dsge modelling at the banco de portugal - douglas · pdf filedsge modelling at the banco de...

49
M M A A C C R R O O - - L L I I N N K K A A G G E E S S , , O O I I L L P P R R I I C C E E S S A A N N D D D D E E F F L L A A T T I I O O N N W W O O R R K K S S H H O O P P J J A A N N U U A A R R Y Y 6 6 9 9 , , 2 2 0 0 0 0 9 9 DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho Félix Economics and Researach Department Banco de Portugal

Upload: voanh

Post on 13-Mar-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

MMAACCRROO--LLIINNKKAAGGEESS,, OOIILL PPRRIICCEESS AANNDD DDEEFFLLAATTIIOONN WWOORRKKSSHHOOPP JJAANNUUAARRYY 66––99,, 22000099

DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal

Ricardo Mourinho Félix Economics and Researach Department

Banco de Portugal

Page 2: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF
Page 3: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

DSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal

Ricardo Mourinho Felix

Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal

IMF Macro Modelling Workshop

Washington, DC

January 6-9, 2009

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 1 / 47

Page 4: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Outline

1 DSGE models at the Banco de Portugal

2 Introducing and calibrating PESSOAHouseholds and labour unionsFirmsGovernmentRest of the world and market clearingCalibration

3 Increasing competition in the domestic marketsMotivation of the paperSimulation design and resultsMain findings

4 Ongoing research using PESSOA

5 Directions for further research

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 2 / 47

Page 5: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

DSGE models at the Banco de Portugal

DSGE models at the Banco de Portugal

DSGE modelling activities started in 2005

Available DSGE models

EA-US model Alves, N., S. Gomes and J. Sousa (2007)PESSOA model Almeida, V., G. Castro and R. Felix (2008)

Ongoing DSGE research projects

Available models are being used in applied researchEAGLE model: joint project with ECB and Banca d’ItaliaIdentification issues in DSGE modelsCredit frictions in DGSE models

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 3 / 47

Page 6: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA

Introducing PESSOA

PESSOA

PortugueseEconomyStructuralSmallOpen economyAnalytical model

Almeida, Vanda, Gabriela Castro and Ricardo Mourinho Felix (2008)“Improving competition in the non-tradables goods and labour market”WP 16/2008, Banco de Portugal

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 4 / 47

Page 7: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA

Introducing PESSOA: the model

Figure 1: Model flowchart

Tradable goods manufacturers

Non-tradable goods manufacturers

Consummer goods retailers

Investment goods retailers

Governm. consump. goods retailers

Export goods retailers

Households

Labour unions

Foreign suppliers Foreign costumers

Government

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 5 / 47

Page 8: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA

Introducing PESSOA: the model

General features

SOE integrated in a monetary union (=euro area)6 types of agents:

HouseholdsLabour unionsManufacturers (intermediate goods producers)Distributors (final goods producers)GovernmentRest of the world (=euro area⇒ S = 1)

Labour and product differentiationCompetition: monopolistic in output markets, perfect in input marketsReal and nominal rigidities (quadratic adjustment costs)

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 6 / 47

Page 9: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA

Introducing PESSOA: the model

PESSOA is largely inspired on GIMF (Kumhof, M. and M. Laxton (2007))

PESSOASmall-open economy modelExogenous monetary policyNo role for public investmentTrade in semi-finished goodsHeterogeneous import contents

GIMFMulti-country modelEndogenous monetary policyPublic investment plays a roleTrade in intermediate and final goodsHomogeneous import content

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 7 / 47

Page 10: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Households and labour unions

Households (I)

General featuresBlanchard-Yaari overlapping generations, declining lifetime productivityLiquidity constrained and liquidity unconstrained (H ∈ {LIQ, OLG})Consume goods from distributors, supply labour to a unionPay taxes on consumption and labour income, receive transfersExternal habit persistence

OLGs’ specific features

Own firmsHold domestic and foreign bonds

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 8 / 47

Page 11: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Households and labour unions

Households (II)

CRRA utility

UHa,t(h) =1

1 − γ

(CHa,t(h)

HabHa,t

)ηH(1 − LHa,t(h))1−η

H

1−γ

Budget constraints

OLG:

PtCOLGa,t (h) +Ba,t(h) +B∗a,t(h) = (1 − τL,t)WtΦaL

OLGa,t (h) + TansfersOLGa,t (h)+

+1

θ

[it−1Ba−1,t−1(h) + i∗t−1B

∗a−1,t−1(h)

]+ Dividendsa,t(h)

LIQ:

PtCLIQa,t (h) = (1 − τL,t)WtΦaL

LIQa,t (h) + TransfersLIQa,t (h)

where Pt = PCt (1 + τC,t) is the numeraire.

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 9 / 47

Page 12: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Households and labour unions

Households (III)

Utility maximisation problems

OLG:

maxCOLGa,t (h),LOLGa,t (h),Ba,t(h),B∗a,t(h)

Et

∞∑s=0

(βθ)s UOLGa,t+s(h)

s.t. Intertemporal budget constraint OLGt

LIQ:

maxCLIQa,t (h),L

LIQa,t (h)

Et

∞∑s=0

(βθ)s ULIQa,t+s(h)

s.t. Intratemporal budget constraint LIQt

Wealth

hwt + fwt = human wealth+financial wealth

Rt+s = Πsl=1θ/it+l−1 human wealth discount factor

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 10 / 47

Page 13: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Households and labour unions

Labour unions

General features

Hire labour from households, rent it to manufacturers charging a markupPay tax on “dividend” arising from monopolistic competitionQuadratic wage growth adjustment costs

Dividend

DUt (h) =(1 − τL,t

)[(Vt(h) −Wt)Ut(h) − Adj.costst(h)]

Dividend maximisation problem

maxVt(h)

Et

∞∑s=0

Rt+sDUt+s(h)

s.t. Adj.costs, Type h labour demand

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 11 / 47

Page 14: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Firms

Manufacturers (I)

General features

Produce tradable and non-tradable goods (J ∈ {T, N}), using labourfrom unions and capital (formed with investment good from distributors)

Pay social security contributions on wage bill, tax on dividends

Quadratic price growth and investment adjustment costs

Production function

ZJt (j) =

((1 − αJU )

1ξZJ

(KJt (j)

) ξZJ−1ξZJ + (αJU )

1ξZJ

(TtA

Jt U

Jt (j)

) ξZJ−1ξZJ

) ξZJξZJ−1

Capital accumulation equation

KJt+1(j) = (1 − δJ )KJ

t (j) + IJt (j)

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 12 / 47

Page 15: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Firms

Manufacturers (II)

Dividend

DJt (j) =[PJt (j)ZJt (j) − (1 + τSP,t)VtU

Jt (j) − P It I

Jt (j) − (Fix.+Adj.costs)Jt (j)

]−

− τK,t

[PJt (j)ZJt (j) − (1 + τSP,t)VtU

Jt (j) − P It

(qJt δ

JKJt (j)

)− (Fix.+Adj.costs)Jt (j)

]

Dividend maximisation problem

maxPJt (j),IJt (j),UJt (j),KJt+1(j)

Et

∞∑s=0

Rt+sDJt+s(j)

s.t. Cap.accum.equation, Prod.function, Adj.costs, Type j intermediate good demand

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 13 / 47

Page 16: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Firms

Distributors (I): General features

Two-stage production technology

1st stage

Produce composite tradable good using domestic tradables and importedgoodsQuadratic import content adjustment costs

2nd stage

Produce private and government consumption, investment and exportgoods (F ∈ {C, I, G,X}) using tradable good produced in 1st stage andnon-tradable goods from domestic manufacturersPay tax on profitsQuadratic price growth adjustment costs

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 14 / 47

Page 17: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Firms

Distributors (II): 1st stage

Production function

YAFt (f) =

(αAF )1

ξAF(ZTFt (f)

) ξAF−1ξAF + (1 − αAF )

1ξAF

(MFt (f)

[1 − ΓAFt (f)

]) ξAF−1ξAF

ξAFξAF−1

Cost

CFt (f) = PTt ZTFt (f) + P ∗t M

Ft (f)

Cost minimisation problem

minZTFt (f),MF

t (f)CFt (f)

s.t. Prod.function, Adj.costs

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 15 / 47

Page 18: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Firms

Distributors (III): 2nd stage

Production function

Y Ft (f) =

((1 − αF )

1ξF

(Y AFt (f)

) ξF−1ξF + (αF )

1ξF

(ZNFt (f)

) ξF−1ξF

) ξFξF−1

Dividend

DFt (f) = (1− τD,t)

[PFt (f)Y

Ft (f)− Λ

AFt (f)Y

AFt (f)− PNt Z

NFt (f)− (Fix.+Adj.costs)

Ft (f)

]

Dividend maximisation problem

maxPFt (f),Y AFt (f),ZNFt (f)

Et

∞∑s=0

Rt+sDFt+s(f)

s.t. Prod.function, Adj.costs, Type f final good demand

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 16 / 47

Page 19: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Government

Government

General features

Collects taxes, pay/receives transfers, consumes, issues debt

Budget constraint

SGt = Taxest − PGt Gt + NetTransfersGt

Bt = Bt−1 − SGt − (it−1 − 1)Bt−1

Structural budget balance fiscal rule(

SG

GDP

)t

=

(SG

GDP

)tart

+ dtax

(RVt − RV sstGDP sst

)+ ddebt

(Bt

GDP sst−(

B

GDP

)tart

)

Labour income tax rate is set endogenously

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 17 / 47

Page 20: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Rest of the world and market clearing

Rest of the world and market clearing

Rest of the world = euro area

Trade linkages: sells goods to distributors, buys export goods fromdistributors

Financial linkages: households sell/buy bonds in the RoW

Market clearing

∑H

LHt =

∑J

UJt

ZJt =

∑F

ZJFt + Fix.+Adj.costst

YCt =

∑H

CHt + Fix.+Adj.costst; Y

It =

∑J

IJt + Fix.+Adj.costst

YGt = Gt + Fix.+Adj.costst; Y

Xt = Xt + Fix.+Adj.costst

B∗t = it−1B

∗t−1 + P

Xt Xt − P

∗t Mt + NetTransfers

∗t

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 18 / 47

Page 21: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Introducing and calibrating PESSOA Calibration

Calibration

Productivity growth, inflation rate, interest rate: euro area DSGE modelsSteady-state key ratios: National Accounts data, 1995-2006Structural parameters: DSGE literatureNominal and real rigidities: Parameters from the literature as initialguesses

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 19 / 47

Page 22: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Motivation of the paper

Increasing competition in the domestic markets:motivation

The Portuguese economy: 90’s versus 2000’s

90’s A case of success in the European integration process2000’s Slowdown in economic activity, real divergence vs. euro area

What is behind this ?Most popular stories are:

FDI was diverted to Eastern European countriesIntegration of emerging economies with low unit labour costs

It can be disputed:FDI: E(rK) > cost of capitalNon-competitive Portuguese companies were displaced

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 20 / 47

Page 23: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Motivation of the paper

Increasing competition in the domestic markets:motivation

How to restore competitiveness in the new international environment ?

Increasing competition in domestic markets fosters internationalcompetitiveness

Improves resource allocationReduces non-tradable costs (knock-on effects)Crucial for a sound business environment (FDI inflows)Faster adjustment to shocksPortugal has still margin to improve competition

References: OECD, EC; Aghion; Høj, Conway, Nicoletti; Laxton and Bayoumi;

Blanchard and Giavazzi

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 21 / 47

Page 24: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Motivation of the paper

Increasing competition in the domestic markets:motivation

How to restore competitiveness in the new international environment ?

Figure 2: Regulation stance in Portugal

Source: OECD, Product Market Regulation Indicators Source: OECD, Employment Protection Legislation Indicators

Employment Protection Legislation Product Market Regulation0 less restrictive; 4 most restrictive 0 less restrictive; 4 most restrictive

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

US

UK

CA

NZ IE AU

SW SK

HU JP DK

CZ

KO FI

PL

AT

NL IT DE

BE

NW SE

FR

GR

ES

MX

PT

TU

1998

2003

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

AU

UK IC US IE DK

NZ

CA

SE

LU JP FI

BE

NL

AT

SK

DE N

KO PT

ES S

FR

CZ

GR IT HU

MX

TU PL

1998

2003

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 22 / 47

Page 25: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Simulation design and results

Simulation design

FeaturesPermanent shocks to non-tradables price and wage markupsPerfect foresight/information

Design

Non-tradable : Decline of 2 pp. in price markup (from 20% to 18%)Wage : Decline of 2.5 pp. in wage markup (from 25% to 22.5%)

Pass-through : 80 % of the decline achieved in 2 years

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 23 / 47

Page 26: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Simulation design and results

The impact of increasing competition in non-tradables

Table 1: LR impact

NTGDP 1.3

Consumption 1.9GFCF 2.1Exports 1.5Imports 0.3

Human wealth 1.2Real wage (firms) 0.5Labour inc. tax (pp.) -2.0NFA ( % GDP) 4.7Real exch. rate (+ depr.) 1.5

Domestic ToT (+ depr.) 1.7Price tradables 0.3Price non-tradables -1.4

Tradables output 2.0Non-tradables output 1.4Tradables hours 1.7Non-tradables hours 1.2

Source: Own calculations

1 Real exchange rate depreciation(pN ⇓, pT ↑) ⇒ λF ↓⇒ (pX ↓, ε ↑)

2 Higher demand for domesticintermediates and final goods(pX ↓, ε ↑) ⇒ X ↑ε ↑⇒ (ZTF ⇑,MF ↑)

3 Increase in the capital intensity ofoutput(pI/v) ↓⇒ (K/L) ↑

4 Households’ consumption increases(w ↑, τL ↓) ⇒ hw ↑; fw ↑⇒ C ↑

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 24 / 47

Page 27: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Simulation design and results

The impact of increasing competition in labour market

Table 2: LR impact

NT W AllGDP 1.3 1.2 2.5

Consumption 1.9 1.7 3.5GFCF 2.1 0.8 2.9Exports 1.5 1.1 2.5Imports 0.3 0.3 0.6

Human wealth 1.2 1.2 2.3Real wage (firms) 0.5 -0.6 0.0Labour inc. tax (pp.) -2.0 -1.2 -3.2NFA ( % GDP) 4.7 4.5 9.2Real exch. rate (+ depr.) 1.5 0.8 2.2

Domestic ToT (+ depr.) 1.7 0.0 1.7Price tradables 0.3 -0.3 0.0Price non-tradables -1.4 -0.3 -1.7

Tradables output 2.0 1.7 3.7Non-tradables output 1.4 0.8 2.2Tradables hours 1.7 2.0 3.7Non-tradables hours 1.2 1.1 2.2

Source: Own calculations

1 Real exchange rate depreciation(pN , pT ) ↓⇒ λF ↓⇒ (pX ↓, ε ↑)

2 Higher demand for domesticintermediates and final goods(pX ↓, ε ↑) ⇒ X ↑ε ↑⇒ (ZTF ↑> MF ↑)

3 Higher labour intensity(v/pI) ↓⇒ (K/L) ↓

4 Households’ consumptionincreasesDU ↓< (w ↑, τL ↓) ⇒ hw ↑; fw ↑⇒ C ↑

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 25 / 47

Page 28: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Simulation design and results

Implementation issue: SR negative impact onconsumption

Figure 3: SR impact

-1.5

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Cons. H.Wealth Hours

-1.5

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Inflation Real interest rate

1 Real interest rate increases temporarily(π ↓; i) ⇒ r ↑

2 Households’ consumption declinesr ↑⇒ hw ↓⇒ C ↓

3 Higher demand, hours increaseπ ↓⇒ ε ↑⇒ Y ↑⇒ L ↑

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 26 / 47

Page 29: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Increasing competition in the domestic markets Main findings

The impact of increasing competition: main findings

Increasing competition in domestic markets promotes the real exchangerate adjustment of the Portuguese economy within the EMUA cut in non-tradable goods prices and wage markups improvesinternational competitiveness and boost economic activityPractical implementation issue: short-run negative impact inconsumption and leisureEstimated impacts are on the downside: fiercer competition inducesproductivity gains not considered

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 27 / 47

Page 30: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Ongoing research using PESSOA

The Portuguese economy in the EMU: a story of shocksand frictions (ongoing research!)

Aim of the study

Assess the performance of the Portuguese economy in the EMU through thelens of a DSGE model and draw some policy implications (if there are some!)

Structure of the articleEmpirical evidence and identification of some stylised factsMain shocks and the role of frictions

S1 Total factor productivity slowdownS2 The fiscal policy imbalance and the fiscal consolidationS3 The aftermath of the sharp interest rate declineS4 Fiercer competition in international goods marketsS5 Still low competition in domestic markets

Policy implications (hopefully some will arise!)

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 28 / 47

Page 31: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Directions for further research

Directions for further research

Extend the calibrated version of the model to includeMacro-financial linkagesThe role of commodities, in particular oilSearch and matching frictions in the labour market

Estimate a stripped down version of the model using Bayesian techniquesPhase-in the model in regular projection and simulation activities

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 29 / 47

Page 32: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

DSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal

Ricardo Mourinho Felix

Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal

IMF Macro Modelling Workshop

Washington, DC

January 6-9, 2009

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 30 / 47

Page 33: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

The regulatory stance in Portugal (A1)

Figure 4: PMR indicators

Product market regulation

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

AU UK IC US IE DK

NZ

CA SE

LU JP FI

BE

NL

AT

SK DE N

KO PT

ES S FR

CZ

GR IT HU

MX

TU PL

1998

2003

State control

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

AU IC US

DK

SK

NZ JP CA

KO UK

MX

SE

NL

AT IE LU DE

SW F

IB

EC

ZF

RE

S PT

NW GR

TU IT HU PL

1998

2003

Barriers to entrepreneurship

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

UK

CA IE N SE FI

AU NZ

US

SK LU DK PT IT JP HU

DE IC GR

ES

FR

BE

AT NL

KO S

CZ

MX PL

TU

1998

2003

Barriers to trade and investment

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

IC BE

UK IE FI

DE

NL

ES

AT LU US

NW SE PT

DK

NZ

AU CZ JP FR

SW CA IT

GR

KO HU

SK TU

MX PL

1998

2003

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 31 / 47

Page 34: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

The regulatory stance in Portugal (A2)

Figure 5: EPL indicators

Collective dismissals

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

NZ JP KO CZ

FR IE TU FI

AU

CA

HU N

UK

US

NL

ES

AT

GR PT

DE

MX

SK

DK S BE PL

SE IT

1998

2003

Employment protection legislation

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

US

UK

CA

NZ IE

AU

SW SK

HU JP DK

CZ

KO F

IP

LA

T NL IT DE

BE

NW SE

FR

GR

ES

MX PT

TU

1998

2003

Regular employment:difficulty of dismissal

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

US

UK

DK S BE

AU IE

CA PL

TU

HU

NZ FI

SK FR

KO

GR

DE IT NL

ES JP MX

AT

CZ N PT

SE

1998

2003

Regular employment:notice and severance pay for no-fault individual dismissals

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

5.5

US

NZ IT IE AT

KO

CA

AU F

I NU

KD

EP

L S SE

HU JP DK

FR

NL

MX

GR

BE

ES

CZ

SK TU PT

1998

2003

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 32 / 47

Page 35: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

The regulatory stance in Portugal (A3)

Figure 6: Weight of administered prices in HICP

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Irel

and

Mal

ta

Fin

land

Cyp

rus

Spa

in

Italy

Est

onia

Luxe

mbo

urg

Aus

tria

Latv

ia

Fra

nce

Gre

ece

Net

herla

nds

Sw

eden

Eur

o ar

ea

Slo

veni

a

Uni

ted

Kin

gdom

Lith

uani

a

Den

mar

k

Por

tuga

l

Ger

man

y

Bel

gium

Slo

vaki

a

Hun

gary

Pol

and

Bul

garia

Cze

ch R

epub

lic

Rom

ania

Services Goods

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 33 / 47

Page 36: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Introducing PESSOA

Figure 7: Model flowchart

Tradable goods manufacturers

Non-tradable goods manufacturers

Consummer goods retailers

Investment goods retailers

Governm. consump. goods retailers

Export goods retailers

Households

Labour unions

Foreign suppliers Foreign costumers

Government

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 34 / 47

Page 37: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Households

Figure 8: The households’ flowchart

Government Labour unions

Rest of the world Manufacturers

Retailers (C,G,I,X)

OLG households

LIQ households

DT,DNi*B*ε

DC,DG,DI,DX

COLG

CLIQ

LOLG

LLIQ

W

W

DU

τL iB

τL τΤ

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 35 / 47

Page 38: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Firms Figure 9: The firms’ flowchart

ZNCES(KT,LT)

LN LTKN KT

ZTCES(KT,LT)

Retailers

YACCES(ZTC,MC)

YCCES(YAC,ZNC)

YAICES(ZTI,MI)

YICES(YAI,ZNI)

YACCES(ZTX,MX)

YXCES(YAX,ZNX)

YAGCES(ZTG,MG)

YGCES(YAG,ZNG)

M=MC+MI+MX+MG

Manufacturers

Domestic primary inputs Rest of the world inputs

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 36 / 47

Page 39: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

OLG households

Optimal aggregate conditions

COLGt

n(1 − ψ) − LOLGt

=

(ηOLG

1 − ηOLG

)(1 − τL,t)wt

it = i∗t

COLGt = mpct(hwLt + hwKt + fwt

)

hwLt = n(1 − ψ)wt(1 − τL,t) +θχ

rthwLt+1

hwKt = (1 − ι)(dNt + dTt + dCt + dGt + dIt + dXt

)+ (1 − ψ)

(dUt + trgt + trxt

)+

θ

rthwKt+1

fwt = rt−1

[bt−1 + b∗t−1 · εt−1

]

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 37 / 47

Page 40: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Labour unions

The equilibrium condition: a wage Phillips curve

σU,t

σU,t − 1wt − vt =

=φUTt

σU,t − 1

(πVtπVt−1

− 1

)πVtπVt−1

−(

1 − τL,t+1

1 − τL,t

rt

Ut+1Tt+1

Ut

φU

σU,t − 1

(πVt+1

πVt− 1

)πVt+1

πVt

in steady-state:

v =σU

σU − 1w

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 38 / 47

Page 41: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Manufacturers

The equilibrium conditions: a Phillips curve

σJ,t

σJ,t − 1

λJtpJt

− 1 =

φPJ

σJ,t − 1

(πJtπJt−1

− 1

)πJtπJt−1

−(

1 − τK,t+1

1 − τK,t

rt

φPJ

σJ,t − 1

pJt+1

pJt

ZJt+1

ZJt

(πJt+1

πJt− 1

)πJt+1

πJt

in steady-state:

pJ =σJ

σJ − 1λJ

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 39 / 47

Page 42: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Manufacturers

The equilibrium conditions: desired capital stock level

qJt =θ

rt

πIt+1

πt+1

[qJt+1

(1 − δJ

)+rJK,t+1

pIt+1

− τK,t+1

(rJK,t+1

pIt+1

− qJt+1δJ

)]

+ (1 − τK,t+1)θ

rt

πIt+1

πt+1

IJt+1

KJt+1

[φJK

(IJt+1

KJt+1

−IJ

KJ

)+ φJI

(IJt+1

KJt+1

−IJtKJt

)]

− (1 − τK,t+1)θ

rt

πIt+1

πt+1

φJK2

(IJt+1

KJt+1

−IJ

KJ

)2

+φJI2

(IJt+1

KJt+1

−IJtKJt

)2

In steady-state, after-tax real return on capital equals the certain equivalent real return ofgovernment bonds.

r

θ= 1 + (1 − τk)

(rJKpI

− δJ

)

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 40 / 47

Page 43: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Manufacturers

The equilibrium conditions: optimal investment path

Investment path condition depends on investment adjustment cost parameters.

qJt = 1 +(1 − τK,t

) [φJK

(IJtKJt

−IJ

KJ

)+ φJI

(IJtKJt

−IJt−1

KJt−1

)]In steady-state, Tobin’s-Q equals unity, market value of installed capital equals replacementcost.

The equilibrium conditions: optimal labour demand

(1 + τSP,t

)vt = λJt

(ZJt α

JU

TtAJt UJt

) 1ξZJ

TtAJt

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 41 / 47

Page 44: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: steady-state key ratios

Table 3: Steady-state key ratios

Data ModelExpenditure (as a % of GDP)Private consumption 0.64 0.61Government consumption and GFCF 0.22 0.21Private investment 0.21 0.21Exports 0.29 0.29Imports 0.37 0.33

Labour income share (as a % of overall income) 0.57 0.56Tradable goods 0.54 0.54Non-tradable goods 0.58 0.58

Capital-output ratio (as a % of output) NA 2.34Tradable goods NA 2.53Non-tradable goods NA 2.21

Government (as a % of GDP)Debt stock 0.57 0.53Fiscal balance -0.07 -0.02Overall revenues 0.38 0.39Overall expenditure 0.45 0.41

External account (as a % of GDP)Net foreign assets -0.60 -0.60Current account -0.06 -0.02Trade balance -0.08 -0.04

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 42 / 47

Page 45: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: households and labour union parameters

Table 4: Households parameters

Households discount rate (annualised) β 0.97Intertemporal elasticity of substitution 1

γ0.20

OLG households instant probability of death (annualised) 1 − θ 0.04OLG households habit persistence ν 0.70Consumption share - OLG households ηOLG 0.74Consumption share - LIQ households ηLIQ 0.70Lifetime productivity decline rate (annualised) 1 − χ 0.04Share of LIQ households ψ 0.40Share of dividend transfers from OLG to LIQ households ι 0.20Memo items:Marginal propensity to consume wealth 0.05Average planning horizon (years) 25Average worklife (years) 25

Table 5: Labour union parameters

Wage mark-upσUσU−1 1.25

Wage rigidity - Adjustment cost φU 200Memo items:Duration wage contracts (quarters) 6.4

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 43 / 47

Page 46: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: manufacturers parameters

Table 6: Manufacturers parameters

Tradable Non-tradableJ = T J = N

Depreciation rate (annualised) δ 0.09 0.09Labour augmenting prod. growth (annualised) g 1.02 1.02EoS between capital and labour ξJ 0.99 0.99Quasi labour income share αJ 0.60 0.60Price markup

σJσJ−1 1.10 1.20

Capital adjustment cost φKJ 50 50Investment adjustment cost φIJ 100 100Price adjustment cost φPJ 200 200Memo items:Duration price contracts (quarters) 3.9 5.7

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 44 / 47

Page 47: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: markups

Figure 10: Markups and PMR indicator

Tradables Non-tradables

y = 0.0114x + 0.1058

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0PMR indicator

Mar

kup

y = 0.0996x + 0.0593

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0PMR indicator

Mar

kup

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 45 / 47

Page 48: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: distributors parameters

Table 7: Distributors parameters

Consumer Govt. Invest. ExportF = C F = G F = I F = X

EoS domestic tradable/imported good ξAF 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50Assembled good quasi domestic content αAF 0.12 0.02 0.02 0.19EoS assembled/non-tradable good ξF 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50Non-tradable good (quasi) factor share αF 0.71 0.98 0.88 0.15Price markup

σFσF−1 1.05 1.05 1.05 1.03

Import content adjustment cost φAF 2 2 2 2Price adjustment cost φPF 200 200 200 200Memo items:Implied import content 0.29 0.10 0.40 0.30Implied non-tradable content 0.38 0.88 0.53 0.05Duration price contracts (quarters) 2.7 2.7 2.7 1.8

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 46 / 47

Page 49: DSGE Modelling at the Banco de Portugal - Douglas · PDF fileDSGE modelling at the Banco de Portugal Ricardo Mourinho F elix Economics and Research Department, Banco de Portugal IMF

Appendix

Calibration: government and foreign economyparameters

Table 8: Government parameters

Labour income tax rate τL 0.29Consumption tax rate τC 0.30Capital income tax rate τK 0.17Employers social security contribution rate τSP 0.19Debt to GDP ratio (annualised) b

gdp0.53

Speed adjustment towards the target debt ratio parameter ddebt 0.10

Table 9: Foreign economy parameters

Foreign interest rate (annualised) i∗ 1.05Foreign inflation (annualised) π∗ 1.02EoS between domestic and imported goods ξ∗ 1.50

R. Felix (BdP) IMF Workshop 47 / 47