýþ7�ÁÈ�ª:í×ØVQw&

#

®å¸TÁôiz�È

þHa#(6ärù

#

ÑÒVQw&uL{:ÅçRÊ2»²(�¨å$

#

!L�³$^ÀV��¨(=¡�

#

$%(¾�åqs¡]�

%

$#!

"'C_W

Page 18: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

$

Z

%

!"#$N!�=?Q

ÑfüÛ¬Wgh

#

®%ÁÂLý\rFÍe(./�×Y�

#

UHÂJ

Tý\rF(./'TFtúw&hתZñBÞ

%

túw&ÎDÒÄý\

(f%iЦ

#

ÀÌU¾º»

&

w&ÑH(úÔ

%

#TúÔ$(¸²^ÀþH

(��w&

#

tú(WÔ�îQT3"#ftú(Æ4!���Â(�½

#

i7h:(�½

%

ý\&'rF´�(¬WÝ�¶#�Ú��0äÂ

#

#G

ÀÌL^ÀU¾º»(túUÀR(ý\rF�h�Âp

&

À(

%

tú0;�¬WªwR(%&

#

;�0H(µlöW=^ÀþHäv(�

�i�½R(@ï

#

tú�îQLh�·ª�⨸(

%

ãÍ�}w�JT+

ä\Ý{ELª��·

&

=>�({�%6$z{

#

yQ;�z7�¡<

%

U�x8ÞéB(Zd}ww�

!P:\>BH:E75D>DF7"

jk3V¬��

!=5>G:8# !""," %

Zd}ww�s�`¬Q^ÀþHÚ¨(µlQ¬Wµlc

[T��U¾ZñBÞ

#

17+ä(CÀf%ÞM�jkgh(Í}

%

#T

0H(µlc[ºñdéµl(�í0H

#

ºñ�íÎ(µlsu¸TZd

%

L{z$

#

�³c[kk#T^Àabi~]M¨Íe(H®!¸TZd

%

L4%

&

B%

&

Ù:�XÉãÍ%6$

#

¬WZd}w(C·�Û�½Ñä

�Í�Wµ¸(ú@�\±²uÞytkQ(

%

�³(1¯Ý��fVW�

Í�Wµ¸(±²uDOaÿivwR(�#

%

V5�³(æ|s7+ä(

kpÂ

#

s¸3æhf%CÀ(Zd

%

GH1Týþ7�Á=

#

®ê¬Íe��Îw�Ð*i¤K[�ÞÌs

�³»²(ì�w&

#

®éêJ¨9�³(�t0;��¸RÊnx(u

#

z^À«1ý\rF(tu

%

#G

#

�³»²±¼���þ��()

&

�¸u�

&

Ú:;(©ß

%

·*

#

ý\rF(¬WÝ��o��³i=\

å_&'Òu

%

L$%V�0Òu(\�

#

�³i=\BÍëÀtu

#

U

%#!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 19: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

Rf�~VÍe�í

#

�³±¼��Pb=\h�Òu

#

DOh�cuÞ

7§=\(�í

%

²�

#

®êz�./RSÒÄ<çëyÞ¨i{z�o

#

«1tú(ÀÌ

%

RfL®%�WæPë�¨¸Q�³TZd

&

túT@

ï(ý\rF/0

#

%\(ýþ��s�Y9Ûj

#

�³iý\0s�ª

§¸CÀ

&

ÀÂЦ(îÜ

%

!V5(îÜiý\��0uT¾�(zß

DO�wUÀ

%

$

%

¨©#s

�AÁ³fýþ7�1¯(wjÝ��ÀÌLfÉÊ�W(j%åR

%

G

H$%ýþ7��Ãw��z{Vº/0±¼7$%(ÉÊ�W$ÞM9Ý

b

%

®ê(ÉÊÝbÀ{�

#

HÂJT³�YÝ2./(�ù$â©ß

%

#Tyn(ÉÊÖ×

#

ù$â�ÈÀ+ä&¢

'

ýþ7�

( #

Ud{�©

ßF�AÁ³ÀeÛHuån

%

VÝ�W{LQ)LWÍe

$

¬�JÊ�³(+,1¯

%

ù$â©ß(��

/// '

M\Ý 

(

zîRD

�3Àë\]ËÌ

&

\´�Û

&

\�N³%6(wß

%

!�³ã�z{V¬

¼¬(�K

%

BRQN³TÚ((\�Ý ÀLWÝ�¶ù

$ '

ÙNª´

(

i

'

À<aV

( %

ÙNª´(¬WÝ�âe�

'

ºªÕ�Æý

( #

V5s´Ü�

J:ªÝÒÄÞtºª!ûü4²¬³

#

ºªÕ�(ñ2Æü�³�

#

�³�

¯Vã�aÿT�:úÜDOtuÆ�

#

À<aVÝ��À<�=aV

#

:

u]ëÛ�³%�

#

üY(�ß@\�ö

%

L\´Ý Íe(�$W{s�

'

m�

(

©ß

%

\%ï`åI

#

qü%\\´�¨àá

#

ù$âD�Q

'

�M

��

(

(¾Ì�³ÞÔ+%\(ý\��

#

7§�}�í

%

Lm�I«

#

³�³&mâu«ñÞå²

#

9�9Ch=\�º�}

%

»�JÊ<çf=(À[1¯

%

V�$W{Lù$â(

-

\´ï�

.

å$

%

ù$â©ß`qJÊ=(©ß�¨

&

�/i7TîÜ(z{

%

#G

#

&#!

"'C_W

Page 20: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

Ld

-

À%ÍÈ

.

(M:ã�$

#

T¬ã���wÀë

#

TM�tu

Àë

%

LtuÀë

!

¹\´ï�

"

$

#

ù$â78_�ªæ�3�ñ

&

Z

t

&

¡�ÉK1�ù

%

VQK1�ù�0;¯ü�³

#

z5�Á·

&

Àu

&

ýkÉtu¸Ô

%

dÚ(s�ÐÑÒÄZ7VQ¡�ÅÂÞ7§%\(Ù

É�¨iÀÂCÀ(7TîÜ

#

Tz7¾�\Ý@)UÀ

%

BR

#

L

-

\

´ï�

.

T»0

'

ÔÃtuå¸Ìm

(

T

#.

À

'

�²

(

ã�

#

ù$âé

9

$ '

d�²ÔÛÇ�F

#

®�Yâîd�ø

%

R�

#

ù@Ôu²­YFd

u�

#

ü�Ú�½¾

#

Zíã×

#

!ÙÉýãå���ä²!�å

%( !

ù

# #'', $ !)" "

$

%

ªJ�B«

Û�&9�AÁ³�)ç{�Ý (w�

#

dÝ�Ú(�Ch�{�(w

&Þjk{�Ý ïÞ(âc

%

7®%ÚÛ(+,Ö×Þè

#

®êz4üQ

{��TÝ(Ö×

#

`q�̾n�«_

#

{�Ý ©! �+,

#

ÒÄÎ

D()

&

y%i+,

#

z{3&'

&

òó

&

ö�(M*+,

%

U0îIJ(

#

V�¢æ()i+,({�/xy0ïÞ:K(ye1¯

#

ÈÀ®�:

=\úÜ(à�Y9'À(UV

%

HÂJT®ê��'TfLWÍe({��©!xy17à©

$

¬�îÜ

ü���FÚ¨

#

���¬c�(ì7

%

®êA�Û�³i~6ÞFp�F

(Ú¨

#

�ÒÄ�³´,s¦

#

:�xB�¤K

#

R7)(Þz{VQÚ¨

%

Vbc®êÈ�fVQÚ¨�I[ãÍñ�:=\(£V�½17¢Ià©

i�ã

%

=\úÜ#Tó%Äç´y'bÈ�17àè(�#i'Ä

#

¹®

�oLÀµ(àf�é0óÝb(%Äç´yêÈ

%

#T&�¢Ià©iD

$

#

Fgh�$H+Ikk+JEë

%

®ê�Ê�³f

H=N

(��yïÞ(

Ü�ghs�V¬©!(�$W{

%

»�89

'

�:

(

!0�

'

�
(

'#!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 21: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

!py

%

Vbc�|uÅ·ì

#

LÈ�{×UVúÜ(à�

#

�͸3úÜ

Ft�(¶í

%

BR

#

{�-.ÀÀ2ÈÊ:�Ô�-

#

L&'t�(¥¦

ëß

)

L.$�Àë{�/(:�¬ìî

#

!0�ÀëJKh�(n�t�

¬ìî

%

V0SPúÜ�ØïÞ0ì

#

za�3cd¼8�ØiÅÄt�(

º»

#

7!ft���Ó0ä�

%

T3�ãVQgh

#

®êÀ±�Lýþ7�Á£��2�{�w&

#

²�

«1$Wtu©!Ãy(rs

%

®ê'Tï�f()i�FÚ¨(Äç��

#

�b¬��Ï(��

#

!0�rÚi7

)

ï�f�:ð�(8×

#

!h�v

JW�/à�

)

àf%Äç´

#

�b��úÔrFf%

#

!N�"arF�

Í�ªÐÑfå

&

­0

#

!0��³»²17�Íe(

'

Ë2y(f%

( !

Æ

¨�

&

ñm

# !""!" %

ýþ7�ÁÈiz�ȱ¼FÌV5¬�w&

#

s�Í

ñ�:=\�½(�Q0�»²i~6�ªkp(

#

!��LF³�·(t

uúÔ0Òf%iCÀ(UÀR��¨¸(

%

#G

#

®ê'TÕæ�5À̬

�<çc<

#

"aãî��·ªturF

#

"arF�Í�ªÀ(

&

&

0I'bªf%

#

7!99jkgh(þ¨

#

�QV�þ¨

#

!0�±©(

¶ùiÚ¨

#

1T7¦(Ò¤

%

LV¬dR�AÁ³Êb(ÒÄýþ7�cä

TZdÞÀÌf%túT®êDO3{×(©uÍ~

%

à�ÎD(�

#

HÂÝÃLýþ7�£��2�{�w&

#

�0���@

+,9ƨ�iñmÉD�(�{�ýþ7�

%

#T�{�ýþ7�Ý��

LãÍ%6ü&�¸{�/Ö×(UÀRD�Þ(

#

!®%ÚÛL{�Íe

znüÛ{�/Ö×

#

BRL�QkQ$&�Vª(w��aÅÂ

#

VQz

à�¥¯{�Ý (©!Þ�Q�3

%

#G

#

�AÁ³)ç{�Ý (Ì-

B{�Ý (vwÝ i:ýþ7�h^Ûò�

#

0B�{�ýþ7�hÓ

ñ®%(+,Ö×

%

(#!

"'C_W

Page 22: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

#

Ñb

&&&

!"#$C¨©¬­

F

!"

2l

+"

8�ÑÝ(�

#

��($%nüܬÏÝ9s¾(ä3I

«

#

U0H(�VÏs¾(Ýh0�&'Ô<

#

!��}

&

tui�/

%

!

ýþ7�Ls1VQs¾R^À2V�J(1¯

%

ãRV�y*

#

ýþ7�

~R�ä¾�<ç

#

$%¾�<ç(�3�0nýþ7�Ô<(̾

%

Í%60H(�

#

®êz0oL\>»²i7�»²(�F%�

#

%6³)

£b�Ô(¸²¢:�J�7ý�²Ô»$DóBÞ(

#

éê(w&Ã{:

ÅçRkp$%�}Ô<̾(p~

%

·*

#

ýþ7�~)�ä�:=\ú

Ü

%

ýþ7�Fcd¼8�ØÓÓÑä

#

VQýþc[(<çi7Tf%\

ÿ�u\�Ý9z{

#

!%\�Ü�®êÀÌýã

&

ÀÂtu(UÀ

%

#G

#

®êýþ7�ÁÈeì(@¿u�s�Àë×�Â(�Ãw�

#

7!T$%

tuDO+,Í~iM¨UÀ

%

®êýþ7�ÁÂiz�=²ë'T��J

¨9�Âyôy(ÉÊ®Ì

#

®ê(u1kp#®êuÀ¬WJH5(%6

iJH5(%\

%

�|45

Þ;.

!

íî

&!""!'K

�ió)*×Q

)))

ïð�y

&

)*×Q2)*&'dñ4ò

'K

´µ

(

(Ãpq#�¶·4

K

!

ow3

&!""''K

(Ã)*×Q�/

$

ºù¾P

%K

/:ó

!

6¯Þ

!

ËÌÍU±

K

ôR(Ã)*×Q�

(

¾P2�>

K

´µ

(

(�±4¶·4

K

%(�

&#'','K

>ÃëI

K

(

fgpq¶·4

K

ö÷q

!

ø'ù

&!""''K

)*×Q�(/B���

K

/:ó

!

6¯Þ

!

ËÌÍU±

K

ôR

(Ã)*×Q�

(

¾P2�>

K

´µ

(

(�±4¶·4

K

)#!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"

Page 23: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

6¯Þ

&!""#'K

)*×Q/&'U³

)))

ôR2vú

K

pq#��®

" #K

6¯Þ

&!""''K

�>(Ã)*×Q/)*'Æ

K

/:ó

!

6¯Þ

!

ËÌÍU±

K

ôR(Ã

)*×Q�

(

¾P2�>

K

´µ

(

(�±4¶·4

K

=5>G:8" N(& !"", 'KOD<7BB7F<4>BN5:Y75<;>D\ NG>5C>F74<?F>BW>5V7<8( * P:\>BH:E75D>DF7

*YY5:>FGK24/@'4=&7546+47" ++ &!' ( ,"# -,!,K

H><78" I(&#'')'K_7\?8F:E75?D6<G797>5<:]N4SB?F*\C?D?8<5><?:D( [G7P:5C><?E7[G7:5;:]OD

9?8I<7Y8KNG=\?8875<><?:DKN7<758S456( e?56?D?>N:B;<7FGD?FOD8<?<4<7>D\ I<><7AD?E758?<;K

H?\\7D8" *(& #'), 'K 234<"%01+1#1+"% "(>",+418( G#1'+%4"(134234"$8"(>1$#,1#$&1+"%K

375V7B7;( AD?E758?<;:]&>B?]:5D?>N5788K

H::\87BB" &(& #'). 'K234<&04("$N#$4&#,$&,8( -)#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"% )"'4/+,K&G><G>C(

&G><G>C9:487N4SB?8G758K

a7BC>D" I(&#')+'K9&:+%; )#*'+,)"'+,8( -O"@4(#'U+47"(-/4$+,&% E"64$%/4%1KP7dX:5V(

3>8?F3::V8N4SB?8G758K

@:d?" [(&#'+''K234B%. "(=+*4$&'+0/( 234>4,"%. 54@#*'+,"(134C%+14. >1&140KP

%.

4.KP7d

X:5V( P:5<:DK

WFId?<7" U(&(& #''$ 'KN:8<C:\75D8?C" N4SB?F*\C?D?8<5><?:D" >D\ <G7N4SB?FOD<7578<KOD

2>C8B7;" HK T 2:B]" M(1\8K 54("#%.+%; D4/",$&1+,)#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%( 9".4$%

)&$&."F40" )"01/".4$% <3&''4%;40K[G:48>D\ U>V8( I>67N4SB?F><?:D8K

_:G5" M(&#''"'K[G7&:D8<?<4<?:D>B&>87]:5N4SB?F*\C?D?8<5><?:DKOD 2>C8B7;" HK" 3>FG75"

_K" H::\87BB" &K" a5:D7DS756" NK" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K" 2G?<7" UK" T2:B]" M(1\8K

54("#%.+%; )#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%KP7dS45;N>5V( I>67N4SB?F><?:D8K

_:G5" M(& #'+) 'KB13+,0("$N#$4&#,$&10( -% B00&8"% =&7 &%. U&'#40KP7dX:5V( W>5F7B

=7VV75" ODFK

2>C8B7;" H(& #''">'KN57]>F7KOD 2>C8B7;" HK" 3>FG75" _K" H::\87BB" &K" a5:D7DS756"

NK" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K" 2G?<7" UKT2:B]" M(1\8K54("#%.+%; )#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%K

P7dS45;N>5V( I>67N4SB?F><?:D8K

*$!

"'C_W

Page 24: ’C W - 《公共行政评论》jpa.sysu.edu.cn/docs/20130129120023707928.pdf · prL ’7‹( £ƒ# 0rF‹}ı›# ;+Dóô& u^⁄ ... ⁄å$% UfV‹K|(u^w⁄w&(–]07

!"#$%&

!"#!

'(

$

)

2>C8B7;" H(& #''"S 'K OD<5:\4F<?:DK OD 2>C8B7;" HK" 3>FG75" _K" H::\87BB" &K"

a5:D7DS756" NK" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K" 2G?<7" UKT 2:B]" M(1\8K54("#%.+%; )#*'+,

-./+%+01$&1+"%KP7dS45;N>5V( I>67N4SB?F><?:D8K

2>C8B7;" H(& #''"F'K[G7*67DF;N758Y7F<?E7( N4SB?F*\C?D?8<5><:58>8*67D<?>B@7>\758KOD

2>C8B7;" HK" 3>FG75" _K" H::\87BB" &K" a5:D7DS756" NK" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K"

2G?<7" UK" T 2:B]" M(1\8K 54("#%.+%; )#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%K P7dS45;N>5V( I>67

N4SB?F><?:D8K

2>C8B7;" HKT2:B]" MK&#''$'KOD<5:\4F<?:D( &>D >9?6G W:\75D N5:c7F<R?D\ 9>YY?D788?D >

N:8<C:\75D 15>-K OD 2>C8B7;" HK T 2:B]" MK 1\8K 54("#%.+%; D4/",$&1+,)#*'+,

-./+%+01$&1+"%( 9".4$% )&$&."F40" )"01/".4$% <3&''4%;40K [G:48>D\ U>V8( I>67

N4SB?F><?:D8K

2>C87B7;" HK" H::\87BB" &K" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K" 2G?<7" U(T2:B]" M(& #''" 'KN4S?F

*\C?D?8<5><?:D >D\ H:E75D>DF7N5:F788( IG?]<?D6<G7N:B?<?F>B=?>B:647KOD 2>C8B7;" HK"

3>FG75" _K" H::\87BB" &K" a5:D7DS756" NK" _:G5" MK" I<?E758" &K" 2G?<7" UKT2:B]"

M(1\8K54("#%.+%; )#*'+,-./+%+01$&1+"%KP7dS45;N>5V( I>67N4SB?F><?:D8K

!$!

#

`abc

$

defghijk"